SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 14
LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT STORMWATER APPROACH Overcoming Barriers to Implementation
Brickyard Park and Ride May 2009	 June 2010 Project is a 200 stall expansion of an existing King County Metro Park and Ride lot located in unincorporated King County.
Stormwater Management Approach Pervious asphalt pavement with distributed detention storage in shallow arch-pipe system.  Biofiltration swale for WQ treatment. n
Topography and Groundwater
Brickyard: Drainage Section Arch pipe detention system section
60% Design Cost Comparison Cost Savings = $88,000 or 3.8% of Construction Cost Cost Assumptions: Subtract 8 CBs and 630 LF of 12-inch pipe Decrease detention storage by about ½ or 16,000 cubic feet Decrease earthwork cut and haul (due to less detention storage) Add washed crushed base course material
Construction
Paving Day – August 28, 2009
Completed Paving
When Something Goes Wrong
Repairs
Common Barriers to Use of LID	 Unfamiliarity Design team, permitting agency, owner, contractor, etc. Do you have public support for your ROW project?  Site limitations (soils, slopes, high groundwater, etc.) Cost (perceived and/or real) Local code limitations  Risk/Liability (both to owner and design team)
Risk Mitigation Take Advantage of Continuing Professional Education LID Certification Classes are offered locally Webinars – Contract Language/Risk Management Attend Professional Conferences – ASCE International Conference on LID Start Small to Build Confidence and Experience Seek Highly Collaborative Project Teams LID methods require an understanding of natural systems that include the surrounding ecology, soil, and plant communities.  This requires close collaboration of people across disciplines (architect, civil,  geotech, landscape architect, environmental scientist, etc.)     Partner with suppliers and builders early in design to increase success
Amie Broadsword, PE, LEED AP amieb@paceengrs.com 425-827-2014 A Special Thank You to Today’s Sponsors!

More Related Content

What's hot

MacDonald Dan Oct 1 2014 [1130 am Session A] TAC 2014 Montreal [Compat...
MacDonald Dan   Oct 1  2014 [1130 am  Session A]   TAC 2014  Montreal [Compat...MacDonald Dan   Oct 1  2014 [1130 am  Session A]   TAC 2014  Montreal [Compat...
MacDonald Dan Oct 1 2014 [1130 am Session A] TAC 2014 Montreal [Compat...Dan MacDonald, P.Eng.
 
The Trajectories of Large Scale Landfills and their International Counterparts
The Trajectories of Large Scale Landfills and their International CounterpartsThe Trajectories of Large Scale Landfills and their International Counterparts
The Trajectories of Large Scale Landfills and their International CounterpartsCircular Economy Asia
 
Glenwood Forest Tank Replacement Project
Glenwood Forest Tank Replacement ProjectGlenwood Forest Tank Replacement Project
Glenwood Forest Tank Replacement Projectglenwood94901
 
Ua green initiatives
Ua green initiativesUa green initiatives
Ua green initiativesEllieNowels
 
Dimension system-hosts-colony-of-cranes
Dimension system-hosts-colony-of-cranesDimension system-hosts-colony-of-cranes
Dimension system-hosts-colony-of-cranesTensar
 
Sp3 v6 Ladd Arbortetum Multiuse Trail 2014 02-17 council presentation ladd
Sp3 v6 Ladd Arbortetum Multiuse Trail 2014 02-17 council presentation laddSp3 v6 Ladd Arbortetum Multiuse Trail 2014 02-17 council presentation ladd
Sp3 v6 Ladd Arbortetum Multiuse Trail 2014 02-17 council presentation laddcityofevanston
 
Riu Explorers Conference
Riu Explorers ConferenceRiu Explorers Conference
Riu Explorers Conferenceajstocks
 
Tx cs pa_4_mile_3.12
Tx cs pa_4_mile_3.12Tx cs pa_4_mile_3.12
Tx cs pa_4_mile_3.12Tensar
 
High Peak BC Allotments update July 2013
High Peak BC Allotments update July 2013High Peak BC Allotments update July 2013
High Peak BC Allotments update July 2013Anthony Mckeown
 
ARM Casper case study-LR
ARM Casper case study-LRARM Casper case study-LR
ARM Casper case study-LRNeil McCarthy
 
