1. The ideal educational system
Higher education
18 13
17 12 Secondary education Secondary education C
O
16 11 grammar school VET
M
P
15 10 U
L
14 9 S
O
13 8 R
Y
12 7
11 6 E
D
10 5 Primary education U
C
9 4 A
T
8 3 I
O
7 2 N
6 1
5 c
4 l Kindergarten
a
a s
g s
e
Final assignment made by Mara Soekarjo and Patrick Vermeulen
25th of January 2010
2. FOREWORD
Foreword
Dear reader,
The past year we have been doing research into twelve different European educational systems.
The report in front of you is the finalization of our efforts.
In September 2008, all the fifth formers in our school were informed about the paper they were
supposed to write. The subject of the paper had to be affiliated with our sector (Economy,
Management and Society).
While mapping our options we came across a field we both found interesting and which
concerned the both of us: education. We both thought the educational system in the Netherlands
was lacking, so we decided to try to draft “the ideal educational system”, as we think it should be.
The freedom in researching this and analyzing something we face everyday was what attracted us
the most.
For our assignment we asked students from all over Europe to contribute to our assignment.
These students who helped us by answering our survey are part of our targeted audience. All of
them are active participants of the national school unions in their countries. We sincerely wish this
paper will inspire them and will give them ideas to improve the educational system in their
country, since our results offer a clear overview of the educational systems used throughout
Europe. This paper may be a bit long for a school paper, but our aim was to write a paper that has
a lot of practical importance and therefore we had to make it extensive.
We first chose our theme and after that we looked for two school subjects supporting this
assignment. Owing to the fact that we wish this report to have international meaning, we decided
to use English throughout, so everyone in Europe will understand it. English is thereby one of our
subjects. The research we have done was primarily focused on the structure and organization of
education, so Management & Organization is the second subject we assigned this paper to.
We sincerely hope you will enjoy reading our research and that it will inspire you to new
educational heights.
Mara and Patrick
1
3. TABLE OF CONTENTS AND INTRODUCTION
Table of contents
Introduction
General introduction to the subject
........................................................................3
Main query
Sub queries
Modus operandi
Commentary
Introducing the participating countries
....................................................................5
Austria
Bavaria
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Croatia
Denmark
Finland
France
Iceland
The Netherlands
Norway
Slovenia
Sweden
Analyses
Different levels
............................................................................................................11
Introduction
Analysis
Transition from primary to secondary education
...............................................14
Time spent at school
.................................................................................................15
Compulsory education
Complementary information
Subject clusters
...........................................................................................................16
Grades and tests
.........................................................................................................18
Different tests
Grading
Materials
.......................................................................................................................19
Final exams
...................................................................................................................21
Methods of examination
Examination subjects
Grading-system
Preparation for the transition from secondary to higher education
..............25
Discussions and conclusions
Different levels
............................................................................................................27
Number of levels
Duration of the education
Transition from primary to secondary education
...............................................27
Structure of primary and secondary education
Decision
Time spent at school
.................................................................................................28
Subject clusters and specific subjects
....................................................................29
Grades and tests
.........................................................................................................29
Materials
.......................................................................................................................30
Final exams
...................................................................................................................30
Transition from secondary to higher education
..................................................31
2
4. TABLE OF CONTENTS AND INTRODUCTION
Final conclusion
Overall view
.................................................................................................................32
Primary education and the transition to secondary education
Levels and organisation of secondary education
Examination
Continuing education on a higher level
List of recommendations
..........................................................................................33
Additional chapters
Post mortem
................................................................................................................35
Bibliography
..................................................................................................................36
Journal
...........................................................................................................................37
Appendix
I. Distribution of tasks
...............................................................................................40
II. Survey
.......................................................................................................................41
Accompanying letter
The educational system in your country
III. Results of the survey
............................................................................................45
Starting at highschool
Different levels of education
Grades and tests
Materials
Choice of sector
Final exams
Preparation for the next step
Spending time at school
Additional information
Introduction
General introduction to the subject
If you take a look at reports about education, you will find a lot of comparisons regarding the
methods of educating and the results accomplished with them. It is on the other hand hard to find
a tangible paper that compares different educational systems. That is why we have chosen for this
type of investigation, which has proven to be a clear method of showing the weaknesses and
strengths of several school systems.
Our aim was to draft an educational system which is ideal in our opinion. We investigated the
structure of education, not the content; we investigated the organization and the system instead of
the methods and curricula.
Our research covered a hypothetical situation. We have compared different components of twelve
European educational systems and let them inspire us. We drafted our system from scratch, so we
did not take for instance the Dutch educational system as point of departure and tried to improve
that. We started from scratch and built our ideal system step by step, using the results of our
research as inspiration. We concentrated on an ideal structure. Our final conclusion is hypothetical
and based on our opinion, which means it perhaps will not be possible to put it into practice,
because of several practical disabilities we did not take into account.
Because of the set up of our investigation, it would be next to impossible to formulate a
hypothesis. The possible results of our research are endlessly varied, so predicting one would be a
mistake.
3
5. TABLE OF CONTENTS AND INTRODUCTION
Main query
We have chosen to work with the comparative and solution-finding query “What are the
features of an ideal educational system?”
Sub queries
It was not really relevant for our investigation to set up sub queries. We have focused on different
fields of research and we have isolated the following topics:
1. Different levels of secondary education
2. Transition from primary to secondary education
3. Time spent at school
4. Subject clusters
5. Grades and tests
6. Materials
7. Final Exams
8. Transition from secondary to higher education
For each topic we tried to find an aspect which best meets our requirements for an ideal
educational system.
Modus operandi
Our research was composed of several phases.
1. Making a survey and sending it to our foreign correspondents.
2. Taking inventory of the results.
3. Analysis of the results, gathering background information.
4. Discussion of the analysis and finding our ideal model.
5. Creating an overall picture of our ideal educational system.
Commentary
We made an extensive survey with questions regarding eight topics. Fortunately, Mara was able to
attend two seminars with European school students present, where she found students from
twelve different countries willing to participate in our project. All of them answered the survey.
We used the results of the survey as a base, which was completed with information from the
Internet. You will find the survey attached to this paper.
We specifically asked our correspondents about their personal opinion on the different topics.
Their opinions were invaluable for our investigation, since they allowed us to take a multilayered
perspective at things, instead of just our own. All of our correspondents are international officers
of their national school student union, so we can safely assume their answers can be very well
trusted.
After we analyzed the results objectively, we discussed the different features we discovered. We
included the features we liked in our ideal educational system.
Finally, we made a list of recommendations and an overall view of our ideal educational system.
4
6. TABLE OF CONTENTS AND INTRODUCTION
Introducing the participating countries
Mara found fourteen students from twelve different countries willing to participate in our
research. They will be introduced shortly and you will be provided with an impression of every
educational system.
1
Austria
Austria, or the Republic of Austria, is a
country in Central Europe that lies landlocked
between several countries including Germany,
Italy and the Czech Republic. The majority of
Austrians speak German; other recognized
languages are Croatian, Hungarian and
Slovene. The capitol of Austria is Vienna.
Our Austrian correspondent is Katharina
Spielmann.
Bavaria
Since every German federal state can make
rules about education autonomously, we have
chosen one federal state. Bavaria, officially
known as the Free State of Bavaria, is a federal
state located in southeast Germany. It is the
largest German state, almost taking up twenty
of the countries area. The state capital is
Munich.
Our Bavarian correspondent is Kristina
Pröstler.
Overviews from http://www.edufile.info.
5
7. TABLE OF CONTENTS AND INTRODUCTION
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Bosnia and Herzegovina is a country
located in southeast Europe. It is almost
landlocked, except for a coastline of the
Adriatic Sea. Three major ethnic groups
reside in Bosnia and Herzegovina: the
Bosniaks, the Serbs and the Croats, each
with their own language. The capitol of
Bosnia and Herzegovina is Sarajevo.
Our correspondent from Bosnia and
Herzegovina is Darija Sesar.
Croatia
The Republic of Croatia is a country in
southeast Europe. It borders Slovenia,
Hungary and Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Croatian is the official language. The
capital of Croatia is Zagreb.
