SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 14
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Open Access or Open Excess;
libraries at a crossroads
Leo Waaijers.
When scientific and scholarly publishing is no
longer seen as copyright exploitation but as a
service, as is the case in the OA paradigm,
there is a need for a market where quality of
the service can be matched against price.
Where are we now?
Dominant business model
Authors’ perception: publishing is ‘free’. In fact they give away their
copyrights, completely and exclusively! Publishers exploit the acquired
copyright monopolies.
Effects
• Packaged products (‘Big deals’)
• Permission needed for re-use (including repository storage)
• Advance payments
• Exorbitant profit margins*
The perfect business model
*http://svpow.com/2012/01/13/the-obscene-profits-of-commercial-scholarly-publishers
In theory, yes.
OA publishing is a market oriented service
(i.e. organising peer review) for authors as
opposed to the monopolistic exploitation of
copyrights.
Can Open Access cure this?
A burgeonning market
http://www.eigenfactor.org/openaccess/
A burgeonning market
http://www.eigenfactor.org/openaccess/
Fees and quality vary widely
Average prices1,2
: No fee OA journals: € 0
Fee based OA journals: € 904
Hybrid journals: € 2727
All three categories include good and bad journals.
So, there is room for price/perfomance comparisons, i.e.
a market place.
1. A study of open access journals using article processing charges. David J. Solomon, Bo-Christer
Björk. August 2012. http://www.openaccesspublishing.org/apc2/
2. Developing an effective market for open access processing charges. Bo-Christer Björk, David J.
Solomon. March 2014.
http://www.wellcome.ac.uk/stellent/groups/corporatesite/@policy_communications/documents/web
_document/wtp055910.pdf
Open Excess or Open Access?
Publisher keeps big (OA) deal
Author publishes for free
Library pays the annual
invoice in advance
Publisher serves author
‘Author’ pays publication fee
Libarary organises the OA
market
Hybrid publishers e.g.
Springer deal, NL;
SCOAP3 deal*, CERN; ….
OA publishers e.g.
PLOS; MDPI; Copernicus,
BioMedCentral, ….
We have arrived at a crossroads
http://scoap3.org/scoap3journals/journals-apc
Open Excess Open Access
*
Principles
• Named crowd sourcing
• Academia only
• Structured via Journal Score Cards
• Transparant price information
Two Journal Score Cards
1. Base Journal Score Card
18 item questionnaire leading to a 1-5 score,
analysing a journal web site’s transparency,
usually completed by libraries*,
takes 15 to 20 minutes per journal.
* Resuming their original professional role as quality monitor.
2. Valuation Journal Score Card
4 item questionnaire leading to 1-5 score,
experience based reality check,
usually completed by authors and editors*,
takes 3 minutes per journal.
* Spontaneously, or invited by their library or publisher.
Valuation Score
≥ 3 < 3
Base
Score
≥ 3 Strong
journal
Threat
(to author)
Journal may not meet its promises
< 3
Opportunity
(to publisher)
Improve journal’s web site
Weaker
journal
producing a SWOT matrix
http://www.qoam.eu
QOAM becomes the meeting point where
shopping authors select a journal to publish
their article in, publishers may find out how to
improve their journal and funders, policy
makers, journalists and the public at large
enter a transparent academic publishing
environment.
Please spread the word. QOAM is an academic self-help
instrument that fully depends on the contributions of libraries,
authors and journal editors. It is independent of publishers
although a growing list of publishers have included their OA and
hybrid journals in QOAM for academic judgement. Today QOAM
has 16.000+ journals waiting to be scored.
Your comments and questions are most welcome via QOAM’s
contact form.
Thank you very much!
Leo Waaijers.
Take home message

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Sherpa Romeo
Sherpa RomeoSherpa Romeo
Sherpa RomeoMKH-QMUL
 
How to Handle Article Processing Charges: SFU Open Access Fund
How to Handle Article Processing Charges: SFU Open Access FundHow to Handle Article Processing Charges: SFU Open Access Fund
How to Handle Article Processing Charges: SFU Open Access FundCharleston Conference
 
16,25 16,40 h. astrid van wesenbeeck
16,25 16,40 h. astrid van wesenbeeck16,25 16,40 h. astrid van wesenbeeck
16,25 16,40 h. astrid van wesenbeeckFESABID
 
Jay patel Open Access TIPPA Midwest presentation june 2013
Jay patel Open Access TIPPA Midwest presentation june 2013Jay patel Open Access TIPPA Midwest presentation june 2013
Jay patel Open Access TIPPA Midwest presentation june 2013Jay Patel
 
UKSG Conference 2016 Breakout Session - The Predatory Publishing Phenomenon: ...
UKSG Conference 2016 Breakout Session - The Predatory Publishing Phenomenon: ...UKSG Conference 2016 Breakout Session - The Predatory Publishing Phenomenon: ...
UKSG Conference 2016 Breakout Session - The Predatory Publishing Phenomenon: ...UKSG: connecting the knowledge community
 
PeerJ at the Science and Tech Forum
PeerJ at the Science and Tech ForumPeerJ at the Science and Tech Forum
PeerJ at the Science and Tech ForumPeter Binfield
 
