SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 8
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011
                                                                          UK
                                                                                                         ‘Our Global Future’
                                                                                                             4th March 2011




The underlying soil may provide difficulties as the area in focus is by nature made situated on fluvial soils, which may
                      ay
not provide a reliable foundation for the design.
Defence against floating solid objects such as vehicles and trees in river flow must be considered. Mit
                                                                                                    Mitigation of these
hazards may be overcome through the planting of large trees to surround buildings.
Strength of bamboo is greatly affected by contact with water. Appropriate protection methods should be considered,
in accordance with cost effectiveness an availability.
                                      and


Bibliography
Associated Press. 2007. In Pictures: Floods devastating parts of Asia. CBBC Newsround. [Online] BBC, 5 August 2007.
[Cited: 15 December 2010.] http://news.bbc.co.uk/cbbcnews/hi/newsid_6920000/newsid_6923500/6
                             http://news.bbc.co.uk/cbbcnews/hi/newsid_6920000/newsid_6923500/6923552.stm.
Byrne, Steven. Early Concept Design. University of Strathclyde, Glasgow : s.n.
Gray, Louise and Reuters. 2009. UK to help Bangladesh tackle climate change . Telegraph. [Online] 13 July 2009.
[Cited: 15 December 2010.] http://www.telegraph.co.uk
                            http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/5819066/UK-to-help-Bangladesh
                                                                                   Bangladesh-tackle-climate-
change.html.
Rijcken, Ties. Floating Communities. EcoBoat. [Online] Holland & Co. [Cited: 10 December 2010.]
http://www.ecoboot.nl/artikelen/WeblogTiesFloatingCommunities.html.php.
Seraj, Salek M and Ahmed, K Iftekhar. 2004. Building Safer Houses in Rural Bangladesh. Dhaka : Bangladesh
                           ,
University of Engineering and Technology, 2004. ISBN 984
                                                     984-32-1280-5.
United Nations. 2009. World Population Prospects - The 2008 Revision. Department of Economic and Social Affairs
                                                                                                        Af
Population Division. [Online] 2009. [Cited: 10 December 2010.]
http://www.un.org/esa/population/publications/wpp2008/wpp2008_text_tables.pdf.




Understanding the informal settlement
Martin Thomson
University of Strathclyde


Preface
This paper is an edited extract from my 4th year architectural dissertation written on     informal settlement
development and it accompanies the A3 poster produced for this           conference. The dissertation was a theoretical
exploration of the challenges informal settlements face. It argued six principles as essential for sustainable
development of 'failing' informal settlements.


Keywords: Informal settlement development, holistic approach, sustainability, urban


The informal settlement is an incredibly complex phenomenon. They are responsive to cultural, social and economic
variations with differing political, religious and historical backgrounds. This paper takes a step back from these
                               ical,
complexities in an attempt to           understand fundamental principles which can lead to successful development of a
                                                                                                 cessful
spontaneous settlement. Six elements have been identified:
                         i)       perceived land tenure;
                         ii)      informal economics;
                         iii)     building deregulation;
                         iv)      social cohesion;
                         v)       appropriate governance and;
                         vi)      external support.
Each is detailed in the following pages. A strong argument is established, with examples and references reinforcing
                                     es.                                        examples
each.




Posters                                                                                                                156
EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011
                                                                           UK
                                                                                                          ‘Our Global Future’
                                                                                                              4th March 2011




The Six Principles
i) Perceived land tenure
Importance
  “The removal of tenure-insecurity related obsta
                          insecurity         obstacles that prevent or constrain households from using their housing
         effectively as a productive asset is possibly the single most critical poverty reduction intervention”
                            oductive                                                              intervention
                                                                                                        (Moser, 1996, 5.)
Protection from eviction is seen as one of the key el
                                                   elements to alleviate those from poverty (UN Habitat, 2003, 168).
                                                                                                               168)


Definition
Perceived security of tenure, as referred to here, is protection from eviction at a level where its affect encourages the
     ived
squatter invest money, time and effort in their dwelling.


Argument
When protection from eviction is realised, squatter houses will naturally be built to a better condition, with more
                                                                naturally
permanent materials, over a longer period of time. A sense of permanence must be felt by the squatter to incite
building upon their situation, otherwise sub standard conditions will remain. The influence of secure tenure goes
                                         sub-standard                                           secu
beyond physical improvements; permanent neighbourhoods naturally encourage stronger social connections between
neighbours and communities begin to flourish (UN Habitat, 2003, 150). With strong community ties, social security
emerges empowering the squatters further. Also a community allows collective decisions to be made on improvements
                   ng
to the settlement as a whole, like pavements or sanitation.


ii) Informal Economics
Importance
“...the economic activity and employment in the urban informal sector are extremely important in developing countries
 where population and demand for jobs, goods and services are typically growing more quickly than national averages
                                     and...for formal job creation to cope with.”
                                                                                                   (de Soto, 2000, 102)


Definition
The informal economy provides variously paid labour w
      formal                                           where individuals contribute to local communities by offering
affordable goods and employment within a social framework of trust and reciprocity, devised and implemented out of
necessity by the people (Yeung and Old, 2000) UN habitat defines the informal sector as “the generally small-scale
                                    d       2000).
industries and commercial activities that are not registered enterprises but provide large amounts of products and
services that people use each day.” (2003, 100).


Argument
The informal economy, when exercised freely, is a powerful tool for the poor of the world’s developing cities. It
 he
provides much needed work that fends off destitution, offers new economic opportunity, introduces social stability and
a better quality of life (Mingione, 1996 cited in Daniels, 2004, 3). Through its tax free and localised     operations,
the informal sector can offer affordable goods to the urban poor in addition to providing them with employment,
compensating for the often saturated and inaccessible formal sector (UN Habitat, 2003, 102).
 ompensating
Formal labour costs are kept lower by the cheaper goods and services available to their staff from this unregistered
market. The formal market can also exploit directly the lower cost of raw materials and input the extralegal sector
                                                                                        inputs
offers (UN Habitat,2003,102).
However, perhaps the most essential argument for the presence of the extralegal sector is the impenetrable nature of
the legal sector for those who are poor. This was evident during the Asian monetary crisis in 1998 where the informal
                                                                                                             in
sector ballooned as the formal sector took a huge hit.
It should be remembered that:
     “It is with such humble beginnings that many of today’s great corporations and industries have their origins.”
                                                                                                (UN Habitat, 2003, 53).




Posters                                                                                                                 157
EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011
                                                                          UK                               Confere
                                                                                                         ‘Our Global Future’
                                                                                                             4th March 2011




iii) Building Deregulation
Importance
When a poor person has control of when and to what extent to build their home, they effectively have more control
over their poverty - they build when they can afford and when best suits their situation; they bui what they need and
                                                                                               build
to what degree.


Definition
Building deregulation, as referred to here, is when a squatter has the freedom to build    and modify their dwelling,
free from restrictive and prescripted building regulations.


Argument
The squatter comes to the city and often enters tenuous employment. Their situation is rarely static as they adjust to
                   s
their new urban life and what disposable income theyhave is largely dependent on dwelling arrangements. Having the
freedom to build grants the new urban dweller social mobility, as they can erect a structure appropriate to their
                                      n
aspirations and circumstance.
Self-built houses free from regulation also tackle poverty in another way. If migrants can exercise a level of freedom
      built
upon arrival to the city, they equip themselves with self-belief otherwise crushed if authorities intervene heavily.
                           hey                             belief
Armed with determination to challenge their surrounding poverty, they inin-turn challenge the social boundaries which
would otherwise cut them off from the rest of the city. Allowed to exercise personal and local resources of imagination,
initiative, commitment, responsibility, skill and muscle power the urban poor realise the potential they hold (Turner,
1976, 50).


iv) Social Cohesion
Importance
       “Social cohesion is critical for societies to prosper economically and for development to   be sustainable.”
                                                                                                   (UN Habitat,2003,71)
A community provides a crucial social support network which low income classes often need to fall back on and rely on
to go forward. Social cohesion can lead to community driven development, which is essential for solving the problems
                            on
unique to any one settlement.


Definition
Social cohesion, as discussed in this paper, refers to the creation of a community, that is, a group of people who reside
in the same geographical area and share a certain quality of relationship, providing a network of social support
(Pacione, 2001, 355).


Argument
The low income classes of the developing world have no formal channels of support and social security must be sought
                                                                                                              so
elsewhere. The most crucial source is from their immediate community. A network of friends and family can mean the
difference between a roof to sleep under or homelessness.
          “No-one will ever go hungry because there will always be an open door and a gesture of solidarity”
              one
                         Gabriela Torres Barbosa, squatter resident, Rio de Janeiro (New Internationalist, 2006, 4).
Social cohesion is an essential prerequisite for a community. However, the influence of a community goes beyond
sustenance and support to the individual. Collective agreement and funding within a community can be used to
implement services and facilities when the local authorities are unable to. When external bodies can implement
services, a community voice may be essential if the area is t receive the most appropriate service for its particular
                                                             to
needs.




