What is strategy?What is strategy?
What is strategy?
– Is it a plan?
– Does it refer to how we will obtain the ends we
seek? Is it a position taken?
– Just as military forces might take the high ground
prior to engaging the enemy,
– might a business take the position of low-cost
provider?
– does strategy refer to perspective, to the view one
takes of matters, and to the purposes, directions,
decisions and actions stemming from this view?
– Does strategy refer to a pattern in our decisions and
actions?
– does repeatedly copying a competitor’s new product
offerings signal a "me too" strategy?
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy isStrategy is
Strategy is all these—
it is perspective, position, plan, and pattern.
Strategy is the bridge between policy or high-order goals on
the one hand and tactics or concrete actions on the other.
Strategy and tactics together straddle the gap between ends
and means.
strategy is a term that refers to a complex web of thoughts,
ideas, insights, experiences, goals, expertise, memories,
perceptions, and expectations that provides general guidance
for specific actions in pursuit of particular ends.
Strategy is at once the course we chart, the journey we
imagine and, at the same time, it is the course we steer, the
trip we actually make. Even when we are embarking on a
voyage of discovery, with no particular destination in mind,
the voyage has a purpose, an outcome, an end to be kept in
view. Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
MeaningMeaning
Strategy is a term that comes from the
Greek strategia, meaning "generalship."
In the military, strategy often refers to
maneuvering troops into position before
the enemy is actually engaged
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
definitions in usedefinitions in use
Some of the definitions in use include the
following:
– Strategy is that which top management does that is
of great importance to the organization.
– Strategy refers to basic directional decisions, that is,
to purposes and missions.
– Strategy consists of the important actions necessary
to realize these directions.
– Strategy answers the question: What should the
organization be doing?
– Strategy answers the question: What are the ends
we seek and how should we achieve them?
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
What is strategicWhat is strategic
management?management?
A continuous, iterative process aimed at
keeping an organization as a whole
appropriately matched to its environment
(Samuel C. Certo and J. Paul Peter, Strategic Management)
Keeping the business in tune with
management and marketing forces both
outside and inside the firm
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Competitive strategyCompetitive strategy
Competitive strategy leads to competitive
advantage
– Generates supernormal ROI
– Offers services of value
– Uses cost effective technology
– Avoids erosion of competitive advantage by
exploiting and developing a technological base
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Stages in Strategic managementStages in Strategic management
Strategic analysis
– Environmental analysis
– Establish organizational direction
Strategy formulation
Strategy implementation
Strategic control
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy & HRM ?Strategy & HRM ?– NEED FOR STRATEGIC HRM– NEED FOR STRATEGIC HRM
Physical assets are viewed as investments
Can
– superior technology
– Superior facility
– Superior product
Bring about and more importantly sustain competitive
advantage?
Physical facilities can be duplicated, cloned or
reverse engineered and they no longer provide
competitive advantage
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy & HRM ?Strategy & HRM ?– NEED FOR STRATEGIC HRM– NEED FOR STRATEGIC HRM
Cost of employees as variable cost of production.
– No formal recognition of human resource as a key
resource
– No recognition of firms contribution to training
– Cost of recruitment, training and replacement
– ROI for investments in human resources
“maintainable advantage usually from outstanding
depth in selected human skills, logistics
capabilities, knowledge bases
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
HRM –HRM – Changing times?Changing times?
Views of employees as cost center is changing
Selection process
Induction and training process
Education
Retention - negative impact of employee turn over
Compensation
Innovation and learning – cost of un recorded knowledge
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
strategic HRMstrategic HRM
HRM is a strategic tool only if it contributes
to the bottom line. The question is; Does it?
– Forecasts of shifts in skill needs from manual
to cerebral
– Human Resources needs to looked at from an
Investment perspective.
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategic analysis HRMStrategic analysis HRM
“To be competitive, organizations in many
industries must have highly skilled.
Knowledgeable workers. They must also have a
relatively stable labour force since employee
turnover works directly against obtaining the kind
of coordination and organizational learning that
leads to fast response and high-quality products
and services”
- Edward Lawler
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resourcesHuman resources
Investment considerationsInvestment considerations
Management values
Risk return on investments
Economic rationale for investment in
training
Utility theory
– Outsourcing as an alternative to investment in
Human resources
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resourcesHuman resources
Investment considerationsInvestment considerations
Management values
Risk return on
investments
Economic rationale for
investment in training
Utility theory
– Outsourcing as an
alternative to
investment in Human
resources
Values, Philosophies of
management / senior managers.
Cost center
– HR cost center
– Replaceable resource
Investment
– HR value adder
– Critical resource
KEY personnel
– Enhances human capital/
prevents depletion
BPL, Govt,Vs Infosys, Vs
Reliance, TCS
Education, training, reward,
promotion.
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resourcesHuman resources
Investment considerationsInvestment considerations
The employers do not own the
resource in which they have
invested.
Returns must be great enough
to overcome the risks
Cash outlays to maintain no
layoff policy, the benefits are
not easily quantified
Incur costs in short run for long
term strategic benefit.
– Flexible committed work force
– Better organizational culture
Reliance communication
Bond money
Management values
Risk return on
investments
Economic rationale for
investment in training
Utility theory
– Outsourcing as an
alternative to
investment in Human
resources
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resourcesHuman resources
Investment considerationsInvestment considerations
Human capital theory
– Empr Not to bear the cost of Gen
training as the employees transfer skills
developed at employers expense.
