Why did my goat die? Why didn't the dewormer work?
1. MY GOAT (OR SHEEP) DIEDâŚ
why didnât my dewormer work?
Susan Schoenian & Amy Garza
University of Maryland Extension
Western Maryland Research & Education Center
American Consortium for Small Ruminant Parasite
Control (ACSRPC) - www.acsrpc.com
2. Periparturient egg rise
âaround the time of giving birthâ
⢠Ewes and does suffer a
temporary loss of immunity
to worms around
the time of parturition
[late gestation ď lactation]
⢠The periparturient egg rise serves
as the primary source of infection
for the new crop of lambs and kids.
⢠The periparturient egg risk poses
the most risk when lambing and
kidding occur in the spring (then
winter) and/or on pasture and to
highly-stressed females.
3. Anthelmintic (dewormer) resistance
⢠Resistance is inevitable;
no treatment will kill 100
percent of worms.
⢠Worms have developed
resistance to all
dewormers and all
dewormer classes.
⢠Resistance varies by
geographic region and
individual farm and is the
result of past deworming
practices.
Anthelmintic = Dewormer
4. Anthelmintic (dewormer) resistance
⢠Resistant worms pass their
resistant genes onto their
offspring; resistance is
permanent!
⢠You cannot prevent
resistance, but you can
affect the rate by which it
develops.
⢠On most farms, resistance
is probably still at a level
where there is still time to
slow it down and enable the
continued use of some
anthelmintics.
5. Understanding anthelmintic resistance
80-95% effective.
Treatment is effective, but
resistance is increasing.
95-100% effective. Small
number of resistant worms may
be present.
ď
ď
Anthelmintic failure.
Animals die.
Less than 80%.
Production losses become
apparent as effectiveness
of dewormer moves closer
to zero.
Adapted from Wormer
Resistance âThe need for
changeâ Meat Promotion Wales
7. Determining anthelmintic resistance
⢠FAMACHAŠ and the Five Point
CheckŠ donât work if you donât have
an effective treatment(s) for clinicallyparasitized animals.
⢠Clinically-parasitized animals will
almost always die without an
effective anthelmintic treatment
(deworming).
⢠There are two ways to test for
anthelmintic resistance.
1) Fecal egg count reduction test (FECRT)
2) DrenchRiteÂŽ test
⢠It is recommended that you test for
anthelmintic resistance every 2-3
years.
8. 1) Fecal egg count reduction test (FECRT)
⢠Determines the effectiveness
of an individual treatment.
⢠Best time to do is early to mid-summer
when Haemonchus (barber pole worm)
is most active.
⢠Collect fecal samples (> 250 epg) from
treated animals (ideally n > 15) for each
anthelmintic (or combination) you want
to test.
⢠Favor animals with higher FAMACHAŠ
and dag scores.
⢠If possible, include a group (n > 15) of
untreated animals as a control group.
9. http://www.uaex.edu/Other_Areas/publications/PDF/FSA-9608.pdf
Fecal egg count reduction test (FECRT)
⢠Compare pre- and post-treatment fecal egg counts
8-10 days for benzimidazoles (SafeGuardÂŽ, ValbazenÂŽ)
b) 14-17 days for macrocylic lactones (IvomecÂŽ, CydectinÂŽ)
c) 5-7 days for levamisole (ProhibitÂŽ)
d) 10-14 days for all dewormers
a)
11. Fecal egg count reduction test
Sheep and goat farm in West Virginia (2013)
Mature goats
Kid goats
Lambs
Control
3
3
9
15
COWP
3
6
0
9
Valbazen Ivermectin
0
2
4
2
9
8
13
12
Cydectin
2
4
4
10
Prohibit
0
1
8
9
Total
10
20
38
68
⢠Animals were weighed and given accurate dose of anthelmintic on July 17.
⢠Lambs were dosed according to label.
⢠Goats were given 1.5 to 2x the sheep dose of dewormer.
⢠COWP: does were given a 1 g bolus; kids were given a 0.5 g bolus
⢠Fecal samples were collected on the day of treatment and 14 days later.
⢠Animals with higher FAMACHAŠ and dag scores were favored.
⢠Fecal egg counts were determined using the modified McMaster technique
⢠If first fecal egg count was below 250 epg, animal was removed from study.
12. FECRT Results: Does
Control
July 17
July 31
FECR
1
400
350
13%
2
450
600
-33%
3
700
200
71%
AVG
COWP
517
July 17
383
July 31
17
FECR
COWP
July 17
July 31
FECR
1
250
0
100%
2
250
75
70%
3
542
150
72%
AVG
347
75
81%
July 17
July 31
FECR
1
1425
475
67%
2
1850
25
99%
AVG
1638
250
83%
July 17
July 31
FECR
1
275
600
-118%
2
1525
575
62%
AVG
900
587.5
-28%
Cydectin
Ivermectin
16. http://www.acsrpc.org/Resources/Topics/DrenchRiteAssay.html
2) DrenchRiteÂŽ Assay
⢠Determines drug resistance for all
anthelmintic classes simultaneously
from a pooled fecal sample.
â Resistance to CydectinÂŽ is predicted
based on the results for ivermectin.
⢠Also determines which parasites your
animals have.
⢠Collect a pooled fecal sample from at
least 10 animals with >350-500 epg.
Favor animals with higher FAMACHAŠ
and dag scores.
⢠Follow instructions for collecting, handling, and shipping sample to
Dr. Ray Kaplanâs lab at the University of Georgia.
17. DrenchRiteÂŽ Assay
Sheep farm in Washington County
⢠On September 4, a pool
fecal sample was collected
from a group of mature
ewes that had not been
recently dewormed.
⢠Ewes with higher
FAMACHAŠ and positive
dag scores were sampled.
⢠Sample was prepared and
shipped via FedEx to the
University of Georgia.
18.
19. A comparison of tests
FECRT
⢠Takes 7-14 days to get
results, longer if someone else does
FECs.
⢠Cost for 75 samples
(15 samples x 4 drugs + control group)
75 x Labor = ?
75 x $5 = $375
75 x $10 = $750
DrenchRiteÂŽ Assay
⢠Labor-intensive lab test
⢠Only one lab in US does
DrenchRiteÂŽ Test (UGA)
⢠Takes 3-4 weeks to get results
⢠Cost $450 per sample
⢠Three possible results:
1. Resistant (R)
2. Suspected resistant (SR)
⢠Need more animals
⢠More precise results: % efficacy
⢠Can be a lot of animal variation.
3. Susceptible (S)