SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 10
FACULTY OF THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT



                                           SUSD0001. S1 - 2010
                 Sustainable Development & the Urban Environment



                                      Course Convenor: Professor James Weirick
                                Tutors: Vivien Chow - Marika Hahn - Kathleen McDowell




                                                    Essay Topic:




Evaluating a study case where designing for occupants with sustainable criteria and an adequate site analysis, allowed
                        achieving a high performance and low energy consumption building.




                               Nicolas Carbone Gamarra – Student Number: z3281988
                                                 May 24 – 2010
SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment
                                                                                                 2010




                                                                                                   24-05-2010




UNSW. Fbe   Master in Sustainable Development. |                                  Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010

                                                   Page 2 of 10
SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment
                                                                                                               2010

        EVALUATING A STUDY CASE WHERE DESIGNING FOR OCCUPANTS WITH SUSTAINABLE
            CRITERIA AND AN ADEQUATE SITE ANALYSIS, ALLOWED ACHIEVING A HIGH
                   PERFORMANCE AND LOW ENERGY CONSUMPTION BUILDING.


                                           Nicolas Carbone-Gamarra
                                UNSW - SUSD0001 | Master of Sustainable Development

                                                             ****


It is broadly accepted that architectural design is more            two centuries. Examples of this could be the enormous
effective when designing for future occupants                       advances in transportation, building structures and
addressing their needs and challenges, but also it is well          power supplies. Accordingly it is equally important to
known that currently, functional modern architecture by             notice how energy consumption rate has increased due
itself is not necessary sustainable over the long term.             to poorly constructed buildings. This was illustrated by
Therefore, it is becoming increasingly important to                 the Worldwatch Institute Report which explains that
review the architectural design criteria along with a               buildings in the United States for example use 17% of
clear understanding of the natural processes and their              the total freshwater flows and 25% of harvested wood.
interactions with human needs incorporating the concept             In addition, they are responsible not only for the 50% of
of sustainable development and ESD criteria                         (CFC) production and 40% of the total energy
(Environmental Sustainable Design). In the pursuit of               consumption, but also for generating 33% of CO2
these qualities, many commercial buildings are being                emissions in the country (Mendler & Odell 2000).
designed to become sustainable identifying the energy
uses and proposing more effective materials according               Moreover, as populations grow energy consumption
to the specific site and climate condition in which they            also increases, driving societies to deplete natural
are immerse. Although a variety of approaches have                  resources that could severely compromise our
being reviewed, this essay will focus on evaluating a               development in the near future (Sachs 2004, p.1). That
study case where designing for occupants with                       is why researchers have shown increasing concern about
sustainable criteria and an adequate site analysis,                 the world energy demand rate, which is expected to
allowed achieving a high performance and low energy                 climb 50 % to 80 % above 1990, levels (Omer 2008,
consumption building also delightful, functional,                   p.2266). Naturally, it is becoming increasingly
productive and regenerative by design. The information              necessary to consider the designing and promotion of
given in this essay will be structured in five sections.            low-energy buildings in a cost-effective and
The first will expose the energy problem and the                    environmentally responsible way to achieve not only the
increasing tendency of energy consumption rates. Then,              more effective, but also the least expensive sustainable
a description of the building situation and an evaluation           strategy as possible. Passive and low energy architecture
of some site conditions will be presented. Later, an                has been proposed and investigated in different
architectural critique is offered in order to understand            locations of the world addressing in all cases the
the main strategies for functionality. In addition a                concept of sustainable development. Therefore, by
review of the main ESD criteria used during the design              incorporating design strategies that exploit these
phase will be exposed. Finally the results of the analysis          principles may be the way of moving in the pursuit of
will lead to suggestions and conclusions for improving              economical and environmental sustainability.
the architectural designing process in the pursuit of
sustainability.                                                     The case of „30 The Bond‟ reflects a sustainable
                                                                    building rated with 5 stars achieved from the Green Star
First of all it is important to understand that energy has          Office as Built rating tool (Green Star), in which
not only been part of sustainable development, but it               sustainability, performance and economical aspects
also represents development itself. It is widely known              where key issues to design, not only addressing site
that, high levels of energy inputs have allowed human               conditions and climate variables but also expectations,
development to experience rapid growth during the last              necessities and aspirations of future occupants.

UNSW. Fbe    Master in Sustainable Development. |                                               Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010

                                                        Page 3 of 10
SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment
                                                                                                               2010

According to the (OECD., 2002) in (Godfaurd 2005),                 should carefully investigate the full potential of site,
“Sustainable buildings can be defined as those buildings           building organisation, shape and climate influences to
that have minimum adverse impacts on the built and                 maximise the desired levels of comfort or protection to
natural environment striving for integral quality;                 future occupants from unwanted influences. The
including economic, social and environmental                       building skin for instance, should be designed for
performance in a broad way”. 30 The Bond is located in             adaptation to the specific climate, orientation or natural
30-34 Hickson Road, Millers Point Sydney; and is a                 conditions of the individual site and by doing this to
leading example of social and environmental                        achieve better performance to the specific site
sustainability within commercial objectives, being the             conditions identifying possible potentials and
first CBD office building in Australia to commit to a 5            diminishing the uses of artificial sources for interior
star energy rating with lower CO2 emissions than a                 climate. In this case: continuously sun exposition from
typical office building (Bovis Lend lease – “The Bond              early hours until sunset and strong West and South West
Project Data Sheet” - June 06).                                    winds affected the full height glazing. So the external
                                                                   shading system had to deal with those difficulties to be
As it was mentioned before, “Site Analysis” played a               certain to response and be reliably even through periods
huge role in determining which strategies were the most            of high winds. On the other hand, day lighting, shading,
suitable to implement in the design. In the case of 30-34          air flows or solar radiation along with protection from
Hickson Rd for instance, it is a very constricted site,            noise and air pollution can become important factors in
with only three exposed facades being the fourth a                 the designing of any building skin. Here is where double
heritage hand hewn listed sandstone wall built by                  facades may come into play with intelligent solar
convicts in early 1840‟s (Moreton 2006). The                       control systems or mechanical operable devices that
incorporation of this feature into the building is one of          may enable to fairly reduce the energy consumption and
the highlights of the development because it gives                 at the same time to improve internal performance of the
thermal mass, humidity control and natural lightning               building
representing also a commitment with heritage and
history. But before using the historic element in the              Finally the studied site is connected with three heritage
design, some previous actions were required to fix and             buildings from the 1840s that have been preserved as
clean the original drainage cavity and also the                    part of the cultural and social project. Due to the
surrounding soil full of bitumen residues from the old             particular location, the project confronts several
construction. According to Moreton 2006 “Complex                   challenges to address. However, not only site
contamination both in liquid and solid forms had existed           restrictions but also communal consultation where the
for many years on the site after the Gasworks ceased               main sources of inputs that were taken into
operations in 1921”. In early periods for example, a               consideration for achieving the final design.
chemical DPC was introduced into the connection
points between the rock face and the stone walls of the            More than 300 people participated actively during the
building to form a barrier against further seepage but             design process, being consulted in several occasions
unfortunately this chemical product is not only toxic but          from conceptualization to completion. The answers
also hazardous for people. Therefore, before using the             obtained, provided the main architectural input which
historic wall it was necessary to clean deeply the area            was that the building should not be designed to achieve
affected and moreover to remove all the toxic and                  certain level of sustainability according to a specific
hazardous materials.                                               rating tool; but that it should be planed to secure the
                                                                   desire levels of comfort, and performance in accordance
Opposite to this sandstone wall is the main façade                 to the sustainable criteria hence, achieving better
facing west which orientation is very complicate to deal           standards and reduced energy consumption rates. This
with, when designing for sustainability due to the lack            statement is very important because it sets “people‟s
of shading, the constant direct insolation and glare. In           comfort” as the most important issue, when deciding
the urban design context for instance, the building                strategies to be addressed. “By putting people at the
envelope played a huge role to achieve certain levels of           heart of their project „30 The Bond‟, intended to
sustainability because it transmit daylight, direct solar          develop a process whereby the project reflects the
radiation and fresh air; all qualities that improve life at        aspirations of the people who will ultimately be using
the interior of the building itself. Therefore, designers          and interacting with it on a daily basis” (Moreton 2006).

UNSW. Fbe    Master in Sustainable Development. |                                               Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010

                                                         Page 4 of 10
SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment
                                                                                                                2010

An integration of the new development into the existing           that the internal performance as well as the occupants
community with a minimum of disruption or friction                comfort and wellbeing was an important factor to define
was achieved by incorporating and respecting the                  the designing strategy and specifications, enhancing a
human environment, local residents, community groups              productive and high quality working space. This shows
and other businesses in the area.                                 the importance of designing for occupants in first place
                                                                  rather than designing for achieving certain ratting or
30 the Bond, shows a good example in which                        recognition; at the end, occupants will be using the
collaboration between developers and the community                space and they required to fulfil their needs in terms of
may work to profit everyone involved achieving not                comfort, happiness and wellbeing to develop efficiency,
only technical sustainability but also social development         productivity and economical effectiveness without
in an urban scale. For instance, an agreement between             compromising their own health. Accordingly to Lend
Lend Lease, Deutsche Office Trust and the residents               Lease CEO (Asia Pacific) Ross Taylor “this new work
involving the public areas of the development, ends in a          environment, with the internal building design and
commitment between the three parties to modify the                layout will be a place for „our people‟ that will inspire
rooftop by lowering it within the building envelope and           and drive our distinct culture in years to come” (Lend
also creating a space used to grow a native wildflower            Lease 2003).
garden improving the views for residents in the
surrounding buildings.                                            Another relevant input delivered from the internal
                                                                  consultations, was the aspiration to use excellence in
As well as the consultation and involvement of the local          materials selection that could achieve strict
community, owners and developers looked for inputs                environmental guidelines improving interior fitout and
from their own staff. The result was a series of ESD              also air quality. To achieve this high level of
„Aspirations‟ rated in order of importance and                    expectations, materials selection included bamboo,
significance. These inputs, lead to some design                   wool, sisal, goat hair, linen, cotton, and leather; all these
definitions and built an accurate brief which included; in        natural materials are well known for their high qualities,
first place wide open floor plans, with services cores            environmental credentials and their contribution to
sitting on the edge to enhance high levels of planning            improve healthy environments. The sense of quality can
efficiencies, and day lighting effectiveness. These               be recognized due to the constant testing and quality
features are complemented with building balconies and             measurements. For instance in the selection of bamboo,
open areas to achieve versatility and to improve the              Lend Lease not only looked at a range of factors
interior air quality securing constant integration of             including the manufacturing process, coatings and the
views and human contact. An example of it could be the            glues used but also at practicalities such as the hardness
atrium which is a public space encouraging interaction            and durability. Other important factor to choose high
between the building‟s occupants and the community. It            quality materials was the fact that the building should
contains internal stairs, glass lifts and double storey           achieve important levels of versatility and openness
“pods” which are used for shared activities creating a            therefore the possibility to re-arrange spaces was a
great sense of connection (Moreton 2006). The design              constant. A great example of this are the eastern crafted,
features also incorporates glass lifts, open stairs,              timber slatted panels, which give the impression of
balconies and terraces all the ones, which contribute to          being a single partition forming part of a wall but when
enhancing visibility and connectivity, maximising                 opened, either individually or in any combination,
functionality and achieving great levels of commitment            reveal the expansive west views, over the harbour and
and comfort.                                                      docks.