Our Croatian correspondent is
Domagoj Babić.
6
8. TABLE OF CONTENTS AND INTRODUCTION
Denmark
Denmark, or the Kingdom of Denmark, is
a country located in Northern Europe. It
is a Scandinavian country, southwest of
Sweden. The national language is Danish, a
language that is remarkable like Swedish
and Norwegian. The capitol of Denmark is
Copenhagen.
Our correspondents from Denmark are
Mark Burgdorf Fransen and Gwen
Gruner-Widding.
Finland
Finland, or the Republic of Finland, is a
country located in Northern Europe,
bordered by Sweden. The mother
language is Finnish. The capital is
Helsinki.
Our Finnish correspondents are Jyri
Rasinmäki and Björn Larsén.
7
9. TABLE OF CONTENTS AND INTRODUCTION
France
France, or the French Republic, is a
country located in West Europe. It is the
largest country in the European Union
and is one of its oldest members. The
official language is French. The capitol is
Paris.
Our French correspondent is Victor
Grezes.
Iceland
Iceland is a country situated in the
North Atlantic Ocean. It is one of
the European island countries and is
populated by 320.000 people. The
official language is Icelandic. The
capitol city is Reykjavik.
Our Icelandic correspondent is
Stefán Rafn Sigurbjörnsson.
8
10. TABLE OF CONTENTS AND INTRODUCTION
The Netherlands
The Netherlands is a country situated in
North-West Europe. The official language
is Dutch and the capital is Amsterdam.
The survey was answered by ourselves.
Norway
Norway, or the Kingdom of Norway,
is a North-European country. Being
one of the Scandinavian countries,
the Norwegian language shares
similarities with the other
Scandinavian languages. The capital is
Oslo.
Our correspondent from Norway is
Bjørn-Erik Ness, with help from
Kristin Hagan.
9
11. TABLE OF CONTENTS AND INTRODUCTION
Slovenia
Slovenia, or the Republic of
Slovenia, is a country located in
Central Europe, bordering Italy,
Croatia, Hungary and Austria. The
capital of Slovenia is Ljubljana. The
three official languages are
Slovenian, Italian and Hungarian. The
capital is Ljubljana.
Our Slovenian correspondent is
Klemen Balanč.
Sweden
Sweden, or the Kingdom of Sweden, is
a country located on the Scandinavian
Peninsula. It is the third largest country
in the EU. The official language is
Swedish. The capital is Stockholm.
Our Swedish correspondent is Sofia
Brändström.
10
12. ANALYSES
Analyses
Different levels
Introduction
Before we can start comparing the different systems, three terms have to be introduced. Looking
at the different levels, the more practical types of education can be separated from the more
academically oriented types.
The collective term for academically oriented types of secondary school is grammar school. A
type of education preparing students for jobs based in manual or practical activities is called
Vocational Education and Training, abbreviated as VET.
VET studies usually come with a period of apprenticeship: students ‘learn the work while doing it’.
Students are provided with training on the job, while working for an employer who helps them to
learn their trade. In exchange for this training, students give their continuing dedication to the
employer for an agreed period, after they have become proficient in their chosen field. Students
learn the theoretical part at their vocational school.
Analysis
Austria
In Austria, you have three different levels:
- Berufsbildende Schule (BS) is an apprenticeship without a general qualification for university
entrance. The education takes two years of school and a practical part to complete. You could
call this VET.
- Berufsbildende Mittlere und Höhere Schule (BMHS) is a higher school where students learn
special skills like accounting or engineering. The education is finished after five years, and
students can go to work or to university.
- Allgemeinbildende Höhere Schulen (AHS) is general high school, where students obtain the
licence to go to university. AHS is a grammar school. This school is specialized on humanistic
education. To complete, it takes four years for the lower stage and four years for the upper
school.
Bavaria
In Bavaria, three levels of secondary education are provided:
- Hauptschule is about teaching students the basics and preparing them to get a job after
finishing school, mostly in the technical sector. The school has a lot of practical subjects. It takes
five or six years to complete Hauptschule. Hauptschule can be seen as VET.
- Realschule was founded to bridge Hauptschule and Gymnasium. Students learn more theory
than on a Hauptschule, though there are more practical and work-orientated subjects than on
a Gymnasium. It takes six years to complete Realschule.
- Gymnasium is grammar school. A high amount of theoretical study is required. It takes nine
years to complete, but changes are planned to implement eight years instead of nine. Students
are able to go to university afterwards.
Bosnia and Herzegovina
There are no specified levels in the educational system of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Secondary
education is provided by general and technical secondary schools where studies last for four
years. All forms of secondary education include an element of vocational training.
Croatia
Croatian secondary schools can be divided in two types: gymnasiums and vocational schools.
11
13. ANALYSES
Vocational schools are practical schools, and take about two to three years to complete.
Gymnasiums are grammar schools, which take four years. You can choose four different types of
courses:
- prirodoslovno-matematička gimnazija: a school specialized in maths, informatics and science.
- jezična gimnazija: a ‘language-school’ - at least three foreign languages are required.
- klasična gimnazija: a school specialized in classical languages (Latin and Ancient Greek).
- opća gimnazija: a general grammar school.
Denmark
After primary school (the compulsory education), students can basically choose between
gymnasium and vocational education.
Vocational education does not have any levels. It takes three to five years; depending on which
profession you want to learn.
The gymnasium is divided in four different types:
- Højere Forberedelseseksamen (HF), which is a ‘business’ gymnasium.
- Højere Handelseksamen (HHX), which is a ‘higher business’ gymnasium.
- Højere Teknisk Eksamen (HTX), which is a ‘technical’ gymnasium.
- Studentereksamen (STX), which is a general or regular gymnasium.
Most people consider HF as the easiest, followed by the higher business. HTX is definitely the
toughest, with a lot more lessons a year than any of the other courses. In addition to that, the
subjects treat more advanced curricula.
HHX, HTX and STX all take 3 years to complete, and HF takes only 2 years to complete.
Finland
The Finnish secondary school, which is not compulsory, has two levels. Both levels take three years
to finish.
- ammatillinen oppilaitos, yrkesinstitut is the vocational school. The aim of vocational programs is
vocational competence. It is preparing you for a job.
- Lukio, gymnasium is the upper secondary school. This is general secondary education that
prepares students for the final matriculation examination and to continue their study on
university.
France
French secondary education is built from two types of schools:
- Collège, to which can be referred as ‘junior high school’ and lasts for four years.
- Lycée, which follows the collège and lasts for three years.
Every French student, except for the VET students, follows the same ‘normal’ school system,
consisting of collège and lycée. The first year of lycée is the same for everyone. Students specialize
in their last two years. The subjects clusters can be found in the sub query ‘subject clusters’.
There isn’t any difference in the difficulty of the provided education. The difference is in the
content of the subjects.
The vocational education takes two years to finish. The education for lycée-students takes three
years.
Iceland
After the compulsory education, students can go to upper secondary school. It’s called
gymnasium. The typical course length is four years, but it can vary, especially in vocational courses.
Furthermore, there are no levels in Iceland. The Icelandic educational system provides great
freedom for the schools, so it’s up to each school to make its education difficult or easy.
12
14. ANALYSES
The Netherlands
In the Netherlands, there are three levels of secondary education.
1. VMBO (Voorbereidend Middelbaar BeroepsOnderwijs) is VET where vocational training is
combined with a little bit of theoretical education. The VMBO itself is divided into four
different levels. A different mix of practical vocational training and theoretical education is
combined in each level. This education takes four years and is preparing students for the
lowest type of tertiary education.
2. HAVO (Hoger Algemeen Voorgezet Onderwijs) is general education that prepares students for
the middle level of tertiary education. Although HAVO is a bit less rigorous as VWO, it can
also be qualified as a type of general education.
3. VWO (Voorbereidend Wetenschappelijk Onderwijs) is general education that prepares students
for university: - the highest level of tertiary education. VWO is dived in two levels: Atheneum
and Gymnasium. It’s actually the same, except for the fact that studying either Latin or Ancient
Greek is compulsory in Gymnasium.
