This document summarizes a presentation given at Vanderbilt University on GIS Day about developing a world-historical gazetteer. The presentation discusses the need for a comprehensive gazetteer that can reconcile places across time periods and languages. It provides examples of existing historical gazetteers and describes the goals of creating a "spine" gazetteer that would integrate data about places, people, events and cultural objects from various projects to enable new search and analysis capabilities for studying world history.
1. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Linking Pasts with
Historical Gazetteers
Karl Grossner, PhD
World History Center,
University of Pittsburgh
2. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Linking Pasts refers to…
Linking historical data developed by, used in,
and published by research projects in many
disciplines
An annual symposium hosted by the Pelagios
project (Linked Pasts III is 4-6 Dec. @ Stanford)
A working group of Pelagios Commons
(Linked Pasts WG)
http://commons.pelagios.org
3. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
www.geohumanities.org
GeoHumanities
4. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
A spatial turn
http://spatial.scholarslab.org/spatial-turn/
by Jo Guldi (SMU;
https://www.joguldi.com/)
5. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
GeoHumanities
What do humanists want?
What do humanists need?
What might humanists get?”
Peter K. Bol (2011)
In Dear, M. et al (Eds.) GeoHumanities: Art,
history, text at the edge of place.
a. Maps and some spatial
analysis
b. A world-historical gazetteer
c. ??
“
www.geohumanities.org
6. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Geo-parsing, geo-tagging
http://recogito.pelagios.org/help/tutoria
If research questions are spatial,
sources (texts, maps, tabular
data) must be
geo-parsed: extract place
references (names, usually)
or
geo-tagged
geo-coded: identify a
suitable location
7. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Why a world-historical
gazetteer?
• Time matters. Places typically have multiple
names, which change over time
• Places themselves come and go
• Many areas of the world are underserved
• Modern gazetteers are
problematic
• lack useful temporal information
• don’t offer useful reconciliation
services
8. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Where is Poland?
9. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
What’s a gazetteer?
a geographic information system
10. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
11. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Gazetteers…
have been defined variously as
geographical indexes or dictionaries (OED)
specialized indexes of place names, minimally (Name, Type,
Location)
have been in existence since Strabo’s Geographica
(b. ~63 BCE; d. ~24 CE)
1999 - 2004: First global digital gazetteer developed
as part of Alexandria Digital Library @ UC Santa
Barbara
By 2017, a profusion of digital gazetteers and a
rapidly growing number of digital historical gazetteers
12. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
http://www.geonames.org/4644585/
13. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
14. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
15. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
More modern digital
gazetteers
• Google Maps, etc
• Navigating modern roads,
• Locating points of interest
• MapZen Places
• Modern places
• New competitor to GeoNames,
better curated
• Getty Thesaurus of
Geographic Names (TGN)
• Few coordinates, locations in
hierarchy
16. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
More modern digital
gazetteers
• Google Maps, etc
• Navigating modern roads,
• Locating points of interest
• MapZen Places
• Modern places
• New competitor to GeoNames,
better curated
• Getty Thesaurus of
Geographic Names (TGN)
• Few coordinates, locations in
hierarchy
17. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Descriptive Gazetteers
Ancient, Medieval, Modern Cases
cf. Mostern & Southall (2016) Gazetteers Past. In Placing Names: Enriching and
Integrating Gazetteers
18. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
19. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
20. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Strabo
Geographica
(20 BC – 23 AD)
pictured, title page from
1620 edition
geography:
description of the land
chorography:
description of “political
21. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
22. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
http://www.perseus.tufts.edu
23. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of
_Europe_according_to_Strabo.jpg
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:C
%2BB-Geography-Map1-StrabosMap.PNG
24. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Representation on a modern map of Iberia according to Strabo
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Iberia-Strabon-
es.png
25. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Chinese local
gazetteers/histories
26. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Chinese local
gazetteers/histories
• Song Dynasty (960-1279), 地方志 (“difangzhi”)
local histories studied by
• Will, Pierre-Étienne (1992)
• Hargett, James (1996)
• Bol, Peter (2001)
• Mostern, Ruth M. (2011)
• Will: “…as early as the Sui and Tang” (6-10 c.);
proto-gazetteers in 4c
• (“tujing”), “maps with explanation”
27. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Chinese local
gazetteers/histories
• The land (topography, hydrology, toponomy,
products, monuments
• Its inhabitants (population, customs,
prominent families and individuals, literary
works)
• Its government (structure, personnel, finances,
biography)
• Local contemporary and historical accounts of
“the situation”
• These became objects of historical study in 18c.
28. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Great Britain: Itineraries to
Gazetteers
The Itinerary of John Leland in or
about the Years 1535 – 1543
Britannia
William Camden (1551-1623)
A tour thro' the whole island
of Great Britain
Daniel Defoe (1660-1731)
Villare Cantianum (1659)
Imperial Gazetteer of
England and Wales (1870-1872)
Gazetteer of the World (1856)
29. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Gazetteer of the World, or
Dictionary of Geographic Knowledge (1859)
30. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Lippincott’s Gazetteer of the World (1856)
31. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Historical Gazetteers
Everything (?) old is new again
32. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
http://www.visionofbritain.org.uk/
33. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
34. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
35. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
36. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
http://pleiades.stoa.org/
“a community-built gazetteer
and graph of ancient places”
37. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
38. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
• Title
• Description
• URI
• Representative point
• Location(s)
• Names
• Makes connection
with
• Has connection with
• Place type
• References
• Evidence
• See Further
• See Also
39. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Bol’s desiderata
A world-historical gazetteer
40. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Bol’s world-historical gazetteer
• It must accommodate multiple indicators of
temporality, including (i) start and end “valid”
dates; (ii) date of source in which it is mentioned
• It must be multilingual, for both place names and
feature types
• It should incorporate gazetteer data from multiple
historical projects (local and national)... also
volunteered information
• It must be “...open-ended and cumulative;” i.e.
extensible; able to grow in a completely flexible
manner
• It must be built with a viable strategy for long-term
sustainability
41. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Meeting Bol’s requirements +
Extensibility
Multivocality
Integration
Sustainability
• Represent indeterminate, uncertain temporal
and spatial values
• Model space and time (place and period)
together
Grossner, Janowicz & Keßler. (2016).
Place, Period, and Setting for Linked Data
Gazetteers.
In Berman, M.L., Mostern, R. and Southall, H.
(Eds.)
Placing Names: Enriching and Integrating
Gazetteers.
42. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
A plethora
Long-standing
Pleiades
“a community-built gazetteer and
graph of ancient places”
Great Britain Historical GIS
“information about Britain's localities
as they have changed over time
A Vision of Britain Through Time
“maps, statistical trends and historical
descriptions; 1801 - present
Trismegistos (places, people, texts)
”…papyrological and epigraphical
resources; principally Egypt and the
Nile valley (800 BC-AD 800)”
Map of Early Modern London
"a standard for placenames ca. 1550-
1650."
Emerging
al-Ṯurayyā: ”a geospatial model
of the early Islamic world"
Kima: “open digital historical
Hebrew gazetteer
Pelagios Commons al Sur
“the early period of the Conquest
of South America (16-17 c.)
Early Modern Europe
The Dutch colonial world
Syriaca.org
Slave Societies Digital Archive
“Africans in the Atlantic World;
16th to the 20th centuries”
Vanderbilt University
43. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
a virtuous circle
Linked Open Data in humanities research
44. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
People
Cultural
Objects Places
sources
data
products
45. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
People
Cultural
Objects P l a c e s
Name ID Lat Long
Nashville P1234 36.1
6
86.78
Memphis P1235 35.1
4
90.04
…
Name ID BirthYear BirthLoc
Duane Allman A9876 1947 P1234
Memphis Slim A9877 1915 P1235
46. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
G a z e t t e e r ( N a m e A u t h o r i t y )
People
Cultural
Objects P l a c e s
Name ID Lat Long
Nashville P1234 36.1
6
86.78
Memphis P1235 35.1
4
90.04
…
Name ID BirthYear BirthLoc
Duane Allman A9876 1947 P1234
Memphis Slim A9877 1915 P1235
Name ID Lat Long Type
Nashville, IN GN63457 39.2 86.25 USA Town
Nashville, TN GN39586 36.16 86.78 USA City
Memphis GN49203 29.84 -31.25 Egypt Ruin
Memphis, TN GN5829 35.14 90.04 USA City
47. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
http://www.geonames.org/4644585/
48. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
G a z e t t e e r ( N a m e A u t h o r i t y )
People
Cultural
Objects P l a c e s
Name ID Lat Long ExactMatch
Nashville P1234 36.1
6
86.78 gn:4644585
Memphis P1235 35.1
4
90.04 gn:58293
…
Name ID BirthYear BirthLoc
Duane Allman A9876 1947 P1234
Memphis Slim A9877 1915 P1235
Name ID Lat Long Type
Nashville, IN 63457 39.2 86.25 USA Town
Nashville, TN 4644585 36.16 86.78 USA City
Memphis 49203 29.84 -31.25 Egypt Ruin
Memphis, TN 58293 35.14 90.04 USA City
I n t e r c o n n e c t i o n
F o r m a t
( R D F , ? ? )
LOD Cloud
49. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Linked Pasts vision
search, browse, visualize
Ap p s + AP Is
Periods
People
Places
Events
Cultural
Objects
“union index”
50. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Linked Data
"a recommended best practice for exposing,
sharing, and connecting pieces of data,
information, and knowledge on the Semantic
Web using URIs and RDF."
