2. Enduring
• to have or gain continued or lasting
acknowledgment or recognition, as of
worth, merit or greatness
Great Hall, Oxford University
Built 1386
So…
How do we endure and
prosper in the face of
continuous market,
economic, and
environmental change?
4. The Big Three Trends
• Globalization
• Technology – Web 2.0
• Workforce Issues
5. Top 6 Issues facing
business
1. Financing and credit crunch
2. Keeping up with Technology
3. Workforce and People Shortage
4. Rising Health Care Costs
5. Rising Energy Costs
6. Rising Taxes
6. Change is the only constant…
“As it relates to science and technology, the
rate of change in the next decade, is likely
to be 4 to7 times faster than in the last
decade. If it is 4x faster it would be like
planning for 2006 in 1890, if it is 7x faster
it would be like planning for 2006 in 1670.”
-Expert on Education Panel, The Aspen Institute, 2007
7. So you can see farther…
Understanding these trends
and issues will allow you to
better position yourself and
your organization to
succeed in the rapidly
changing marketplace.
10. Treasury Advisory Committee on the
Auditing Profession
TreasuryTreasury
AdvisoryAdvisory
CommitteeCommittee
focuses onfocuses on
encouraging aencouraging a
sustainablesustainable
auditingauditing
professionprofession
12. GAO Report on Audit Market
Concentration
• Audit market for large public companies
remains highly concentrated, while
smaller public company market has
become significantly less concentrated
• Market concentration doesn’t appear to
have significant negative impact
• Large public company audit
concentration is unlikely to be reduced in
the near term
• No consensus for addressing market
concentration
14. HUD IPA Roster
Proposal
• Would create an Independent Public
Accountant (IPA) roster of auditors
allowed to perform HUD audits
– Firms register with HUD and agree to adhere
to eligibility requirements
– HUD could remove auditors for various
reasons including failing to maintain
compliance with eligibility requirements
– Once removed, a firm would no longer be
allowed to perform HUD audits
• Comments due in early April
16. Tax Strategy Patents
• Comprehensive patent reform bill,
including
ban on tax strategy patents, passed
House
– Led by Boucher (D-VA), Goodlatte (R-VA)
• Baucus (D-MT) and Grassley (R-IA)
introduced companion legislation in
Senate
• The IRS opposes tax strategy patents
18. More Likely Than Not
• Congressmen Crowley (D-NY) and Ramstad
(R-MN) have legislation (H.R. 4318) to
equalize the taxpayer and tax preparer
standards at “substantial authority,” the
current taxpayer standard
• A bill is expected to be introduced in the
Senate shortly
• In Notice 2008-13, the IRS provided interim
guidance
19. Multi State Income Tax
Legislation
• Congressmen Hank Johnson (D-GA) and
Chris Cannon (R-NV) introduced
legislation to create uniform national
standards for state income tax
withholding for employees who work in a
state other than their residence for more
than 60 days per year
• AICPA submitted testimony at a hearing
in the House Judiciary Committee
• AICPA engaged in legislative campaigns
and may be reaching out to state
societies
20. •The current licensing of P.A.s results in a second tier
professional that is not functionally different than a CPA
• The public would benefit from the licensing of a second
tier of accounting professional who has proven ability
through education, examination, ethics and experience,
but is more limited in their scope of practice than a CPA.
• The second tier of licensing would be more meaningful
to the public and give them a true choice in the matter of
choosing a professional.
Tax Preparer Licensing – version 2.0
Oklahoma – HB 1752
21. Tax Preparer Licensing – Risk to
CPAs?
Unlicensed Accountants
Unlicensed accountants are using tax preparer
legislation as step to second-tier accounting license.