Norway
The secondary education in Norway can be divided in two parts: lower secondary school (which
is compulsory and the same for every student) and upper secondary school (which is optional). In
upper secondary school, students have to choose between general education and vocational
studies.
Studiespesialisering is a general education, where students are prepared to study at university. It
takes three years to complete this study.
Vocational Education and Training (VET) takes two years in school and two years in
apprenticeship. After two years of school or finishing apprenticeship, students can take
supplementary studies that qualify for higher education.
Slovenia
There are several types of secondary schools in Slovenia: public vocational schools, secondary
technical schools, vocational colleges, student residential facilities and most common gymnazija
(grammar school or gymnasium).
Gymnazija is the highest level of secondary education; it gives you a basic knowledge that is
required to enter university. It takes four years to complete the gymnazija. Secondary technical
schools also take four years to complete. Vocational schools take two to three years to complete.
Sweden
Secondary school is called gymnasieskola. It is not compulsory, although most students attend it.
The secondary school is divided into so called national programs; e.g. students cannot choose
between different levels, but can choose between different educational focuses. The programs are
Natural Science, Social Science, Health and Care, Technical, Children and leisure, Hotel and
restaurant, Industrial, Vehicles, Building, Crafts, Aesthetics, Media, International Baccalaureate, Trade
and administration, Energy, Ventilation and sanitation, and Electricity.
Most programs are divided into different specializations, so there are many programs to choose
between.
The programs are divided into two general categories: preparatory and vocational programs. All
programs give qualification to enter university and college. Every program takes three years.
13
15. ANALYSES
Transition from primary to secondary education
Austria
Austrian children enter secondary education aged ten. It is a huge problem that children have to
choose secondary school when they are ten years old, since they are too young to make that
choice. Parents usually decide what level their children take.
Bavaria
In Bavaria children enter secondary education when they are ten years old. Grades obtained in
the final year of primary school decide what level of secondary education will be followed. It puts
a lot of stress on a youngster’s mind, owing to the fact that they are only ten years old when they
have to make this choice. The choice of secondary education is heavily influenced by the parents.
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Primary education in Bosnia and Herzegovina lasts until the age of fifteen, where a system of
points is used to decide which level a student will take. These points correspond with the grades
obtained in the final year of primary school.
Croatia
Children start primary school at the age of six, and start their secondary school around the age of
fourteen-fifteen. The level of secondary education is decided by the grades obtained in the last
two years of primary. This system does not seem to be equalized and therefore the value of these
points is negligible.
Denmark
In Denmark students are around the age of fifteen-sixteen when they start with their secondary
education. There is a choice in either Gymnasium or vocational school. The general aptitude of the
student is tested and the optimal course is decided based upon the results of this test.
Finland
Primary education starts in Finland around the age of six. Students can enroll in secondary
education at the age of fourteen-fifteen. The level education is decided according to the results of
a test made at the end of the final year in primary school.
France
French students start secondary education aged eleven/twelve, for which no test is required.
Fourteen of fifteen years old students are tested to decide if they will continue their education on
VET- or lycée-level. This system seems to work well.
Iceland
Primary education lasts until the age of ten. There used to exist a test to decide the level of
education, but nowadays there is no way to decide this. Secondary education ends at the age of
fourteen, where one can continue with higher education.
Netherlands
Dutch students enroll secondary education around the age of twelve. The level of secondary
education is decided by the result of a test made in the final year of primary school and the
opinion of the primary school teacher.
Norway
Students start lower secondary education at the age of twelve-thirteen. Fifteen- or sixteen-year-
old students start upper secondary education. Education is the same for every student until after
lower secondary education. A difference in level of education is issued in higher secondary
education.
14
16. ANALYSES
Slovenia
Students start secondary school when they are fourteen of fifteen years old. The level of
secondary education is decided by the marks gotten during the last two years of primary school
plus an exam in Slovenian, maths and a foreign language.
Sweden
Secondary education starts at the age sixteen-seventeen. What level a student takes is decided by
the grades obtained in primary school. Popular schools look for the highest grades; less popular
schools have less high standards.
Time spent at school
Compulsory education
Country From To
Austria 6 14
Bavaria 6 18
Bosnia and Herzegovina 7 15
Croatia 6/7 14/15
Denmark 6/7 14/15
Finland 7 15
France 6 16
Iceland 6 16
The Netherlands 4/5 18 (or graduation)
Norway 6 16
Slovenia 6 15
Sweden 7 16
Complementary information
Austria
The amount of hours students have to go to school depends on the level and the kind of
education they follow.
Bavaria
Schools in Bavaria finish every day at one ‘o clock. This is actually a problem, because students have
not enough time. Students have thirty hours a week. The older they get, the more hours they have
to go to school per week.
15
17. ANALYSES
Bosnia and Herzegovina
All students have to spend the same number of hours in school: six hours per day.
Croatia
The amount of hours students have to be at school is regulated by school classes’ plans and
national framework curricula. Students have to go to school for 35 weeks. The number of hours
they have to spend at school is depending on their age and level of education.
Denmark
The number of hours students have to attend is depending on which subjects they have chosen.
Every subject is designated between 100-250 hours. Twenty percent of the lessons is actually
‘virtual’. This means ‘no teacher present’ and the lesson is ‘over the internet’. The government
claims this is to create more independent students.
Danish law states that ninety percent of the lessons in each subject must be attended in order to
pass the subject. The amount of hours students have to attend differs per level of education.
Finland
Students have to follow 75 courses. One course takes about 36 to 38 hours, so every student
spends around 2700 hours at school.
Iceland
There are no laws regarding the amount of hours students have to spend at school every year.
There is a certain amount of schooldays that the schools have to be operational, which is 170
days per year (=34 weeks per year). Students have to attend around 90% of all classes.
The Netherlands
Every student has to go to school 1000 hours per year, which is decreased to 700 hours in his or
her final year. This amount is regardless of the type of education a student follows.
Norway
Students have the right to be taught in the number of hours the curriculum for each subject is
classed into. A Norwegian law states that the qualification and skills shown by the student are
more important than the actual time spent at school.
Slovenia
A student has to attend to at least eighty percent of the hours required for each subject. It
depends on the type of education how many hours they have to attend.
Sweden
The law guarantees students at least 6665 hours in lower and upper grade schools.
Subject clusters
Austria
In Austria general subjects, German, English and maths, are the same at every school, but the
chosen subjects can differ.
While grammar school offers many theoretical chosen subjects, BMHS has more practical
subjects, e.g. more subjects revolving around learning a profession. Chosen subjects do not actually
exist, because every subject at school has to be followed.
Subject clusters do not exist. It depends on the type of school what subjects a student has to
follow. There does exist a special type of schooling, called Wahlfächer, where you can actually
choose subjects. Subjects cannot be quit.
16
18. ANALYSES
Bavaria
Bavarian students cannot choose individual subjects, but choose a path. These paths consist of a
package of subjects that go well together, similar to the Dutch subject clusters. Paths consist of
compulsory main subjects and additional subjects chosen by the student. Certain special paths
require certain subjects. Students must also follow special subjects, like Debate or Band classes.
The compulsory subjects in Bavaria are German, maths and English. There are countless subjects a
student can choose.
Languages can be quit in the final two years, because the basics are known by then. Subjects
deemed unnecessary can be quit as well.
Croatia
The Croatian compulsory subjects are the same for every level of secondary education: Croatian,
maths and English. Grammar schools have their own set of optional subjects and vocational
schools idem.
Denmark
In Denmark all subjects are the same, regardless of what level a student follow. The vocational and
business grammar schools have the same subjects. In technical grammar school a student has to
pick one extra subject. Subject clusters exist of a few compulsory subjects completed with chosen
subjects.
Students have six months to decide if they definitely want to follow their chosen subjects.
Finland
Every student in Finland follows the same general subjects and has to add three optional subjects
to complete his collection of subjects. Schools also have special courses they autonomously offer,
which brings a rich variety in the Finnish schooling.
Subjects cannot be quit, only when a student is of mixed nationality (both Finnish and Swedish)
and he or she wants to quit either Finnish or Swedish.