General training
– OJT, Tuition fee reimbursement
– Recoup cost of general training
[loyalty, flexibility]
Specific training
Employee related
– Cost of mobility, relocation,
residence, children's education and
other psychological issues,
– new salary lower/ greater
LAY OFF
Management values
Risk return on
investments
Economic rationale for
investment in training
Utility theory
– Outsourcing as an
alternative to
investment in Human
resources
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resourcesHuman resources
Investment considerationsInvestment considerations
Utility of each HR
activity [attempts to determine
economic value of human resource
programs activities and procedures]
– Recruitment process
Employee with higher
productivity
– Performance appraisal
Return on output
Return on sales
– Advt, training, special roles,
Management values
Risk return on
investments
Economic rationale for
investment in training
Utility theory
– Outsourcing as an
alternative to
investment in Human
resources
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resourcesHuman resources
Investment considerationsInvestment considerations
Where world class capabilities and
strategic advantage cannot be
developed.
The resources devoted to perform
the service internally is greater
than those needed when outsourced
Excessive dependence on suppliers
can be avoided.
Salary, executive search, HRIS,
Benefits administration etc are
outsourced
Key areas viz., performance
appraisal, employee relations and
labour relations are retained by
companies.
Management values
Risk return on
investments
Economic rationale for
investment in training
Utility theory
– Outsourcing as an
alternative to
investment in Human
resources
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Investments in training andInvestments in training and
developmentdevelopment
Investments in employability
– Who moved my cheese?/ Jack Welch –
• the building was still standing , but the people were gone.
– Employers have responsibility to ensure they are getting the best
results from each employee before terminating them. (the
employer will have to coach, counsel and train the employee and
also take advantage of the same.
Current practices
– OJT
– MDP
– Prevention of skill obsolescence M,NC, CNC/ soft wares domain / telecommunication
– Reduction of career plateauing narayan murthy / VRS, golden hand shake/
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Investment practices for improved retentionInvestment practices for improved retention
Organizational cultures emphasizing interpersonal
relationship values
Effective selection procedures
Compensation and benefits
Job enrichment and job satisfaction
Practices providing work life balance
Organizational direction creating confidence in
the future
Retention of technical employee
Other practices in facilitating retention
– Opportunities for training, growth, new learning, liberal
transfer policies
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Investments in job-secure work forcesInvestments in job-secure work forces
Recognition of the costs of downsizing and lay offs
– Bumping less senior employees
Reduced productivity
Cost of training the incumbent, wage supplement
– Costs relating to termination of employees
Separation payments, higher rates for unemployment
compensation, Depletion of the firms investment in training
employees.
– Administrative costs
Human resource processing activities, Clerical expenses, cost
of conducting medical examination of laid off employees,
increased supervisory obligations for managers of reassigned
employees.
– Intangible costs
Morale, disruption of efficiencies in work processes,
Accidents, Depletion of goodwill, irregular age distribution
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Investments in job-secure work forcesInvestments in job-secure work forces
Avoiding business cycle-based layoffs
Alternatives to layoffs
– When down turn is of short duration
– Block / shut off inflow of personnel into the
organization –attrition brings down the cost
– Redeployment of current employees
– Curtailment of sub contractors and reallocate the work
to permanent employees
– Sharing of economic loss – wipro
– Fewer work days
Employment guarantees
The work effort and job security relationship
– The less secure the greater is the flexibility and
productivity
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Ethical implications of employmentEthical implications of employment
practicespractices
Job security
Performance pressures
Compensation
Work environment
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
ExerciseExercise = Identify the type of investment= Identify the type of investment
Employment security
Self-managed teams and decentralization of decision-
making
Extensive training and development
Continuous improvement HR programs
Reduced status distinctions and barriers
Sharing of financial and performance information
Trust between management and employees at all
organizational levels
Communication in global markets
Efficient and effective use of new information
technologies
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
ECC recognises that people are the real source of competitive
advantage. It is through people that ECC delivers total customer
satisfaction. An extensive and rigorous recruitment process ensures
quality induction. L&T's Graduate Engineer Trainee recruitment
process covers India's major engineering colleges and institutions.
Programmes, plant visits and comprehensive information-sharing
facilitate induction.
The basic principles of ECC's Human Resources policies include
Recruitment based solely on merit by following well-defined and
systematic selection procedures without discrimination
Sustain motivated and quality work force through appropriate and fair
performance evaluation, reward and recognition systems
Identify training needs within the Organisation and design and
implement those need based training programmes resulting in
continuous upgradation of knowledge, skills and attitudes of the
employees
Maintain a quality Human Resource Management System to meet the
international standards as per ISO 9001. Plan, design, train, equip
and motivate the department staff to meet this standard of
expectation.
ECC's Work Culture
Work culture emphasises:
· Freedom to experiment
· Continuous learning and training
· Transparency
· Quality in all aspects of work
· Rewards based on performance and potentialRef: SHRM – Charles Greer
Stages in Strategic managementStages in Strategic management
Strategic analysis
– Environmental analysis
human resource environment
human resource legal environment
– Establish organizational direction
Strategy formulation
– Human resource planning
Strategy implementation
– Work force utilisation and employment practices
– Reward and development system
Strategic control
– Performance impact of human resource practices
– Human resource evaluationRef: SHRM – Charles Greer
The human resourceThe human resource
environmentenvironment
Global changes
– WTO, GATT, EU, G&, G10 etc.
Boarders and barriers
E-commerce, M-commerce
Emerging markets, new markets.
Technology
Demography
Culture
Etc….
