Government's influence on where and how to redevelop can be used to strengthen its human capital, improve the natural environment, and assist businesses in maintaining profitability while serving community interests. While most recognize the Triple Bottom Line as a business approach, communities involved in redevelopment can also use it when formulating redevelopment strategies. Learn how this approach can help policy makers and businesses reinforce their accountability to community through sound planning practices.
Investment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy Cheruiyot
Building the triple bottom line.final
1. Robert P. Franke, AICP
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
October 14, 2010
2010 Sustainable Florida Conference
2. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
“A hundred years after we are gone and
forgotten, those who never heard of us will
be living with the results of our actions.”
Oliver Wendell Holmes, US Supreme Court Justice (1902-1932)
October 14, 2010
2
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
3. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
REDEVELOPMENT
“undertakings, activities, or projects in a
community redevelopment area for the
elimination and prevention of the development or
spread of slums and blight, or for the reduction or
prevention of crime, or for the provision of
affordable housing.”
October 14, 2010
3
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
4. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Sustainable development… meets the needs of
the present without compromising the ability of
future generations to meet their own needs.
October 14, 2010
4
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
5. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
TRIPLE BOTTOM LINE
The triple bottom line (abbreviated as "TBL" or
"3BL", and also known as "people, planet, profit")
is a measure of organizational (and societal)
success in terms of economic, ecological and
social values.
October 14, 2010
5
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
6. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
Almost all local government bodies share certain
characteristics:
a continuing organization;
the authority to undertake public activities;
the ability to enter into contracts;
the right to sue and be sued;
the ability to collect taxes and determine a budget.
Areas of local government authority usually include:
public schools;
local highways;
municipal services;
and some aspects of social welfare and public order.
October 14, 2010
6
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
8. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
163.345 Encouragement of private enterprise.--
(1) Any county or municipality, to the greatest
extent it determines to be feasible in carrying out
the provisions of this part, shall afford maximum
opportunity, consistent with the sound needs of
the county or municipality as a whole, to the
rehabilitation or redevelopment of the community
redevelopment area by private enterprise.
(emphasis added)
October 14, 2010
8
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
9. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
REDEVELOPMENT IS GUIDED BY:
FLORIDA STATUTES, CHAPTER 163, PART III
LOCAL COMPREHENSIVE PLANS
LOCAL CODES OF ORDINANCES
LOCAL LAND USE AND ZONING CODES
LOCAL DESIGN GUIDELINES
October 14, 2010
9
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
11. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
NEIGHORHOOD CENTERED
Neighborhood has distinct boundaries
Involve stakeholders
Establish shared vision
PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT
SHARED VISION
IDENTIFY ASSETS OF NEIGHBORHOOD
Redevelopment plan should be based on assets
Use workshops/community meetings/charrettes
Create clearing house for redevelopment information
October 14, 2010
11
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
12. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
QUALITY OF THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT
Shared vision
Comp plan amendments
Zoning code changes
Design regulations
Other code revisions
Agency management
ECONOMIC ELEMENT
Implement shared vision
Have funding variety
Tax increments
Tax abatements
Revolving loan pool
Restructure permit fees
October 14, 2010
12
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
13. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
POLITICAL PROCESS
Shared Vision
Leadership: Public (Elected)/Private (Unelected
Leaders)
Involve Stakeholders
Establish Clearly Defined Goals
October 14, 2010
13
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
15. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
Identify community assets as well as needs;
Strengthen community capacity;
Act as catalyst for entrepreneurship in
neighborhoods; and
Act as catalyst for business in neighborhood centers
and edge commercial
October 14, 2010
15
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
16. A CHECK LIST OF CRA PLAN BASICS FOR
THE TRIPLE BOTTOM LINE
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
16
17. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
COMMUNITY
PLACEMAKING
TRANSPORTATION / MOVEMENT
ENVIRONMENT
RESOURCES
BUSINESS
BUILDINGS
October 14, 2010
17
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
18. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
DOES YOUR CRA PLAN…
Provide for affordable housing
Provide for job opportunities
Promote access to government services
Provide access to transportation / movement
Promote improved quality of life
Involve residents in decision making process
Create community networks and interaction
Include children in the planning process
October 14, 2010
18
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
19. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
HELPING PEOPLE:
Affordable Housing:
Develop partnerships: Habitat for Humanity,
Community Development Corporations, For-profit
businesses; and
Provide incentives: land, down payment/mortgage
assistance, design services
Jobs:
Develop partnerships: Chambers of Commerce, County
Economic Development Agencies, Enterprise Florida,
School Boards, Local Business (contractors, retail,
industrial)
October 14, 2010
19
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
20. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
