SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 12
AMUL VS IMUL TRADEMARK CASE STUDY
• Sit Dolor Amet
AMUL VS IMUL TRADEMARK CASE STUDY
TRADEMARK
A trademark is a sign capable of distinguishing the goods or
services of one enterprise from those of other enterprises.
Trademarks are protected by intellectual property rights. The
symbols ™ (the trademark symbol) and ® (the registered
trademark symbol) can be used to indicate trademarks; the
latter is only for use by the owner of a trademark that has been
registered.
TRADEMARKS ACT ,1999
• The Trade Marks Registry was established in India in 1940 and presently it
administers the Trade Marks Act, 1999 and the rules there under.
• It acts as a resource and information center and is a facilitator in matters relating to
trade marks in the country.
• The objective of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 is to register trade marks applied for in
the country and to provide for better protection of trade mark for goods and services
and also to prevent fraudulent use of the mark.
• The main function of the Registry is to register trade marks which qualifies for
registration under the Act and Rules.
USAGE OF TRADEMARK
• A trademark identifies the brand owner of a particular
product or service.
• The owner of a trademark may pursue legal
action against trademark infringement. Most countries
require formal trademark registration as a precondition
for pursuing this type of action. The United States,
Canada, and other countries also recognize common
law trademark rights, which means action can be
taken to protect any unregistered trademark if it is in
use. Still, common law trademarks offer to the holder,
in general, less legal protection than registered
trademarks.
TRADEMARK
INFRINGEMENT
• Trademark infringement is the unauthorized use of a
trademark or service mark on or in connection with
goods and/or services in a manner that is likely to
cause confusion, deception, or mistake about the
source of the goods and/or services.
• Amul is an Indian dairy cooperative society, based at Anand in Gujarat . Formed in 1946, it is a
cooperative brand managed by the Gujarat Cooperative Milk Marketing Federation Ltd. (GCMMF),
which today is jointly controlled by 36 lakh(3.6 million) milk producers in Gujarat, and the apex body of
13 district milk unions, spread across 13,000 villages of Gujarat. Amul spurred India’s White
Revolution, which made the country the world's largest producer of milk and milk products.
• Kaira Union introduced the brand “Amul” for marketing its product range. The word “Amul” is derived
from Sanskrit word ‘Amulya’ which means ‘priceless’ or precious, a name proposed by then founding
leader of Agriculture College, Maganbhai Patel.
• The Amul model : The Amul model of dairy development is a three -tiered structure with the dairy
cooperative societies at the village level federated under a milk Union at the district level and a
Federation of member Union at the state level.
IMUL - A milk producer’s co-operative union in West Bengal, which
sought to market a brand of milk.
• ‘Ichhamati Co-operative Milk Producers’ Union Limited (IMUL) filed an application for registration of the mark ‘IMUL’ (depicted
in a triangular shape) (Application No. 1281174) under class 29 (milk goods and other dairy products) of the Trademarks Act,
1999.
• After the advertisement of this application, Kaira District Co-Operative Milk Producers’ Union Limited (appellant) opposed
registration of the trademark.
• The opposition was based on the ground that the appellant was carrying on a well established business of manufacturing,
marketing and exporting milk products under the name AMUL since 1955.
THE DISPUTE
APPELLANT – AMUL
RESPONDENT- IMUL
 By virtue of its long, continuous and extensive use of the trademark, it was contended that
the public now associated ‘AMUL’ with the appellant’s products. Therefore, the respondent’s
adoption of the mark IMUL would cause confusion among the public and in the trade as it
was deceptively similar to the appellant’s trademark.
 The registrar, however, found that the respondent’s adoption of the mark IMUL was honest
and was not deceptively similar.
 The decision was based on the fact that the respondent had been using this mark since 2001
and its turnover had increased continuously since then.
 According to the registrar, refusal of registration would cause unnecessary inconvenience and
damage to the respondents.
THE DECISION
 After perusing several cases, the Intellectual Property Appellate Board , IPAB held that a
statement showing increase in sales turnover (by way of affidavit) was no ground to grant
registration of a trademark that was deceptively similar to AMUL’s trademark.
 It was held that the mark (IMUL) was phonetically similar to AMUL, except for the first letter ‘A’
and ‘I’.
 Against this order, the appellant appealed to IPAB (Circuit Bench, Kolkata).
 Despite notice, the respondents did not appear before the IPAB nor did they file counter
statements.
 The IPAB decided the matter in favour of AMUL ex parte. The order of the IPAB (No. 34 of 2013)
is available.
 The IPAB used the test of “an unwary purchaser with average intelligence and imperfect recollection”
to show that phonetically similar marks are likely to cause confusion among such purchasers.
 Moreover, case law showed that AMUL had become a household name and the appellant had been
successful, in the past, in restraining others from using its registered trademark.
 The board comprising Vice-Chairman S. Usha and member V. Ravi said: “The marks are no doubt
phonetically similar, except for first letters a and i . When we consider the marks to be deceptively
similar, the possibility of confusion is certain. The trademark, therefore, shall not proceed to
registration.”
 Also, since the respondents did not appear before the IPAB to prove the use of the mark IMUL since
2001 and give reasons for adopting the same, the IPAB held that AMUL was a well known mark and
the registration of a deceptively similar mark ought not to have been allowed. Therefore, the order
was set aside.
IPR PPT.pptx

