SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
EDUC 5508 – Integrated Studies from K-7: Science Focus 
Assignment 1 -Children’s View of Science 
Introduction 
Overview 
The aim of this assignment was to determine the prior knowledge of two children regarding 
a particular science topic. The data collected was interpreted and compared to literature 
regarding alternative conceptions. From this data appropriate activities were chosen to 
address the alternative conceptions. 
Importance of Obtaining Prior Knowledge 
When students arrive in the science classroom they are not empty vessels waiting to be 
filled with information, instead students have already created their own explanations for 
many scientific concepts (Baxter, 1991). They will have observed or experienced a number 
of scientific phenomena to create their own ideas and beliefs about why something 
happens; this is called everyday concept formation (Cutter-Mackenzie & Logan, 2013). It is 
important that science lessons makes links to these everyday science concepts so that 
students remain engaged and can see the reasons behind studying science. By obtaining 
prior knowledge teachers can find out what is relevant to students and teach topics 
students will be able to engage with (Cutter-Mackenzie & Logan, 2013). 
Learning a child’s prior knowledge also allows teachers to identify a student’s alternative 
conceptions. These are the beliefs and explanations developed through their own 
experiences that are different from the accepted scientific concepts (Cutter-Mackenzie & 
Logan, 2013). Once these alternative concepts have been identified lessons can be planned 
to target them. As Ausubel declared “the most important single factor influencing learning is 
what the learner already knows. Ascertain this and teach him appropriately” (Ausubel cited 
in Garbett, 2013). This also adheres to the constructivist theories like those of Piaget who 
stated that prior knowledge is what children use to make sense of new information. 
According to Piaget, people assimilate information by making it fit into what they already 
know or they accommodate new ideas by adjusting their way of thinking. If the information
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
is too unfamiliar people have a tendency to just ignore it (Piaget cited in Woolfolk & 
Margett, 2013). If students distort the information by trying to make it fit or simply ignore 
new information this will negatively impact their education. As such the teacher needs to 
comprehend that prior knowledge could be acting as a constraint to learning new scientific 
concepts (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). If teachers are aware of what the student already 
knows they will know whether these new ideas will fit or if other methods will have to be 
used to assist in the students learning. 
Once it is established what a student already knows a teacher can use this information to 
assist in planning the rest of the topic. A teacher does not want to reteach what has already 
been taught in previous years or leave gaps in the topic areas. Also if a teacher is aware of 
what a student already knows they are able to shape activities to suit child capabiliti es. This 
is important as if the concept/topic is too hard the student will become disengaged and 
unmotivated. However if it is too easy then the student can become bored which in turn can 
lead to behavioural issues (Hunt cited in Woolfolk & Margett, 2013). It should be 
remembered that determining a student’s prior knowledge is also part of knowing your 
students which is a vital part of adhering to the professional standards of graduate teachers 
(TRBWA, 2014). 
Science topic selected 
The topic selected for this assignment is the night/day cycle, a year 3 topic included in the 
earth and space sciences section of the national curriculum. Although this may seem an easy 
topic there are a number of alternative conceptions that are held by both young children 
(and adults) regarding the causes for day and night (Skamp, 2004). 
Details of children interviewed 
Two students were interviewed for this assignment. The first was a year three student who 
will be referred to as Jennifer. The second was a year two student who has recently turned 
seven; her pseudonym for the sake of this assignment will be Sophie.
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
Day and Night 
The reasons for day and night have been considered for thousands of years. To comprehend 
the science conception behind night and day there needs to be an understanding that the 
earth is spherical, it revolves around the sun and it rotates on its axis . 
Earth is believed to have been formed 4.56 billion years ago (Rees, 2005) and although the 
earth is depicted as a perfect sphere (see fig.1) the earth actually bulges around the equator 
due to the centrifugal forces as the earth rotates (Sanders & Gatehouse, 2004). 
Figure 1: The Blue marble (Reto Stöckli, 2002) 
Earth is the third closest planet to the sun and revolves around the sun (Williamson & 
Garton, 2011). As shown by the illustration in figure 2, the sun is at the centre of the solar 
system with the planets following an orbit around the sun. 
Figure 2: The inner solar system on 19 September 2008 (Lomb, 2008)
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
For centuries it had been believed that the earth was the centre of the universe. The sun, 
moon and planets all revolved around the earth creating a geocentric model (see fig. 3). This 
was based on Ptolemy’s theories outlined in the Almagest (Rees, 2005). 
Figure 3: Ptolemy’s system of orbits from The Celestial Atlas published in 1660-61 (Rees, 
2005) 
In 1543 Nicolaus Capernicus wrote a paper describing the universe as heliocentric; all the 
planets revolved around the sun (see fig. 4). This paper revolutionised how astrologers 
studied space and the reasons for night and day. 
Figure 4: A map produced by Copernicus in 1543 to show the earth and planets circling the 
sun (Rees, 2005)
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
Once it is understood that the earth revolves around the sun we can determine the reason 
for the day/night cycle. As well as revolving around the sun the earth also rotates on its axis. 
This axis is an imaginary line that runs through the centre of the earth from pole to pole at 
angle of 23.5 degrees. This axis always points to the same place in space called the South 
Celestial pole (William & Garton, 2011). The earth spins at 1700km/h, however, people do 
not notice because everything is moving at this speed. The only way that we would notice 
the spinning would be if the speed were to suddenly change or we were to stop spinning 
(Williamson & Garton, 2011). As the earth spins most locations on the earth will pass from 
shadow to daylight creating the day/night cycle (Rees,2005). The side of the earth facing the 
sun will be in the sunlight which would be day time and the areas facing away from the sun 
would be in shadow creating night time (see fig. 5). 
Figure 5: The day/night cycle (Science encyclopaedia for kids, 2014). 
Every day the earth rotates once however there are two definitions for what is considered a 
day. A solar day lasts for 24 hours which is the length of time the sun takes to return to the 
highest point in the sky from the same point the previous day (Rees,2005). A sidereal day is 
the earth’s rotation in relation to the stars; it is the time it takes a star to return to its 
highest point. This is four minutes shorter than a solar day (Rees, 2005).
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
Figure 6: Solar and Sidereal day (Rees, 2005) 
The difference in time between the two definitions is because the earth has to turn a little 
further in order for the sun to reach the same point (see fig. 6) (Rees, 2005). 
In the southern hemisphere the longest day of the year happens on the 22nd December and 
is called the Summer Solstice. Then on the 22nd June the shortest day occurs, and is called 
the winter solstice. The opposite occurs in the northern hemisphere (Williamson & Garton, 
2011). 
Due to the rotation of the earth the sun seems to move across the sky from east to west 
(see fig.7). 
Figure 7: The sun’s apparent movement across the sky (BBC Bitesize, 2014).
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
This movement across the sky allowed for sundials to tell the time as the shadow projected 
by an object would move as well, this shadow can be used indicate the time(Bely et al, 
2010). It is this apparent movement from east to west, however, that may be the root of 
some alternative conceptions. 
Alternative Conceptions regarding day and night 
There are a number of alternative conceptions for the causes of day/night as the day/night 
cycle is something that all children can observe with their own eyes. They see the sun out 
during the day and the darkness at night. To explain the day turning into night some 
children believe that the sun goes behind the clouds (Allen, 2010),or behind the hills (Baxter 
cited in Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994) the sun simply moves out into space (Vosniadou & 
Brewer, 1994). Disappearance/appearance is something many young children are familiar 
with. Babies and toddlers are introduced to the concept early on by often playing games 
such as ‘peek-a-boo’. As such, they may accept the notion that things can just appear and 
disappear (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). 
If children have not observed the movement of the sun across the sky they may also believe 
that the sun and moon rise up and down (Allen, 2010). This alternative conception is quite 
often link with the alternative conception of the earth being flat. Therefore students must 
comprehend that the earth is a sphere before they can even begin to understand the 
scientific explanation for day/night (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). Vosniadou and Brewer 
refer to these types of conceptions as initial mental models, as they are based solely on the 
child’s observations (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). 
As mentioned in the previous section the apparent movement of the sun from east to west 
can cause students to believe that the sun moves around the earth (Allen, 2010). This 
alternative conception was actually the widely held belief for hundreds of years, so it is 
understandable to see why children will have the same idea. Children have to be able to 
understand that the sun remains stationary in relation to the earth which is spinning around 
the sun. Once they understand this they can then understand why the rotation of the earth 
would then cause day/night (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994).
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
Another alternative conception involves the moon blocking the sun at night and the 
opposite during the day (Allen, 2010). This links to the belief that the moon only comes out 
at night (Allen, 2010). The idea of the moon only coming out at night is not surprising as 
many children’s picture books show the moon wearing a night cap in the night sky (Allen, 
2010). Some children also believe that the sun and moon swap places (Allen, 2010). A 
similar idea is that the moon and the sun are both fixed in position and as the earth rotates 
we see one or the other. This mixes the scientific fact of the earth rotating and the 
alternative conception of a stationary moon (Allen, 2010). These conceptions could be a 
result of the fact that it is very rare to see a picture with the moon out in the daytime, and 
many children may never have looked for the moon during the day. It is also claimed that 
literature about night and day often does not explain explicitly what the moon is doing in 
relation to the day/night cycle (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). These last few conceptions are 
referred to as synthetic mental models as although not being scientifically correct they do 
show have to some level of scientific knowledge such as knowing the earth is a sphere or 
that the earth rotates (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). 
The causes for these alternative conceptions can be due a number of things including 
personal experience, the impact of the media, as well as religious and cultural backgrounds 
of the individual. For example an Aboriginal theory from Yolungo peoples of the northern 
