3. Agenda for NRECA Agile Fractal Grid
Kickoff Meeting
8:00 Welcome by Martin Lowery; Opening by Chuck Speicher
8:15 Introductions of the Participants – John Reynolds
8:45 Achieving the Common Language through Design Patterns
9:20 The Vision of the Agile Fractal Grid – Craig Miller
9:45 Break
10:00 Discussion of the Managed Services Store and Applications
10:20 Discussion of the Distributed Systems Elements
11:45 Discussion of the Industrial Internet – Security, Resiliency, Efficiency
12:15 Lunch
1:00 Scope of the SmartAmerica Challenge vs. the Production Rollout
2:00 SEIT Process and Phase 1 Planning
2:30 Break
3:00 Phase 2 Implementation and Thread Assignments
3:30 General Discussion, Issues, Action Items, and Understandings
4:00 Wrap Up and Conclusion
8. It has been said that
the greatest engineering achievement of the 20th century
has been the building of the electric grid.
- The National Academy of Engineering
10. Department of Energy
Carol Hawk
Program Manager,
Cyber Security for Energy Delivery Systems
Ivanpah
World's largest solar plant started producing electricity today
Ivanpah was supported by $1.6 billion in investments
from the Energy Department's Loan Programs Office.
It represents the future of energy –
utility-scale renewable power generation
that uses the latest technology to harness the sun
where it is most abundant.
13. Department of Homeland Security
Lisa Kaiser
Sarah Mahmood
Executive Order (EO) 13636: Improving Critical Infrastructure Cybersecurity
Presidential Policy Directive (PPD)-21: Critical Infrastructure Security and Resilience,
Critical Infrastructure Cyber Community Voluntary Program
Secretary of Homeland Security
Jeh Johnson
14. PM – ISE
DNI
Pamela Wise-Martinez
Mike Howell
Kshemendra Paul
Mission Partners
15. Congress
Diane Rinaldo
Legislative Director
For Mike RogersMike Rogers
– Michigan 8th District
U.S. House of Representatives
Chairman, House Intelligence Committee
Member, Energy and Commerce Committee
United States House Energy Subcommittee on Communications and Technology
United States House Energy Subcommittee on Health
Cyberthreat Data Sharing
and Protection
18. We are planning to support the 940 rural co-ops in the U.S. with
hybrid cloud/device services protected by the Security Fabric.
This is also the candidate energy “testbed” for the SmartAmerica demonstration.
19. What NRECA has asked us to do.
1. Stand up an “app store” for both operational and analytical
applications for the cooperatives.
2. Participate in the “Substation of the Future” for the remote
equipment and subsystems.
3. Apply the Security Fabric within the emerging Industrial
Internet to protect all communications between the
elements.
20. Introduction to the
Security Fabric Alliance
• The Security Fabric Alliance is a working association dedicated to
practical deployment of the power grid and critical infrastructure
complex system solution in the United States:
– Utilities and telecommunications providers
– Systems integrators
– Manufacturers
– Technology partners
– National certification and interoperability entity
• The alliance is intended to give the CEO of a utility the purview of
up-to-the moment knowledge of the options available to make wise
investment decisions regarding infrastructure deployment for
optimal returns.
The variation includes the proper orientation for large, medium, and small utilities.
21. There are many participants at different levels
in the Security Fabric Alliance.
ComponentsProductsSubsystems
ResearchIntegration
Utility
Customers
• Intel – servers with Quark + TPM
• Wind River – Security Connect
• Middleware
• RTI – DDS
• GridStat
• Indra - iSpeed
• MultiSpeak
• TeamF1 – Secure Communications
• Secure Crossing – Protocol Whitelisting
• PsiNaptic – Secure Service Distribution
• SNMP Research – SNMP Agent
• Freescale – HSM w/Vybrid SoC
• Xilinx – CompactRIO SOC
• Green Hills Software - INTEGRITY
• Altera - tamper proofing
• Microsoft – Active Directory
• Red Hat – Auth Hub
• General Electric – EMS
• Alstom Grid – EMS
• Siemens – DMS
• Viridity Energy – DR + DER
+ Microgrid
• Lemko – LTE systems
• Intel Security – SIEM + GTI
• Intel – Encanto
+ silicon support
• Sypris – Supply
Chain Root of Trust
• TCIPG
• EPRI – CIM Standards
• MIT – Security &
Privacy Standards
• EPG – Phasor Data Portfolio
• GridSense– NAN & Line Sensors
• S&C IntelliTeam
• SafeNet – Secure Key Management
• Heart - Transverter
• Freescale One Box
• Cisco Cloud-in-a-Box
• Integrated Architectures – SEIT
• MACE Fusion - DoD
• Kryptos Logic – Red Team Certification
• M2M Dynamics
• Drummond Group – C&IT
• Intel Security - Distribution
...First Stage……
• ERCOT
• ONCOR
• AEP
• NRECA
• NRTC
Suppliers
• Verizon
• Level3
• AT&T
• Internet2
• BT
• ViaSat
• Hughes
• ARINC
• Stratus
• Symmetricom
…Second Stage……
• APPA
• SDG&E
• PJM
• NYISO
• Southern Company
• Duke Energy
• CAISO
• Pecan Street
• Mueller Community
• Pike Powers
• PNNL – CyberSecurity
Test Center
• Lincoln Labs
• OMG SIG
• SmartAmerica
Managed Services
• Tazca – Connect
• CSG International
• Digi International
• N-Dimension
• SETI
• Lockheed Martin
• SAIC
• Threat Connect
22. To establish the security of end-to-end systems using the Security Fabric elements,
you need to do all seven… not just some.