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Surrender and Revocation of Patents
Surrender and Revocation of PatentsSurrender and Revocation of Patents
Surrender and Revocation of PatentsDVSResearchFoundatio
 
The rights and limitations of patentee ppt
The rights and limitations of patentee pptThe rights and limitations of patentee ppt
The rights and limitations of patentee pptPUTTU GURU PRASAD
 
Moot memorial
Moot memorialMoot memorial
Moot memorialAnkit Sha
 
Trademark ppt by-pooja gurwani
Trademark ppt by-pooja gurwaniTrademark ppt by-pooja gurwani
Trademark ppt by-pooja gurwaniPooja Gurwani
 
Intellectual Property Rights
Intellectual Property Rights Intellectual Property Rights
Intellectual Property Rights CK Raju
 
International ipr
International iprInternational ipr
International iprVijay Vj
 
TM Infringement- Rajeev Mandal.
TM Infringement- Rajeev Mandal.TM Infringement- Rajeev Mandal.
TM Infringement- Rajeev Mandal.Rajiv Mandal
 
Geographical Indication of Intellectual Property
Geographical Indication of Intellectual PropertyGeographical Indication of Intellectual Property
Geographical Indication of Intellectual PropertyDevansh Aggarwal
 
Trademark Infringement,Types of Trademark Infringements and Remedies of Infri...
Trademark Infringement,Types of Trademark Infringements and Remedies of Infri...Trademark Infringement,Types of Trademark Infringements and Remedies of Infri...
Trademark Infringement,Types of Trademark Infringements and Remedies of Infri...raogari
 
Intellectual property rights (2)
Intellectual property rights (2)Intellectual property rights (2)
Intellectual property rights (2)StudsPlanet.com
 
Bare Act- The Transfer of Property Act, 1882
Bare Act- The Transfer of Property Act, 1882Bare Act- The Transfer of Property Act, 1882
Bare Act- The Transfer of Property Act, 1882Abijah Naresh Jumani
 
Introduction to Trade Marks Act, 1999
Introduction to Trade Marks Act, 1999Introduction to Trade Marks Act, 1999
Introduction to Trade Marks Act, 1999DVSResearchFoundatio
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Surrender and Revocation of Patents
Surrender and Revocation of PatentsSurrender and Revocation of Patents
Surrender and Revocation of Patents
 
The rights and limitations of patentee ppt
The rights and limitations of patentee pptThe rights and limitations of patentee ppt
The rights and limitations of patentee ppt
 
Trademark
TrademarkTrademark
Trademark
 
Moot memorial
Moot memorialMoot memorial
Moot memorial
 
Trademark ppt by-pooja gurwani
Trademark ppt by-pooja gurwaniTrademark ppt by-pooja gurwani
Trademark ppt by-pooja gurwani
 
Trademark Act, 1999
Trademark Act, 1999Trademark Act, 1999
Trademark Act, 1999
 
Trademark assignment
Trademark assignmentTrademark assignment
Trademark assignment
 
Intellectual Property Rights
Intellectual Property Rights Intellectual Property Rights
Intellectual Property Rights
 
International ipr
International iprInternational ipr
International ipr
 
TM Infringement- Rajeev Mandal.
TM Infringement- Rajeev Mandal.TM Infringement- Rajeev Mandal.
TM Infringement- Rajeev Mandal.
 
ACTIONABLE CLAIM
ACTIONABLE CLAIMACTIONABLE CLAIM
ACTIONABLE CLAIM
 
Geographical Indication of Intellectual Property
Geographical Indication of Intellectual PropertyGeographical Indication of Intellectual Property
Geographical Indication of Intellectual Property
 
Trademark Infringement,Types of Trademark Infringements and Remedies of Infri...
Trademark Infringement,Types of Trademark Infringements and Remedies of Infri...Trademark Infringement,Types of Trademark Infringements and Remedies of Infri...
Trademark Infringement,Types of Trademark Infringements and Remedies of Infri...
 
