ECER Conference Paper 2021

1. *Middle East Technical University
**University of Gothenburg
AFFILIATIONS
PRE-SERVICE MATH
TEACHERS'
PROFESSIONAL IDENTITY
DEVELOPMENT THROUGH
ONLINE ANTICIPATORY
REFLECTIONS
Amine Merve ERCAN*, Nur AKKUŞ ÇAKIR*,
Ali YILDIRIM**
AUTHORS
The purpose of this study is to investigate the development of pre-service teachers´ professional identity
through online anticipatory reflections. Reflection is a cognitive process of (re)constructing expertise,
awareness or knowledge (Korthagen, 2001), and perceived as a pivotal notion in teacher training and
development (Wopereis, Sloep, & Poortman, 2010). Research studies suggest that reflective writing have a
magnitude effect on teacher identity development process (Izadinia, 2013), which in turn affect many
decisions teachers make in relation to curriculum, classroom management, lesson plans and materials
(Noormohammadi, 2014). Additionally, reflection is essential for improving teaching methods and
improvement in teaching methods influences identities (Graham & Phelps, 2003). Reflection not only
promotes individual (aspirant) learning process and professional development but also prepares the ground
for educational change and reform (Griffiths, 2000).
“Self-reflection” has a crucial place in teacher education programs and the professional development of
teachers (Noormohammadi, 2014). Lester (1998) argued that reflective teachers easily link theory to
practice, and reflection is a substantial factor, which has a role on the success of inexperienced teachers
since it affects teacher persistence, retention and resilience. Also, reflective writing develops a teacher’s
sense of self-efficacy, job satisfaction and ability to create stronger communication with colleagues (Braun &
Crumpler, 2004). Additionally, teacher candidates can form their identities by self-reflection because
internalizing the profession and creating a link between theory and practice is tied to telling and retelling the
stories if the teacher is inexperienced (Binks et al., 2009).
Anticipatory self-reflection is a future-oriented self-reflection which allows reflective writers to criticize
themselves in the context of the possible occurrences they may face in the future (Van Mannen, 1995). In the
literature, there exist studies emphasizing the importance and positive effects of anticipatory reflective
practices in the teacher education process (e.g. Wilson, 2008). In addition, there are studies of math teacher
identity development focusing on aspects of beliefs, knowledge, and emotions in the area of mathematics
(e.g., Skog & Andersson, 2015), and expertise in a specific subcategory such as subject matter expertise,
didactical expertise, pedagogical expertise necessary to be a good teacher (Dede & Akkoc, 2016). However,
intervention studies focusing on the effect of reflections on teacher identity development at pre-service level
are few. In addition, the impact of online reflections on professional identity development is studied even to a
lesser degree
INTRODUCTION
FRAMEWORK
In this study, Bejiaard, Verloop and Vermunt (2000)’s teacher
identity model which define teacher identity under three major
areas (subject matter expertise (SME), didactical expertise
(DE), pedagogical expertise (PE)) was utilized as a framework
to define math teacher identity. SME refers to a mathematics
teacher' capability of explaining the reasoning behind math
topics and understanding of misconceptions; DE refers to a
mathematics teacher' organization ability of topic in line with
students' capability of mathematics; and PE refers to the
ability of teaching, communication and classroom
management skills (Beijaard et al., 2004).
The pre and posttest results were analyzed through paired
sample t-test in response to the 1st RQ while the qualitative
data were analyzed through thematic analysis (Braun &
Clarke, 2006) in response to 2nd RQ. The identity
development framework of Bejiaard et al. (2000) was used to
to analyze the quantitative data, and part of the interview
data. Except for the 1st question, all interview data were
subjected to inductive thematic analysis. The results of both
strands of the method were integrated in the presentation of
results and discussion.
ANALYSIS
The quantitative analysis of the differences between the pre and post-intervention results responding to the first research question, through the paired-sample t-tests
for each sub-dimensions indicated that there existed a significant difference between the pre and the post-intervention scores of self-categorization (MD=-0.22, SD=.62,
t(30)=-1.96, p.05) and confidence/self-efficacy dimensions (MD=-0.26, SD=.81, t(30)=-1.77, p.05) while there existed no significant difference in the natural inclination
towards children and teaching dimension (MD=-0.12, SD=.54, t(30)=-1.22, p>.05). The results of the paired-samples t-test conducted on teacher identity as a single
dimension also indicated a significant difference between the pre and post-intervention scores (MD=-3.36, SD=7.55), t(30)=-2.47, p.05).
The thematic analysis of the interview data indicated that pedagogical expertise, didactical expertise, and subject matter expertise were priorities for all pre-service
teachers as critical competencies. The pre-service teachers found pedagogical expertise and didactical expertise most important for a strong teacher identity.
Affordances of the intervention and the feedback were also explored through the interviews conducted at the end of the intervention. The affordances included (1)
inclining to think on education-related issues such as educational philosophy, being a teacher and teaching, (2) making aware not only of their existed beliefs, thoughts,
and knowledge also of the cultural diversity, (3) changing existed perception about educational issues, and (4) facilitating a sense of engagement to the profession by
inquiring who they are as potential teachers, what their main values and their feelings are.
