Introduction to Multilingual Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)
EESAP4 Lodder, Marleen
1. ERASMUS UNIVERSITY ROTTERDAM
Rotterdam School of Management (RSM) &
Dutch Research Institute for Transitions (DRIFT)
Cradle to Cradle® in the Built
Environment
@ 4th European Conference on Energy
Efficiency and Sustainability in
Architecture and Planning
Academic Chair ‘Cradle to Cradle for Innovation and Quality’
Cradle to Cradle® and C2C® are registered trademarks held by McDonough Braungart Design Chemistry, LLC (MBDC).
2. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
‘CRADLE TO CRADLE FOR INNOVATION AND QUALITY’
Department of Decision and Information Sciences
Rotterdam School of Management (RSM)
Katja Hansen
Senior Researcher
Diana den Held
Senior Researcher
Douglas Mulhall
Senior Researcher
prof.dr. Michael Braungart Marleen Lodder
PhD Student
2
3. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
‘CRADLE TO CRADLE FOR INNOVATION AND QUALITY’
1. Erasmus University Rotterdam
“Cradle to Cradle for Innovation
and Quality”
Rotterdam School of Management
2. University Twente
“Cradle to Cradle in Industrial
Design Engineering”
3. Technical University Delft
Visiting professorship
Building Design Technology
Faculty of Architecture
- C2C lab
• Technische Universität München
Cradle to Cradle Followship
Fakultät für Bauingenieur-
und Vermessungswesen
Fakultät für Architektur
3
4. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
MARLEEN LODDER
– PhD-candidate Erasmus University Rotterdam
• Rotterdam School of Management (RSM)
• Dutch Research Institute for Transitions (DRIFT)
– The Transition towards Beneficial Area (Re)Development
• Ecological-, Economical and Societal Added Value
• Healthy Area’s in itself and for their surroundings
• Variable Scales according to context and continuous cycles
• Process that involves public-, private-, civil society- & ecological “stakeholders”
– Background
• Master Architectural Engineering, Eindhoven University of Technology
• Bachelor Built Environment, Avans University of Applied Sciences ‘s-
Hertogenbosch
4
5. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
Source: EPEA
5
BEECH TREE
6. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
CRADLE TO CARDLE® IN THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT
Michael Braungart & William McDonough
"We do not want sustainability, because that is not enough. We want real quality.“
(Braungart)
“A delightfully diverse, safe, healthy and just world - with clean air, soil, water and power -
economically, equitably, ecologically, and elegantly enjoyed.”
(McDonough)
Source: http://www.amazon.com Source: http://www.mcdonough.com Source: http://greenatwork.com
6
7. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
CRADLE TO CARDLE® IN THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT
7
Up
8. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
Source: EPEA
8
TAKE – MAKE – WASTE
9. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
FRACTAL TRIANGLE
(McDonough W. & Braungart M., 2002)
McDonough, W., & Braungart, M. (2002). Design for the triple top line: New tools for sustainable commerce. Corporate Environmental Strategy, 9(3), 251-258.
9
10. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
TRIPLE TOP LINE
(McDonough W. & Braungart M., 2002)
“triple top line growth:
products that enhance
the well-being of nature
and culture while
generating economic
value” (pp252)
McDonough, W., & Braungart, M. (2002). Design for the triple top line: New tools for sustainable commerce. Corporate Environmental Strategy, 9(3), 251-258.
Source: Diana den Held
10
11. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
BUILDINGS LIKE TREES
ECO EFFICIENCY– ECO-EFFECTIVENESS
Source: EPEA
11
Doing things
right
Doing the
right things!
12. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 201312
HOW CAN ONE BECOME CLIMATE NEUTRAL?
Source: UNEP
13. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 201313
HOW CAN A CITY BECOME CARBON NEUTRAL?
Source: Copenhagen climate plan
14. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
?
THE GREENEST HOUSE IS THAT, THAT IS NEVER BUILT?
14
15. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
Source: Toyota
15
TREES WITH ZERO EMISSIONS?
16. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
?
