The interim report on the US Blackout of 2003
points to failures of SCADA systems and critical
software applications as the chief culprits. Companies
who operate SCADA systems and advanced
online applications should note carefully the role of
these systems in the Blackout events.
1. THOUGHT LEADERS FOR MANUFACTURING & SUPPLY CHAIN
ARC INSIGHTS
By Harry Forbes
The Joint US-Canadian Task Force
named 3 major causes of the US
Blackout. These were “situational
unawareness”, poor tree trimming, and
lack of effective diagnostic support for
critical operations.
INSIGHT# 2003-51MP
DECEMBER 10, 2003
Blackout Task Force
Highlights SCADA System Woes
Keywords
Blackout, Critical Condition Monitoring (CCM), SCADA
Summary
The interim report on the US Blackout of 2003
points to failures of SCADA systems and critical
software applications as the chief culprits. Com-
panies who operate SCADA systems and advanced
online applications should note carefully the role of
these systems in the Blackout events.
Analysis
The joint US-Canadian Task Force charged with investigating the causes of
the 2003 US Blackout issued its interim report in November, 2003. The re-
port adds much to the publicly available information concerning the events
of August 14, 2003. Press reports have emphasized that the Task Force
blamed Ohio utility FirstEnergy (FE) for the outage.
A careful reading of the document, however, shows that the blame is fixed
both on FirstEnergy and on the Midwest Independent System Operator
(MISO). The new information shows that personnel in both organizations
0
10
20
30
01530456075
Minutes Before 4:11PM EDT on August 14
NumberofAbnormalEvents
FirstEnergy SCADA Alarms inoperable
MISO State Estimator inoperable