This document provides an overview of chapter 14 from a textbook on controlling productivity, quality, and safety. It begins with learning objectives for the chapter, which cover explaining concepts like productivity, quality control, and safety regulations. It then discusses topics like measuring and improving productivity, the history and tools of quality control like flowcharts and control charts, and the supervisor's role in quality and safety. Graphics include charts showing productivity growth and injury rates by industry. The overall document serves as instructional material on controlling key business operations.
2. Learning Objectives
Learning Objectives
After reading and studying this chapter, you should
be able to:
1. Explain the concept of productivity.
2. Identify and explain the ways in which management,
government, unions, and employees affect
productivity.
3. Describe some steps supervisors can take to increase
productivity.
4. Differentiate between total quality and quality control.
5. Describe the role of variance in controlling quality.
6. 2008 Thomson/SouthŠ Identify some important tools for controlling quality.
Western. All rights reserved.
14â2
3. Learning Objectives (contâd)
Learning Objectives (contâd)
After reading and studying this chapter, you should
be able to:
7. Explain what the Occupational Safety and Health
Administration (OSHA) does.
8. Describe the supervisorâs role in promoting safety.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â3
4. Global Competition and Productivity
⢠High U.S. Productivity:
Mid-1990s to Present
ď To overcome stagnant
productivity, U.S.
companies built new
facilities, upgraded
technology, transformed
production processes and
work methods, and
invested heavily in
employee training.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â4
5. EXHIBIT 14.1
U.S. Productivity Growth in Manufacturing Output per Hour: 1960sâ2006
Year
Annual Rate
Year
Annual Rate
1960s
2.2
1995
3.9
1970s
2.7
1996
4.1
1980s
1.4
1997
5.0
1990
2.5
1998
4.8
1991
2.3
1999
5.1
1992
5.1
2000
4.1
1993
2.2
2001
0.9
1994
3.1
2002
4.8
2003
6.2
2004
1.4
2005
4.1
2006 (1st Quarter)
3.7
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
14â5
6. Improving Productivity and Cost Control
⢠Productivity
ď Indicates how efficiently a country is utilizing its
human resources in producing goods and services.
ď Is a measure of efficiency (inputs to outputs).
⢠Calculating the Productivity Ratio:
Total output of goods/services
Total costs (or inputs)
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â6
7. Improving Productivity
⢠How Productivity is Increased
1. Increase the total output without
changing the total costs.
2. Decrease the total input costs
without changing the total
output.
3. Increase the output and
decrease the input costs.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â7
8. EXHIBIT 14.2
Examples of Productivity Measurements
Input
Output
Salesperson labor hours
Sales volume per salesperson
Energy used, in BTUs
Number of pounds fabricated
Training hours for customer service
personnel
Percent of error-free written orders
Number of hours of plantwide safety
meetings
Number of accident-free days
Labor hours spent on preventive
maintenance
Number of hours without a machine
breakdown
Cost of raw materials
Quantity of finished goods produced
Total labor hours of service personnel
Total quantity of services produced
Total labor hours of production
workforce
Total quantity of goods produced
Total costs
Total number (or value) of goods or
services produced
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthBTU, British thermal unit.
Western. All rights reserved.
14â8
9. Why Productivity Is Important
⢠For Individual Companies:
ď Increased productivity translates into lower prices,
larger market share, and greater profits.
ď Enables investment in research and development,
new advanced technology, increased wages and
benefits, and improved working conditions.
⢠For a Nation:
ď Increased productivity greatly enhances its economic
growth and health.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â9
11. EXHIBIT 14.5
How Supervisors Can Improve Employee Productivity
⢠Train employees. Can their abilities be upgraded?
⢠Clearly communicate the need for high standards so that
workers understand what is expected of them.
⢠Use motivation techniques to inspire workers to increase
output. Pride, ego, and security are several important
motivators available.
⢠Eliminate idleness, extended breaks, and early quitting
time.
⢠Build in quality the first time work is done. Productivity is
lost when items are scrapped or need to be reworked.
⢠Work on improving attendance and turnover in your work
group.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â11
12. EXHIBIT 14.5
How Supervisors Can Improve Employee Productivity (contâd)
⢠Reduce accidents. Accidents normally result in time lost
to investigations, meetings, and reportsâeven if the
employee does not suffer a lostâwork-time injury.
