SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 17
Building alliances between farmers & environmentalists What CAP is needed to face up to the environmental challenges? 1 December 2009, Dublin Luigi Boccaccio BirdLife International Stefan Benko Ariel Brunner Ariel Brunner L Boccaccio
Why an alliance between farmers & environmentalists? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],MUTUAL GAINS: RSPB
The “Health Check” has left the CAP basically unchanged until 2013. We can’t afford more waiting Conservation status of agricultural habitats European Commission 2009 RSPB Mariano Fracchiolla
The CAP has changed…  but has also stayed the same!   Source, DG Agri EU-10 EU-12 EU-15 EU-25 EU-27
8% of the CAP is currently directed at the environment ...yet the whole CAP money is accounted as “ Preservation and management of natural resources” under Heading 2 of the EU budget!  CAP 2007-2013 budget (including national financing)  RSPB & IEEP figures based on Rural Development Programmes Completely untargeted spending, mostly historic entitlements discriminating against extensive farming
The main instruments are intrinsically flawed... ,[object Object],www.nrn.ie ,[object Object],...while others are opportunistically distorted A Hay Luigi Boccaccio
Time for the tough question, what is the CAP for? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The CAP is on weak ground ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Well, first we should go back to basic principles ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
So where does BirdLife stand? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],We still need a CAP, but the right one! Luigi Boccaccio Luigi Boccaccio
What we don’t want? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],RSPB
So what does it mean in practice? (1) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
So what does it mean in practice? (2) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Hellenic Ornithological Society Andy Hay RSPB-images.com
So what does it mean in practice? (3) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],E Vukelic Andris Klepers
The CAP cannot solve everything Adrian long Marigo Ariel Brunner Ariel Brunner ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],NABU
Interested in knowing more? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Thank you for your attention! BIRDLIFE INTERNATIONAL EUROPEAN DIVISION Avenue de la Toison d’Or 67 1060 BRUSSELS- BELGIUM Tel. +32 2 280 08 30 www.birdlife.org Ariel Brunner Ariel Brunner Stefan Benko [email_address] Luigi Boccaccio

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

2018 DRR Financing 4.3 Onno Heuvel
2018 DRR Financing 4.3 Onno Heuvel2018 DRR Financing 4.3 Onno Heuvel
2018 DRR Financing 4.3 Onno HeuvelUNDP Eurasia
 
Lecture Common Agriculture Policy
Lecture Common Agriculture PolicyLecture Common Agriculture Policy
Lecture Common Agriculture PolicyJeroen Candel
 
Tools and Approaches for Mainstreaming Biodiversity in the EU, Laure ledoux, ...
Tools and Approaches for Mainstreaming Biodiversity in the EU, Laure ledoux, ...Tools and Approaches for Mainstreaming Biodiversity in the EU, Laure ledoux, ...
Tools and Approaches for Mainstreaming Biodiversity in the EU, Laure ledoux, ...OECD Environment
 
110622 presentatie ukraineshort
110622 presentatie ukraineshort110622 presentatie ukraineshort
110622 presentatie ukraineshortralphbrieskorn
 
Samoa Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2016: Yvette Kerslake (UNDP) - Regi...
Samoa Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2016: Yvette Kerslake (UNDP) - Regi...Samoa Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2016: Yvette Kerslake (UNDP) - Regi...
Samoa Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2016: Yvette Kerslake (UNDP) - Regi...Brussels Briefings (brusselsbriefings.net)
 
AEBIOM Annual Report 2014
AEBIOM Annual Report 2014AEBIOM Annual Report 2014
AEBIOM Annual Report 2014Anamaria Olaru
 
Achieving PCSD: A Challenge for Europe's agriculture
Achieving PCSD: A Challenge for Europe's agricultureAchieving PCSD: A Challenge for Europe's agriculture
Achieving PCSD: A Challenge for Europe's agricultureCéline Charveriat
 
