Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
EDEN - Siemens Comparison Chart
1. SIEMENS 5 KW System
System description:
Gas supply 1.62Nm3/h biogas CH4-CO2 53/47 (8.14kW)
Electric power DC 4kW
AC 3.3kW
Heat recovery 2.7kW
Efficiency (on biogas) Electrical 38%
Overall 69%
Technology Stack Siemens (tubular, pressurized,
need a steam-reformer)
System Siemens
References (field trials) HERA (Torino)
State of art Product development
System suitable for demo yes
Future market Power generation up to MW (high electrical
efficiency in combination with microturbines)
Allan Casanova Dr. Joachim Hoffmann
VP, Business Development Technical program manager
Siemens Power Generation (USA) Stationary Fuel Cells
Stationary Fuel Cells hoffmannjoachim@siemens.com
allan.casanova@siemens.com
TECHNICAL ADVICE
Technology
Advantages:
- Large experience, oldest system test program
- Inherent strength and tolerance to rapid temperature change
- High electrical efficiency on biogas
- Steam-reforming before stack (in the case of biogas can work as a fuse in electrical circuits, and
protect the stack, the most expensive part of the SOFC system)
- System develop for industrial purpose (up to MWs)
- Maintenace from Europe
Disadvantages:
- Steam-reforming with recirculation through an ejector, little possibilities of changing the nominal
CO2 percentage.
- Cost per kW high
Experience SOFC systems
4 units delivered to the field (Powerco, Szencorp and EWE), 10 for EWE in 2007
Experience with biogas
They can run a known composition through a test station
System suitable for demo yes
ITEM COST / TIME INCLUDED NOT INCLUDED
DELIVERY COST EVALUATION
System 360.000$ yes
Freight rate no
Insurances no
2. Delivery Time 6 months
Other 12.914$ Gas compressor
OPERATION COSTS EVALUATION
On-site training,
Travel and living
installation and start up 9.100$ Training up to 5 people
expenses 1 person
support (5 days)
32.700$/year or 2.725$/
Monitoring no
month
Operation costs
Maintenance
4.000hr of operation or Problem diagnostic
Warranty
1 year assistance
After-sales service
(logistics)