SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 22
Download to read offline
+




CALLING A SPADE A SPADE
New Zealand Public’s Attitudes to Natural Resources 2012


Straterra Mining Club October 2012
+
                         Background

       There have been eight Public Attitude Energy Surveys
        since 2004
+
                  Research Design

     1000   interviews Feb/ March, 2012
       Some questions as per the previous
        measures to monitor changes over time
     CATI    (computer assisted telephone
        interviewing) with a random sample of the
        NZ population 18+ years; up to 6 calls to
        reach a person
+ SAMPLE PROFILE

       Other North Island Urban 20%                            Auckland 33%

       Gisbourne 7
       Hamilton 46
       HBC 10
       Hawkes Bay 27                                                           Other North Island Towns 14%
       New Plymouth 13
       Palmerston North 21                                                     Gisbourne NMU 2
       Rotorua 11                                                              Hamilton NMU 36
       Tauranga 31                                                             Hawkes Bay NMU 8
       Te Awamutu 4                                                            New Plymouth NMU 11
       Wanganui 10                                                             Palmerston North NMU 19
       Whangarei 15                                                            Rototura NMU 10
                                                                               Tauranga NMU 16
                                                                               Wanganui NMU 6
                                                                               Whangarei NMU 20
                                                            Wellington 10%     Kapiti 9


   Other South Island Urban 6%

                                                  Christchurch 14%
   Dunedin 29
   Invercargill 11
   Nelson 16
                                      Other South Island Towns 5%

                                      Dunedin NMU 20
                                                                              NMU = Non Main Urban
                                      Invercargill NMU 11
                                      Nelson NMU 18
+
    Sample Profile
    The sample is exactly proportionate to the New Zealand population by region,
    gender and age.

    Region:

           56% live in the three main cities of Auckland (33%),
            Christchurch (14%) and Wellington (10%).
           25% live in other main urban areas, 19% North Island and 6%
            South Island.
           19% live in towns and rural areas, 14% North Island and 5%
            South Island.
           In total, 76% live in the North Island and 24% live in the South
            Island.

    Gender

           51% are female and 49% are male.
+
Coal & Natural
Resources
+
                        General Attitudes
                           Concern for NZ's Standard of Living
              60
                                   53
              50

              40
 Percentage




              30      24
                                                     19
              20

              10
                                                                        3                  1
              0
                     Very         Quite           Quite       Very     Don't Know
                   Concerned    Concerned      Unconcerned Unconcerned
                                              Level of Concern


Q1:How concerned or unconcerned are you about New Zealand’s standard of living over the next 5-10 years?
+
                         Development of Natural Resources for Prosperity
                  50

                  45                       43

                  40         38

                  35

                  30
     Percentage




                  25

                  20

                  15
                                                            11
                  10
                                                                               6
                   5                                                                        2
                   0
                       Very Important     Quite           Quite              Very       Don't know
                                        Important      Unimportant        Unimportant
                                                    Level of Importance

    Q2:How important or unimportant do you think the development of New Zealand’s natural resources is in
    improving New Zealand’s economic prosperity and standards of living? Natural resources include oil, gas,
    coal,gold and iron sands.
+
                                                       Coal in New Zealand
             120



             100            6                                             2                      5
                                                   6
                                                                         10
                           20                     12                      6                     18
              80                                   2
                                                   7                     15                      7
                            8
Percentage




              60                                                                                                Don't know
                                                                                                28
                           25                                                                                   Have no opinion
                                                  54                     45                                     Disagree Strongly
              40                                                                                                Disagree
                                                                                                                Agree
                           35                                                                   35
              20                                                                                                Agree Strongly
                                                                         22
                                                  18

                            7                                                                    8
               0
                   Coal mining in NZ is NZ has large resources We should be making       Using NZ coal can
                     undertaken in       of coal that could be greater use of our coal improve everyone's
                    environmentally        used to produce           resources        standard of living here
                    responsible way     energy and make steel
                                          and other products
                                                       Coal Statements



Q6:I now have a number of statements that I am going to read to you and I would like you to tell me whether you
agree or disagree with each statement.
+
                       "We should be making greater use of our Coal
                                       resources"
                 120