1.6 LIFE: the EU programme for the Environment & Climate action (A.Burrill)
1.6 LIFE: the EU programme for the Environment & Climate action (A.Burrill)1.6 LIFE: the EU programme for the Environment & Climate action (A.Burrill)
1.6 LIFE: the EU programme for the Environment & Climate action (A.Burrill)Stevie Swenne
 
Frédérique Willard, Agence Française de Développement – Mainstreaming biodive...
Frédérique Willard, Agence Française de Développement – Mainstreaming biodive...Frédérique Willard, Agence Française de Développement – Mainstreaming biodive...
Frédérique Willard, Agence Française de Développement – Mainstreaming biodive...Development Co-operation Directorate (DCD-DAC)
 
110622 presentatie ukraineshort
110622 presentatie ukraineshort110622 presentatie ukraineshort
110622 presentatie ukraineshortralphbrieskorn
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Mainstreaming Biodiversity and Environment in the Mekong
Mainstreaming Biodiversity and Environment in the MekongMainstreaming Biodiversity and Environment in the Mekong
Mainstreaming Biodiversity and Environment in the Mekong
 
Valuing biodiveristy and reversing its decline by 2030
Valuing biodiveristy and reversing its decline by 2030Valuing biodiveristy and reversing its decline by 2030
Valuing biodiveristy and reversing its decline by 2030
 
Mainstreaming of ecosystem services into decision making in Ca Mau province, ...
Mainstreaming of ecosystem services into decision making in Ca Mau province, ...Mainstreaming of ecosystem services into decision making in Ca Mau province, ...
Mainstreaming of ecosystem services into decision making in Ca Mau province, ...
 
2018 DRR Financing 4.3 Onno Heuvel
2018 DRR Financing 4.3 Onno Heuvel2018 DRR Financing 4.3 Onno Heuvel
2018 DRR Financing 4.3 Onno Heuvel
 
Lecture Common Agriculture Policy
Lecture Common Agriculture PolicyLecture Common Agriculture Policy
Lecture Common Agriculture Policy
 
Tools and Approaches for Mainstreaming Biodiversity in the EU, Laure ledoux, ...
Tools and Approaches for Mainstreaming Biodiversity in the EU, Laure ledoux, ...Tools and Approaches for Mainstreaming Biodiversity in the EU, Laure ledoux, ...
Tools and Approaches for Mainstreaming Biodiversity in the EU, Laure ledoux, ...
 
110622 presentatie ukraineshort
110622 presentatie ukraineshort110622 presentatie ukraineshort
110622 presentatie ukraineshort
 
Ecoverde ingles-1
Ecoverde ingles-1Ecoverde ingles-1
Ecoverde ingles-1
 
Modeling the water-food-energy nexus in the arab world: Economic and welfare ...
Modeling the water-food-energy nexus in the arab world: Economic and welfare ...Modeling the water-food-energy nexus in the arab world: Economic and welfare ...
Modeling the water-food-energy nexus in the arab world: Economic and welfare ...
 
Documenting climate mainstreaming in the EU budget - making the system more t...
Documenting climate mainstreaming in the EU budget - making the system more t...Documenting climate mainstreaming in the EU budget - making the system more t...
Documenting climate mainstreaming in the EU budget - making the system more t...
 
CAP notes
CAP notesCAP notes
CAP notes
 
Samoa Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2016: Yvette Kerslake (UNDP) - Regi...
Samoa Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2016: Yvette Kerslake (UNDP) - Regi...Samoa Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2016: Yvette Kerslake (UNDP) - Regi...
Samoa Agritourism Policy Setting Workshop 2016: Yvette Kerslake (UNDP) - Regi...
 