Addressing the open and clear lines of sight within the           Finally but equally important, is the desire to reduce the
building, modular and flexible workstation units were             green house gas emissions, goal accomplished by the
provided and installed within the office areas to ensure          reduction of a 30% of CO2 emissions compared with a
efficiency and practicality maintaining the quality of the        common office building (Moreton 2006). This has been
working environment. The environmental credentials of             achieved through the use of natural ventilation in
this workstations supplied, were also tested to ensure            wintergardens and meeting rooms, passive chilled beam
they met with the strict criteria for all materials and           for cooling, fully operable shading on the facades and
processes used throughout the development. It is clear            natural daylight through the skylight over the atrium

UNSW. Fbe    Master in Sustainable Development. |                                               Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010

                                                        Page 5 of 10
SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment
                                                                                                               2010

More specifically, chilled beams reduce the needs of air           But To understand the reasons that had „30 The Bond‟
conditioning by pumping chilled water through cooling              to push over the common benchmarks, first it is
elements in the ceiling, the ones that creates a natural           necessary to understand the implications of building
convection process of hot air rising and cold air falling.         environment in occupants performance and how low
This process allows natural control of temperature thus            energy     consumption      buildings   could    affect
reducing the load of air conditioning systems                      systematically occupants health and economical
minimizing the external energy requirements. Chilled               effectiveness. Accordingly to Steemers (2010) “low
beams also increase the usable space reducing the                  energy design cannot be limited to the technical issues
overall height of the building to maximize the natural             that impact on our planet”.
day lighting and views but this enlargement of spaces
also requires external shading device to minimize                  Also occupants affect the energy performance of
afternoon sun radiation and therefore, air conditioning            buildings and are affected by building environment
load                                                               itself. This is supported by evidence given in several
                                                                   studies like the document presented by ASHRAE in
As it was mentioned before several aspirations were                2001 where clearly appears that people spend about 80–
identified by the workshops including greenhouse gas               90% of their time indoors and therefore various comfort
reduction, indoor environment quality, water                       and health effects are to be associated with the building
management, materials selection, waste management,                 characteristics such as, ventilation, conditioning
pollution and biodiversity                                         systems, and the indoor air quality. Addressing the fact
                                                                   of this result, “it has been naturally between researchers
Applied ESD criteria to develop the design project                 to shift in the direction from energy and environmental
involved the commitment with the environment but also              performance of buildings towards a focus on human-
a strong effort to provide a better place for future users.        centred concerns” (Steemers 2003).
In this sense as it was expressed, a reduction of
greenhouse gas emissions was a defining principle in               Evidence in EPA Indoor air quality and student
the designing process. Indoor environment quality also             performances, shows that when individuals experience
represented one of the main goals to achieve. That is              at least two symptoms of discomfort they begin to
why fresh air is continually provided to the workplace             perceive a reduction in their performance. Consequently
and exhausted out of the building without being                    occupants are demanding the best indoor environmental
recirculated increasing the air quality and reducing the           quality for their wellbeing and productivity. Therefore
risk of sick building syndrome. Another important                  Well-being has become an integral concern for
feature was water management to reduce overall                     sustainable design.
consumption. In order to accomplish this, not only water
AAA-rated fixtures, and water sub metering were                    To confirm this assumption, Steemers (2010) suggest
incorporated to allow any leak detection but also,                 that “Most important, is the fact that low energy design
rainwater collection and storage for sub soil drip                 can achieve some of the highest levels of occupant
irrigation system was implemented on the roof to                   satisfaction”. This Provide clear evidence that
maximise water conservation. In terms of materials,                promotion and achievement of low energy buildings is
over 80% of construction material considering finishing            not only sustainable in the environmental aspects but
and fitout presented a high percentage of recycled                 also gives interesting economical returns in the
sources or waste diverted from landfill. Also, in louvers          midterm; based in the high efficiency and performance
and shading devices for instance it is considerable the            of occupants and working force involved.
use of recycled wharf timbers and patinated aged
copper. Meanwhile in interiors low CFC paints                      “Occupants and developers of office buildings
complement the timber decking from sustainable                     continuously ask for healthy and stimulating working
sources and low VOC carpets. Finally the rooftop                   environments” (Gratia E, 2003)
incorporates a roof garden increasing biodiversity.
                                                                   In this particular study case the occupants wellbeing
Lend Lease CEO Ross Taylor said, “Creating the Bond                was always the engine to pre-establish a design criteria
has allowed Lend Lease to again push the boundaries of             in order to achieve better performance in accordance to
what is possible” (Lend Lease design 2009).                        better perception of the working space.

UNSW. Fbe    Master in Sustainable Development. |                                               Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010

                                                         Page 6 of 10
SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment
                                                                                                                        2010

                                                                          In this aspect „30 The Bond‟ enhance a balance between
Based on the studied case it is possible to conclude that                 sustainability, performance and occupants aspirations
the challenge is then, to design buildings that can be                    representing the accomplished goal and demonstrating
responsive to users in terms of aspirations and needs to                  that a clear and strong occupants-focus strategy could
enhance better environments and more comfortable                          lead into a sustainable building not only with better
spaces. But also to create sustainable buildings which                    performance but also recognised for its design,
can identify the energy uses and propose more effective                   representing a delightful, functional, productive and
materials according to the specific site and climate                      regenerative building.
condition.

                                                                                                                          3039 words


                                                                   ****

                                                            Reference List




[1] ASHRAE. (2001)Indoor air quality: position document.                  [8] Moreton Jhon. (2006) Lean Clean Green Machine “How
       Atlanta: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating,                        Bovis Lend Lease latest eco masterpiece has stirring
       and Air-Conditioning Engineers; 2001.
                                                                                   the building industry”. Sydney-Australia. PDF
[2] EPA. (2000) Indoor air quality and student performance.                        document downloaded 03-05-10
         402-K-03-006. Washington D.C: United States
         Environmental     Protection    Agency,     Indoor               [9] OECD. 2002, 'Design of Sustainable Building Policies:
         Environments Division Office of Radiation and                           Scope for improvement and barriers', Head of
         Indoor Air; 2000.
                                                                                 Publications Serv., vol.5, pp.39, accessed 02/04/ 10
[3] John Godfaurd, et.al. 2005, 'Sustainable building solutions:                 www.olis.oecd.org/olis/2001doc.nsf/LinkTo/env-
         a review of lessons from the natural world,' Elsevier                   epoc-wpnep(2001)5-final
         - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.40,
         pp.319 - 328 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv,                   [10] Omer, A 2008, „Energy environment and sustainable
         accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW                                             development‟, Renewable and Sustainable Energy
[4] Gratia E. (2003) Design of low energy office building.
                                                                                  Reviews, No. 12, pp. 2265-2300, accessed 16 May
          Energy and Buildings, No. 35,pp.473-491, accessed                       2009 from Sciencedirect database.
          16 May 2009 from Elsevier-Sciencedirect database.
                                                                          [11] Sachs, J 2004, „Sustainable Energy Systems for the 21st
[5] Lend Lease Design. (2007) The Bond Project Data Sheet                          Century‟, The Earth Institute at Columbia
         June 06. Sydney-Australia. PDF document                                   University,     accessed     22      July     2009,
         downloaded     and    accessed   on    03-05-10                           www.earth.columbia.edu/sitefiles/File/about/director
         www.lendlease.com.au                                                      /pubs/DSDS020404.pdf


[6] Lend Lease Design. (2009) 30 The Bond, 30 Hickson                     [12] Steemers K.(2003) Towards a research agenda for
         Road, Millers Point, Sydney-Australia. Web                                adapting to climate change. Building Research and
         document by “Whitaker Hadenham Openshaw”,                                 Information Journal number 31(3–4) pages 291–301.
         accesed                                  17-03-10
         http://www.architecture.com.au/awards_search?opti
         on=showaward&entryno=20052019                                    [13] Steemers K. (2010) Energy efficient design and occupant
                                                                                   well-being: Case studies in the UK and India.
[7] Mendler, S & Odell, W 2000, HOK Guidebook to                                   Building and Environment, number 45(3–4) pages
        sustainable Design, J.Willey, New York                                     270–278. Accessed 16 /05/ 2009 from Sciencedirect
                                                                                   database.




UNSW. Fbe     Master in Sustainable Development. |                                                      Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010

                                                              Page 7 of 10
SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment
                                                                                                              2010

                                             CRITICAL LITERATURE REVIEW


                     Energy efficient design and occupant well-being: Case studies in the UK and India
                                        (Koen Steemers, Shweta Manchanda – 2010)


Introduction

The purpose of this literature review is to analyse the mentioned paper and from this reading to get some values, data
and structure to develop a comprehensive research relating occupants wellbeing, comfort and performance in an office
building ambience. First, this literature review presents the main purpose of the selected paper, the one is summarized
and described; later a brief critique is offered to understand the main points of the selected reading. Finally the
conclusions will offer a way to structure the definitive research.

First it is possible to sustain that the main objective of the reading proposed is to demonstrate the relationship between
sustainable building design and occupant wellbeing. It starts with a definition of sustainable design and wellbeing. Then
several case study office buildings from UK and India are presented. Then the results demonstrate that increasing
energy use in the case study buildings is associated with increasing mechanisation (e.g. centralised air conditioning) and
reduced occupant‟s control. The result of this situation is that the reduced control also reduces occupant comfort and
satisfaction therefore, deteriorating performance. Finally, the paper reveals that the reported health conditions of
occupants correlates strongly with their levels of satisfaction. The overall conclusion is that energy use in typical office
buildings is opposite to the wellbeing of the occupants which means that while increasing energy use does not improve
wellbeing satisfaction or performance moreover it decreases them.