                 100                                   3       2
                        5            4
                                                       12     10
                        9           13
                                                               6
                                                       7
                 80    13            9
                                                       12     15
                                    11                                Don't know
    Percentage




                       15
                                                                      Have no opinion
                 60
                                                                      Disagree strongly
                                                       28
                                                                      Disagree
                                    30
                       26                                     45      Agree
                 40
                                                                      Agree strongly
                                                       39
                       32           33

                 20
                                                              22



                  0
                       2009         2010              2011    2012
                                             Year




Q6-3:We should be making greater use of our coal resources.
+
                              "Coal mining in NZ is undertaken in an
                                environmentally responsible way"
                 120



                 100
                                                      10                6
                                       11
                       21
                                                                        20
                 80                                   23
                                       26
                                                                        8              Don't know
    Percentage




                       22
                                                      9                                Have no opinion
                 60                    5
                                                                                       Disagree strongly
                        4              10             13                25
                                                                                       Disagree
                        9
                                                                                       Agree
                 40
                                                                                       Agree strongly
                                       30             30
                       26
                                                                        35
                 20
                       17              18             16

                                                                        7
                  0
                       2009           2010           2011              2012
                                             Year



Q6-1:Coal mining in New Zealand is undertaken in an environmentally responsible way.
+
                        "NZ has large resources of coal that could be used to
                        produce energy and make steel and other products"
                  120




                  100
                                       11             11                6
                          21
                                                                        12
                  80                                  18                2
                                       24                               7
                          16                                                         Don't know
                                                      5
     Percentage




                                       5                                             Have no opinion
                  60      7                           9
                                       9                                             Disagree strongly
                          9                                                          Disagree
                                                      27                54           Agree
                  40
                                       26                                            Agree strongly
                          23

                                                      30
                  20      24           25
                                                                        18


                   0
                         2009         2010           2011              2012
                                             Year



    Q6-2:New Zealand has large resources of coal that could be used to produce energy and make steel and other
    products.
+
                          Knowledge of Coal
                                   Awareness of Coal Mining Locations
                 60


                                                       50
                 50



                 40
    Percentage




                              31
                 30                            28



                 20
                                                                                       16
                                         12                                       11
                 10
                          3                                      2    3       3
                      1            1                                      1
                 0




                                               Coal Mining Location



Q5a:Where is coal mined in New Zealand?
+

                             Awareness of NZ Coal Exports
                  70

                       62
                  60



                  50



                  40
     Percentage




                                                                29
                  30



                  20


                                                    9
                  10



                  0
                       Yes                         No        Don't Know
                                                 Awareness



    Q5c:Does New Zealand export Coal overseas?
+
                    Attitudes to Natural Resources

                                    NZ Highest Per Capita Natural Resources
              30

                                                      26
                                                                         25
              25
                                        22

              20
                                                                                                         17
 Percentage




              15



              10

                                                                                         6
                         5
              5



              0
                   Agree Strongly      Agree    Have no opinion        Disagree   Disagree Strongly   Don't Know
                                                        Level of Agreement




Q6-4:New Zealand has the highest per capita natural resources in the world.
+
                                    Development of NZ's Coal & Natural Resources
                                             Overall        18               41                       16        6         16     4

                             Environment is protected                  36                   43                      10 4 6 1

                    Environment returned to as it was                  36                  38                   13        5 7 2

                  No increase in greenhouse emissions             27                  44                    11       4     12    3

                           Local people are employed                        41                   43                       8 2 61            Agree Strongly
     Conditions




                                                                                                                                            Agree
                              Done by NZ companies                     35                  43                       9 2 10 1
                                                                                                                                            Disagree

                                  Lower diesel prices             28                  42                    13       4      12 1            Disagree Strongly
                                                                                                                                            Have no opinion
                                Communities Benefit          21                  43                        18        3     13 1             Don't Know

                                 Boosts NZ economy                      39                      44                       10 3 5

                          Standard of living Improves                  37                       45                       10 2 5 1

                                  Money Stays in NZ                          45                  37                      9 2 7