– The imperative >>‘HR focus’
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The human resource environmentThe human resource environment
-General environment-General environment
Technology and organisational structure
Worker values and attitudinal trends
Management trends
Demographic trends
Trends in utilisation of human resources
International developments
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The human resource environmentThe human resource environment
-General environment-General environment
Technology and
organisational structure
Worker values and
attitudinal trends
Management trends
Demographic trends
Trends in utilisation of
human resources
International
developments
Influence of technology
HRIS
Redeployment of HR staff to
operating units
New organisational structures
(Short / accountability)
– Unbounded corporations
– Virtual corporations /
networked organisations
– Cellular organisations/guilds
– Respondent organisations/
supply niche components
Stimulus for entrepreneurial
business
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The human resource environmentThe human resource environment
-General environment-General environment
Technology and
organisational structure
Worker values and
attitudinal trends
Management trends
Demographic trends
Trends in utilisation of
human resources
International
developments
Ethical/moral issues
(older generation blaming
younger generation)
Time spent on work/ leisure
Work enjoyment / satisfaction
/appeals
Loyalty of employees
– Location near / far
Age
– Younger no loyalty and expect
none
– New employee Perception
before joining and after joining
the job (extrinsic to intrinsic)
(image, induction and orientation,
socialization process)
Emphasis on core values, cultures,
family, social service)Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The human resource environmentThe human resource environment
-General environment-General environment
Management of diversity
Work teams
Virtual teams
Human resource outsourcing
Open book management
TQM
Integrated manufacturing
Reengineering
Management of professionals
Managing of aftermath of Mrg
& Aqui
Technology and
organisational structure
Worker values and
attitudinal trends
Management trends
Demographic trends
Trends in utilisation of
human resources
International
developments
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The human resource environmentThe human resource environment
-General environment-General environment
Aging work force (HMT)
Baby boom-US, China
Labour Shortages
Racial diversity
Occupational
distribution for women
Dual career couples
Technology and
organisational structure
Worker values and
attitudinal trends
Management trends
Demographic trends
Trends in utilisation of
human resources
International
developments
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The human resource environmentThe human resource environment
-General environment-General environment
Telecommuting /
working from home
Relocation from work
Growing use of
temporary and
contingent workers
Employee leasing
Technology and
organisational structure
Worker values and
attitudinal trends
Management trends
Demographic trends
Trends in utilisation of
human resources
International
developments
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The human resource environmentThe human resource environment
-General environment-General environment
NAFTA
EU
GATT
WTO
G7
Technology and
organisational structure
Worker values and
attitudinal trends
Management trends
Demographic trends
Trends in utilisation of
human resources
International
developments
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The human resource environmentThe human resource environment
-Legal environment-Legal environment
An overview of Industrial Relations Climate
Emerging trends and paradigm shifts towards
Employee Relations
Employee Relations Policy
Implications of:
– Employment Related Legislations
– Payment Related Legislations
– Social Security Related Legislations
– Welfare Related Legislations
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The human resource environmentThe human resource environment
-Legal environment-Legal environment
Equal employment opportunity for women.
– Age, gender discrimination, promiscuous gender based
harassment. Promiscuity, Dealing with incidences, pregnancy
discrimination, Disability discrimination, Religious discrimination,
Reservations and protection, health care benefits, family and
medical leave.
Employee relations
– Negligent hiring, immigration, Employment at will, Drug testing,
Safety
Labour relations and collective bargaining.
Emerging issues
Strategic impact of the legal environment
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Labour Legislations in IndiaLabour Legislations in India
The Apprentices Act, 1961
The Bonded Labour System (Abolition)
Act, 1976
The Child Labour (Prohibition &
Regulation) Act, 1986
The Children (Pledging of Labour) Act,
1933
The Contract Labour (Regulation &
Abolition) Act, 1970
The Employees Provident Funds and
Misc. Provisions Act,1952
The Employees State Insurance Act,
1948
The Employers Liability Act, 1938
The Employment Exchange (Compulsory
Notification of Vacancies) Act, 1959
The Equal Remuneration Act, 1976
The Factories Act, 1948
The Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923
The Weekly Holidays Act, 1942
The Industrial Disputes Act
The Industrial Employment (Standing
Orders) Act,1946
The Inter-state Migrant Workmen
(Regulation of Employment and
Conditions of Service) Act, 1979
The Labour Laws (Exemption from
Furnishing Returns & Maintaining
Registers by Certain Establishments)
Act, 1988
The Maternity Benefit Act, 1961
The Minimum Wages Act, 1948
The Payment of Bonus Act, 1965
The Mines Act,1952
The Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972
The Payment of Wages Act, 1936
The Sales Promotion Employees
(Conditions of Service) Act, 1976
The Shops and Establishments Act, 1953
The Trade Union Act, 1926
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Labour legislationsLabour legislations
The term `labour legislation’ is used to
cover all the laws which have been
enacted to deal with “employment and
non-employment” wages, working
conditions, industrial relations, social
security and welfare of persons
employed in industries.
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Need for labour legislation in India:Need for labour legislation in India:
Organized industry in a planned economy calls for the
spirit of co-operation and mutual dependence for
attaining the common purpose of greater, better and
cheaper production. Since this has not been happening
voluntarily, the need for State intervention.
The need for labour legislation may be summarized as
under:
– Necessary for the health, safety, and welfare of workers;
– Necessary to protect workers against oppressive terms as
individual worker is economically weak and has little
bargaining power;
– To encourage and facilitate the workers in the
organization;
– To deal with industrial disputes;
– To enforce social insurance and labour welfare schemes.
In India, labour legislation is treated as an arm of the
State for the regulation of working and living conditions
of workers.
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Principles of labour legislationPrinciples of labour legislation
Social Justice:
Social Equity
Standards in terms of living, position in
society etc. of the working population.
National Economy
International Uniformity
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Principles of labour legislationPrinciples of labour legislation
Social Justice:
Social Equity
Standards in terms of living,
position in society etc. of
the working population.
National Economy
International Uniformity
– The essence of democracy
is ensuring social justice to
all sections of the
community.
– This demands the
protection of those who
cannot protect themselves.
– In modern industrial set-up,
workers, left to themselves,
are unable to protect their
interest.
– Therefore, the State has to
intervene to help them by
granting them freedom of
association, the power of
collective bargaining and by
providing for mediation or
arbitration in the case of
industrial conflict.
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Principles of labour legislationPrinciples of labour legislation
Social Justice:
Social Equity
Standards in terms of living,
position in society etc. of
the working population.