territories believed that the Walu the sun woman lit a fire every morning and carried the 
torch from east to west then extinguished the torch every evening. She would then journey 
underground throughout the night to return to the morning camp. The sunsets and sunrises 
were caused by spilling ochre on the clouds (Norris, 2008). Children would use this story to 
explain what they see. This type of belief is not only restricted to aboriginals but many other 
cultures as well. Some studies have even found many different cultures across the world 
have similar theories for astrological events (Skamp, 2004). Although not matched with 
current scientific theories teachers must be still be sensitive of religious and cultural beliefs.
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
Procedure 
Selection of children 
Before selecting the students it was decided that space and more specifically the reason we 
have day and night would be the topic discussed. Therefore it was appropriate to choose a 
child who was in year three, which is when this topic is part of the national curriculum. It 
was then decided that a participant from a lower year would provide a good comparison as 
they would not covered the topic in school and may have different ideas as to why we have 
night and day. 
Ethical Issues 
To ensure that there were no ethical issues, whilst organising the interview it was explained 
to the parents what we expected from their children. It was explained that there would be 
three interviewers who would ask the children to draw a picture which would be followed 
by some questions about space. We also asked permission to create audio recordings of the 
conversation. Once arriving for the interview the parents were asked to read through an 
information sheet and sign a permission form (see Appendix A & B). It was not only the 
parent’s permission that needed to be collected, however, the child also had to provide 
informed assent. The 1989 Convention on the rights of the child stresses the importance of a 
child’s right to make decisions that affect their lives (Einsardóltir, 2007). As such, the 
children also received an explanation about what was happening and why they were being 
interviewed using terms they would understand. It was also made clear that the children 
could stop the interview at any time. To avoid any issues that could be caused by inequality 
in the relationship between the child and the interviewer it was arranged that the main 
interviewer was someone the child new well. Jennifer was a close family friend to one of the 
interviewers and Sophie was a child who the interviewer had met on numerous occasions. 
Since there was already relationships formed between the interviewer and child before the 
research commenced it was hoped that the child would not only feel comfortable enough to 
say stop, but also feel comfortable to enough to share their ideas. 
Another ethical issue would be the confidentiality of the data, as participants data should be 
respected and protected (Einsardóltir, 2007). It was made clear that audio recording would
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
be deleted upon completion of the assignment and any data gathered would only be shared 
by members of the group and the assessors of the assignment. It was also made clear that in 
the report they would be given pseudonyms. 
Data collection methods 
Data was collected from the children through a recorded conversation. To begin with the 
students were asked to draw a picture of a person in daytime and then draw a picture of a 
person at night time (See Appendix C & D). They were then asked to describe the picture 
and were asked questions about their drawings such as; how do we know it is daytime? 
What can they see? What can they smell? And what can they hear? They were then asked to 
add words to the picture to describe day and then night (See Appendix C & D). This was to 
ensure they knew what day and night were. 
The students were then asked a number of focus questions about day and night. The 
students were provided with a small ball that looked like the earth and a larger yellow ball 
which they were told could represent the sun. It was explained that they could use these to 
help explain their answers. The questions included: 
What do you think causes day and night? 
What happens to the sun at night? 
What happens to the moon during the day? 
What do we mean by sun set? 
What do we mean by sunrise? 
When you are sleeping, is someone on the other side of the world sleeping? 
For both interviews there was a main interviewer with two secondary interviewers 
observing the child’s behaviour. The main interviewer would use constant words of support 
to encourage the child to share and expand their ideas. They were never told an idea was 
incorrect instead it was made clear that all ideas were valued.
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
Results 
Day/Night drawings 
The first activity the children were asked to do was a picture of day and night. Both children 
portrayed daytime with the sun shining and a person outside. For night time both children 
drew the moon in the night sky, with a person inside (See Appendix C & D). Jennifer drew a 
person in bed sleeping and Sophie drew a house with someone looking out the window. 
After they had finished the picture the conversation that followed is summarised in the 
table below (see table 1). A full copy of the transcript can be found in the appendix (see 
Appendix E & F). 
Jennifer Sophie 
Day time drawing 
How do we know it is day 
time? 
Because the sun is out. Because the sun is up and it 
is not dark. 
What do you see in the day 
time? 
You can play sport. 
What does day time smell 
like? 
Nothing. Nothing. 
What does it sound like? Birds, teachers talking. Birds. 
How does it make you feel? Happy. 
Night time drawing 
What do you see? Pitch black but can see the 
moon and stars. 
Moon and stars. Its dark and 
nothings around. 
What do you hear? Nothing, I’m asleep but 
sometimes hear my baby 
sister crying. 
Mozzies and nocturnal 
creatures. 
Does night time have a 
smell? 
No. 
Does everyone sleep at night 
time? 
Not nocturnal creatures or 
some people. 
Yes. 
Table 1: Table summarising day/night drawing discussion.
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
From this discussion it is clear that both children understand the dif ference between day 
time and night time. The day is light because of the sun and the night time is dark and they 
are able to see the moon and the stars. 
Interview about the day/night cycle 
The children were then asked the focus questions. The two interviews have been 
summarised in the following table (See table. 2). 
Jennifer Sophie 
When shown the balls the student could: 
Recognise small 3D globe as 
the earth 
Yes Yes 
Locate Australia on the globe Yes Yes 
Recognise the larger yellow 
Yes No 
ball as the sun. 
Students answers to the focus questions: 
What causes day and night? The earth turns around and 
when the earth turns away 
from the sun it turns to the 
moon. When the earth 
doesn’t see the sun it goes 
dark. 
The sun and the moon spin 
around the earth slowly 
swapping places. 
Later in the conversation 
The sun goes behind the 
moon. 
If Australia is in day time is 
everyone in day time? 
No, England is 8 hours 
behind. 
No, at different times the 
sun goes around the world. 
When the moon comes up 
the sun goes up on the other 
side. 
What happens to the sun at 
night? 
Nothing it stays. Well the sun 
does move but at night it 
stays there and the earth 
rotates. 
As the moon comes up the 
sun goes down. 
What happens to the moon At night we see the moon The moon goes behind the
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
during the day? and during the day we see 
the sun and other countries 
see the moon. 
sun. 
Have you seen the moon 
during the day? 
Yes, since its morning you 
can still faintly see it. 
No 
Describe sunrise Demonstrates with the balls. 
The earth is starting to tilt so 
its going down for Australia 
but coming up for other 
countries. 
The sun is going down and 
the moon is going up. 
Describe sunset Demonstrates with the balls 
the sun rising for Australia. 
The sun is going down. 
Does the sun move? Only for the seasons. Earth stays in the same spot 
and the sun moves around 
the earth. 
Does the moon move? No. It stays where it is. Yes. The sun and moon 
switch spots. 
Table 2: Table summarising answers to the focus questions. 
Jennifer also mentioned a solar system craft project she was making with her mum. When 
questioned she revealed that the solar system is ‘everything’. She described it as everything 
that goes round the sun including the earth and other planets. She could also name other 
planets and recognise that they were different sizes. 
It should be mentioned that if the interview was performed again it would have been 
beneficial to ask the students to draw their conception, as well as using the balls to describe 
what they are saying. Drawings would have given a greater insight and may have discovered 
further alternative conceptions. Also, by using the balls the interviewers had assumed that 
students new the earth was a sphere and could actually have caused some alternative 
conceptions to be missed.
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
Interpretation and comparison to literature 
Using these results we are able to see quite clearly that both children interviewed have very 
different alternative conceptions. Jennifer was able to correctly identify the science 
conception that the earth rotates and revolves around the sun but still held other 
alternative conceptions. Jennifer’s main alternative conceptions included the fact that she 
believed the sun moved for the seasons and that the moon remained stationary. On the 
whole Jennifer seemed quite knowledgeable about the subject of the solar system but 
would benefit from having a few topics clarified. Jennifer is originally from the United 
Kingdom and still has family living in England and Scotland so was able to use this 
knowledge regarding different time-zones and for her understanding that if it was day in 
Australia it would be night the other side of the globe (Sharp & Sharp, 2007). 
Sophie on the other hand believed that the sun moved and the earth remained in the same 
position which is a common alternative conception. There also seemed to be some 
confusion about whether the sun went around or up and down. She also seemed unsure 
about the moon blocking the sun at night and vice versa during the day. The idea that the 
sun and moon swap places was also an alternative conception that arose from the 
interview. Sophie’s almost contradictory answers are not unusual in astrology and she may 
have been trying to work out her ideas as she was explaining them (Baxter, 1994). Sophie 
did however show some scientific views as well, as she did explain that the moon did not 
remain stationary. One thing that we should bear in mind is that Sophie is younger than 
Jennifer so is therefore bound to have different alternative conceptions. 
A number of alternative conceptions mentioned in the literature became apparent from the 
interview with Jennifer and Sophie. Jennifer’s main alternative conception about the sun 
moving for the seasons has appeared in the literature (Allen, 2010) however is not directly 
linked to day/night so was not discussed previously. Jennifer’s conception that the moon 
remains stationary was one of the alternative views discussed by the literature. As 
previously stated this could be due to the fact the moon is not discussed when referring to 
the day/night cycle so students are unsure how it is involved (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). 
Sophie displayed a number of the conceptions that were mentioned in the literature. She 
held the alternative conception that the sun went around the earth (Allen, 2010). Sophie’s
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
geocentric model is not unusual for children her age (Skamp, 2010). She is unable to feel the 
earth spinning therefore is not likely to deduce that the earth is rotating. Instead she 
believes the sun is moving which is most likely due to observing the sun move across the 
sky. She was also adamant that the moon did not ever come out during the day. This could 
explain why she thinks the sun and moon must swap places or that the moon blocks the sun 
(Allen, 2010). 
Both students were using synthetic mental models, as there was a mixture of accepted 