                                                        0        20          40            60                   80              100   120
                                                                                       Percentage


Q7:How much do you agree or disagree with the development of New Zealand’s coal and other natural resources
such as oil, gas, gold and iron sands (if following statements apply)?
+


LIGNITE
+
    Awareness of Uses

                                      Awareness of Lignite Uses
                  70

                                                                         62                62
                            60
                  60


                                             50
                  50



                  40
     Percentage




                                      34                                                              Yes
                       29                                                                             No
                  30
                                                                                                      Don't Know
                                                                   22                 23

                  20
                                                      16                       16               15
                                 11
                  10



                  0
                       Home Heating        Industry               Making Fertiliser   Making Diesel
                                                       Lignite Uses



    Q11: Now some questions about lignite. Did you know lignite could be used for…
+                                         Development of Southland's Lignite

        Environment is protected                           29                    43                    7        4         15        3


            Environment returned                                32                40                    7       4         13        4


       No increase in greenhouse                       27                   41                    7     4             18            4


          Local people employed                                 32                    46                        6 3           11    2


          Done by NZ companies                              30                    45                        7 2            13       2      Agree Strongly
                                                                                                                                           Agree
              Lower diesel prices                      26                    43                        10       3          15       2      Disagree Strongly
                                                                                                                                           Disagree
           Lower priced fertiliser                    24                    44                     10       3             17        2      Have no opinion
                                                                                                                                           Don't know

            Communities benefit                  20                    46                        12         4            17         3


         If it boosts NZ economy                                33                     47                           6 3        10   2


If NZ standard of living improves                           31                        47                        7    3        11    2


    If most the money stays in NZ                                34                    43                       6 2           12    2

                                     0%    10%    20%           30%   40%    50%           60%   70%        80%          90%        100%



Q14: How much do you agree or disagree with the development of Southland’s Lignite?
+


QUESTIONS?

CALLING A SPADE A SPADE
New Zealand Public’s Attitudes to Natural Resources 2012


Straterra Mining Club October 2012
Pauline colmar 1000 n zers attitudes to natural resources   presentation mining event 111012

More Related Content

More from Manu Caddie

It's Election Year - So What?!
It's Election Year - So What?! It's Election Year - So What?!
It's Election Year - So What?! Manu Caddie
 
Portlandia Cycling
Portlandia CyclingPortlandia Cycling
Portlandia CyclingManu Caddie
 
Green jobs for tairāwhiti
Green jobs for tairāwhitiGreen jobs for tairāwhiti
Green jobs for tairāwhitiManu Caddie
 
Participatory Budgeting & Public Finance Planning in New Zealand
Participatory Budgeting & Public Finance Planning in New ZealandParticipatory Budgeting & Public Finance Planning in New Zealand
Participatory Budgeting & Public Finance Planning in New ZealandManu Caddie
 
Rod Oram - Sustainable Dunedin March 2013
Rod Oram - Sustainable Dunedin March 2013Rod Oram - Sustainable Dunedin March 2013
Rod Oram - Sustainable Dunedin March 2013Manu Caddie
 
RMA Changes Workshop
RMA Changes Workshop RMA Changes Workshop
RMA Changes Workshop Manu Caddie
 
Climate Campaigning
Climate Campaigning Climate Campaigning
Climate Campaigning Manu Caddie
 
Lessons from Think Big
Lessons from Think BigLessons from Think Big
Lessons from Think BigManu Caddie
 
7 Lessons to my 20 year old self.
7 Lessons to my 20 year old self.7 Lessons to my 20 year old self.
7 Lessons to my 20 year old self.Manu Caddie
 
8 reasons to lock the gate
8 reasons to lock the gate8 reasons to lock the gate
8 reasons to lock the gateManu Caddie
 
Parihaka presentation
Parihaka presentationParihaka presentation
Parihaka presentationManu Caddie
 
Fracking: A Sensible Response to Peak Conventional Oil? Paul Bruce
Fracking: A Sensible Response to Peak Conventional Oil? Paul BruceFracking: A Sensible Response to Peak Conventional Oil? Paul Bruce
Fracking: A Sensible Response to Peak Conventional Oil? Paul BruceManu Caddie
 
