Presentation delivered to a Global CCS Institute symposium on Policy and Regulatory Frameworks for CCS in Tokyo on 3 September 2013.
Presentation by Office of Marine Environment, Water Environment Division, Environmental Management Bureau, Ministry of Environment Japan.
Regulatory Framework for Carbon Dioxide Sub-seabed Storage - Safety and Potential Environmental Impact
1. 1
Regulatory Framework for Carbon
Dioxide Sub-seabed Storage - Safety
and Potential Environmental Impact
Office of Marine Environment
Water Environment Division
Environmental Management Bureau
Ministry of Environment
September 3, 2013
2. 2
Contents
Carbon dioxide sub-seabed storage:
1. The regulatory framework of CO2 sub-seabed storage
under the London Protocol
2. The regulatory framework of CO2 sub-seabed storage
under the Marine Pollution Prevention Law
3. Project of Ministry of Environment about CCS (2008~)
3. 1. The regulatory framework of
CO2 sub-seabed storage under the London
Protocol
3
4. 4
The 1996 London Protocol
Parties of The 1996 London Protocol
Angola
Australia
Barbados
Belgium
Bulgaria
Canada
Chile
China
Denmark
Egypt
France
Georgia
Germany
Ghana
Iceland
Ireland
Italy
Japan
Kenya
Luxembourg
Marshall Islands
Mexico
Netherlands
New Zealand
Nigeria
Norway
Philippines
Republic of Korea
Saint Kitts and Nevis
Saudi Arabia
Sierra Leone
Slovenia
South Africa
Spain
Suriname
Sweden
Switzerland
Tonga
Trinidad & Tobago
United Kingdom
Vanuatu
Yemen
42
Countries
Afghanistan
Antigua & Barbuda
Argentina
Australia
Azerbaijan
Barbados
Belarus
Belgium
Benin
Bolivia
Brazil
Bulgaria
Canada
Cape Verde
Chile
China
Costa Rica
Cote d'Ivoire
Croatia
Cuba
Cyprus
Dem. Rep. of the Congo
Denmark
Dominican Republic
Egypt
Equatorial Guinea
Finland
France
Gabon
Germany
Greece
Guatemala
Haiti
Honduras
Hungary
Iceland
Iran (Islamic Republic of)
Ireland
Italy
Jamaica
Japan
Jordan
Kenya
Kiribati
Libya
Luxembourg
Malta
Mexico
Monaco
Montenegro
Morocco
Nauru
Netherlands
New Zealand
Nigeria
Norway
Oman
Pakistan
Panama
Papua New Guinea
Peru
Philippines
Poland
Portugal
Republic of Korea
Russian Federation
Saint Lucia
St. Vincent & Grenadines
Serbia
Seychelles
Sierra Leone
Slovenia
Solomon Islands
South Africa
Spain
Suriname
Sweden
Switzerland
Syrian Arab Republic
Tonga
Tunisia
Ukraine
United Arab Emirates
United Kingdom
United Rep. of Tanzania
United States
Vanuatu
Hong Kong, China
Macao, China
Faroe Islands
Parties of The London Convention
90
Countries
5. Structure of the London Protocol
Purpose:
Prevention of marine pollution by dumping of
wastes from land-based sources
Principle:
・ Prohibit the dumping of any wastes or other
matter with the exception of those listed in
Annex I.
・ Permit is required for dumping in accordance
with provisions of Annex II.
Annex I
Waste or other matter that may be
considered for dumping
(Reverse List)
Annex II
Assessment of wastes or other
matter that may be considered
for dumping
Generic WAG
Guidelines for assessment of wastes
that may be considered for dumping
WAG: Waste Assessment Guidelines
Specific WAG
Waste-specific guidelines
.8 CO2 for sub-seabed sequestration(2006)
.1 dredged material
.2 sewage sludge
.3 fish waste
.4 vessels and platforms
.5 inert, inorganic geological material
.6 organic material of natural origin
.7 bulky items from small islands
5
6. 6
The regulation of CCS at the London Protocol
Annex I
“Carbon dioxide streams from carbon dioxide capture processes
for sequestration” may only be considered for dumping, if
(1) disposal is into a sub-seabed geological formations
(2) wastes consist overwhelmingly of CO2 (may contain incidental
associated substances derived from the source material, and
the capture and sequestration processes used)
(3) no wastes or other matter are added for the purpose of
disposing of those wastes or other matter.
Background
1. CCS has the potential risk for marine environment.
(Ex: death, slow growth and hindrances to incubation)
2. This regulation is not out of the scope of the London Protocol.
7. 2. The regulatory framework of
CO2 sub-seabed storage under
the Marine Pollution Prevention Law
Amendment of LP Annex I
Implementation of LP within country
(2006~)
Amendment of Marine Pollution Prevention Law
7
8. Objective of Marine Pollution Prevention Law
Objective (Article 1)
●The OPRC convention
・ Removing any discharged oil, hazardous liquid substances, waste and others
・ Taking measures to prevent hazard to vessel traffics caused by offshore fire
and others.