Posters                                                                                                                 158
EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011
                                                                              UK                               Confere
                                                                                                             ‘Our Global Future’
                                                                                                                 4th March 2011




The community however must not become the only reliable source of support for inhabitants. Developing cities are
ethnically diverse, and successful actors participate as many different identities – one for his neighbourhood, one for
                          ccessful                                                                              o
cross-city business, one for acquiring resources – engaging freely, gathering resources quickly and efficiently by
maximising the opportunities of the city (UN Habitat: 2003:47)
                                                         2003:47).


v) Appropriate Governance
Importance
Community driven development - development in which the community are in control of the main decisions - is the most
appropriate mechanism for informal settlement development (Abbott, 2002a, 6).


Definition
Appropriate governance, as discussed her refers to relevant stakeholders in decision making having proportionate
                                        here,
influence at different stages of settlement development. The community must control decisions, to an appropriate degree,
when decisions affect the local community. Equally, authorit
                                                    authorities must control decisions, to an appropriate degree, when
                                                                          ol
decisions begin to affect the wider city.


Argument
The centralised system, when governing the poor, fails because its scale and limitation of management deny the variety
and flexibility required for the unique and delicate communities found within informal settlements (Turner, 1976, 7).
When people govern themselves, a custom fit system of correct scale is applied. Human priorities cannot be adequately
accounted for by housing policy, but the sens
                                           sensitivity of self- governance can, therefore providing more appropriate
responses to squatter settlement development (UN Habitat, 2003, xxvii).
Settlement integration and full community responsibility are incompatible (Abbott, 2002a, 11). For a settlement to
evolve from a small isolated colony into an integrated district, self governance must relinquish power to local authorities
                                                                 self-governance
accordingly. If local authorities are to act responsibly and react dynamically to informal settlements they must understand
                                                                   dynamically
when this is to occur and to what degree.
       his


vi) External support
Importance
“...there are limits to what low-income groups can achieve for themselves, either individually or collectively, without some
                                 income
                            form of technical support and other resources from external agents.”
                                                                                                              (Lee, 1998, 2)
Definition
External support, as referred to here, is support provided from out with the squatter      settlement necessary to
compensate what the settlement cannot facilitate.


Argument
The development of a settlement is limited to the capacity of those driving it; external support is needed to compensate
                                               the
areas the community cannot fulfil. The intermediary body which provides external support is typically an NGO, facilitating,
stimulating or supporting individual or community based org
                                                         organisations (Lee, 1998, 2). Community organisation will not
always spontaneously arise, particularly in heterogeneous settlements where social cohesion is weak. Successful
community based development is often facilitated externally, where access to land, infrastructure and services
                                                                                       infrastructure
necessary for environmental improvement are made available. If internal limitations are overcome, a settlement can
develop to a far greater degree.
Similarly, like the previous arguments, there is also a d
                                                        degree of balance required. For development to be sustainable, a
community cannot become dependent on outside agencies (Lee, 1998, 16).


Case Studies
Sultanbeyli, Istanbul (Neuwirth, 2005, 143
                                       143-173)
Sultanbeyli is a suburb in the east of Istanbul. It grew rapidly in the mid 1980s and between 1986 and 1989 an estimated
20,000 houses were erected. Today its fifteen neighbourhoods host 300,000 residents of which 48,000 are university
students. Banks, post offices, department stores and travel agents line its high streets. It is descr
                                                                                                described as a desirable place
however it is a squatter community: the vast majority of its 30,000 structures are not legally registered.
With good living conditions, substantial development and integration with the formal city, it is a ‘successful’ informal
settlement. Architecturally it is indistinguishable fromlegal neighbourhoods and even receives better services than some
 ettlement.
Posters                                                                                                                    159
EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011
                                                                              UK                               Confere
                                                                                                             ‘Our Global Future’
                                                                                                                 4th March 2011




formal areas. How it has reached striking equality with the formal city can be understood under the six preconditioning
elements for squatter settlement development.
               uatter
Perceived security of tenure: Present. In Turkey every citizen has the right to vote. This makes squatter clearances
politically intangible, preventing the authorities from reining in. With 42.6 percent of Turkey’s urban population living in
                                                                                                        pop
squatter settlements, their staying power will undoubtedly remain (Davis, 2006, 24).
Informal economics: Present. Informal businesses operate freely in Sultanbeyli. Sultanbeyli is a squatter settlement
because the vast majority of its buildings hold no official titles, including its businesses. They provide cheaper goods and
                                    ldings
services to the residents allowing them to prosper on lower wages.
Building deregulation: Present. The residents of Sultanbeyli have built and continue to build their own neighbourhoods.
Self-built dwellings range from single-story poured concrete boxes to spacious apartment houses with large balconies and
                                       story
complete           modern services. Freedom to build their own dwellings on vacant land with little opposition from the
government has created a thriving settlement.
     rnment
Social cohesion: Present. Zamanhan Ablak, as described by Neuwirth, and his neighbours pooled money, each house
contributing to the payment of sewers, schools and a local mosque. This shows clear signs of communit and social
                                                                                             community
cohesion as well as self-governance.
Appropriate governance: Present. Exercising self governance, the community was able to make the most appropriate
                                                 self-governance,
decisions to the upgrading of their settlement. Turkish law allows communities over 2,000 residents to form quasi-
                                                                                          residents          quasi
independent       municipalities, granting continued decision making to the community and, crucially, introducing the city
                                                                     to
government’s influence.
External Support: Present. Zamanhan and his neighbours could not facilitate piped water into their homes. Instead this
was provided externally by the municipal government. For the first two years, squatters fetched water by hand but
afterwards the government supplied barrelled water and eventually installed piped water.
The squatter settlement of Sultanbeyli is a well serviced suburb and displays numerous signs of integration. Poverty
appears to be minimal and its people enjoy opportunities usually only attainable by formal city inhabitants. All six
elements are present and have created substantial settlement development, good living conditions and integration with
                                        substantial
the wider city.


Kampung Penas Tanggul, Jakarta (Winayanti 2004, 8
                                                8-24)
Located in the east of Jakarta, the squatter settlement of Kampung Penas Tanggul is home to 388 people (August 2000
                                                                                                                 2000).
Established in 1970 by rural migrants from various locations in Java, the settlement has slowly developed from a
collection of bamboo and wood shacks into a community of brick houses with concrete interlinking pathways. Access to
water and toilets may be shared facilities but show substantial upgrading.
                        e
Perceived security of tenure: Present. From 1997 onwards, there have been no evictions and confidence to stay has
emerged. Confidence to build, however, did not         arise until 2000 when the squatters were issued a Rukun etangga
(recognition as an official neighbourhood) from the authorities. This granted them a formal address, but not ownership of
land. The formalized address however saw residents gradually invest in their situation, building with more permanent
materials and with greater foresight. It      should also be mentioned that the security of tenure also brought an
increased level of external support from an NGO.
Informal Economics: Present. The 21 residents interviewed relied purely on informal employ
                                                                                       employment for income. These
ranged from street vendors to construction workers, scavengers to taxi drivers. Without access to this informal
employment it is highly unlikely the rural migrants would be skilled or educated enough to find formal work (the majorit
                                                                                                                 majority
had just elementary school education).
Building deregulation: Present. The squatters of Penas Tanggul have freedom to build and improve their dwellings. 20
of the 83 structures were upgraded after secure tenure was first perceived. A number of the bamb
                                                                                            bamboo and wood structures
had an upper floor added or the lower structure was replaced with brick.
Social cohesion: Present. Despite the diverse origins of Penas Tanggul’s residents, coming from numerous regions of
Java and Sulawesi (both islands of Indonesia signs of social cohesion were present from the beginning. The settlement
                                    Indonesia),
land was first     divided up under the coordination of a respected group leader. This led to the layout of common
facilities and mutual cooperation to improve and maintain their env
                                                                 environment.
Appropriate governance: Absent. Community driven development oversaw the addition of communal toilets, footpath
paving and a waste disposal program. Governance of Penas Tanggul is a completely internal affair. There is no dialogue
between Penas Tanggul (or indeed any Jakarta informal settlement) and the government, despite their recognition as a
               anggul
neighbourhood of Jakarta. In the long term this will leave the settlement isolated from the city of Jakarta.
External support: Present. A high level of external support is present in the development of Penas Tanggul, and has
                                            external
been since 1986. Over this long period of time, the two NGOs have facilitated free medication, free school lessons for
children and subsidized education and hospital treatment. Crucially, they educated squatters on their human rights and
                                                           Crucially,
mobilized a protest to save the settlement from eviction. The NGOs also taught the people on environmental issues to
improve the water quality of the river and the environment of their settlement.
The residents of Penas Tanggul have experienced great improvements in the quality of their lives both environmentally
     esidents
and health-wise. The settlement itself has developed from temporary bamboo and wooden shacks to permanent brick
            wise.                                                                                    p
dwellings. These improvements are reflected in the fact five of the six elements are present. The level of development,

Posters                                                                                                                    160
EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011
                                                                               UK                               Confere
                                                                                                              ‘Our Global Future’
                                                                                                                  4th March 2011




however, is limited because the settlement has no dialogue with local authorities, leaving it isolated and still significantl
                                                                                                                 significantly
vulnerable.