HELPING PEOPLE continued:
Access to government services:
Websites, meetings, newsletters, kiosks, signage
Access to transportation:
Land Use and Zoning, Bus Routes / Shelters,
Community Trolleys, Sidewalk Connections, Greenways
Improved quality of life
A combination of the above;
Identify crime reduction actions and opportunities; and
Involve neighborhood children
October 14, 2010
20
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
21. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
DOES YOUR CRA PLAN…
Promote design regulations / guidelines
Promote efficient use of land
Provide for a redevelopment design process
Provide for Way Finding
Provide for recreation (active and passive)
Promote inclusive communities
Promote crime prevention through design
Promote lighting standards to minimize overage
October 14, 2010
21
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
22. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
DOES YOUR CRA PLAN…
Provide for convenient public transportation
Provide links between modes of transport
Limit the number of required parking spaces
Provide for shared parking
Promote walking and cycling
Provide local amenities within reasonable walking
distance
October 14, 2010
22
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
23. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
DOES YOUR CRA PLAN…
Provide green spaces and linkages between
green spaces
Provide for green design (architecture /
engineering)
Provide for multi-modal transportation
Provide for community gardens or local farmers’
markets
Protect existing habitats
October 14, 2010
23
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
24. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
HELP THE ENVIRONMENT
Provide green spaces
Streetscapes, neighborhood parks, pocket parks, native
plants, involve neighborhood children
Provide for green design (architecture / engineering)
Tie to incentives, provide design assistance, update codes,
green infrastructure
Provide for multi-modal transportation
Build partnerships: local transportation agencies; amend
Comprehensive Plan and land development codes, rebuild
bicycle / pedestrian connections
Provide for community gardens or local farmers’
markets
October 14, 2010
24
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
25. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
October 14, 2010
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com 25
DOES YOUR CRA PLAN…
Promote historic preservation
Promote use of low environmental impact
materials during construction
Promote the use of locally reclaimed materials
during construction
Promote water use efficiency in projects
Encourage composting
Encourage the reduction of noise and light
pollution
26. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
October 14, 2010
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com 26
DOES YOUR CRA PLAN…
Provide administrative incentives
Provide for financial incentives
Provide for planning and land use incentives
Provide for marketing incentives
27. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
HELP BUSINESS
Provide administrative incentives
Streamline development review / building permit
review (one-stop approval)
Site selection assistance
Restructure permit fees for CRA projects
Waive fees such as demolition
Provide technical assistance for property owners and
small businesses
October 14, 2010
27
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
28. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
HELP BUSINESS continued
Provide for financial incentives
Tax credits / abatements
Loans or interest subsidies
Local, State, Federal Grants or Loans
Micro loans using local banks and savings and loans
Public assembly of land
Shared cost of upgraded / new utilities
Environmental remediation cost
Relocation costs / training costs
Per Job Bounty
Cash Payments for Developer’s Costs
October 14, 2010
28
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
29. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
HELP BUSINESS continued
Provide for planning and land use incentives
Land use / zoning amendments (new zoning for old
land)
Create density bonus program
Mixed use land use designation
Prepare and complete streetscape projects
October 14, 2010
29
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
30. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
HELP BUSINESS continued
Provide for marketing incentives
Prepare market analysis for target industries /
business
Assist with local business promotion
Hold design competitions to generate interest
Work with local businesses and media
Assist with recruiting / job fairs
October 14, 2010
30
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
32. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
AUSTIN, TEXAS
The City of Austin began implementing sustainable
guidelines in the early 1990s through Austin Energy
Green Building (AEGB), the first comprehensive program
in the U.S. designed to encourage sustainable practices in
residential, commercial and municipal construction.
In 2000, Austin became one of the first cities to require
Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED®)
Silver certification for its new municipal buildings.
October 14, 2010
32
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
33. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
PORTLAND, OREGON
Commitments made for the following:
Reduce greenhouse gas emissions from City operations to 10%
below 1990 levels by 2015
Will recycle 85% of waste stream materials from City facilities by
2015
Ensure all white copy/printing paper used by the City will be 100%
post consumer recycled content by 2015
Will improve watershed health by managing 50% of stormwater
from City facilities using sustainable strategies
Use best management practices in reducing water usage in City
facilities and operations to 1997 levels
The Bureau of Planning and Sustainability will collect relevant
performance measures
October 14, 2010
33
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
34. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
SEATTLE, WASHINGTON
Mayor Greg Nickels has released the city’s 2006-2007
Environmental Action Agenda, which builds on Seattle’s
leadership in the fight against climate change and
outlines how the city will restore its urban forest, protect
water quality and build healthy communities.
