SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
CRITICAL SOCIAL WORK SOCW4003 Direct Methods of Practice 2010 Linda Smith
[object Object],[object Object]
Introduction to critical thinking  (Garvin and Seabury, 1997:44) * critical thinking around various constructs * lack of attention to differences, oppression  * social group membership: age, race, sexual    orientation, ethnicity, gender, race, social class, disability  * ‘the other’ and ourselves * problems arise - absence attention to this knowledge * power differences, discrimination, transformative work * group membership, how reinforced/denigrated - social,    political historical contexts * therapeutic experiences harmful if not culturally compatible or    reinforce power imbalances * positionality (group identities, experiences) + standpoint    (outsider/insider status) influence expectations + development    of critical consciousness
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Critical consciousness “ process of continuous self-reflection coupled  with action to discover and uncover how we, our  approaches to social work practice and our  environment have been and continue to be shaped  by societal assumptions and power dynamics”  (Garvin and Seabury, 1997:46)
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Reflexive-therapeutic view (therapeutic helping) Individualist-reformist  Socialist-collectivist (maintenance or social order)  (emancipatory/transformational)
FRAMEWORKS FOR ANALYSING THEORIES   Theories of radical change        Radical SW  Marxist SW ‘ consciousness raisers’  ‘revolutionaries’   Subjective   Objective     Interactionist     Traditional SW ‘ seekers after meaning’   ‘fixers’     Theories of regulation
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
DISCUSSION EXERCISE: FOUR SUPPOSITIONS OF THE CRITICAL SOCIAL SCIENCE PARADIGM Macro-social structures shape social relations at every level of life The world is divided between ‘haves’ and ‘have-nots’ and the interests of these groups are opposed and irreconcilable The oppressed are complicit in their oppression Its emphasis is on empowering oppressed people to act, collectively, to achieve social change

More Related Content

What's hot

Three Theories About
Three Theories AboutThree Theories About
Three Theories About
Daryl Bambic
 
Major Theoretical Perspectives in Sociology
Major Theoretical Perspectives in SociologyMajor Theoretical Perspectives in Sociology
Major Theoretical Perspectives in Sociology
Kostyk Elf
 
international relation
international relation international relation
international relation
Julien Mort
 
Major theoretical perspectives in sociology
Major theoretical perspectives in sociologyMajor theoretical perspectives in sociology
Major theoretical perspectives in sociology
Seth Allen
 

What's hot (20)

Three Theories About
Three Theories AboutThree Theories About
Three Theories About
 
Soc101chapter1
Soc101chapter1Soc101chapter1
Soc101chapter1
 
Critical Theory and Media Studies
Critical Theory and Media StudiesCritical Theory and Media Studies
Critical Theory and Media Studies
 
Crowds
CrowdsCrowds
Crowds
 
Conflict Theory
Conflict TheoryConflict Theory
Conflict Theory
 
Marxism & Youth Culture
Marxism & Youth CultureMarxism & Youth Culture
Marxism & Youth Culture
 
Major Theoretical Perspectives in Sociology
Major Theoretical Perspectives in SociologyMajor Theoretical Perspectives in Sociology
Major Theoretical Perspectives in Sociology
 
SCLY3 – power and politics: defining power
SCLY3 – power and politics: defining powerSCLY3 – power and politics: defining power
SCLY3 – power and politics: defining power
 
Chapter 1
Chapter 1Chapter 1
Chapter 1
 
Sociological perspectives wccc rev8 31
Sociological perspectives wccc rev8 31Sociological perspectives wccc rev8 31
Sociological perspectives wccc rev8 31
 
Ideas in social sciences
Ideas in social sciencesIdeas in social sciences
Ideas in social sciences
 
Conflict perspective
Conflict perspectiveConflict perspective
Conflict perspective
 
international relation
international relation international relation
international relation
 
Critical theory in Education
Critical theory in EducationCritical theory in Education
Critical theory in Education
 
Max Weber
Max WeberMax Weber
Max Weber
 
Critical theory to study in and out school context
Critical theory to study in and out school contextCritical theory to study in and out school context
Critical theory to study in and out school context
 
The three main sociological perspectives
The three main sociological perspectivesThe three main sociological perspectives
The three main sociological perspectives
 
03 - Theoretical Perspective
03 - Theoretical Perspective03 - Theoretical Perspective
03 - Theoretical Perspective
 
Major theoretical perspectives in sociology
Major theoretical perspectives in sociologyMajor theoretical perspectives in sociology
Major theoretical perspectives in sociology
 
International Relations: Constructivism pt1
International Relations:  Constructivism pt1International Relations:  Constructivism pt1
International Relations: Constructivism pt1
 

Similar to Critical Sem 1

Claremont movements institutions
Claremont movements institutionsClaremont movements institutions
Claremont movements institutions
brianmclaren
 
PS 240 Thinking Politically Spring 2011
PS 240 Thinking Politically Spring 2011PS 240 Thinking Politically Spring 2011
PS 240 Thinking Politically Spring 2011
Christopher Rice
 
Vip mini course social movements 2013 sess 2
Vip mini course social movements 2013 sess 2Vip mini course social movements 2013 sess 2
Vip mini course social movements 2013 sess 2
Roger Yates
 