Kibera, Nairobi (Kramer, 2006, 83 -95 & Neuwirth, 2005, 67
                                   95                   67-100)
Kibera is home to an estimated 600,000 squatters and sits side by side with the formal city but with stark inequalities in
living conditions. Squeezed into just 1.2km squared, the only spaces within the settlement not occupied by mud huts are
large piles of rubbish and sewage. Waterways are effectively open sewers, safe running water is absent and electricity is
a privilege. Dirt lanes are only a few feet wide and life is very tough.
Kibera is materially poor, under-developed and separated from the rest of the city. Opportunities are low and crime is
                                 developed
high. The six prerequisite elements for informal settlement developed will be used to help understand why Kibera exists in
such dire conditions.
Perceived security of tenure: Absent. The squatters of Kibera are tenants on unregistered land. Rich land lords acquire
the land illegitimately from authorities and politicians who in turn refuse to recognise Kibera as a permanent settlement.
The mud huts are rented out on an understood temporary basis and thus tenure security is absent.
                                          rstood
Informal Economics: Present. Hawkers sell foodstuffs like maize and kale and many women sell spooled cloth and used
clothes. There are unregistered barbers, even a blacksmith and households with televisions open their doors to assume
                                                                               televisions
business as small cinemas. The informal economy is therefore practised widely and freely in Kibera.
Building deregulation: Absent. Local landlords acquire the title less mud huts of Kibera from local politicians who in
                                                               title-less
turn deny any modification to them by their tenants. A government official explains that if a hut is modified by a resident,
the hut will be demolished. He attempts to justify this by saying the huts are only temporary, even though they have
been present for decades. Such tight control over squatter housing denies many opportunities and good living conditions
to the poor squatters.
Social cohesion: Absent. The settlement is strongly divided into ten distinct neighbourhoods defined along ethnic lines.
In December 2001 riots broke out which destroyed homes and saw twelve killed. The high crime rates reflect the lack of
     cember
cross-community relationships within the settlement.
      community


Appropriate governance: Absent. Self-governance is built on community togetherness and control over decision
                                        -governance                                        c
making, both which are absent in Kibera. The top down unilateral decision making by the government on issues in Kibera
                                             top-down
has done nothing to improve conditions.
External Support: Absent. The Nairobi authorities sadly refuse to provide a    any services or include Kibera in any city
plans due to the settlement’s illegal status. There is no city wide policy on tackling the squatter problem in Nairobi,
                                                          city-wide
discouraging any long term action to be taken. NGO based support is present, but with the she size of Kibera and the
                                                                                               sheer
multitude of problems it hosts, the support is insignificant to the whole.
Poverty in Kibera is severe and visible everywhere. By analysing the settlement using the six elements, it is clear as to
why it fails to develop. One element may be present, the informal economy, but on its own it cannot facilitate
                                 ent
development.


Conclusions
This paper does not seek to answer the complex problems squatter settlements pose but attempts to offer a framework
where the main barriers to development are brought down. Initially the six point framework pulls the settlement free from
                                       nt
the most restrictive constraints. Perceived security of tenure brings permanence; informal economics brings greater
economic equality; deregulated building processes enables dwellings to be appropriate to dweller salary and situation;
                                                     enables
social cohesion brings improved social security; appropriate governance allows the most correct decisions involving the
settlement and the city to be made; and external support provides essential help to otherwise unattainable goals.
                                                                     essential
It was then stressed that, the guidelines must evolve and change with the development of the settlement to overlook
integration between the settlement and city. The informal sector must begin to feed into and off of the formal sector for
economic and city integration to occur. The deregulated building principles must gradually succumb to building standards,
                                                                  principles
just as the once informal cities of the most developed countries have. Social cohesion, ideally, will be at such a level as
not to segregate and fragment neighbourhoods from the city but to provide the security which comes with it.
Appropriate government is a fluid understanding: governance of human habitation should never be static and local and
central governing bodies must always remain in dialogue, powers adjusting for the most appropriate decisions to be
             ning                                                                                  d
made. External support must understand that for development to be sustainable, its role must be temporary and
supportive, not permanent and controlling.
The three case studies explored these guidelines. Sultanbeyli, the settlement described as largely developed, displayed
all six elements. Kampung Penas Tanggul, a settlement which has developed impressively under improved conditions but
with limited integration with the wider city, displayed five of the six elements. Appropriate governance was absent, central
                  ration
government having no input and integration difficult to foresee. The failing settlement Kibera confirmed the importance of
the elements, as all but one were absent.
                          ne
Defining and arguing each element showed that none is constrained to itself. Each has influence on another, if not every,
element. This reflects the need for a multi disciplinary approach to development to address the complex nature of human
                                      multi-disciplinary                                                           hum

Posters                                                                                                                     161
EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011
                                                                             UK                               Confere
                                                                                                            ‘Our Global Future’
                                                                                                                4th March 2011




settlement. It is a warning against narrow focused approaches, whether heavily top down intervention or purely grass-
                                                                                top-down                          grass
roots. The current climate of neo-liberal self help, having conquered over many interventional approaches, is in fear of
                                  liberal self-help,
pulling the balance too far towards the community and fragmenting cities.
The sheer scale and global occurrence of squatter settlements demands that there be real understanding of why and how
these areas develop or stagnate. Without this understanding the developing countries will stay developing.
                                                                           countries


Acknowledgements
I am very grateful for the assistance throughout the original dissertation from Dr Ombretta Romice of Strathclyde
University Architecture Department. The essay was able to build on a strong structure and clear direction and I thank
                                                                                           clearer
Ombretta for this.


Bibliography
Abbott (1996) John Abbott. Sharing the city: co
                                             community participation in urban management. London: Earthscan
                                                                                        .
Abbott (2002a) John Abbott. An analysis of infinformal settlement upgrading and critique of existing methodological
                                                                                             xisting
approaches. Habitat International Vol 26, Issue 3,
          .                                          September 2002, pp 303-315
Amis and Kumar (2000) Amis, P and S Kumar Urban economic growth, infrastructure and poverty in India: Lessons
from Visakhapatnam. Environment and Urbaniz
                  .                 Urbanization 12:(1):185-196
Amnesty International (2006) Amnesty International: Zimbabwe: quantifying destruction: satellite images of forced
evictions 8 September 2006
Appadurai (2001) Appadurai, A Deep democracy: Urban governmentality and the horizon of politics Environment and
                                                                                       politi
Urbanization 2001 13 (2):23-43
BPPD and BPS DKI Jakarta (1997) Evalus
                                Evalusasi Rukun Warga (RW) Kumuh DKI Jakarta. Penerbit BPS Kantor Statistik
                                                                            .
Propinsi DKI Jakrata.
Bromley (2009) Daniel W. Bromley. Formalising proper relations in the developing world: The wrong prescription for
                                              property
the wrong malady . Land Use Policy Journal.
Buyamin, A., & Kartini (1998). Forced evictions in Jakarta. In K. Fernandes (Ed.), Forced evictions and housing right
abuses in Asia, 2nd Report 1996-97. Karachi:
                                97.                Eviction Watch Asia, City Press.
Charmes (2000) J. Charmes Informal sector, p     poverty and gender: A review of empirical evidence. Background
paper for World Development Report 2001 Centre of Economics and Ethics for Environmental and Development,
                                      2001.
University of Versailles-St Quentin en Yveliness
                         St
Daniels (2004) P.W. Daniels Urban Challenges: the fo
                                                  formal and informal economies of mega-cities Cities, Vol 21, No. 6,
                                                                                        cities
p501-511, 2004
Davis(2006) Mike Davis, Planet of Slums 2006 Verso Publishers, London.
                                  Slums.
de Soto (2000) Hernando de Soto. The Mystery of Capital: Why capitalism triumphs in the West and fails everywhere
else. 2000. Basic books: New York
Erman (1997) Erman T.Squatter (gecekondu) Housing versus Apartment Housing: Turkish Rural-to-Urban Migrant
                                                                                    Rural
Residents’ Perspectives. Habitat Intl. Vol. 28, No 1, pp.91-106, 1997.
Grimond (2007) Audio interview – a discussion with J
                                                   Johnny Grimond, writer-at-large for The Economist. The Economist,
May 2007
Habitat, (2005) UN Habitat. State of the World’s Cities 2004/2005. Earthscan Publishers UK & USA .
Huchzerymer (1999). Huchzermeyer, M. The exploration of appropriate informal settlement interventions in South
Africa: Contributions from a comparison with Brazil. Ph.D. Thesis, South Africa: University of Cape Town, unpublished.
Jeffres, & Dobos (1995) L.W. Jeffres and J. Dobos, Separating people’s satisfaction       with life and public perceptions
of the quality of life in the environment. Social Indicators Research 34 (1995), pp. 181–211
Kingdon and Knight (2004) Geeta Gandhi Kingdo and John Knight Unemployment
                                           Kingdon                               in South Africa: The Nature of
the Beast World Development Vol. 32, No. 3, pp391
                        ent                 pp391-408, 2004.Kramer (2006) Kramer, Mark. Dispossessed: Life in our
World’s Urban Slums. 2006. Orbis Books, New York.
Lloyd (1979) Lloyd, Peter. Slums of Hope.
                             ums    Hope.1979. Manchester University Press
Lizarralde,(2008) Gonzalo Lizzaralde. Unexpected negative outcomes of community participation Habitat International
32 , 2008
Main and Williams (1994) Hamish Main and Stephen Wyn Williams Environment and housing in third world cities John
                                                                                  ing
Wiley and sons, Chichester
Mashhour (1999) Mostafa Ali Salem Mashhour Resident’s sense of comtrol, self-esteem and sense of community in
                                                                             esteem
aided self-help housing in Egypt Strathclyde University Thesis, unpublished.