In short, pre-service teachers found the intervention meaningful and instructive. The workload created a problem for some participants, therefore they suggested
preparing intervention with a more flexible timeline to give time to think on the weekly topics more deeply. The value of more peer interaction was also highlighted.
CONCLUSION
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
(1) What impact do weekly online anticipatory reflections
have on pre-service teachers’ professional identity
development?
(2) How do pre-service teachers perceive their
experiences on online anticipatory reflections in relation
to their professional identity development?
METHODOLOGY
Following an equally weighted concurrent mixed-method design, a single group quasi-experimental pre-test
post-test design was used for the quantitative strand while semi-structured interviews were used for the
qualitative strand. For the intervention, a ten-week module involving anticipatory reflections was designed
and integrated into a must course of the pre-service elementary math education program of a state university
in Turkey. The participants received prompts as weekly assignments affecting 10% of the grade. Before the
intervention, the participants were given tutoring about blogging, WordPress and Edmodo for 5 hours, owned
their blog pages and posted first blogs. Throughout the following ten weeks, they received weekly prompts
organized following the teacher identity framework of Bejiaard et al. (2000). The topics of the seventh and
eighth weeks were about pedagogical expertise, the fourth and sixth weeks were didactical expertise, the
third and fifth weeks were subject matter expertise and the first, ninth and tenth weeks were on teacher
professional development. All prompts were composed of the reflective questioning method generated by
Rolfe, Freshwater and Jasper (2001).
The participants of the study included the students who were registered for the must course offered only to
3rd-year students in the program. A total of 31 students (13% male, 87% female) took part in the
intervention study, and seven participated in semi-structured interviews.
The data collection involved a scale (ETIM) given to the students at the beginning and end of the
intervention. ETIM is a three-dimensional five-point Likert scale generated by Friesen and Besley (2013) to
measure the participants’ understandings of the early development of their teacher identity. In addition, a
semi-structured interview schedule was used involving questions on the pre-service teachers’ perceptions
about the intervention process and their professional identities in terms of SME, DE and PE. All participants
responded to both pre and post-intervention surveys, and seven pre-service teachers (5 female, 2 male)
participated in interviews.

2. Beijaard, D., Verloop, N., & Vermunt, J. D. (2000). Teachers’ perceptions of Professional identity: An exploratory study from a personal knowledge
perspective. Teaching and teacher education, 16(7),749-764.
Binks, E., Smith, D. L., Smith, L. J., & Joshi, R. M. (2009). Tell me your story:A reflection strategy for preservice teachers. Teacher Education
Quarterly, 36(4),141-156.
Braun, J. A., & Crumpler, T. P. (2004). The social memoir:An analysis of developing reflective ability in a pre-service methods course. Teaching and
Teacher Education, 20(1),59- 75.
Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative research in psychology, 3(2),77-101Bengtsson, J. (2003).
Possibilities and limits of self-reflection in the teaching profession. Studies in Philosophy and Education, 22(3-4),295-316.
DEDE, H. G., & Akkoç, H. (2016). A comparison of professional identity of pre-service mathematics teachers in pedagogical formation program and
undergraduate teacher education program. Turkish Journal of Computer and Mathematics Education (TURCOMAT), 7(1),188-206.
Friesen, M. D., & Besley, S. C. (2013). Teacher identity development in the first year of teacher education: A developmental and social psychological
perspective. Teaching and Teacher Education, 36,23-32.
Graham, A., & Phelps, R. (2003). Being a teacher:Developing teacher identity and enhancing practice through metacognitive and reflective learning
processes. Australian Journal of Teacher Education, 27(2),11.
Griffiths, V. (2000). The reflective dimension in teacher education. International Journal of Educational Research, 33(5),539-555.
Izadinia, M. (2013). A review of research on student teachers' professional identity. British Educational Research Journal, 39(4),694-713.
Korthagen, F. A. (2001). A reflection on reflection. Linking practice and theory:The pedagogy of realistic teacher education, 51.
Lester, F. K., & Lambdin, D. V. (1998). The ship of Theseus and other metaphors for thinking about what we value in mathematics education
research. Mathematics education as a research domain: A search for identity, (pp. 415-425). Dordrecht:Springer.
Noormohammadi, S. (2014). Teacher reflection and its relation to teacher efficacy and autonomy. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences,
98(1),1380-1389.
Rolfe, G., Freshwater, D., & Jasper, M. (2001).Critical Reflection for Nursing and the Helping Professions a User's Guide.
Skog, K., & Andersson, A. (2015). Exploring positioning as an analytical tool for understanding becoming mathematics teachers’ identities.
Mathematics Education Research Journal, 27(1),65-82.
Van Manen, M. (1995). On the epistemology of reflective practice. Teachers and Teaching, 1(1),33-50.
Wilson, J. P. (2008). Reflecting‐on‐the‐future:A chronological consideration of reflective practice. Reflective Practice, 9(2),177-184.
Wopereis, I., Sloep, P., & Poortman, S. (2010).Het weblog als instrument voor reflectie opleren en handelen: Een verkennende studie binnen de
eerste-en tweedegraads lerarenopleiding.
REFERENCES