France
French students can follow three different subject clusters:
1. Literary: concentration in languages and literature with specialization in modern and classical
languages, mathematics and arts
2. Economical: concentration in economics and history/geography with specialization in
economics, mathematics and languages.
3. Scientific: concentration in mathematics and science with extra specialization in mathematics.
Additional subjects can be physics, chemistry, biology and natural sciences, and technology.
Iceland
Every student in Iceland follows the same package of general subjects, existing of Icelandic, maths,
science, Danish, a third language and sociology.
The schools decide the other subjects autonomously. The schools are encouraged by the
government to be as creative as possible. A wide variety of subjects are thus offered among
schools, such as poison making and horseback riding.
Only chosen subjects can be quit.
The Netherlands
All Dutch programs of secondary education spend the first few years on the same fifteen
compulsory subjects. After this basic curriculum, students can slowly decide which subjects they
want to follow. The subject cluster you wish to take in the future thus decides the subjects,
because every subject cluster has its compulsory subjects. The subjects that are compulsory for
every student, regardless of chosen subject cluster, are Dutch, English and maths. The additional
subjects are largely decided throughout the choice of subject cluster.
17
19. ANALYSES
Subjects can only be quit if you have the minimum amount of subjects needed. In grammar
school, a classical language (Ancient Greek or Latin) is compulsory.
Norway
Norwegian primary and secondary schools offer the same package of subjects. Qualifications for
subjects differ per level of education. The different levels prepare for different goals and therefore
decide the difficulty of the subjects.
General subjects in Norway are maths, English, Norwegian, physics, social sciences and physical
education. The list of chosen subjects is long and every study has subjects unique to them.
Subjects can only be quit when they are replaced with another subject.
Slovenia
In Slovenia the subjects differ per program, but every students has maths and the mother tongue.
Subject clusters do not exist in Slovenia; there only is a difference in programs.
Sweden
Subjects in Sweden are worth points. A minimum of 2500 points should be met. Swedish, English,
maths and physical education are worth 100 points; taking a religion or science class is rewarded
with 50 points. Points are gained when a course is completed. Some courses are specific to a
certain program.
Grades and tests
Different tests
Students in every investigated country have to face smaller and bigger tests. The bigger tests are
given at the end of semester, covering a large amount of subject matter. The smaller tests are given
throughout the year and can occur unannounced and orally.
Grading
Austria
A 1-5 scale is used to grade the tests; one being the highest and five being the lowest. This system
is looked down upon, because there are too few grades, so no real distinction can be made.
Bavaria
Marks (6-1) are used from class three to class ten. From class eleven on, points (1-15) are used.
The marks and points correspond as follows:
Mark Points Word equivalent Pass/fail? Mark Points Word equivalent Pass/fail?
15 6
1 14 Very good Passed 4 5 Sufficient Passed
13 4
12 3
2 11 Good Passed 5 2 Insuffient Failed
10 1
9
3 8 Satisfying Passed 6 0 Not enough Failed
7
18
20. ANALYSES
Bosnia and Herzegovina
The grading-scale is the exact opposite of the Austrian scale:
five is the highest and one the lowest grade.
Croatia
The grading-system used is five to one; five being the highest
and one being the lowest.
Denmark
The grading is done according to the American system: a
certain amount of points qualifies for a certain letter. The pass
grades are A=12 B=10 C=7 and the fail-grades are D=4 E=2
F=0 Fx=-3.
Finland
The grading is 4 to 10, 4 being the lowest and 10 being the highest. Finnish universities have
entrance exams, which actually makes the grades useless, since universities only look at the grades
obtained in the entrance exams.
France
The grading is 0-20, 10 being average and 20 being perfect. It is thought that perfection is a state
humanly unattainable. Therefore it is impossible to get a 20.
Grades have a different value in the different sectors. The grades obtained in maths and sciences
weigh heavier in the scientific sector and languages are of more value in the literary sector.
Iceland
The grading is 0-10, 0 being the lowest and 10 being the highest. Tests are entirely up to the
teachers, absolutely decentralized.
The Netherlands
The grading is 1-10, 1 being the lowest and 10 being the highest.
Norway
The grades go from 1 to 6, 1 being the lowest and 6 being the highest. Some subjects have higher
demands to get a good grade.
Slovenia
The grading is 1-5, 1 being the lowest and 5 being the highest.
Sweden
A 1 to 4 grading is used. 1 is not approved and 4 is very well approved. The grading system will be
changed to the American system (A-F). The four-point-scale offers too little distinction and will
therefore be changed.
Materials
Austria
The Austrian system heavily relies on books. Other methods of education, like practical lessons,
are not regarded being as useful as books. Parents have to make a small contribution, around 20
Euros); school covers the remaining costs.
Bavaria
School finances all used materials, which are most of the time books. The preferred method of
teaching is listing to the teacher and studying from books, but excursions, experiments and the use
of Internet are becoming more and more commonplace.
19
21. ANALYSES
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Students from Bosnia and Herzegovina have to pay for their books, which are the most common
material used for education. Extra methods of teaching are scarce, but audio is used and in some
cases the Internet.
Croatia
In Croatia students use books. The Croatian government used to pay for the materials, but as a
result of the recession the students now have to finance their books themselves. In vocational
school practical lessons are abundant, while grammar school favors experiments as extra method
of teaching.
Denmark
Danish schools use books and digital material. A laptop is required in the technical gymnasium. The
parents have to pay 350 Euros, and the school finances the extra books. Some subjects like
science or music use practical methods, and in the final year of gymnasium you are obliged to
follow a workshop.
Finland
Finland uses books and the Internet. In most cases parents pay, but smaller school sometimes are
willing to pay for the material, to make the school more attractive. Teachers have great freedom in
shaping the lessons as they see fit. It is encouraged to look ‘beyond the book’.
France
In France the preferred method of education is the book. The prices for books are set regionally,
and the parents have to pay. The educational system in France also uses digital sources and
practical lessons.
Iceland
Icelandic schools use books and in some cases the teachers have the freedom to produce their
own material and pus it on the Internet so it is accessible by the students. The Icelandic
government used to pay for schoolbooks, but nowadays the students have to pay. Practical and
digital lessons are also a part of the education.
The Netherlands
Dutch students primarily use books, with some supporting Internet-lessons. The schools finance all
the materials, by using the 316 euro per student given to them by the
government.
Norway
Norway uses books, with digital lessons. In secondary and upper secondary
the students receive a computer for schoolwork. The government pays for
the books, but students have to pay an annual fee for the computer. Some
subjects do not require books. Practical lessons are seen as a welcome
addition to any subjects, so these are encouraged.
Slovenia
In the educational system of Slovenia books are the preferred method.
Books can be hired from specific companies, or bought by the parents.
Practical lessons and digital lessons are becoming more popular.
Sweden
Mostly books are used in Sweden, and a lot of schools have started
supplying their student with laptops. The schools pay for the material, and
decide on the amount of money spent. Every school had the freedom to
decide on the methods itself.
20
22. ANALYSES
Final exams
Methods of examination
Austria
The official Austrian term for the final exams is Matura or Reifeprüfung. The different levels stand
for different education. The gymnasium (AHS) focuses on general education. Students can decide if
they want to take either three written exams and four oral exams, or vice versa. The written
exams are held during one week in May. Oral exams are held a month later.
Another way to finish your Matura is to write a Fachbereichsarbeit (FBA), which is a detailed
work on a special subject. Making your FBA is a lot of work, but it reduces your number of written
exams by one.
The Austrian Matura is decentralized, meaning all exams students take are made their own
teachers. There exists an examination board, which consists of a candidate’s teacher, the
headmaster and one external person (usually someone from another school).
Bavaria
The term for the final exams in Germany is Abitur, which is often shortened to Abi. The
governments of the different federal states produce the final exams. These are written exams, but
in some cases students also have the possibility to take oral exams to improve their grade.
The final mark consists of two parts:
- The mark obtained in the final exams students take in May, made by the government (=
centralized)
- A summary mark, which consists of marks obtained during the last one or two years,
depending on which school the student goes.
Bosnia and Herzegovina
In Bosnia and Herzegovina, the final year is not very different from the other years. To pass your
final year, your marks have to be passes. If students do not have sufficient marks, the teachers of
that subject make a special test.