The Designs Act, 2000
The Designs Act, 2000 The Designs Act, 2000
The Designs Act, 2000
 
Intellectual property rights (2)
Intellectual property rights (2)Intellectual property rights (2)
Intellectual property rights (2)
 
Bare Act- The Transfer of Property Act, 1882
Bare Act- The Transfer of Property Act, 1882Bare Act- The Transfer of Property Act, 1882
Bare Act- The Transfer of Property Act, 1882
 
Trade marks
Trade marksTrade marks
Trade marks
 
Madrid system
Madrid systemMadrid system
Madrid system
 
Industrial design ipr
Industrial design iprIndustrial design ipr
Industrial design ipr
 
Introduction to Trade Marks Act, 1999
Introduction to Trade Marks Act, 1999Introduction to Trade Marks Act, 1999
Introduction to Trade Marks Act, 1999
 

Ähnlich wie IPR PPT.pptx

Deceptive similarity under trademark
Deceptive similarity under trademarkDeceptive similarity under trademark
Deceptive similarity under trademarkNipun Paleja
 
trademark
trademarktrademark
trademarkIMDR
 
Law case study by neetu
Law case study by neetuLaw case study by neetu
Law case study by neetuNeetu Marwah
 
Case study on trademark infringement
Case study on trademark infringementCase study on trademark infringement
Case study on trademark infringementShilpa Rathod
 
Trade marks and service marks with special reference to Sri Lanka
Trade marks and service marks with special reference to Sri LankaTrade marks and service marks with special reference to Sri Lanka
Trade marks and service marks with special reference to Sri LankaMaxwell Ranasinghe
 
Freedom of Expression and Trademark Rights in India
Freedom of Expression and Trademark Rights in IndiaFreedom of Expression and Trademark Rights in India
Freedom of Expression and Trademark Rights in IndiaVijay Makyam
 
IP Considerations for New Businesses and Start Ups
IP Considerations for New Businesses and Start UpsIP Considerations for New Businesses and Start Ups
IP Considerations for New Businesses and Start Ups123contenthub
 
trade and merchandise mark act
trade and merchandise mark act trade and merchandise mark act
trade and merchandise mark act SarthakGupta190
 
ethics in intellectual property rights
ethics in intellectual property rightsethics in intellectual property rights
ethics in intellectual property rightsASWANTHMp
 
Infringement of trademark
Infringement of trademarkInfringement of trademark
Infringement of trademarkSolubilis
 
Brand management
Brand managementBrand management
Brand managementLotusKathir
 

Ähnlich wie IPR PPT.pptx (20)

Trademark law ppt
Trademark law pptTrademark law ppt
Trademark law ppt
 
Deceptive similarity under trademark
Deceptive similarity under trademarkDeceptive similarity under trademark
Deceptive similarity under trademark
 
Trademark
TrademarkTrademark
Trademark
 
trademark
trademarktrademark
trademark
 
Trade mark rights
Trade mark rightsTrade mark rights
Trade mark rights
 
Trade mark
Trade markTrade mark
Trade mark
 
Trademark Essay
Trademark EssayTrademark Essay
Trademark Essay
 
Ipr avi
Ipr aviIpr avi
Ipr avi
 
Law case study by neetu
Law case study by neetuLaw case study by neetu
Law case study by neetu
 
Case study on trademark infringement
Case study on trademark infringementCase study on trademark infringement
Case study on trademark infringement
 
Trade marks and service marks with special reference to Sri Lanka
Trade marks and service marks with special reference to Sri LankaTrade marks and service marks with special reference to Sri Lanka
Trade marks and service marks with special reference to Sri Lanka
 
Freedom of Expression and Trademark Rights in India
Freedom of Expression and Trademark Rights in IndiaFreedom of Expression and Trademark Rights in India
Freedom of Expression and Trademark Rights in India
 
TM-Inf & PO_IPR.pptx
TM-Inf & PO_IPR.pptxTM-Inf & PO_IPR.pptx
TM-Inf & PO_IPR.pptx
 
IP Considerations for New Businesses and Start Ups
IP Considerations for New Businesses and Start UpsIP Considerations for New Businesses and Start Ups
IP Considerations for New Businesses and Start Ups
 
trade and merchandise mark act
trade and merchandise mark act trade and merchandise mark act
trade and merchandise mark act
 
ethics in intellectual property rights
ethics in intellectual property rightsethics in intellectual property rights
ethics in intellectual property rights
 