April 12 Planning Public Forum
April 12 Planning Public ForumApril 12 Planning Public Forum
April 12 Planning Public Forumpublicinvolvement
 
Item #9 ppt - intent to develop - 220 grove
Item #9   ppt - intent to develop - 220 groveItem #9   ppt - intent to develop - 220 grove
Item #9 ppt - intent to develop - 220 groveMarian Vargas Mendoza
 
Revitalization of Old Fields by Leta Smith
Revitalization of Old Fields by Leta SmithRevitalization of Old Fields by Leta Smith
Revitalization of Old Fields by Leta SmithDaniel Matranga
 
Session 3 - Michael Berna Indiana Logistics Summit 2012
Session 3 - Michael Berna Indiana Logistics Summit 2012Session 3 - Michael Berna Indiana Logistics Summit 2012
Session 3 - Michael Berna Indiana Logistics Summit 2012Fred Davidson
 

What's hot (19)

MacDonald Dan Oct 1 2014 [1130 am Session A] TAC 2014 Montreal [Compat...
MacDonald Dan   Oct 1  2014 [1130 am  Session A]   TAC 2014  Montreal [Compat...MacDonald Dan   Oct 1  2014 [1130 am  Session A]   TAC 2014  Montreal [Compat...
MacDonald Dan Oct 1 2014 [1130 am Session A] TAC 2014 Montreal [Compat...
 
The Trajectories of Large Scale Landfills and their International Counterparts
The Trajectories of Large Scale Landfills and their International CounterpartsThe Trajectories of Large Scale Landfills and their International Counterparts
The Trajectories of Large Scale Landfills and their International Counterparts
 
Life cycle pcsm for well pads
Life cycle pcsm for well padsLife cycle pcsm for well pads
Life cycle pcsm for well pads
 
Thomas Pool Options
Thomas Pool OptionsThomas Pool Options
Thomas Pool Options
 
Glenwood Forest Tank Replacement Project
Glenwood Forest Tank Replacement ProjectGlenwood Forest Tank Replacement Project
Glenwood Forest Tank Replacement Project
 
Ua green initiatives
Ua green initiativesUa green initiatives
Ua green initiatives
 
Dimension system-hosts-colony-of-cranes
Dimension system-hosts-colony-of-cranesDimension system-hosts-colony-of-cranes
Dimension system-hosts-colony-of-cranes
 
Sp3 v6 Ladd Arbortetum Multiuse Trail 2014 02-17 council presentation ladd
Sp3 v6 Ladd Arbortetum Multiuse Trail 2014 02-17 council presentation laddSp3 v6 Ladd Arbortetum Multiuse Trail 2014 02-17 council presentation ladd
Sp3 v6 Ladd Arbortetum Multiuse Trail 2014 02-17 council presentation ladd
 
Bee Creek Sewer Line
Bee Creek Sewer LineBee Creek Sewer Line
Bee Creek Sewer Line
 
Crossrail-C336-Paddington-New-Yard
Crossrail-C336-Paddington-New-YardCrossrail-C336-Paddington-New-Yard
Crossrail-C336-Paddington-New-Yard
 
Yashar Pourang Portfolio
Yashar Pourang Portfolio Yashar Pourang Portfolio
Yashar Pourang Portfolio
 
Riu Explorers Conference
Riu Explorers ConferenceRiu Explorers Conference
Riu Explorers Conference
 
Tx cs pa_4_mile_3.12
Tx cs pa_4_mile_3.12Tx cs pa_4_mile_3.12
Tx cs pa_4_mile_3.12
 
High Peak BC Allotments update July 2013
High Peak BC Allotments update July 2013High Peak BC Allotments update July 2013
High Peak BC Allotments update July 2013
 
ARM Casper case study-LR
ARM Casper case study-LRARM Casper case study-LR
ARM Casper case study-LR
 
April 12 Planning Public Forum
April 12 Planning Public ForumApril 12 Planning Public Forum
April 12 Planning Public Forum
 
Item #9 ppt - intent to develop - 220 grove
Item #9   ppt - intent to develop - 220 groveItem #9   ppt - intent to develop - 220 grove
Item #9 ppt - intent to develop - 220 grove
 