Accredited
Business
Accountant
Alert to State CPA Society Executives:
CPA
VS
24. MOBILITY
Score Card for 2008
• 24 States with mobility in place
• 12 States have 2008 Bills introduced
• 36 States have legislation passed or
introduced
• 7 State BOAs have voted to support
mobility
• 43 States in place, introducing Bills, or
voting to support
25. FASB and FAF Changes
• Changes to the oversight, structure, and
operations of the FAF, FASB, and GASB:
– FASB board reduced from 7 to 5
– Provides FASB chair more authority
– Secures stable mandatory funding source for
GASB
– Provides the GASB chair more authority to
set the agenda
• FAF appointments
• AICPA comment letter
26. U.S. GAAP Codification
• Jan. 15—FASB released Codification for
one-year verification period
• Codification
– Organizes thousands of pronouncements into
roughly 90 topics
– Doesn’t change GAAP
– More user-friendly set of standards
• Use the Codification in your daily work
and provide feedback to FASB
• Register at http://asc.fasb.org
28. AICPA Center for Audit
Quality Audit Committee
Survey
5% Fair
17%
Good
53%
Very
Good
25%
Excellent
Q9: Based on your experience as an audit committee member, how would you
rate the overall quality of audits publicly traded companies being conducted
today?
29. Peer Review Facilitated
State Board Access Pilot
• Ohio, Oklahoma, North Carolina, Texas,
Tennessee, and South Dakota piloted the
program
• Assessment of feedback is underway
• Implementation will be phased in over the
next 12 to 18 months
33. IFRS – International
Financial Reporting Standards
Not if but when…
Goodbye GAAP?
Think about this – If SEC timeline is 2013 – what year
do you have to convert to show three years of
comparable f/s?
35. Slide 35
IFRS: The Globalization of Financial Reporting
A simpler set of accounting
principles
About IFRS
IFRS:
• Standards
- IFRS: 8
- IAS: 29
• Interpretations
- IFRIC: 8
- SIC: 11
• Framework
US GAAP:
• Standards:
- SFAS: 106
- APB: 16
- ARB: 4
• Interpretations
- FSP: 49
- EITF: 108
- FIN: 27
• Concepts Statements: 6
• Other
- FTB: 32
- AICPA Interpretations: 6
- SOP: 51,
- AICPA Industry Audit and
Accounting Guides, SABs,
DIGs…
2,000 pages vs 25,000 pages
37. IFRS - Top 10
considerations for
transition preparation?
1. Investigate differences between IFRS and
U.S. GAAP
– Revenue recognition, taxes, hedge accounting
– Establish project teams to address top issues
– Review IASB agenda for critical projects
relevant to you
2. Be prepared with large expense
– Larger EU co. spent .05 % of revenues Year 1
– Upgrade IT systems and applications
38. Top 10 Considerations
continued….
3. Expect more disclosures during transition
– This may close the gap or more subjectivity
4. Identify contracts, grants, agreements,
etc. with requirements to provide U.S.
GAAP F/S
• Garner support from those charged with
governance and stakeholders early in the
process
6. Don’t train and educate too early (but do
so)
39. Top 10 Considerations
continued….
7. Outline governance and risk
management processes that will be used
during the transition
8. Make IFRS the basis for internal
reporting, budgets, etc.
9. Be open and transparent about pros &
cons of switch and
10.Ensure communications are clear and
consistent
43. What stuck out for you?
After the gathering and categorizing of major issues, we asked the group for
their reactions. One insight was that “systems” as an issue has dropped off the
list. The other “ahha” was the issues are very much the same for all levels and
types of organizations.
44. Emerging Issues from AICPA
Tom Foard discussed some of the leading issues he has seen from AICPA Business
& industry Executive Committee and CFO magazine. The group noted that these are
the same globally as well…
45. Source: 2007 Private Company Index Report by Entrex
Private Company Trends per CEOs
Lean
Operations
Workforce
46. Source: 2007 Private Company Index Report by Entrex
Private Company Trends per CEOs
Workforce
50. CFO Competencies
Needed
• Change
Management (C)
• Strategic Ability (S)
• Critical Thinking (S)
• Business
Perspective (C)
• Organizational
Agility (C)
• Dealing with
Ambiguity (S)
• Communication &
Leadership
• Strategic & Critical
Thinking
• Focus on the Customer,
Client, and Market
• Interpretation of
Converging Information
• Technologically adept
C – Catalyst
S - Strategist
53. 53
• Human Capital, Technical Training
(standards) and Succession related
issues top the lists
• Retention moves up by firm size
• Firms with 5 CPAs and under are less
focused on Succession, yet the most
vulnerable
• Firms 21+ are all Human Capital
Issues
PCPS Top MAP Issues
Bottom Line
54. 54
Top 10 Reasons to Join a Firm
0 20 40 60 80 100
Career Growth
PTO
Salary
Respect for Company Mission
Challenging Work
Healthcare
Atmosphere
Management Style
401k
Flexible Work
Top Talent Partner
55. 55
Finding Qualified Staff
• Your unique value proposition
• Incorporating newer team members in
Business Development
• A function of marketing
• Social functions
• Websites
• Team Recruitment Action Plan
56. Top 10 Reasons to Stay
0 20 40 60 80 100
Respect for Mission Statement
Career Growth
Salary
Management Style
Challenging Work
Flexible Work
PTO
Atmosphere
Equity Incentives
Training(tie)
401k(tie)
Top Talent Partner
57. Advancement – Partner Track
Top Talent Partners
Firm Has a Ptr
Track
31% 41%
Firm Does Not 37% 55%
Do Not Know 32% 4%
Who Thought Their Firm Had a Partner Track?