IPR: Introduction to Trademark
IPR: Introduction to TrademarkIPR: Introduction to Trademark
IPR: Introduction to Trademark
 
Infringement of trademark
Infringement of trademarkInfringement of trademark
Infringement of trademark
 
Brand management
Brand managementBrand management
Brand management
 
Info 442 chapter6
Info 442 chapter6Info 442 chapter6
Info 442 chapter6
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

cse-csp batch4 review-1.1.pptx cyber security
cse-csp batch4 review-1.1.pptx cyber securitycse-csp batch4 review-1.1.pptx cyber security
cse-csp batch4 review-1.1.pptx cyber securitysandeepnani2260
 
Engaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptx
Engaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptxEngaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptx
Engaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptxAsifArshad8
 
INDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory affair 1st sem CRR
INDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory  affair 1st sem CRRINDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory  affair 1st sem CRR
INDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory affair 1st sem CRRsarwankumar4524
 
General Elections Final Press Noteas per M
General Elections Final Press Noteas per MGeneral Elections Final Press Noteas per M
General Elections Final Press Noteas per MVidyaAdsule1
 
Quality by design.. ppt for RA (1ST SEM
Quality by design.. ppt for  RA (1ST SEMQuality by design.. ppt for  RA (1ST SEM
Quality by design.. ppt for RA (1ST SEMCharmi13
 
RACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATION
RACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATIONRACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATION
RACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATIONRachelAnnTenibroAmaz
 
GESCO SE Press and Analyst Conference on Financial Results 2024
GESCO SE Press and Analyst Conference on Financial Results 2024GESCO SE Press and Analyst Conference on Financial Results 2024
GESCO SE Press and Analyst Conference on Financial Results 2024GESCO SE
 
The Ten Facts About People With Autism Presentation
The Ten Facts About People With Autism PresentationThe Ten Facts About People With Autism Presentation
The Ten Facts About People With Autism PresentationNathan Young
 
Internship Presentation | PPT | CSE | SE
Internship Presentation | PPT | CSE | SEInternship Presentation | PPT | CSE | SE
Internship Presentation | PPT | CSE | SESaleh Ibne Omar
 
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.com
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.comSaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.com
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.comsaastr
 
proposal kumeneger edited.docx A kumeeger
proposal kumeneger edited.docx A kumeegerproposal kumeneger edited.docx A kumeeger
proposal kumeneger edited.docx A kumeegerkumenegertelayegrama
 
A Guide to Choosing the Ideal Air Cooler
A Guide to Choosing the Ideal Air CoolerA Guide to Choosing the Ideal Air Cooler
A Guide to Choosing the Ideal Air Coolerenquirieskenstar
 
Dutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular Plastics
Dutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular PlasticsDutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular Plastics
Dutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular PlasticsDutch Power
 
Chizaram's Women Tech Makers Deck. .pptx
Chizaram's Women Tech Makers Deck.  .pptxChizaram's Women Tech Makers Deck.  .pptx
Chizaram's Women Tech Makers Deck. .pptxogubuikealex
 
THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...
THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...
THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...漢銘 謝
 
Application of GIS in Landslide Disaster Response.pptx
Application of GIS in Landslide Disaster Response.pptxApplication of GIS in Landslide Disaster Response.pptx
Application of GIS in Landslide Disaster Response.pptxRoquia Salam
 
Early Modern Spain. All about this period
Early Modern Spain. All about this periodEarly Modern Spain. All about this period
Early Modern Spain. All about this periodSaraIsabelJimenez
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (17)

cse-csp batch4 review-1.1.pptx cyber security
cse-csp batch4 review-1.1.pptx cyber securitycse-csp batch4 review-1.1.pptx cyber security
cse-csp batch4 review-1.1.pptx cyber security
 
Engaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptx
Engaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptxEngaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptx
Engaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptx
 
INDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory affair 1st sem CRR
INDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory  affair 1st sem CRRINDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory  affair 1st sem CRR
INDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory affair 1st sem CRR
 
General Elections Final Press Noteas per M
General Elections Final Press Noteas per MGeneral Elections Final Press Noteas per M
General Elections Final Press Noteas per M
 
Quality by design.. ppt for RA (1ST SEM
Quality by design.. ppt for  RA (1ST SEMQuality by design.. ppt for  RA (1ST SEM
Quality by design.. ppt for RA (1ST SEM
 
RACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATION
RACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATIONRACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATION
RACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATION
 