science concepts and student observation that created their ideas about the day/night cyle 
(Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). Neither of the children revealed any new alternative 
conceptions that had not been mentioned in the literature studied. 
Rationale for teaching to these alternative conceptions 
The main point that came from both of the interviews was the alternative conception 
regarding the movement of the sun. Jennifer believed that the sun moved nearer and 
further to the earth to create the seasons, whereas Sophie believed the sun moved around 
the earth. Therefore the position and movement of the sun would be the main alternative 
conception to be addressed. Although the sun does rotate it stays the same distance from 
the earth and the earth actually rotates around the sun (Rees, 2005). 
The first activity choosen would be the shoe box model activity. Students would colour the 
inside of a shoebox black. The student would then draw a picture of Australia on a 
polystyrene ball, this would represent the earth. The student would then place a pipe 
cleaner through a polystyrene ball and attach the pipe cleaners to the edge of the box that 
has view holes cut out from the top and side of the box. A strong light source would then 
shine on the polystyrene earth. Students should then be able to see the line of shadow for 
when day end and night begins. The student can then turn the pipe cleaner to show how the 
earth rotates creating day and night across the globe (Howitt, Blake, Zadnik, 2010). Not only 
would students be able to see that the light source (the sun) does not move but they would 
also understand that the earth is rotating. During the discussion, however, the teacher 
should explain that the theory that the sun went around the earth causing day and night is 
not a completely outlandish idea. The students should understand that for hundreds of 
years this was the widely held belief. If students know this they can be made to feel better
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
about their own alternative conceptions (Baxter, 1991). This can help reduce any negative 
association children may have about science. 
The second activity to target this alternative conception would be for students to physically 
enact the day and night cycle. Students working in pairs would create their own homemade 
globes using a template (Silverston, 2014). They will attach wire to the top of the globe so 
they are able to spin. Once they have made the globes, in a darkened classroom one 
member of the pair would shine a strong light source at the globe whilst the other person 
spins the globe. The person hold the light source must stay on the same spot to show how it 
is the earth spinning causes day and night not the sun. The teacher should then ask the 
students which way they should spin the globe to promote discussion and allow students to 
share ideas. This is very similar to the previous activity just on a larger scale but gives the 
students a chance to really compound their knowledge. If students are still having trouble 
understanding that the sun remains in the same spot more time can be spent on this, 
however, if students understand the concept, the teacher could introduce the movement 
around the sun. The student holding the globe can place it on his/her head and spin around 
whilst revolving around the person holding the light source. The teacher should emphasise 
that the sun does not move from its spot even though it does rotate. 
Both these activities are very hands on and use physical models. Physical models are tools 
that allow the science concept to be explored at a deeper level and are vital for cognitive 
development (Vygotsky cited in Woolfolk & Margetts, 2013). Having the children physically 
create or act out the concept is more effective than just telling the students the scientific 
concept and hoping it sinks in. In some cases, simply telling students facts often results in 
students creating hybrid between their alternative conception and the scientific 
conception(Gilbert et al cited in Baxter, 1991). Teachers should also be aware that children 
want to protect their original idea so they need to provide the opportunities to discover and 
try out new theories and then be able to back them up with evidence (Baxter, 1991). Being 
actively involved in the learning creates ownership of these new ideas and therefore are 
more likely to replace the old concepts with these new ideas. 
Both activities would hopefully engage the student’s interest and then retain the student’s 
interest through to the next concept within that topic. If the student is engaged in the
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
activity they are more motivated are more likely to be able to recall information (Skamp, 
2004). These activities are also tailor made to concentrate on the specific alternative 
concept revealed by the interview. Studies have shown that students who received targeted 
teaching showed significant improvement within that topic (Diakidou & Kendeou, 2001). So 
with these targeted activities student’s knowledge of space should be increased. 
Since both of these activities use visual models to help explain the causes of day/night, the 
teacher must be careful not to confuse the students further, as students may not 
understand what the model is actually representing (Skamp, 2004). To avoid any confusions 
the teacher must be able to predict what students may incorrectly focus upon and redirect 
the attention to the concept they are trying to explain (Frazier cited in Skamp, 2004). This 
also links to the importance of social discussion and teacher scaffolding when doing these 
activities (Vygotsky cited in Woolfolk & Margetts, 2013). As students discuss ideas with their 
peers and the teachers, they begin to understand more about the concept and how it links 
to other concepts within the topic (Skamp, 2004). 
Reflection 
Reporting 
The purpose of this report was to identify the importance of using prior knowledge to 
determine a child’s alternative conceptions . These conceptions can then be addressed with 
activities designed to challenge these alternative conceptions and replace them with 
scientific conceptions. 
Responding 
What surprised me was the number of alternative conceptions students could have about a 
single scientific topic and how if they are not addressed directly, they can restrict the 
learning process of the students. 
Relating 
The attainment of knowledge about a topic is a gradual process and as such alternative 
models change over time. Students begin with an initial mental model based on 
observations then over time, as they learn more, they create synthetic mental models that
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
reflect both observations and scientific models until finally arriving at the fully formed 
scientific mental model (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). If the student believes the world is flat 
(initial model) there is no way they can comprehend the reason for day/night (rotation of a 
spherical earth). As such, initial and synthetic models can be seen to act as a barrier to 
learning. Students can also become protective of their ideas and become resistant to other 
explanations, which once again negatively impacts on their learning process (Driver, 1989). 
If the alternative conceptions are identified and teacher then tailers a teaching program to 
question these beliefs students are more likely to progress through the subject. Studies 
have shown that students who received targeted teaching showed significant improvement 
when compared to students who were just following the stages of a textbook (Diakidou & 
Kendeou, 2001). 
Reasoning 
After completing this assignment I now comprehend why there is an emphasis on getting to 
know your students and listening to their ideas and beliefs . An important part of that 
process would be to recognise the importance of discussion not only to learn the 
conceptions, but also when sharing ideas and evidence (Driver, 1989). However, not all 
students are going to have the same alternative conceptions, as the literature showed there 
were a number of alternative conceptions for the small topic of night and day (Vosniadou & 
Brewer, 1994, Allen, 2010). The challenge for the future would be how to create lessons 
that address all the student’s alternative conceptions. 
Reconstructing 
As a teacher I hope to ensure that I use the student’s prior knowledge to assist with my 
planning and preparation of not just science lessons but other subjects as well. I had been 
aware that students come with prior knowledge and use this to construct new ideas but 
have never considered that prior knowledge in the form of alternative conceptions could 
actually hinder a child’s progress. Now in the classroom I will make a concerted effort to 
target these alternative conceptions to ensure their academic progress is not hindered.
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
References 
Allen, M. (2010). Misconceptions in primary science. Berkshire, England: Open University 
Press. 
Baxter, J. (1991). A constructivist approach to astronomy in the National Curriculum. Physics 
Education 26 (1) doi:10.1088/0031-9120/26/1/007 
BBC Bitesize. (2014). Days and Nights. Retrieved from 
http://www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/ks3/science/environment_earth_universe/astronomy_space 
/revision/4/ 
Bely,P., Christian, C., & Roy, J.(2010). A Question and answer guide to Astronomy. 
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 
Cutter-Mackenzie, A., & Logan, M. (2013). Making links between science and the learners 
world. In A. Fitzgerald (Ed.) Learning and Teaching primary science (pp248-260) Port 
Melbourne, VIC: Cambridge University Press. 
Driver, R. (1989). Students’ conceptions and the learning of science, International Journal of 
ScienceEducation, 11:5, pp481-490, doi: 10.1080/0950069890110501 
Einarsdóttir, J. (2007).Research with children: methodological and ethical challenges', 
European Early Childhood Education Research Journal, 15(2), pp197- 211. doi: 
10.1080/13502930701321477 
Garbett,D, (2013). Making Science work in the primary classroom. In A. Fitzgerald (Ed.) 
Learning and Teaching primary science (pp248-260). Port Melbourne, VIC: Cambridge 
University Press. 
Howitt, C. , Blake, E., & Zadnik, M. (2010) Is the grass still green at night? Astrophysics of the 
dark. In Howitt, C. , Blake, E (Ed.)Planting the seeds of science, (2nd ed., pp. 33-53). WA: 
Australian Learning and Teaching Council.
Stephanie Heritage 21215735 
Lomb, N., (2008). The inner solar system [Image].Three planets in the western sky: the 
spectacle continues. Sydney Observatory retrieved from 
http://www.sydneyobservatory.com.au/2008/three-planets-in-the-western-sky-the-spectacle- 
continues/ 
Norris, R. (2008). In search of Aboriginal Astronomy. Australian Sky & Telescope, retrieved 
from http://www.atnf.csiro.au/people/rnorris/papers/_n217.pdf 
Rees, M. (E.d). (2005). Universe: The Definitive Visual Guide. London: Dorling Kindersley 
Limited. 
Reto Stöckli. (2002).The blue marble [image] retrieved from 
http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/IOTD/view.php?id=2181 
Sanders, M.,& Gatehouse, G.(Eds.). (2004). Earth and Moon. Oxan, England: Atlantic Europe 
Publishing Company. 
Science encyclopaedia for kids. (2014). The day/night cycle [Image]. The earth’s place in 
space. Retrieved from http://s cience.jrank.org/kids /pages /221/EARTH-S-PLACE-IN-SPACE.html 
Silvester, N. (2014.) A Homemade World Globe With a Pattern and Directions. Bright Hub 
Education. Retrieved from http://www.brighthubeducation.com/help-with-geography/ 
123525-how-to-make-make-a-homemade-globe-for-a-project/ 
Sharp, J., & Sharp, J. (2007). Beyond shape and gravity: children’s ideas about the Earth in 
space reconsidered. Research Papers in education, 22 (3). doi:10.1080/02671520701497613 
Teacher registration board of western Australia (TRBWA).(2011). Professional standards for 
teachers in WA, retrieved from 
http://www.trb.wa.gov.au/files/8113/8354/1958/Professional_Standards_for_Teachers_in_ 
WA.pdf 
Vosniadou, S., & Brewer, W.(1994).Mental Models of the Day/night cycle. Cognitive science, 
18, pp123-183. Retrieved from science Direct. 
Williamson, K., & Garton, A. (2011). Science Essentials 7. Australian Curriculum Edition. 
South Yarra, Victoria: Macmillan
Stephanie Heritage 21215735