Introduction to the Directory of Open Access journals
Introduction to the Directory of Open Access journalsIntroduction to the Directory of Open Access journals
Introduction to the Directory of Open Access journalsIna Smith
 
Scholarly Publishing Expertise at the UT Libraries
Scholarly Publishing Expertise at the UT LibrariesScholarly Publishing Expertise at the UT Libraries
Scholarly Publishing Expertise at the UT LibrariesScholarlyCommTenn
 
Open Access 101 for the IFMSA NTD and Global Surgery Pre-GAs
Open Access 101 for the IFMSA NTD and Global Surgery Pre-GAsOpen Access 101 for the IFMSA NTD and Global Surgery Pre-GAs
Open Access 101 for the IFMSA NTD and Global Surgery Pre-GAsRight to Research
 
How UT Librarians Can Help You Secure (and Keep) NIH Funding
How UT Librarians Can Help You Secure (and Keep) NIH FundingHow UT Librarians Can Help You Secure (and Keep) NIH Funding
How UT Librarians Can Help You Secure (and Keep) NIH FundingScholarlyCommTenn
 
The value of scholarly-led, non-profit business model to achieve Open Access ...
The value of scholarly-led, non-profit business model to achieve Open Access ...The value of scholarly-led, non-profit business model to achieve Open Access ...
The value of scholarly-led, non-profit business model to achieve Open Access ...REDALYC
 
Questionable Publishers, National Scholarly Editor's Forum, Cape Town, July 3...
Questionable Publishers, National Scholarly Editor's Forum, Cape Town, July 3...Questionable Publishers, National Scholarly Editor's Forum, Cape Town, July 3...
Questionable Publishers, National Scholarly Editor's Forum, Cape Town, July 3...DOAJ (Directory of Open Access Journals)
 
Predatory publishing: pitfalls for the unwary. 25 Oct 2013
Predatory publishing: pitfalls for the unwary. 25 Oct 2013Predatory publishing: pitfalls for the unwary. 25 Oct 2013
Predatory publishing: pitfalls for the unwary. 25 Oct 2013Simon Huggard
 
Open Access Scholarship
Open Access ScholarshipOpen Access Scholarship
Open Access ScholarshipZera Day
 
Thinking about resources general
Thinking about resources generalThinking about resources general
Thinking about resources generalEISLibrarian
 
Open access publishing overview
Open access publishing overviewOpen access publishing overview
Open access publishing overviewMartin Weller
 
Open Access at Cardiff University - Sonja Haerkoenen
Open Access at Cardiff University - Sonja HaerkoenenOpen Access at Cardiff University - Sonja Haerkoenen
Open Access at Cardiff University - Sonja HaerkoenenCLICLibraries
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Sherpa Romeo
Sherpa RomeoSherpa Romeo
Sherpa Romeo
 
Understanding Open Access and Recent Developments Around the World
Understanding Open Access and Recent Developments Around the WorldUnderstanding Open Access and Recent Developments Around the World
Understanding Open Access and Recent Developments Around the World
 
How to Handle Article Processing Charges: SFU Open Access Fund
How to Handle Article Processing Charges: SFU Open Access FundHow to Handle Article Processing Charges: SFU Open Access Fund
How to Handle Article Processing Charges: SFU Open Access Fund
 
16,25 16,40 h. astrid van wesenbeeck
16,25 16,40 h. astrid van wesenbeeck16,25 16,40 h. astrid van wesenbeeck
16,25 16,40 h. astrid van wesenbeeck
 
Towards a transparent and open scholarly communication system
Towards a transparent and open scholarly communication systemTowards a transparent and open scholarly communication system
Towards a transparent and open scholarly communication system
 
Open: much more than a different business model.
Open: much more than a different business model.Open: much more than a different business model.
Open: much more than a different business model.
 
Jay patel Open Access TIPPA Midwest presentation june 2013
Jay patel Open Access TIPPA Midwest presentation june 2013Jay patel Open Access TIPPA Midwest presentation june 2013
Jay patel Open Access TIPPA Midwest presentation june 2013
 
UKSG Conference 2016 Breakout Session - The Predatory Publishing Phenomenon: ...
UKSG Conference 2016 Breakout Session - The Predatory Publishing Phenomenon: ...UKSG Conference 2016 Breakout Session - The Predatory Publishing Phenomenon: ...
UKSG Conference 2016 Breakout Session - The Predatory Publishing Phenomenon: ...
 
PeerJ at the Science and Tech Forum
PeerJ at the Science and Tech ForumPeerJ at the Science and Tech Forum
PeerJ at the Science and Tech Forum
 
Introduction to the Directory of Open Access journals
Introduction to the Directory of Open Access journalsIntroduction to the Directory of Open Access journals
Introduction to the Directory of Open Access journals
 
Scholarly Publishing Expertise at the UT Libraries
Scholarly Publishing Expertise at the UT LibrariesScholarly Publishing Expertise at the UT Libraries
Scholarly Publishing Expertise at the UT Libraries
 
Open Access 101 for the IFMSA NTD and Global Surgery Pre-GAs
Open Access 101 for the IFMSA NTD and Global Surgery Pre-GAsOpen Access 101 for the IFMSA NTD and Global Surgery Pre-GAs
Open Access 101 for the IFMSA NTD and Global Surgery Pre-GAs
 
How UT Librarians Can Help You Secure (and Keep) NIH Funding
How UT Librarians Can Help You Secure (and Keep) NIH FundingHow UT Librarians Can Help You Secure (and Keep) NIH Funding
How UT Librarians Can Help You Secure (and Keep) NIH Funding
 
The value of scholarly-led, non-profit business model to achieve Open Access ...
The value of scholarly-led, non-profit business model to achieve Open Access ...The value of scholarly-led, non-profit business model to achieve Open Access ...
The value of scholarly-led, non-profit business model to achieve Open Access ...
 
