The document summarizes an introduction to urban planning presentation given by Dr. K. Nagayama. It discusses key topics in urban planning including what is required, what issues should be addressed, common planning processes, and notable agenda items. Specific topics covered include urbanization trends, poverty alleviation, economic development strategies, stakeholder engagement, and public-private partnerships. The overall presentation provides an overview of essential concepts in urban planning.
1. Learning Session for UBMPS
Introduction to Urban Planning
July 24, 2007
Dr. K. Nagayama
Deputy Team Leader, JICA Study Team
1
2. Learning Session for UBMPS
Topics
1. What is required by “Urban Planning” ?
2. What should “Urban Planning” address ?
3. What process is needed for “Urban
Planning” ?
4. Some Notable Planning Agenda
2
3. Learning Session for UBMPS
Topics
1. What is required by “Urban Planning” ?
2. What should “Urban Planning” address ?
3. What process is needed for “Urban
Planning” ?
4. Some Notable Planning Agenda
3
5. Learning Session for UBMPS
How to manage “Urbanization”?
• Rapid population increase is taking place
in cities.
• Rural-to-urban Migration is predominant.
• Pull effect (Urban)+ Push effect (Rural)
Urban “bright” or Urban “blight” ?
Urban “bright” or Urban “blight” ?t
ge men
M ana
t h
G row
5
7. Learning Session for UBMPS
Poverty alleviation is a
challenging urban issue.
• Poverty is related to “Employment,
Education, Health, Housing, …….
• Rural economy is a reason of “Being
Poverty”.
• Economic Trickle -down Effect
Planning Target vs. Political Target?
Planning Target vs. Political Target?
t
ge men
M ana
t h
G row
7
8. Learning Session for UBMPS
Economic Trickle -down Effect
Income Level
Peripheral Central Peripheral
8
11. Learning Session for UBMPS
Conceptual Structure of
the National Development
Mineral Resources-
Agriculture-based
based Development
Development
Darkhan
Hovd
Erdenet Choybaisan
Uliastay World City
Undurkhaan
Harhorm
Ulaanbaatar
Agriculture-based
National Development Corridor Choir Development
Reforestation Zuun
Mineral Resources-
based Development
National Growth Corridor
11
12. Learning Session for UBMPS
Topics
1. What is required by “Urban Planning” ?
2. What should “Urban Planning” address ?
3. What process is needed for “Urban
Planning” ?
4. Some Notable Planning Agenda
12
13. Learning Session for UBMPS
Four (4) Principles of Urban Planning
1. Public Benefits first
2. Priority to “Conservation”
3. Keep moving with 4Es (Engineering,
Education, Enforcement)
4. Secure People’s “quality of life”
13
14. Learning Session for UBMPS
Common issues held by cities
1.Lack of sufficient infrastructures and
public service facilities
2.Poor institutions for urban planning and
growth management;
3.Weak financial and tax basis of local
governments;
4.Less coordination and integration among
locally available resources;
5.Less autonomous motivations due to a
centralized resource allocation system.
14
15. Learning Session for UBMPS
Five Planning Issues
• Issues:
– Livability
– Competitiveness
– Bankability
– Good Governance
– Environmental Conservation
15
16. Learning Session for UBMPS
Key Elements for Urban Planning
Physical & Spatial
Structure
(hardware)
Integrated Urban Plan
Institutional & Human Resoruce
Legal Systems Development
(software) (humanware)