Posters                                                                                                                   162
EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011
                                                                              UK                               Confere
                                                                                                             ‘Our Global Future’
                                                                                                                 4th March 2011




Mingione (1996) E. Mingione Urban poverty and the underclass: A reader Blackwell Oxford and Cambridge, MA
                                                                       Blackwell,
Moser (1996) C. Moser Confronting Crisis: A summ
                                            summary of households responses to poverty and vulnerability in four poor
urban communities Environmentally Sustain
                                  Sustainable Development Studies and Monographs Series, No. 7. 1996. World Bank,
Washington      DC.
New Internationalist (2006) NI 386 Squatter Town: The South’s Urban Explosion January/February 2006
Neuwirth (2005) Neuwirth, Robert. Shadow Cities: A Billion Squatters, a New Urban World. 2005. London: Routledge
Nijman (2008) Jan Nijman Against the odds: Slum rehabilitation in neoliberal Mumbai Cities 25 (2008) 73 – 85
                                                                             Mumbai.
Pacione (2001) Michael Pacione Urban Geography: a global perspective Routledge Publishers, New York
                                                                                               Yor
Sengupta & Sharma (2009) Urmi Sengupta & Sujeet Sharma. No longer SukumasissL Challeneges in grassroots-led
                                                                                                      grassroots
squatter resettlement program Kathmandu with Sepcial reference to Kirtipur Housing Project. Habitat International 33
                  ent                                                                     . Habit
(2009) 33- 44
Shapiro (1985) Shapiro, A L Housing the Poor in Paris, 1850 – 1902. 1985. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison.
Sivam (2002) Constraints affecting the efficiency of the urban residential land market in developing countries: a case
study of India. Habitat International 26, 523
                                          523-537.
Turner (1976) Turner, John. Housing by People Towards Autonomy in Building Environments. 1976. Great Britain:
                                       People:                             Environments
Marion Boyars Publishers Ltd
UN Habitat (2003) UN Habitat The Challenge of Slums: Global report on human settlements 2003. Earthscan Publishers
                                                                                        2003
London.
Varela -Michel (1997) M. Varela Michel Cultural Adaption and Rural Migrant Hosuing (Mexico). McGill University,
Montreal
Westaway (2006) Margaret S.Westaway. A Longitudinal Investigation of Satisfaction with Personal and Environmental
                                                                                                           Environmenta
quality of life in an informal South African housing settlement, Doornkop, Soweto. Habitat International. Vol 30, Issue 1,
                                                                                 .                            3
March 2006, pp175-198
Winayanit & Lang (2004) Lana Winayanti & Heracles C. Lang Provision of urban services in an informal settlement: a
                                                                                                     settlem
case study of Kampung Penas Tanggul, Jakarta. Habitat International 28 (2004) 41 – 65
Wirth (1938) L. Wirth Urbanism as a way of life American , Journal of Sociology 44, 1 – 24
Yeung and Old (2000) H. W. Yeung and K. Old Globalization of Chinese Business Firms MacMillan, London. 2000.
Zebardast (2006) Esfandiar Zebardast Marginalization of the urban poor and the expansion of the spontaneous
settlements on the Tehran metropolitan fringe. Cities, Vol. 23, No. 6, p439-454, 2006.




Design of a wooden framed bicycle
Joshua Lewis
Cardiff University


Project Brief
Here in the UK, there are many options available to us when it comes to transport, but in many of the sub   sub-Saharan
countries of Africa, personal mobility is a problematic issue that is faced daily. The public transport services available in
                                                                            daily.
these regions are often overcrowded, dangerous and unaffordable. The bicycle is the cheapest form of personal
transportation available, and while bicycles are available in these regions, they are still prohibitively expensive and most
                                                                                            prohibitively
locals cannot afford them. Therefore, these nations are heavily reliant on bicycles donated from the developed world.
However, when these bicycles brake down there is a dearth of adequate spare parts available, as manufacturers often no
longer support the older models.
What is required is a bicycle that can be made cheaply out of local materials, does not require special tools or skills, and
that can make use of a wide range of spare parts. Due to these requirements it is not possible for the bicycle frame to be
                                                                                           possible
made from traditional materials such as steel or aluminium, and so wood must be considered instead. Such a bicycle
must be an improvement on the bikes currently available in the area, and the needs of the locals must be a     accounted for
during its design. If such a bicycle could be designed and tested, plans produced, and assembly instructions developed;
then there is the potential to greatly improve the lives of millions of people, whilst also benefiting the economies of the
regions affected. Such improvements would free people from poverty and bring greater opportunities to the people of
Africa.




Posters                                                                                                                    163

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Andere mochten auch (13)

Urbz home grownhouse
Urbz home grownhouseUrbz home grownhouse
Urbz home grownhouse
 
The informal settler families
The informal settler familiesThe informal settler families
The informal settler families
 
Slum is Urban Problem, How to Solve it?
Slum is Urban Problem, How to Solve it?Slum is Urban Problem, How to Solve it?
Slum is Urban Problem, How to Solve it?
 
03 studying an informal settlement
03 studying an informal settlement03 studying an informal settlement
03 studying an informal settlement
 
Design for homeless
Design for homelessDesign for homeless
Design for homeless
 
01 housing in delhi
01 housing in delhi01 housing in delhi
01 housing in delhi
 
Baoli at Red Fort
Baoli at Red FortBaoli at Red Fort
Baoli at Red Fort
 
04 development and informal settlement
04 development and informal settlement04 development and informal settlement
04 development and informal settlement
 
02 introduction to informal settlements
02 introduction to informal settlements02 introduction to informal settlements
02 introduction to informal settlements
 
Slums In India
Slums In IndiaSlums In India
Slums In India
 
Slums In India
Slums In IndiaSlums In India
Slums In India
 
Slum rehabilitation authority
Slum rehabilitation authoritySlum rehabilitation authority
Slum rehabilitation authority
 
A Slum Redevelopment Project
A Slum Redevelopment ProjectA Slum Redevelopment Project
A Slum Redevelopment Project
 

Ähnlich wie Martin thomson understanding the informal settlement

Weekly SustainableDevt.pptx
Weekly SustainableDevt.pptxWeekly SustainableDevt.pptx
Weekly SustainableDevt.pptxNathanMoyo1
 
my project
my projectmy project
my projectmemman
 
Incremental Housing.pdf
Incremental Housing.pdfIncremental Housing.pdf
Incremental Housing.pdfViataViriezky
 
A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR SUSTAINABLE AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR THE RURAL POO...
A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR SUSTAINABLE   AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR THE RURAL POO...A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR SUSTAINABLE   AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR THE RURAL POO...
A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR SUSTAINABLE AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR THE RURAL POO...Tony Lisko
 
IMPLEMENTATION OF VALUE MANAGEMENT AS AN ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY TOOL FOR BUI...
IMPLEMENTATION OF VALUE MANAGEMENT AS AN ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY TOOL FOR BUI...IMPLEMENTATION OF VALUE MANAGEMENT AS AN ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY TOOL FOR BUI...
IMPLEMENTATION OF VALUE MANAGEMENT AS AN ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY TOOL FOR BUI...ijmvsc
 
Impact of Housing Finance Market on Growth of East African Economies: Evidenc...
Impact of Housing Finance Market on Growth of East African Economies: Evidenc...Impact of Housing Finance Market on Growth of East African Economies: Evidenc...
Impact of Housing Finance Market on Growth of East African Economies: Evidenc...inventionjournals
 
A strategic framework for sustainable construction in jordan
A strategic framework for sustainable construction in jordanA strategic framework for sustainable construction in jordan
A strategic framework for sustainable construction in jordanAlexander Decker
 
Essay On Water Sector
Essay On Water SectorEssay On Water Sector
Essay On Water SectorSheri Elliott
 
12/2010 Realising the "Imagined armies of expert civilians": A summary of nat...
12/2010 Realising the "Imagined armies of expert civilians": A summary of nat...12/2010 Realising the "Imagined armies of expert civilians": A summary of nat...
12/2010 Realising the "Imagined armies of expert civilians": A summary of nat...Australian Civil-Military Centre
 
Infrastructural development financil
Infrastructural development financil Infrastructural development financil
Infrastructural development financil Ayub Ali
 
Knowledge Generation, Use and Management in Sustainable Infrastructure Engine...
Knowledge Generation, Use and Management in Sustainable Infrastructure Engine...Knowledge Generation, Use and Management in Sustainable Infrastructure Engine...
Knowledge Generation, Use and Management in Sustainable Infrastructure Engine...William Hall
 
Fundamental of Sustainable Construction.ppt
Fundamental of Sustainable Construction.pptFundamental of Sustainable Construction.ppt
Fundamental of Sustainable Construction.pptTantish QS, UTM
 
20150707 나는pm이다 박성호 교수님 발표자료
20150707 나는pm이다 박성호 교수님 발표자료20150707 나는pm이다 박성호 교수님 발표자료
20150707 나는pm이다 박성호 교수님 발표자료Dong-Hwan Han, Ph.D.
 