Every school makes their own final exams; this makes it a decentralized process.
Croatia
The students are tested in their final year of secondary school by the National Centre for
Evaluation of Education. The final exams are called Matura.These exams are nationwide exams
and were introduced in the schoolyear 2009/2010. The exams are made by an independent
centre, therefore the Croatian examination system is centralized; individual schools do not make
their own exams.
Before this system was introduced, schools made examinations for their own students. This
worked well, except that the level of the exams was incomparable.
Denmark
In Denmark, an exam can be written or oral. For some subjects (for instance a language), a written
component is compulsory, but other subjects (for instance history) have no written parts. Some
subjects have an oral or practical component. This depends on which type of school a student
goes to, along with the chosen subjects.
An interesting way of examination in Denmark is the 24-hours take-home exam. This way of
examination means that students go to school, collect their exam and during the following 24
hours they have to write a paper about their given subject. After 24 hours they have to come
back to school and hand it in. This way of examination is a method a lot of universities use. At
universities, it is an examination used for tests that are too long to be completed in a single
21
23. ANALYSES
session as an in-class exam. Universities have 24-hour take-home exams, but some exams also
have a deadline that is a week or two.
You need to pass a total of ten exams spread out over all three years of secondary education.
One in the first year, one or two in the second year, and seven or eight in your final year. After all
exams are passed, both the examination grade and the yearly grade are put on your diploma.
Finland
The final exams are called Ylioppilastutkinto or Studentexamen. The Matriculation Examination
Board arranges the final exams, so the Finnish exams are centralized exams. Students will also get
a diploma with the average of their grades obtained in the last school year.
Students will not obtain their place in a higher education based on their grades from their Final
Exams - every university has its own entrance exam. Students will get some extra points for an
excellent Final Exam-score, but every student must take the test provided by the university. The
philosophy behind this is that this way everyone has a ‘second chance’. If, for some reason, you
failed your final exams, you will still have the possibility to study at any place you want, as long as
achieve acceptable results on your entrance exam.
France
If you pass your final exam, it’s called passer le bac in French. The official term for the final exams
is le baccalauréat.
There is a difference between the professional and the technologic baccalauréat: the aim of the
professional baccalauréat is to acquire a diploma that allows you to get a job and possibilities for a
future career. The technological baccalauréat is made for the students who are unable to follow
the ‘general’ sections, but still intend to carry on their studies once they have graduated.
The final exams in France are centralized. For graduation, only the marks obtained at the final
exams will be used. Universities sometimes look at the results you obtained during your last two
years. As you can imagine, this formidable idea came from Napoleon Bonaparte, who was a big
fan of centralization.
Almost every exam is written (essay-form), but some exams are examined orally (foreign
languages) or examined with practical tests. Interesting is that multiple-choice exams do not
appear in the baccalauréat.
The technical exams do not differ much from the other levels, only a more practical approach is
used.
22
24. ANALYSES
Iceland
Icelandic students in their final year are tested in the same manner they were during the other
years of secondary education. Teachers can make their own tests and decide about how to test
their students autonomously. Also because Iceland is a very small country (as stated in the
introduction of Iceland: the population only exists of about 320.000 people), they like to keep
their system decentralized.
There is a very good education basis for teachers and a good monitoring system in Iceland. This
way it can be monitored that teachers provide a good level for the final exams. It has been tried in
2005 to install a centralized exam at the end of secondary schools, but it was abolished the same
year, because many people were dissatisfied.
The Netherlands
The final exam (eindexamen) in the Netherlands consists of two parts. In May, all students in their
final year take a written exam in all their subjects. The Ministry of Education makes these tests. The
weight of the marks achieved in the Central Exams is 50% of the final mark. The other 50% of the
mark is an average of all the School Exams that were taken throughout the two final years. These
tests are made by the schools and are either written, oral or a project (such as writing a paper);
schools can autonomously decide how they want to fill in the School Exams.
In addition to the final marks (mark for Central exam and mark for School Exam combined), the
mark for your Final Assignment will also appear on your diploma. This is an assignment students
have to write in their final year, in which two chosen subject are combined. Students have to do a
research into a field of their choice. The assignment you are reading right now is a Final
Assignment.
Norway
If you finish secondary education in Norway, you will get a final grade and an exam grade. The
exam grade is the grade you obtained for the big exam you make at the end of your secondary
school. At the final grading of each subject, teachers look at the skills of students in the last period
of each year.
There is no centralized system in Norway; the individual schools are responsible for all
examinations. Teachers can decide on if they want to make either oral or written exams.
Slovenia
In Slovenia, your final exams are (just as in Austria and Croatia) called Matura. It’s an obligatory
test and is the main criteria for admission to university or college, since Slovenian universities do
not have their own entrance exams.
The final exam is a completely centralized affair, because all exams are made by the National
Examinations Centre. Thus, these exams are very objective and kind of basic. The exams are both
written and oral.
Sweden
The situation in Sweden is very interesting: they do not have final exams at all. Students do have
national tests, which they have to do in grade 5 and 9, but these test are not similar to exams. If
you want to apply for university, they look either to your secondary education grades, or you have
to do an entrance exam.
The system in Sweden is different, because education is only mandatory until the age of 16,
secondary education isn’t mandatory in Sweden. It is a choice and therefore final exams do not
exist.
23
25. ANALYSES
Examination subjects
Country Compulsory Chosen
Austria German, maths, foreign language Depending on your specialization
Bavaria German, maths, Depending on your specialization/school
Croatia Croatian, maths, foreign language Everything you want, as much as you want.
Denmark Written Danish It’s like a lottery every year: if your subject is
drawn, you have to do the exam.
Finland Mother tongue (Finnish or Swedish) Maths, foreign language, second domestic
language, one other subject
France Subjects linked to your sector
Iceland All general and all chosen subjects are compulsory in your exams.
Netherlands Dutch, English, maths Depending on your chosen sector.
Norway Norwegian Subjects where you have to be chosen
Slovenia Slovene, maths, foreign language You can choose yourself
As you can see the mother tongue, math and one foreign language are the compulsory subjects
for the final exams in the majority of countries. Every exam consists of compulsory and elective
subjects, although the amount of subjects differs.
Grading-system
Austria
Students’ teachers check the written exams and a principal or a teacher from another school
rechecks them. Oral exams are graded by a committee of teachers, the principal of the school and
‘the president of the Matura’. Thus, grades in Austria are given thoroughly discussed.
Bavaria
The student’s teachers grade the exams with help of the guidelines made by the ministry of
Education of the regarding federal. The final exams are checked and graded internally, but with
guidelines issued by an external organization.
Bosnia and Herzegovina
The teachers of the student’s school decide on the grades of the exams. The final exams are
graded internally.
Croatia
The exams are graded by the same organization that makes the exams: the National Centre for
Evaluation of Education. So, all exams are checked and graded externally.
Denmark
An external censor and the teacher decide all grades. They both give the student the grade they
think he or she deserves. They will have to discuss and reach consensus about the final grade. So,
this is a combination of internally and externally grading.
Finland
The exams are checked by official workers of the Matriculation Examination Board. Thus, the
exams in Finland are checked externally. The tests are graded according to a normal distribution
(see illustration on the next page) into seven verbal grades with Latin names:
Improbatur (I), Approbatur (A), Lubenter Approbatur (L), Cum Laude Approbatur (C), Magna
Cum Laude Approbatur (M), Eximia Cum Laude Approbatur (E) and Laudatur (L); L being the
best you can get, A being required to pass the test.
24
26. ANALYSES
!
France
The papers are sent anonymously to a national centre where they are corrected. The French final
exams are graded externally.
Iceland
All Icelandic secondary schools can decide autonomously about the shape and design of the
examination. Therefore, they can internally grade the exams themselves.
The Netherlands
The School Exams are checked internally by the teachers who made the exams. The government
makes guidelines to check the Central Exams. The student’s teacher (First Corrector) checks the
exam, which is later rechecked by a teacher from another school (Second Corrector). If they
disagree, they have to meet and discuss to reach consensus. So, it is a combination of internal and
external grading.