16
17. Learning Session for UBMPS
Planning Elements for Sustainable
Urban Growth
1 Economic System Social System 2
for Sustainable Growth for Equitable Growth
3
Environmental Conservation & Management
Environmental Conservation & Management
4 5
Strategic Development Balanced Development
of Leading Metropolitan Cities of Local Cities
17
18. Learning Session for UBMPS
Key Factors/ Elements
to Successful and Meaningful Master Plan
(6) Ownership of
An Institutional Plan
Framework
(2) Strong Local
Leadership
(7) Support of (5) Possibility (1) Local (3) Stakeholder
Donors of Resource Enthusiasm Participation
Mobilization
Donor
Coordination
(4) Capacity
Realistic Rationalized
Building
Planning and Plan & Planning
Management Process
Framework
18
19. Learning Session for UBMPS
Contents of Urban Master Plan
1. Urban Planning Policy (Goals and Missions)
2. Urban Land Use & Zoning
3. Transport System & Structure
4. Urban Infrastructure and Utilities
5. Housing and Living Conditions
6. Urban Environment and Disaster Management
7. Urban Growth Management and Governance
8. Financial Capacity Strengthening
19
20. Learning Session for UBMPS
Topics
1. What is required by “Urban Planning” ?
2. What should “Urban Planning” address ?
3. What process is needed for “Urban
Planning” ?
4. Some Notable Planning Agenda
20
21. Learning Session for UBMPS
Strategic Planning
Process
1. Where are we now?
(Diagnostic Analysis, Comparative
advantages)
2. Where would we like to be?
(Future Visions)
3. What issues do we need to address?
(Formuationo of Projects/Programs)
4. What action must we take to get there?
(Prioritization, Implementation Programming)
21
22. Learning Session for UBMPS
Rationales of Planning Process
Status
Status
Analysi
Analysi
ss Visioning
Visioning
SWOT
Analysi
s Programmin
Future Demand Programmin
Forecast g
g
Development Prioritization
Prioritization
Framework
Cost Estimate Action
Action
Planning
Planning
Cost-Benefit Analysis
Financial Scheduling
22
23. Learning Session for UBMPS
Strategic Planning Approach…
2. Visioning
3. Strategy Building Vision
Strategic Path
1. Status Analysis
Present
Situation
2015 2030
23
24. Learning Session for UBMPS
Stakeholders Workshops Leader’s
City
Initiation
Conceptualization
lessons
View-exchange
Group Presentation
24
25. Learning Session for UBMPS
Setting of Planning Goals
For up-lifting people’s quality of life
More smooth
More smooth
Livable Housing
Livable Housing
people’s mobility
people’s mobility Ulaanbaatar
Ulaanbaatar
!!
Urban Visions
Urban Visions
Help the poor !!
Help the poor Environment-
Environment-
conscious !!
conscious
25
26. Learning Session for UBMPS
Issues and Measures of Urban
Planning Planning Issues
Urban
Issues of Urban Planning
1. Create “Livable City” for All Public Transport System
2. Achieve sustainable and Land Use Zoning
competitive economic
growth Road Transport Network
3. Strengthen the municipal Industries, Business,
financing capacity Tourism & FRI Inducement
4. Assure Environmental ICT and Urban Utilities
Conservation
New Taxation and Laws
5. Prepare legal Framework
for Growth Management & Alleviation of Environmental
Good Governance Pollution
26
27. Learning Session for UBMPS
Topics
1. What is required by “Urban Planning” ?
2. What should “Urban Planning” address ?
3. What process is needed for “Urban
Planning” ?
4. Some Notable Planning Agenda
27
28. Learning Session for UBMPS
Demand-Supply Gap Fulfillment
Service
Capacity/Volume Supply Schedule A
Supply Schedule B
Shortage/Congestion
Over-supply/Investment Risk
Demand Curve
2007 2015 2020 2030
28
29. Learning Session for UBMPS
Public Transport Modal Hierarchy
Applicable Modes and Systems
60,000+
CAPACITY (Persons/hr/Lane)
50,000
Mass Rapid Transit
40,000
30,000
Light Rail
20,000
Transit
Bus Priority
10,000 Tramway
Bus in
Monorail
Mixed Traffic
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
29
OPERATING SPEED (km/hr)
30. Learning Session for UBMPS
Multimodal Cargo Transport
and Unit Load System
Unit Unit Unit
Factory B Factory B Factory C
Truck in Unit Truck in Unit
Station
Railway in Unit
Port / Airport
Airplane in Unit
Port / Airport
Railway in Unit
Truck in Unit
Station
Unit
Unit Truck in Unit
Customer B
Customer A 30
31. Learning Session for UBMPS
The Global Trend of Containerization,
Globalization & Standardization
Packaged in
Standardized Units
Container
Each Cargo Item
Standardized International
Transport
Transported
as Unit
Vessel
Train Truck 31 Airplane
32. Learning Session for UBMPS
What is PPP?