AEBIOM Annual Report 2014
AEBIOM Annual Report 2014AEBIOM Annual Report 2014
AEBIOM Annual Report 2014
 
Achieving PCSD: A Challenge for Europe's agriculture
Achieving PCSD: A Challenge for Europe's agricultureAchieving PCSD: A Challenge for Europe's agriculture
Achieving PCSD: A Challenge for Europe's agriculture
 
5.1 buckle oecd
5.1 buckle oecd5.1 buckle oecd
5.1 buckle oecd
 
Case study: Cyprus: Pricing for irrigation and the cost of water scarcity
Case study: Cyprus: Pricing for irrigation and the cost of water scarcityCase study: Cyprus: Pricing for irrigation and the cost of water scarcity
Case study: Cyprus: Pricing for irrigation and the cost of water scarcity
 
1.6 LIFE: the EU programme for the Environment & Climate action (A.Burrill)
1.6 LIFE: the EU programme for the Environment & Climate action (A.Burrill)1.6 LIFE: the EU programme for the Environment & Climate action (A.Burrill)
1.6 LIFE: the EU programme for the Environment & Climate action (A.Burrill)
 
Frédérique Willard, Agence Française de Développement – Mainstreaming biodive...
Frédérique Willard, Agence Française de Développement – Mainstreaming biodive...Frédérique Willard, Agence Française de Développement – Mainstreaming biodive...
Frédérique Willard, Agence Française de Développement – Mainstreaming biodive...
 
110622 presentatie ukraineshort
110622 presentatie ukraineshort110622 presentatie ukraineshort
110622 presentatie ukraineshort
 
OECD work on biodiversity, development and development co-operation
OECD work on biodiversity, development and development co-operationOECD work on biodiversity, development and development co-operation
OECD work on biodiversity, development and development co-operation
 

Ähnlich wie Farmers & environmentalists need new CAP to face challenges

Redesigning the CAP
Redesigning the CAPRedesigning the CAP
Redesigning the CAPKrijn Poppe
 
Nijenrode lecture 2021 krijn poppe
Nijenrode lecture 2021 krijn poppeNijenrode lecture 2021 krijn poppe
Nijenrode lecture 2021 krijn poppeKrijn Poppe
 
Multifunctional Approaches in EU policies
Multifunctional Approaches in EU policies Multifunctional Approaches in EU policies
Multifunctional Approaches in EU policies ExternalEvents
 
Juli Mylona - Bioconomy - plant science and agriculture. Future funding under...
Juli Mylona - Bioconomy - plant science and agriculture. Future funding under...Juli Mylona - Bioconomy - plant science and agriculture. Future funding under...
Juli Mylona - Bioconomy - plant science and agriculture. Future funding under...epsoeurope
 
EAAE Seminar162 CAP and innovation
EAAE Seminar162 CAP and innovationEAAE Seminar162 CAP and innovation
EAAE Seminar162 CAP and innovationKrijn Poppe
 
CEPS seminar -Public goods from private land
CEPS seminar -Public goods from private landCEPS seminar -Public goods from private land
CEPS seminar -Public goods from private landallysun
 
Scotland_the future of the CAP
Scotland_the future of the CAPScotland_the future of the CAP
Scotland_the future of the CAPallysun
 
Biodiversity in the EU Budget and Tracking
Biodiversity in the EU Budget and TrackingBiodiversity in the EU Budget and Tracking
Biodiversity in the EU Budget and TrackingOECD Environment
 
20151202_Infoday RS2_Marta Conde 1
20151202_Infoday RS2_Marta Conde 120151202_Infoday RS2_Marta Conde 1
20151202_Infoday RS2_Marta Conde 1Redit
 
The Future of Food and Farming: EU and the CAP
The Future of Food and Farming: EU and the CAPThe Future of Food and Farming: EU and the CAP
The Future of Food and Farming: EU and the CAPTassos Haniotis
 
Biodiversity Mainstreaming through National Policies and Legislation
Biodiversity Mainstreaming through National Policies and Legislation Biodiversity Mainstreaming through National Policies and Legislation
Biodiversity Mainstreaming through National Policies and Legislation ExternalEvents
 
GFPR 2022 Nigeria June 23 _Report Overview and Policy Messages.pptx
GFPR 2022 Nigeria June 23 _Report Overview and Policy Messages.pptxGFPR 2022 Nigeria June 23 _Report Overview and Policy Messages.pptx
GFPR 2022 Nigeria June 23 _Report Overview and Policy Messages.pptxOmobolanle3
 
