2. Different Emphasis
If you’ve done this week’s reading, you will notice that
this lecture has a different title from the chapter
The chapter title is ‘Differentiated Learners’, and the
chapter focuses on teachers teaching for a subset of
students, which it calls ‘diverse’ or ‘differentiated’
learners
But we are all diverse! ‘Diverse’ means ‘different’, and
none of us are the same as each other
I resist the notion that ‘we’re normal, they’re diverse’
3.
4.
5.
6. Difference, not deficit
While student differences can pose challenges to a
teacher, recognising that all students are diverse, not just
a subset, changes the perspective
As far as possible, student differences should ideally be
seen as a set of resources on which the teacher and the
other students can draw in constructing learning
together
In this process, different students will contribute more at
different times
7. Recognition and Distribution
You’ll remember the tension Nancy Fraser describes,
between recognition and distribution, from last week’s
lecture
Treating all students as diverse, and their differences as
resources, does not mean denying those differences,
identities or challenges
It does not mean ‘treating all students as though they
were the same’
It does mean finding ways to enhance opportunity
8. Thinking about differences
Spend a few moments individually listing as many
differences between students as you can think of (there
will be chocolate for the longest list!)
Now compare your list with the person next to you,
Boggle-style, and add any they have that you missed
and vice versa
Select three particular forms of difference, and with your
partner think of ways to use that difference as a resource
in teaching the whole class
9. Students with Disabilities
(better language than ‘disabled students’)
Some students’ differences will be specific disabilities that
are named and identified: the reading outlines some of
these
Other differences will also make learning more
challenging, but not be identified or supported in the
same ways
Developing specific learning programs and strategies, in
collaboration with support services, is part of teaching
10. Differentiated Instruction
This is a strong interest of Education Queensland and was
part of the recent state-wide Teaching and Learning
audit of all state schools
Differentiation of instruction – different learning activities
for learners with different needs – was in many cases the
weakest dimension on this audit, so the issue is receiving
a lot of attention
It is sometimes understood to mean ‘streaming’ of classes
by ability, but the research evidence shows this is seldom
effective
11. Differentiated Instruction
Differentiating instruction can be difficult to manage as a
teacher: there are likely not to just be 2 or even 3 groups
but many on some dimensions
At the same time it’s an impossible demand on a teacher
to individualise teaching for all students, all the time
It’s also not a fair outcome to require the most able
students to spend all their time helping their less able
fellow students – although it’s valuable for both
sometimes
12. The Classroom as a Learning
Community
There is no easy approach to differentiating instruction
One possible approach is moving away from a model in
which the teacher is the centre and provider of all
learning experiences toward a model of the classroom as
a learning community in which each person bears some
responsibility for his/her own learning and the learning of
her/his classmates
A learning community enhances learner autonomy and
is in line with MYS principles and values