●The Marpol Convention
・ Regulating discharge of oil, hazardous liquid substances and waste from
vessels, platforms and aircrafts into ocean
・ Regulating emission of exhaust gas from vessels into air
●The London Convention/Protocol
・ Regulating disposal of oil, hazardous liquid substances and waste under
seabed
Protection of marine environment
Protection of people’s lives, bodies and property
Control, treatment,
prevention, measures
8
9. The regulation of disposal under seabed
1.wastes or other matter related to the exploration of
seabed mineral resources
2.Gases consist overwhelmingly of carbon dioxide.
9
Oil Hazardous liquid substances Wastes
Prohibited disposal and storage under seabed
Except for
Permission of the Minister of Environment is
necessary.
10. The permission flow under the Law ①
10
1. Submission of Application documents
2. Judgment on permission
3. Disposal and storage CO2, and Monitoring
4. Renewal of permission (every 5 years)
11. The necessary documents for permission ①
11
1. Information of a representative
2. Plans of disposal of CO2
disposing schedule and storage period (under 5 years).
The characteristics of disposal CO2
The quantity of disposal CO2
Necessary items on an application form
• The source of CO2
• The procedure of capturing CO2 (only by using amine).
• The component of disposal gases.
→ CO2 must be over 99%.
The measurement
1. gas chromatography : target for hydrocarbon, carbon monoxide
and other impurities.
2. alkali absorption method : target for carbon dioxide.
12. The necessary documents for permission ②
12
2. Plans of disposal of CO2
disposal point and range of CO2
The procedure of disposal CO2
The action plan in troubles to marine environment
Necessary items on an application form
• Latitude and longitude
• The depth of water and disposal CO2 under seabed
• The arrangement of institutions
• The range of spreading disposal CO2
• Facilities of transporting and storage
• The condition of pressure, velocity and temperature etc.
• The method of maintenance and closure of the injection well
• Moments when the pressure at the injection well is high enough
to influence marine environment.
• The measures to the much leakage of CO2 to sea
13. The necessary documents for permission ③
13
3. Plans of monitoring for marine environment
A) Normal monitoring (Not leakage)
B) Precautionary Monitoring for leakage of CO2
C) Emergency monitoring at leakage of CO2
Necessary items at an application form
• Annual report to the
Minster of the Environment
• Unexpected value
• Report to the Minster of the
Environment, based on this
monitoring
• Suspicious leakage of
CO2
• Continuous monitoring during
Influence on marine environment
Action to remove the obstacles to marine environment
14. Monitoring plan ①
14
Monitoring Items Target Frequency
Normal
Monitoring
Stored CO2
Quantity stored at the project
more than once
a year
Cumulative straged quantity at the
site
Concentration of streamig gases
Temporal change of pressure,
velosity and temperature while
streaming
Circumstances
of the site
Georogical characteristics
more than once
a year
The point and the range of the
stored CO2
twice during the
project
Chemical characteristics of sea
water
basically more
than once a
year
Marine lives and ecosystems at
the site
more than once
during the
project
Social characteristics
(ex. Fishing grounds)
15. Monitoring plan ②
15
Monitoring Items Target Frequency
Precautionary
Monitoring for
leakage of CO2
Stored CO2
Temporal change of pressure
while streaming as soon as
possible after
events of
possible
leakage
happen
Circumstances
of the site
Georogical characteristics
The point and the range of the
stored CO2
Chemical characteristics of sea
water
• Annual report to the
Minster of the Environment
• Unexpected value
• Report to the Minster of the
Environment, based on this
monitoring
• Suspicious leakage of
CO2
16. Monitoring plan ③
16
Monitoring Items Target Frequency
Emergency
monitoring at
leakage of CO2
Stored CO2
Temporal change of pressure
while streaming
as soon as
possible after
recognizing
marine
environment is
influenced by
leaked CO2
Detailed conditions of stored CO2
Circumstances
of the site
Georogical characteristics
Chemical characteristics of sea
water
Living things and ecosystems at
the site
Social characteristics
(ex. Fishing grounds)
• Continuous monitoring during
Influence on marine environment
Action to remove the obstacles to marine environment
17. Necessary documents for application
17
1. Application documents for permission
2. Potential environmental assessment documents
prior to the project
3. Documents of site selection
4. Documents explaining that there are no ways other
than disposing CO2 under seabed.
5. Financial and technical capacities to proceed the
project and the monitoring.
6. The outline of the project
18. Potential environmental assessment ①
18Permission
Yes
Possible influence to marine environment
No
The hypothesis of CO2 leakage
Leakage simulation
Potential environmental assessment
・Prediction increase CO2 concentration in the leakage from seabed.
・Decision to watched species
Assumption of leakage volume
Stream direction
Stream velocity Information about marine environment
The field survey
Rejected
Characteristics of Stored CO2
(including over 99% CO2)
Yes
Rejected
No
19. Potential environmental assessment ②
19
Target Item
Streaming CO2
Temperature, Pressure, Viscosity and
Density etc.
Stored CO2
Temperature, Pressure, Viscosity and
Density etc.