Anarchists I've Known (of) & Loved
Anarchists I've Known (of) & LovedAnarchists I've Known (of) & Loved
Anarchists I've Known (of) & LovedManu Caddie
 
Mining Presentation for Ngāti Porou
Mining Presentation for Ngāti PorouMining Presentation for Ngāti Porou
Mining Presentation for Ngāti PorouManu Caddie
 
Extractive Industries on the East Coast: Green Drinks Rotorua, April 2012
Extractive Industries on the East Coast: Green Drinks Rotorua, April 2012Extractive Industries on the East Coast: Green Drinks Rotorua, April 2012
Extractive Industries on the East Coast: Green Drinks Rotorua, April 2012Manu Caddie
 
Hei Tikitiki: Traditional Rites of Passage for Young Māori
Hei Tikitiki: Traditional Rites of Passage for Young MāoriHei Tikitiki: Traditional Rites of Passage for Young Māori
Hei Tikitiki: Traditional Rites of Passage for Young MāoriManu Caddie
 
Who killed the electric car?
Who killed the electric car?Who killed the electric car?
Who killed the electric car?Manu Caddie
 
East Coast Fracking Presentation
East Coast Fracking PresentationEast Coast Fracking Presentation
East Coast Fracking PresentationManu Caddie
 
Petrobras presentation
Petrobras presentationPetrobras presentation
Petrobras presentationManu Caddie
 

More from Manu Caddie (20)

It's Election Year - So What?!
It's Election Year - So What?! It's Election Year - So What?!
It's Election Year - So What?!
 
Portlandia Cycling
Portlandia CyclingPortlandia Cycling
Portlandia Cycling
 
Green jobs for tairāwhiti
Green jobs for tairāwhitiGreen jobs for tairāwhiti
Green jobs for tairāwhiti
 
Participatory Budgeting & Public Finance Planning in New Zealand
Participatory Budgeting & Public Finance Planning in New ZealandParticipatory Budgeting & Public Finance Planning in New Zealand
Participatory Budgeting & Public Finance Planning in New Zealand
 
Rod Oram - Sustainable Dunedin March 2013
Rod Oram - Sustainable Dunedin March 2013Rod Oram - Sustainable Dunedin March 2013
Rod Oram - Sustainable Dunedin March 2013
 
RMA Changes Workshop
RMA Changes Workshop RMA Changes Workshop
RMA Changes Workshop
 
Climate Campaigning
Climate Campaigning Climate Campaigning
Climate Campaigning
 
Lessons from Think Big
Lessons from Think BigLessons from Think Big
Lessons from Think Big
 
7 Lessons to my 20 year old self.
7 Lessons to my 20 year old self.7 Lessons to my 20 year old self.
7 Lessons to my 20 year old self.
 
8 reasons to lock the gate
8 reasons to lock the gate8 reasons to lock the gate
8 reasons to lock the gate
 
Parihaka presentation
Parihaka presentationParihaka presentation
Parihaka presentation
 
Fracking: A Sensible Response to Peak Conventional Oil? Paul Bruce
Fracking: A Sensible Response to Peak Conventional Oil? Paul BruceFracking: A Sensible Response to Peak Conventional Oil? Paul Bruce
Fracking: A Sensible Response to Peak Conventional Oil? Paul Bruce
 
Anarchists I've Known (of) & Loved
Anarchists I've Known (of) & LovedAnarchists I've Known (of) & Loved
Anarchists I've Known (of) & Loved
 
Mining Presentation for Ngāti Porou
Mining Presentation for Ngāti PorouMining Presentation for Ngāti Porou
Mining Presentation for Ngāti Porou
 
Extractive Industries on the East Coast: Green Drinks Rotorua, April 2012
Extractive Industries on the East Coast: Green Drinks Rotorua, April 2012Extractive Industries on the East Coast: Green Drinks Rotorua, April 2012
Extractive Industries on the East Coast: Green Drinks Rotorua, April 2012
 
Hei Tikitiki: Traditional Rites of Passage for Young Māori
Hei Tikitiki: Traditional Rites of Passage for Young MāoriHei Tikitiki: Traditional Rites of Passage for Young Māori
Hei Tikitiki: Traditional Rites of Passage for Young Māori
 
Who killed the electric car?
Who killed the electric car?Who killed the electric car?
Who killed the electric car?
 