4. Audit
– Records noteworthy events for later analysis
5. Confidentiality
– Encrypts sensitive data for matters of privacy.
6. Integrity
– Ensures that messages have not been
altered.
7. Availability
– Prevents denial of service attacks
1. Identity Management
– Ensures the device identity is established
genuinely
2. Mutual Authentication
– Allows both the Device Node and the
Controller to verify the trustworthiness their
identity to each other.
3. Authorization
– Manages permission to proceed with specific
operations.
These are the seven tenets of security
as described in the NIST-IR 7628 Guidelines.
23. The OMG process is more about establishing markets
as opposed to just setting standards.
SFA Reference
Builds
Certification of
Conformance &
Interoperability
The OMG is planning to standardize
the Security Fabric
for all critical infrastructure.
25. Systems Engineering, Integration, and Test
• President – Energy One Solutions
• Secretary General – GO15
Very Large Power Grid Operators
• President and CEO
Alstom ESCA Corporation
• CTO – PJM Interconnection
• Co-founder Viridity EnergyAlain Steven
John Reynolds
Alain Steven
Rick Schaal
Mike Sisto
Jim Baller
Bob Lamont
Paul Carroll
Mike Sisto
• IBM’s Wireless Emerging Business Opportunities
• AT&T, Lucent Technologies and Hewlett-Packard
• Lemko Distributed Mobile Wireless Network solutions
Rick Schaal
• VP, Engineering – Viridity
• Executive Program Director –
Alstom ESCA
• Program Director – AREVA
• DMS Lead – Puget Sound Energy
• American Public Power Association
• Fiber to the Home Council
• Google Inc.
• National Association of Telecommunications
Officers and Advisors
• + several hundred specific broadband projects
27. Texas A&M University
Named second in the nation by The Wall Street Journal among all universities,
public and private, in a survey of top U.S. corporations, non-profits and government agencies,
based on graduates that recruiters prefer to hire.
“Home of the 12th Man”
Walt Magnussen
28. Real-Time Innovations
AEGIS Weapons System
Total Ship Computing Environment
NASA Robotic Controls Unmanned Aircraft Systems
Tom O’Conner
Mark Hamilton
30. GridSense
Transformer IQ
Line IQ
Inspection
Brett Sargent • System Capacity
• Phase Imbalance
• Metering / Theft
• Conservation Voltage
Reduction
• Four Quadrant True
Power Factor
• Line Fault Directionality
• PQ – voltage sags/swells,
interruptions, surges,
unbalance
• Transformer Asset
Management
31. Lemko
LTE over Satellite
Cellular on Wheels
Utility Industry
WiMax Replacement
Security Industry
Transportation Industry
Mike Sisto
Public Safety
Healthcare industry
42. Green Hills Software
Smart Farming
Smart Medical Systems
GE Aircraft Engines
EMC High End Storage Systems
Transportation Systems
Phase Array Radar Systems
Weapons Control Systems
Guidance Systems
Game Systems
Automotive Systems
John Warther
John Killam
Brad Jackson
Brian Riley
43. LocalGrid Technologies
Power Quality Analyzer
Microgrid controls:
• Microgrid and Generation Control
• Generation and Asset Monitoring
• Storage Integration
Device EnvironmentController Environment
Hypervisor
Application
Management
Agent
Hypervisor
Application
Management
Agent
David Berg
51. Utilities Telecommunications Council
Eric Wagner
Brett Kilbourne
• Advocacy and Training
• License Sentry
• Frequency Coordination
• Microwave Coordination
• PLC Database
• RF Safety and Training
• Regulatory Filing and Tracking
54. National Rural Electrical Cooperative
Association
Martin Lowery
Robbin Christianson
David Pinney
Maurice Martin
Barry Lawson
Bridgette Bourge
Bob Lamouth
Doug Lambert
Paul Carrol
Craig Miller