Norway
Anonymous teachers from other parts of the country grade the exams in Norway. So, the exams
in Norway are graded externally.
Slovenia
The Matura-exams are graded by teachers from the National Examinations Centre. These
teachers get the exams coded, so the teachers do not know whose exam they are grading. The
exams are graded externally.
Preparation for the transition from secondary to higher education
Austria
The schools in Austria do not have any real preparation. Students have to decide autonomously
which study they want to apply for. Visiting universities is possible, but has to be arranged by the
student.
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Universities make brochures to show what they offer, but secondary schools do not organize any
formal preparation. Students have the possibility to talk to counselors, which is informal.
Croatia
Croatian secondary schools offer some preparation, which starts a year before students have to
choose their university education. Counselors are available to talk to.
Denmark
The preparation starts the first year of gymnasium. Students must make ‘future plans’ for five
years. Although info-days with education-fairs are organized and guidance by counseling is offered,
students must actively search for information. Students can visit open-days and can drop-in and
follow a lecture at universities.
Finland
Finnish schools have a subject called student guiding, where further studies are discussed.
Universities also visit schools to give information. The majority of preparation is done by school
and starts the last year of secondary school.
25
27. ANALYSES
Iceland
There is no formal preparation in Iceland. If you want to prepare, you have to do it yourself.
Universities regularly give study tours.
The Netherlands
Students are prepared during the final years of secondary education. Certain studies at university
require certain subjects followed on secondary school and therefore the preparation starts
relatively early. The guidance at school is however not always arranged properly, so students have
to do a lot of preparation themselves. Unfortunately, many students are dropping out in their first
year at university, because they have made the wrong decision.
Norway
Students in Norway are offered counseling service. They can visit universities and follow a lecture.
Preparation starts the last two years of secondary school. The preparation is sufficient, but many
students drop out at their first year of study. Many of them have made the wrong decision and are
unmotivated.
Slovenia
Slovenian students can visit information days at universities. Universities have two information days
per year.
Sweden
All Swedish schools have ‘professional counselors’ to guide the students through the process of
choosing their further studies.
26
28. DISCUSSIONS AND CONCLUSIONS
Discussions and conclusions
Different levels
Number of levels
Secondary education in the majority of the countries has a clear division between vocational
schools and grammar schools. Some countries like Austria, Bavaria and the Netherlands even have
a level in-between, allowing for more diversity and options. Croatia and Denmark have different
types of grammar school (business and technical grammar school.)
The system in Sweden is one-of-a-kind, for they have no different levels, but seventeen different
programs. We find this a very interesting way of secondary schooling, but we favor a clear division
in levels. We think students can develop at best when they are offered an education which also
suits them according to their intellectual abilities, not only according to their interests.
We think it is positive that students can choose between vocational and grammar school, e.g.
choose between practical and theoretical education. To pick from a large variety of secondary
schooling is a good thing, because that way students can pick a course that suits them best.
We do think a change should be made in the mixture of theoretical and practical education.
Vocational schools should offer a bit more theory, where grammar schools should pay more
attention to practical approaches. Students will profit more when they are offered a better mix of
teaching.
We also think apprenticeship should be compulsory in vocational education. Apprenticeship offers
experience and offers students more understandability about the real content of the job.
Duration of the education
The number of years a student has to spend at school differs per country. In Denmark the HF
gymnasium takes two years, while the gymnasium in Bavaria takes nine years. VET takes fewer
years to compete than grammar schools in every country.
The structure of primary and secondary school we would like to introduce will be very different
from the existing structures. Lengthening primary school will allow us to cut basic education from
secondary school, which can be shortened to three (VET) or four (grammar school) years.
The main causes and arguments for this measure can be found in the topic ‘primary to secondary
education’.
Transition from primary to secondary education
Structure of primary and secondary education
A clear division can be made based on the age when compulsory education starts. Primary school
in Slovenia and Bosnia and Herzegovina starts at age 6-7 and lasts till age 14-15. Every student
follows the same education until this age, regardless of intelligence or general aptitude. Norwegian
education is split into primary education, lower secondary education and upper secondary
education. Primary and lower secondary education focus on the development of basic knowledge
and are the same for every student.
These systems inspired us to develop our structure of primary and secondary school.
We agree with the mentioned countries that the main goal of primary education should be to
provide students with basic education. ‘Our’ primary school (and also compulsory education) will
start when students are six years old. Education should be compulsory until after finishing
secondary education. This means compulsory education will not be linked to a fixed age.
27
29. DISCUSSIONS AND CONCLUSIONS
Primary school will offer students a basic curriculum. The main practice of basic competences will
be cut from secondary education, which should therefore take three (VET) or four (grammar
schools) years. Primary education should be lengthened in order to complete the basic curriculum
properly and should last from grade one to grade nine, from age six to age fifteen.
Secondary school will be primarily about specialization. By specialization we mean the possibility
for students to follow lessons that they have chosen themselves. A social sciences oriented student
can drop subjects like biography and chemistry, while a science oriented student can stop
following subjects like geography and history. Every student will be offered an education perfectly
suiting his or her interests. We agree basic subjects as the mother tongue, English and maths are
significantly important and therefore we do think they should be rehearsed in secondary school.
Continuing education at university will lead to an academically oriented knowledge.
This measure is based on three arguments, linked to the problems we found during our research:
1. Basic knowledge versus specialization
Treating the majority of the basic curriculum in primary school allows us to cut a lot of time
spent at secondary school wasted by basic teaching. Every student will have the same amount
of basic knowledge. Because secondary school will be dominated by specialization, students
get taught using a more in-depth method.
2. Social development
Students will spend more time together in class with students of different intellectual and
social abilities/competences. This will result in more developed social skills, since the students
will have to deal with a lot more ‘different people’ and the social estrangement with people
from different levels and backgrounds will decrease.
3. Choice of students versus choice of parents
Correspondents from several countries classified the fact that twelve-year-old students are
not capable of deciding which secondary school they should take, as a problem. Students are
too young and starting secondary school at such an early age puts too much stress on a
youngster. Lengthening primary school will allow students to develop a more clear view about
what they really want to do, mapping the strengths and weaknesses. The choice of secondary
school will be theirs to make instead of their parents’.
Decision
Sweden uses the grades gotten in the final year of primary school to decide what level of
secondary school students should attend. Danish students on the other hand have to make a test.
We think a marriage of this would work. The ‘advice’ will be based on both the final test and the
grades obtained in the final year.
In addition to this objective measure, we think the recommendation of the primary school teacher
should also be taken into account. A test can examine the intellectual abilities; teachers have
personal experience with the youngsters and have therefore a clear image of the student. If
students somehow fail to make their test according to their aptitude, they can always be ‘saved’ by
their final-year teacher. Nevertheless the final-year teacher’s vote should never be prevailing.
Time spent at school
If one was to take a look at the ages children start secondary education, the average age is six
years. In our opinion six years is a good age to start primary school, as stated in the sub query
primary to secondary education. Kindergarten should not be compulsory, but should be offered.
Primary education is compulsory in every country. However, there is a difference in the duration
of it. Norwegian primary school lasts until ninth grade, so students are sixteen when finishing
compulsory education. Dutch education is compulsory until students are eighteen years old or
when they have graduated.
28
30. DISCUSSIONS AND CONCLUSIONS
We think offering every child a proper education is of the greatest importance. Education should
be made compulsory until after graduation secondary school. This will protect children and make
sure that they have reached a sufficient level of knowledge when they start to work. We therefore
also think compulsory education should depend on whether a student finishes his or her
education instead of reaching a certain age.
The actual time a student spends at his or her secondary school, should be linked to the subjects
the student is following. In order to assure proper lessons, a set quantity of hours should be met,
according to subject.
Subject clusters and specific subjects
Every country has got a certain amount of compulsory subjects. Usually these are the mother
language, English and maths. We agree with these subjects and will include them in our model,
since they are basic skills and are an absolute requirement for continuation of secondary
education. Since we think the focal point in secondary education should specialization, these
compulsory subjects should be seen as an addition to your chosen subjects. The compulsory
subjects should be rehearsed instead of mainly practiced, as are the chosen subjects.