Questionable Publishers, National Scholarly Editor's Forum, Cape Town, July 3...
Questionable Publishers, National Scholarly Editor's Forum, Cape Town, July 3...Questionable Publishers, National Scholarly Editor's Forum, Cape Town, July 3...
Questionable Publishers, National Scholarly Editor's Forum, Cape Town, July 3...
 
Predatory publishing: pitfalls for the unwary. 25 Oct 2013
Predatory publishing: pitfalls for the unwary. 25 Oct 2013Predatory publishing: pitfalls for the unwary. 25 Oct 2013
Predatory publishing: pitfalls for the unwary. 25 Oct 2013
 
Open Access Scholarship
Open Access ScholarshipOpen Access Scholarship
Open Access Scholarship
 
Thinking about resources general
Thinking about resources generalThinking about resources general
Thinking about resources general
 
Open access publishing overview
Open access publishing overviewOpen access publishing overview
Open access publishing overview
 
Open Access at Cardiff University - Sonja Haerkoenen
Open Access at Cardiff University - Sonja HaerkoenenOpen Access at Cardiff University - Sonja Haerkoenen
Open Access at Cardiff University - Sonja Haerkoenen
 

Andere mochten auch

Magazine cover layouts
Magazine cover layoutsMagazine cover layouts
Magazine cover layoutsEvieBerryCBA15
 
Initial Idea Generation
Initial Idea GenerationInitial Idea Generation
Initial Idea GenerationEvieBerryCBA15
 
Me, myself and irene poster analysis
Me, myself and irene poster analysisMe, myself and irene poster analysis
Me, myself and irene poster analysisEvieBerryCBA15
 
WIT MOLD LIMITED Presentation_V1.6
WIT MOLD LIMITED Presentation_V1.6WIT MOLD LIMITED Presentation_V1.6
WIT MOLD LIMITED Presentation_V1.6Nancy Zhou
 
Tammy film poster analysis
Tammy film poster analysisTammy film poster analysis
Tammy film poster analysisEvieBerryCBA15
 
Love, Rosie film poster analysis
Love, Rosie film poster analysisLove, Rosie film poster analysis
Love, Rosie film poster analysisEvieBerryCBA15
 
The Conjuring Film Poster Analysis
The Conjuring Film Poster AnalysisThe Conjuring Film Poster Analysis
The Conjuring Film Poster AnalysisEvieBerryCBA15
 

Andere mochten auch (11)

Magazine cover layouts
Magazine cover layoutsMagazine cover layouts
Magazine cover layouts
 
Initial Idea Generation
Initial Idea GenerationInitial Idea Generation
Initial Idea Generation
 
Me, myself and irene poster analysis
Me, myself and irene poster analysisMe, myself and irene poster analysis
Me, myself and irene poster analysis
 
Film pitch final
Film pitch finalFilm pitch final
Film pitch final
 
Cover star
Cover starCover star
Cover star
 
WIT MOLD LIMITED Presentation_V1.6
WIT MOLD LIMITED Presentation_V1.6WIT MOLD LIMITED Presentation_V1.6
WIT MOLD LIMITED Presentation_V1.6
 
Magazine research
Magazine researchMagazine research
Magazine research
 
Tammy film poster analysis
Tammy film poster analysisTammy film poster analysis
Tammy film poster analysis
 
Love, Rosie film poster analysis
Love, Rosie film poster analysisLove, Rosie film poster analysis
Love, Rosie film poster analysis
 
Disability
DisabilityDisability
Disability
 
The Conjuring Film Poster Analysis
The Conjuring Film Poster AnalysisThe Conjuring Film Poster Analysis
The Conjuring Film Poster Analysis
 

Ähnlich wie Open access or open excess; libraries at a crossroads

You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? (NYAM Nursing)
You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? (NYAM Nursing)You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? (NYAM Nursing)
You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? (NYAM Nursing)Jill Cirasella
 
Open Science @ Instituto Gukbenkian de Ciência
Open Science @ Instituto Gukbenkian de CiênciaOpen Science @ Instituto Gukbenkian de Ciência
Open Science @ Instituto Gukbenkian de CiênciaMaria Antónia Correia
 
Publishing as a Public Intellectual
Publishing as a Public IntellectualPublishing as a Public Intellectual
Publishing as a Public IntellectualJill Cirasella
 
Open Access Mash-Up: Protecting Your Rights As an Author + Putting the Public...
Open Access Mash-Up: Protecting Your Rights As an Author + Putting the Public...Open Access Mash-Up: Protecting Your Rights As an Author + Putting the Public...
Open Access Mash-Up: Protecting Your Rights As an Author + Putting the Public...Jill Cirasella
 
