This is the presentation given by Vincent M Price during Impact 2012 in Mumbai. It's a walk through of how do you transform your insurance processes for greater competitive advantage with BPM and decision management
Distribution-agents and direct 31 and 36% respectively-but brokers 15, banks 8, on line? Product-specialization and expansion-crop/livestock Private market-4%2002 to 41% 2010- Consolidation and new entrants-new competitors example Travelers announce May 28 th JV with Mahandra and Mahandra general insurance auto Swiss Re and L&T into health market May 2012 Profitability-underwriting discipline given sof market, deregulation, heavy discounts to gain market share pressure on results such as private focus on better risks-public ratio 121 versus 106 for private 2010-placing pressure also on expense ratios such as sales and distribution
Main Point: To focus on improving processes, organizations must consider their broad business network of customers, partners, and suppliers, and how their processes span across this network. Speaker Notes: For a moment, think about your business network – no not just your IT infrastructure, but the broad network of relationships and interactions that make up your business. Most organizations reflexively think of their business network within the walls of the business, and with good reason. In today’s world these internal networks are changing rapidly. Organizational structures are changing. Traditional hierarchical organizations are becoming matrixed and geographically dispersed. Mergers and acquisitions are accelerating, and lower employee loyalty is driving higher levels of churn in your workforce. Even at a personal level, changes are accelerating. Job roles are more nebulous, and ad-hoc teaming across organizations is growing. Here we can see the business network for an insurance carrier. There is a formal corporate structure with employees organized by lines of business, but the organization is becoming blurred. Complex claims are processed across divisions, and ad-hoc teams are needed to customize insurance offerings for demanding customers. In the meantime, the company must ensure consistency and compliance across all the activities within the business to meet regulatory demands. Each of these external connections is just as important as the ones inside the business, and in fact, may becoming more important. In a recent survey of business executives, 79% said that they expect the number of collaborative relationships they have with 3 rd parties to increase 1, while 87% of CIOs think their organization will be more collborative in the next five years 2 . As more, and more functions move outside the walls of the businesses, the distinction between external and internal members of the business network is disappearing, and companies must look to maximize the value of the interactions throughout their networks. The broad business network also profoundly effects how your organization can improve business processes. In this example we see how three of our insurance company’s processes touch multiple points inside and outside of their business. In order to improve these processes, the touch points and connections between the different entities in the business network must also be considered. This pervasive dynamism throughout the extended enterprise means that not only must the processes that span the network be robust, but also flexible enough to easily accommodate change without disrupting business activities. To effective meet these challenges, organizations need to consider end-to-end process management 1 Economist Intelligence Unit – Companies without borders, Collaborating to Compete 2 IBM Global CIO Study, 2009
Pressure Bottom Line-heavy discounts and rising loss ratios Public 90% Pvt 60-70% Combined 121 & 106% 2010 Operational-no silos Demanding Customer-claims service/self service/coverages Regulatory-Compliance reporting Channels-direct/agent-on-line-banks Risk-discipined underwriting and emerging risks such as climate/cat on property, corporate d&o, political and terorism
Unfortunately in today’s world the complexity of legacy systems and the multitude of outside requirements like regulation and product requirements etc., can make these goals almost unattainable From a line of business perspective, you have : Siloed business units Differing priorities across Lines of Business Redundant processes – may have different claims processes for similar products across lines of business Manual, high touch processes – although much of the “paper” in the insurance business has been converted to electronic formats, often back office processes are still heavily reliant on human intervention to execute on transactions From an IT perspective: Legacy systems and vendor solution packages that won’t integrate Inflexible, hard coded applications Multiple projects to manage with cross-dependencies Data and information that is difficult to access real-time
We have customers who follow a shared-services organization model and realize that BPM can help in a lot of different places. Customers like this go out and advocate BPM to different lines of business so that they can, depending on priorities, drive: ● Customer Value ● Service Effectiveness ● Operational Efficiency ● Service Efficiency Then they gather input from different groups who are interested in using BPM to help their processes and they identify a pipeline of all the different implementable locations within their organization.
Main Point: Customer who buy insurance seldom care about what is happening behind the scenes. All they care about is the outcomes. They want to be served quickly and competently. When we think about ‘outcomes’ the industry is striving to shorten cycle times, make it easier to do business, develop competitive edge in service-differentiate yourselves from the competition other than price. Behind the scenes this often brings with it reduced expenses, increased capacity and profitability .
06/07/12 IBM Confidential, Not For External Use The business scenarios our prototypes support, starting with the most recent.
06/07/12 IBM Confidential, Not For External Use The business scenarios our prototypes support, starting with the most recent.
Full company name: Versicherungskammer Bayern Insurance (VKB)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-jk_1Sj-D8I
06/07/12 IBM Confidential, Not For External Use The business scenarios our prototypes support, starting with the most recent.
