1.
Leonard Agranat, Daniel Cady, Amanda Cohen, Nikhil Kulkarni, Chris Machielse, Linda Yeung

2.
Agenda
Origins
Current Big Picture
Areas for Improvement
Revised Big Picture
Recommendations
Q&A
2

3.
Volkswagen
terminated
Origins
project
1993 Officially launched
Assembly Plant opened in the U.S.
Idea developed October 27, 1997 2008
by Nicholas 2010 sales were only
Hayek, CEO of 5,927 units
SMH No longer associated with SMH December, 2010
Late 1980’s January 1, 1999
March 4, 1994 January, 2009
Joined forces with Waiting list in US is 12
Mercedes-Benz October, 1998 months
Smart car sales launched
in 9 European Countries
July 3, 1991 July 1, 2011
Penske Automotive
Agreement reached
Group rescinds all US
with Volkswagen to
distribution rights to
develop new project
Mercedes-Benz
3

4.
Current Big Picture
execute
product
service
STP
segment
price
business marketing source of
objective objective volume target
position place
promotion
4

5.
Current Big Picture
execute
product
service
STP
segment
price
business marketing source of
objective objective volume target
position place
promotion
5

6.
Business Objective
Fundamental • Smart Car USA
Entity
Core • Technology
Competence • Engineering
• Undefined
Goal
6

7.
Marketing Objective
Acquisition
– Small category: fuel-efficient subcompacts
– Recent entry to market (2008)
– Small customer base
– Challenge: Overcome head and heart loyalty
7

8.
Source of Volume
Only have 0.1% market share
Stimulate Demand for subcompacts
– Main variable: small size and fuel efficiency
– Dynamic variable: price and customizability
“SmartCar is unique and has no real
competition”
Raising awareness for subcompact cars
8

9.
Who is Smart talking to?
Marketing Objective
acquisition retention
Pulling buyers Have current
stimulate into the owners
subcompact purchase more
demand category. Smart Cars.
Source of Volume
Retain current
steal Target buyers customers who
of competing also own
share vehicles. competing
vehicles.
9

10.
Current Big Picture
execute
product
service
STP
segment
price
business marketing source of
objective objective volume target
position place
promotion
10

11.
Segment
Source: Strategic Business Insights
11

12.
How does Smart segment?
Address high degree for self-expression
Need to look “cool”
– Regular compact cars are boring
Sponsorship at young, urban events
12

13.
Target
Jenna
Age 23
“Urban hipster”
13

14.
Lives in the city
14

15.
•Large cars hard to park
•Public transportation is tedious
15

16.
Cares about the environment
16

17.
Fashion forward
17

18.
Smart Car changes
with her style
18

19.
Positioning
“unBig, unCar”
Small cars are just as capable as big cars
Deemphasize importance of having big car
Small cars are fuel efficient
19

20.
5-Box Positioning Statement
When I want
to buy a car, I Bigger cars are Driving small
want not necessarily cars are
something big better smarter.
and strong
When I look to
buy a car, I will When I look to
buy a big car, buy a car, I will
or SUV buy a Smart Car.
20

21.
Current Picture Diagram
execute
product
service
STP
segment
price
business marketing source of
objective objective volume target
position place
promotion
21

22.
Product
Has not changed product line since 2008
– Pure coupe
– Passion coupe
– Passion cabriolet
22

23.
Search Attributes
Price
Miles per gallon
Appearance
Safety
23

24.
Price
Base price $12,490
All models under $20,000
– Offer affordable car to young target market
Competitive with other subcompact cars
2 year, 24,000 mile warranty
24

25.
Miles per Gallon
High fuel economy
– 33 city and 44 highway mpg
Highest mileage, gas-only vehicle in US
Source: FuelEconomy.gov
25

26.
Appearance
Sleek look
Small enough to fit in
tight spaces
Entirely customizable
exterior
– Color, design,
pattern, change
panels
26

27.
Safety
Highest possible crash test ratings
– Frontal offset
– Side-impact
– Roof strength
Source: Insurance Institute for Highway Safety
27

28.
Experience Attributes
Ride quality
– Excels in turning radius and parking ease
– Stiff suspension
– Automatic transmission feels like manual
– Rough riding experience
28

29.
Promotion
Buzz around US
launch
Few TV or print ads
Active on social
media
Lowest brand
awareness car in
America
Source: Young Intelligence
29

30.
Promotion
30

31.
Place
Sold in Mercedes-Benz dealerships
– Share the same showrooms
Intimidates potential Smart Car buyers
– Loss of sales due to this reason
31

32.
The unSales Growth
32

33.
Rick Perry, General Manager
34

34.
Revised Big Picture
execute
product
STP
segment
price
business marketing source of
objective objective volume target
position place
promotion
35

35.
Revised Big Picture
execute
product
STP
segment
price
business marketing source of
objective objective volume target
position place
promotion
36

36.
unGoal: 1500 units/month
37

37.
Revised Big Picture
execute
product
STP
segment
price
business marketing source of
objective objective volume target
position place
promotion
38

38.
Revised Big Picture
execute
product
STP
segment
price
business marketing source of
objective objective volume target
position place
promotion
39

39.
Source of Volume
Steal Share from other cars in category
Clearly not the market leader
40

40.
41

41.
Safety
Size
42

42.
Value
Size
43

43.
Revised Big Picture
execute
product
STP
segment
price
business marketing source of
objective objective volume target
position place
promotion
44

44.
Important Attributes
Importance
5
4.44
4.5
4.11
3.95 4.02
4 3.85
3.56
3.46
3.5
Reported Importance
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
Size Fuel Economy Brand Name Exterior Styling Reliability Value Safety
Attribute
n=92
45