National Economy
International Uniformity
Legislation based on this
principle provides for
achievement of definite
standards.
– EQUAL REMUNERATION
ACT
– Specific provisions of
law – such as in
factories act
– Work timings
– Work environment
– Dangerous machines act
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Principles of labour legislationPrinciples of labour legislation
Social Justice:
Social Equity
Standards in terms of living,
position in society etc. of
the working population.
National Economy
International Uniformity
These standards for the
working class can be
achieved by bringing
about changes in the Law
of our land.
– Power to change the
Law is exercised by the
government.
– Existing laws may be
amended to meet the
changed standards.
ESI
EPF
Minimum wages
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Principles of labour legislationPrinciples of labour legislation
Social Justice:
Social Equity
Standards in terms of living,
position in society etc. of
the working population.
National Economy
International Uniformity
Measures have to be
provided through
legislation to:
– Ensure normal growth
of industry for the
benefit of the nation as
a whole
– Satisfy the physical and
intellectual needs of the
citizens
– Ensure the growth of
industrial efficiency such
as to adjust the wage
system with a view to
increase the productivity
and prosperity of the
workers
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Principles of labour legislationPrinciples of labour legislation
Social Justice:
Social Equity
Standards in terms of living,
position in society etc. of
the working population.
National Economy
International Uniformity
ILO Since its inception,
securing minimum
standards (for the working
population – worldwide) on
a uniform basis in respect of
all labour matters has been
the main objective of ILO.
o To this end, conventions
are passed at the
conferences of ILO.
– As a member of the ILO,
adopting these conventions
would require appropriate
legislation to be brought
about.
– The influence of
international labour
conventions has been
significant in shaping the
course of labour legislation
in India.
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Legal environmentLegal environment
- Bench mark- Bench mark
Obey the Law. Law is society’s codification of
right and wrong; Play by the rules
• It is important to perform in a manner consistent
with expectations of government and the law.
• It is important to comply with various national and
supra-national laws and regulations.
• It is important to be a law-abiding corporate
citizen.
• It is important that a successful firm be defines as
one that fulfils its legal obligations.
• It is important to provide goods and services that
at least meet the minimal legal requirements.Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy formulationStrategy formulation
What are the purpose(s) and objective(s) of
the organization?
Where is the organization presently going?
What critical environmental factors does the
organization currently face?
What can be done to achieve organizational
objectives more effectively in the future?
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy formulation processStrategy formulation process
Development of organizational philosophy and
mission statement
Environmental scanning
Analysis of SWOT
Formulation of strategic objectives
Generation of alterative strategy
Evaluation and selection of strategies
Informal / incremental strategic planning
– Managed/logical incremental planning
A strategy is the pattern or plan that integrates an organisation’s major goals, policies,
and action sequences into a cohesive whole
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Competitive strategy in BusinessCompetitive strategy in Business
UnitsUnits
Periodic forward scanning
Analysis based on longer time frame
Communication about goals and resource
allocation
Framework for short-term plan evaluation and
integration
Decisional criteria framework for short term
decision making
PLANNING IN SBU’S
– Base strategy will be integrated with functional specializations to
exploit the opportunity seen by the strategy and achieve the goals.
– Low cost leadership, differentiation, nicheRef: SHRM – Charles Greer
Value Chain AnalysisValue Chain Analysis
Primary activities
– Inbound logistics
– Operations
– Outbound logistics
– Marketing and
sales
– Service
Secondary Activity
– Procurement
– Human Resource
Management
– Technology
Development
– Infrastructure
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Steps in Value Chain AnalysisSteps in Value Chain Analysis
Value chain analysis can be broken down
into a three sequential steps:
1. Break down a market/organisation into its key
activities under each of the major headings in
the model (primary activities / secondary
activities)
2. Assess the potential for adding value via cost
advantage or differentiation, or identify current
activities where a business appears to be at a
competitive disadvantage;
3. Determine strategies built around focusing on
activities where competitive advantage can be
sustained
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
HR strategy ?HR strategy ?
'a human resource system that is tailored to the
demands of the business strategy'
-Miles and Snow 1984
'the pattern of planned human resource activities
intended to enable an organization to achieve its
goals'
- Wright and McMahan 1992
“the pattern planned human resource deployments
and activities intended to enable an organisation to
achieve its goals”
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
SHRM concernSHRM concern
SHRM concern is to ensure
– HR management is fully integrated with the
strategy and strategic needs of the firm
– HR policies cohere across policy areas and
areas of hierarchy
– HR practices are adjusted and used by line
manages and employees as part of their
everyday work
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategic HRMStrategic HRM(IMPORTANCE)(IMPORTANCE)
Needs investment –ROI
Cost of investment
Reduction in total Labour cost
Efficiency in operation
Optimal use of human resources
A source of competitive advantage
Technical skills (pace of technological change)
Knowledge and capabilities
Management of critical and Difficult HR areas
Management of change (Resistance to change)
Lack of trust
Antagonistic labour
Motivational problems
Management relations
Economic turbulence
Within the country (turbulence)
Globalisation
Dramatically changing demographics
Differences in workforce values
Strategic human resource management and ∟ HRP are considered important
to manage uncertainties; HR is integrated with strategy; Integrating and
aligning HR function with strategyRef: SHRM – Charles Greer
Benefits of SHRMBenefits of SHRM
1. Identifying and analysing external opportunities and
threats that may be crucial to the company's success.
2. Provides a clear business strategy and vision for the
future.
3. To supply competitive intelligence that may be useful
in the strategic planning process.
4. To recruit, retain and motivate people.
5. To develop and retain of highly competent people.
6. To ensure that people development issues are
addressed systematically.
7. To supply information regarding the company's
internal strengths and weaknesses.