Consentration of CO2 Conformity to the standard
Mainly impurities Some kinds of impurities and percentage
Reaction of CO2
stored under seabed
Reaction of minerals and stored CO2
Characteristics of CO2
The hypothesis of CO2 leakage
The scenario of CO2 leakage, based on geological information
and circumstances of sea
The point of CO2 leakage
The range of spreading CO2
The quantity of CO2 leakage
(Examples)
(Examples)
20. Potential environmental assessment ③
20
Potential environmental assessment
Classification Target Item
Environment of sea
water and seabed
Water quality
Concentration of TCO2, Hydrogen ions and
toxic substances
Bottom sediment
Concentration of TCO2 and toxic
substances
Marine lives
Planktons
Primary productivity, zoo plankton and
phytoplankton species and quantity of
planktons with calciums
Fish Fishing grounds and fields of spawning
Seaweeds and coral Distribution of seaweeds and coral
Benthos Benthos with calciums
Ecosystems
Vulnerability and importande of
ecosystems
Kelp coasts, tidelands and coral coasts,
and distribution of rare living things
Ecocystem around hot springs Distribution of hot springs
Social Characteristics
Recreation
Distribution of these things
Parks
Fishing grounds
Ship routes
Cables on seabeds
Mineral exploration
(Examples)
21. Other documents
21
Documents of site selection
Viewpoints Item
Geological
Little records of big earthquakes changing geological features
Little possibility of changing geological features
Potential routes of CO2 movement and leakage
Technical
Technical possibility of moitoring
Possible means of stopping leakage CO2
Natural No especial protective species
Documents explaining that there are no ways other than disposing CO2 under seabed
• Disposal under lands
• Utilization for industrial purposes
Financial and technical capacities to proceed the project and the monitoring.
• balance sheets in the project term
• Achievements of other projects
(Examples)
22. The permission flow under the Law ①
22
1. Submission of Application documents
Application documents of disposal CO2 under seabed
Potential environmental assessment documents prior
to the project
Documents of site selection
Documents about project, etc.
2. Judgment on permission
Disposal CO2 meets the Criteria
Environmental assessment prior to the project shows
the leakage hypothesis and influence on environment
is little.
The monitoring is planned in order to detect the
leakage soon.
23. The permission flow under the Law ②
23
3. Disposal CO2 and Monitoring
Monitoring disposal CO2 about
quantity, place, temperature and
pressure, etc.
Monitoring disposal site about
stratum, sea water and creatures, etc.
Permission of the
Minister of Environment
Rejected
Minister of
Environment
The direction
of
improvement
and stop
The
revocation of
permission
4. Renewal of permission (every 5 years)
Revising the project, based on the latest information
and knowledge. (The notice shows permission under 5 years)
24. 3. Project of Ministry of Environment about CCS
(2008~)
24
25. 25
環境省 海洋環境室
Manuals of inspection and permission
The detail framework of inspection and permission
(2008 ~)
26. 26
MATSUSHIMA
OFFSHORE
AMAKUSA
OFFSHORE
OKINAWA
OFFSHORE
OOSAKA BAY
ISE BAY
TOKYO BAY
AGA
OFFSHORE
AKITA
OFFSHORE
NORTH- KYUSYUU
OFFSHORE
SOUMA~KASHIMA
OFFSHORE
TOMAKOMAI
&MUKOGAWA
OFFSHORE
UCHIURA
BAY
BEPU BAY
Marine ecosystem survey
Marine ecosystem survey sea site:five site( )
& Offshore CCS Potential Survey sea site: ( )
*
&CCS Demonstration Project site select survey site
( )
**
<References>
* 「CO2 geological storage study report 005,2007」,
Research Institute of Innovative Technology for
the Earth (RITE)
** Japan CCS Co., Ltd. (JCCS)
Marine Survey for Offshore CCS Project(2011-2013)
Marine Ecosystem Survey
1. Marine Organisms and Ecosystem Survey
(Plankton, Shellfish, Benthos)
2. Seawater Chemical Survey
(pH, pCO2, Temperature, Salinity, TOC etc.)
Long Term Management Method
Consideration of Long term
management method for Offshore
CCS in Japan
(Survey about the management
methods in foreign countries)
27. 27
Database on biological impact by CO2 exposure
Target species
NOEC/
LOEC/
EC50
⊿pCO2
(ppm)
Effect Endpoint Notes Reference
Hemicentrotus
pulcherrimus
(Japanese green
sea urchin)
LOEC
200
Reduced Survival rate
・Life stage:
Juvenile
・Exposure
period:
6 months
・Control pCO2:
360ppm
Shirayama
and
Thornton,
2005LOEC Reduced Growth rate
Mytilus edulis
(Blue mussel)
NOEC 1,535 None
Regeneration
(Tissues of a
reproductive
organ)
・Life stage:
Adult
・Exposure
period:
60 days
・Control pCO2:
340ppm
Beesley et
al., 2008
http://www.env.go.jp/water/kaiyo/ccs/eikyo_db/database.htm
- Extracted from the Ministry of the Environment Japan - (2008 ~)
(42 benthos and 36 other species)