Revitalization of Old Fields by Leta Smith
Revitalization of Old Fields by Leta SmithRevitalization of Old Fields by Leta Smith
Revitalization of Old Fields by Leta Smith
 
Session 3 - Michael Berna Indiana Logistics Summit 2012
Session 3 - Michael Berna Indiana Logistics Summit 2012Session 3 - Michael Berna Indiana Logistics Summit 2012
Session 3 - Michael Berna Indiana Logistics Summit 2012
 

Viewers also liked

Birmingham park-and-ride-lots
Birmingham park-and-ride-lotsBirmingham park-and-ride-lots
Birmingham park-and-ride-lotsMagic City Post
 
Stringfellow Park and Ride Expansion
Stringfellow Park and Ride ExpansionStringfellow Park and Ride Expansion
Stringfellow Park and Ride ExpansionFairfax County
 
METRO Park-and-Ride Survey Presentation (Daniel Christen Graduate Thesis/Appl...
METRO Park-and-Ride Survey Presentation (Daniel Christen Graduate Thesis/Appl...METRO Park-and-Ride Survey Presentation (Daniel Christen Graduate Thesis/Appl...
METRO Park-and-Ride Survey Presentation (Daniel Christen Graduate Thesis/Appl...djchristen
 
Integrating Green Infrastructure into Regional Planning
Integrating Green Infrastructure into Regional PlanningIntegrating Green Infrastructure into Regional Planning
Integrating Green Infrastructure into Regional PlanningTranspo Group
 
TMC Boards to PNR Counts
TMC Boards to PNR CountsTMC Boards to PNR Counts
TMC Boards to PNR CountsAndrew Rohne
 
RV 2014: HSR for Midsize Cities: TOD Lessons from Near and Far by Eric Eidlin
RV 2014: HSR for Midsize Cities: TOD Lessons from Near and Far by Eric EidlinRV 2014: HSR for Midsize Cities: TOD Lessons from Near and Far by Eric Eidlin
RV 2014: HSR for Midsize Cities: TOD Lessons from Near and Far by Eric EidlinRail~Volution
 
RV 2015: Sustainable Corridors: Broad and Specific Looks by David Leard, AICP
RV 2015: Sustainable Corridors: Broad and Specific Looks by David Leard, AICPRV 2015: Sustainable Corridors: Broad and Specific Looks by David Leard, AICP
RV 2015: Sustainable Corridors: Broad and Specific Looks by David Leard, AICPRail~Volution
 
My pnr introduction
My pnr introductionMy pnr introduction
My pnr introductionixigo.com
 
Lesson 9 Optional PNR elements
Lesson 9 Optional PNR elementsLesson 9 Optional PNR elements
Lesson 9 Optional PNR elementsAngelina Njegus
 
An independent view of transport
An independent view of transportAn independent view of transport
An independent view of transportSKM Colin Buchanan
 

Viewers also liked (11)

Birmingham park-and-ride-lots
Birmingham park-and-ride-lotsBirmingham park-and-ride-lots
Birmingham park-and-ride-lots
 
Stringfellow Park and Ride Expansion
Stringfellow Park and Ride ExpansionStringfellow Park and Ride Expansion
Stringfellow Park and Ride Expansion
 
METRO Park-and-Ride Survey Presentation (Daniel Christen Graduate Thesis/Appl...
METRO Park-and-Ride Survey Presentation (Daniel Christen Graduate Thesis/Appl...METRO Park-and-Ride Survey Presentation (Daniel Christen Graduate Thesis/Appl...
METRO Park-and-Ride Survey Presentation (Daniel Christen Graduate Thesis/Appl...
 
Integrating Green Infrastructure into Regional Planning
Integrating Green Infrastructure into Regional PlanningIntegrating Green Infrastructure into Regional Planning
Integrating Green Infrastructure into Regional Planning
 
TMC Boards to PNR Counts
TMC Boards to PNR CountsTMC Boards to PNR Counts
TMC Boards to PNR Counts
 
my VMT paper
my VMT papermy VMT paper
my VMT paper
 
RV 2014: HSR for Midsize Cities: TOD Lessons from Near and Far by Eric Eidlin
RV 2014: HSR for Midsize Cities: TOD Lessons from Near and Far by Eric EidlinRV 2014: HSR for Midsize Cities: TOD Lessons from Near and Far by Eric Eidlin
RV 2014: HSR for Midsize Cities: TOD Lessons from Near and Far by Eric Eidlin
 