James Griffiths Evaluating Biodiversity Tokyo 170211
James Griffiths Evaluating Biodiversity Tokyo 170211James Griffiths Evaluating Biodiversity Tokyo 170211
James Griffiths Evaluating Biodiversity Tokyo 170211wbcsdslideshare
 
Rural Network for improvement and dissemination of soil conservation systems ...
Rural Network for improvement and dissemination of soil conservation systems ...Rural Network for improvement and dissemination of soil conservation systems ...
Rural Network for improvement and dissemination of soil conservation systems ...ExternalEvents
 
Ecosystems services: the essential capital for the poorest (UNDP presentation)
Ecosystems services: the essential capital for the poorest  (UNDP presentation)Ecosystems services: the essential capital for the poorest  (UNDP presentation)
Ecosystems services: the essential capital for the poorest (UNDP presentation)UNDP Eurasia
 
Els serveis ambientals dels ecosistemes: quin pes tenen en el context socioec...
Els serveis ambientals dels ecosistemes: quin pes tenen en el context socioec...Els serveis ambientals dels ecosistemes: quin pes tenen en el context socioec...
Els serveis ambientals dels ecosistemes: quin pes tenen en el context socioec...Medi Ambient. Generalitat de Catalunya
 
Chmielinski P. et al. (2020), CAP second pillar and rural development in the ...
Chmielinski P. et al. (2020), CAP second pillar and rural development in the ...Chmielinski P. et al. (2020), CAP second pillar and rural development in the ...
Chmielinski P. et al. (2020), CAP second pillar and rural development in the ...Paweł Chmieliński
 

Ähnlich wie Farmers & environmentalists need new CAP to face challenges (20)

Redesigning the CAP
Redesigning the CAPRedesigning the CAP
Redesigning the CAP
 
Nijenrode lecture 2021 krijn poppe
Nijenrode lecture 2021 krijn poppeNijenrode lecture 2021 krijn poppe
Nijenrode lecture 2021 krijn poppe
 
Multifunctional Approaches in EU policies
Multifunctional Approaches in EU policies Multifunctional Approaches in EU policies
Multifunctional Approaches in EU policies
 
Juli Mylona - Bioconomy - plant science and agriculture. Future funding under...
Juli Mylona - Bioconomy - plant science and agriculture. Future funding under...Juli Mylona - Bioconomy - plant science and agriculture. Future funding under...
Juli Mylona - Bioconomy - plant science and agriculture. Future funding under...
 
EAAE Seminar162 CAP and innovation
EAAE Seminar162 CAP and innovationEAAE Seminar162 CAP and innovation
EAAE Seminar162 CAP and innovation
 
CEPS seminar -Public goods from private land
CEPS seminar -Public goods from private landCEPS seminar -Public goods from private land
CEPS seminar -Public goods from private land
 
Scotland_the future of the CAP
Scotland_the future of the CAPScotland_the future of the CAP
Scotland_the future of the CAP
 
Biodiversity in the EU Budget and Tracking
Biodiversity in the EU Budget and TrackingBiodiversity in the EU Budget and Tracking
Biodiversity in the EU Budget and Tracking
 
20151202_Infoday RS2_Marta Conde 1
20151202_Infoday RS2_Marta Conde 120151202_Infoday RS2_Marta Conde 1
20151202_Infoday RS2_Marta Conde 1
 
The Future of Food and Farming: EU and the CAP
The Future of Food and Farming: EU and the CAPThe Future of Food and Farming: EU and the CAP
The Future of Food and Farming: EU and the CAP
 
Biodiversity Mainstreaming through National Policies and Legislation
Biodiversity Mainstreaming through National Policies and Legislation Biodiversity Mainstreaming through National Policies and Legislation
Biodiversity Mainstreaming through National Policies and Legislation
 
GFPR 2022 Nigeria June 23 _Report Overview and Policy Messages.pptx
GFPR 2022 Nigeria June 23 _Report Overview and Policy Messages.pptxGFPR 2022 Nigeria June 23 _Report Overview and Policy Messages.pptx
GFPR 2022 Nigeria June 23 _Report Overview and Policy Messages.pptx
 
PtB of IEEP at EESC's Sustainable Develoment Observatory Conference on SDGs a...
PtB of IEEP at EESC's Sustainable Develoment Observatory Conference on SDGs a...PtB of IEEP at EESC's Sustainable Develoment Observatory Conference on SDGs a...
PtB of IEEP at EESC's Sustainable Develoment Observatory Conference on SDGs a...
 