Summary and main purpose of the selected reading

In this article the author presents findings showing that there has been a shift in the direction of scientific research
related to the energy and environmental performance of buildings towards a focus on human-centred concern where
people are demanding the best indoor environmental quality for their wellbeing and productivity. Many international
standards are also now beginning to move towards people-centric regulations and guidelines for building design and
engineering, recognizing that some of the older ideas of sustainability have ignored significant psychological, cultural
and sociological dimensions.

According to Steemers 2010, the most effective way to determine comfort is through a combination of measurable
parameters of the environment and their correlation with reported occupants comfort. This investigation shows that
lighting, job satisfaction, thermal conditions, and noise are among the top factors dominating the occupant responses.
However, air quality and degree of control are also important. This correlation is critically influenced by the perception
of control that the users has over their own environment, particularly when the physical conditions become distracting
or extreme.

Also it is mentioned that is common to assume that outdoor environment and the weather affect indoor perceptions
hence natural ventilation design tend to have better results than mechanically ventilated ones. For instance some of the
presented findings show that sickness is reported higher in India than in UK and this could be explained by the use of
naturally ventilated building in UK.

Despite the fact that the tendency has been to diminish the occupants ability to control their own environment, some
studies reflect that it should be the opposite because a key linking variable between energy consumption and occupant
happiness is the degree of control that the occupants have. Steemers exposes when increasing control is given to
occupants it does not only improve their physical and psychological sense of comfort and well-being but it also can
result in significantly lower levels of energy consumption. The relationships between energy efficient design and the
occupants are multifaceted and of key importance to the performance of buildings.

UNSW. Fbe      Master in Sustainable Development. |                                            Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010

                                                        Page 8 of 10
SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment
                                                                                                                2010

The article exposes that increased energy use is typically associated with increased mechanical equipment and
centralized control. It also shows that air-conditioned buildings emit 2 to 3 times CO2 compared to mixed mode and
naturally ventilated ones for no significant improvement of comfort, neither a positive direct relationship between the
energy use (or CO2 emissions) and occupant satisfaction. Nevertheless, the observations established that low energy
buildings could provide good levels of satisfaction in many cases even in different contexts. Moreover low energy
buildings can be, and often are, perceived by their occupants to be more satisfactory which leads to conclude that
increasing energy intensity does not reflect an improvement in comfort.

Finally, the author states that people affect and are affected by the built environment, thus it is possible to suggest that
the „human-dimension‟ of design requires the application of existing and new research methodologies to ensure truly
sustainable design where „people-focus‟ is the main concern of it to enhance better spaces addressing productivity,
comfort, and wellbeing.

Critique and conclusions

Although Steemers, have shown a comprehensive analysis in occupants and well being, it is also true that he has not
mentioned the triple bottom line that supports the basis of sustainability, therefore some of the concepts related to it are
not present in the reading. Some of these are the correlation between occupants, wellbeing and economic productivity.
To extend this idea it is necessary to complement the reading with other literature that can exploit the concepts of space
productivity, and occupant performance. It is also remarkable to sustain that the triple bottom line of sustainable
development is structured in Economics, Environmental and Social. Therefore, not to include any of them in the further
analysis will not lead into sustainable practises or sustainable designing criteria.

A complementary reading should be considered to enhance a better understanding of Lighting, natural air flows, interior
air quality, materials selection, waste management, water consumption, building management process and adequate site
analysis; in order to define ESD criteria and therefore to reach better buildings. But these further researches should not
underestimate either occupants‟ aspiration or economic inputs.

The selected paper offers a very interesting starting point to develop a more deeply research focus in occupants,
wellbeing, but also misses the correlation between exposed ideas with the concept of building performance, both
complementary in the pursuit of an economical and productive sustainable office building.




Reference List

Steemers K. (2010) Energy efficient design and occupant well-being: Case studies in the UK and India. Building and Environment,
         number 45(3–4) pages 270–278. Accessed 16 /05/ 2009 from Sciencedirect database.



                                                            ****




UNSW. Fbe    Master in Sustainable Development. |                                                Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010

                                                         Page 9 of 10
SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment
                                                                                                                   2010

                                                         ANNEXE 1

                                           PRELIMINARY BIBLIOGRAPHY


       Clements-Croome, D. (2004) Intelligent buildings: design, construction and operation., London, Thomas Telford,
                pp.408

       Fazia Ali-Touder, Helmut Mayer. 2006, 'Numerical study on the effects of aspect ratio and orientation of an urban
                 street canyon on outdoor thermal comfort in hot and dry climate,' Elsevier - Journal of Building and
                 Environment, vol.41, pp.94-108 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW

       Fernandez-Gonzales, A. 2007, 'Analysis of the thermal performance and comfort conditions produced by five
                passive solar heating strategies in the United States midwest,' Elsevier - Journal of Solar Energy, vol.81,
                pp.581-593 www.elsevier.com/locate/solener, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW

       John Godfaurd, Derek Clemens-Croome, George Jeronimidis. 2005, 'Sustainable building solutions: a review of
               lessons from the natural world,' Elsevier - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.40, pp.319 - 328
               www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW

       Kontoleon KJ, Eumorfopoulou EA. 2010, 'The effect of orientation and proportion of a plant-covered wall layer on
                the thermal performance of a building zone,' Elsevier - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.45,
                pp.1287-1303 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW

       Melchert, L. 2007, 'The Dutch sustainable building policy: A model for developing countries?,' Elsevier - Journal of
                 Building and Environment, vol.42, pp.893-901 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, accesed. 01 April
                 2010, UNSW

       Morel N, Faist A. 1993, 'Design tools for building Thermal Analysis: The significance of Integration,' Elsevier -
                Journal of Building and Environment, vol.28, pp.465-473 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, accesed. 01
                April 2010, UNSW

       OCDE. 2002, 'Design of Sustainable Building Policies: Scope for improvement and barriers', Head of Publications
              Service, OECD, vol.5, pp.39 http://www.olis.oecd.org/olis/2001doc.nsf/LinkTo/env-epoc-wpnep(2001)5-
              final, accesed. 02 April 2010

       Pushkar S, Becker R, Katz A. 2005, 'A methodology for design of environmentally optimal buildings by variable
                grouping,' Elsevier - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.40, pp.1126-1139
                www.elsevier.com/locate.buildenv, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW

       Roulet, C.A. 2001, 'Indoor environment quality in buildings and its impact on outdoor environment,' Elsevier -
                Journal of Energy and Buildings, vol.33, pp.183-191 www.elsevier.com/locate/enbuild, accesed. 01 April
                2010, UNSW

       Sam C.M., Hui. 2010, 'Low Energy building design in high density urban cities,' Elsevier - Journal of Renewable
              Energy, vol.24, pp.627-640 www.elsevier.nl/locate/renene, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW

       Santamouris M, et. al,. 2010, 'On the efficiency of night ventilation techniques applied to residential buildings,'
               Elsevier - Journal of Energy and Buildings, pp.5 www.elsevier.com/locate/enbuild, accesed. 01 April
               2010, UNSW

       Tombazis + AN, Preuss S.A. . 2001, 'Design of Passive Solar buildings in Urban Breas,' Elsevier - Journal of Solar
               Energy, vol.70, pp.311-318 www.elsevier.com/locate/solener, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW

       Tove Malmqvist, Mauritz Glaumann. 2009, 'Environmental Efficiency in residential buildings - A simplified
              comunication approach,' Elsevier - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.44, pp.937-947
              www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW

       Tzu-Ping Lin, Matzarakis A, Ruey-Lung Hwang. 2010, 'Shading effect on long-term outdoor thermal comfort,'
                Elsevier - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.45, pp.213-221 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv,
                accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW

                                                              ****



UNSW. Fbe   Master in Sustainable Development. |                                                   Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010

                                                         Page 10 of 10

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Concrete waste as building material
Concrete waste as building materialConcrete waste as building material
Concrete waste as building materialGaurab Luitel
 
A systematic approach towards restoration of heritage buildings a case study
A systematic approach towards restoration of heritage buildings  a case studyA systematic approach towards restoration of heritage buildings  a case study
A systematic approach towards restoration of heritage buildings a case studyeSAT Publishing House
 
REPAIR, REHABILITATION &RETROFITTING OF RCC FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT WITH ...
REPAIR, REHABILITATION &RETROFITTING OF RCC FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT WITH ...REPAIR, REHABILITATION &RETROFITTING OF RCC FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT WITH ...
REPAIR, REHABILITATION &RETROFITTING OF RCC FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT WITH ...civej
 
Wood A Natural Choice - How the Building Material Contributes to Sustainable ...
Wood A Natural Choice - How the Building Material Contributes to Sustainable ...Wood A Natural Choice - How the Building Material Contributes to Sustainable ...
Wood A Natural Choice - How the Building Material Contributes to Sustainable ...Think Wood
 
A comparative study on sustainable building construction with conventional re...
A comparative study on sustainable building construction with conventional re...A comparative study on sustainable building construction with conventional re...
A comparative study on sustainable building construction with conventional re...VISHNU VIJAYAN
 
Sustainability in Building Construction: Strategy for Achieving Sustainable D...
Sustainability in Building Construction: Strategy for Achieving Sustainable D...Sustainability in Building Construction: Strategy for Achieving Sustainable D...
Sustainability in Building Construction: Strategy for Achieving Sustainable D...IRJET Journal
 
Low Cost Housing in Egypt by Using Stabilized Soil Bricks
Low Cost Housing in Egypt by Using Stabilized Soil BricksLow Cost Housing in Egypt by Using Stabilized Soil Bricks
Low Cost Housing in Egypt by Using Stabilized Soil BricksIJCMESJOURNAL
 
adaptive-reuse-architecture-documentation-and-analysis-2168-9717-1000172
adaptive-reuse-architecture-documentation-and-analysis-2168-9717-1000172adaptive-reuse-architecture-documentation-and-analysis-2168-9717-1000172
adaptive-reuse-architecture-documentation-and-analysis-2168-9717-1000172Yael C.Agmon
 
Ground engineering solutions for infrastructure projects
Ground engineering solutions for infrastructure projectsGround engineering solutions for infrastructure projects
Ground engineering solutions for infrastructure projectsAbhishek Mangukiya
 
Materials in Action - Examining the Impacts of Building Materials
Materials in Action - Examining the Impacts of Building Materials Materials in Action - Examining the Impacts of Building Materials
Materials in Action - Examining the Impacts of Building Materials Think Wood
 

Was ist angesagt? (19)

Concrete waste as building material
Concrete waste as building materialConcrete waste as building material
Concrete waste as building material
 
A systematic approach towards restoration of heritage buildings a case study
A systematic approach towards restoration of heritage buildings  a case studyA systematic approach towards restoration of heritage buildings  a case study
A systematic approach towards restoration of heritage buildings a case study
 
References
ReferencesReferences
References
 
Sustainable Architecture and Sustainable Cities
Sustainable Architecture and Sustainable CitiesSustainable Architecture and Sustainable Cities
Sustainable Architecture and Sustainable Cities
 
20320140503030
2032014050303020320140503030
20320140503030
 
REPAIR, REHABILITATION &RETROFITTING OF RCC FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT WITH ...
REPAIR, REHABILITATION &RETROFITTING OF RCC FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT WITH ...REPAIR, REHABILITATION &RETROFITTING OF RCC FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT WITH ...
REPAIR, REHABILITATION &RETROFITTING OF RCC FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT WITH ...
 