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
jeremylockett77
 
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
croftsshanon
 
Ed101 socio cultural change
Ed101 socio cultural changeEd101 socio cultural change
Ed101 socio cultural change
Rajah Aquia
 
Vip social theory part two
Vip social theory part twoVip social theory part two
Vip social theory part two
Roger Yates
 
AHMAD ALIYU SYMBOLIC VIOLENCE
AHMAD ALIYU SYMBOLIC VIOLENCEAHMAD ALIYU SYMBOLIC VIOLENCE
AHMAD ALIYU SYMBOLIC VIOLENCE
Aliyu Ahmad
 
Intersectionality&Privilege
Intersectionality&PrivilegeIntersectionality&Privilege
Intersectionality&Privilege
Nykolai Blichar
 

Similar to Critical Sem 1 (20)

Claremont movements institutions
Claremont movements institutionsClaremont movements institutions
Claremont movements institutions
 
About Social Movements PowerPoint 2.pptx
About Social Movements PowerPoint 2.pptxAbout Social Movements PowerPoint 2.pptx
About Social Movements PowerPoint 2.pptx
 
Political Theory and Ideology
Political Theory and IdeologyPolitical Theory and Ideology
Political Theory and Ideology
 
PS 240 Thinking Politically Spring 2011
PS 240 Thinking Politically Spring 2011PS 240 Thinking Politically Spring 2011
PS 240 Thinking Politically Spring 2011
 
Vip mini course social movements 2013 sess 2
Vip mini course social movements 2013 sess 2Vip mini course social movements 2013 sess 2
Vip mini course social movements 2013 sess 2
 
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
 
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx1  S o c i a l  T h e o r i e s   Social Theories  .docx
1 S o c i a l T h e o r i e s Social Theories .docx
 
OSEI Common Language Guide
OSEI Common Language GuideOSEI Common Language Guide
OSEI Common Language Guide
 
Ed101 socio cultural change
Ed101 socio cultural changeEd101 socio cultural change
Ed101 socio cultural change
 
Political Theory And Ideology
Political Theory And IdeologyPolitical Theory And Ideology
Political Theory And Ideology
 
COJO3040
COJO3040COJO3040
COJO3040
 
sociological Perspectives.pptx
sociological Perspectives.pptxsociological Perspectives.pptx
sociological Perspectives.pptx
 
POLITICS WEEK 2-3.pptx
POLITICS WEEK 2-3.pptxPOLITICS WEEK 2-3.pptx
POLITICS WEEK 2-3.pptx
 
Critical pedagogy
Critical pedagogyCritical pedagogy
Critical pedagogy
 
Vip social theory part two
Vip social theory part twoVip social theory part two
Vip social theory part two
 
AHMAD ALIYU SYMBOLIC VIOLENCE
AHMAD ALIYU SYMBOLIC VIOLENCEAHMAD ALIYU SYMBOLIC VIOLENCE
AHMAD ALIYU SYMBOLIC VIOLENCE
 
Social theories lecture 3
Social theories lecture 3Social theories lecture 3
Social theories lecture 3
 
#SoMeActivism
#SoMeActivism#SoMeActivism
#SoMeActivism
 
Intersectionality&Privilege
Intersectionality&PrivilegeIntersectionality&Privilege
Intersectionality&Privilege
 
PS 240 Thinking Politically Spring 2015
PS 240 Thinking Politically Spring 2015PS 240 Thinking Politically Spring 2015
PS 240 Thinking Politically Spring 2015
 

Critical Sem 1

  • 1. CRITICAL SOCIAL WORK SOCW4003 Direct Methods of Practice 2010 Linda Smith
  • 2.
  • 3. Introduction to critical thinking (Garvin and Seabury, 1997:44) * critical thinking around various constructs * lack of attention to differences, oppression * social group membership: age, race, sexual orientation, ethnicity, gender, race, social class, disability * ‘the other’ and ourselves * problems arise - absence attention to this knowledge * power differences, discrimination, transformative work * group membership, how reinforced/denigrated - social, political historical contexts * therapeutic experiences harmful if not culturally compatible or reinforce power imbalances * positionality (group identities, experiences) + standpoint (outsider/insider status) influence expectations + development of critical consciousness
  • 4.
  • 5. Critical consciousness “ process of continuous self-reflection coupled with action to discover and uncover how we, our approaches to social work practice and our environment have been and continue to be shaped by societal assumptions and power dynamics” (Garvin and Seabury, 1997:46)
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13. Reflexive-therapeutic view (therapeutic helping) Individualist-reformist Socialist-collectivist (maintenance or social order) (emancipatory/transformational)
  • 14. FRAMEWORKS FOR ANALYSING THEORIES Theories of radical change     Radical SW Marxist SW ‘ consciousness raisers’ ‘revolutionaries’   Subjective Objective Interactionist Traditional SW ‘ seekers after meaning’ ‘fixers’ Theories of regulation
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18. DISCUSSION EXERCISE: FOUR SUPPOSITIONS OF THE CRITICAL SOCIAL SCIENCE PARADIGM Macro-social structures shape social relations at every level of life The world is divided between ‘haves’ and ‘have-nots’ and the interests of these groups are opposed and irreconcilable The oppressed are complicit in their oppression Its emphasis is on empowering oppressed people to act, collectively, to achieve social change