Pecha Kucha format presentation about innovative solutions being deployed by the Caribbean Wastewater Project (Revolving Fund) GEF-IADB/UNEP, by Alfredo Coelloin the 8th GEF Biennial International Waters Conference.
3. CHALLENGE
LACK OF FINANCING IN THE
WASTEWATER SECTOR!
Image courtesy of Stuart Miles at FreeDigitalPhotos.net
4. 20 Millions USD
GEF-CReW Grant for all Components
Establish innovative financing mechanisms
for cost-effective and sustainable financing of
wastewater management in the WCR
Establish innovative financing mechanisms
for cost-effective and sustainable financing of
wastewater management in the WCR
1
5. T &T
T&T Revolving
Fund
T&T Revolving
Fund
Rehab. of Scarborough
WWTP
Rehab. of Scarborough
WWTP
Jamaica
Credit
Enhancement
Facility
Credit
Enhancement
Facility
US$3 millionUS$3 million
Rehabilitation
of 8 existing
WWTP
Rehabilitation
of 8 existing
WWTP
Belize
Belize
Wastewater
Revolving Fund
Belize
Wastewater
Revolving Fund
US$5 millionUS$5 million
WW Works
In BWSL
WW Works
In BWSL
Guyana
Guyana
Wastewater
Revolving Fund
Guyana
Wastewater
Revolving Fund
US$3 millionUS$3 million
Public Private
Partnership
Public Private
Partnership
US$2 million
6. Image courtesy of Twobee at FreeDigitalPhotos.net
Financing is not the main issue
What is Really Happening???
7. • Enabling Environment - Institutional, Policy, Plans,
Legislative, Regulatory, Tariff, Cost Recovery?
• Public and Political Awareness and Commitment ?
• Need for and Type of Investment - business case,
technology selection, decentralized/centralized
etc. ?
8. Improve national and local capacity for wastewater
management through strengthened policy,
institutional & legislative frameworks
Improve national and local capacity for wastewater
management through strengthened policy,
institutional & legislative frameworks
Facilitate regional dialogue and knowledge
exchange with the key stakeholders in the WCR
Facilitate regional dialogue and knowledge
exchange with the key stakeholders in the WCR
2
3
13. LESSONSLEARNT
• Enabling Environment: Policy,
Institutional, Legislative & Regulatory is
critical for all activities
• Start with small scale project
14. LESSONSLEARNT
• Sequential rather than parallel
implementation
• Wastewater on the National Agenda:
Need to Link to IWRM, Global & Regional
Initiatives
17. FROM
CReW
LACK OF FINANCING IN THE WASTEWATER SECTOR
TO
CReW+
IMPROVE THE ENABLING ENVIRONMENT / WIDER RANGE OF FINANCING
OPTIONS / MULTIFOCAL/ INTEGRATED APPROACH&
TREATED WASTEWATER AS A RESOURCE
Hello everyone, very happy to be here with you today.
Numbers don't usually lie!! This is the reality, Aprox 85% of the wastewater produced in the Caribbean reaches the sea untreated.
My name is Alfredo Coello and this is the CReW ·Caribbean Regional Fund for Wastewater Management“
20 sc Ok
13 countries are participating in the project – both Spanish and English Speaking. 4 of them have Pilot projects - Belize Guyana Jamaica and Trinidad & Tobago. Started in July 2011 and will finish in January 2017, including an 18 month no-cost extension period.
20 sc OK
When we started the CReW, the main challenge was the lack of financing for Wastewater management, supported by the general view of those in the sector, as well as decision-makers, that wastewater treatment is expensive and a burden and provides little return.
So, the main and first component of the CReW was designed to tackle this issue, thus to test 4 pilot financing mechanisms. It is implemented by IDB. We are already working with three financing mechanisms and finalizing the structure of the fourth in Trinidad and Tobago. The total amount for the project all components is 20 million, with more than 16 million being dedicated to this component.
And these are the four pilots, Three Revolving funds and one Credit enhancement Facility. The pilot that has captured the most attention is the Jamaica case, mostly due to the application of the so called K-factor to ensure repayment of the loans and sustainability of the financing mechanism.
But before we consider the other project components, let’s take quick look at the issue of financing. CReW has found that lack of financing per se is not the mayor issue, as initially thought. What is Really Happening with Waste Water? The reality is more complicated and involves many questions that need answering.