Food Policies in the Global North
Food Policies in the Global NorthFood Policies in the Global North
Food Policies in the Global North
 
James Griffiths Evaluating Biodiversity Tokyo 170211
James Griffiths Evaluating Biodiversity Tokyo 170211James Griffiths Evaluating Biodiversity Tokyo 170211
James Griffiths Evaluating Biodiversity Tokyo 170211
 
Rural Network for improvement and dissemination of soil conservation systems ...
Rural Network for improvement and dissemination of soil conservation systems ...Rural Network for improvement and dissemination of soil conservation systems ...
Rural Network for improvement and dissemination of soil conservation systems ...
 
Ecosystems services: the essential capital for the poorest (UNDP presentation)
Ecosystems services: the essential capital for the poorest  (UNDP presentation)Ecosystems services: the essential capital for the poorest  (UNDP presentation)
Ecosystems services: the essential capital for the poorest (UNDP presentation)
 
Els serveis ambientals dels ecosistemes: quin pes tenen en el context socioec...
Els serveis ambientals dels ecosistemes: quin pes tenen en el context socioec...Els serveis ambientals dels ecosistemes: quin pes tenen en el context socioec...
Els serveis ambientals dels ecosistemes: quin pes tenen en el context socioec...
 
Chmielinski P. et al. (2020), CAP second pillar and rural development in the ...
Chmielinski P. et al. (2020), CAP second pillar and rural development in the ...Chmielinski P. et al. (2020), CAP second pillar and rural development in the ...
Chmielinski P. et al. (2020), CAP second pillar and rural development in the ...
 
Climate Change and Food Systems: Transformation for Adaptation, Mitigation, a...
Climate Change and Food Systems: Transformation for Adaptation, Mitigation, a...Climate Change and Food Systems: Transformation for Adaptation, Mitigation, a...
Climate Change and Food Systems: Transformation for Adaptation, Mitigation, a...
 

Mehr von Ireland's National Rural Network

Transnational & Inter-Territorial Cooperation Between Rural Areas - Martin Mc...
Transnational & Inter-Territorial Cooperation Between Rural Areas - Martin Mc...Transnational & Inter-Territorial Cooperation Between Rural Areas - Martin Mc...
Transnational & Inter-Territorial Cooperation Between Rural Areas - Martin Mc...Ireland's National Rural Network
 
Role of Leader in creating local alliances - Jean Michae Courades
Role of Leader in creating local alliances - Jean Michae CouradesRole of Leader in creating local alliances - Jean Michae Courades
Role of Leader in creating local alliances - Jean Michae CouradesIreland's National Rural Network
 
Transnational & Inter-territorial Projects: The Ballyhoura Development Experi...
Transnational & Inter-territorial Projects: The Ballyhoura Development Experi...Transnational & Inter-territorial Projects: The Ballyhoura Development Experi...
Transnational & Inter-territorial Projects: The Ballyhoura Development Experi...Ireland's National Rural Network
 
Development of Trans-National Cooperation projects - Adrian Neal
Development of Trans-National Cooperation projects - Adrian NealDevelopment of Trans-National Cooperation projects - Adrian Neal
Development of Trans-National Cooperation projects - Adrian NealIreland's National Rural Network
 

Mehr von Ireland's National Rural Network (14)

Collaboration in Local Development - Ciaran Lynch
Collaboration in Local Development - Ciaran LynchCollaboration in Local Development - Ciaran Lynch
Collaboration in Local Development - Ciaran Lynch
 
Measuring the impact of the RDP - Paul Keating
Measuring the impact of the RDP - Paul KeatingMeasuring the impact of the RDP - Paul Keating
Measuring the impact of the RDP - Paul Keating
 
Co-operatives: An Overview - Martin Meteyard
Co-operatives: An Overview - Martin MeteyardCo-operatives: An Overview - Martin Meteyard
Co-operatives: An Overview - Martin Meteyard
 
Transnational & Inter-Territorial Cooperation Between Rural Areas - Martin Mc...
Transnational & Inter-Territorial Cooperation Between Rural Areas - Martin Mc...Transnational & Inter-Territorial Cooperation Between Rural Areas - Martin Mc...
Transnational & Inter-Territorial Cooperation Between Rural Areas - Martin Mc...
 