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Barrett M107 .50 CAL SNIPER RIFLE
Barrett M107 .50 CAL SNIPER RIFLEBarrett M107 .50 CAL SNIPER RIFLE
Barrett M107 .50 CAL SNIPER RIFLEShubham Rai
 
Usmc Snipers
Usmc SnipersUsmc Snipers
Usmc Snipersphilq
 
Sniper fx mm presentation (5m) oct.2012
Sniper fx mm presentation   (5m)  oct.2012Sniper fx mm presentation   (5m)  oct.2012
Sniper fx mm presentation (5m) oct.2012Yasser Ghorayeb
 

Viewers also liked (7)

American Sniper
American SniperAmerican Sniper
American Sniper
 
Barrett M107 .50 CAL SNIPER RIFLE
Barrett M107 .50 CAL SNIPER RIFLEBarrett M107 .50 CAL SNIPER RIFLE
Barrett M107 .50 CAL SNIPER RIFLE
 
The Sniper by Liam O Flaherty
The Sniper  by Liam O FlahertyThe Sniper  by Liam O Flaherty
The Sniper by Liam O Flaherty
 
The Sniper
The SniperThe Sniper
The Sniper
 
Sniper rifles
Sniper riflesSniper rifles
Sniper rifles
 
Usmc Snipers
Usmc SnipersUsmc Snipers
Usmc Snipers
 
Sniper fx mm presentation (5m) oct.2012
Sniper fx mm presentation   (5m)  oct.2012Sniper fx mm presentation   (5m)  oct.2012
Sniper fx mm presentation (5m) oct.2012
 

Similar to Assignment 1 copy 1

Astronomy education research down under.pdf
Astronomy education research down under.pdfAstronomy education research down under.pdf
Astronomy education research down under.pdfLisa Muthukumar
 
Week 9 Earth and Space SciencesThe Earth and Space Sciences sub-s.docx
Week 9 Earth and Space SciencesThe Earth and Space Sciences sub-s.docxWeek 9 Earth and Space SciencesThe Earth and Space Sciences sub-s.docx
Week 9 Earth and Space SciencesThe Earth and Space Sciences sub-s.docxmelbruce90096
 
Poster: DEVELOPMENT AND VALIDATION OF A LEARNING PROGRESSION OF BASIC ASTRONO...
Poster: DEVELOPMENT AND VALIDATION OF A LEARNING PROGRESSION OF BASIC ASTRONO...Poster: DEVELOPMENT AND VALIDATION OF A LEARNING PROGRESSION OF BASIC ASTRONO...
Poster: DEVELOPMENT AND VALIDATION OF A LEARNING PROGRESSION OF BASIC ASTRONO...Silvia Galano
 
The Earth, moon and sun teaching unit
The Earth, moon and sun teaching unitThe Earth, moon and sun teaching unit
The Earth, moon and sun teaching unitJoanne Villis
 
Uniwerse in a Box - Podręcznik
Uniwerse in a Box - PodręcznikUniwerse in a Box - Podręcznik
Uniwerse in a Box - PodręcznikJacekKupras
 
A Review Of Astronomy Education Research
A Review Of Astronomy Education ResearchA Review Of Astronomy Education Research
A Review Of Astronomy Education ResearchAllison Koehn
 
Poster: Development and validation of a learning progression of basic astrono...
Poster: Development and validation of a learning progression of basic astrono...Poster: Development and validation of a learning progression of basic astrono...
Poster: Development and validation of a learning progression of basic astrono...Silvia Galano
 
Evolution (Educación Secundaria - Bachillerato - School of stars - Pamploneta...
Evolution (Educación Secundaria - Bachillerato - School of stars - Pamploneta...Evolution (Educación Secundaria - Bachillerato - School of stars - Pamploneta...
Evolution (Educación Secundaria - Bachillerato - School of stars - Pamploneta...Planetario de Pamplona
 
In this first module we have explored the historical ideas of the na.pdf
In this first module we have explored the historical ideas of the na.pdfIn this first module we have explored the historical ideas of the na.pdf
In this first module we have explored the historical ideas of the na.pdfartcraft14
 
Astronomy chapter 1 power point.pptx
Astronomy chapter 1 power point.pptxAstronomy chapter 1 power point.pptx
Astronomy chapter 1 power point.pptxDr Robert Craig PhD
 
Astronomy Textbook Part 1.pdf
Astronomy Textbook Part 1.pdfAstronomy Textbook Part 1.pdf
Astronomy Textbook Part 1.pdfShujaMehdi3
 
Solar System Powerpoint Lesson
Solar System Powerpoint LessonSolar System Powerpoint Lesson
Solar System Powerpoint Lessoners331
 
Galaxy Forum Africa 11 - Medupe
Galaxy Forum Africa 11 - MedupeGalaxy Forum Africa 11 - Medupe
Galaxy Forum Africa 11 - MedupeILOAHawaii
 
Galaxy Forum Africa 11 - Medupe
Galaxy Forum Africa 11 - MedupeGalaxy Forum Africa 11 - Medupe
Galaxy Forum Africa 11 - MedupeILOAHawaii
 

Similar to Assignment 1 copy 1 (20)

E328 Unit and Lesson
E328 Unit and LessonE328 Unit and Lesson
E328 Unit and Lesson
 
Is the earth flat or round
Is the earth flat or roundIs the earth flat or round
Is the earth flat or round
 
Astronomy education research down under.pdf
Astronomy education research down under.pdfAstronomy education research down under.pdf
Astronomy education research down under.pdf
 
Week 9 Earth and Space SciencesThe Earth and Space Sciences sub-s.docx
Week 9 Earth and Space SciencesThe Earth and Space Sciences sub-s.docxWeek 9 Earth and Space SciencesThe Earth and Space Sciences sub-s.docx
Week 9 Earth and Space SciencesThe Earth and Space Sciences sub-s.docx
 
Poster: DEVELOPMENT AND VALIDATION OF A LEARNING PROGRESSION OF BASIC ASTRONO...
Poster: DEVELOPMENT AND VALIDATION OF A LEARNING PROGRESSION OF BASIC ASTRONO...Poster: DEVELOPMENT AND VALIDATION OF A LEARNING PROGRESSION OF BASIC ASTRONO...
Poster: DEVELOPMENT AND VALIDATION OF A LEARNING PROGRESSION OF BASIC ASTRONO...
 
