Christopher B. Barrett POLICY SEMINAR Socio-Technical Innovation Bundles for Agri-Food Systems Transformation: Implications for research and the One CGIAR agenda MAR 19, 2021 - 09:30 AM TO 11:00 AM EDT

1. Christopher B. Barrett
Cornell University
International Food Policy Research Institute
virtual seminar
March 19, 2021

2. Cornell Atkinson – Nature Sustainability 2020 expert
panel on “Innovations to Build Sustainable, Equitable,
Inclusive Food Value Chains” comprised a diverse
group of 23 experts from across disciplines, regions,
organizations, etc. Met Dec 2019-Nov 2020. Added 10
additional co-authors, report issued Dec. 2020.
Expert panel

3. AFS innovations have enabled huge advances in human well-being.
Core motivation
But also adverse, unsustainable spillover effects on climate,
natural environment, public health/nutrition, social justice.
Must update objectives, accelerate and reorient innovations.

4. The expert panel reached several key conclusions:
1. B/c AFS consist of complex webs of actors and processes,
must keep four key features firmly in mind:
- Human agency by billions actors is key .. mechanism design
- Heterogeneity precludes one-size-fits-all solutions
- Spillover effects pervasive and demand portfolio approaches
- Science-based innovation needed in evolutionary systems
Key conclusions

5. 2. A shared vision of HERS agri-food systems.
Must embrace multiple objectives simultaneously:
Key conclusions

6. 3. Must design for future states, not today’s. Looking 25-50 yrs
ahead (past 2030 SDGs, to scaled impact of emergent and
ideated innovations), 3 major changes loom:
- Climate change
- Population shifts – urbanization, aging
- Income growth
One key implication:
Pay FAR more attention to Africa … will account for >50% of
global food demand growth to 2100
Key conclusions

7. Report highlights
4. A profuse pipeline exists of promising (natural and social)
science advances at various stages of deployment readiness.
Span value chains and geographies.

8. Report highlights
Figure 1: The agri-food systems innovation cycle.
The agri-food systems innovation cycle

9. 1. Develop socio-technical innovation bundles.
No magic bullets exist. Need to bundle in order to:
(i) realize synergies needed to adapt/scale
(ii) address political economy arising from spillovers
(iii)meet heterogeneous needs
7 Essential Actions

10. 2. Reduce the land and water footprint of food.
Decoupling food production from land increasingly culturally, economically,
technologically feasible. Manage de-agrarianization’s creative destruction.
7 Essential Actions
Photo: Gerry Machen/Creative Commons
Photo: Betterindia.com
Photo: Beck Deifenbach/Reuters

11. 3. Commit to co-creation with shared and verifiable responsibility.
Agreed KPMs, safety nets, penalties can accelerate beneficial innovation and
minimize adverse unintended consequences.
7 Essential Actions

12. 4. Deconcentrate power. Reducing market and political
power imbalances and broadening participation in innovation
dialogues can accelerate innovation.
7 Essential Actions

13. 5. Mainstream systemic risk management.
COVID-19 underscores the rising importance of effective systemic risk
management. Need innovative risk reduction and risk transfer mechanisms.
7 Essential Actions

14. 6. Develop novel financing mechanisms.
AFS innovations require $$$ (hundreds of billions annually).
How to mobilize private resources beyond public spending/philanthropy?
7 Essential Actions

15. 7. Reconfigure public support for AFSs
Two key roles for gov’ts:
-invest in essential public goods and services
-facilitate dialogue to find cooperative solutions.
Much current government AFS spending is wasteful ($2bn/day!)
Redirect towards social protection programs, agri-food research, and physical
and institutional infrastructure.
Foster civil society dialogues to identify and support contextually appropriate
socio-technical bundles.
7 Essential Actions

16. Report and associated journal articles, videos, etc. available at
https://blogs.cornell.edu/nature-sustainability/
Thank you for your time and interest!
Thank you