Agriculture and Business - John Malone
Agriculture and Business - John MaloneAgriculture and Business - John Malone
Agriculture and Business - John Malone
 
Role of Leader in creating local alliances - Jean Michae Courades
Role of Leader in creating local alliances - Jean Michae CouradesRole of Leader in creating local alliances - Jean Michae Courades
Role of Leader in creating local alliances - Jean Michae Courades
 
From Noaberhulp to Network - Johann Schulte
From Noaberhulp to Network - Johann SchulteFrom Noaberhulp to Network - Johann Schulte
From Noaberhulp to Network - Johann Schulte
 
Measuring the Impact of the RDP - Bernd Schuh
Measuring the Impact of the RDP - Bernd SchuhMeasuring the Impact of the RDP - Bernd Schuh
Measuring the Impact of the RDP - Bernd Schuh
 
Transnational & Inter-territorial Projects: The Ballyhoura Development Experi...
Transnational & Inter-territorial Projects: The Ballyhoura Development Experi...Transnational & Inter-territorial Projects: The Ballyhoura Development Experi...
Transnational & Inter-territorial Projects: The Ballyhoura Development Experi...
 
Reinventing Co-operatives - Seamus O Donohoe
Reinventing Co-operatives - Seamus O DonohoeReinventing Co-operatives - Seamus O Donohoe
Reinventing Co-operatives - Seamus O Donohoe
 
Development of Trans-National Cooperation projects - Adrian Neal
Development of Trans-National Cooperation projects - Adrian NealDevelopment of Trans-National Cooperation projects - Adrian Neal
Development of Trans-National Cooperation projects - Adrian Neal
 
About the NRN
About the NRNAbout the NRN
About the NRN
 
Social Partnership and the Evolution of LEADER in Ireland
Social Partnership and the Evolution of LEADER in IrelandSocial Partnership and the Evolution of LEADER in Ireland
Social Partnership and the Evolution of LEADER in Ireland
 
Irish Farmers Markets - Technical Survey
Irish Farmers Markets - Technical SurveyIrish Farmers Markets - Technical Survey
Irish Farmers Markets - Technical Survey
 

Farmers & environmentalists need new CAP to face challenges

  • 1. Building alliances between farmers & environmentalists What CAP is needed to face up to the environmental challenges? 1 December 2009, Dublin Luigi Boccaccio BirdLife International Stefan Benko Ariel Brunner Ariel Brunner L Boccaccio
  • 2.
  • 3. The “Health Check” has left the CAP basically unchanged until 2013. We can’t afford more waiting Conservation status of agricultural habitats European Commission 2009 RSPB Mariano Fracchiolla
  • 4. The CAP has changed… but has also stayed the same! Source, DG Agri EU-10 EU-12 EU-15 EU-25 EU-27
  • 5. 8% of the CAP is currently directed at the environment ...yet the whole CAP money is accounted as “ Preservation and management of natural resources” under Heading 2 of the EU budget! CAP 2007-2013 budget (including national financing) RSPB & IEEP figures based on Rural Development Programmes Completely untargeted spending, mostly historic entitlements discriminating against extensive farming
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17. Thank you for your attention! BIRDLIFE INTERNATIONAL EUROPEAN DIVISION Avenue de la Toison d’Or 67 1060 BRUSSELS- BELGIUM Tel. +32 2 280 08 30 www.birdlife.org Ariel Brunner Ariel Brunner Stefan Benko [email_address] Luigi Boccaccio