TREES HAVE BENEFICIAL EMISSIONS
Source: EPEA
16
Absorbs CO2
Produces Oxygen
Produces biomass
Supports biodiversity
Provides habitat to many species
Filters the air
Makes soil
………. etc.
17. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
Source: http://atsukojoe.wordpress.com
17
HOW HUMANS COULD HAVE A…………………
…………………BIG BENEFICIAL FOOTPRINT
18. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
?
AND HOW BUILDINGS COULD HAVE A…………………
…………………BIG FOOTPRINT!
Source: Unknown
18
19. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
Source: http://www.stefanoboeriarchitetti.net/
19
BUILDINGS LIKE TREES – CITIES LIKE FORESTS
20. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
QUALITY INGREDIENTS + QUALITY DESIGN =
QUALITY PRODUCTS
=
20
Source: EPEA
21. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
UNKNOWN INGREDIENTS & UGLY DESIGN =
LOW QUALITY PRODUCTS
= ?
21
Source: EPEA
22. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
Source: http://www.businessweek.com Source: http://home.howstuffworks.com
22
INDOOR AIR QUALITY
23. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
HAITI & TURKEY. BAD DESIGN & UNKNOWN
INGREDIENTS = CATASTROPHE
Source: EPEA
23
24. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
OFF-GASSING OF CHILDREN'S TOYS
QUALITY QUESTION
Source: HUI
24
25. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
OFF-GASSING OF “NATURAL” CARPET
QUALITY QUESTION
Source: HUI
25
26. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
?
- Based on Stewart Brand, How Buildings Learn, 1994
26
27. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
BIOLOGICAL & TECHNICAL METHOBOLISMS
Source: EPEA
27
Up
28. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
SERVICE PRODUCTS
- Upcycled of re-used at the same or a higher quality in a technical environment
Source: EPEA
28
Up
29. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
CONSUMPTION PRODUCTS
- Cascade models for creating added value for the natural environment as “food”
29
Source: EPEA Source: http://methodhome.com/ocean-plastic/
Up
30. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
Source: EPEA Source: http://methodhome.com/ocean-plastic/
CONSUMPTION PRODUCTS
- Cascade models for creating added value for the natural environment as “food”
Source: Bor, A., Hansen, K., Goedkoop, M., Rivière, A., Alvarado,
C., & van den Wittenboer, W. (2011). Usability of life cycle
assessment for cradle to cradle purposes. Utrecht: NL Agency.
30
Up
31. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
MINIMIZE THE NEGATIVE FOOTPRINT….
…. WHILE OPTIMIZING THE POSITIVE
31
Source: Based on image by Royal Haskoning
33. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
CONTEXT SPECIFIC PRINCIPLES
- Hannover Principles
- Almere Principles
- Venlo Principles
- Limburg Principles
- Marina Principles
- C2C Architects Manifesto
- C2C Architecture Charter
33
34. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
There is not yet a 100%
C2C building, highway or airport
New approaches are required to get there.
Focus on Innovation instead of
Certification
34
35. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
FRAMEWORK:
CRADLE TO CRADLE CRITERIA FOR THE BUILT
ENVIRONMENT
PLANNING GUIDE
How To Plan A Big Beneficial Footprint; Guide To Innovation Tools For
Cradle To Cradle-Inspired Value In Building Developments.
REGISTRY
http://www.rsm.nl/research/decision-information-sciences/research/cradle-to-cradle-for-innovation-and-quality/registry/
35
36. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
C2C® CRITERIA FOR THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT
For more information see:
http://www.duurzaamgebouwd.nl/bookstore
36
37. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
- Definition of a C2C building
- Criteria based on C2C principles
- Implementation criteria
- Measuring intentions, milestones & roadmaps
- Defining C2C energy
C2C® CRITERIA FOR THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT
37
38. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
DEFINITION OF A CRADLE TO CRADLE® BUILDING
“Cradle to Cradle building contains defined elements that
add value and celebrate innovation and enjoyment by
measurably enhancing the quality of
- materials,
- biodiversity,
- air,
- and water,
- using current solar income,
- being deconstructable
- and recyclable,
- and performing diverse practical and life-enhancing
functions for its stakeholders to holistically improve the
economy, ecology and social equity.”