This are just a few of the questions that come to mind. And most of them should be considered before embarking upon the development of a financing mechanism. CReW’s experience had taught us that the most important question is the first one - Has the country the right policy, legislative and institutional framework to enable the development of a SUSTAINABLE financing mechanism?.
Do I have in place a sound Enabling Environment?
Can I use the money?
Am I aware of available technologies?
How about operation monitoring and maintenance of the facilities?
Do I have a plan to repay the loans. i.e. tariffs?
Do I have a master plan or business plan attached to the investment?
Do I really need to make the investment?
Does the general Public understand the importance of Wastewater Management?
The reality is that each country is in a different state of development in regard to the enabling environment. Components Two and Three are implemented by UNEP and deal with the strengthening of the institutional, policy and legislative frameworks as well as communication, knowledge sharing and documentation of lessons learnt.
Now I will share with you some of the many activities implemented during the project. Here we see the Appropriate Technologies Workshop for the Spanish speaking countries, which was also done for the English speaking countries. It aimed to provide the knowledge not just about new technologies but also how to calculate and design the process involved in the treatment of the wastewater.
This photo is from the workshop on Resource Valuation, planned to help countries to make decisions on wastewater management when there is lack of quantifiable data or information. Three sites were studied in two countries and methodologies and results were shared at this workshop.
In general, all activities were designed to address the questions introduced before and to build capacity in the participating countries.
Wastewater is an issue neglected by the media too! Sensitizing them was important so they can help us get the message to the public. So we held workshops for both Spanish and English-speaking journalists. Here journalists interview someone from Guyana Wastewater Incorporated at a wastewater collection facility in Georgetown.
I really like this slice, it is an artist’s representation drafted live while the group was having the dicussion, of one of the key topics discussed in the Knowledge Sharing session at the Fourth Project Steering Committee Meeting, July 2015 Guatemala : Putting Wastewater on the National Agenda. What helps?
timing OK
Let’s move on now to lessons learnt.
I have already mentioned the most important of them all - the Enabling Environment has to be in place.
Also be patient, start slowly, and don’t try to test with large, complicated projects.
Slides 13- 15 OK - Black and White very effective. Not sure if saying start slow conveys right message. Want to emphasize need for high impact, short term results from activities such as smaller shorter projects that can then be replicated and used to engender public, institutional and political support.
Understand the situation in each country and go step by step, managing adaptively where necessary. And of course it is helpful if there is a national plan that includes linkages to other sectors and is consistent with Global and Regional Initiatives.
15 sc ok
Of real importance though is to start the communication component right from the kick off of the project and develop a communication strategy to support your objectives as early as possible.
Last but not least, the need for champions… No champion… no hope… no game, so do what to have to do to find one.
15 sc Ok
In addition to our national partners – ministeries, agencies etc . Regional partners – public and private sector as well as intergovernmental and non-governmental, have worked with us to do so much more than would otherwise have been possible. Not least the partnership between UNEP and IDB which has been very successful and continues to grow stronger.
18 sc OK
During the implementation of the project much has been done in developing and creating partnerships which in turns allowed us to enhance the goals set at the beginning of the project,
Some of the others are shown in this slice, CDB, the Water Center, Minister of Water in the region and many more
With this last note, I leave you with Mr Corbin who will present to you the CReW+
The CReW team is currently finalizing the draft of a new Project Identification Form for CReW+, a new initiative born from lessons learnt in implementing CReW, and with significant inputs from a wide range of stakeholders.
It will provide a wider range of financing options, give more flexibility, be multifocal, use a more integrated approach, and have interventions at local, community and national levels.
28 sc!!!!!!!!!
It is targeting the SDG´s and promoting an integrated approach the use of wastewater as a resource. The number of countries is expected to increase, based upon expressions of interest so far received. We like to think that this is due to the benefits that participating countries have seen during the CReW.
Thank you very much for this chance to share the work and achievements of the CReW. I hope you have enjoyed my first Pecha Kucha Presentation!, Hopefully it´s not my last.
A very successful activity was training in facilitation early in 2013, to help countries improve the quality of stakeholder participation, solve problems and reach consensus on action. We saw countries use facilitation techniques at all levels after this and used them ourselves.
Here is a facilitated Session during the 2014 Project Steering Committee Meeting, which started the work of shaping the project’s replication strategy. It was a great collaborative effort that planted the seed of CReW+
23 sc!!!!! Not good
Check timing after donna input!!!