⢠Seek to improve production measures. Will process or
work-flow improvements help?
⢠Try to eliminate or reduce equipment or machinery
breakdowns. Preventive maintenance is important.
⢠Exercise good control techniques. Follow up on
performance and take corrective action promptly.
⢠Involve your employees in the process of improvement.
Select their ideas and suggestions for improvement.
Form special productivity improvement teams.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â12
13. EXHIBIT 14.6
Performance Report
Name of department
Fabrication
Performance period
November 2006
Budgeted output
15,700 lbs.
Budgeted scrap
152 lbs.
Actual output
15,227 lbs.
Actual scrap
120 lbs.
Variance
â473 lbs.
Item
Direct labor
Overtime
Supplies
Maintenance and repairs
Utilities
Scrapped material
Total
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
+32 lbs.
Actual
$32,000
1,500
500
4,250
1,300
1,200
$40,750
Budgeted
$32,000
1,000
385
3,000
1,200
1,520
$39,105
14â13
Variance
$
0
â500
â115
â1,250
â100
â320
â$1,645
14. Recent Productivity Improvement Methods
⢠Robotics
ď The use of programmed computer-controlled
machines to perform repetitive manipulations of tools
or materials.
⢠Just-in-Time (JIT) Inventory Control System
ď Scheduling materials to arrive only when they are
needed in the production process.
⢠Computer-Assisted Manufacturing (CAM)
ď Using special computers to assist equipment in
performing processes.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â14
15. Historical Insight
⢠Evolution of the Quality Explosion in the U.S.
ď W. Edwards Demingâs 85â15 rule
ďś Assumes
that when things go wrong, 85 percent of
the time the cause is from elements controlled by
management.
ďś Management rather than the employee is to blame
for most poor quality.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â15
16. EXHIBIT 14.7
Demingâs Fourteen Points for Quality
1. Top management should establish and publish a statement of the
organizationâs purpose and commitment to quality products and services
and continuous improvement.
2. Everyone throughout the organization should learn the new philosophy.
3. Dependence on âinspectingâ quality into products should be shifted to an
attitude of âexpectingâ quality by having it built into the system.
4. There must be a systematic way to select quality suppliers, rather than
simply on the basis of cost.
5. The organization must be devoted to continuous improvement.
6. All employees should be trained in the most modern quality and problemsolving techniques.
7. Leadership techniques consistent with getting the most commitment from
employees should be practiced throughout the entire organization.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
Source: From W. Edwards Deming, Out of Crisis (Cambridge, MA, MIT Press, 1986).
14â16
17. EXHIBIT 14.7
Demingâs Fourteen Points for Quality (contâd)
8.
Fear should be eliminated from the work environment.
9.
Teams and work groups must work smoothly together; barriers between
functional departments must be eliminated.
10. Exhortations, posters, and slogans asking for new levels of workforce
productivity must be backed by providing the methods to achieve these.
11. Numerical production quotas should be eliminated. Constant
improvement should be sought instead.
12. Barriers that deprive employees from pride in their work must be
removed.
13. A vigorous program of education, retraining, and self-improvement for all
employees must be instituted.
14. A structure in top management that will push the thirteen points above to
achieve the transformation must be created.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
Source: From W. Edwards Deming, Out of Crisis (Cambridge, MA, MIT Press, 1986).
14â17
18. EXHIBIT 14.8
The Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award
Organizations must observe eight essentials in order to win:
1. Establish a plan to seek improvement continuously in all phases of operationsâ
not just manufacturing but purchasing, sales, human relations, and other areas.
2. Put in place a system that accurately tracks and measures performance in those
areas.
3. Establish a long-term strategic plan based on performance targets that compare
with the worldâs best in that particular industry.
4. Link closely in a partnership with suppliers and customers in a way that provides
needed feedback for continuous improvement.
5. Demonstrate a deep understanding of customers in order to convert their wants
into products.
6. Establish and maintain long-lasting customer relationships, going beyond
product manufacture and delivery to include sales, service, and ease of
maintenance.
7. Focus on preventing mistakes instead of developing efficient ways to correct
them; that is, feedforward control is a must.
8. Perhaps most difficult, but imperative, is to make a commitment to quality
improvement throughout all levels of the organization, including top, middle, and
bottom.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â18
19. EXHIBIT 14.9
The Total Quality Chain
Total Quality
Refers to an organizationâs overall effort to achieve customer satisfaction
through continuous improvement of products or services.