38
39. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
C2C® CRITERIA FOR THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT
1. State your intentions
EVERYTHING IS A NUTRIENT FOR SOMETHING ELSE
2. Quality of materials
– Defined pathways
– Defined use periods
– Design for disassembly
3. Soil production, Bio-nutrients
4. Climate, Air and Sound quality
5. Water quality
USE CURRENT SOLAR INCOME
6. Produce more energy then one needs by using current solar income
CELEBRATE DIVERSITY
7. Bio-diversity, Conceptual-diversity, Social-diversity, Cultural-
diversity
39
40. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
THE PRINCIPLE CRITERIA
1. STATE YOUR INTENTIONS.
Which C2C principles do you plan to implement by when?
Which Goals do you plan to declare?
40
41. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE:
C2C ROADMAP, measurable goals and milestones in a defined period
- Desso
Source: www.desso.com
41
42. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
THE PRINCIPLE CRITERIA
Example of Goals for the sites:
“In Ten Years Our Site is Profitably Energy-
Positive”
- Keep Investment at Home
- Generate, Sell, and Buy Power
- Install & Maintain the Systems
42
43. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
THE PRINCIPLE CRITERIA
Example of Goals for Materials:
“In ten years 90 percent of the
materials used in our building
will have C2C materials passports”
43
44. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EVERYTHING IS A NUTRIENT FOR SOMETHING ELSE
2. DEFINE MATERIALS AND THEIR INTENDED
USE PATHWAYS
(a) whose contents are measurably defined in technical or
biological pathways from manufacturing through use and
recovery and
(b) whose impacts are measurably beneficial for human health
and the environment.
44
45. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE:
- DESSO AirMaster®
A carpet which ensures cleaner air in your home or office
Source: DESSO
45
46. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE:
- DESSO AirMaster®
A carpet which ensures cleaner air in your home or office
Source: DESSO
46
47. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
C2C MATERIAL PASSPORTS & MATERIAL BANKING
- combined with Building Information Models (BIM)
Source: Based on multiple sources Source: www.ibom.biz
47
48. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
Definition Materials Passport:
Set of data describing defined characteristics of materials in
products that give them value for recovery and reuse.
Passports are a marketplace mechanism to encourage product
designs, material recovery systems, and chain of possession
partnerships that improve the quality, value, and security of
supply for materials so they can be reused in continuous
loops or closed loops or beneficially returned to biological
systems.
For other definitions please refer to Resource Repletion, Role of Buildings, Katja
Hansen, Michael Braungart, Douglas Mulhall, The Springer Encyclopaedia of
Sustainability Science and Technology, 2012, pp. 9096-9117 ISBN 978-0-387-
89469-0
MATERIAL PASSPORTS
48
49. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
Source: www.youtube.com
EXAMPLE:
Maersk
49
50. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
Source: www.youtube.com
EXAMPLE:
Maersk
50
51. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EVERYTHING IS A NUTRIENT FOR SOMETHING ELSE
3. INTEGRATE BIOLOGICAL NUTRIENTS.
Recycle biological nutrients and water by integrating topsoil and
biomass production into buildings, landscaping, and spatial plans
to generate more biomass and clean water than before
development of the site.
51
52. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE:
- QUANTIFYING NUTRIENT RECYCLING - BASIS FOR C2C
Water environment & technology 1997
Source: HUI
52
54. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EVERYTHING IS A NUTRIENT FOR SOMETHING ELSE
4. ENHANCE CLIMATE, AIR AND SOUND
QUALITY.
Actively contribute to measurably improving air quality so the
indoor air is healthier for occupants than before it entered the
building and provides a comfortable climate for occupants.