Community Wellbeing in Cities through the Sustainable Affordable Housing.
 Community Wellbeing in Cities through the Sustainable Affordable Housing. Community Wellbeing in Cities through the Sustainable Affordable Housing.
Community Wellbeing in Cities through the Sustainable Affordable Housing.NOR SUZYLAH SOHAIMI
 
In pursuit of Sustainable Growth
In pursuit of Sustainable Growth In pursuit of Sustainable Growth
In pursuit of Sustainable Growth Breno Nunes
 
20 years of bottom-up, participative governance in rural areas: lessons learn...
20 years of bottom-up, participative governance in rural areas: lessons learn...20 years of bottom-up, participative governance in rural areas: lessons learn...
20 years of bottom-up, participative governance in rural areas: lessons learn...Universitat de València
 

Ähnlich wie Martin thomson understanding the informal settlement (20)

Weekly SustainableDevt.pptx
Weekly SustainableDevt.pptxWeekly SustainableDevt.pptx
Weekly SustainableDevt.pptx
 
datastream
datastreamdatastream
datastream
 
my project
my projectmy project
my project
 
Incremental Housing.pdf
Incremental Housing.pdfIncremental Housing.pdf
Incremental Housing.pdf
 
A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR SUSTAINABLE AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR THE RURAL POO...
A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR SUSTAINABLE   AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR THE RURAL POO...A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR SUSTAINABLE   AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR THE RURAL POO...
A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR SUSTAINABLE AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR THE RURAL POO...
 
IMPLEMENTATION OF VALUE MANAGEMENT AS AN ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY TOOL FOR BUI...
IMPLEMENTATION OF VALUE MANAGEMENT AS AN ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY TOOL FOR BUI...IMPLEMENTATION OF VALUE MANAGEMENT AS AN ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY TOOL FOR BUI...
IMPLEMENTATION OF VALUE MANAGEMENT AS AN ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY TOOL FOR BUI...
 
24
2424
24
 
Impact of Housing Finance Market on Growth of East African Economies: Evidenc...
Impact of Housing Finance Market on Growth of East African Economies: Evidenc...Impact of Housing Finance Market on Growth of East African Economies: Evidenc...
Impact of Housing Finance Market on Growth of East African Economies: Evidenc...
 
A strategic framework for sustainable construction in jordan
A strategic framework for sustainable construction in jordanA strategic framework for sustainable construction in jordan
A strategic framework for sustainable construction in jordan
 
Essay On Water Sector
Essay On Water SectorEssay On Water Sector
Essay On Water Sector
 
12/2010 Realising the "Imagined armies of expert civilians": A summary of nat...
12/2010 Realising the "Imagined armies of expert civilians": A summary of nat...12/2010 Realising the "Imagined armies of expert civilians": A summary of nat...
12/2010 Realising the "Imagined armies of expert civilians": A summary of nat...
 
Infrastructural development financil
Infrastructural development financil Infrastructural development financil
Infrastructural development financil
 
Knowledge Generation, Use and Management in Sustainable Infrastructure Engine...
Knowledge Generation, Use and Management in Sustainable Infrastructure Engine...Knowledge Generation, Use and Management in Sustainable Infrastructure Engine...
Knowledge Generation, Use and Management in Sustainable Infrastructure Engine...
 
106
106106
106
 
Fundamental of Sustainable Construction.ppt
Fundamental of Sustainable Construction.pptFundamental of Sustainable Construction.ppt
Fundamental of Sustainable Construction.ppt
 
20150707 나는pm이다 박성호 교수님 발표자료
20150707 나는pm이다 박성호 교수님 발표자료20150707 나는pm이다 박성호 교수님 발표자료
20150707 나는pm이다 박성호 교수님 발표자료
 
Community Wellbeing in Cities through the Sustainable Affordable Housing.
 Community Wellbeing in Cities through the Sustainable Affordable Housing. Community Wellbeing in Cities through the Sustainable Affordable Housing.
Community Wellbeing in Cities through the Sustainable Affordable Housing.
 
In pursuit of Sustainable Growth
In pursuit of Sustainable Growth In pursuit of Sustainable Growth
In pursuit of Sustainable Growth
 
UTSpeaks: Our Fragile Cities (Part 1: Keith Crews)
UTSpeaks: Our Fragile Cities (Part 1: Keith Crews)UTSpeaks: Our Fragile Cities (Part 1: Keith Crews)
UTSpeaks: Our Fragile Cities (Part 1: Keith Crews)
 
20 years of bottom-up, participative governance in rural areas: lessons learn...
20 years of bottom-up, participative governance in rural areas: lessons learn...20 years of bottom-up, participative governance in rural areas: lessons learn...
20 years of bottom-up, participative governance in rural areas: lessons learn...
 

Mehr von Nipesh P Narayanan (20)

Ways of Knowing
Ways of KnowingWays of Knowing
Ways of Knowing
 
Baoli at Tughlaqabad
Baoli at TughlaqabadBaoli at Tughlaqabad
Baoli at Tughlaqabad
 
Hazrat Nizamuddin ki Baoli
Hazrat Nizamuddin ki BaoliHazrat Nizamuddin ki Baoli
Hazrat Nizamuddin ki Baoli
 
Baoli at R K Puram
Baoli at R K PuramBaoli at R K Puram
Baoli at R K Puram
 
Agrasen Ki Baoli
Agrasen Ki BaoliAgrasen Ki Baoli
Agrasen Ki Baoli
 
Baoli at Feroz Shah Kotla
Baoli at Feroz Shah KotlaBaoli at Feroz Shah Kotla
Baoli at Feroz Shah Kotla
 
Baoli at Old fort
Baoli at Old fortBaoli at Old fort
Baoli at Old fort
 
Gandhak Ki Baoli
Gandhak Ki BaoliGandhak Ki Baoli
Gandhak Ki Baoli
 
Rajaon ki Baoli
Rajaon ki BaoliRajaon ki Baoli
Rajaon ki Baoli
 
Rajaon ki Baoli
Rajaon ki BaoliRajaon ki Baoli
Rajaon ki Baoli
 
Baoli at Northern Ridge
Baoli at Northern RidgeBaoli at Northern Ridge
Baoli at Northern Ridge
 
Qutab Sahib ki Baoli
Qutab Sahib ki BaoliQutab Sahib ki Baoli
Qutab Sahib ki Baoli
 
Lecture 11 globalization
Lecture 11  globalizationLecture 11  globalization
Lecture 11 globalization
 
Lecture 10 postmodernism
Lecture 10   postmodernismLecture 10   postmodernism
Lecture 10 postmodernism
 
Lecture 9 postmodernism
Lecture 9   postmodernismLecture 9   postmodernism
Lecture 9 postmodernism
 
Lecture 8 meanderings of modernism - futurism & formalism
Lecture 8   meanderings of modernism - futurism & formalismLecture 8   meanderings of modernism - futurism & formalism
Lecture 8 meanderings of modernism - futurism & formalism
 
Lecture 7 regionalism in india and search for indianness
Lecture 7   regionalism in india and search for indiannessLecture 7   regionalism in india and search for indianness
Lecture 7 regionalism in india and search for indianness
 
Assignment 4 guidelines
Assignment 4 guidelinesAssignment 4 guidelines
Assignment 4 guidelines
 
Assignment 3 guidelines
Assignment 3 guidelinesAssignment 3 guidelines
Assignment 3 guidelines
 
Lecture 6 modernism
Lecture 6   modernismLecture 6   modernism
Lecture 6 modernism
 