The four pillars of the Action Agenda - the Climate Change
Initiative, the Restore Our Waters program, the Green
Seattle Initiative and Healthy People & Communities - link
the health of the urban ecosystems to the prosperity,
health and social equity of the city as a whole.
October 14, 2010
34
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
35. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
LET’S TAKE A LOOK AT SOME FLORIDA
PROJECTS THAT HAVE USED THESE
SUSTAINABLE TECHNIQUES IN
REDEVELOPMENT.
October 14, 2010
35
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
36. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
CHILDREN’S PLANNING INITIATIVE
As part of the CRA’s planning process, the
CRA staff organized a charrette for adults
in three communities; and concurrently,
the communities’ children were asked to
participate in their own planning workshop
to identify what they liked about their
neighborhood and what things they’d
like to change. This program was an
APA Florida award winner.
October 14, 2010
36
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
37. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
The City recently embarked on a project that
included a breakwater, a 92-slip marina, the
7,200 square foot Harbormaster Building
housing a restaurant and professional offices,
and a 21,000 square foot Class-A office
building known as the Ice House. The second
phase of the development, the construction of
two buildings totaling 72,000 square feet of
mixed-use space, was recently completed. The
mixed-use condominium is a model that offers
interesting possibilities to creative developers.
As a part of the public/private partnership, the
city invested $1.2 million along the pier to
construct a waterfront promenade, landscape
pedestrian plazas, and install new railing and
historically styled lighting.
October 14, 2010
37
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
WATERFRONT MIXED
USE
38. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
TECOLINE STREETCAR
Tampa’s wonderful downtown
streetcar system is in the midst of
expansion. The TecoLine system will
be expanded to go from the
Convention Center to Whiting Street.
Underground utilities are being
relocated and laying the track began
earlier this year. Station construction
and completion are scheduled for the
fourth quarter 2010.
October 14, 2010
38
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
39. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
WYLAND MURAL Wyland’s 10’ x 1,000’ mural is
adorned with mangroves,
inspired by the Everglades, in
addition to manatees, coral
reefs, dolphins, turtles,
mangroves and other sea life.
Over the next year, this wall will
be transformed into Wyland
Walk, a fully remodeled corridor
spanning the length of the
world-renown mural, featuring
park benches, lush landscaping
and a spiraling walkway
marveled with sea-toned colors
of recycled glass.
October 14, 2010
39
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
40. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
The City of Doral, located in
Miami-Dade County, hired Iler
Planning Group (IPG) to
develop the City’s first Green
Master Plan. The Green Plan
establishes strategies for
reducing the City’s
contribution to global
warming. The Plan was an
APA’s Florida award winner.
GREEN MASTER
PLAN
October 14, 2010
40
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
41. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
Recipients receive assistance
with rent for the first year for
a new or expanding business.
It will pay one-half or up to
$600 a month to the landlord
for qualifying businesses.
COMMERCIAL RENT SUBSIDY
October 14, 2010
41
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
42. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
Intended to increase homeowner
occupancy in the CRA in order to
provide economic support to the
downtown businesses
Designed to attract new residents to
targeted areas within the CRA
There is no income limitations
Persons currently residing /claiming
homestead exemption in the CRA
district are not eligible
Multifamily or Office Conversion to be
restored to single family: $20,000.00
Single family detached housing (zoned
RB-2, RPB or currently renter
occupied): $10,000.00
Single family detached infill housing:
$10,000.00
HOME OWNERSHIP
October 14, 2010
42
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com
43. 2010 Sustainable Florida
Conference
RESOURCES: FLORIDA INCENTIVES
TARGETED INDUSTRY INCENTIVES:
Qualified Target Industry Tax Refund (QTI)
Qualified Defense and Space Contractor Tax Refund (QDSC)
Capital Investment Tax Credit (CITC)
High Impact Performance Incentive Grant (HIPI)
WORKFORCE TRAINING INCENTIVES:
Quick Response Training Program (QRT)
Incumbent Worker Training Program (IWT)
INFRASTRUCTURE INCENTIVE:
Economic Development Transportation Fund
SPECIAL OPPORTUNITY INCENTIVES
Rural Incentives
Urban Incentives
Enterprise Zone Incentives
Brownfield Incentives
FLORIDA OPPORTUNITY FUND
October 14, 2010
43
Urban Visions, Inc.
http://theurbanvisions.com