Beyond Open Access: Facing the Real Problems
Beyond Open Access: Facing the Real ProblemsBeyond Open Access: Facing the Real Problems
Beyond Open Access: Facing the Real ProblemsPandelis Perakakis
 
You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? Understanding and Prote...
You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? Understanding and Prote...You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? Understanding and Prote...
You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? Understanding and Prote...Jill Cirasella
 
Marie Farge KB-150525
Marie Farge KB-150525Marie Farge KB-150525
Marie Farge KB-150525beaeel
 
Open access copyright and publishing - UoS guide
Open access copyright and publishing - UoS guideOpen access copyright and publishing - UoS guide
Open access copyright and publishing - UoS guidee1033930
 
How Publishers Can Thrive in an Open Access Marketplace
How Publishers Can Thrive in an Open Access MarketplaceHow Publishers Can Thrive in an Open Access Marketplace
How Publishers Can Thrive in an Open Access MarketplaceMarcus Banks
 
UKSG Conference 2017 Breakout - How publishers can thrive in an open access m...
UKSG Conference 2017 Breakout - How publishers can thrive in an open access m...UKSG Conference 2017 Breakout - How publishers can thrive in an open access m...
UKSG Conference 2017 Breakout - How publishers can thrive in an open access m...UKSG: connecting the knowledge community
 
Changing the Structure of Scholarly Publishing: Open Access, Open Archives, a...
Changing the Structure of Scholarly Publishing: Open Access, Open Archives, a...Changing the Structure of Scholarly Publishing: Open Access, Open Archives, a...
Changing the Structure of Scholarly Publishing: Open Access, Open Archives, a...John McDonald
 
Want to make your research OA so where do you publish?
Want to make your research OA so where do you publish? Want to make your research OA so where do you publish?
Want to make your research OA so where do you publish? Open Access India
 
What to Know Before You Submit to a Journal...or Sign Its Contract
What to Know Before You Submit to a Journal...or Sign Its ContractWhat to Know Before You Submit to a Journal...or Sign Its Contract
What to Know Before You Submit to a Journal...or Sign Its ContractJill Cirasella
 
Flexible (subsidiaries) models for funding open access in journal publishing
Flexible (subsidiaries) models for funding open access in journal publishingFlexible (subsidiaries) models for funding open access in journal publishing
Flexible (subsidiaries) models for funding open access in journal publishing@cristobalcobo
 
Open_Access_Publishing (1).pptx
Open_Access_Publishing (1).pptxOpen_Access_Publishing (1).pptx
Open_Access_Publishing (1).pptxbhavna321001
 

Ähnlich wie Open access or open excess; libraries at a crossroads (20)

You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? (NYAM Nursing)
You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? (NYAM Nursing)You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? (NYAM Nursing)
You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? (NYAM Nursing)
 
Open Science @ Instituto Gukbenkian de Ciência
Open Science @ Instituto Gukbenkian de CiênciaOpen Science @ Instituto Gukbenkian de Ciência
Open Science @ Instituto Gukbenkian de Ciência
 
Publishing as a Public Intellectual
Publishing as a Public IntellectualPublishing as a Public Intellectual
Publishing as a Public Intellectual
 
How to publish - Springer Nature
How to publish - Springer NatureHow to publish - Springer Nature
How to publish - Springer Nature
 
Open Access Mash-Up: Protecting Your Rights As an Author + Putting the Public...
Open Access Mash-Up: Protecting Your Rights As an Author + Putting the Public...Open Access Mash-Up: Protecting Your Rights As an Author + Putting the Public...
Open Access Mash-Up: Protecting Your Rights As an Author + Putting the Public...
 
Beyond Open Access: Facing the Real Problems
Beyond Open Access: Facing the Real ProblemsBeyond Open Access: Facing the Real Problems
Beyond Open Access: Facing the Real Problems
 
You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? Understanding and Prote...
You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? Understanding and Prote...You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? Understanding and Prote...
You Know What You Write, But Do You Know Your Rights? Understanding and Prote...
 
Marie Farge KB-150525
Marie Farge KB-150525Marie Farge KB-150525
Marie Farge KB-150525
 
Open access copyright and publishing - UoS guide
Open access copyright and publishing - UoS guideOpen access copyright and publishing - UoS guide
Open access copyright and publishing - UoS guide
 
How Publishers Can Thrive in an Open Access Marketplace
How Publishers Can Thrive in an Open Access MarketplaceHow Publishers Can Thrive in an Open Access Marketplace
How Publishers Can Thrive in an Open Access Marketplace
 
UKSG Conference 2017 Breakout - How publishers can thrive in an open access m...
UKSG Conference 2017 Breakout - How publishers can thrive in an open access m...UKSG Conference 2017 Breakout - How publishers can thrive in an open access m...
UKSG Conference 2017 Breakout - How publishers can thrive in an open access m...
 
Importance of OA for academic libraries
Importance of OA for academic librariesImportance of OA for academic libraries
Importance of OA for academic libraries
 
Open Access: the basics & how to do it without paying
Open Access: the basics & how to do it without payingOpen Access: the basics & how to do it without paying
Open Access: the basics & how to do it without paying
 
Open Access explained
Open Access explainedOpen Access explained
Open Access explained
 
Changing the Structure of Scholarly Publishing: Open Access, Open Archives, a...
Changing the Structure of Scholarly Publishing: Open Access, Open Archives, a...Changing the Structure of Scholarly Publishing: Open Access, Open Archives, a...
Changing the Structure of Scholarly Publishing: Open Access, Open Archives, a...
 