Martin thomson understanding the informal settlement

  • 1. EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011 UK ‘Our Global Future’ 4th March 2011 The underlying soil may provide difficulties as the area in focus is by nature made situated on fluvial soils, which may ay not provide a reliable foundation for the design. Defence against floating solid objects such as vehicles and trees in river flow must be considered. Mit Mitigation of these hazards may be overcome through the planting of large trees to surround buildings. Strength of bamboo is greatly affected by contact with water. Appropriate protection methods should be considered, in accordance with cost effectiveness an availability. and Bibliography Associated Press. 2007. In Pictures: Floods devastating parts of Asia. CBBC Newsround. [Online] BBC, 5 August 2007. [Cited: 15 December 2010.] http://news.bbc.co.uk/cbbcnews/hi/newsid_6920000/newsid_6923500/6 http://news.bbc.co.uk/cbbcnews/hi/newsid_6920000/newsid_6923500/6923552.stm. Byrne, Steven. Early Concept Design. University of Strathclyde, Glasgow : s.n. Gray, Louise and Reuters. 2009. UK to help Bangladesh tackle climate change . Telegraph. [Online] 13 July 2009. [Cited: 15 December 2010.] http://www.telegraph.co.uk http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/5819066/UK-to-help-Bangladesh Bangladesh-tackle-climate- change.html. Rijcken, Ties. Floating Communities. EcoBoat. [Online] Holland & Co. [Cited: 10 December 2010.] http://www.ecoboot.nl/artikelen/WeblogTiesFloatingCommunities.html.php. Seraj, Salek M and Ahmed, K Iftekhar. 2004. Building Safer Houses in Rural Bangladesh. Dhaka : Bangladesh , University of Engineering and Technology, 2004. ISBN 984 984-32-1280-5. United Nations. 2009. World Population Prospects - The 2008 Revision. Department of Economic and Social Affairs Af Population Division. [Online] 2009. [Cited: 10 December 2010.] http://www.un.org/esa/population/publications/wpp2008/wpp2008_text_tables.pdf. Understanding the informal settlement Martin Thomson University of Strathclyde Preface This paper is an edited extract from my 4th year architectural dissertation written on informal settlement development and it accompanies the A3 poster produced for this conference. The dissertation was a theoretical exploration of the challenges informal settlements face. It argued six principles as essential for sustainable development of 'failing' informal settlements. Keywords: Informal settlement development, holistic approach, sustainability, urban The informal settlement is an incredibly complex phenomenon. They are responsive to cultural, social and economic variations with differing political, religious and historical backgrounds. This paper takes a step back from these ical, complexities in an attempt to understand fundamental principles which can lead to successful development of a cessful spontaneous settlement. Six elements have been identified: i) perceived land tenure; ii) informal economics; iii) building deregulation; iv) social cohesion; v) appropriate governance and; vi) external support. Each is detailed in the following pages. A strong argument is established, with examples and references reinforcing es. examples each. Posters 156
  • 2. EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011 UK ‘Our Global Future’ 4th March 2011 The Six Principles i) Perceived land tenure Importance “The removal of tenure-insecurity related obsta insecurity obstacles that prevent or constrain households from using their housing effectively as a productive asset is possibly the single most critical poverty reduction intervention” oductive intervention (Moser, 1996, 5.) Protection from eviction is seen as one of the key el elements to alleviate those from poverty (UN Habitat, 2003, 168). 168) Definition Perceived security of tenure, as referred to here, is protection from eviction at a level where its affect encourages the ived squatter invest money, time and effort in their dwelling. Argument When protection from eviction is realised, squatter houses will naturally be built to a better condition, with more naturally permanent materials, over a longer period of time. A sense of permanence must be felt by the squatter to incite building upon their situation, otherwise sub standard conditions will remain. The influence of secure tenure goes sub-standard secu beyond physical improvements; permanent neighbourhoods naturally encourage stronger social connections between neighbours and communities begin to flourish (UN Habitat, 2003, 150). With strong community ties, social security emerges empowering the squatters further. Also a community allows collective decisions to be made on improvements ng to the settlement as a whole, like pavements or sanitation. ii) Informal Economics Importance “...the economic activity and employment in the urban informal sector are extremely important in developing countries where population and demand for jobs, goods and services are typically growing more quickly than national averages and...for formal job creation to cope with.” (de Soto, 2000, 102) Definition The informal economy provides variously paid labour w formal where individuals contribute to local communities by offering affordable goods and employment within a social framework of trust and reciprocity, devised and implemented out of necessity by the people (Yeung and Old, 2000) UN habitat defines the informal sector as “the generally small-scale d 2000). industries and commercial activities that are not registered enterprises but provide large amounts of products and services that people use each day.” (2003, 100). Argument The informal economy, when exercised freely, is a powerful tool for the poor of the world’s developing cities. It he provides much needed work that fends off destitution, offers new economic opportunity, introduces social stability and a better quality of life (Mingione, 1996 cited in Daniels, 2004, 3). Through its tax free and localised operations, the informal sector can offer affordable goods to the urban poor in addition to providing them with employment, compensating for the often saturated and inaccessible formal sector (UN Habitat, 2003, 102). ompensating Formal labour costs are kept lower by the cheaper goods and services available to their staff from this unregistered market. The formal market can also exploit directly the lower cost of raw materials and input the extralegal sector inputs offers (UN Habitat,2003,102). However, perhaps the most essential argument for the presence of the extralegal sector is the impenetrable nature of the legal sector for those who are poor. This was evident during the Asian monetary crisis in 1998 where the informal in sector ballooned as the formal sector took a huge hit. It should be remembered that: “It is with such humble beginnings that many of today’s great corporations and industries have their origins.” (UN Habitat, 2003, 53). Posters 157
  • 3. EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011 UK Confere ‘Our Global Future’ 4th March 2011 iii) Building Deregulation Importance When a poor person has control of when and to what extent to build their home, they effectively have more control over their poverty - they build when they can afford and when best suits their situation; they bui what they need and build to what degree. Definition Building deregulation, as referred to here, is when a squatter has the freedom to build and modify their dwelling, free from restrictive and prescripted building regulations. Argument The squatter comes to the city and often enters tenuous employment. Their situation is rarely static as they adjust to s their new urban life and what disposable income theyhave is largely dependent on dwelling arrangements. Having the freedom to build grants the new urban dweller social mobility, as they can erect a structure appropriate to their n aspirations and circumstance. Self-built houses free from regulation also tackle poverty in another way. If migrants can exercise a level of freedom built upon arrival to the city, they equip themselves with self-belief otherwise crushed if authorities intervene heavily. hey belief Armed with determination to challenge their surrounding poverty, they inin-turn challenge the social boundaries which would otherwise cut them off from the rest of the city. Allowed to exercise personal and local resources of imagination, initiative, commitment, responsibility, skill and muscle power the urban poor realise the potential they hold (Turner, 1976, 50). iv) Social Cohesion Importance “Social cohesion is critical for societies to prosper economically and for development to be sustainable.” (UN Habitat,2003,71) A community provides a crucial social support network which low income classes often need to fall back on and rely on to go forward. Social cohesion can lead to community driven development, which is essential for solving the problems on unique to any one settlement. Definition Social cohesion, as discussed in this paper, refers to the creation of a community, that is, a group of people who reside in the same geographical area and share a certain quality of relationship, providing a network of social support (Pacione, 2001, 355). Argument The low income classes of the developing world have no formal channels of support and social security must be sought so elsewhere. The most crucial source is from their immediate community. A network of friends and family can mean the difference between a roof to sleep under or homelessness. “No-one will ever go hungry because there will always be an open door and a gesture of solidarity” one Gabriela Torres Barbosa, squatter resident, Rio de Janeiro (New Internationalist, 2006, 4). Social cohesion is an essential prerequisite for a community. However, the influence of a community goes beyond sustenance and support to the individual. Collective agreement and funding within a community can be used to implement services and facilities when the local authorities are unable to. When external bodies can implement services, a community voice may be essential if the area is t receive the most appropriate service for its particular to needs. Posters 158
  • 4. EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011 UK Confere ‘Our Global Future’ 4th March 2011 The community however must not become the only reliable source of support for inhabitants. Developing cities are ethnically diverse, and successful actors participate as many different identities – one for his neighbourhood, one for ccessful o cross-city business, one for acquiring resources – engaging freely, gathering resources quickly and efficiently by maximising the opportunities of the city (UN Habitat: 2003:47) 2003:47). v) Appropriate Governance Importance Community driven development - development in which the community are in control of the main decisions - is the most appropriate mechanism for informal settlement development (Abbott, 2002a, 6). Definition Appropriate governance, as discussed her refers to relevant stakeholders in decision making having proportionate here, influence at different stages of settlement development. The community must control decisions, to an appropriate degree, when decisions affect the local community. Equally, authorit authorities must control decisions, to an appropriate degree, when ol decisions begin to affect the wider city. Argument The centralised system, when governing the poor, fails because its scale and limitation of management deny the variety and flexibility required for the unique and delicate communities found within informal settlements (Turner, 1976, 7). When people govern themselves, a custom fit system of correct scale is applied. Human priorities cannot be adequately accounted for by housing policy, but the sens sensitivity of self- governance can, therefore providing more appropriate responses to squatter settlement development (UN Habitat, 2003, xxvii). Settlement integration and full community responsibility are incompatible (Abbott, 