The Earth, moon and sun teaching unit
The Earth, moon and sun teaching unitThe Earth, moon and sun teaching unit
The Earth, moon and sun teaching unit
 
Uniwerse in a Box - Podręcznik
Uniwerse in a Box - PodręcznikUniwerse in a Box - Podręcznik
Uniwerse in a Box - Podręcznik
 
Ch 1
Ch 1Ch 1
Ch 1
 
Galileo's assistant
Galileo's assistantGalileo's assistant
Galileo's assistant
 
A Review Of Astronomy Education Research
A Review Of Astronomy Education ResearchA Review Of Astronomy Education Research
A Review Of Astronomy Education Research
 
Poster: Development and validation of a learning progression of basic astrono...
Poster: Development and validation of a learning progression of basic astrono...Poster: Development and validation of a learning progression of basic astrono...
Poster: Development and validation of a learning progression of basic astrono...
 
Evolution (Educación Secundaria - Bachillerato - School of stars - Pamploneta...
Evolution (Educación Secundaria - Bachillerato - School of stars - Pamploneta...Evolution (Educación Secundaria - Bachillerato - School of stars - Pamploneta...
Evolution (Educación Secundaria - Bachillerato - School of stars - Pamploneta...
 
SCI6 WEEK 4 - Q4.docx
SCI6 WEEK 4 - Q4.docxSCI6 WEEK 4 - Q4.docx
SCI6 WEEK 4 - Q4.docx
 
In this first module we have explored the historical ideas of the na.pdf
In this first module we have explored the historical ideas of the na.pdfIn this first module we have explored the historical ideas of the na.pdf
In this first module we have explored the historical ideas of the na.pdf
 
Take to the Skies
Take to the SkiesTake to the Skies
Take to the Skies
 
Astronomy chapter 1 power point.pptx
Astronomy chapter 1 power point.pptxAstronomy chapter 1 power point.pptx
Astronomy chapter 1 power point.pptx
 
Astronomy Textbook Part 1.pdf
Astronomy Textbook Part 1.pdfAstronomy Textbook Part 1.pdf
Astronomy Textbook Part 1.pdf
 
Solar System Powerpoint Lesson
Solar System Powerpoint LessonSolar System Powerpoint Lesson
Solar System Powerpoint Lesson
 
Galaxy Forum Africa 11 - Medupe
Galaxy Forum Africa 11 - MedupeGalaxy Forum Africa 11 - Medupe
Galaxy Forum Africa 11 - Medupe
 
Galaxy Forum Africa 11 - Medupe
Galaxy Forum Africa 11 - MedupeGalaxy Forum Africa 11 - Medupe
Galaxy Forum Africa 11 - Medupe
 

More from stephanieannheritage

More from stephanieannheritage (7)

Times newspaper article - 1786
Times newspaper article - 1786Times newspaper article - 1786
Times newspaper article - 1786
 
Integrated unit plan overview
Integrated unit plan overviewIntegrated unit plan overview
Integrated unit plan overview
 
Integrated unit
Integrated unitIntegrated unit
Integrated unit
 
Quiz sheet
Quiz sheetQuiz sheet
Quiz sheet
 
Scan0003
Scan0003Scan0003
Scan0003
 
Assessment checklists year 7
Assessment checklists year 7Assessment checklists year 7
Assessment checklists year 7
 
Royal perth show - Worded maths questions
Royal perth show - Worded maths questionsRoyal perth show - Worded maths questions
Royal perth show - Worded maths questions
 

Recently uploaded

DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginnersDATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginnersSabitha Banu
 
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...Postal Advocate Inc.
 
Procuring digital preservation CAN be quick and painless with our new dynamic...
Procuring digital preservation CAN be quick and painless with our new dynamic...Procuring digital preservation CAN be quick and painless with our new dynamic...
Procuring digital preservation CAN be quick and painless with our new dynamic...Jisc
 
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatEarth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatYousafMalik24
 
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceRoles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceSamikshaHamane
 
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdfInclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdfTechSoup
 
ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4
ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4
ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4MiaBumagat1
 
Full Stack Web Development Course for Beginners
Full Stack Web Development Course  for BeginnersFull Stack Web Development Course  for Beginners
Full Stack Web Development Course for BeginnersSabitha Banu
 
What is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERP
What is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERPWhat is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERP
What is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERPCeline George
 
Like-prefer-love -hate+verb+ing & silent letters & citizenship text.pdf
Like-prefer-love -hate+verb+ing & silent letters & citizenship text.pdfLike-prefer-love -hate+verb+ing & silent letters & citizenship text.pdf
Like-prefer-love -hate+verb+ing & silent letters & citizenship text.pdfMr Bounab Samir
 
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️9953056974 Low Rate Call Girls In Saket, Delhi NCR
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17Celine George
 
Grade 9 Q4-MELC1-Active and Passive Voice.pptx
Grade 9 Q4-MELC1-Active and Passive Voice.pptxGrade 9 Q4-MELC1-Active and Passive Voice.pptx
Grade 9 Q4-MELC1-Active and Passive Voice.pptxChelloAnnAsuncion2
 
THEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
THEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATIONTHEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
THEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATIONHumphrey A Beña
 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxiammrhaywood
 
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17Celine George
 

Recently uploaded (20)

DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginnersDATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
 
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdfTataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
 
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
USPS® Forced Meter Migration - How to Know if Your Postage Meter Will Soon be...
 
Procuring digital preservation CAN be quick and painless with our new dynamic...
Procuring digital preservation CAN be quick and painless with our new dynamic...Procuring digital preservation CAN be quick and painless with our new dynamic...
Procuring digital preservation CAN be quick and painless with our new dynamic...
 
YOUVE_GOT_EMAIL_PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE_GOT_EMAIL_PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptxYOUVE_GOT_EMAIL_PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE_GOT_EMAIL_PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
 
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatEarth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
 
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceRoles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
 
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdfInclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
 
ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4
ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4
ANG SEKTOR NG agrikultura.pptx QUARTER 4
 
Full Stack Web Development Course for Beginners
Full Stack Web Development Course  for BeginnersFull Stack Web Development Course  for Beginners
Full Stack Web Development Course for Beginners
 
What is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERP
What is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERPWhat is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERP
What is Model Inheritance in Odoo 17 ERP
 
Like-prefer-love -hate+verb+ing & silent letters & citizenship text.pdf
Like-prefer-love -hate+verb+ing & silent letters & citizenship text.pdfLike-prefer-love -hate+verb+ing & silent letters & citizenship text.pdf
Like-prefer-love -hate+verb+ing & silent letters & citizenship text.pdf
 
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
 
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptxYOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
 
Grade 9 Q4-MELC1-Active and Passive Voice.pptx
Grade 9 Q4-MELC1-Active and Passive Voice.pptxGrade 9 Q4-MELC1-Active and Passive Voice.pptx
Grade 9 Q4-MELC1-Active and Passive Voice.pptx
 
LEFT_ON_C'N_ PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
LEFT_ON_C'N_ PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptxLEFT_ON_C'N_ PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
LEFT_ON_C'N_ PRELIMS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
 
THEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
THEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATIONTHEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
THEORIES OF ORGANIZATION-PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
 