RV 2015: Sustainable Corridors: Broad and Specific Looks by David Leard, AICP
RV 2015: Sustainable Corridors: Broad and Specific Looks by David Leard, AICPRV 2015: Sustainable Corridors: Broad and Specific Looks by David Leard, AICP
RV 2015: Sustainable Corridors: Broad and Specific Looks by David Leard, AICP
 
My pnr introduction
My pnr introductionMy pnr introduction
My pnr introduction
 
Lesson 9 Optional PNR elements
Lesson 9 Optional PNR elementsLesson 9 Optional PNR elements
Lesson 9 Optional PNR elements
 
An independent view of transport
An independent view of transportAn independent view of transport
An independent view of transport
 

Similar to Lid Stormwater Approach: Overcoming Barriers to Implementation

Wilma Dykeman Riverway Road Intersection Re-modernization
Wilma Dykeman Riverway  Road Intersection Re-modernizationWilma Dykeman Riverway  Road Intersection Re-modernization
Wilma Dykeman Riverway Road Intersection Re-modernizationMsplcdYkee69
 
Presentation-Orange-County-Great-Park-Storm-Water-Reuse-Pond-System-June-2014
Presentation-Orange-County-Great-Park-Storm-Water-Reuse-Pond-System-June-2014Presentation-Orange-County-Great-Park-Storm-Water-Reuse-Pond-System-June-2014
Presentation-Orange-County-Great-Park-Storm-Water-Reuse-Pond-System-June-2014Joseph Merzlak
 
APR 23 10 LIVING WITH LID [Compatibility Mode]
APR 23 10 LIVING WITH LID [Compatibility Mode]APR 23 10 LIVING WITH LID [Compatibility Mode]
APR 23 10 LIVING WITH LID [Compatibility Mode]Mike Campbell, AICP, CPSWQ
 
2011 6 14 Home Builders of MD Environmental Site Design Introduction
2011 6 14 Home Builders of MD Environmental Site Design Introduction2011 6 14 Home Builders of MD Environmental Site Design Introduction
2011 6 14 Home Builders of MD Environmental Site Design IntroductionTheodore Scott
 
Kenworth Trucks saving water case study
Kenworth Trucks saving water case studyKenworth Trucks saving water case study
Kenworth Trucks saving water case studyNEXTDC
 
Rainwater Harvesting For Decision Makers
Rainwater Harvesting For Decision MakersRainwater Harvesting For Decision Makers
Rainwater Harvesting For Decision MakersVictor Zapanta Manlapaz
 
Waterman Drainage Project
Waterman Drainage ProjectWaterman Drainage Project
Waterman Drainage ProjectAndrew Motycka
 
Senior Design Capstone Presentation
Senior Design Capstone PresentationSenior Design Capstone Presentation
Senior Design Capstone Presentationfinkjosh
 
Economics of upgrading a gravel road to Otta seal surface
Economics of upgrading a gravel road to Otta seal surfaceEconomics of upgrading a gravel road to Otta seal surface
Economics of upgrading a gravel road to Otta seal surfaceAliNahvi
 
res_kevin_gagne 2016 update FINAL
res_kevin_gagne 2016 update FINALres_kevin_gagne 2016 update FINAL
res_kevin_gagne 2016 update FINALkevingg
 
NJ Future Redevelopment Forum 2017 Cammarata
NJ Future Redevelopment Forum 2017 CammarataNJ Future Redevelopment Forum 2017 Cammarata
NJ Future Redevelopment Forum 2017 CammarataNew Jersey Future
 
VGBC Online Series, Phần 9: Địa điểm và Sinh thái trong Công trình xanh
VGBC Online Series, Phần 9: Địa điểm và Sinh thái trong Công trình xanhVGBC Online Series, Phần 9: Địa điểm và Sinh thái trong Công trình xanh
VGBC Online Series, Phần 9: Địa điểm và Sinh thái trong Công trình xanhVietnam Green Building Council
 
Proposal to reclaim Chicago's lakefront from the highway using immersed tunnels
Proposal to reclaim Chicago's lakefront from the highway using immersed tunnelsProposal to reclaim Chicago's lakefront from the highway using immersed tunnels
Proposal to reclaim Chicago's lakefront from the highway using immersed tunnelsJames Chuck
 