This basic curriculum provided at primary school has to include, alongside of the basic subjects,
subjects like social studies, physical education and an introduction to science. This way, even if you
do not choose for a scientific course, a student will still have a basic understanding of scientific
fields. We offer students a more in-depth curriculum with this measure.
A clear system is used in France consisting of three subject clusters: literary, economical and
scientific. This is something that we favor for its distinction and clarity. Specific subjects are
compulsory for specific subject clusters; the rest can be entirely up to the student. We want to
allow them as much freedom as possible.
In Denmark a ‘trying-out system’ is used. Students ‘try out’ their temporary subject cluster and
chosen subjects the first six months of secondary school. This way the students can easily and
freely decide what subjects they really wish to follow. We are very enthusiastic about this method
and we therefore want to include this in our model. Since students start secondary school aged
fourteen/fifteen and the education takes only three or four years, students have to announce
which sector they want to take when they register. After six months, their choice will be finalized.
Finally we want to incorporate the system based on points used in Sweden in our system. Each
subject requires a certain amount of points to pass the subject. By participating with projects,
tests, excursions and other activities points are acquired. Students will be motivated to actively
participate in both lessons and extracurricular activities.
Grades and tests
What first caught our eye was that every country has both small and big tests. The smaller tests
usually consist of oral testing and unannounced tests, while the bigger tests are usually at the end
of a semester and are always properly announced. We will include this system in our model. A
curriculum has to be completed in the end. This means big tests are required. We also agree with
unannounced small tests, since they keep students sharp and force students to stay on course.
The grading is varied. The Netherlands and Iceland use the 1-10 system, while France uses a
system from 0 to 20 and in Croatia a 1-5 scale is used. We think the system used in Iceland and
the Netherlands works best. The scale is large enough to give a good perspective and a clear
distinction can be made. We think the French system is too vague and a five-point system used in
Croatia cannot give good insights in the distinctions of quality.
29
31. DISCUSSIONS AND CONCLUSIONS
Materials
There is not much to discuss about our research on this subject. Books are used throughout
Europe. It is noteworthy that Swedish and Norwegian schools provide students with a personal
laptop. We think a personal laptop is wonderful: schoolwork can be done anytime and everywhere
and can be adjusted to modern methods of presenting and studying. We do think books are
sufficient sources for education, but they are a bit boring for modern students.
Lastly, we think that materials should be as diverse as possible, so aside from books, we think that
practical lessons, excursions, experiments, group projects should be encouraged. A theory-only
system is flawed, because there is no way to test the knowledge in a practical situation.
Final exams
Again, there is a very clear division: the exams in half of the participating countries are centralized
and the other half has got decentralized final exams.
Comparing the systems, we think a centralized exam has got the most advantages.
The first argument is that centralized exams assure that graduates all make an exam of the same
level. A difference in difficulty of different schools is eliminated because of the centralization. The
second reason is that in this case entrance exams for universities are not needed anymore. A
student proves that he or she is smart enough for university when passing the final exams. An
entrance requirement can for instance contain a minimal mark obtained in the final exams.
Therefore the final exams in our ideal system will be centralized. Schools should examine their
students autonomously during their school years, but graduation should only be depending on the
marks obtained in the final exams.
We do not think a final exam should be one big test at the end of a student’s school career. The
final exams should contain multiple tests, spread out over the final year of secondary school. This
way the workload is also spread. Students can for instance have four tests belonging to their
‘English final exam’: one listing-test, one 24-hour exam (as seen in Denmark), one reading-test and
one speaking-exam. The whole final year at secondary school will be dominated completely by
final exams.
Completely centralized and objective final exams also mean that a National Centre for Evaluation
of Education (as seen in Croatia) should be established. A certain commission should be
responsible for the constructing of the final exams and the grading. This kind of external grading
assures that the exams are graded objectively.
Looking at the subjects that will be examined: every student should take final exams of at least
seven subjects. Three of those are compulsory for everyone: the mother tongue, English and
mathematics. These subjects actually belong to the ‘basic education’ also provided in primary
education. Since these subjects are so important, they will be rehearsed in secondary school as
well. To make sure students leave secondary school with sufficient skills in these important
subjects, they will be tested in the form of a final exam. The other four subjects you can choose
yourself.
30
32. DISCUSSIONS AND CONCLUSIONS
Transition from secondary to higher education
The preparations for the transition in all countries we compared have one thing in common: it
seems to be insufficient everywhere. Countries either do not have a formal preparation (which
results in students having to prepare for themselves), or the preparation provided by school is not
working (which also results in students having to prepare themselves).
Universities have info-days and in some countries you can even drop-in and follow a lecture in.
Still, the fact remains that lots of students dropout of their study after the first year. We think a
proper preparation, which should be done by the school, is the solution. We do think that the
info-days and drop-in-lessons are a great way of introducing students to the study.
Preparation should already start at the first year secondary education.
In the final year of secondary school, when students are supposed to have a clear view of their
interests, they can visit universities and focus on what kind of higher education they want to
choose.
31
33. FINAL CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Final conclusion
Overall view
The different features of our ideal educational system have been discussed in the eight sub conclusions
corresponding with our eight topics. Some new measures cover multiple areas and were therefore
discussed in all of the concerning sub conclusions. This final conclusion will provide a clear overview of
our ideal system; extensive arguments and cases for specific measures can be found in the eight sub
conclusions. A list of tangible recommendations can also be found in this final conclusion.
Primary education and the transition to secondary education
Children will start primary school aged six. Parents
can decide to send their children to kindergarten,
Higher education
where they will learn while playing. Kindergarten
should be seen as an optional and complementary
preparation for primary school.
Primary education will provide students with a solid 18 13
basis of knowledge. This basic curriculum will be 17 12 Secondary education Secondary education C
O
completed in nine years, since primary education 16 11 grammar school VET
M
P
15 10 U
will last from grade one to grade nine. The basic 14 9
L
S
curriculum will contain the basic subjects alongside 13 8
O
R
of special subjects like social studies, physical 12 7 Y
education and an introduction to sciences. 11 6 E
D
10 5 Primary education U
C
Children will be approximately fifteen years old 9 4 A
T
when they decide to which secondary school they 8 3 I
O
will go. The level of their secondary school is 7 2 N
6 1
decided based the grades obtained and a final test 5 c
made in their final year of primary school. Their 4 l Kindergarten
a
teacher can recommend a level of secondary a s
school, but the final choice relies in the hands of g s
e
children themselves.
Levels and organisation of secondary education
There will be a clear division between vocational education and grammar schools. Vocational
education will be a mainly practically, but will also contain a bit of essential theory. Apprenticeship
is compulsory. Vocational education will last three years. Grammar schools will offer a theoretical
education, which is completed with several practical supplements. Grammar school will last four
years.
Secondary education will be mainly about specialization and therefore students will choose a
subject cluster when entering secondary education. These three subject clusters, literary,
economical and scientific, will exist of several subjects that fit that theme. The first six months of
secondary education will be a try-out period. Students will have to announce which subject cluster
they want to take when they register and have to finalize their choice after these six months.
Alongside these chosen subjects, every student has to follow lessons of the mother tongue,
English and maths. Although the main aim of secondary education is specialization, these subjects
are so inevitably important they still have to be rehearsed in secondary education.
The amount of hours a student has to spend at school will be in linked to the subjects he or she
has chosen.
32
34. FINAL CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Students will study mainly from books. Schools will provide students with a laptop if this is
financially possible.
Examination
In the first two (VET) or three (grammar school) years of secondary school, students have tests
made by their own teachers. They will be graded by means of a 1-10 scale.
A scale based on points will be introduced in addition to this. Students can acquire points by
participating with projects, excursions and other (extracurricular) activities. Every subject requires
a certain amount of points to pass.
The last year of secondary school will be dominated by the final exams. The exams consist of
multiple tests, spread out over the last year of secondary school. A National Center for Evaluation
of Education will be established to coordinate these centralized exams. This commission will be
responsible for the construction and the grading of the final exams. Students will take final exams
in at least seven subjects, among which the aforementioned subjects will be. The other four will be
chosen by students themselves by means of their chosen subject cluster.