58. Advancement – Partner Level
Top Talent Responses
55%
23%
22% Firm Encourages
Them to Pursue Ptr
Status
Firm Does Not
Encourage
Pursuing Ptr Status
Don't Know if Firm
Encourages
59. Alternate Career Paths
• Many young professionals may not want the
partner track
• Most of the survey respondents agreed that
not pursuing a partner track does not have to
hurt your career
Top Talent Partners
Will not Hinder Young
CPA’s Career
65% 83%
Alternate Career Paths
are Available
50% 76%
60. Identify & Develop New
Partners
• Competency assessment
• Technical knowledge
• Client service development
• People development
• Leadership development
• Business Development
• Succession plan and communication
Don’t Miss the Emerging Partner Program at the MDBIZEXPO!
61. Identify & Develop New
Partners
• Give power and responsibility for all to do their
jobs autonomously
• Chart your firm’s skill sets (see PCPS Human
Capital Center for Firm Needs and Competency
assessment tools)
• Identify future potential
• Understand the difference between a top-notch
manager and a leader
• Mentor promising staff
• Get partners actively involved in mentoring and
client contact
• Include junior staff in decision making
62. Identify & Develop New
Partners
• Set the firm requirements for new
owners
• Provide formal leadership training for
appropriate members
• Set a timetable for new leadership
• Don’t underestimate the amount of time
it can take to groom a new partner
• Choose a managing partner that you see
as “the face of the firm”
• Create a compensation plan
Source: PREPARING FOR TRANSITION: The State of Succession
Planning and How to Handle the Process in Your Firm A White
Paper from the AICPA Private Companies Practice Section
(PCPS)
63. Why do I need a succession
plan?
• Consider these facts:
– In 1993, 47% of AICPA membership was over 40
years of age, in 2006, 74% of AICPA members
was over 40 years of age.
– The 2004 PCPS Succession Survey found that of
the nearly 500 firms surveyed, only 25% had a
documented succession plan in place, yet over
60% of the firms had owners in the 55-62 age
bracket.
– In 2008, PCPS updated the Succession Survey
and found that of the nearly 500 firms surveyed,
35% had a documented succession plan. A
marked improvement over 2004.
64. Why do I need a succession
plan?
• Based on current statistics, there will be more
sellers than buyers in the next 5-10 years.
• Succession is about MAP and client transition,
not multiples.
• Many practitioners feel the next generation is
not ready to lead the firm.
• The next generation is not sure they want to.
• Successful succession planning for a partner
takes about five years of preparation.
• Niche practices will have even greater
struggles.
65. Types of Succession
Strategies
• Position the firm for sale so the
owner(s) can retire.
• Position the firm for merger with an
eventual buyout of the original
owner(s).
• Position the firm for internal transition to
future leaders.
• Practice continuation with other firms.
• Turn out the lights at the end of the day.