Information on publishing
Information on publishingInformation on publishing
Information on publishing
 
Want to make your research OA so where do you publish?
Want to make your research OA so where do you publish? Want to make your research OA so where do you publish?
Want to make your research OA so where do you publish?
 
What to Know Before You Submit to a Journal...or Sign Its Contract
What to Know Before You Submit to a Journal...or Sign Its ContractWhat to Know Before You Submit to a Journal...or Sign Its Contract
What to Know Before You Submit to a Journal...or Sign Its Contract
 
Flexible (subsidiaries) models for funding open access in journal publishing
Flexible (subsidiaries) models for funding open access in journal publishingFlexible (subsidiaries) models for funding open access in journal publishing
Flexible (subsidiaries) models for funding open access in journal publishing
 
Open_Access_Publishing (1).pptx
Open_Access_Publishing (1).pptxOpen_Access_Publishing (1).pptx
Open_Access_Publishing (1).pptx
 

Mehr von presentacionesCRECS2015

Futuro de las revistas: ¿es posible la profesionalización?
Futuro de las revistas: ¿es posible la profesionalización?Futuro de las revistas: ¿es posible la profesionalización?
Futuro de las revistas: ¿es posible la profesionalización?presentacionesCRECS2015
 
Las revistas de comunicación en las redes sociales científicas.
Las revistas de comunicación en las redes sociales científicas. Las revistas de comunicación en las redes sociales científicas.
Las revistas de comunicación en las redes sociales científicas. presentacionesCRECS2015
 
Estrategia de internacionalización y consolidación de Miguel Hernández Commun...
Estrategia de internacionalización y consolidación de Miguel Hernández Commun...Estrategia de internacionalización y consolidación de Miguel Hernández Commun...
Estrategia de internacionalización y consolidación de Miguel Hernández Commun...presentacionesCRECS2015
 
La internacionalización de las revistas científicas españolas.
La internacionalización de las revistas científicas españolas.La internacionalización de las revistas científicas españolas.
La internacionalización de las revistas científicas españolas.presentacionesCRECS2015
 
¿De qué hablamos cuando hablamos de internacionalización de las revistas? Ref...
¿De qué hablamos cuando hablamos de internacionalización de las revistas? Ref...¿De qué hablamos cuando hablamos de internacionalización de las revistas? Ref...
¿De qué hablamos cuando hablamos de internacionalización de las revistas? Ref...presentacionesCRECS2015
 
Resultados provisionales para una categorización de revistas de Ciencias Huma...
Resultados provisionales para una categorización de revistas de Ciencias Huma...Resultados provisionales para una categorización de revistas de Ciencias Huma...
Resultados provisionales para una categorización de revistas de Ciencias Huma...presentacionesCRECS2015
 
30 años de revistas científicas del área de comunicación en Portugal: debilid...
30 años de revistas científicas del área de comunicación en Portugal: debilid...30 años de revistas científicas del área de comunicación en Portugal: debilid...
30 años de revistas científicas del área de comunicación en Portugal: debilid...presentacionesCRECS2015
 
Consecuencias de los procesos de evaluación y acreditación científica de las ...
Consecuencias de los procesos de evaluación y acreditación científica de las ...Consecuencias de los procesos de evaluación y acreditación científica de las ...
Consecuencias de los procesos de evaluación y acreditación científica de las ...presentacionesCRECS2015
 
La calidad editorial de las revistas en el Catálogo Latindex: prospectiva de ...
La calidad editorial de las revistas en el Catálogo Latindex: prospectiva de ...La calidad editorial de las revistas en el Catálogo Latindex: prospectiva de ...
La calidad editorial de las revistas en el Catálogo Latindex: prospectiva de ...presentacionesCRECS2015
 
Voluntarismo y profesionalización en la gestión de Revista de Psicodidáctica ...
Voluntarismo y profesionalización en la gestión de Revista de Psicodidáctica ...Voluntarismo y profesionalización en la gestión de Revista de Psicodidáctica ...
Voluntarismo y profesionalización en la gestión de Revista de Psicodidáctica ...presentacionesCRECS2015
 
El sistema de revisión por pares: ¿cuáles son sus actores, factores intervini...
El sistema de revisión por pares: ¿cuáles son sus actores, factores intervini...El sistema de revisión por pares: ¿cuáles son sus actores, factores intervini...
El sistema de revisión por pares: ¿cuáles son sus actores, factores intervini...presentacionesCRECS2015
 
Divergencias entre el proceso de publicación científica y las necesidades de ...
Divergencias entre el proceso de publicación científica y las necesidades de ...Divergencias entre el proceso de publicación científica y las necesidades de ...
Divergencias entre el proceso de publicación científica y las necesidades de ...presentacionesCRECS2015
 
Revistas científicas como comunidades de valor.
Revistas científicas como comunidades de valor.Revistas científicas como comunidades de valor.
Revistas científicas como comunidades de valor.presentacionesCRECS2015
 