Wood A Natural Choice - How the Building Material Contributes to Sustainable ...
Wood A Natural Choice - How the Building Material Contributes to Sustainable ...Wood A Natural Choice - How the Building Material Contributes to Sustainable ...
Wood A Natural Choice - How the Building Material Contributes to Sustainable ...
 
A comparative study on sustainable building construction with conventional re...
A comparative study on sustainable building construction with conventional re...A comparative study on sustainable building construction with conventional re...
A comparative study on sustainable building construction with conventional re...
 
Q04601104112
Q04601104112Q04601104112
Q04601104112
 
The Role of Advance Composite material In Contemporary Buildings
The Role of Advance Composite material In Contemporary BuildingsThe Role of Advance Composite material In Contemporary Buildings
The Role of Advance Composite material In Contemporary Buildings
 
Sustainability in Building Construction: Strategy for Achieving Sustainable D...
Sustainability in Building Construction: Strategy for Achieving Sustainable D...Sustainability in Building Construction: Strategy for Achieving Sustainable D...
Sustainability in Building Construction: Strategy for Achieving Sustainable D...
 
Adaptive Reuse and Industrial Buildings
Adaptive Reuse and Industrial BuildingsAdaptive Reuse and Industrial Buildings
Adaptive Reuse and Industrial Buildings
 
Low Cost Housing in Egypt by Using Stabilized Soil Bricks
Low Cost Housing in Egypt by Using Stabilized Soil BricksLow Cost Housing in Egypt by Using Stabilized Soil Bricks
Low Cost Housing in Egypt by Using Stabilized Soil Bricks
 
Termonologies of Pollution and Energy efficiency
Termonologies of Pollution and Energy efficiency Termonologies of Pollution and Energy efficiency
Termonologies of Pollution and Energy efficiency
 
Final presentation (1)
Final presentation (1)Final presentation (1)
Final presentation (1)
 
Ijciet 10 01_098
Ijciet 10 01_098Ijciet 10 01_098
Ijciet 10 01_098
 
adaptive-reuse-architecture-documentation-and-analysis-2168-9717-1000172
adaptive-reuse-architecture-documentation-and-analysis-2168-9717-1000172adaptive-reuse-architecture-documentation-and-analysis-2168-9717-1000172
adaptive-reuse-architecture-documentation-and-analysis-2168-9717-1000172
 
Ground engineering solutions for infrastructure projects
Ground engineering solutions for infrastructure projectsGround engineering solutions for infrastructure projects
Ground engineering solutions for infrastructure projects
 
Materials in Action - Examining the Impacts of Building Materials
Materials in Action - Examining the Impacts of Building Materials Materials in Action - Examining the Impacts of Building Materials
Materials in Action - Examining the Impacts of Building Materials
 

Andere mochten auch

Hydro Salt
Hydro   SaltHydro   Salt
Hydro Saltcharsh
 
Team Census Ulhaas10 Brochure
Team Census   Ulhaas10 BrochureTeam Census   Ulhaas10 Brochure
Team Census Ulhaas10 Brochurephilemons
 
Catgo Tropical 09/01/2010
Catgo Tropical 09/01/2010Catgo Tropical 09/01/2010
Catgo Tropical 09/01/2010AgriPoint
 
Patrick Lightbody Presentation Tae Slides
Patrick Lightbody Presentation Tae SlidesPatrick Lightbody Presentation Tae Slides
Patrick Lightbody Presentation Tae SlidesAjax Experience 2009
 
موسوعة غينس للارقام القياسيه 3
موسوعة غينس للارقام القياسيه 3موسوعة غينس للارقام القياسيه 3
موسوعة غينس للارقام القياسيه 3arabogrop
 
Upgrading Share Point Portal Server 2003 Customizations To Share Point Server...
Upgrading Share Point Portal Server 2003 Customizations To Share Point Server...Upgrading Share Point Portal Server 2003 Customizations To Share Point Server...
Upgrading Share Point Portal Server 2003 Customizations To Share Point Server...RCSLLC
 
Absolute Dating
Absolute DatingAbsolute Dating
Absolute Datingcharsh
 
Get the Facts on Why We Need Youth Sports Character Programs
Get the Facts on Why We Need Youth Sports Character ProgramsGet the Facts on Why We Need Youth Sports Character Programs
Get the Facts on Why We Need Youth Sports Character ProgramsIntello
 
COLI/BOLI, IOLI/STOLI – The good, the bad, and the ugly
COLI/BOLI, IOLI/STOLI – The good, the bad, and the uglyCOLI/BOLI, IOLI/STOLI – The good, the bad, and the ugly
COLI/BOLI, IOLI/STOLI – The good, the bad, and the uglyTony Roehl
 
Test Analyst 3 + Yrs Manual Automation Theme
Test Analyst 3 + Yrs Manual Automation ThemeTest Analyst 3 + Yrs Manual Automation Theme
Test Analyst 3 + Yrs Manual Automation Themeamitcitm
 
Tom Ferry Presentation
Tom Ferry PresentationTom Ferry Presentation
Tom Ferry PresentationJim Marks
 
Kagaya Yutaka Art - PPS by Sonia Medeiros
Kagaya Yutaka Art - PPS by Sonia MedeirosKagaya Yutaka Art - PPS by Sonia Medeiros
Kagaya Yutaka Art - PPS by Sonia MedeirosSonia Medeiros
 
Invite5加入流程.
Invite5加入流程.Invite5加入流程.
Invite5加入流程.ERIC CHUANG
 
Brasil III PPS by Sonia Medeiros
Brasil III PPS by Sonia MedeirosBrasil III PPS by Sonia Medeiros
Brasil III PPS by Sonia MedeirosSonia Medeiros
 
Media Ctr Presentation
Media Ctr PresentationMedia Ctr Presentation
Media Ctr Presentationbarbarapassero
 

Andere mochten auch (20)

Presentation library-053015
Presentation library-053015Presentation library-053015
Presentation library-053015
 
Hydro Salt
Hydro   SaltHydro   Salt
Hydro Salt
 
Team Census Ulhaas10 Brochure
Team Census   Ulhaas10 BrochureTeam Census   Ulhaas10 Brochure
Team Census Ulhaas10 Brochure
 
Catgo Tropical 09/01/2010
Catgo Tropical 09/01/2010Catgo Tropical 09/01/2010
Catgo Tropical 09/01/2010
 
Examples Of Work
Examples Of WorkExamples Of Work
Examples Of Work
 
Belle harbor 1
Belle harbor   1Belle harbor   1
Belle harbor 1
 
Patrick Lightbody Presentation Tae Slides
Patrick Lightbody Presentation Tae SlidesPatrick Lightbody Presentation Tae Slides
Patrick Lightbody Presentation Tae Slides
 
Wave Energy
Wave EnergyWave Energy
Wave Energy
 
موسوعة غينس للارقام القياسيه 3
موسوعة غينس للارقام القياسيه 3موسوعة غينس للارقام القياسيه 3
موسوعة غينس للارقام القياسيه 3
 
Ramadan (Reminder Slides)
Ramadan (Reminder Slides)Ramadan (Reminder Slides)
Ramadan (Reminder Slides)
 
Upgrading Share Point Portal Server 2003 Customizations To Share Point Server...
Upgrading Share Point Portal Server 2003 Customizations To Share Point Server...Upgrading Share Point Portal Server 2003 Customizations To Share Point Server...
Upgrading Share Point Portal Server 2003 Customizations To Share Point Server...
 
Absolute Dating
Absolute DatingAbsolute Dating
Absolute Dating
 
Get the Facts on Why We Need Youth Sports Character Programs
Get the Facts on Why We Need Youth Sports Character ProgramsGet the Facts on Why We Need Youth Sports Character Programs
Get the Facts on Why We Need Youth Sports Character Programs
 
COLI/BOLI, IOLI/STOLI – The good, the bad, and the ugly
COLI/BOLI, IOLI/STOLI – The good, the bad, and the uglyCOLI/BOLI, IOLI/STOLI – The good, the bad, and the ugly
COLI/BOLI, IOLI/STOLI – The good, the bad, and the ugly
 
Test Analyst 3 + Yrs Manual Automation Theme
Test Analyst 3 + Yrs Manual Automation ThemeTest Analyst 3 + Yrs Manual Automation Theme
Test Analyst 3 + Yrs Manual Automation Theme
 
Tom Ferry Presentation
Tom Ferry PresentationTom Ferry Presentation
Tom Ferry Presentation
 
Kagaya Yutaka Art - PPS by Sonia Medeiros
Kagaya Yutaka Art - PPS by Sonia MedeirosKagaya Yutaka Art - PPS by Sonia Medeiros
Kagaya Yutaka Art - PPS by Sonia Medeiros
 
Invite5加入流程.
Invite5加入流程.Invite5加入流程.
Invite5加入流程.
 