links data, not documents
URL + protocol (e.g. http://)
use them to name resources
Resource Description Framework
(XML-like format of Subj-Pred-Obj triples)
Semantic Web
URI
RDF
-- Tim Berners-
Lee
51. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
52. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Ruth Mostern (WHC Director)
Principal Investigator
Karl Grossner
Technical Director
Ryan Horne
WHC post-doctoral fellow
Patrick Manning (WHC Founder)
Project consultant
NEH-funded project at the
University of Pittsburgh’s
World History Center
(2017-2019)
53. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Enhanced gazetteers
For places, agents, cultural objects
54. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
a Linked Pasts vision
search, browse, visualize
Ap p s + AP Is
Cultural
Objects
People
Places
Periods
Events
“union index”
55. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Pelagios
search, browse, visualize
Ap p s + AP Is
Cultural
Objects
People
Places
“union index”
56. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Peripleo
57. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
World-Historical
Gazetteer
58. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
World-Historical Gazetteer
Ap p s + AP Is
WHG
Global “Spine”
Gazetteer
Cultural
Objects
People
Places
Events
“union index”
search, browse, visualize
59. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
World-Historical Gazetteer
• Focus on centuries after 1500
• Broader range of place types in “spine,”
including
• Peoples (ethnonyms) and associated languages
• Cultural and physical geographic regions
• Historical routes and itineraries
• Mountain ranges, watersheds
• Ocean currents
• Bibliographic links
• “Topical signatures” for places derived from
texts
WHG
Global “Spine”
Gazetteer
60. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Data for the “spine”
61. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
W-H Gazetteer Spine Record
Name
Locations
ID
URI
Relations (within, part-of)
Snippets (abstract)
Links (close-, exact-match)
Place
1
1
1..*
0..*
When0..*
0..*
0..*
0..*
Source1
PlaceType1..*
62. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
W-H Gazetteer Union Index
ID
URI
Place
1
1
ConflationOf1..*
Title1
63. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
64. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
65. GIS Day @ Vanderbilt University November 15, 2017
Questions? Comments?
http://whgazetteer.org
http://linkedplaces.org
e: grossner@pitt.edu
t: @kgeographer
Editor's Notes
Explaining the title, part I
I’m a geographer, trained in geographic information science with at least one foot in the humanities
9 essays comprising the best explanation of the “spatial turn” I have encountered
The spatial turn has increasingly manifested in the humanities over the past decade:
- edited volumes, an AAG journal, the ADHO Special Interest Group I co-founded in 2013
In Bol’s chapter in GeoHumanities (2011) book, he argues that WRT to spatial research questions in the humanities, a world-historical gazetteer is critical dh cyberinfrastructure
When a literary scholar, a historian, a philologist, an archaeologist creates data in anticipation of asking spatial questions, they must invariably geo-reference source material: identify place names found in texts, maps, and tabular datasets, establish their identity in an authority, and find or estimate suitable location data.
That’s the job of a gazetteer, but many names in historical sources are not found in modern gazetteers
The simplest form: name, page, page grid
Explaining the title, part I
Identify exact matches in authority gazetteers
Identify exact matches in authority gazetteers
Explaining the title, part I
Explaining the title, part II, a particular gazetteer project