East Coast Fracking Presentation
East Coast Fracking PresentationEast Coast Fracking Presentation
East Coast Fracking Presentation
 
Petrobras presentation
Petrobras presentationPetrobras presentation
Petrobras presentation
 
Faith+activism
Faith+activismFaith+activism
Faith+activism
 

Pauline colmar 1000 n zers attitudes to natural resources presentation mining event 111012

  • 1.
  • 2. + CALLING A SPADE A SPADE New Zealand Public’s Attitudes to Natural Resources 2012 Straterra Mining Club October 2012
  • 3. + Background  There have been eight Public Attitude Energy Surveys since 2004
  • 4. + Research Design  1000 interviews Feb/ March, 2012  Some questions as per the previous measures to monitor changes over time  CATI (computer assisted telephone interviewing) with a random sample of the NZ population 18+ years; up to 6 calls to reach a person
  • 5. + SAMPLE PROFILE Other North Island Urban 20% Auckland 33% Gisbourne 7 Hamilton 46 HBC 10 Hawkes Bay 27 Other North Island Towns 14% New Plymouth 13 Palmerston North 21 Gisbourne NMU 2 Rotorua 11 Hamilton NMU 36 Tauranga 31 Hawkes Bay NMU 8 Te Awamutu 4 New Plymouth NMU 11 Wanganui 10 Palmerston North NMU 19 Whangarei 15 Rototura NMU 10 Tauranga NMU 16 Wanganui NMU 6 Whangarei NMU 20 Wellington 10% Kapiti 9 Other South Island Urban 6% Christchurch 14% Dunedin 29 Invercargill 11 Nelson 16 Other South Island Towns 5% Dunedin NMU 20 NMU = Non Main Urban Invercargill NMU 11 Nelson NMU 18
  • 6. + Sample Profile The sample is exactly proportionate to the New Zealand population by region, gender and age. Region:  56% live in the three main cities of Auckland (33%), Christchurch (14%) and Wellington (10%).  25% live in other main urban areas, 19% North Island and 6% South Island.  19% live in towns and rural areas, 14% North Island and 5% South Island.  In total, 76% live in the North Island and 24% live in the South Island. Gender  51% are female and 49% are male.
  • 8. + General Attitudes Concern for NZ's Standard of Living 60 53 50 40 Percentage 30 24 19 20 10 3 1 0 Very Quite Quite Very Don't Know Concerned Concerned Unconcerned Unconcerned Level of Concern Q1:How concerned or unconcerned are you about New Zealand’s standard of living over the next 5-10 years?
  • 9. + Development of Natural Resources for Prosperity 50 45 43 40 38 35 30 Percentage 25 20 15 11 10 6 5 2 0 Very Important Quite Quite Very Don't know Important Unimportant Unimportant Level of Importance Q2:How important or unimportant do you think the development of New Zealand’s natural resources is in improving New Zealand’s economic prosperity and standards of living? Natural resources include oil, gas, coal,gold and iron sands.
  • 10. + Coal in New Zealand 120 100 6 2 5 6 10 20 12 6 18 80 2 7 15 7 8 Percentage 60 Don't know 28 25 Have no opinion 54 45 Disagree Strongly 40 Disagree Agree 35 35 20 Agree Strongly 22 18 7 8 0 Coal mining in NZ is NZ has large resources We should be making Using NZ coal can undertaken in of coal that could be greater use of our coal improve everyone's environmentally used to produce resources standard of living here responsible way energy and make steel and other products Coal Statements Q6:I now have a number of statements that I am going to read to you and I would like you to tell me whether you agree or disagree with each statement.
  • 11. + "We should be making greater use of our Coal resources" 120 100 3 2 5 4 12 10 9 13 6 7 80 13 9 12 15 11 Don't know Percentage 15 Have no opinion 60 Disagree strongly 28 Disagree 30 26 45 Agree 40 Agree strongly 39 32 33 20 22 0 2009 2010 2011 2012 Year Q6-3:We should be making greater use of our coal resources.