Brasil III PPS by Sonia Medeiros
Brasil III PPS by Sonia MedeirosBrasil III PPS by Sonia Medeiros
Brasil III PPS by Sonia Medeiros
 
Media Ctr Presentation
Media Ctr PresentationMedia Ctr Presentation
Media Ctr Presentation
 

Ähnlich wie Susd0001 Nicolas Carbone Individual Assignment (2)

Challenges facing componentsreuse in industrialized housing: A literature review
Challenges facing componentsreuse in industrialized housing: A literature reviewChallenges facing componentsreuse in industrialized housing: A literature review
Challenges facing componentsreuse in industrialized housing: A literature reviewIEREK Press
 
Sustainable Design for Occupants to Achieve High Performance and Low Energy B...
Sustainable Design for Occupants to Achieve High Performance and Low Energy B...Sustainable Design for Occupants to Achieve High Performance and Low Energy B...
Sustainable Design for Occupants to Achieve High Performance and Low Energy B...Nicolas Carbone Gamarra
 
THE ADVANTAGES OF USING SUSTAINABLE BUILDING DESIGN IN SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE...
THE ADVANTAGES OF USING SUSTAINABLE BUILDING DESIGN IN SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE...THE ADVANTAGES OF USING SUSTAINABLE BUILDING DESIGN IN SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE...
THE ADVANTAGES OF USING SUSTAINABLE BUILDING DESIGN IN SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE...EkengJerry
 
Benefits of Project Management to Realizing Sustainable Buildings
Benefits of Project Management to Realizing Sustainable BuildingsBenefits of Project Management to Realizing Sustainable Buildings
Benefits of Project Management to Realizing Sustainable BuildingsDr. Amarjeet Singh
 
Sustainability and green engineering
Sustainability and green engineeringSustainability and green engineering
Sustainability and green engineeringkeroma07
 
Sustainable building practices and materials in relation to.pdf
Sustainable building practices and materials in relation to.pdfSustainable building practices and materials in relation to.pdf
Sustainable building practices and materials in relation to.pdfsdfghj21
 
IRJET - Anlysis and Study of Existing Sustainable Building
IRJET -  	  Anlysis and Study of Existing Sustainable BuildingIRJET -  	  Anlysis and Study of Existing Sustainable Building
IRJET - Anlysis and Study of Existing Sustainable BuildingIRJET Journal
 
Vidyavardhaka college mysore pdf ss
Vidyavardhaka college mysore pdf ssVidyavardhaka college mysore pdf ss
Vidyavardhaka college mysore pdf ssAjit Sabnis
 
MG7101 Engineering Development Project.docx
MG7101 Engineering Development Project.docxMG7101 Engineering Development Project.docx
MG7101 Engineering Development Project.docxstirlingvwriters
 
Sustainable building materials in Green building construction.
Sustainable building materials in Green building construction.Sustainable building materials in Green building construction.
Sustainable building materials in Green building construction.Tendai Mabvudza
 
IRJET-Evaluating Performance and Costing of Ecological Sustainable Scientific...
IRJET-Evaluating Performance and Costing of Ecological Sustainable Scientific...IRJET-Evaluating Performance and Costing of Ecological Sustainable Scientific...
IRJET-Evaluating Performance and Costing of Ecological Sustainable Scientific...IRJET Journal
 
Sustainability through Intelligence in Buildings
Sustainability through Intelligence in BuildingsSustainability through Intelligence in Buildings
Sustainability through Intelligence in BuildingsIJERA Editor
 
A Review On Green Buildings
A Review On Green BuildingsA Review On Green Buildings
A Review On Green BuildingsVicki Cristol
 
Implication of Sustainable Development in Site Planning in Composite Climate ...
Implication of Sustainable Development in Site Planning in Composite Climate ...Implication of Sustainable Development in Site Planning in Composite Climate ...
Implication of Sustainable Development in Site Planning in Composite Climate ...IRJET Journal
 
ASSESSMENT OF THE GREEN AND ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGY IN THE CONSTRUCTION OF A...
ASSESSMENT OF THE GREEN AND ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGY IN THE CONSTRUCTION OF A...ASSESSMENT OF THE GREEN AND ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGY IN THE CONSTRUCTION OF A...
ASSESSMENT OF THE GREEN AND ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGY IN THE CONSTRUCTION OF A...IRJET Journal
 

Ähnlich wie Susd0001 Nicolas Carbone Individual Assignment (2) (20)

Challenges facing componentsreuse in industrialized housing: A literature review
Challenges facing componentsreuse in industrialized housing: A literature reviewChallenges facing componentsreuse in industrialized housing: A literature review
Challenges facing componentsreuse in industrialized housing: A literature review
 
Sustainable Design for Occupants to Achieve High Performance and Low Energy B...
Sustainable Design for Occupants to Achieve High Performance and Low Energy B...Sustainable Design for Occupants to Achieve High Performance and Low Energy B...
Sustainable Design for Occupants to Achieve High Performance and Low Energy B...
 
THE ADVANTAGES OF USING SUSTAINABLE BUILDING DESIGN IN SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE...
THE ADVANTAGES OF USING SUSTAINABLE BUILDING DESIGN IN SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE...THE ADVANTAGES OF USING SUSTAINABLE BUILDING DESIGN IN SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE...
THE ADVANTAGES OF USING SUSTAINABLE BUILDING DESIGN IN SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE...
 
Benefits of Project Management to Realizing Sustainable Buildings
Benefits of Project Management to Realizing Sustainable BuildingsBenefits of Project Management to Realizing Sustainable Buildings
Benefits of Project Management to Realizing Sustainable Buildings
 
Sustainability and Green Engineering
Sustainability and Green EngineeringSustainability and Green Engineering
Sustainability and Green Engineering
 
Sustainability and green engineering
Sustainability and green engineeringSustainability and green engineering
Sustainability and green engineering
 
Sustainable building practices and materials in relation to.pdf
Sustainable building practices and materials in relation to.pdfSustainable building practices and materials in relation to.pdf
Sustainable building practices and materials in relation to.pdf
 
URBAN DESIGN COMPENDIUM 1 & 2...(INTEGRATED DESIGN)
URBAN DESIGN COMPENDIUM 1 & 2...(INTEGRATED DESIGN)URBAN DESIGN COMPENDIUM 1 & 2...(INTEGRATED DESIGN)
URBAN DESIGN COMPENDIUM 1 & 2...(INTEGRATED DESIGN)
 
IRJET - Anlysis and Study of Existing Sustainable Building
IRJET -  	  Anlysis and Study of Existing Sustainable BuildingIRJET -  	  Anlysis and Study of Existing Sustainable Building
IRJET - Anlysis and Study of Existing Sustainable Building
 
Vidyavardhaka college mysore pdf ss
Vidyavardhaka college mysore pdf ssVidyavardhaka college mysore pdf ss
Vidyavardhaka college mysore pdf ss
 
MG7101 Engineering Development Project.docx
MG7101 Engineering Development Project.docxMG7101 Engineering Development Project.docx
MG7101 Engineering Development Project.docx
 
Sustainable building materials in Green building construction.
Sustainable building materials in Green building construction.Sustainable building materials in Green building construction.
Sustainable building materials in Green building construction.
 
Aquatecture.pdf
Aquatecture.pdfAquatecture.pdf
Aquatecture.pdf
 
Green building prepared eh
Green building prepared ehGreen building prepared eh
Green building prepared eh
 
IRJET-Evaluating Performance and Costing of Ecological Sustainable Scientific...
IRJET-Evaluating Performance and Costing of Ecological Sustainable Scientific...IRJET-Evaluating Performance and Costing of Ecological Sustainable Scientific...
IRJET-Evaluating Performance and Costing of Ecological Sustainable Scientific...
 
Sustainability through Intelligence in Buildings
Sustainability through Intelligence in BuildingsSustainability through Intelligence in Buildings
Sustainability through Intelligence in Buildings
 
Green building.pptx
Green building.pptxGreen building.pptx
Green building.pptx
 
A Review On Green Buildings
A Review On Green BuildingsA Review On Green Buildings
A Review On Green Buildings
 
Implication of Sustainable Development in Site Planning in Composite Climate ...
Implication of Sustainable Development in Site Planning in Composite Climate ...Implication of Sustainable Development in Site Planning in Composite Climate ...
Implication of Sustainable Development in Site Planning in Composite Climate ...
 
ASSESSMENT OF THE GREEN AND ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGY IN THE CONSTRUCTION OF A...
ASSESSMENT OF THE GREEN AND ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGY IN THE CONSTRUCTION OF A...ASSESSMENT OF THE GREEN AND ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGY IN THE CONSTRUCTION OF A...
ASSESSMENT OF THE GREEN AND ENERGY SAVING TECHNOLOGY IN THE CONSTRUCTION OF A...
 

Mehr von Nicolas Carbone Gamarra

06. Carta de Recomendacion IDIEM (Fabian Gonzalez)
06. Carta de Recomendacion IDIEM (Fabian Gonzalez)06. Carta de Recomendacion IDIEM (Fabian Gonzalez)
06. Carta de Recomendacion IDIEM (Fabian Gonzalez)Nicolas Carbone Gamarra
 
05. Carta de Recomendacion JR Candia FCh.
05. Carta de Recomendacion JR Candia FCh.05. Carta de Recomendacion JR Candia FCh.
05. Carta de Recomendacion JR Candia FCh.Nicolas Carbone Gamarra
 
00. CV. Nicolas Carbone - Arquitecto, Máster en Desarrollo Sustentable. 2015
00. CV. Nicolas Carbone - Arquitecto, Máster en Desarrollo Sustentable. 201500. CV. Nicolas Carbone - Arquitecto, Máster en Desarrollo Sustentable. 2015
00. CV. Nicolas Carbone - Arquitecto, Máster en Desarrollo Sustentable. 2015Nicolas Carbone Gamarra
 
Nicolas Carbone Gamarra Arqto. MSc Desarrollo Sustentable. CV
Nicolas Carbone Gamarra   Arqto. MSc Desarrollo Sustentable. CVNicolas Carbone Gamarra   Arqto. MSc Desarrollo Sustentable. CV
Nicolas Carbone Gamarra Arqto. MSc Desarrollo Sustentable. CVNicolas Carbone Gamarra
 
N.Carbone Gamarra Cv, Arquitecto, Master En Desarrollo Sustentable
N.Carbone Gamarra   Cv, Arquitecto, Master En Desarrollo SustentableN.Carbone Gamarra   Cv, Arquitecto, Master En Desarrollo Sustentable
N.Carbone Gamarra Cv, Arquitecto, Master En Desarrollo SustentableNicolas Carbone Gamarra
 
N.Carbone Gamarra Architect Portfolio (Reduc)
N.Carbone Gamarra   Architect   Portfolio (Reduc)N.Carbone Gamarra   Architect   Portfolio (Reduc)
N.Carbone Gamarra Architect Portfolio (Reduc)Nicolas Carbone Gamarra
 
N. Carbone Gamarra. A comprehensive comparison 5 & 6 Stars, Green Star Buildi...
N. Carbone Gamarra. A comprehensive comparison 5 & 6 Stars, Green Star Buildi...N. Carbone Gamarra. A comprehensive comparison 5 & 6 Stars, Green Star Buildi...
N. Carbone Gamarra. A comprehensive comparison 5 & 6 Stars, Green Star Buildi...Nicolas Carbone Gamarra
 

Mehr von Nicolas Carbone Gamarra (8)

01. Certificado de Titulo
01. Certificado de Titulo01. Certificado de Titulo
01. Certificado de Titulo
 
06. Carta de Recomendacion IDIEM (Fabian Gonzalez)
06. Carta de Recomendacion IDIEM (Fabian Gonzalez)06. Carta de Recomendacion IDIEM (Fabian Gonzalez)
06. Carta de Recomendacion IDIEM (Fabian Gonzalez)
 
05. Carta de Recomendacion JR Candia FCh.
05. Carta de Recomendacion JR Candia FCh.05. Carta de Recomendacion JR Candia FCh.
05. Carta de Recomendacion JR Candia FCh.
 