Estrategias para mejorar la visibilidad y difusión de la revista Fotocinema: ...
Estrategias para mejorar la visibilidad y difusión de la revista Fotocinema: ...Estrategias para mejorar la visibilidad y difusión de la revista Fotocinema: ...
Estrategias para mejorar la visibilidad y difusión de la revista Fotocinema: ...presentacionesCRECS2015
 
Wimblu: diez años formando investigadores.
Wimblu: diez años formando investigadores.Wimblu: diez años formando investigadores.
Wimblu: diez años formando investigadores.presentacionesCRECS2015
 
Revistas científicas UPV : un proyecto de integración para la mejora de su vi...
Revistas científicas UPV : un proyecto de integración para la mejora de su vi...Revistas científicas UPV : un proyecto de integración para la mejora de su vi...
Revistas científicas UPV : un proyecto de integración para la mejora de su vi...presentacionesCRECS2015
 
Data journals y data papers: ¿nuevas revistas, viejas costumbres?
Data journals y data papers: ¿nuevas revistas, viejas costumbres?Data journals y data papers: ¿nuevas revistas, viejas costumbres?
Data journals y data papers: ¿nuevas revistas, viejas costumbres?presentacionesCRECS2015
 
Editores + bibliotecarios + OJS = Revistas científicas competitivas.
Editores + bibliotecarios + OJS = Revistas científicas competitivas.Editores + bibliotecarios + OJS = Revistas científicas competitivas.
Editores + bibliotecarios + OJS = Revistas científicas competitivas.presentacionesCRECS2015
 
Balance de la experiencia con el acceso abierto de los editores de revistas c...
Balance de la experiencia con el acceso abierto de los editores de revistas c...Balance de la experiencia con el acceso abierto de los editores de revistas c...
Balance de la experiencia con el acceso abierto de los editores de revistas c...presentacionesCRECS2015
 

Mehr von presentacionesCRECS2015 (20)

Futuro de las revistas: ¿es posible la profesionalización?
Futuro de las revistas: ¿es posible la profesionalización?Futuro de las revistas: ¿es posible la profesionalización?
Futuro de las revistas: ¿es posible la profesionalización?
 
Las revistas de comunicación en las redes sociales científicas.
Las revistas de comunicación en las redes sociales científicas. Las revistas de comunicación en las redes sociales científicas.
Las revistas de comunicación en las redes sociales científicas.
 
Estrategia de internacionalización y consolidación de Miguel Hernández Commun...
Estrategia de internacionalización y consolidación de Miguel Hernández Commun...Estrategia de internacionalización y consolidación de Miguel Hernández Commun...
Estrategia de internacionalización y consolidación de Miguel Hernández Commun...
 
La internacionalización de las revistas científicas españolas.
La internacionalización de las revistas científicas españolas.La internacionalización de las revistas científicas españolas.
La internacionalización de las revistas científicas españolas.
 
¿De qué hablamos cuando hablamos de internacionalización de las revistas? Ref...
¿De qué hablamos cuando hablamos de internacionalización de las revistas? Ref...¿De qué hablamos cuando hablamos de internacionalización de las revistas? Ref...
¿De qué hablamos cuando hablamos de internacionalización de las revistas? Ref...
 
Resultados provisionales para una categorización de revistas de Ciencias Huma...
Resultados provisionales para una categorización de revistas de Ciencias Huma...Resultados provisionales para una categorización de revistas de Ciencias Huma...
Resultados provisionales para una categorización de revistas de Ciencias Huma...
 
30 años de revistas científicas del área de comunicación en Portugal: debilid...
30 años de revistas científicas del área de comunicación en Portugal: debilid...30 años de revistas científicas del área de comunicación en Portugal: debilid...
30 años de revistas científicas del área de comunicación en Portugal: debilid...
 
Consecuencias de los procesos de evaluación y acreditación científica de las ...
Consecuencias de los procesos de evaluación y acreditación científica de las ...Consecuencias de los procesos de evaluación y acreditación científica de las ...
Consecuencias de los procesos de evaluación y acreditación científica de las ...
 
La calidad editorial de las revistas en el Catálogo Latindex: prospectiva de ...
La calidad editorial de las revistas en el Catálogo Latindex: prospectiva de ...La calidad editorial de las revistas en el Catálogo Latindex: prospectiva de ...
La calidad editorial de las revistas en el Catálogo Latindex: prospectiva de ...
 
Presentación de Anuario ThinkEPI 2015.
Presentación de Anuario ThinkEPI 2015.Presentación de Anuario ThinkEPI 2015.
Presentación de Anuario ThinkEPI 2015.
 
Voluntarismo y profesionalización en la gestión de Revista de Psicodidáctica ...
Voluntarismo y profesionalización en la gestión de Revista de Psicodidáctica ...Voluntarismo y profesionalización en la gestión de Revista de Psicodidáctica ...
Voluntarismo y profesionalización en la gestión de Revista de Psicodidáctica ...
 
El sistema de revisión por pares: ¿cuáles son sus actores, factores intervini...
El sistema de revisión por pares: ¿cuáles son sus actores, factores intervini...El sistema de revisión por pares: ¿cuáles son sus actores, factores intervini...
El sistema de revisión por pares: ¿cuáles son sus actores, factores intervini...
 