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
 

Assignment 1 copy 1

  • 1. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 EDUC 5508 – Integrated Studies from K-7: Science Focus Assignment 1 -Children’s View of Science Introduction Overview The aim of this assignment was to determine the prior knowledge of two children regarding a particular science topic. The data collected was interpreted and compared to literature regarding alternative conceptions. From this data appropriate activities were chosen to address the alternative conceptions. Importance of Obtaining Prior Knowledge When students arrive in the science classroom they are not empty vessels waiting to be filled with information, instead students have already created their own explanations for many scientific concepts (Baxter, 1991). They will have observed or experienced a number of scientific phenomena to create their own ideas and beliefs about why something happens; this is called everyday concept formation (Cutter-Mackenzie & Logan, 2013). It is important that science lessons makes links to these everyday science concepts so that students remain engaged and can see the reasons behind studying science. By obtaining prior knowledge teachers can find out what is relevant to students and teach topics students will be able to engage with (Cutter-Mackenzie & Logan, 2013). Learning a child’s prior knowledge also allows teachers to identify a student’s alternative conceptions. These are the beliefs and explanations developed through their own experiences that are different from the accepted scientific concepts (Cutter-Mackenzie & Logan, 2013). Once these alternative concepts have been identified lessons can be planned to target them. As Ausubel declared “the most important single factor influencing learning is what the learner already knows. Ascertain this and teach him appropriately” (Ausubel cited in Garbett, 2013). This also adheres to the constructivist theories like those of Piaget who stated that prior knowledge is what children use to make sense of new information. According to Piaget, people assimilate information by making it fit into what they already know or they accommodate new ideas by adjusting their way of thinking. If the information
  • 2. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 is too unfamiliar people have a tendency to just ignore it (Piaget cited in Woolfolk & Margett, 2013). If students distort the information by trying to make it fit or simply ignore new information this will negatively impact their education. As such the teacher needs to comprehend that prior knowledge could be acting as a constraint to learning new scientific concepts (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). If teachers are aware of what the student already knows they will know whether these new ideas will fit or if other methods will have to be used to assist in the students learning. Once it is established what a student already knows a teacher can use this information to assist in planning the rest of the topic. A teacher does not want to reteach what has already been taught in previous years or leave gaps in the topic areas. Also if a teacher is aware of what a student already knows they are able to shape activities to suit child capabiliti es. This is important as if the concept/topic is too hard the student will become disengaged and unmotivated. However if it is too easy then the student can become bored which in turn can lead to behavioural issues (Hunt cited in Woolfolk & Margett, 2013). It should be remembered that determining a student’s prior knowledge is also part of knowing your students which is a vital part of adhering to the professional standards of graduate teachers (TRBWA, 2014). Science topic selected The topic selected for this assignment is the night/day cycle, a year 3 topic included in the earth and space sciences section of the national curriculum. Although this may seem an easy topic there are a number of alternative conceptions that are held by both young children (and adults) regarding the causes for day and night (Skamp, 2004). Details of children interviewed Two students were interviewed for this assignment. The first was a year three student who will be referred to as Jennifer. The second was a year two student who has recently turned seven; her pseudonym for the sake of this assignment will be Sophie.
  • 3. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 Day and Night The reasons for day and night have been considered for thousands of years. To comprehend the science conception behind night and day there needs to be an understanding that the earth is spherical, it revolves around the sun and it rotates on its axis . Earth is believed to have been formed 4.56 billion years ago (Rees, 2005) and although the earth is depicted as a perfect sphere (see fig.1) the earth actually bulges around the equator due to the centrifugal forces as the earth rotates (Sanders & Gatehouse, 2004). Figure 1: The Blue marble (Reto Stöckli, 2002) Earth is the third closest planet to the sun and revolves around the sun (Williamson & Garton, 2011). As shown by the illustration in figure 2, the sun is at the centre of the solar system with the planets following an orbit around the sun. Figure 2: The inner solar system on 19 September 2008 (Lomb, 2008)
  • 4. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 For centuries it had been believed that the earth was the centre of the universe. The sun, moon and planets all revolved around the earth creating a geocentric model (see fig. 3). This was based on Ptolemy’s theories outlined in the Almagest (Rees, 2005). Figure 3: Ptolemy’s system of orbits from The Celestial Atlas published in 1660-61 (Rees, 2005) In 1543 Nicolaus Capernicus wrote a paper describing the universe as heliocentric; all the planets revolved around the sun (see fig. 4). This paper revolutionised how astrologers studied space and the reasons for night and day. Figure 4: A map produced by Copernicus in 1543 to show the earth and planets circling the sun (Rees, 2005)
  • 5. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 Once it is understood that the earth revolves around the sun we can determine the reason for the day/night cycle. As well as revolving around the sun the earth also rotates on its axis. This axis is an imaginary line that runs through the centre of the earth from pole to pole at angle of 23.5 degrees. This axis always points to the same place in space called the South Celestial pole (William & Garton, 2011). The earth spins at 1700km/h, however, people do not notice because everything is moving at this speed. The only way that we would notice the spinning would be if the speed were to suddenly change or we were to stop spinning (Williamson & Garton, 2011). As the earth spins most locations on the earth will pass from shadow to daylight creating the day/night cycle (Rees,2005). The side of the earth facing the sun will be in the sunlight which would be day time and the areas facing away from the sun would be in shadow creating night time (see fig. 5). Figure 5: The day/night cycle (Science encyclopaedia for kids, 2014). Every day the earth rotates once however there are two definitions for what is considered a day. A solar day lasts for 24 hours which is the length of time the sun takes to return to the highest point in the sky from the same point the previous day (Rees,2005). A sidereal day is the earth’s rotation in relation to the stars; it is the time it takes a star to return to its highest point. This is four minutes shorter than a solar day (Rees, 2005).
  • 6. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 Figure 6: Solar and Sidereal day (Rees, 2005) The difference in time between the two definitions is because the earth has to turn a little further in order for the sun to reach the same point (see fig. 6) (Rees, 2005). In the southern hemisphere the longest day of the year happens on the 22nd December and is called the Summer Solstice. Then on the 22nd June the shortest day occurs, and is called the winter solstice. The opposite occurs in the northern hemisphere (Williamson & Garton, 2011). Due to the rotation of the earth the sun seems to move across the sky from east to west (see fig.7). Figure 7: The sun’s apparent movement across the sky (BBC Bitesize, 2014).
  • 7. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 This movement across the sky allowed for sundials to tell the time as the shadow projected by an object would move as well, this shadow can be used indicate the time(Bely et al, 2010). It is this apparent movement from east to west, however, that may be the root of some alternative conceptions. Alternative Conceptions regarding day and night There are a number of alternative conceptions for the causes of day/night as the day/night cycle is something that all children can observe with their own eyes. They see the sun out during the day and the darkness at night. To explain the day turning into night some children believe that the sun goes behind the clouds (Allen, 2010),or behind the hills (Baxter cited in Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994) the sun simply moves out into space (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). Disappearance/appearance is something many young children are familiar with. Babies and toddlers are introduced to the concept early on by often playing games such as ‘peek-a-boo’. As such, they may accept the notion that things can just appear and disappear (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). If children have not observed the movement of the sun across the sky they may also believe that the sun and moon rise up and down (Allen, 2010). This alternative conception is quite often link with the alternative conception of the earth being flat. Therefore students must comprehend that the earth is a sphere before they can even begin to understand the scientific explanation for day/night (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). Vosniadou and Brewer refer to these types of conceptions as initial mental models, as they are based solely on the child’s observations (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). As mentioned in the previous section the apparent movement of the sun from east to west can cause students to believe that the sun moves around the earth (Allen, 2010). This alternative conception was actually the widely held belief for hundreds of years, so it is understandable to see why children will have the same idea. Children have to be able to understand that the sun remains stationary in relation to the earth which is spinning around the sun. Once they understand this they can then understand why the rotation of the earth would then cause day/night (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994).
  • 8. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 Another alternative conception involves the moon blocking the sun at night and the opposite during the day (Allen, 2010). This links to the belief that the moon only comes out at night (Allen, 2010). The idea of the moon only coming out at night is not surprising as many children’s picture books show the moon wearing a night cap in the night sky (Allen, 2010). Some children also believe that the sun and moon swap places (Allen, 2010). A similar idea is that the moon and the sun are both fixed in position and as the earth rotates we see one or the other. This mixes the scientific fact of the earth rotating and the alternative conception of a stationary moon (Allen, 2010). These conceptions could be a result of the fact that it is very rare to see a picture with the moon out in the daytime, and many children may never have looked for the moon during the day. It is also claimed that literature about night and day often does not explain explicitly what the moon is doing in relation to the day/night cycle (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). These last few conceptions are referred to as synthetic mental models as although not being scientifically correct they do show have to some level of scientific knowledge such as knowing the earth is a sphere or that the earth rotates (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). The causes for these alternative conceptions can be due a number of things including personal experience, the impact of the media, as well as religious and cultural backgrounds of the individual. For example an Aboriginal theory from Yolungo peoples of the northern territories believed that the Walu the sun woman lit a fire every morning and carried the torch from east to west then extinguished the torch every evening. She would then journey underground throughout the night to return to the morning camp. The sunsets and sunrises were caused by spilling ochre on the clouds (Norris, 2008). Children would use this story to explain what they see. This type of belief is not only restricted to aboriginals but many other cultures as well. Some studies have even found many different cultures across the world have similar theories for astrological events (Skamp, 2004). Although not matched with current scientific theories teachers must be still be sensitive of religious and cultural beliefs.