00. CV. Nicolas Carbone - Arquitecto, Máster en Desarrollo Sustentable. 2015
00. CV. Nicolas Carbone - Arquitecto, Máster en Desarrollo Sustentable. 201500. CV. Nicolas Carbone - Arquitecto, Máster en Desarrollo Sustentable. 2015
00. CV. Nicolas Carbone - Arquitecto, Máster en Desarrollo Sustentable. 2015
 
Nicolas Carbone Gamarra Arqto. MSc Desarrollo Sustentable. CV
Nicolas Carbone Gamarra   Arqto. MSc Desarrollo Sustentable. CVNicolas Carbone Gamarra   Arqto. MSc Desarrollo Sustentable. CV
Nicolas Carbone Gamarra Arqto. MSc Desarrollo Sustentable. CV
 
N.Carbone Gamarra Cv, Arquitecto, Master En Desarrollo Sustentable
N.Carbone Gamarra   Cv, Arquitecto, Master En Desarrollo SustentableN.Carbone Gamarra   Cv, Arquitecto, Master En Desarrollo Sustentable
N.Carbone Gamarra Cv, Arquitecto, Master En Desarrollo Sustentable
 
N.Carbone Gamarra Architect Portfolio (Reduc)
N.Carbone Gamarra   Architect   Portfolio (Reduc)N.Carbone Gamarra   Architect   Portfolio (Reduc)
N.Carbone Gamarra Architect Portfolio (Reduc)
 
N. Carbone Gamarra. A comprehensive comparison 5 & 6 Stars, Green Star Buildi...
N. Carbone Gamarra. A comprehensive comparison 5 & 6 Stars, Green Star Buildi...N. Carbone Gamarra. A comprehensive comparison 5 & 6 Stars, Green Star Buildi...
N. Carbone Gamarra. A comprehensive comparison 5 & 6 Stars, Green Star Buildi...
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort ServiceCall US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Servicecallgirls2057
 
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03DallasHaselhorst
 
Memorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQM
Memorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQMMemorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQM
Memorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQMVoces Mineras
 
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent ChirchirMarketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchirictsugar
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Uttam Nagar Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Uttam Nagar Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Uttam Nagar Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Uttam Nagar Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607dollysharma2066
 
Unlocking the Future: Explore Web 3.0 Workshop to Start Earning Today!
Unlocking the Future: Explore Web 3.0 Workshop to Start Earning Today!Unlocking the Future: Explore Web 3.0 Workshop to Start Earning Today!
Unlocking the Future: Explore Web 3.0 Workshop to Start Earning Today!Doge Mining Website
 
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptxThe-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptxmbikashkanyari
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City GurgaonCall Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaoncallgirls2057
 
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfInnovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfrichard876048
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Rohini Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Rohini Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Rohini Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Rohini Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMintel Group
 
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024Adnet Communications
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckHajeJanKamps
 
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Kirill Klimov
 
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdfDigital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdfJos Voskuil
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort ServiceCall US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
 
Enjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCR
Enjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCREnjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCR
Enjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCR
 
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
 
Memorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQM
Memorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQMMemorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQM
Memorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQM
 
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent ChirchirMarketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Uttam Nagar Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Uttam Nagar Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Uttam Nagar Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Uttam Nagar Delhi NCR
 
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
 
Unlocking the Future: Explore Web 3.0 Workshop to Start Earning Today!
Unlocking the Future: Explore Web 3.0 Workshop to Start Earning Today!Unlocking the Future: Explore Web 3.0 Workshop to Start Earning Today!
Unlocking the Future: Explore Web 3.0 Workshop to Start Earning Today!
 
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptxThe-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
 
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City GurgaonCall Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
 
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfInnovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Rohini Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Rohini Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Rohini Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Rohini Delhi NCR
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
 
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
 
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
 
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
 
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdfDigital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
 

Susd0001 Nicolas Carbone Individual Assignment (2)