Continuing education on a higher level
Education will be compulsory until after finishing secondary education. In most cases students will
be eighteen or nineteen years old then. If students wish to develop their knowledge to an
academically based knowledge, they can continue their education on higher education. Although
higher education is optional, it should be encouraged by secondary school. Schools have to start
the preparation already in the first year of secondary education. Students will follow lessons
‘career counseling’. Counseling will first focus on discovering a student’s interest to later find a
study in accordance with their interests. Universities will ease a student’s decision by organizing
open-days and offering the possibility to drop-in and follow a lecture.
List of recommendations
1. Different levels
I. A clear division in levels should be made in the structure of secondary education.
Students should have the choice between VET and grammar school, the choice between
a more practical and a more theoretical education.
II. Vocational education should also contain a bit of theoretical education. Grammar schools
should also have a sufficient amount of practical education.
III. Apprenticeship should be compulsory in vocational education.
2. Primary to secondary
Duration of the education/ structure
I. Primary school should start at age six.
II. Compulsory education should not be linked to an age. Education should be compulsory
until after graduating secondary school.
III. Primary education should last from grade one to grade nine, from age six to age
fourteen.
IV. The main goal of primary education should be providing students with basic education.
Secondary schools should be for specialization.
V. Secondary education should take three (VET) or four (grammar schools) years. Students
will finish secondary education aged 18/19.
33
35. FINAL CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Decision about transition
VI. The advice to which level of secondary education a student should go, should be based
on both the result a final test made in the last year of primary school and the grades
obtained in the last year of primary school.
VII. The recommendation of the final-year teacher should be heard, but should never be
prevailing.
3. Time at school
I. Primary school should start at age six.
II. The actual time students spend at secondary school should be linked to the subjects
followed by the student.
4. Subject clusters
I. There should be three compulsory subjects: the mother tongue, English and maths.
II. The basic education offered in primary education should contain, alongside of the basic
subjects, subjects like social studies, physical education and an introduction to science.
III. There should be a clear system consisting of three sectors: literary, economical and
scientific (the French system).
IV. The first six months of secondary education should be a try-out period. Students have to
announce which sector they want to take when they register and will have to finalize
their choice after six months.
V. A system based on points should be introduced. Every subject requires a certain amount
of points to pass.
VI. Points are acquired by participating with projects, tests, excursions and other activities.
Tests award a certain amount of points, projects idem, etc. This way students have some
freedom in their lessons.
5. Grades and tests
Tests
I. There should be both small and big tests. Smaller tests should consist of oral testing and
unannounced tests. Bigger tests are always announced.
Grading
II. A 1-10 scale should be used.
6. Materials
I. Students should study mainly from books.
II. A personal laptop for students should be provided by schools if this is financially possible.
7. Final exams
I. The final exam-system should be centralized.
II. The final exams should contain multiple tests, spread out over the last year of secondary
school.
III. A National Centre for Evaluation of Education should be established. This commission
should be responsible for the construction and grading of the final exams.
IV. Every student should take final exams in at least seven subjects. Three of them will be the
mother tongue, English and maths. Students can choose the other four themselves.
8. Secondary to higher
I. Universities should offer info-days and the possibility for students to drop-in and follow a
lecture.
II. Preparation done by school should already start during the first year of secondary
education.
III. Students should follow lessons ‘career counseling’ and should be helped by a career
counselor to find a study in accordance with their interests.
34
36. ADDITIONAL CHAPTERS
Additional chapters
Post mortem
First of all we would like to note that this project was a challenge. It required a lot of hard work,
research and writing. We do believe this helped to create a well-rounded paper, which is both
informative and constructive.
We started this project with high hopes and with confidence in our abilities. It seemed to us that
we had the opportunity to produce a survey exactly how we thought a survey is supposed to be:
without any rules or regulations on the context. We would employ our potential to the fullest
degree and we would see where this would lead us. Because we worked enthusiastically on a
broad range of subjects, we eventually focused naturally on a few, which we see as more
important. This resulted in not as much elaboration in every chapter, but seeing that we wanted a
multilayered perspective of all the different types of education models, this is not a great loss.
In our opinion our analyses have the greatest value, written as objectively as possible, and have a
practical value as well. Our foreign correspondents all shared our enthusiasm and are very keen to
see the results.
What is so interesting about this project is the way it opened our eyes to the differences in
educational systems. We could not help but wonder how you would feel if you, for example, were
a Danish student and you had to go home and make a written exam in twenty-four hours! How
every country deals with similar problems on its own way is something that could be a topic for
several other studies, but also lingered in our minds while making this one.
Studying all these different solutions inspired us to make our own solutions, partly by fusing
features of different models together, partly by using our own opinions and experience. The survey
provided us with an overview of all the features, opinions and strengths and weaknesses. This way
we were able to pair advantageous components with one another. This was the basis for our
entire research.
Due to the many unique features residing in each national system, this has become quite a large
paper. This was something that could not be avoided: we needed a lot of room to cover all the
facts.
We did not encounter many problems during the process of making this paper, but sometimes
our correspondents did not give a sufficient answer. We completed their answers with information
found on the Internet, or we did not include them in our analyses.
In some cases (like our new structure of primary and secondary education) it was necessary to
involve teaching methods in our research, but we want to stress that our focus has always been on
the structure of education.
In retrospective we are positive about our achievements. The hard work paid off in a research
giving the results we wanted.
A fact that makes our paper special is that apart from the mark we receive, we believe it mainly
has a practical value. We hope that we can interest educators throughout Europe, an maybe even
can make a difference with this survey.
Patrick & Mara
35
37. ADDITIONAL CHAPTERS
Bibliography
Our research is largely based on the results of our survey. We regard this as our most important
source. We have included it as an appendix. The answers given by our foreign correspondents
were thoroughly satisfying, but in some cases we did use some additional information from the
Internet.
1. Bildungssystem Österreich (without date). Consulted on multiple dates between 16-sep-2009
and 25-jan-2010, http://www.bildungssystem.at/
2. Education, Audiovisual & Culture Executive Agency (2009). National summary sheets on
education system in Europe and ongoing reforms. Consulted on multiple dates between 16-
sep-2009 and 25-jan-2010, http://eacea.ec.europa.eu/ressources/eurydice/pdf/047DN/
047_DE_EN.pdf
3. Euroeducation (1995-2010; constantly updated). The European Education Directory. Consulted
on multiple dates between 01-jan-2009 and 25-jan-2010, http://www.euroeducation.net.
4. Netherlands organization for international cooperation in higher education (without date).
Nuffic Glossary. Consulted on multiple dates between 16-sep-2009 and 25-jan-2010, http://
nufficglossary.nuffic.nl.
5. Økonomisk Institut og Center for Anvendt Datalogi (without date). 24 hours take-home exam
for the B.Sc. in Economics 2009-I. Consulted on 1th of November 2009, http://www.ibt2.dk/
Eksamensopgaver/V09/second.words.pdf.
6. Organising Bureau of European School Student Unions (without date). Educational CountryFile.
Consulted on muliple dates between 01-jan-2009 and 25-jan-2010, http://www.edufile.info.
7. Slovenian National Examinations Centre (without date). Consulted on 27th of October 2009,
http://www.ric.si/ric_eng/.
8. SSIS toscana (February 2007). The Icelandic educational system. Consulted on the 4th of
November 2009, http://ssis.adm.unipi.it/user/toscana/
Feb2007The_Icelandic_educational_system.doc.
9. The Finnish Matriculation Examination (without date). The Finnish Matriculation Examination.
Consulted on 27th of October 2009, http://www.ylioppilastutkinto.fi/en/.
10.The Finnish Matriculation Examination (without date). Statistics from the Finnish Matriculation
Examination Board 2007. Consulted on 27th of October 2009, http://www.ylioppilastutkinto.fi/
Tilastoja/Matriculation_07_web.pdf.
11.University of Minnesota Morris (without date). Grade Conversion Scales. Consulted on 1th of
November 2009, http://www.morris.umn.edu/academic/french/Grade%20Conversion
%20Scales.pdf.
36