2002a, 11). For a settlement to evolve from a small isolated colony into an integrated district, self governance must relinquish power to local authorities self-governance accordingly. If local authorities are to act responsibly and react dynamically to informal settlements they must understand dynamically when this is to occur and to what degree. his vi) External support Importance “...there are limits to what low-income groups can achieve for themselves, either individually or collectively, without some income form of technical support and other resources from external agents.” (Lee, 1998, 2) Definition External support, as referred to here, is support provided from out with the squatter settlement necessary to compensate what the settlement cannot facilitate. Argument The development of a settlement is limited to the capacity of those driving it; external support is needed to compensate the areas the community cannot fulfil. The intermediary body which provides external support is typically an NGO, facilitating, stimulating or supporting individual or community based org organisations (Lee, 1998, 2). Community organisation will not always spontaneously arise, particularly in heterogeneous settlements where social cohesion is weak. Successful community based development is often facilitated externally, where access to land, infrastructure and services infrastructure necessary for environmental improvement are made available. If internal limitations are overcome, a settlement can develop to a far greater degree. Similarly, like the previous arguments, there is also a d degree of balance required. For development to be sustainable, a community cannot become dependent on outside agencies (Lee, 1998, 16). Case Studies Sultanbeyli, Istanbul (Neuwirth, 2005, 143 143-173) Sultanbeyli is a suburb in the east of Istanbul. It grew rapidly in the mid 1980s and between 1986 and 1989 an estimated 20,000 houses were erected. Today its fifteen neighbourhoods host 300,000 residents of which 48,000 are university students. Banks, post offices, department stores and travel agents line its high streets. It is descr described as a desirable place however it is a squatter community: the vast majority of its 30,000 structures are not legally registered. With good living conditions, substantial development and integration with the formal city, it is a ‘successful’ informal settlement. Architecturally it is indistinguishable fromlegal neighbourhoods and even receives better services than some ettlement. Posters 159
  • 5. EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011 UK Confere ‘Our Global Future’ 4th March 2011 formal areas. How it has reached striking equality with the formal city can be understood under the six preconditioning elements for squatter settlement development. uatter Perceived security of tenure: Present. In Turkey every citizen has the right to vote. This makes squatter clearances politically intangible, preventing the authorities from reining in. With 42.6 percent of Turkey’s urban population living in pop squatter settlements, their staying power will undoubtedly remain (Davis, 2006, 24). Informal economics: Present. Informal businesses operate freely in Sultanbeyli. Sultanbeyli is a squatter settlement because the vast majority of its buildings hold no official titles, including its businesses. They provide cheaper goods and ldings services to the residents allowing them to prosper on lower wages. Building deregulation: Present. The residents of Sultanbeyli have built and continue to build their own neighbourhoods. Self-built dwellings range from single-story poured concrete boxes to spacious apartment houses with large balconies and story complete modern services. Freedom to build their own dwellings on vacant land with little opposition from the government has created a thriving settlement. rnment Social cohesion: Present. Zamanhan Ablak, as described by Neuwirth, and his neighbours pooled money, each house contributing to the payment of sewers, schools and a local mosque. This shows clear signs of communit and social community cohesion as well as self-governance. Appropriate governance: Present. Exercising self governance, the community was able to make the most appropriate self-governance, decisions to the upgrading of their settlement. Turkish law allows communities over 2,000 residents to form quasi- residents quasi independent municipalities, granting continued decision making to the community and, crucially, introducing the city to government’s influence. External Support: Present. Zamanhan and his neighbours could not facilitate piped water into their homes. Instead this was provided externally by the municipal government. For the first two years, squatters fetched water by hand but afterwards the government supplied barrelled water and eventually installed piped water. The squatter settlement of Sultanbeyli is a well serviced suburb and displays numerous signs of integration. Poverty appears to be minimal and its people enjoy opportunities usually only attainable by formal city inhabitants. All six elements are present and have created substantial settlement development, good living conditions and integration with substantial the wider city. Kampung Penas Tanggul, Jakarta (Winayanti 2004, 8 8-24) Located in the east of Jakarta, the squatter settlement of Kampung Penas Tanggul is home to 388 people (August 2000 2000). Established in 1970 by rural migrants from various locations in Java, the settlement has slowly developed from a collection of bamboo and wood shacks into a community of brick houses with concrete interlinking pathways. Access to water and toilets may be shared facilities but show substantial upgrading. e Perceived security of tenure: Present. From 1997 onwards, there have been no evictions and confidence to stay has emerged. Confidence to build, however, did not arise until 2000 when the squatters were issued a Rukun etangga (recognition as an official neighbourhood) from the authorities. This granted them a formal address, but not ownership of land. The formalized address however saw residents gradually invest in their situation, building with more permanent materials and with greater foresight. It should also be mentioned that the security of tenure also brought an increased level of external support from an NGO. Informal Economics: Present. The 21 residents interviewed relied purely on informal employ employment for income. These ranged from street vendors to construction workers, scavengers to taxi drivers. Without access to this informal employment it is highly unlikely the rural migrants would be skilled or educated enough to find formal work (the majorit majority had just elementary school education). Building deregulation: Present. The squatters of Penas Tanggul have freedom to build and improve their dwellings. 20 of the 83 structures were upgraded after secure tenure was first perceived. A number of the bamb bamboo and wood structures had an upper floor added or the lower structure was replaced with brick. Social cohesion: Present. Despite the diverse origins of Penas Tanggul’s residents, coming from numerous regions of Java and Sulawesi (both islands of Indonesia signs of social cohesion were present from the beginning. The settlement Indonesia), land was first divided up under the coordination of a respected group leader. This led to the layout of common facilities and mutual cooperation to improve and maintain their env environment. Appropriate governance: Absent. Community driven development oversaw the addition of communal toilets, footpath paving and a waste disposal program. Governance of Penas Tanggul is a completely internal affair. There is no dialogue between Penas Tanggul (or indeed any Jakarta informal settlement) and the government, despite their recognition as a anggul neighbourhood of Jakarta. In the long term this will leave the settlement isolated from the city of Jakarta. External support: Present. A high level of external support is present in the development of Penas Tanggul, and has external been since 1986. Over this long period of time, the two NGOs have facilitated free medication, free school lessons for children and subsidized education and hospital treatment. Crucially, they educated squatters on their human rights and Crucially, mobilized a protest to save the settlement from eviction. The NGOs also taught the people on environmental issues to improve the water quality of the river and the environment of their settlement. The residents of Penas Tanggul have experienced great improvements in the quality of their lives both environmentally esidents and health-wise. The settlement itself has developed from temporary bamboo and wooden shacks to permanent brick wise. p dwellings. These improvements are reflected in the fact five of the six elements are present. The level of development, Posters 160
  • 6. EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011 UK Confere ‘Our Global Future’ 4th March 2011 however, is limited because the settlement has no dialogue with local authorities, leaving it isolated and still significantl significantly vulnerable. Kibera, Nairobi (Kramer, 2006, 83 -95 & Neuwirth, 2005, 67 95 67-100) Kibera is home to an estimated 600,000 squatters and sits side by side with the formal city but with stark inequalities in living conditions. Squeezed into just 1.2km squared, the only spaces within the settlement not occupied by mud huts are large piles of rubbish and sewage. Waterways are effectively open sewers, safe running water is absent and electricity is a privilege. Dirt lanes are only a few feet wide and life is very tough. Kibera is materially poor, under-developed and separated from the rest of the city. Opportunities are low and crime is developed high. The six prerequisite elements for informal settlement developed will be used to help understand why Kibera exists in such dire conditions. Perceived security of tenure: Absent. The squatters of Kibera are tenants on unregistered land. Rich land lords acquire the land illegitimately from authorities and politicians who in turn refuse to recognise Kibera as a permanent settlement. The mud huts are rented out on an understood temporary basis and thus tenure security is absent. rstood Informal Economics: Present. Hawkers sell foodstuffs like maize and kale and many women sell spooled cloth and used clothes. There are unregistered barbers, even a blacksmith and households with televisions open their doors to assume televisions business as small cinemas. The informal economy is therefore practised widely and freely in Kibera. Building deregulation: Absent. Local landlords acquire the title less mud huts of Kibera from local politicians who in title-less turn deny any modification to them by their tenants. A government official explains that if a hut is modified by a resident, the hut will be demolished. He attempts to justify this by saying the huts are only temporary, even though they have been present for decades. Such tight control over squatter housing denies many opportunities and good living conditions to the poor squatters. Social cohesion: Absent. The settlement is strongly divided into ten distinct neighbourhoods defined along ethnic lines. In December 2001 riots broke out which destroyed homes and saw twelve killed. The high crime rates reflect the lack of cember cross-community relationships within the settlement. community Appropriate governance: Absent. Self-governance is built on community togetherness and control over decision -governance c making, both which are absent in Kibera. The top down unilateral decision making by the government on issues in Kibera top-down has done nothing to improve conditions. External Support: Absent. The Nairobi authorities sadly refuse to provide a any services or include Kibera in any city plans due to the settlement’s illegal status. There is no city wide policy on tackling the squatter problem in Nairobi, city-wide discouraging any long term action to be