66. General Succession Steps
1) Have the difficult conversations
2) Multiple partner firms, bring in a
consultant to facilitate
3) Determine the best succession
strategy, internal or external
4) Build the plan
69. Tom’s Top 5 Workplace Tips
1. Be the right person – versus the right
organization
2. Be specific and don’t assume anything
3. Define roles and career path (in easy
increments and steps)
4. Invest in training – it has high ROI, and is a
retention tool
5. Offer challenging work and reward even small
steps
72. SUPPORTS
CHALLENGES
VALUES
B O L D S T E P S
2. Legislative / PAC
1. Talent Mgmt/Human Capital Development
3. New / Young
Professionals
4. Financial Literacy
5. Regulation
• Competence
• Objectivity & Integrity
• Openness & member Involvement
• Professional Foresight
The MACPA is a progressive,
professional association dedicated
to serving CPAs in the Maryland
region, enabling them to grow,
prosper and remain viable in a
dynamic, rapidly changing
environment.
TechnologyStrategic
Alliances
Government
Relations
IMAGE
Organizational
Structure
Professional
Development
• Protect the Public Interest
• Responsiveness
2008 Priorities
73. Promoting the CPA License!
Filling the pipeline…
1. Student members
2. CPA Candidates
3. New/Young Professionals
4. Leadership Academy
1.
Recruit
Students
2.
Promote
CPA
License
4.
Fast
Track
Career
3.
Build
CPA
Skills
Issues addressed:
•Retention
•Recruitment
•Succession Planning
•Leadership
•Staffing
•Generational Issues
74. Legislative Success!
Pass Mobility
Opposed by DLLR
Opposed by Maryland Society of Accountants
Stop / Amend Maryland Individual Tax Preparer
Act
Amend Corporate reporting requirements
Repeal “Tech Tax” Sales Tax on Computer
Services
Prevent Sales Tax on Accounting & Tax Services
Stop trial lawyers efforts at repealing contributory
fault doctrine
76. Maryland Individual Tax
Preparers Act
• Requires registration and examination of all tax
preparers
• Registered Tax Preparers (cannot use terms
licensed or certified)
• CPAs and staff are exempt (along with other
Circ 230 Practitioners
• Out-of-state CPAs exempt
• Independent Regulatory Exam required
• Safe Harbor disclosure required
– “I am not a CPA”
• MACPA seat on State Board
77. Legislative Success!
Corporate Income Tax
Reporting
(amendments to SB 2)
Repeal Tech Tax
Prevent Sales Tax on
Services
Stop Comparative Fault
Over 500 Visits, e-mails, calls by our CPA members!
78. MD Rate 11.5%
What would happen if we
weren’t there?
"There's no strong voice of landscaping, computer services and arcade
owners. …that's one of the reasons they got picked.”
- former Senator Barbara Hoffman (commenting on the special
session where they passed the sales tax on computer services)
"An old adage among politicians
is that if you don't holler at tax-
raising time, you'll get hurt." –
Lou Panos
79. Audits of Employee Benefit
Plans
Ian Dingwall, CPA
Chief Accountant
US DOL
• Maryland Plan Assets $127.2 Billion
• Error Rate of 30% over 37 Firms
• Error is failing 1 or more of 10 GAAS
• MACPA Board oversight
• Sessions at EXPO
• DOL workshop
80. So what are we doing
about this?
• DOL Workshop
• SBA Strategic Alliance
• Intuit Partnership Workshops & Resources
• iTunes – Podcasts on breaking issues
• Blogs – CPA Success, New CPAs,
Legislative Insider, CPA Island
• Webcasts on breaking topics
• Learn, Connect, Grow at the
MDBIZEXPO!
81. SBA Strategic Alliance
• Sessions at the EXPO
• Workshops & Resources for CPAs
• Maryland Statistics
– 536,200 small businesses
– 141,700 employer firms
– Employ 53.3% of labor force
– Employing 1.1 million people
82. Intuit –
Future of Small Business Report
• Two sessions at the EXPO
– Future of Small Business
– What CPAs need to know about the future of
small business
• Workshop for CPAs to faciitate strategy
sessions with clients and prospects
86. “Web 2.0 generally refers to a second generation of
services available on the WWW that lets people
collaborate and share information online.” - Wikipedia.com
Shared Pictures =
Shared Knowledge =
Shared Bookmarks =
Shared News =
Shared Videos =
Shared Everything =
Web 2.0 & You
87. Web 2.0 continues to grow
Try this professional networking site
www.CPALEARNING2.com
www.linkedin.com
89. Promoting the CPA License!
Filling the pipeline…
1. Student members
2. CPA Candidates
3. New/Young Professionals
4. Leadership Academy
1.