http://w3-01.ibm.com/sales/ssi/cgi-bin/ssialias?infotype=CR&subtype=NA&htmlfid=0CRDD-8EBBT3&appname=crmd Client Business Challenges With hundred branches and several hundred agencies dispersed throughout Russia, its claims management process was disconnected and strained with contradictory data, delayed decision making, and inconsistent levels of customer service. Without a significant change in its process management model and staff performance, the company would not be able to deliver world class customer service and remain competitive. Solution With the solution in place, the company executives were able to remotely monitor and analyze staff performance, capturing the number of new claims against claims processed per day, and the number of deadlines met. They evaluated the quality of work performed per case, amount of time needed and spent, expertise required and provided, and whether a change had to be applied to fulfill the promises made to customers. Furthermore, the solution helped identify bottlenecks, risks against corporate standards and other process improvement areas, allowing the executives to reprioritize tasks and reallocate talent and resources in flight. A large insurance provider in Russia offering over hundreds of individual and corporate insurance products. The company also expanded its sales of insurance products to online. Business need The auto insurance segment in Russia experienced rapid growth after the introduction of the Mandatory Third Party Motor Liability Insurance (OSAGO) in 2003 and continued to be the growth driver in Russia’s insurance industry, with the Comprehensive Car Insurance Policy (KASKO) making up the largest share in the portfolios of the leading insurers. As a result of this growth as well as its expansion of online sales, the company won a lot of business and consequently, experienced a rapid increase in settlement claims. However, its claims systems were too complex to keep up and unable to allow the company to add new features and capabilities that the business required. The company’s claims process was disconnected with contradictory data, slowing down the settlement process and resulting in increase operational cost. To efficiently manage its insurance claims processes, deliver world-class customer service and accommodate future business growth, the company recognized that it needed to automate its claims process. Solution implementation The company engaged IBM and IBM Business Partners BI Telecom and CROC to automate its claims process by implementing IBM WebSphere Lombardi Edition software. The software provided data analysis that the company used to evaluate the quality of work performed on the case, amount of time needed and spent, expertise required and provided, and whether a change had to be applied to fulfill the promises made to customers. Additionally, it captured and integrated data so that the company staff was able to see the number of new claims, claims processed per day and the number of deadlines and corporate standards being met. These capabilities helped the company to forecast necessary expertise and allocation of time and resources for future claims with similar characteristics. It also offered an easy way for the company to provide process coaches to help the staff complete required tasks quickly, accurately and consistently to ensure work is done on time. Real-time dashboards also showed both work-in-progress and historical performance against the company’s goals. Performance metrics were then automatically collected in the client’s performance data warehouse, and its built-in optimizer identified bottlenecks and other process improvement areas. Based on this information, the company was able to reprioritize tasks and reallocate talent as appropriate, saving time and money. Process scoreboards and performance measurements also enabled the company staff to maintain consistent levels of service to customers and gauge customer satisfaction. With the success of the new settlement claims process management, the company hopes to extend the use of WebSphere Lombardi Edition software for other processes in the near future. Benefits The company saved significant time and money by automating its claims process. With improved process efficiency and staff performance, the company was able to deliver world class customer service and increase its customer satisfaction levels. Instrumented The solution captures and integrates both latest and historical case data and applies business rules and analytics to transform it into relevant information that the company can use to forecast required time and resources per claim with similar characteristics. Interconnected Every aspect of claims processing, including the customer call center, is now centralized at the company’s operations center in Voronezh rather than dispersed throughout its 88 individual branches and 383 agencies. Anyone within the company’s 88 branches and 383 agencies who was working on a settlement case gained a 360-degree view of its status and work in progress as well as the ability to take immediate action and collaborate on process instances during process execution Intelligent The solution provided the company with a real-time analysis of insurance case performances, which helped it to actively manage the process and help ensure continued compliance with customer expectations.
06/07/12 IBM Confidential, Not For External Use The business scenarios our prototypes support, starting with the most recent.
IBM's vision is to allow customers to create more agile and dynamic processes today, that serve as the foundation for greater innovation in the future. A central piece of this vision is to improve the alignment between business architecture and IT infrastructure, and keep this alignment flexible and continuous to adapt to changing business needs. This in turn enables business agility, and allows processes to be continually improved over time. It is important, though, to understand the unique value that different technologies bring to enable agility, specifically Business Process Management and Business Rules Management. There are real synergies between the two, which is clearly identified in this slide. BPM is here to orchestrate the various tasks / actors / services that comprise the end-to-end business of the organizations whereas the BRMS is here to manage automated decisions at specific points in the process. In most of the cases, BRMS is exposed to BPM through web services that are invoked by the process to make a decision that has direct influence on how the business operates. BRMS is not just a technology to do simple routing rules inside a business process, but is instead used to automate complex, highly-variable decisions that take place at different points in a process, as well as in other systems that may not be involved in orchestrated processes.
Main Point: Process problems are inherent in today’s business environment. Typical process problems lead to many issues that only IBM BPM can solve. Speaker Notes: To better understand how business process management can reduce complexity and boost growth we should take a deeper look at the problems that cause process management problems. Yes, you have systems. But they typically only solve part of the process. At the human level, the problem is that work is not well controlled Finally, there is no end to end visibility to the process – that spans humans and systems This leads to replication of efforts and inefficient processes, lack of control over system and business events, incomplete and inaccurate data flow between systems, inconsistent prioritization, unstructured tasks and poor visibility. These issues lead to unstructured tasks, inefficient working environments, inconsistent prioritization, incomplete data flow, lack of control over systems and business events and poor visibility into process performance.
Here is a deeper look at the problems that cause process management problems. The key points here: Yes, you have systems. But they typically only solve part of the process. At the human level, the problem is that work is not well controlled Finally, there is no end to end visibility to the process – that spans humans and systems Good problem example: Aflac wants to grow their business at 100%, but their invoice reconciliation process is so manual that it will cost too much. Also, delays in resolving invoice issues affect customer satisfaction Transition: BPM is the solution to these problems So, a good way to think about BPM is that it is a layer that gives you the control and visibility over the processes. Key points: It sits between people and systems and manages the process across those participants Prioritizes your work, but also gives you visibility and control And when the process evolves and changes – you can quickly implement that change and that is immediately Back to Aflac -by deploying BPM, they cut manual processing by 80% (efficiency) while improving how well they work (affectivity) Transition: So now I would like to talk a bit about Lombardi