  • 1. FACULTY OF THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT SUSD0001. S1 - 2010 Sustainable Development & the Urban Environment Course Convenor: Professor James Weirick Tutors: Vivien Chow - Marika Hahn - Kathleen McDowell Essay Topic: Evaluating a study case where designing for occupants with sustainable criteria and an adequate site analysis, allowed achieving a high performance and low energy consumption building. Nicolas Carbone Gamarra – Student Number: z3281988 May 24 – 2010
  • 2. SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment 2010 24-05-2010 UNSW. Fbe Master in Sustainable Development. | Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010 Page 2 of 10
  • 3. SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment 2010 EVALUATING A STUDY CASE WHERE DESIGNING FOR OCCUPANTS WITH SUSTAINABLE CRITERIA AND AN ADEQUATE SITE ANALYSIS, ALLOWED ACHIEVING A HIGH PERFORMANCE AND LOW ENERGY CONSUMPTION BUILDING. Nicolas Carbone-Gamarra UNSW - SUSD0001 | Master of Sustainable Development **** It is broadly accepted that architectural design is more two centuries. Examples of this could be the enormous effective when designing for future occupants advances in transportation, building structures and addressing their needs and challenges, but also it is well power supplies. Accordingly it is equally important to known that currently, functional modern architecture by notice how energy consumption rate has increased due itself is not necessary sustainable over the long term. to poorly constructed buildings. This was illustrated by Therefore, it is becoming increasingly important to the Worldwatch Institute Report which explains that review the architectural design criteria along with a buildings in the United States for example use 17% of clear understanding of the natural processes and their the total freshwater flows and 25% of harvested wood. interactions with human needs incorporating the concept In addition, they are responsible not only for the 50% of of sustainable development and ESD criteria (CFC) production and 40% of the total energy (Environmental Sustainable Design). In the pursuit of consumption, but also for generating 33% of CO2 these qualities, many commercial buildings are being emissions in the country (Mendler & Odell 2000). designed to become sustainable identifying the energy uses and proposing more effective materials according Moreover, as populations grow energy consumption to the specific site and climate condition in which they also increases, driving societies to deplete natural are immerse. Although a variety of approaches have resources that could severely compromise our being reviewed, this essay will focus on evaluating a development in the near future (Sachs 2004, p.1). That study case where designing for occupants with is why researchers have shown increasing concern about sustainable criteria and an adequate site analysis, the world energy demand rate, which is expected to allowed achieving a high performance and low energy climb 50 % to 80 % above 1990, levels (Omer 2008, consumption building also delightful, functional, p.2266). Naturally, it is becoming increasingly productive and regenerative by design. The information necessary to consider the designing and promotion of given in this essay will be structured in five sections. low-energy buildings in a cost-effective and The first will expose the energy problem and the environmentally responsible way to achieve not only the increasing tendency of energy consumption rates. Then, more effective, but also the least expensive sustainable a description of the building situation and an evaluation strategy as possible. Passive and low energy architecture of some site conditions will be presented. Later, an has been proposed and investigated in different architectural critique is offered in order to understand locations of the world addressing in all cases the the main strategies for functionality. In addition a concept of sustainable development. Therefore, by review of the main ESD criteria used during the design incorporating design strategies that exploit these phase will be exposed. Finally the results of the analysis principles may be the way of moving in the pursuit of will lead to suggestions and conclusions for improving economical and environmental sustainability. the architectural designing process in the pursuit of sustainability. The case of „30 The Bond‟ reflects a sustainable building rated with 5 stars achieved from the Green Star First of all it is important to understand that energy has Office as Built rating tool (Green Star), in which not only been part of sustainable development, but it sustainability, performance and economical aspects also represents development itself. It is widely known where key issues to design, not only addressing site that, high levels of energy inputs have allowed human conditions and climate variables but also expectations, development to experience rapid growth during the last necessities and aspirations of future occupants. UNSW. Fbe Master in Sustainable Development. | Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010 Page 3 of 10
  • 4. SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment 2010 According to the (OECD., 2002) in (Godfaurd 2005), should carefully investigate the full potential of site, “Sustainable buildings can be defined as those buildings building organisation, shape and climate influences to that have minimum adverse impacts on the built and maximise the desired levels of comfort or protection to natural environment striving for integral quality; future occupants from unwanted influences. The including economic, social and environmental building skin for instance, should be designed for performance in a broad way”. 30 The Bond is located in adaptation to the specific climate, orientation or natural 30-34 Hickson Road, Millers Point Sydney; and is a conditions of the individual site and by doing this to leading example of social and environmental achieve better performance to the specific site sustainability within commercial objectives, being the conditions identifying possible potentials and first CBD office building in Australia to commit to a 5 diminishing the uses of artificial sources for interior star energy rating with lower CO2 emissions than a climate. In this case: continuously sun exposition from typical office building (Bovis Lend lease – “The Bond early hours until sunset and strong West and South West Project Data Sheet” - June 06). winds affected the full height glazing. So the external shading system had to deal with those difficulties to be As it was mentioned before, “Site Analysis” played a certain to response and be reliably even through periods huge role in determining which strategies were the most of high winds. On the other hand, day lighting, shading, suitable to implement in the design. In the case of 30-34 air flows or solar radiation along with protection from Hickson Rd for instance, it is a very constricted site, noise and air pollution can become important factors in with only three exposed facades being the fourth a the designing of any building skin. Here is where double heritage hand hewn listed sandstone wall built by facades may come into play with intelligent solar convicts in early 1840‟s (Moreton 2006). The control systems or mechanical operable devices that incorporation of this feature into the building is one of may enable to fairly reduce the energy consumption and the highlights of the development because it gives at the same time to improve internal performance of the thermal mass, humidity control and natural lightning building representing also a commitment with heritage and history. But before using the historic element in the Finally the studied site is connected with three heritage design, some previous actions were required to fix and buildings from the 1840s that have been preserved as clean the original drainage cavity and also the part of the cultural and social project. Due to the surrounding soil full of bitumen residues from the old particular location, the project confronts several construction. According to Moreton 2006 “Complex challenges to address. However, not only site contamination both in liquid and solid forms had existed restrictions but also communal consultation where the for many years on the site after the Gasworks ceased main sources of inputs that were taken into operations in 1921”. In early periods for example, a consideration for achieving the final design. chemical DPC was introduced into the connection points between the rock face and the stone walls of the More than 300 people participated actively during the building to form a barrier against further seepage but design process, being consulted in several occasions unfortunately this chemical product is not only toxic but from conceptualization to completion. The answers also hazardous for people. Therefore, before using the obtained, provided the main architectural input which historic wall it was necessary to clean deeply the area was that the building should not be designed to achieve affected and moreover to remove all the toxic and certain level of sustainability according to a specific hazardous materials. rating tool; but that it should be planed to secure the desire levels of comfort, and performance in accordance Opposite to this sandstone wall is the main façade to the sustainable criteria hence, achieving better facing west which orientation is very complicate to deal standards and reduced energy consumption rates. This with, when designing for sustainability due to the lack statement is very important because it sets “people‟s of shading, the constant direct insolation and glare. In comfort” as the most important issue, when deciding the urban design context for instance, the building strategies to be addressed. “By putting people at the envelope played a huge role to achieve certain levels of heart of their project „30 The Bond‟, intended to sustainability because it transmit daylight, direct solar develop a process whereby the project reflects the radiation and fresh air; all qualities that improve life at aspirations of the people who will ultimately be using the interior of the building itself. Therefore, designers and interacting with it on a daily basis” (Moreton 2006). UNSW. Fbe Master in Sustainable Development. | Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010 Page 4 of 10
  • 5. SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment 2010 An integration of the new development into the existing that the internal performance as well as the occupants community with a minimum of disruption or friction comfort and wellbeing was an important factor to define was achieved by incorporating and respecting the the designing strategy and specifications, enhancing a human environment, local residents, community groups productive and high quality working space. This shows and other businesses in the area. the importance of designing for occupants in first place rather than designing for achieving certain ratting or 30 the Bond, shows a good example in which recognition; at the end, occupants will be using the collaboration between developers and the community space and they required to fulfil their needs in terms of may work to profit everyone involved achieving not comfort, happiness and wellbeing to develop efficiency, only technical sustainability but also social development productivity and economical effectiveness without in an urban scale. For instance, an agreement between compromising their own health. Accordingly to Lend Lend Lease, Deutsche Office Trust and the residents Lease CEO (Asia Pacific) Ross Taylor “this new work involving the public areas of the development, ends in a environment, with the internal building design and commitment between the three parties to modify the layout will be a place for „our people‟ that will inspire rooftop by lowering it within the building envelope and and drive our distinct culture in years to come” (Lend also creating a space used to grow a native wildflower Lease 2003). garden improving the views for residents in the surrounding buildings. Another relevant input delivered from the internal consultations, was the aspiration to use excellence in As well as the consultation and involvement of the local materials selection that could achieve strict community, owners and developers looked for inputs environmental guidelines improving interior fitout and from their own staff. The result was a series of ESD also air quality. To achieve this high level of „Aspirations‟ rated in order of importance and expectations, materials selection included bamboo, significance. These inputs, lead to some design wool, sisal, goat hair, linen, cotton, and leather; all these definitions and built an accurate brief which included; in natural materials are well known for their high qualities, first place wide open floor plans, with services cores environmental credentials and their contribution to sitting on the edge to enhance high levels of planning improve healthy environments. The sense of quality can efficiencies, and day lighting effectiveness. These be recognized due to the constant testing and quality features are complemented with building balconies and measurements. For instance in the selection of bamboo, open areas to achieve versatility and to improve the Lend Lease not only looked at a range of factors interior air quality securing constant integration of including the manufacturing process, coatings and the views and human contact. An example of it could be the glues used but also at practicalities such as the hardness atrium which is a public space encouraging interaction and durability. Other important factor to choose high between the building‟s occupants and the community. It quality materials was the fact that the building should contains internal stairs, glass lifts and double storey achieve important levels of versatility and openness “pods” which are used for shared activities creating a therefore the possibility to re-arrange spaces was a great sense of connection (Moreton 2006). The design constant. A great example of this are the eastern crafted, features also incorporates glass lifts, open stairs, timber slatted panels, which give the impression of balconies and terraces all the ones, which contribute to being a single partition forming part of a wall but when enhancing visibility and connectivity, maximising opened, either individually or in any combination, functionality and achieving great levels of commitment reveal the expansive west views, over the harbour and and comfort. docks. Addressing the open and clear lines of sight within the Finally but equally important, is the desire to reduce the building, modular and flexible workstation units were green house gas emissions, goal accomplished by the provided and installed within the office areas to ensure reduction of a 30% of CO2 emissions compared with a efficiency and practicality maintaining the quality of the common office building (Moreton 2006). This has been working environment. The environmental credentials of achieved through the use of natural ventilation in this workstations supplied, were also tested to ensure wintergardens and meeting rooms, passive chilled beam they met with the strict criteria for all materials and for cooling, fully operable shading on the facades and processes used throughout the development. It is clear natural daylight through the skylight over the atrium UNSW. Fbe Master in Sustainable Development. | Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010 Page 5 of 10