  • 12. + "Coal mining in NZ is undertaken in an environmentally responsible way" 120 100 10 6 11 21 20 80 23 26 8 Don't know Percentage 22 9 Have no opinion 60 5 Disagree strongly 4 10 13 25 Disagree 9 Agree 40 Agree strongly 30 30 26 35 20 17 18 16 7 0 2009 2010 2011 2012 Year Q6-1:Coal mining in New Zealand is undertaken in an environmentally responsible way.
  • 13. + "NZ has large resources of coal that could be used to produce energy and make steel and other products" 120 100 11 11 6 21 12 80 18 2 24 7 16 Don't know 5 Percentage 5 Have no opinion 60 7 9 9 Disagree strongly 9 Disagree 27 54 Agree 40 26 Agree strongly 23 30 20 24 25 18 0 2009 2010 2011 2012 Year Q6-2:New Zealand has large resources of coal that could be used to produce energy and make steel and other products.
  • 14. + Knowledge of Coal Awareness of Coal Mining Locations 60 50 50 40 Percentage 31 30 28 20 16 12 11 10 3 2 3 3 1 1 1 0 Coal Mining Location Q5a:Where is coal mined in New Zealand?
  • 15. + Awareness of NZ Coal Exports 70 62 60 50 40 Percentage 29 30 20 9 10 0 Yes No Don't Know Awareness Q5c:Does New Zealand export Coal overseas?
  • 16. + Attitudes to Natural Resources NZ Highest Per Capita Natural Resources 30 26 25 25 22 20 17 Percentage 15 10 6 5 5 0 Agree Strongly Agree Have no opinion Disagree Disagree Strongly Don't Know Level of Agreement Q6-4:New Zealand has the highest per capita natural resources in the world.
  • 17. + Development of NZ's Coal & Natural Resources Overall 18 41 16 6 16 4 Environment is protected 36 43 10 4 6 1 Environment returned to as it was 36 38 13 5 7 2 No increase in greenhouse emissions 27 44 11 4 12 3 Local people are employed 41 43 8 2 61 Agree Strongly Conditions Agree Done by NZ companies 35 43 9 2 10 1 Disagree Lower diesel prices 28 42 13 4 12 1 Disagree Strongly Have no opinion Communities Benefit 21 43 18 3 13 1 Don't Know Boosts NZ economy 39 44 10 3 5 Standard of living Improves 37 45 10 2 5 1 Money Stays in NZ 45 37 9 2 7 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 Percentage Q7:How much do you agree or disagree with the development of New Zealand’s coal and other natural resources such as oil, gas, gold and iron sands (if following statements apply)?
  • 19. + Awareness of Uses Awareness of Lignite Uses 70 62 62 60 60 50 50 40 Percentage 34 Yes 29 No 30 Don't Know 22 23 20 16 16 15 11 10 0 Home Heating Industry Making Fertiliser Making Diesel Lignite Uses Q11: Now some questions about lignite. Did you know lignite could be used for…
  • 20. + Development of Southland's Lignite Environment is protected 29 43 7 4 15 3 Environment returned 32 40 7 4 13 4 No increase in greenhouse 27 41 7 4 18 4 Local people employed 32 46 6 3 11 2 Done by NZ companies 30 45 7 2 13 2 Agree Strongly Agree Lower diesel prices 26 43 10 3 15 2 Disagree Strongly Disagree Lower priced fertiliser 24 44 10 3 17 2 Have no opinion Don't know Communities benefit 20 46 12 4 17 3 If it boosts NZ economy 33 47 6 3 10 2 If NZ standard of living improves 31 47 7 3 11 2 If most the money stays in NZ 34 43 6 2 12 2 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Q14: How much do you agree or disagree with the development of Southland’s Lignite?
  • 21. + QUESTIONS? CALLING A SPADE A SPADE New Zealand Public’s Attitudes to Natural Resources 2012 Straterra Mining Club October 2012