45.
Most Important Attributes
1. Reliability
2. Value
3. Safety
46

46.
Address Importance
I don’t think fuel Smart is not only I can travel & do
economy is very a great value, but more for my gas
important. it can save you money with a fuel
money on gas too. efficient Smart.
I will buy a new When I look to
car without buy a car, I will
considering MPG. buy a Smart Car.
47

47.
Perception Problems
Perception
5
4.46
4.5
4
3.5
3 2.83 2.82
2.55
2.5
2.11
1.96
2 1.80
1.5
1
0.5
0
Size Fuel Economy Brand Name Exterior Styling Reliability Value Safety
48

48.
Lowest Ranking Perceptions
1. Safety
2. Size
3. Styling
49

49.
Address Perceptions
Smart is a great Smart is a great Smart is both a
value, but it is too value, and it great value and a
dangerous. performs well in safe vehicle.
crash tests.
When I look to
When I look to
buy a car, I will
buy a car, I will
purchase a larger
buy a Smart Car.
vehicle.
50

50.
Discrepancies Between
Importance and Perceptions
5
4.46 4.44
4.5
4.11
3.95 4.02
4 3.85
3.56
3.46
3.5
3 2.83 2.82
2.55
2.5 Importance
2.11 Perception
1.96
2 1.80
1.5
1
0.5
0
Size Fuel Economy Brand Name Exterior Styling Reliability Value Safety
51

51.
Revised Big Picture
execute
product
STP
segment
price
business marketing source of
objective objective volume target
position place
promotion
52

52.
Improve Warranty Coverage
Increase beyond 2 year/24,000 mile
Match Ford Fiesta
– 3 year/36,000 mile bumper-to-bumper warranty
– 5 year/60,000 mile powertrain warranty
– 5 year/60,000 mile roadside assistance
53

53.
Revised Big Picture
execute
product
STP
segment
price
business marketing source of
objective objective volume target
position place
promotion
54

54.
Place
Make separate
dealership for Smart
Cars
Different target
markets hurt potential
sales of Smart Cars
55

55.
Price Ranges
$200,000
$160,000
$150,000
Min
$100,000 Max
$38,000
$50,000
$19,000
$12,000
$0
Mercedes-Benz Smart Car
56

56.
Cost of Implementation
Add 26 dealerships in urban areas with
Jennas
– e.g. Southfield, MI instead of Bloomfield Hills
Cost per new dealer = $816k
– $265k annual salaries
– $551k startup costs
Total cost = $21,216,000
57

57.
Revised Big Picture
execute
product
STP
segment
price
business marketing source of
objective objective volume target
position place
promotion
58

58.
Promotion
Image promotion  need people to realize what
Smart Car can offer for value.
– Currently there are poor views of Smart Car.
– More GRP’s
– Promote on young, hip shows (Modern Family,
America’s Next Top Model, etc.)
Promote what matters to consumers
– Safety, value
Mercedes has allocated $25 million for media
59

59.
60

60.
Example Ad
Small is safe.
The Smart Fortwo earns the highest possible ratings in roof
strength, frontal offset, and side impact tests.
61

61.
Cost of New Promotion
Cost per 30 second spot:
– Modern Family: $250k
– America’s Next Top Model: $61k
1 exposure per episode
– 24 episodes for Modern; 10 for Top Model per
season
Total Cost: $6,610,000
Total GRPs: 167
62

62.
Key Takeaways
Current Recommended
Cost per 30 second spot:
Business Objective – Goal -- 1500 units / month
– Modern Family: $250k
Source of Volume Stimulate Demand Steal Share
– America’s Next Top Model: $61k
Position Emphasize Smallness Emphasize Safety, Value
1 exposures per episode
–
Product 24 episodes for Modern;mi for Top Model per
2 year / 24,000 10 3 year / 36,000 mi
Place
season In Mercedes Showroom Standalone Dealership
Total Cost: $6,610,000
Promotion
Total GRPs: 167 on Social Media
Focus More TV & Print ads
63

63.
Questions?
64

64.
Works Cited
http://www.strategicbusinessinsights.com/vals/usframework
.jpg
http://www.iihs.org/ratings/ratingsbyseries.aspx?id=632
http://young-intelligence.com/2011/11/ad-review-smarts-
uncar-campaign/
Interview with Rick Perry, General Manager of Mercedes-
Benz of Bloomfield Hills
Business Plan Handbook
65

65.
SUPPLEMENTAL SLIDES
66

66.
Supplemental Slides
Competing Vehicles Launched Since 2008
Dealership Cost Calculations
GRP Calculations
unBig, unCar spot
Crash test video
67

67.
Must Keep Pace in Increasingly
Competitive Segment
Chevy Cruze Chevy Sonic Fiat 500
Ford Fiesta Kia Forte Kia Soul
Nissan Cube Nissan Leaf Scion iQ
68

68.
Dealership Costs
Currently: 74 dealerships; add 26
Average unit sales for US car dealer: 653
– Smart Car goal: 180 (1500 units/mo. * 12 mo. / 100 dealerships)
27.5% of operation
Dealership Startup Costs: $265k
Average payroll: $2M/yr. * 27.5% = $551k
Source: Business Plans Handbook
69

69.
Dealership Costs
Cost per new dealer = 551k + 265k = $816k
Total Cost (26 new) = 816 * 26 = $21,216,000
70

70.
GRP Calculation
Viewers per episode
Modern: 13.5 million
Model: 4 million
Episodes per season
Modern: 24
Model: 10
18+ citizens of America: 217.8 million
Source: TVbytheNumbers.com
71

71.
GRP Calcuation
GRPs = ∑ reachi × frequencyi
13.5������ 4������
GRPs = ∗ 24 + ∗ 10 = 167.125
217.8������ 217.8������
72