8. To meet the expectations of the customers effectively.
9. To ensure high productivity.
10. To ensure business surplus thorough competency
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
HRM Practices
Firm strategy Institutional /
Political forces
HR Capital pool
(Skills, abilities)
HR behaviors
Firm level outcomes
(performance,
satisfaction,
absenteeism etc)
Resource
based view
of the firm
Cybernetics
Agency/transaction costs
Resource dependence
institutional
Behavioral
approach
Theoretical frame work of SHRM
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Theoretical frame work of SHRM
Strategy driven
– Resource based view
Competitive advantage based on unique allocation of resources {selection
/Compensation package} (TCS)
– Behavioral view
Control and influence the behaviors of individuals (Infosys)
– Cybernetics systems
Adoption or abandonment of practices based on feedback on contributions to
strategy (Bosch – MICO)
– Agency/transactions cost view
Use of control systems, performance evaluation and reward systems etc
– (In the absence of performance evaluation strategy may not be pursued)
Non-Strategy driven
– Resource dependence and power theories
– Power and politics= legislation, unionization, control of resources, expectations of
social responsibility.
– Institutional theory
– In appropriate performance evaluation dimensions (inertia / rational decision
making.appraisal
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
International strategyInternational strategy
Multinational, global and transnational
strategies
Strategic alliances
Sustainable global competitive advantage
Globally competent managers
Location of production facilities
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resource contributionsHuman resource contributions
to strategyto strategy
Environmental scanning and competitive
advantage
Implementation of resource reallocation
decisions Slide >
Lead time for dealing with labour shortages.
..
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Other issuesOther issues
Strategy driven role behaviors and practices
– Innovation – cooperation, group oriented, long term appraisal system, generalized skill
development, broad career path, compensation approaches accentuating internal equity flexible
compensation packages including stock ownership
– quality enhancement- employment security guarantees. Extensive training programs,
participative decision making (process orientation)
– cost reduction – performance evaluation system emphasizing results in the short term. Virtually
no training programs, very specialized jobs, narrow specialized career jobs,Procedure for
continual tracking of wage rates in the labour market.
Strategic human resource activity typology
– Relational : transactional $ High : low strategic value Slide >
Classifying human resource types
Jeffrey sonnenfeld and Maury peiperl Slide
Miles and snow: Defenders, prospectors, analyzers and reactors
Network organization and strategy
Integration of strategy and human resource planning
– Evolution of strategy and human resource planning integration.
Evolution of linkages between Strategic business planning and HRM
– Administrative linkage, one way – HR is involved in implementation, two way- involved HRM
and strategic business plans, integrated
– Determinants of integration
Conditions under which determinants may not be appropriate.
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
HUMAN RESOURCE ACTIVITY TYPOLOGY
Staffing planning
Benefits of planning
Retirement planning
Compliance
Performance enhancement
Consulting
Employee relations
Labour negotiations
Executive compensation
Employee development
Management development
Recruitment interviewing
< IMPORTANT TO EXECUTIVES >
Payroll
Benefits administration
Retirement administration
Employee records
Relocation administration
Recruitment information processing
< IMPORTANT TO EMPLOYEES >
Recruitment information
processing
Employee assistance programs
Strategic value of
activity
Low
High
RelationshipTransactional Type of HR activityBack Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Benefits of integrating HRP with StrategicBenefits of integrating HRP with Strategic
planningplanning
Generates more solutions to complex
organizational problems
Ensures consideration of human resources in
organizational goal setting process
Ensures consideration of human resources in
assessment of organizational abilities to
accomplish goals and implement strategies
Reciprocal integration prevents strategy
formulation based on personal
rigidities/preferences
Facilitates concurrent consideration of strategic
plans and managerial succession.
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategic components of HRMStrategic components of HRM
relevant to internal fitrelevant to internal fit
Management awareness
Management of the function
Portfolio of programs
Personnel skills
Information technology
Awareness of the environment
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
HR Practitioners RoleHR Practitioners Role
The HR managers have keen role in the effective planning and
implementation of the policies and decisions that in tune with the
business changes.
– They should act as strategic partners and be proactive in their role than
mere reactive, passive spectators.
– The HR managers should understand how far their decisions
contribute to business surplus incorporating human competency and
performance to the organisation.
– Strategic HR managers need a change in their outlook from seeing
themselves as relationship managers to strategic resource managers.
Kossek (1987, 1989) argues that major HRM innovations occur when senior
management takes the lead and adoption of innovative SHRM practices is
dependent on the nature of relationship of the HR Department with the CEO and
the line managers.
Legge (1978) commenting on the actions of the personnel practitioner in the
innovation process suggests that adoption of an innovation by an organization
depends largely on HR practitioners' credibility with information and resource
providers.
– HR Department and HR managers in these innovative organizations play a
strategic role (Ulrich, 1997) linking the HR strategy with the business
strategy of the organization.
– A crucial aspect concerning SHRM is the concepts of fit and flexibility.
The degree of fit determines the human resource system's integration with
organization strategy. It is the role of HR Managers to ensure this fit in
between Human Resource System with the Organization Strategy.
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Requirements for SHR-ManagersRequirements for SHR-Managers
Information management skills
Planning skills
Management skills
Integration skills
Change management skills
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resource planningHuman resource planning
Strategic role of HRP
Over view of HRP
Managerial issues in planning
Selecting forecasting technique
Forecasting the supply of human resources
Forecasting the demand for human
resources
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resource planningHuman resource planning
Strategic role of HRP
Over view of HRP
Managerial issues in
planning
Selecting forecasting
technique
Forecasting the supply of
human resources
Forecasting the demand
for human resources
Developmental planning
for strategic leadership
Assessment of strategic
alternatives
Adding value
Contribution to strategic
human resource
management
Strategic salary planning.
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resource planningHuman resource planning
Strategic role of HRP
Over view of HRP
Managerial issues in
planning
Selecting forecasting
technique
Forecasting the supply of
human resources
Forecasting the demand
for human resources
Steps in HRP
– Interfacing strategic planning and
scanning the environment
– Taking an inventory of the companies
current human resources.