  • 6. SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment 2010 More specifically, chilled beams reduce the needs of air But To understand the reasons that had „30 The Bond‟ conditioning by pumping chilled water through cooling to push over the common benchmarks, first it is elements in the ceiling, the ones that creates a natural necessary to understand the implications of building convection process of hot air rising and cold air falling. environment in occupants performance and how low This process allows natural control of temperature thus energy consumption buildings could affect reducing the load of air conditioning systems systematically occupants health and economical minimizing the external energy requirements. Chilled effectiveness. Accordingly to Steemers (2010) “low beams also increase the usable space reducing the energy design cannot be limited to the technical issues overall height of the building to maximize the natural that impact on our planet”. day lighting and views but this enlargement of spaces also requires external shading device to minimize Also occupants affect the energy performance of afternoon sun radiation and therefore, air conditioning buildings and are affected by building environment load itself. This is supported by evidence given in several studies like the document presented by ASHRAE in As it was mentioned before several aspirations were 2001 where clearly appears that people spend about 80– identified by the workshops including greenhouse gas 90% of their time indoors and therefore various comfort reduction, indoor environment quality, water and health effects are to be associated with the building management, materials selection, waste management, characteristics such as, ventilation, conditioning pollution and biodiversity systems, and the indoor air quality. Addressing the fact of this result, “it has been naturally between researchers Applied ESD criteria to develop the design project to shift in the direction from energy and environmental involved the commitment with the environment but also performance of buildings towards a focus on human- a strong effort to provide a better place for future users. centred concerns” (Steemers 2003). In this sense as it was expressed, a reduction of greenhouse gas emissions was a defining principle in Evidence in EPA Indoor air quality and student the designing process. Indoor environment quality also performances, shows that when individuals experience represented one of the main goals to achieve. That is at least two symptoms of discomfort they begin to why fresh air is continually provided to the workplace perceive a reduction in their performance. Consequently and exhausted out of the building without being occupants are demanding the best indoor environmental recirculated increasing the air quality and reducing the quality for their wellbeing and productivity. Therefore risk of sick building syndrome. Another important Well-being has become an integral concern for feature was water management to reduce overall sustainable design. consumption. In order to accomplish this, not only water AAA-rated fixtures, and water sub metering were To confirm this assumption, Steemers (2010) suggest incorporated to allow any leak detection but also, that “Most important, is the fact that low energy design rainwater collection and storage for sub soil drip can achieve some of the highest levels of occupant irrigation system was implemented on the roof to satisfaction”. This Provide clear evidence that maximise water conservation. In terms of materials, promotion and achievement of low energy buildings is over 80% of construction material considering finishing not only sustainable in the environmental aspects but and fitout presented a high percentage of recycled also gives interesting economical returns in the sources or waste diverted from landfill. Also, in louvers midterm; based in the high efficiency and performance and shading devices for instance it is considerable the of occupants and working force involved. use of recycled wharf timbers and patinated aged copper. Meanwhile in interiors low CFC paints “Occupants and developers of office buildings complement the timber decking from sustainable continuously ask for healthy and stimulating working sources and low VOC carpets. Finally the rooftop environments” (Gratia E, 2003) incorporates a roof garden increasing biodiversity. In this particular study case the occupants wellbeing Lend Lease CEO Ross Taylor said, “Creating the Bond was always the engine to pre-establish a design criteria has allowed Lend Lease to again push the boundaries of in order to achieve better performance in accordance to what is possible” (Lend Lease design 2009). better perception of the working space. UNSW. Fbe Master in Sustainable Development. | Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010 Page 6 of 10
  • 7. SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment 2010 In this aspect „30 The Bond‟ enhance a balance between Based on the studied case it is possible to conclude that sustainability, performance and occupants aspirations the challenge is then, to design buildings that can be representing the accomplished goal and demonstrating responsive to users in terms of aspirations and needs to that a clear and strong occupants-focus strategy could enhance better environments and more comfortable lead into a sustainable building not only with better spaces. But also to create sustainable buildings which performance but also recognised for its design, can identify the energy uses and propose more effective representing a delightful, functional, productive and materials according to the specific site and climate regenerative building. condition. 3039 words **** Reference List [1] ASHRAE. (2001)Indoor air quality: position document. [8] Moreton Jhon. (2006) Lean Clean Green Machine “How Atlanta: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, Bovis Lend Lease latest eco masterpiece has stirring and Air-Conditioning Engineers; 2001. the building industry”. Sydney-Australia. PDF [2] EPA. (2000) Indoor air quality and student performance. document downloaded 03-05-10 402-K-03-006. Washington D.C: United States Environmental Protection Agency, Indoor [9] OECD. 2002, 'Design of Sustainable Building Policies: Environments Division Office of Radiation and Scope for improvement and barriers', Head of Indoor Air; 2000. Publications Serv., vol.5, pp.39, accessed 02/04/ 10 [3] John Godfaurd, et.al. 2005, 'Sustainable building solutions: www.olis.oecd.org/olis/2001doc.nsf/LinkTo/env- a review of lessons from the natural world,' Elsevier epoc-wpnep(2001)5-final - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.40, pp.319 - 328 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, [10] Omer, A 2008, „Energy environment and sustainable accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW development‟, Renewable and Sustainable Energy [4] Gratia E. (2003) Design of low energy office building. Reviews, No. 12, pp. 2265-2300, accessed 16 May Energy and Buildings, No. 35,pp.473-491, accessed 2009 from Sciencedirect database. 16 May 2009 from Elsevier-Sciencedirect database. [11] Sachs, J 2004, „Sustainable Energy Systems for the 21st [5] Lend Lease Design. (2007) The Bond Project Data Sheet Century‟, The Earth Institute at Columbia June 06. Sydney-Australia. PDF document University, accessed 22 July 2009, downloaded and accessed on 03-05-10 www.earth.columbia.edu/sitefiles/File/about/director www.lendlease.com.au /pubs/DSDS020404.pdf [6] Lend Lease Design. (2009) 30 The Bond, 30 Hickson [12] Steemers K.(2003) Towards a research agenda for Road, Millers Point, Sydney-Australia. Web adapting to climate change. Building Research and document by “Whitaker Hadenham Openshaw”, Information Journal number 31(3–4) pages 291–301. accesed 17-03-10 http://www.architecture.com.au/awards_search?opti on=showaward&entryno=20052019 [13] Steemers K. (2010) Energy efficient design and occupant well-being: Case studies in the UK and India. [7] Mendler, S & Odell, W 2000, HOK Guidebook to Building and Environment, number 45(3–4) pages sustainable Design, J.Willey, New York 270–278. Accessed 16 /05/ 2009 from Sciencedirect database. UNSW. Fbe Master in Sustainable Development. | Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010 Page 7 of 10
  • 8. SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment 2010 CRITICAL LITERATURE REVIEW Energy efficient design and occupant well-being: Case studies in the UK and India (Koen Steemers, Shweta Manchanda – 2010) Introduction The purpose of this literature review is to analyse the mentioned paper and from this reading to get some values, data and structure to develop a comprehensive research relating occupants wellbeing, comfort and performance in an office building ambience. First, this literature review presents the main purpose of the selected paper, the one is summarized and described; later a brief critique is offered to understand the main points of the selected reading. Finally the conclusions will offer a way to structure the definitive research. First it is possible to sustain that the main objective of the reading proposed is to demonstrate the relationship between sustainable building design and occupant wellbeing. It starts with a definition of sustainable design and wellbeing. Then several case study office buildings from UK and India are presented. Then the results demonstrate that increasing energy use in the case study buildings is associated with increasing mechanisation (e.g. centralised air conditioning) and reduced occupant‟s control. The result of this situation is that the reduced control also reduces occupant comfort and satisfaction therefore, deteriorating performance. Finally, the paper reveals that the reported health conditions of occupants correlates strongly with their levels of satisfaction. The overall conclusion is that energy use in typical office buildings is opposite to the wellbeing of the occupants which means that while increasing energy use does not improve wellbeing satisfaction or performance moreover it decreases them. Summary and main purpose of the selected reading In this article the author presents findings showing that there has been a shift in the direction of scientific research related to the energy and environmental performance of buildings towards a focus on human-centred concern where people are demanding the best indoor environmental quality for their wellbeing and productivity. Many international standards are also now beginning to move towards people-centric regulations and guidelines for building design and engineering, recognizing that some of the older ideas of sustainability have ignored significant psychological, cultural and sociological dimensions. According to Steemers 2010, the most effective way to determine comfort is through a combination of measurable parameters of the environment and their correlation with reported occupants comfort. This investigation shows that lighting, job satisfaction, thermal conditions, and noise are among the top factors dominating the occupant responses. However, air quality and degree of control are also important. This correlation is critically influenced by the perception of control that the users has over their own environment, particularly when the physical conditions become distracting or extreme. Also it is mentioned that is common to assume that outdoor environment and the weather affect indoor perceptions hence natural ventilation design tend to have better results than mechanically ventilated ones. For instance some of the presented findings show that sickness is reported higher in India than in UK and this could be explained by the use of naturally ventilated building in UK. Despite the fact that the tendency has been to diminish the occupants ability to control their own environment, some studies reflect that it should be the opposite because a key linking variable between energy consumption and occupant happiness is the degree of control that the occupants have. Steemers exposes when increasing control is given to occupants it does not only improve their physical and psychological sense of comfort and well-being but it also can result in significantly lower levels of energy consumption. The relationships between energy efficient design and the occupants are multifaceted and of key importance to the performance of buildings. UNSW. Fbe Master in Sustainable Development. | Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010 Page 8 of 10
  • 9. SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment 2010 The article exposes that increased energy use is typically associated with increased mechanical equipment and centralized control. It also shows that air-conditioned buildings emit 2 to 3 times CO2 compared to mixed mode and naturally ventilated ones for no significant improvement of comfort, neither a positive direct relationship between the energy use (or CO2 emissions) and occupant satisfaction. Nevertheless, the observations established that low energy buildings could provide good levels of satisfaction in many cases even in different contexts. Moreover low energy buildings can be, and often are, perceived by their occupants to be more satisfactory which leads to conclude that increasing energy intensity does not reflect an improvement in comfort. Finally, the author states that people affect and are affected by the built environment, thus it is possible to suggest that the „human-dimension‟ of design requires the application of existing and new research methodologies to ensure truly sustainable design where „people-focus‟ is the main concern of it to enhance better spaces addressing productivity, comfort, and wellbeing. Critique and conclusions Although Steemers, have shown a comprehensive analysis in occupants and well being, it is also true that he has not mentioned the triple bottom line that supports the basis of sustainability, therefore some of the concepts related to it are not present in the reading. Some of these are the correlation between occupants, wellbeing and economic productivity. To extend this idea it is necessary to complement the reading with other literature that can exploit the concepts of space productivity, and occupant performance. It is also remarkable to sustain that the triple bottom line of sustainable development is structured in Economics, Environmental and Social. Therefore, not to include any of them in the further analysis will not lead into sustainable practises or sustainable designing criteria. A complementary reading should be considered to enhance a better understanding of Lighting, natural air flows, interior air quality, materials selection, waste management, water consumption, building management process and adequate site analysis; in order to define ESD criteria and therefore to reach better buildings. But these further researches should not underestimate either occupants‟ aspiration or economic inputs. The selected paper offers a very interesting starting point to develop a more deeply research focus in occupants, wellbeing, but also misses the correlation between exposed ideas with the concept of building performance, both complementary in the pursuit of an economical and productive sustainable office building. Reference List Steemers K. (2010) Energy efficient design and occupant well-being: Case studies in the UK and India. Building and Environment, number 45(3–4) pages 270–278. Accessed 16 /05/ 2009 from Sciencedirect database. **** UNSW. Fbe Master in Sustainable Development. | Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010 Page 9 of 10
  • 10. SUSD0001 – Sustainable Development & The Urban Environment 2010 ANNEXE 1 PRELIMINARY BIBLIOGRAPHY Clements-Croome, D. (2004) Intelligent buildings: design, construction and operation., London, Thomas Telford, pp.408 Fazia Ali-Touder, Helmut Mayer. 2006, 'Numerical study on the effects of aspect ratio and orientation of an urban street canyon on outdoor thermal comfort in hot and dry climate,' Elsevier - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.41, pp.94-108 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW Fernandez-Gonzales, A. 2007, 'Analysis of the thermal performance and comfort conditions produced by five passive solar heating strategies in the United States midwest,' Elsevier - Journal of Solar Energy, vol.81, pp.581-593 www.elsevier.com/locate/solener, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW John Godfaurd, Derek Clemens-Croome, George Jeronimidis. 2005, 'Sustainable building solutions: a review of lessons from the natural world,' Elsevier - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.40, pp.319 - 328 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW Kontoleon KJ, Eumorfopoulou EA. 2010, 'The effect of orientation and proportion of a plant-covered wall layer on the thermal performance of a building zone,' Elsevier - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.45, pp.1287-1303 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW Melchert, L. 2007, 'The Dutch sustainable building policy: A model for developing countries?,' Elsevier - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.42, pp.893-901 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW Morel N, Faist A. 1993, 'Design tools for building Thermal Analysis: The significance of Integration,' Elsevier - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.28, pp.465-473 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW OCDE. 2002, 'Design of Sustainable Building Policies: Scope for improvement and barriers', Head of Publications Service, OECD, vol.5, pp.39 http://www.olis.oecd.org/olis/2001doc.nsf/LinkTo/env-epoc-wpnep(2001)5- final, accesed. 02 April 2010 Pushkar S, Becker R, Katz A. 2005, 'A methodology for design of environmentally optimal buildings by variable grouping,' Elsevier - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.40, pp.1126-1139 www.elsevier.com/locate.buildenv, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW Roulet, C.A. 2001, 'Indoor environment quality in buildings and its impact on outdoor environment,' Elsevier - Journal of Energy and Buildings, vol.33, pp.183-191 www.elsevier.com/locate/enbuild, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW Sam C.M., Hui. 2010, 'Low Energy building design in high density urban cities,' Elsevier - Journal of Renewable Energy, vol.24, pp.627-640 www.elsevier.nl/locate/renene, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW Santamouris M, et. al,. 2010, 'On the efficiency of night ventilation techniques applied to residential buildings,' Elsevier - Journal of Energy and Buildings, pp.5 www.elsevier.com/locate/enbuild, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW Tombazis + AN, Preuss S.A. . 2001, 'Design of Passive Solar buildings in Urban Breas,' Elsevier - Journal of Solar Energy, vol.70, pp.311-318 www.elsevier.com/locate/solener, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW Tove Malmqvist, Mauritz Glaumann. 2009, 'Environmental Efficiency in residential buildings - A simplified comunication approach,' Elsevier - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.44, pp.937-947 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW Tzu-Ping Lin, Matzarakis A, Ruey-Lung Hwang. 2010, 'Shading effect on long-term outdoor thermal comfort,' Elsevier - Journal of Building and Environment, vol.45, pp.213-221 www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv, accesed. 01 April 2010, UNSW **** UNSW. Fbe Master in Sustainable Development. | Nicolas Carbone Gamarra. 2010 Page 10 of 10