• Establish partnership with commercial
market, Government & communities
→ From Vertical Relation to Horizontal Relation
• Facilitate business sector’s participation
→ Deepen Communication with Stakeholders of
Development
• Re-define government’s roles for social and
economic development
→ Adopt new positive “Social Welfare Policy ”
32
33. Learning Session for UBMPS
Government’s functions shifting from
providing public services itself towards
becoming a “manager of the providers” ….
PPP
PPP Concept
Part of Capital PFI
Investment
Privatization Joint Venture
Overall Management
Outsourcing Sales
Leaseback
Part of Capital Concession
Investment Wider Market
Operation & Initiative
Maintenance
u P % 01
i r P % 01
0
0
33
34. Learning Session for UBMPS
VFM Maximization by PPP
Conventional
Public Initiative PPP
NPV VFM
Public Spending
Risk Cost
Repair/Renewal Cost Project Formation Cost
Total Payment for
Operation/Maintenance
Service Charges
Cost
Construction Cost
34
35. Learning Session for UBMPS
How to promote it ?
Mongolia
Mongolia
Mongolian Gov. Partnership Private Sector
Improve Investment Money,
Environment through Deregulation Technology &
Dialogue Human Resource
Japanese Gov. Partnership
Private Sector
Japan
Japan
35
36. Learning Session for UBMPS
Let’s remind four (4) principles of Urban Planning …
• Public Benefits first
• Priority to “Conservation”
• Keep moving with 4Es
(Engineering, Education,
Enforcement)
• Secure People’s “quality of life”
Thank you ..
36
世界都市 森林再生 資源開発 国土軸 世界都市 国土開発軸 A reforestation exploitation of resources country axis world city Country development axis
We facilitate discussions in this manner in the stakeholder workshops. First, where are we now? This is important question to recognize the reality of the situation of their city. For this question, we, the consultant team provided diagnostic analysis and comparative advantages. The second question is where would we like to be? This calls for participants’ visioning their city in the future. This question is rather difficult to clearly answer. The third question is what issues do we need to address? Since the participants are facing some problems in their city lives, they can easily demonstrate their project ideas. However, the most difficult question is the next one: What action must we take to get there? At present, we are progressing up to the third question.
One of the major changes taking place today is the shift of government functions from the historic “provider” of public services to the “manager of providers” of public services . Taking into consideration the financial viability dominated by inherent characteristics of rail transit development versus government’s limited fiscal situation, URMAP recommended to adopt a PPP-based delivery system. In the system, public sector should share part of initial costs and remain responsible for overall project management, whilst private sector should share the remaining costs for completing the system, and operate and maintain the system after completion. The basic rationale for this change is that when properly implemented, it results in significant benefits, in terms of improved performance and lower costs, to both the government and to the public being serviced. Essentially, it is a shift from a monopoly government provider to a competitive environment. PPP is a broader concept covering PFI, Privatization, Outsourcing, Concession, Joint Venture, Sales Leaseback, Wider Market Initiative , etc. However, what I am presenting is the concept more akin to PFI in UK.
Here, I will touch on the VFM maximization by PPP. Obviously, VFM implies the value of public services against the tax money input . More specifically, VFM is measured as the difference of probable total public spending between the two implementation cases under conventional public initiative and PPP. The former public spending is measured as Public Sector Comparators - PSC in terms of Net Present Value, including risk cost, repair / renewal cost, operation / maintenance cost, and construction cost. Whilst, the latter public spending is measured as Life Cycle Cost - LCC in terms of Net present Value, including project formation cost and total service charges. The difference between PSC and LCC is VFM. According to the experiences in UK, average 15 to 17 percent of VFM was produced from the application of PFI.