This document summarizes the key findings of Ernst & Young's HR practices survey conducted in 2008 in collaboration with the National HR Development Network. The survey received responses from 188 organizations across 15 industry sectors.
The survey found that HR is increasingly involved in strategic business planning. It also found that performance-linked pay is becoming more prevalent and transparency in compensation practices needs to be improved. Additionally, talent acquisition continues to be a priority and employer branding is an important aspect of attracting suitable candidates. Developing leadership skills and strengthening performance management were also highlighted as areas of focus.
The way forward discussed automating more HR processes, increasing workplace flexibility, measuring training effectiveness, and strengthening diversity and feedback programs. In conclusion, the
Tech Startup Growth Hacking 101 - Basics on Growth Marketing
‘HR’s Next Agenda’Ernst & Young - NHRDN HR Practices Survey 2008
1. ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD
HR Practices Survey 2008
N S Rajan
Regional President, NHRD (North)
Partner, Human Capital, E&Y
2. Contents
► About the Survey
► Our Approach
► Key Findings
► Way Forward
► About Ernst & Young
Page 2 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
3. About the survey
Page 3 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
4. About the survey
► ‘HR’s Next Agenda’ - The Ernst & Young NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008 is the first
of its kind study of the people practices in India
► Objectives of the Survey:
► The survey is intended to study the state of HR practices and the upcoming priorities of HR in
India with a view to
► Create a baseline of current practices
► Provide directional guidance to the trends shaping the HR function
► Scope of the Survey:
► HR systems, processes and practices around Organization Vision, Mission & Values,
Recruitment, Performance Management, Training & Development, Career Development,
Compensation & Benefits, Rewards & Recognition etc were studied
► The survey coverage extended to Organizations with varying employee strength, turnover and
industry sectors
Page 4 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
5. About the survey
► 188 Organizations across 15 Industry Sectors responded to the survey
Industry Sectors Respondents Industry Sectors Respondents
Automotive 7 IT/ITes 44
Banking/ Financial Services/ 14 Media and Entertainment 8
Insurance
Professional Services 15
Chemicals and Petroleum 8
Real Estate 9
Consumer Goods 8
Electronics/ Technology 10 Retail 11
Healthcare and 10 Telecommunication 7
Pharmaceuticals
Industrial Products 16 Travel and Tourism 5
Infrastructure 16
Page 5 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
6. Our Approach
Page 6 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
7. Our Approach
► The survey was carried out in the following phases:
Administration
Design Phase Analysis Phase
Phase
►A stratified sampling methodology was adopted to identify participating
organizations across 15 industries on the basis of type of industry, size and
turnover of organizations
►A focused online questionnaire was developed to capture responses across
various fields of HR
► The responses received to date were then collated and analyzed on the basis of
the Survey Framework
► Dataobtained was also supplemented by qualitative insights from select senior
HR professionals who were interviewed
Page 7 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
8. Key Findings
How has the business environment changed? What
are the trends that we foresee?
Are Indian organizations more surefooted on the
global business stage?
What are the expectations that business has from
HR professionals?
Page 8 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
9. HR Strategy and Processes
► HR has a prominent seat at the table and is extensively involved in the strategic
business planning process (90 % )
► Large organizations believe that HR adds critical value to the achievement of
business results (100%)
► Line managers involvement in HR strategy and implementation is high and will
continue to increase (80 %)
► Limited focus on increasing effectiveness of HR processes ( 40%)
HR’s next agenda:
Partner with business to reduce cost and improve efficiency
Increasing accountability of HR with 65% of the organizations planning to
introduce effective measures of performance for HR
Page 9 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
10. HR Strategy and Processes
HR has evolved
into making or breaking a business.
This change has made HR into
a business facilitator.
Aquil Busrai
IBM
Page 10 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
11. Compensation and Benefits
► Increments unlikely to be beyond 8 -10% in the coming year
► Performance linked pay taking significant precedence impacting even junior levels (from
5% of CTC in 2002 to 12-15% currently)
► Financial Services has the highest incidence of short term performance pay
► Chemicals & Petroleum industry is high on benefits
► More transparency required in compensation practices (>50%)
► Low prevalence of Long term Incentives like ESOP
HR’s next agenda:
Strong variability - link between business performance & pay
A Standard Global Compensation system across geographies
Page 11 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
12. Compensation and Benefits
Transparency is not about putting up
compensation structures on the website.
Employees must know that things happen here
in a fair and equitable manner.
Satish Pradhan
Tata Sons
Page 12 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
13. Talent Acquisition & Employer Branding
► Internal recruitment preferred to external recruitment
► Positive corporate reputation biggest draw for hiring suitable talent (100%)
► Well defined Employee Value Proposition highly co-related with organization size
(especially for those with employee strength exceeding 1000)
► New hire coaching and mentoring more prevalent in Retail, Consumer goods and Health
care
► Hiring to continue despite economic slowdown (with 70% of organizations agreeing)
HR’s next agenda:
Focus on Employer Branding- Internal focus to ensure employee experience as per
brand promise, External Communication Cells to build compelling stories of
employer value proposition to key stakeholders
Strengthening Campus Relations Program through campus ambassadors
Page 13 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
14. Talent Acquisition & Employer Branding
The real challenge is
how to attract specialized talent,
together with
building solid employee engagement.