Предимствата на вакуумни канализационни системи
Предимствата на вакуумни канализационни системиПредимствата на вакуумни канализационни системи
Предимствата на вакуумни канализационни системиEmil Hristov
 
IRJET - Design of Improved Drainage System using Pervious Concrete
IRJET  -  	  Design of Improved Drainage System using Pervious ConcreteIRJET  -  	  Design of Improved Drainage System using Pervious Concrete
IRJET - Design of Improved Drainage System using Pervious ConcreteIRJET Journal
 
Charlie Hall Boddingtons Pwpnt Presentation 4 9 2010
Charlie Hall Boddingtons Pwpnt Presentation 4 9 2010Charlie Hall Boddingtons Pwpnt Presentation 4 9 2010
Charlie Hall Boddingtons Pwpnt Presentation 4 9 2010Charles W. "Charlie"​ Hall
 
Urban Planning Design Considerations for Better Water Quality, Bill Hunt NC S...
Urban Planning Design Considerations for Better Water Quality, Bill Hunt NC S...Urban Planning Design Considerations for Better Water Quality, Bill Hunt NC S...
Urban Planning Design Considerations for Better Water Quality, Bill Hunt NC S...Fu Michael Justin
 

Similar to Lid Stormwater Approach: Overcoming Barriers to Implementation (20)

Acf environmental 2016 apwa fl expo - integrated infrastructure-an innovati...
Acf environmental   2016 apwa fl expo - integrated infrastructure-an innovati...Acf environmental   2016 apwa fl expo - integrated infrastructure-an innovati...
Acf environmental 2016 apwa fl expo - integrated infrastructure-an innovati...
 
Nykilde geoweb channel protection design package
Nykilde geoweb channel protection design packageNykilde geoweb channel protection design package
Nykilde geoweb channel protection design package
 
Wilma Dykeman Riverway Road Intersection Re-modernization
Wilma Dykeman Riverway  Road Intersection Re-modernizationWilma Dykeman Riverway  Road Intersection Re-modernization
Wilma Dykeman Riverway Road Intersection Re-modernization
 
Presentation-Orange-County-Great-Park-Storm-Water-Reuse-Pond-System-June-2014
Presentation-Orange-County-Great-Park-Storm-Water-Reuse-Pond-System-June-2014Presentation-Orange-County-Great-Park-Storm-Water-Reuse-Pond-System-June-2014
Presentation-Orange-County-Great-Park-Storm-Water-Reuse-Pond-System-June-2014
 
APR 23 10 LIVING WITH LID [Compatibility Mode]
APR 23 10 LIVING WITH LID [Compatibility Mode]APR 23 10 LIVING WITH LID [Compatibility Mode]
APR 23 10 LIVING WITH LID [Compatibility Mode]
 
2011 6 14 Home Builders of MD Environmental Site Design Introduction
2011 6 14 Home Builders of MD Environmental Site Design Introduction2011 6 14 Home Builders of MD Environmental Site Design Introduction
2011 6 14 Home Builders of MD Environmental Site Design Introduction
 
Nykilde geoweb load support design package
Nykilde geoweb load support design packageNykilde geoweb load support design package
Nykilde geoweb load support design package
 
Kenworth Trucks saving water case study
Kenworth Trucks saving water case studyKenworth Trucks saving water case study
Kenworth Trucks saving water case study
 
Rainwater Harvesting For Decision Makers
Rainwater Harvesting For Decision MakersRainwater Harvesting For Decision Makers
Rainwater Harvesting For Decision Makers
 
Waterman Drainage Project
Waterman Drainage ProjectWaterman Drainage Project
Waterman Drainage Project
 
Senior Design Capstone Presentation
Senior Design Capstone PresentationSenior Design Capstone Presentation
Senior Design Capstone Presentation
 
Economics of upgrading a gravel road to Otta seal surface
Economics of upgrading a gravel road to Otta seal surfaceEconomics of upgrading a gravel road to Otta seal surface
Economics of upgrading a gravel road to Otta seal surface
 
res_kevin_gagne 2016 update FINAL
res_kevin_gagne 2016 update FINALres_kevin_gagne 2016 update FINAL
res_kevin_gagne 2016 update FINAL
 