– Forecasting the demand for human
resources
– Forecasting the supply of human
resources both from within the
organization and from the external labor
market
– Comparing the forecast of demand and
supply
– Planning the actions needed to deal with
anticipated shortages or overages
– Feeding back such information into the
strategic management process
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resource planningHuman resource planning
Strategic role of HRP
Over view of HRP
Managerial issues in
planning
Selecting forecasting
technique
Forecasting the supply of
human resources
Forecasting the demand
for human resources
Planning in a context
of change
Responsibility for
human resource
planning
Failure to plan for
human resources
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resource planningHuman resource planning
Strategic role of HRP
Over view of HRP
Managerial issues in
planning
Selecting forecasting
technique
Forecasting the supply of
human resources
Forecasting the demand
for human resources
Personal implications
Changing receptivity
towards planning
– Stricter legislations for
lay off etc
Other issues
– Mind set of work force
and related actions.
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resource planningHuman resource planning
Strategic role of HRP
Over view of HRP
Managerial issues in
planning
Selecting forecasting
technique
Forecasting the supply of
human resources
Forecasting the demand
for human resources
Purpose of planning
Organisational
characteristics
Industry characteristics
Environmental turbulence
Other consideration
– Technique of forecasting
– Cost
– Accuracy
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resource planningHuman resource planning
Strategic role of HRP
Over view of HRP
Managerial issues in
planning
Selecting forecasting
technique
Forecasting the supply of
human resources
Forecasting the demand
for human resources
Replacement charts Mgr posi
Human resurce
inventories
Succession planning
Markov analysis ….
Renewal models age cohorts, internal
mobilization
Computer simulation
Regression analysis
Trend extrapolation
– Utilisation of supply
forecasting techniques
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human resource planningHuman resource planning
Strategic role of HRP
Over view of HRP
Managerial issues in
planning
Selecting forecasting
technique
Forecasting the supply of
human resources
Forecasting the demand
for human resources
Heuristics, Rule of
thumb and the Delphi
technique
Operations research
and management
science technique
Regression analysis
– Utilisation of demand
forecasting technique
– Trend extrapolation
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy formulation processStrategy formulation process
Development of organizational philosophy and
mission statement
Environmental scanning
Analysis of SWOT
Formulation of strategic objectives
Generation of alterative strategy
Evaluation and selection of strategies
Informal / incremental strategic planning
– Managed/logical incremental planning
A strategy is the pattern or plan that integrates an organisation’s major goals, policies,
and action sequences into a cohesive whole
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy implementationStrategy implementation
work force utilization and employment practiceswork force utilization and employment practices
Efficient utilization of human resources
Dealing with employee shortages
Selection of employees
Dealing with employee surpluses
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy implementationStrategy implementation
work force utilization and employment practiceswork force utilization and employment practices
Efficient utilization of
human resources
Dealing with
employee shortages
Selection of
employees
Dealing with
employee surpluses
Cross training and flexibility in
assigning work
Using work teams
– Requirements for effective
teams
Forming
Storming
Norming
performing
Operating on a non union basis
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy implementationStrategy implementation
work force utilization and employment practiceswork force utilization and employment practices
Efficient utilization of
human resources
Dealing with
employee shortages
Selection of
employees
Dealing with
employee surpluses
Strategic recruiting
Special recruiting for
minorities and women
workers
Flexible retirement as
a source of labour
Managing vendors of
outsourced functions
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy implementationStrategy implementation
work force utilization and employment practiceswork force utilization and employment practices
Managing vendors of
outsourced functions
– Making the outsourcing
decision
– Selecting and negotiating
with outsourcing vendors
– Managing the outsourcing
transactions
– Managing vendor
relationships
– Monitoring and evaluating
vendor performance
Efficient utilization of
human resources
Dealing with
employee shortages
Selection of
employees
Dealing with
employee surpluses
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy implementationStrategy implementation
work force utilization and employment practiceswork force utilization and employment practices
Efficient utilization of
human resources
Dealing with
employee shortages
Selection of
employees
Dealing with
employee surpluses
Reliability and validity
– Predictive validity
– Concurrent validity
– Content validity
Job analysis
KSA
Interviews
Behavioural interviews
Testing
Assessment centres
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy implementationStrategy implementation
work force utilization and employment practiceswork force utilization and employment practices
Redeployment and
retraining
Early retirement
Retreat from
employment security
policy
Downsizing and
layoffs
Termination strategies
Efficient utilization of
human resources
Dealing with
employee shortages
Selection of
employees
Dealing with
employee surpluses
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy implementationStrategy implementation
work force utilization and employment practiceswork force utilization and employment practices
Downsizing and layoffs
– Findings
Co are not well prepared
6 months to 1 year co indicators
do not improve –profits, ROI,
Stock prices, expense ratios
Survivors syndrome
Myth of job security exploded
(Who moved my cheese)
Sustained improvement can be
brought about only with
improvements in productivity,
quality and effectiveness and
integrate reductions in head count
with planned changes in the way
the work is designed.
Downsizing in not a one time
quick fix solution to enhance
competitiveness. –is a part of
continuous improvement.
Efficient utilization of
human resources
Dealing with
employee shortages
Selection of
employees
Dealing with
employee surpluses
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy implementationStrategy implementation
work force utilization and employment practiceswork force utilization and employment practices
Downsizing and layoffs
– Guide lines for conduct of layoffs
Give early warnings /
announcements of layoffs
Soften the impact with
compensation and benefits
Utilise the services of
outplacement firms
Supply retraining services
Provide equitable and decent
treatment to laid off employees
Ensure supportive treatment of
survivors
Maintain a cooperative approach
with unions
Uphold obligation to the
community
Efficient utilization of
human resources
Dealing with
employee shortages
Selection of
employees
Dealing with
employee surpluses
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Special implementationSpecial implementation
challengeschallenges
Career path for technical professionals
Dual career couples
Strategy implementation system – Reward
and development systems
Strategically oriented performance management
system
Strategically oriented compensation systems
Employee development
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy implementation systemStrategy implementation system
– Reward and development systems– Reward and development systems
Performance measurement
approaches
– MBO
– Graphic scale rating
– Narratives
– BARS
– Behavioral observation scales
– 360 –degree feedback
Performance evaluation of
executives
Effectiveness of performance
measurement.