Recruit
Students
2.
Promote
CPA
License
4.
Fast
Track
Career
3.
Build
CPA
Skills
Issues addressed:
•Retention
•Recruitment
•Succession Planning
•Leadership
•Staffing
•Generational Issues
90. 2. Promote the CPA license
• 150 Hours of Education
• Group I – 27 semester hours in
accounting subjects
– Auditing (3 hours)
– Managerial Accounting (3 hours)
– US Federal Income Tax (3 hours)
– Financial Accounting (9 hours)
– Accounting Electives (9 hours)
Maryland Educational requirement
Uniform & Flexible
91. 2. Promote the CPA license
• Group II - 21 semester hours in business subjects (at least
five of the following subjects:
– Economics
– Statistics
– Corporation or business finance
– Management
– US Business Law
– Marketing
– Business Communication
• Ethics – Business, accounting, philosophy of ethics or a
course that examines a framework for ethical decision
making
Uniform & Flexible
Maryland Educational requirement
92. What are the four parts of the “new” CPA
Exam?
1. Auditing & Attestation
2. Business Environment Concepts
3. Financial Accounting & Reporting
4. Regulation
The “New” CPA exam
update
93. CPA Exam changes
• Paper-based
• 2 x year May &
November
• 5 sections
• Computerized
• Anytime
• 2 months per quarter
• Pass all sections in 18
months (to keep passed
sections)
• 4 sections
• 70% new content!
Then: Now:
update
94. 2. Promote the CPA license
Next date : June 17, 2008
At the Maryland Business & Accounting Expo
Maryland DLLR Swearing-in of new CPAs
95. What you can do to promote the
CPA?
• Understand the “new” CPA Exam
• Encourage MACPA candidate
membership
• Use CPA Exam tracking tool to track
employees progress
• Support the swearing-in ceremony
• Create / reinforce firm/company culture
that celebrates CPAs
96. 3. New / Young Professionals
NYPN All member holiday party
Maryland Zoo (in Baltimore)
TBA
“CPE - Certified Penguin Extravaganza”
97. Protect your license &
Differentiating the CPA
• BBJ Supplement
• Smart CEO
• Articles & PR
• Managing our Brand
98. Achieve! Top CPE in Nation
• Public Seminars, Chapters
& Committees
• In-house Training
• Business Learning Institute
• MACPA1040 Fast Track
“it’s better than Gear-Up!”
• Self-study – AICPA CPE
Express
99. Achieve! Member resources
MACPA’s Trusted Partners
• Provident Banking
• RJP Insurance
• AON
• Purchasing Power of the profession
– Savings of up to 70% off!
100. Maryland Business and
Accounting Expo
• 90+ sessions
• $250 for two days of CPE
• 100+ sponsors and providers
• National Thought Leaders on every topic
101. What is a Profession?
Professions enjoy a high social status, regard
and esteem conferred upon them by society.
This high esteem arises primarily from the
higher social function of their work, which is
regarded as vital to society as a whole and thus
of having a special and valuable nature.
Source: Wikipedia
102. What is a Profession?
All professions involve technical, specialized
and highly skilled work. Training for this work
involves obtaining degrees and professional
qualifications without which entry to the
profession is barred. Training also requires
regular updating of skills.
Maryland CPAs are required to achieve the 4 E’s to qualify for
licensure
1. Education – bachelor’s degree + 30 hours
2. Examination – Pass the Uniform CPA Exam
3. Ethics – Maryland requires a separate ethics exam
4. Experience – 1 year of experience working with a CPA
Thereafter, they are required to complete 80 hours of continuing
education every two years, including four hours of ethics
training.
Source: Wikipedia
104. Conclusion
“Greatness is not an unblemished
record. It's the ability to right yourself,
to go through the 'valley of the shadow
of death' and come out even stronger.
To be built to last, you have to be built
to change. You can't possibly be static
— it is a dynamic world. You have to
change what you do to preserve what
you are.”