54
55. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE:
- Mosses for uptake and conversion of fine particulates
EXAMPLE:
Source: Prof. Frahm – Uni Bonn
55
56. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE:
- Happy Healthy School
EXAMPLE:
Source: http://www.happyhealthyschool.com/
56
57. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE:
- Green walls in office spaces
EXAMPLE:
Source: http://www.truestars.nl/Page/299875_groene-wanden-mos-panelen.aspx
57
58. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EVERYTHING IS A NUTRIENT FOR SOMETHING ELSE
5. ENHANCE WATER QUALITY.
Measurably improve water quality so the water is healthier for
biological metabolisms than before it entered the building.
58
59. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE:
- COVENT GARDEN: Urban applications of bionutrient recycling in temperate
climates
Source: Steven Beckers
59
60. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
USE CURRENT SOLAR INCOME
6. INTEGRATE RENEWABLE ENERGY.
Integrate renewable energy (current solar and gravitational
income) into buildings and area plans so the building and site
generate more energy than they use.
60
61. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE:
- Building integrated PV in BSH building Park 20|20
(William McDonough + Partner)
Source: http://daylightaward.nl
61
62. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
CELEBRATE DIVERSITY
7. ACTIVELY SUPPORT BIODIVERSITY.
Integrate measurable species diversity so the area supports more
diversity than before development.
62
63. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE:
- Ferrer Research & Development Center: Releasing endangered butterfly species
every week (William McDonough + Partner)
EXAMPLE:
Source:http://www.mcdonoughpartners.com
63
64. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
CELEBRATE DIVERSITY
8. CELEBRATE CONCEPTUAL DIVERSITY WITH
INNOVATION.
Focus on special beneficial features of a building and integrating
innovative components that are beneficial for the well-being of
occupants and the environment.
64
65. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE:
- Park20|20
(William McDonough + Partner)
EXAMPLE:
Source: www.bouwwereld.nl
65
66. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE:
- NIOO BUILDING
(Claus and Kaan Architects)
Source: http://www.nioo.knaw.nl
66
67. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
THE REGISTRY
For more information see:
http://www.rsm.nl/research/decision-
information-sciences/research/cradle-to-
cradle-for-innovation-and-quality/registry/
67
68. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
“Cradle to Cradle-Inspired Element support
the C2C principles, intentions and goals of
stakeholders by integrating diverse value-
added functions. The integration of quality,
added value, and beneficial impacts.”
C2C-INSPIRED ELEMENTS
Source: Building Registry
68
69. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE OF A C2C-INSPIERED ELEMENT:
- Active Green Facade
(kraaijvanger • Architects)
Source: www.youtube.com
69
70. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
EXAMPLE OF A C2C-INSPIRED ELEMENT:
- Atrium
(Steven Beckers)
Source: Steven Beckers
70
71. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
Marleen Lodder
PhD candidate | Erasmus University Rotterdam | www.marleenlodder.nl | @LMLodder
@ Dutch Research Institute For Transitions (DRIFT)
Burgemeester Oudlaan 50 | M5-37 | 3062 PA Rotterdam | The Netherlands | +31 10 4089775 | lodder@drift.eur.nl | www.drift.eur.nl
@ ROTTERDAM SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT
Academic Chair ‘Cradle to Cradle for Innovation and Quality’
Burgemeester Oudlaan 50 | T9-18 | 3062 PA Rotterdam | The Netherlands | +31 10 4082022 | mlodder@rsm.nl | www.rsm.nl
Follow me on:
Thanks for your attention!
71
72. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
THE CIRCULAR ECONOMY: C2C THE BASIS
- The Ellen MacArthur Foundation
Source: www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org
“The circular economy requires careful
management of material flows, which
are of two types. These are
characterised by McDonough and
Braungart in Cradle to Cradle:
Remaking the Way We Make Things as
biological nutrients—materials designed
to re-enter the biosphere safely and
rebuild natural capital, and technical
nutrients, designed to circulate at high
quality without entering the biosphere.”
(Towards the circular economy 2, pp 26)
72
73. Cradle to Cradle in the Built Environment - July 1st 2013
FRACTAL TRIANGLE
(McDonough W. & Braungart M., 2002)
McDonough, W., & Braungart, M. (2002). Design for the triple top line: New tools for sustainable commerce. Corporate Environmental Strategy, 9(3), 251-258.
73