Quality Control Defined
Measurements designed to check whether the desired quality standards
are being met.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â19
20. Tools for Controlling Quality
⢠Flowchart
ď A visual representation of the sequence of steps
needed to complete a process.
⢠Histogram
ď A graphical representation of the variation found in a
set of data.
⢠Run Chart
ď Data presentation showing results of a process
plotted over time.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â20
21. EXHIBIT 14.10
Flowchart of a Fast-Food Drive-Through Process
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â21
22. EXHIBIT 14.11
Histogram Showing Frequency and Length of Time
Taken by Home Office to Process Loan Request
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
Source: From Total Quality by James W. Dean and James R. Evans. Š 1994. Reprinted with
permission of South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning: www.thomsonrights.com.
14â22
23. EXHIBIT 14.12
Run Chart of Percentage of Restaurant Customers
Waiting in Excess of 1 Minute to Be Seated
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
Source: From Foundations of Total Quality Management: A Readings Book by J. G. Van Matre. Š 1995.
Reprinted with permission of South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning: www.thomsonrights.com.
14â23
24. Tools for Controlling Quality (contâd)
⢠Pareto Charts
ď Problem-analysis charts that use a histogram to
illustrate sources of problems.
⢠Cause-and-Effect Diagram
ď A graphical display of a chain of causes and effects.
⢠Control Chart
ď A statistical control process chart that displays the
âstate of controlâ of a process.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â24
25. EXHIBIT 14.13
Pareto Chart of Customersâ Complaints about Restaurants
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
Source: From Foundations of Total Quality Management: A Readings Book, 1/e by J. G. Van Matre, p. 146. -0030078660. Š 1995.
Reprinted with permission of South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning: www.thomsonrights.com. Fax 800 730-2215
14â25
26. EXHIBIT 14.14
Cause-and-Effect Diagram for âWhy Tables Are Not Cleared Quicklyâ
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
Source: From Foundations of Total Quality Management: A Readings Book, 1/e by J. G. Van Matre, p. 146. -0030078660. Š 1995.
Reprinted with permission of South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning: www.thomsonrights.com. Fax 800 730-2215
14â26
27. EXHIBIT 14.15
Example of a Control Chart
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
Source: From Total Quality, Management, Organization, and Strategy, 1st edition by Dean/Evans Š 1994. Reprinted
with permission of South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning: www.thomsonrights.com. Fax 800 730-2215
14â27
28. The Supervisorâs Role in Achieving Quality
⢠Supervisors can impact quality by:
ď Emphasizing the importance of high quality
ď Providing information and support to help employees
achieve quality
ď Providing meaningful feedback to employees.
⢠Motivating workers to achieve high quality work
requires that supervisors:
ď Let employees know the quality performance is
expected
ď Involve workers in achieving and controlling quality.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â28
29. EXHIBIT 14.16
Characteristics of Effective Employee Involvement Teams
⢠Managers at all levels, especially at the top, should be committed
to the concept and give it their unqualified support.
⢠Projects undertaken should relate directlyâor at least indirectlyâ
to participantsâ work.
⢠Projects should be team efforts, not individual activities.
⢠Participants should be trained in quality-control, decision making,
and problem-solving techniques.
⢠Team leaders also should be trained in group dynamics and
leadership of a group.
⢠Teams should be given feedbackâin the form of resultsâ
regarding their recommendations and solutions.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â29
30. Promoting Employee Safety
⢠The Occupational Safety and Health
Administration (OSHA)
ď Is a federal agency created in 1970 by the
Occupational Safety and Health Act to provide
consistently safer and healthier working conditions for
employees.
ď Requires organizations to keep safety logs and
records of illnesses and injuries incurred on the job
ď Develops standards, conduct standards compliance
inspections, and issues citations and penalties
against organizations that fail to comply.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â30
31. Factors Influencing Safety
Size of the Organization
Size of the Organization
Type of Industry
Type of Industry
Safety
Safety
The People
The People
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â31
32. EXHIBIT 14.20
Occupational Injury and Illness Rates: Selected Industries, 2004
Industry
Incidence Rate per 100 employees
Iron Foundries
15.3
Mobile Home Mfg
15.0
Ship Building/Repair
12.3
Motor Vehicle Body Mfg.