Anand Nayak
ITC
Page 14 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
15. Performance Management and Measurement
► Individual goals not well aligned to business goals (70%)
► Communication of performance feedback and ratings to employees are areas of
improvement (70% )
► Normalization of Ratings – important practice for rationalizing ratings and maintaining
costs (80% )
► PMS Linkages to bonus highest in Financial Services; to training highest in Consumer
goods; to career management highest in IT/ITES
HR’s next agenda:
• Increased used of the Balanced Scorecard
• Development of Reviewer coaching skills for providing relevant feedback and
impartial ratings
Automation of Processes through web based PMS
Page 15 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
16. Performance Management and Measurement
Performance is an equally important
part of the equation.
Pay for performance can work
only if both ends receive equal attention.
Santrupt Misra
Aditya Birla Group
Page 16 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
17. Training and Development
► No budget cuts expected in Training and Development Activities over the next 1 year,
time spent on training to increase (78%)
► Well defined training policy and training needs identification at all levels (70 %)
► Competency based needs identification and development still an area of gap ( 52 %)
► Organizations unable to determine ROI on Development spend, employees unclear on
what skills they are expected to learn
► IT enablement of Training program management lacking
HR’s next agenda:
“Action Learning” – On the Job training programs to replace classroom learning
Measuring effectiveness of training programs
Page 17 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
18. Training and Development
In the context
of decreasing capital investment
and increasing employee costs,
HR needs to drive the supply agenda.
K Ramkumar
ICICI
Page 18 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
19. Leadership Development
► Only a third of identified future leaders satisfied with organizational support for their
development
► In larger organizations, leadership identified as a core competency
► Smaller organizations introducing measures to strengthen their succession planning
process
► Chemicals and Petroleum, Electronics and Technology and Health care and
Pharmaceutical industries indicate that top management considers leadership as a
critical process (70%)
HR’s next agenda:
Task forces of top performers across the hierarchy to work closely with the CEO
on all critical business projects
Increased investment in leadership development initiatives
Page 19 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
20. Leadership Development
Leadership style should be conducive
and enabling towards strategy,
not a constraint
Arvind Agrawal
RPG
Page 20 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
21. Organization Culture
► Information flow takes place in all directions in most organizations (60%)
► Larger the organization, greater is the emphasis on communication and feedback
mechanisms
► Involvement of employees in decision making low (75%)
► Confidence and trust in subordinates is an issue (60%)
► Grievance redressal and whistle blower policies need strengthening (70%)
HR’s next agenda:
Increased empowerment through delegation
Strengthen diversity programs and alternate talent pool programs
Idea portals to collect employee feedback and provide it directly to the leadership
Page 21 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
22. Organization Culture
Construct the social reality,
shape values,
and attend
to the drama and vision
of the organization.
P Dwarakanath
Page 22 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
23. Way Forward
Page 23 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
24. Way Forward
► A snapshot of some of the interesting insights captured as part of the way forward for HR:
Cost
Efficiency
Web Based Job
PMS Sculpting
HR
Action Way
Communication
Learning Forward
Centre of
Programs for HR Excellence
Workplace Competency
Flexibility Based PMS
Diversity
Programs
Page 24 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
25. Way Forward
The true role of an HR professional
is to be an alchemist…
Page 25 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
26. About Ernst & Young
Page 26 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008
27. About Ernst and Young
140,000 people | 750 offices | 134 countries | 1 unwavering commitment
Who we are India expertise Human Capital (India)
• >4000 people • Among 5 global “Centers of
People who demonstrate Excellence”
• 139 partners
integrity, respect, and teaming. • >60 senior professionals
• 9 Locations
People with energy, enthusiasm, • Industry expertise - 13 • End-to-end HR value chain
expertise
and the courage to lead. Industry Practices
• Specialists in strategic people
• Domain Expertise -
People who build relationships solutions
Assurance, Tax, Transactions • Strong business
based on doing the right thing
and Advisory Service Lines understanding &
implementation focus
What we stand for • Global delivery experience
At Ernst & Young, we’re Strategy • > 50% - Repeat business
committed to helping our • 90% clients rated us 5/5 on a
people, our clients and our wider Customer Satisfaction index
communities achieve their
Sector
Sector
potential. It’s how we make a Experts
experts
difference.
Value Performance
creation Technology Process improvement
experts experts
We hold the #1 or #2 market position in 7 of our top 10 markets
Page 27 ‘HR’s Next Agenda’
Ernst & Young - NHRD HR Practices Survey, 2008