Divergencias entre el proceso de publicación científica y las necesidades de ...
Divergencias entre el proceso de publicación científica y las necesidades de ...Divergencias entre el proceso de publicación científica y las necesidades de ...
Divergencias entre el proceso de publicación científica y las necesidades de ...
 
Revistas científicas como comunidades de valor.
Revistas científicas como comunidades de valor.Revistas científicas como comunidades de valor.
Revistas científicas como comunidades de valor.
 
Estrategias para mejorar la visibilidad y difusión de la revista Fotocinema: ...
Estrategias para mejorar la visibilidad y difusión de la revista Fotocinema: ...Estrategias para mejorar la visibilidad y difusión de la revista Fotocinema: ...
Estrategias para mejorar la visibilidad y difusión de la revista Fotocinema: ...
 
Wimblu: diez años formando investigadores.
Wimblu: diez años formando investigadores.Wimblu: diez años formando investigadores.
Wimblu: diez años formando investigadores.
 
Revistas científicas UPV : un proyecto de integración para la mejora de su vi...
Revistas científicas UPV : un proyecto de integración para la mejora de su vi...Revistas científicas UPV : un proyecto de integración para la mejora de su vi...
Revistas científicas UPV : un proyecto de integración para la mejora de su vi...
 
Data journals y data papers: ¿nuevas revistas, viejas costumbres?
Data journals y data papers: ¿nuevas revistas, viejas costumbres?Data journals y data papers: ¿nuevas revistas, viejas costumbres?
Data journals y data papers: ¿nuevas revistas, viejas costumbres?
 
Editores + bibliotecarios + OJS = Revistas científicas competitivas.
Editores + bibliotecarios + OJS = Revistas científicas competitivas.Editores + bibliotecarios + OJS = Revistas científicas competitivas.
Editores + bibliotecarios + OJS = Revistas científicas competitivas.
 
Balance de la experiencia con el acceso abierto de los editores de revistas c...
Balance de la experiencia con el acceso abierto de los editores de revistas c...Balance de la experiencia con el acceso abierto de los editores de revistas c...
Balance de la experiencia con el acceso abierto de los editores de revistas c...
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Juan Pablo Sugiura - eCommerce Day Bolivia 2024
Juan Pablo Sugiura - eCommerce Day Bolivia 2024Juan Pablo Sugiura - eCommerce Day Bolivia 2024
Juan Pablo Sugiura - eCommerce Day Bolivia 2024eCommerce Institute
 
Circle Of Life Civics Presentation Burning Issue
Circle Of Life Civics Presentation Burning IssueCircle Of Life Civics Presentation Burning Issue
Circle Of Life Civics Presentation Burning Issuebdavis22
 
Burning Issue presentation of Zhazgul N. , Cycle 54
Burning Issue presentation of Zhazgul N. , Cycle 54Burning Issue presentation of Zhazgul N. , Cycle 54
Burning Issue presentation of Zhazgul N. , Cycle 54ZhazgulNurdinova
 
Making AI Behave: Using Knowledge Domains to Produce Useful, Trustworthy Results
Making AI Behave: Using Knowledge Domains to Produce Useful, Trustworthy ResultsMaking AI Behave: Using Knowledge Domains to Produce Useful, Trustworthy Results
Making AI Behave: Using Knowledge Domains to Produce Useful, Trustworthy ResultsAccess Innovations, Inc.
 
The Real Story Of Project Manager/Scrum Master From Where It Came?!
The Real Story Of Project Manager/Scrum Master From Where It Came?!The Real Story Of Project Manager/Scrum Master From Where It Came?!
The Real Story Of Project Manager/Scrum Master From Where It Came?!Loay Mohamed Ibrahim Aly
 
Communication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptx
Communication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptxCommunication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptx
Communication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptxkb31670
 
Communication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptx
Communication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptxCommunication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptx
Communication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptxkb31670
 
Machine learning workshop, CZU Prague 2024
Machine learning workshop, CZU Prague 2024Machine learning workshop, CZU Prague 2024
Machine learning workshop, CZU Prague 2024Gokulks007
 
ISO 25964-1Working Group ISO/TC 46/SC 9/WG 8
ISO 25964-1Working Group ISO/TC 46/SC 9/WG 8ISO 25964-1Working Group ISO/TC 46/SC 9/WG 8
ISO 25964-1Working Group ISO/TC 46/SC 9/WG 8Access Innovations, Inc.
 
IPO OFFERINGS by mint hindustantimes.pdf
IPO OFFERINGS by mint hindustantimes.pdfIPO OFFERINGS by mint hindustantimes.pdf
IPO OFFERINGS by mint hindustantimes.pdfratnasehgal888
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (10)

Juan Pablo Sugiura - eCommerce Day Bolivia 2024
Juan Pablo Sugiura - eCommerce Day Bolivia 2024Juan Pablo Sugiura - eCommerce Day Bolivia 2024
Juan Pablo Sugiura - eCommerce Day Bolivia 2024
 
Circle Of Life Civics Presentation Burning Issue
Circle Of Life Civics Presentation Burning IssueCircle Of Life Civics Presentation Burning Issue
Circle Of Life Civics Presentation Burning Issue
 