NJ Future Redevelopment Forum 2017 Cammarata
NJ Future Redevelopment Forum 2017 CammarataNJ Future Redevelopment Forum 2017 Cammarata
NJ Future Redevelopment Forum 2017 Cammarata
 
VGBC Online Series, Phần 9: Địa điểm và Sinh thái trong Công trình xanh
VGBC Online Series, Phần 9: Địa điểm và Sinh thái trong Công trình xanhVGBC Online Series, Phần 9: Địa điểm và Sinh thái trong Công trình xanh
VGBC Online Series, Phần 9: Địa điểm và Sinh thái trong Công trình xanh
 
Proposal to reclaim Chicago's lakefront from the highway using immersed tunnels
Proposal to reclaim Chicago's lakefront from the highway using immersed tunnelsProposal to reclaim Chicago's lakefront from the highway using immersed tunnels
Proposal to reclaim Chicago's lakefront from the highway using immersed tunnels
 
Предимствата на вакуумни канализационни системи
Предимствата на вакуумни канализационни системиПредимствата на вакуумни канализационни системи
Предимствата на вакуумни канализационни системи
 
IRJET - Design of Improved Drainage System using Pervious Concrete
IRJET  -  	  Design of Improved Drainage System using Pervious ConcreteIRJET  -  	  Design of Improved Drainage System using Pervious Concrete
IRJET - Design of Improved Drainage System using Pervious Concrete
 
Charlie Hall Boddingtons Pwpnt Presentation 4 9 2010
Charlie Hall Boddingtons Pwpnt Presentation 4 9 2010Charlie Hall Boddingtons Pwpnt Presentation 4 9 2010
Charlie Hall Boddingtons Pwpnt Presentation 4 9 2010
 
Urban Planning Design Considerations for Better Water Quality, Bill Hunt NC S...
Urban Planning Design Considerations for Better Water Quality, Bill Hunt NC S...Urban Planning Design Considerations for Better Water Quality, Bill Hunt NC S...
Urban Planning Design Considerations for Better Water Quality, Bill Hunt NC S...
 

Lid Stormwater Approach: Overcoming Barriers to Implementation

  • 1. LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT STORMWATER APPROACH Overcoming Barriers to Implementation
  • 2. Brickyard Park and Ride May 2009 June 2010 Project is a 200 stall expansion of an existing King County Metro Park and Ride lot located in unincorporated King County.
  • 3. Stormwater Management Approach Pervious asphalt pavement with distributed detention storage in shallow arch-pipe system. Biofiltration swale for WQ treatment. n
  • 5. Brickyard: Drainage Section Arch pipe detention system section
  • 6. 60% Design Cost Comparison Cost Savings = $88,000 or 3.8% of Construction Cost Cost Assumptions: Subtract 8 CBs and 630 LF of 12-inch pipe Decrease detention storage by about ½ or 16,000 cubic feet Decrease earthwork cut and haul (due to less detention storage) Add washed crushed base course material
  • 8. Paving Day – August 28, 2009
  • 12. Common Barriers to Use of LID Unfamiliarity Design team, permitting agency, owner, contractor, etc. Do you have public support for your ROW project? Site limitations (soils, slopes, high groundwater, etc.) Cost (perceived and/or real) Local code limitations Risk/Liability (both to owner and design team)
  • 13. Risk Mitigation Take Advantage of Continuing Professional Education LID Certification Classes are offered locally Webinars – Contract Language/Risk Management Attend Professional Conferences – ASCE International Conference on LID Start Small to Build Confidence and Experience Seek Highly Collaborative Project Teams LID methods require an understanding of natural systems that include the surrounding ecology, soil, and plant communities. This requires close collaboration of people across disciplines (architect, civil, geotech, landscape architect, environmental scientist, etc.) Partner with suppliers and builders early in design to increase success
  • 14. Amie Broadsword, PE, LEED AP amieb@paceengrs.com 425-827-2014 A Special Thank You to Today’s Sponsors!

Editor's Notes

  1. Compaction was a major concern over the entire lot. Contractor was instructed to keep 1-ft minimum of soil above final grading until ready to install detention and pavement in order to preserve infiltrative capacity of underlying soils.