YOU GET WHAT YOU MEASURE, YOU MEASURE WHAT YOU VALUE, YOU
CAN NOT CONTROL WHAT YOU CANNOT MEASURE.
Strategically oriented
performance
management system
Strategically oriented
compensation systems
Employee
development
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy implementation systemStrategy implementation system
– Reward and development systems– Reward and development systems
Strategically oriented
performance
management system
Strategically oriented
compensation systems
Employee
development
Traditional
compensation systems
– Job analysis > job evaluation >
salary/wage hierarchy
Point system
Factor comparison system
Hybrid system
– Internal equity
– > Wage surveys to establish
external equity.
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy implementation systemStrategy implementation system
– Reward and development systems– Reward and development systems
Traditional compensation
systems
– Inadequacies
Wage for know-how not
given
Compensated for specific
job only
Impact of collective
bargaining on wage
structures.
Does not work well with
managers and
professionals
Strategically oriented
performance
management system
Strategically oriented
compensation systems
Employee
development
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy implementation systemStrategy implementation system
– Reward and development systems– Reward and development systems
Skill based pay
Broad banding
Team based pay
Variable compensation
Executive
compensation
Strategically oriented
performance
management system
Strategically oriented
compensation systems
Employee
development
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Strategy implementation systemStrategy implementation system
– Reward and development systems– Reward and development systems
Strategically oriented
performance
management system
Strategically oriented
compensation systems
Employee
development
Training programs
Training methods
Apprenticeships
Management development
Management development
for international
assignments
Product life cycle and
managerial fit
– PLC, Evolutionary stage >
Steady state
– Development Vs selection
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The performance impact ofThe performance impact of
human resource practiceshuman resource practices
Individual high performance practices
Limitations of individual practices
Evolution of practices
Systems of high performance human resource
practices
Individual best practices Vs systems of practices
Universal practices Vs contingency perspectives
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The performance impact ofThe performance impact of
human resource practiceshuman resource practices
Seven management
practices that enhance
performance –Jefrey Pfeffer
1. Employment security
2. Selective hiring of new personnel
3. Self managed teams and
decentralization of decision
making as basic principle of org
design
4. Comparatively high
compensation on organizational
performance
5. Extensive training
6. Reduced status distinctions and
barriers
7. Extensive sharing of financial and
performance information.
Individual high performance
practices
Limitations of individual
practices
Evolution of practices
Systems of high performance
human resource practices
Individual best practices Vs
systems of practices
Universal practices Vs
contingency perspectives
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The performance impact ofThe performance impact of
human resource practiceshuman resource practices
Compensation
– High compensation linked to organisational
performance
– Incentive based compensation
– Profit sharing
– Team based compensation
Diversity
Employment
– Countercyclical hiring,
downsizing, early retirement
programs, employment security,
human resource outsourcing.
Industrial relations
– Decertification of union
bargaining agent
– Positive labour relations
– Strikes, lockouts
Internal labour market
Individual high performance
practices
Limitations of individual
practices
Evolution of practices
Systems of high performance
human resource practices
Individual best practices Vs
systems of practices
Universal practices Vs
contingency perspectives
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The performance impact ofThe performance impact of
human resource practiceshuman resource practices
motivation
– Decentralized decision
making
– Self managed teams
– Open book management
– Reduced status differentials
or symbolic egalitarianism
Performance management
Staffing
– Cognitive tests, staffing
selectivity, CEO succession
insider outsider, yield
analysis of recruiting sources
Training
Individual high performance
practices
Limitations of individual
practices
Evolution of practices
Systems of high performance
human resource practices
Individual best practices Vs
systems of practices
Universal practices Vs
contingency perspectives
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The performance impact ofThe performance impact of
human resource practiceshuman resource practices
Individual high performance
practices
Limitations of individual
practices
Evolution of practices
Systems of high performance
human resource practices
Individual best practices Vs
systems of practices
Universal practices Vs
contingency perspectives
Each practice has a
different kind of impact on
individual workers – if
possible to address at
individual levels the same
may be done.
Results of studies that
give positive or negative
indication can not be
taken as absolute
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The performance impact ofThe performance impact of
human resource practiceshuman resource practices
Individual high performance
practices
Limitations of individual
practices
Evolution of practices
Systems of high performance
human resource practices
Individual best practices Vs
systems of practices
Universal practices Vs
contingency perspectives
HR practices are path
dependant. They consist
of policies that are
developed over time and
cannot be simply
purchased in the market
by competitors.