Jim Collins – author of Good to Great
Enduring -
105. What STuck out
for you?
Questions & Discussion
Learning Questions
Feedback Form
And a look again at how we look today, with a future glance into ’08 and beyond
*NOTE* Please check with the AiCPA Staff to ensure this is the current information
This is the current status –
10 States have now achieved “no notification” – consistent with the newly revised UAA Section 23 language… As you will see from the map, the ’07 legislative sessions began with 4 states – OH (’61), VA(99), MO (02) and WI (06). Six states have been added to the “gold states” thus far in ’07 and included are 4 additional states that had or still have ongoing legislative activity. Additionally, there are 3 states that have taken first steps in achieving full-no-notification mobility.
Able to give and exchange information within meaningful context and with appropriate delivery and interpersonal skills. Able to influence, inspire, and motivate others to achieve results.
Able to link data, knowledge, and insight together to provide quality advice for strategic decision-making. Able to anticipate and meet the changing needs of clients, employers, customers, and markets better than competitors. Able to interpret and provide a broader context using financial and non-financial information.
Able to utilize and leverage technology in ways that add value to clients, customers and employers.
What concerns are keeping your competitors up at night? Are firms like yours experiencing the same trends that you are? And are there any challenges facing other practices that you have avoided so far but that might be looming down the road?
The 2007 PCPS Top MAP Issues Survey is designed to answer those questions. It takes the pulse of current practice, questioning firms around the country about the problems that are of greatest concern to them. This year, technical complexity and finding and retaining qualified staff were among the top practice management issues facing CPAs in smaller firms. However, by examining the top issues broken down by firm size, it’s possible to glimpse an interesting picture of public practice today.
The PCPS Top MAP Issues Survey gathers information from a broad spectrum of practitioners in firms of various sizes to profile the most critical challenges facing PCPS members. For the first time this year, PCPS is not issuing one overall Top MAP Issues list. That’s because it was determined that averaging the answers from many different types of firms does not necessarily accurately mirror the concerns of each segment. Instead, PCPS is releasing five separate Top MAP Issues lists that reflect the views of CPAs who are sole practitioners and those in firms with two to five professionals, six to ten professionals, 11 to 20 professionals and more than 21 professionals.
To summarize, the MAP Top Issues for 2007 deal with Human Capital issues, Technical training issues in staying up on new regs and standards and succession issues, whether developing a plan or developing new partners to replace the older partners.
One critical concern is that succession didn’t make it on the sole practitioner list and barely made it at number 10 on the 2-5 CPAs. Both categories have the greatest risk since it’s less likely to grow someone from the inside, the number of succession options become limited.
The PCPS Top Talent Study: Gaining a Strategic Advantage in Recruiting and Retention
PCPS conducted a new “Top Talent Study,” in 2006, much like a similar landmark study performed in 2000. In this initiative, CPA firm partners asked their most highly valued nonpartner employees to take a survey that examined, among other things, their hopes for growth opportunities, job benefits and firm culture, and how these elements affected their decisions to join or stay with a firm. For comparison purposes, PCPS also asked partners to offer their opinions on the importance of all the same issues in hiring and retention.
good news for the profession and all that it has to offer young professionals is the fact that 63% of the top talent in this survey said they had no plans to change careers in the next five years, while 29% didn’t know. That means that roughly two-thirds of promising young CPAs expect to stick with accounting, and nearly another one-third can still be influenced to remain in the profession. That’s a good indication that these professionals clearly believe a great future is possible in accounting.
At the same time, partners are much more in tune with their staff than in 2000, when the last Top Talent survey was conducted. Based on the results of that survey, there were great differences between what employees sought and what their firms were offering. In many cases, firms in 2000 also appeared to be investing in programs that were not high on the staff members’ list of priorities. But the gap in understanding, which was so evident in 2000, has narrowed significantly today, the most recent data show.
However, while firm leaders may generally be aware of promising younger staff members’ expectations, other AICPA research raises questions about whether they have taken concrete steps to meet those expectations. For example, in the Top Talent study, 76% of the young CPAs said they were interested in being groomed for a senior position. Another recent PCPS study of firm staffing policies found, however, that 93% of the practices surveyed did not have a leadership development program, 90% did not have a career professional program and 89% did not have a partner-in-training program. Such programs can reassure ambitious staff members about the career opportunities within a firm and clarify firms’ expectations.