  • 9. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 Procedure Selection of children Before selecting the students it was decided that space and more specifically the reason we have day and night would be the topic discussed. Therefore it was appropriate to choose a child who was in year three, which is when this topic is part of the national curriculum. It was then decided that a participant from a lower year would provide a good comparison as they would not covered the topic in school and may have different ideas as to why we have night and day. Ethical Issues To ensure that there were no ethical issues, whilst organising the interview it was explained to the parents what we expected from their children. It was explained that there would be three interviewers who would ask the children to draw a picture which would be followed by some questions about space. We also asked permission to create audio recordings of the conversation. Once arriving for the interview the parents were asked to read through an information sheet and sign a permission form (see Appendix A & B). It was not only the parent’s permission that needed to be collected, however, the child also had to provide informed assent. The 1989 Convention on the rights of the child stresses the importance of a child’s right to make decisions that affect their lives (Einsardóltir, 2007). As such, the children also received an explanation about what was happening and why they were being interviewed using terms they would understand. It was also made clear that the children could stop the interview at any time. To avoid any issues that could be caused by inequality in the relationship between the child and the interviewer it was arranged that the main interviewer was someone the child new well. Jennifer was a close family friend to one of the interviewers and Sophie was a child who the interviewer had met on numerous occasions. Since there was already relationships formed between the interviewer and child before the research commenced it was hoped that the child would not only feel comfortable enough to say stop, but also feel comfortable to enough to share their ideas. Another ethical issue would be the confidentiality of the data, as participants data should be respected and protected (Einsardóltir, 2007). It was made clear that audio recording would
  • 10. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 be deleted upon completion of the assignment and any data gathered would only be shared by members of the group and the assessors of the assignment. It was also made clear that in the report they would be given pseudonyms. Data collection methods Data was collected from the children through a recorded conversation. To begin with the students were asked to draw a picture of a person in daytime and then draw a picture of a person at night time (See Appendix C & D). They were then asked to describe the picture and were asked questions about their drawings such as; how do we know it is daytime? What can they see? What can they smell? And what can they hear? They were then asked to add words to the picture to describe day and then night (See Appendix C & D). This was to ensure they knew what day and night were. The students were then asked a number of focus questions about day and night. The students were provided with a small ball that looked like the earth and a larger yellow ball which they were told could represent the sun. It was explained that they could use these to help explain their answers. The questions included: What do you think causes day and night? What happens to the sun at night? What happens to the moon during the day? What do we mean by sun set? What do we mean by sunrise? When you are sleeping, is someone on the other side of the world sleeping? For both interviews there was a main interviewer with two secondary interviewers observing the child’s behaviour. The main interviewer would use constant words of support to encourage the child to share and expand their ideas. They were never told an idea was incorrect instead it was made clear that all ideas were valued.
  • 11. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 Results Day/Night drawings The first activity the children were asked to do was a picture of day and night. Both children portrayed daytime with the sun shining and a person outside. For night time both children drew the moon in the night sky, with a person inside (See Appendix C & D). Jennifer drew a person in bed sleeping and Sophie drew a house with someone looking out the window. After they had finished the picture the conversation that followed is summarised in the table below (see table 1). A full copy of the transcript can be found in the appendix (see Appendix E & F). Jennifer Sophie Day time drawing How do we know it is day time? Because the sun is out. Because the sun is up and it is not dark. What do you see in the day time? You can play sport. What does day time smell like? Nothing. Nothing. What does it sound like? Birds, teachers talking. Birds. How does it make you feel? Happy. Night time drawing What do you see? Pitch black but can see the moon and stars. Moon and stars. Its dark and nothings around. What do you hear? Nothing, I’m asleep but sometimes hear my baby sister crying. Mozzies and nocturnal creatures. Does night time have a smell? No. Does everyone sleep at night time? Not nocturnal creatures or some people. Yes. Table 1: Table summarising day/night drawing discussion.
  • 12. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 From this discussion it is clear that both children understand the dif ference between day time and night time. The day is light because of the sun and the night time is dark and they are able to see the moon and the stars. Interview about the day/night cycle The children were then asked the focus questions. The two interviews have been summarised in the following table (See table. 2). Jennifer Sophie When shown the balls the student could: Recognise small 3D globe as the earth Yes Yes Locate Australia on the globe Yes Yes Recognise the larger yellow Yes No ball as the sun. Students answers to the focus questions: What causes day and night? The earth turns around and when the earth turns away from the sun it turns to the moon. When the earth doesn’t see the sun it goes dark. The sun and the moon spin around the earth slowly swapping places. Later in the conversation The sun goes behind the moon. If Australia is in day time is everyone in day time? No, England is 8 hours behind. No, at different times the sun goes around the world. When the moon comes up the sun goes up on the other side. What happens to the sun at night? Nothing it stays. Well the sun does move but at night it stays there and the earth rotates. As the moon comes up the sun goes down. What happens to the moon At night we see the moon The moon goes behind the
  • 13. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 during the day? and during the day we see the sun and other countries see the moon. sun. Have you seen the moon during the day? Yes, since its morning you can still faintly see it. No Describe sunrise Demonstrates with the balls. The earth is starting to tilt so its going down for Australia but coming up for other countries. The sun is going down and the moon is going up. Describe sunset Demonstrates with the balls the sun rising for Australia. The sun is going down. Does the sun move? Only for the seasons. Earth stays in the same spot and the sun moves around the earth. Does the moon move? No. It stays where it is. Yes. The sun and moon switch spots. Table 2: Table summarising answers to the focus questions. Jennifer also mentioned a solar system craft project she was making with her mum. When questioned she revealed that the solar system is ‘everything’. She described it as everything that goes round the sun including the earth and other planets. She could also name other planets and recognise that they were different sizes. It should be mentioned that if the interview was performed again it would have been beneficial to ask the students to draw their conception, as well as using the balls to describe what they are saying. Drawings would have given a greater insight and may have discovered further alternative conceptions. Also, by using the balls the interviewers had assumed that students new the earth was a sphere and could actually have caused some alternative conceptions to be missed.
  • 14. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 Interpretation and comparison to literature Using these results we are able to see quite clearly that both children interviewed have very different alternative conceptions. Jennifer was able to correctly identify the science conception that the earth rotates and revolves around the sun but still held other alternative conceptions. Jennifer’s main alternative conceptions included the fact that she believed the sun moved for the seasons and that the moon remained stationary. On the whole Jennifer seemed quite knowledgeable about the subject of the solar system but would benefit from having a few topics clarified. Jennifer is originally from the United Kingdom and still has family living in England and Scotland so was able to use this knowledge regarding different time-zones and for her understanding that if it was day in Australia it would be night the other side of the globe (Sharp & Sharp, 2007). Sophie on the other hand believed that the sun moved and the earth remained in the same position which is a common alternative conception. There also seemed to be some confusion about whether the sun went around or up and down. She also seemed unsure about the moon blocking the sun at night and vice versa during the day. The idea that the sun and moon swap places was also an alternative conception that arose from the interview. Sophie’s almost contradictory answers are not unusual in astrology and she may have been trying to work out her ideas as she was explaining them (Baxter, 1994). Sophie did however show some scientific views as well, as she did explain that the moon did not remain stationary. One thing that we should bear in mind is that Sophie is younger than Jennifer so is therefore bound to have different alternative conceptions. A number of alternative conceptions mentioned in the literature became apparent from the interview with Jennifer and Sophie. Jennifer’s main alternative conception about the sun moving for the seasons has appeared in the literature (Allen, 2010) however is not directly linked to day/night so was not discussed previously. Jennifer’s conception that the moon remains stationary was one of the alternative views discussed by the literature. As previously stated this could be due to the fact the moon is not discussed when referring to the day/night cycle so students are unsure how it is involved (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). Sophie displayed a number of the conceptions that were mentioned in the literature. She held the alternative conception that the sun went around the earth (Allen, 2010). Sophie’s