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The performance impact ofThe performance impact of
human resource practiceshuman resource practices
Has positive impact
Commitment oriented systems
– Decentralized decision making, general
training, Highly skilled employees,
High wages - bonuses
Human capital enhancement
– Comprehensive training, BARS,
Technical and problem solving skills,
selective staffing
Human resource administrative system
– Hourly pay, individual equity,
individual incentive, result based
performance appraisal
Motivation and commitment system
– Receptiveness to new training,
compensation contingent on firms
performance, extent of status
differentials
Skills and organizational structures
– Attitude survey, access to grievance
procedures, formal job anasysis, info
sharing
Individual high performance
practices
Limitations of individual
practices
Evolution of practices
Systems of high performance
human resource practices
Individual best practices Vs
systems of practices
Universal practices Vs
contingency perspectives
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The performance impact ofThe performance impact of
human resource practiceshuman resource practices
Individual high performance
practices
Limitations of individual
practices
Evolution of practices
Systems of high performance
human resource practices
Individual best practices Vs
systems of practices
Universal practices Vs
contingency perspectives
Mxed evidence and
response
– Some individual practices
have had positive impact
– Systems of practices have
both
Adoption
Implementation
fit
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The performance impact ofThe performance impact of
human resource practiceshuman resource practices
Individual high performance
practices
Limitations of individual
practices
Evolution of practices
Systems of high performance
human resource practices
Individual best practices Vs
systems of practices
Universal practices Vs
contingency perspectives
Have their own
applicability
– Evidence for success of
both
– Greater evidence for
contingency
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human Resource EvaluationHuman Resource Evaluation
Overview of evaluation
Approaches to evaluation
Prevalence of evaluation
Evaluating strategic contributions of
traditional areas
Evaluating strategic contributions in
emerging areas
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human Resource EvaluationHuman Resource Evaluation
Overview of evaluation
Approaches to evaluation
Prevalence of evaluation
Evaluating strategic
contributions of traditional
areas
Evaluating strategic
contributions in emerging
areas
Scope of evaluation
Strategic impact
Level of analysis
Criteria
Level of constituents
Ethical dimensiona
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human Resource EvaluationHuman Resource Evaluation
Overview of evaluation
Approaches to evaluation
Prevalence of evaluation
Evaluating strategic
contributions of traditional
areas
Evaluating strategic
contributions in emerging
areas
Audit approaches
Analytical approaches
Quantitative and
qualitative measures
Balance scorecard
perspective
Benchmarking
Industry influences
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human Resource EvaluationHuman Resource Evaluation
Overview of evaluation
Approaches to evaluation
Prevalence of evaluation
Evaluating strategic
contributions of traditional
areas
Evaluating strategic
contributions in emerging
areas
Little
Results not revealed
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human Resource EvaluationHuman Resource Evaluation
Overview of evaluation
Approaches to evaluation
Prevalence of evaluation
Evaluating strategic
contributions of
traditional areas
Evaluating strategic
contributions in emerging
areas
HRP
Staffing
Training
Performance evaluation
systems
Compensation systems
Utility analysis
labour and employee
relations
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
Human Resource EvaluationHuman Resource Evaluation
Overview of evaluation
Approaches to evaluation
Prevalence of evaluation
Evaluating strategic
contributions of traditional
areas
Evaluating strategic
contributions in emerging
areas
Equal employment
opportunity and
management of diversity
Quality readiness
Ref: SHRM – Charles Greer
The first definition is one proposed by Samuel Certo and J. Paul Peter in their book Strategic Management: Concepts and Applications . This definition is highlighted by the following statement from Cornell Maiser, the chairman of the board of Kaiser: We have begun implementation of our strategic plan for the decade. Two years in formulation, the plan calls for Kaiser to identify its most promising business and focus its resources on long-term development and profitability. Increased resources will be allocated to business lines where the company believes it has existing strengths, such as superior technology, low costs, or strong market positions. The second definition is a little more down to earth. It shows that the firm’s management recognizes that there are forces which affect the firm and the firm’s profitability both inside and outside of the business’s operations. These forces affect two primary components of the firm. The management component includes the firm’s operations, financial position, labor situation, and overall management structure. The marketing component includes not only the firm’s marketing strategy (including packaging, advertising, customer service, quality control procedures, etc.), but also recognizes the fact that there is competition that the firm must face. This competition exists both inside and outside of the firm. While the firm’s outside competition is fairly obvious, the inside competition most often arises from conflicts between the production and management functions of the business and the marketing functions. In many small businesses, these conflicts often reside within one person.
The strategic management process is a series of steps that not only formalize the process, but also give a clear path to the firm’s management as to how the process should be completed. Each of these steps is discussed in turn.
What are the purpose(s) and objective(s) of the organization? – The answer to this question tells management where the organization wants to go. As discussed earlier, appropriate strategy reflect the organization’s mission and objectives. Managers who consider this question during the strategy formulation process are more likely to avoid inconsistencies among the company’s mission, objectives, and strategies. Where is the organization presently going? – This question reveals whether an organization is achieving its goals or at least making satisfactory progress. The first question focuses on where the company wants to go; this question focuses on where the organization is actually going. What critical environmental factors does the organization currently face? – This question addresses both internal and external environments and the factors that are both inside and outside the organization. For example, if a poorly trained middle-management team (internal environment) and an increase in competitive pressure (external environment) are critical strategic concerns, then any strategy formulated should deal with these issues. What can be done to achieve organizational objectives more effectively in the future? – The answer to this question results in the formulation of a strategy for the organization. This, it goes beyond environmental analysis and includes the stages of planning and selection. This question should be answered only after managers have had plenty of opportunity to reflect on the answers to the previous questions. In other words, managers can formulate appropriate organizational strategies only when they have a clear understanding of where the company wants to go, where the organization is actually going, and what the environment in which the organization operates is and is likely to be.
Inbound logistics All those activities concerned with receiving and storing externally sourced materials Operations The manufacture of products and services - the way in which resource inputs (e.g. materials) are converted to outputs (e.g. products) Outbound logistics All those activities associated with getting finished goods and services to buyers Marketing and sales Essentially an information activity - informing buyers and consumers about products and services (benefits, use, price etc.) Service All those activities associated with maintaining product performance after the product has been sold Secondary Activity Description Procurement This concerns how resources are acquired for a business (e.g. sourcing and negotiating with materials suppliers) Human Resource Management Those activities concerned with recruiting, developing, motivating and rewarding the workforce of a business Technology Development Activities concerned with managing information processing and the development and protection of "knowledge" in a business Infrastructure Concerned with a wide range of support systems and functions such as finance, planning, quality control and general senior management