taken. NGO based support is present, but with the she size of Kibera and the sheer multitude of problems it hosts, the support is insignificant to the whole. Poverty in Kibera is severe and visible everywhere. By analysing the settlement using the six elements, it is clear as to why it fails to develop. One element may be present, the informal economy, but on its own it cannot facilitate ent development. Conclusions This paper does not seek to answer the complex problems squatter settlements pose but attempts to offer a framework where the main barriers to development are brought down. Initially the six point framework pulls the settlement free from nt the most restrictive constraints. Perceived security of tenure brings permanence; informal economics brings greater economic equality; deregulated building processes enables dwellings to be appropriate to dweller salary and situation; enables social cohesion brings improved social security; appropriate governance allows the most correct decisions involving the settlement and the city to be made; and external support provides essential help to otherwise unattainable goals. essential It was then stressed that, the guidelines must evolve and change with the development of the settlement to overlook integration between the settlement and city. The informal sector must begin to feed into and off of the formal sector for economic and city integration to occur. The deregulated building principles must gradually succumb to building standards, principles just as the once informal cities of the most developed countries have. Social cohesion, ideally, will be at such a level as not to segregate and fragment neighbourhoods from the city but to provide the security which comes with it. Appropriate government is a fluid understanding: governance of human habitation should never be static and local and central governing bodies must always remain in dialogue, powers adjusting for the most appropriate decisions to be ning d made. External support must understand that for development to be sustainable, its role must be temporary and supportive, not permanent and controlling. The three case studies explored these guidelines. Sultanbeyli, the settlement described as largely developed, displayed all six elements. Kampung Penas Tanggul, a settlement which has developed impressively under improved conditions but with limited integration with the wider city, displayed five of the six elements. Appropriate governance was absent, central ration government having no input and integration difficult to foresee. The failing settlement Kibera confirmed the importance of the elements, as all but one were absent. ne Defining and arguing each element showed that none is constrained to itself. Each has influence on another, if not every, element. This reflects the need for a multi disciplinary approach to development to address the complex nature of human multi-disciplinary hum Posters 161
  • 7. EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011 UK Confere ‘Our Global Future’ 4th March 2011 settlement. It is a warning against narrow focused approaches, whether heavily top down intervention or purely grass- top-down grass roots. The current climate of neo-liberal self help, having conquered over many interventional approaches, is in fear of liberal self-help, pulling the balance too far towards the community and fragmenting cities. The sheer scale and global occurrence of squatter settlements demands that there be real understanding of why and how these areas develop or stagnate. Without this understanding the developing countries will stay developing. countries Acknowledgements I am very grateful for the assistance throughout the original dissertation from Dr Ombretta Romice of Strathclyde University Architecture Department. The essay was able to build on a strong structure and clear direction and I thank clearer Ombretta for this. Bibliography Abbott (1996) John Abbott. Sharing the city: co community participation in urban management. London: Earthscan . Abbott (2002a) John Abbott. An analysis of infinformal settlement upgrading and critique of existing methodological xisting approaches. Habitat International Vol 26, Issue 3, . September 2002, pp 303-315 Amis and Kumar (2000) Amis, P and S Kumar Urban economic growth, infrastructure and poverty in India: Lessons from Visakhapatnam. Environment and Urbaniz . Urbanization 12:(1):185-196 Amnesty International (2006) Amnesty International: Zimbabwe: quantifying destruction: satellite images of forced evictions 8 September 2006 Appadurai (2001) Appadurai, A Deep democracy: Urban governmentality and the horizon of politics Environment and politi Urbanization 2001 13 (2):23-43 BPPD and BPS DKI Jakarta (1997) Evalus Evalusasi Rukun Warga (RW) Kumuh DKI Jakarta. Penerbit BPS Kantor Statistik . Propinsi DKI Jakrata. Bromley (2009) Daniel W. Bromley. Formalising proper relations in the developing world: The wrong prescription for property the wrong malady . Land Use Policy Journal. Buyamin, A., & Kartini (1998). Forced evictions in Jakarta. In K. Fernandes (Ed.), Forced evictions and housing right abuses in Asia, 2nd Report 1996-97. Karachi: 97. Eviction Watch Asia, City Press. Charmes (2000) J. Charmes Informal sector, p poverty and gender: A review of empirical evidence. Background paper for World Development Report 2001 Centre of Economics and Ethics for Environmental and Development, 2001. University of Versailles-St Quentin en Yveliness St Daniels (2004) P.W. Daniels Urban Challenges: the fo formal and informal economies of mega-cities Cities, Vol 21, No. 6, cities p501-511, 2004 Davis(2006) Mike Davis, Planet of Slums 2006 Verso Publishers, London. Slums. de Soto (2000) Hernando de Soto. The Mystery of Capital: Why capitalism triumphs in the West and fails everywhere else. 2000. Basic books: New York Erman (1997) Erman T.Squatter (gecekondu) Housing versus Apartment Housing: Turkish Rural-to-Urban Migrant Rural Residents’ Perspectives. Habitat Intl. Vol. 28, No 1, pp.91-106, 1997. Grimond (2007) Audio interview – a discussion with J Johnny Grimond, writer-at-large for The Economist. The Economist, May 2007 Habitat, (2005) UN Habitat. State of the World’s Cities 2004/2005. Earthscan Publishers UK & USA . Huchzerymer (1999). Huchzermeyer, M. The exploration of appropriate informal settlement interventions in South Africa: Contributions from a comparison with Brazil. Ph.D. Thesis, South Africa: University of Cape Town, unpublished. Jeffres, & Dobos (1995) L.W. Jeffres and J. Dobos, Separating people’s satisfaction with life and public perceptions of the quality of life in the environment. Social Indicators Research 34 (1995), pp. 181–211 Kingdon and Knight (2004) Geeta Gandhi Kingdo and John Knight Unemployment Kingdon in South Africa: The Nature of the Beast World Development Vol. 32, No. 3, pp391 ent pp391-408, 2004.Kramer (2006) Kramer, Mark. Dispossessed: Life in our World’s Urban Slums. 2006. Orbis Books, New York. Lloyd (1979) Lloyd, Peter. Slums of Hope. ums Hope.1979. Manchester University Press Lizarralde,(2008) Gonzalo Lizzaralde. Unexpected negative outcomes of community participation Habitat International 32 , 2008 Main and Williams (1994) Hamish Main and Stephen Wyn Williams Environment and housing in third world cities John ing Wiley and sons, Chichester Mashhour (1999) Mostafa Ali Salem Mashhour Resident’s sense of comtrol, self-esteem and sense of community in esteem aided self-help housing in Egypt Strathclyde University Thesis, unpublished. Posters 162
  • 8. EWB-UK National Research & Education Conference 2011 UK Confere ‘Our Global Future’ 4th March 2011 Mingione (1996) E. Mingione Urban poverty and the underclass: A reader Blackwell Oxford and Cambridge, MA Blackwell, Moser (1996) C. Moser Confronting Crisis: A summ summary of households responses to poverty and vulnerability in four poor urban communities Environmentally Sustain Sustainable Development Studies and Monographs Series, No. 7. 1996. World Bank, Washington DC. New Internationalist (2006) NI 386 Squatter Town: The South’s Urban Explosion January/February 2006 Neuwirth (2005) Neuwirth, Robert. Shadow Cities: A Billion Squatters, a New Urban World. 2005. London: Routledge Nijman (2008) Jan Nijman Against the odds: Slum rehabilitation in neoliberal Mumbai Cities 25 (2008) 73 – 85 Mumbai. Pacione (2001) Michael Pacione Urban Geography: a global perspective Routledge Publishers, New York Yor Sengupta & Sharma (2009) Urmi Sengupta & Sujeet Sharma. No longer SukumasissL Challeneges in grassroots-led grassroots squatter resettlement program Kathmandu with Sepcial reference to Kirtipur Housing Project. Habitat International 33 ent . Habit (2009) 33- 44 Shapiro (1985) Shapiro, A L Housing the Poor in Paris, 1850 – 1902. 1985. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison. Sivam (2002) Constraints affecting the efficiency of the urban residential land market in developing countries: a case study of India. Habitat International 26, 523 523-537. Turner (1976) Turner, John. Housing by People Towards Autonomy in Building Environments. 1976. Great Britain: People: Environments Marion Boyars Publishers Ltd UN Habitat (2003) UN Habitat The Challenge of Slums: Global report on human settlements 2003. Earthscan Publishers 2003 London. Varela -Michel (1997) M. Varela Michel Cultural Adaption and Rural Migrant Hosuing (Mexico). McGill University, Montreal Westaway (2006) Margaret S.Westaway. A Longitudinal Investigation of Satisfaction with Personal and Environmental Environmenta quality of life in an informal South African housing settlement, Doornkop, Soweto. Habitat International. Vol 30, Issue 1, . 3 March 2006, pp175-198 Winayanit & Lang (2004) Lana Winayanti & Heracles C. Lang Provision of urban services in an informal settlement: a settlem case study of Kampung Penas Tanggul, Jakarta. Habitat International 28 (2004) 41 – 65 Wirth (1938) L. Wirth Urbanism as a way of life American , Journal of Sociology 44, 1 – 24 Yeung and Old (2000) H. W. Yeung and K. Old Globalization of Chinese Business Firms MacMillan, London. 2000. Zebardast (2006) Esfandiar Zebardast Marginalization of the urban poor and the expansion of the spontaneous settlements on the Tehran metropolitan fringe. Cities, Vol. 23, No. 6, p439-454, 2006. Design of a wooden framed bicycle Joshua Lewis Cardiff University Project Brief Here in the UK, there are many options available to us when it comes to transport, but in many of the sub sub-Saharan countries of Africa, personal mobility is a problematic issue that is faced daily. The public transport services available in daily. these regions are often overcrowded, dangerous and unaffordable. The bicycle is the cheapest form of personal transportation available, and while bicycles are available in these regions, they are still prohibitively expensive and most prohibitively locals cannot afford them. Therefore, these nations are heavily reliant on bicycles donated from the developed world. However, when these bicycles brake down there is a dearth of adequate spare parts available, as manufacturers often no longer support the older models. What is required is a bicycle that can be made cheaply out of local materials, does not require special tools or skills, and that can make use of a wide range of spare parts. Due to these requirements it is not possible for the bicycle frame to be possible made from traditional materials such as steel or aluminium, and so wood must be considered instead. Such a bicycle must be an improvement on the bikes currently available in the area, and the needs of the locals must be a accounted for during its design. If such a bicycle could be designed and tested, plans produced, and assembly instructions developed; then there is the potential to greatly improve the lives of millions of people, whilst also benefiting the economies of the regions affected. Such improvements would free people from poverty and bring greater opportunities to the people of Africa. Posters 163