11.3
Dairies
10.3
Soft Drink Producers
10.2
Airlines
10.0
Hospitals
7.6
Taxi Service
6.7
Grocery Stores
6.3
Hotels
5.7
Auto Dealerships
4.9
Full Service Restaurants
4.0
Book Stores
3.3
Real Estate Firms
3.2
Colleges and Universities
2.7
Womenâs Clothing Stores
2.4
Radio and TV Broadcasting
1.5
Banks
1.5
CPA Firms
0.3
Average incidence rate for
Š 2008 Thomson/South- all industries:
Western. All rights reserved.
4.8
14â32
33. Causes of Accidents
Human Factors
Human Factors
Technical Factors
Technical Factors
Accidents
Accidents
Environmental Factors
Environmental Factors
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â33
34. EXHIBIT 14.21
Personal Injury Investigation
Injured:
Fred Hanna
Position:
Lab Assistant
Presiding:
L. C. Smithson, Technical Supt.
Date of meeting:
4/15/2003
Time of meeting:
2:34 p.m.
Place of meeting:
Plant Conference Room
Present:
L. C. Smithson (Technical Supt.), Fred Hanna (injured), Jim Berry (Housekeeping),
Tom Ahens (Safety Director), Kim Jernigan (Supervisor)
Nature of injury:
Fractured distal end of radius, right arm
Lost time:
42 days (estimated)
Accident time and date:
4/13/2003 at 7:15 a.m.
Cause of injury:
Floor was wetâappeared to be water. Investigation revealed that bags of Seperan (a
synthetic polymer) had been rearranged during the 11 p.m.â7 a.m. shift. One bag
was torn, and its contents had trickled onto the floor, causing it to be exceptionally
slippery when washed at the end of the shift. Janitor noticed but did not flag it or
attempt to remove hazard, as he noted at the end of his shift.
Corrective steps/recommendations:
1. Apply grit to slippery areas; mark with appropriate warning signs.
2. Remind incoming shift personnel of hazardous conditions.
3. Communicate to incoming shift personnel any job priorities.
4. Store Seperan in a more remote area of the plant.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â34
35. EXHIBIT 14.22
What Supervisors Can Do to Improve Safety
⢠Push for upgraded safety equipment and safer work methods.
⢠Establish and communicate safety goals for the department.
⢠Clearly communicate safety requirements to all employees.
⢠Listen to employee job complaints about safety-related matters, including
noise, fatigue, and working conditions.
⢠Make sure new employees thoroughly understand equipment and safety
rules.
⢠Prohibit use of unsafe or damaged equipment.
⢠Encourage safety suggestions from your workers.
⢠Post safety bulletins, slogans, and posters to reinforce the need for safety.
⢠Refuse to let rush jobs cause relaxed safety standards.
⢠Set a proper example. Donât bend safety rules yourself.
⢠Conduct periodic safety meetings, with demonstrations by employee safety
Š specialists or insurance representatives.
2008 Thomson/South-
Western. All rights reserved.
14â35
36. EXHIBIT 14.22
What Supervisors Can Do to Improve Safety (contâd)
⢠Refuse to tolerate horseplay.
⢠Compete with other departments in safety contests.
⢠Report to employees any accidents that occur elsewhere in the company.
⢠Review past accident records for trends and insights.
⢠Encourage reporting of unsafe conditions.
⢠Make regular safety inspections of all major equipment.
⢠Enforce the rules when they are brokenâtake appropriate disciplinary
action to demonstrate your safety commitment.
⢠Look for signs of fatigue in employees, such as massaging shoulders,
rubbing eyes, and stretching or shifting position to relieve pain or fatigue. In
such a case, relief for the employee may be warranted.
⢠Thoroughly investigate all accidents and attempt to remedy the causes.
⢠Develop a system for rewarding or acknowledging excellent safety conduct.
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
14â36
37. Important Terms
Important Terms
⢠cause-and-effect diagram
⢠computer-assisted
manufacturing (CAM)
⢠control chart
⢠Demingâs 85â15 rule
⢠flowchart
⢠histogram
⢠just-in-time (JIT) inventory
⢠Occupational Safety and
Health Administration
(OSHA)
Š 2008 Thomson/SouthWestern. All rights reserved.
â˘
â˘
â˘
â˘
â˘
â˘
â˘
Pareto charts
productivity
quality control
robot
run chart
total quality
Toyota Production
System
14â37