Burning Issue presentation of Zhazgul N. , Cycle 54
Burning Issue presentation of Zhazgul N. , Cycle 54Burning Issue presentation of Zhazgul N. , Cycle 54
Burning Issue presentation of Zhazgul N. , Cycle 54
 
Making AI Behave: Using Knowledge Domains to Produce Useful, Trustworthy Results
Making AI Behave: Using Knowledge Domains to Produce Useful, Trustworthy ResultsMaking AI Behave: Using Knowledge Domains to Produce Useful, Trustworthy Results
Making AI Behave: Using Knowledge Domains to Produce Useful, Trustworthy Results
 
The Real Story Of Project Manager/Scrum Master From Where It Came?!
The Real Story Of Project Manager/Scrum Master From Where It Came?!The Real Story Of Project Manager/Scrum Master From Where It Came?!
The Real Story Of Project Manager/Scrum Master From Where It Came?!
 
Communication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptx
Communication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptxCommunication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptx
Communication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptx
 
Communication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptx
Communication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptxCommunication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptx
Communication Accommodation Theory Kaylyn Benton.pptx
 
Machine learning workshop, CZU Prague 2024
Machine learning workshop, CZU Prague 2024Machine learning workshop, CZU Prague 2024
Machine learning workshop, CZU Prague 2024
 
ISO 25964-1Working Group ISO/TC 46/SC 9/WG 8
ISO 25964-1Working Group ISO/TC 46/SC 9/WG 8ISO 25964-1Working Group ISO/TC 46/SC 9/WG 8
ISO 25964-1Working Group ISO/TC 46/SC 9/WG 8
 
IPO OFFERINGS by mint hindustantimes.pdf
IPO OFFERINGS by mint hindustantimes.pdfIPO OFFERINGS by mint hindustantimes.pdf
IPO OFFERINGS by mint hindustantimes.pdf
 

Open access or open excess; libraries at a crossroads

  • 1. Open Access or Open Excess; libraries at a crossroads Leo Waaijers.
  • 2. When scientific and scholarly publishing is no longer seen as copyright exploitation but as a service, as is the case in the OA paradigm, there is a need for a market where quality of the service can be matched against price.
  • 3. Where are we now? Dominant business model Authors’ perception: publishing is ‘free’. In fact they give away their copyrights, completely and exclusively! Publishers exploit the acquired copyright monopolies. Effects • Packaged products (‘Big deals’) • Permission needed for re-use (including repository storage) • Advance payments • Exorbitant profit margins* The perfect business model *http://svpow.com/2012/01/13/the-obscene-profits-of-commercial-scholarly-publishers
  • 4. In theory, yes. OA publishing is a market oriented service (i.e. organising peer review) for authors as opposed to the monopolistic exploitation of copyrights. Can Open Access cure this?
  • 7. Fees and quality vary widely Average prices1,2 : No fee OA journals: € 0 Fee based OA journals: € 904 Hybrid journals: € 2727 All three categories include good and bad journals. So, there is room for price/perfomance comparisons, i.e. a market place. 1. A study of open access journals using article processing charges. David J. Solomon, Bo-Christer Björk. August 2012. http://www.openaccesspublishing.org/apc2/ 2. Developing an effective market for open access processing charges. Bo-Christer Björk, David J. Solomon. March 2014. http://www.wellcome.ac.uk/stellent/groups/corporatesite/@policy_communications/documents/web _document/wtp055910.pdf
  • 8. Open Excess or Open Access? Publisher keeps big (OA) deal Author publishes for free Library pays the annual invoice in advance Publisher serves author ‘Author’ pays publication fee Libarary organises the OA market Hybrid publishers e.g. Springer deal, NL; SCOAP3 deal*, CERN; …. OA publishers e.g. PLOS; MDPI; Copernicus, BioMedCentral, …. We have arrived at a crossroads http://scoap3.org/scoap3journals/journals-apc Open Excess Open Access *
  • 9. Principles • Named crowd sourcing • Academia only • Structured via Journal Score Cards • Transparant price information
  • 10. Two Journal Score Cards 1. Base Journal Score Card 18 item questionnaire leading to a 1-5 score, analysing a journal web site’s transparency, usually completed by libraries*, takes 15 to 20 minutes per journal. * Resuming their original professional role as quality monitor. 2. Valuation Journal Score Card 4 item questionnaire leading to 1-5 score, experience based reality check, usually completed by authors and editors*, takes 3 minutes per journal. * Spontaneously, or invited by their library or publisher.
  • 11. Valuation Score ≥ 3 < 3 Base Score ≥ 3 Strong journal Threat (to author) Journal may not meet its promises < 3 Opportunity (to publisher) Improve journal’s web site Weaker journal producing a SWOT matrix
  • 13. QOAM becomes the meeting point where shopping authors select a journal to publish their article in, publishers may find out how to improve their journal and funders, policy makers, journalists and the public at large enter a transparent academic publishing environment.
  • 14. Please spread the word. QOAM is an academic self-help instrument that fully depends on the contributions of libraries, authors and journal editors. It is independent of publishers although a growing list of publishers have included their OA and hybrid journals in QOAM for academic judgement. Today QOAM has 16.000+ journals waiting to be scored. Your comments and questions are most welcome via QOAM’s contact form. Thank you very much! Leo Waaijers. Take home message