  • 15. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 geocentric model is not unusual for children her age (Skamp, 2010). She is unable to feel the earth spinning therefore is not likely to deduce that the earth is rotating. Instead she believes the sun is moving which is most likely due to observing the sun move across the sky. She was also adamant that the moon did not ever come out during the day. This could explain why she thinks the sun and moon must swap places or that the moon blocks the sun (Allen, 2010). Both students were using synthetic mental models, as there was a mixture of accepted science concepts and student observation that created their ideas about the day/night cyle (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). Neither of the children revealed any new alternative conceptions that had not been mentioned in the literature studied. Rationale for teaching to these alternative conceptions The main point that came from both of the interviews was the alternative conception regarding the movement of the sun. Jennifer believed that the sun moved nearer and further to the earth to create the seasons, whereas Sophie believed the sun moved around the earth. Therefore the position and movement of the sun would be the main alternative conception to be addressed. Although the sun does rotate it stays the same distance from the earth and the earth actually rotates around the sun (Rees, 2005). The first activity choosen would be the shoe box model activity. Students would colour the inside of a shoebox black. The student would then draw a picture of Australia on a polystyrene ball, this would represent the earth. The student would then place a pipe cleaner through a polystyrene ball and attach the pipe cleaners to the edge of the box that has view holes cut out from the top and side of the box. A strong light source would then shine on the polystyrene earth. Students should then be able to see the line of shadow for when day end and night begins. The student can then turn the pipe cleaner to show how the earth rotates creating day and night across the globe (Howitt, Blake, Zadnik, 2010). Not only would students be able to see that the light source (the sun) does not move but they would also understand that the earth is rotating. During the discussion, however, the teacher should explain that the theory that the sun went around the earth causing day and night is not a completely outlandish idea. The students should understand that for hundreds of years this was the widely held belief. If students know this they can be made to feel better
  • 16. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 about their own alternative conceptions (Baxter, 1991). This can help reduce any negative association children may have about science. The second activity to target this alternative conception would be for students to physically enact the day and night cycle. Students working in pairs would create their own homemade globes using a template (Silverston, 2014). They will attach wire to the top of the globe so they are able to spin. Once they have made the globes, in a darkened classroom one member of the pair would shine a strong light source at the globe whilst the other person spins the globe. The person hold the light source must stay on the same spot to show how it is the earth spinning causes day and night not the sun. The teacher should then ask the students which way they should spin the globe to promote discussion and allow students to share ideas. This is very similar to the previous activity just on a larger scale but gives the students a chance to really compound their knowledge. If students are still having trouble understanding that the sun remains in the same spot more time can be spent on this, however, if students understand the concept, the teacher could introduce the movement around the sun. The student holding the globe can place it on his/her head and spin around whilst revolving around the person holding the light source. The teacher should emphasise that the sun does not move from its spot even though it does rotate. Both these activities are very hands on and use physical models. Physical models are tools that allow the science concept to be explored at a deeper level and are vital for cognitive development (Vygotsky cited in Woolfolk & Margetts, 2013). Having the children physically create or act out the concept is more effective than just telling the students the scientific concept and hoping it sinks in. In some cases, simply telling students facts often results in students creating hybrid between their alternative conception and the scientific conception(Gilbert et al cited in Baxter, 1991). Teachers should also be aware that children want to protect their original idea so they need to provide the opportunities to discover and try out new theories and then be able to back them up with evidence (Baxter, 1991). Being actively involved in the learning creates ownership of these new ideas and therefore are more likely to replace the old concepts with these new ideas. Both activities would hopefully engage the student’s interest and then retain the student’s interest through to the next concept within that topic. If the student is engaged in the
  • 17. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 activity they are more motivated are more likely to be able to recall information (Skamp, 2004). These activities are also tailor made to concentrate on the specific alternative concept revealed by the interview. Studies have shown that students who received targeted teaching showed significant improvement within that topic (Diakidou & Kendeou, 2001). So with these targeted activities student’s knowledge of space should be increased. Since both of these activities use visual models to help explain the causes of day/night, the teacher must be careful not to confuse the students further, as students may not understand what the model is actually representing (Skamp, 2004). To avoid any confusions the teacher must be able to predict what students may incorrectly focus upon and redirect the attention to the concept they are trying to explain (Frazier cited in Skamp, 2004). This also links to the importance of social discussion and teacher scaffolding when doing these activities (Vygotsky cited in Woolfolk & Margetts, 2013). As students discuss ideas with their peers and the teachers, they begin to understand more about the concept and how it links to other concepts within the topic (Skamp, 2004). Reflection Reporting The purpose of this report was to identify the importance of using prior knowledge to determine a child’s alternative conceptions . These conceptions can then be addressed with activities designed to challenge these alternative conceptions and replace them with scientific conceptions. Responding What surprised me was the number of alternative conceptions students could have about a single scientific topic and how if they are not addressed directly, they can restrict the learning process of the students. Relating The attainment of knowledge about a topic is a gradual process and as such alternative models change over time. Students begin with an initial mental model based on observations then over time, as they learn more, they create synthetic mental models that
  • 18. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 reflect both observations and scientific models until finally arriving at the fully formed scientific mental model (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994). If the student believes the world is flat (initial model) there is no way they can comprehend the reason for day/night (rotation of a spherical earth). As such, initial and synthetic models can be seen to act as a barrier to learning. Students can also become protective of their ideas and become resistant to other explanations, which once again negatively impacts on their learning process (Driver, 1989). If the alternative conceptions are identified and teacher then tailers a teaching program to question these beliefs students are more likely to progress through the subject. Studies have shown that students who received targeted teaching showed significant improvement when compared to students who were just following the stages of a textbook (Diakidou & Kendeou, 2001). Reasoning After completing this assignment I now comprehend why there is an emphasis on getting to know your students and listening to their ideas and beliefs . An important part of that process would be to recognise the importance of discussion not only to learn the conceptions, but also when sharing ideas and evidence (Driver, 1989). However, not all students are going to have the same alternative conceptions, as the literature showed there were a number of alternative conceptions for the small topic of night and day (Vosniadou & Brewer, 1994, Allen, 2010). The challenge for the future would be how to create lessons that address all the student’s alternative conceptions. Reconstructing As a teacher I hope to ensure that I use the student’s prior knowledge to assist with my planning and preparation of not just science lessons but other subjects as well. I had been aware that students come with prior knowledge and use this to construct new ideas but have never considered that prior knowledge in the form of alternative conceptions could actually hinder a child’s progress. Now in the classroom I will make a concerted effort to target these alternative conceptions to ensure their academic progress is not hindered.
  • 19. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 References Allen, M. (2010). Misconceptions in primary science. Berkshire, England: Open University Press. Baxter, J. (1991). A constructivist approach to astronomy in the National Curriculum. Physics Education 26 (1) doi:10.1088/0031-9120/26/1/007 BBC Bitesize. (2014). Days and Nights. Retrieved from http://www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/ks3/science/environment_earth_universe/astronomy_space /revision/4/ Bely,P., Christian, C., & Roy, J.(2010). A Question and answer guide to Astronomy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Cutter-Mackenzie, A., & Logan, M. (2013). Making links between science and the learners world. In A. Fitzgerald (Ed.) Learning and Teaching primary science (pp248-260) Port Melbourne, VIC: Cambridge University Press. Driver, R. (1989). Students’ conceptions and the learning of science, International Journal of ScienceEducation, 11:5, pp481-490, doi: 10.1080/0950069890110501 Einarsdóttir, J. (2007).Research with children: methodological and ethical challenges', European Early Childhood Education Research Journal, 15(2), pp197- 211. doi: 10.1080/13502930701321477 Garbett,D, (2013). Making Science work in the primary classroom. In A. Fitzgerald (Ed.) Learning and Teaching primary science (pp248-260). Port Melbourne, VIC: Cambridge University Press. Howitt, C. , Blake, E., & Zadnik, M. (2010) Is the grass still green at night? Astrophysics of the dark. In Howitt, C. , Blake, E (Ed.)Planting the seeds of science, (2nd ed., pp. 33-53). WA: Australian Learning and Teaching Council.
  • 20. Stephanie Heritage 21215735 Lomb, N., (2008). The inner solar system [Image].Three planets in the western sky: the spectacle continues. Sydney Observatory retrieved from http://www.sydneyobservatory.com.au/2008/three-planets-in-the-western-sky-the-spectacle- continues/ Norris, R. (2008). In search of Aboriginal Astronomy. Australian Sky & Telescope, retrieved from http://www.atnf.csiro.au/people/rnorris/papers/_n217.pdf Rees, M. (E.d). (2005). Universe: The Definitive Visual Guide. London: Dorling Kindersley Limited. Reto Stöckli. (2002).The blue marble [image] retrieved from http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/IOTD/view.php?id=2181 Sanders, M.,& Gatehouse, G.(Eds.). (2004). Earth and Moon. Oxan, England: Atlantic Europe Publishing Company. Science encyclopaedia for kids. (2014). The day/night cycle [Image]. The earth’s place in space. Retrieved from http://s cience.jrank.org/kids /pages /221/EARTH-S-PLACE-IN-SPACE.html Silvester, N. (2014.) A Homemade World Globe With a Pattern and Directions. Bright Hub Education. Retrieved from http://www.brighthubeducation.com/help-with-geography/ 123525-how-to-make-make-a-homemade-globe-for-a-project/ Sharp, J., & Sharp, J. (2007). Beyond shape and gravity: children’s ideas about the Earth in space reconsidered. Research Papers in education, 22 (3). doi:10.1080/02671520701497613 Teacher registration board of western Australia (TRBWA).(2011). Professional standards for teachers in WA, retrieved from http://www.trb.wa.gov.au/files/8113/8354/1958/Professional_Standards_for_Teachers_in_ WA.pdf Vosniadou, S., & Brewer, W.(1994).Mental Models of the Day/night cycle. Cognitive science, 18, pp123-183. Retrieved from science Direct. Williamson, K., & Garton, A. (2011). Science Essentials 7. Australian Curriculum Edition. South Yarra, Victoria: Macmillan