Here are the top talents’ top 10 reasons to join a firm:
Career growth opportunities: 80%
Paid personal/vacation time: 79%
Salary: 78%
Respect for company mission statement: 73%
Interesting, challenging projects: 71%
Medical benefits: 70%
Comfortable office atmosphere: 69%
Open door/accessible management style: 68%
Retirement savings plan: 67%
Flexible work schedule: 65%
In comparison, the partners’ top reason was Salary at 93% followed by Heathcare at 83% and Paid Time Off at 79%. The good news for firms is Salary isn’t the top reason for joining a firm. While important and firms need to be within a market range, its not the primary reason. Firms should note that item 7, Management style at 68% for Top Talent, it wasn’t even in the top 20 in the opinion of partners. Firms should develop a Unique Selling Proposition for recruits that address the top 10 according to Top Talent.
The top talent’s top 10 reasons to stay with a firm:
Respect for company mission statement: 93%
Career growth opportunities: 92%
Salary: 89%
Open-door/accessible management style: 89%
Interesting/challenging projects: 88%
Flexible work schedule: 88%
Paid personal/vacation time: 86%
Comfortable office atmosphere: 83%
Equity incentives: 79%
Retirement savings plan: 78% (tied)
Training/professional development opportunities: 78% (tied)
In comparison, the partners top reasons were Salary: 91%,Career growth opportunities: 90%,Respect for company mission statement: 88%. Again partner opinions put salary at the top, while its third on the list for top talent. Again, paying market rate is important, but other factors are equally important in retention. The two areas with the greatest difference between top talent and partners are Management Style and Equity Incentives with each having a 20 point difference between the two groups. Firms may find that differences between top talent and the style of managers may have a greater impact on losing talent. Its important for firms to work with personalities within the practice and try to manage teams to reduce conflict.
As previously noted, career growth was number one on the Top Talent’s list of reasons to join a firm and number two on their list of reasons to stay with a firm.
Top Talent Insight: When it comes to promotion and advancement, there were several apparent disconnects of which partners should be aware:
First, among the top talent, 31% said their firms had a partner track, 37% said their firms did not and 32% weren’t sure. Among the partners, 41% said their firms had one, 55% said they did not and 4% did not know. Partners may have to communicate better about the existence of a career track and how it works in their firm.
Top Talent Questionnaire question – Does your firm have a “partner track” in place?
Third, 55% of the top talent said their firms encouraged them to pursue possible partner status, 23% said they didn’t and 22% didn’t know. Compare that with the partner responses: 81% believe their firms encourage promising people to become partners. Perhaps this message is not being expressed forcefully enough.
Top Talent Questionnaire question – Does management encourage you to pursue possible partner status?
Top Talent Insight: 59% of the young professionals surveyed agreed or strongly agreed that their job stress was high. However, there’s good news for those who don’t want to move up the career ladder and, perhaps, experience more stress. Many of the top talent believe that it’s possible to remain with a firm even if they don’t want to become owners. In one healthy sign, 65% of respondents did not believe it hindered their career if they did not want to become partner. Only 9% thought it did, and 27% weren’t sure. Once again, a communications effort might be in order, since 83% of partners said this decision will not hinder someone’s career. In the same vein, 50% of top talent said there were alternative career paths for those who did not want to be partner, while 33% weren’t sure. Among partners, 76% believed their firms offered alternative career paths.
Firms can and should offer paths other than firm ownership. And clearly, firms should communicate all available options to their employees early before their talent seek the ideal opportunity elsewhere.
Top Talent Questionnaire questions:
– I would consider my job high-stress. (scale of 1-5)
-- If you are not interested in becoming a partner, does that hinder your professional success there?
-- Are there alternatives career paths available at your firm for those who did not aspire to be partner?
Here is some advice for all of us that have anguished over the events of the past year as our Profession has gotten bruised and battered. This is the closing slide we use at our town hall meetings and captures the fellings of this task force.