GESCO SE Press and Analyst Conference on Financial Results 2024
GESCO SE Press and Analyst Conference on Financial Results 2024GESCO SE Press and Analyst Conference on Financial Results 2024
GESCO SE Press and Analyst Conference on Financial Results 2024
 
The Ten Facts About People With Autism Presentation
The Ten Facts About People With Autism PresentationThe Ten Facts About People With Autism Presentation
The Ten Facts About People With Autism Presentation
 
Internship Presentation | PPT | CSE | SE
Internship Presentation | PPT | CSE | SEInternship Presentation | PPT | CSE | SE
Internship Presentation | PPT | CSE | SE
 
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.com
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.comSaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.com
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.com
 
proposal kumeneger edited.docx A kumeeger
proposal kumeneger edited.docx A kumeegerproposal kumeneger edited.docx A kumeeger
proposal kumeneger edited.docx A kumeeger
 
A Guide to Choosing the Ideal Air Cooler
A Guide to Choosing the Ideal Air CoolerA Guide to Choosing the Ideal Air Cooler
A Guide to Choosing the Ideal Air Cooler
 
Dutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular Plastics
Dutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular PlasticsDutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular Plastics
Dutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular Plastics
 
Chizaram's Women Tech Makers Deck. .pptx
Chizaram's Women Tech Makers Deck.  .pptxChizaram's Women Tech Makers Deck.  .pptx
Chizaram's Women Tech Makers Deck. .pptx
 
THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...
THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...
THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...
 
Application of GIS in Landslide Disaster Response.pptx
Application of GIS in Landslide Disaster Response.pptxApplication of GIS in Landslide Disaster Response.pptx
Application of GIS in Landslide Disaster Response.pptx
 
Early Modern Spain. All about this period
Early Modern Spain. All about this periodEarly Modern Spain. All about this period
Early Modern Spain. All about this period
 

IPR PPT.pptx

  • 1. AMUL VS IMUL TRADEMARK CASE STUDY
  • 2. • Sit Dolor Amet AMUL VS IMUL TRADEMARK CASE STUDY
  • 3. TRADEMARK A trademark is a sign capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one enterprise from those of other enterprises. Trademarks are protected by intellectual property rights. The symbols ™ (the trademark symbol) and ® (the registered trademark symbol) can be used to indicate trademarks; the latter is only for use by the owner of a trademark that has been registered.
  • 4. TRADEMARKS ACT ,1999 • The Trade Marks Registry was established in India in 1940 and presently it administers the Trade Marks Act, 1999 and the rules there under. • It acts as a resource and information center and is a facilitator in matters relating to trade marks in the country. • The objective of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 is to register trade marks applied for in the country and to provide for better protection of trade mark for goods and services and also to prevent fraudulent use of the mark. • The main function of the Registry is to register trade marks which qualifies for registration under the Act and Rules.
  • 5. USAGE OF TRADEMARK • A trademark identifies the brand owner of a particular product or service. • The owner of a trademark may pursue legal action against trademark infringement. Most countries require formal trademark registration as a precondition for pursuing this type of action. The United States, Canada, and other countries also recognize common law trademark rights, which means action can be taken to protect any unregistered trademark if it is in use. Still, common law trademarks offer to the holder, in general, less legal protection than registered trademarks. TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENT • Trademark infringement is the unauthorized use of a trademark or service mark on or in connection with goods and/or services in a manner that is likely to cause confusion, deception, or mistake about the source of the goods and/or services.
  • 6. • Amul is an Indian dairy cooperative society, based at Anand in Gujarat . Formed in 1946, it is a cooperative brand managed by the Gujarat Cooperative Milk Marketing Federation Ltd. (GCMMF), which today is jointly controlled by 36 lakh(3.6 million) milk producers in Gujarat, and the apex body of 13 district milk unions, spread across 13,000 villages of Gujarat. Amul spurred India’s White Revolution, which made the country the world's largest producer of milk and milk products. • Kaira Union introduced the brand “Amul” for marketing its product range. The word “Amul” is derived from Sanskrit word ‘Amulya’ which means ‘priceless’ or precious, a name proposed by then founding leader of Agriculture College, Maganbhai Patel. • The Amul model : The Amul model of dairy development is a three -tiered structure with the dairy cooperative societies at the village level federated under a milk Union at the district level and a Federation of member Union at the state level.
  • 7. IMUL - A milk producer’s co-operative union in West Bengal, which sought to market a brand of milk.
  • 8. • ‘Ichhamati Co-operative Milk Producers’ Union Limited (IMUL) filed an application for registration of the mark ‘IMUL’ (depicted in a triangular shape) (Application No. 1281174) under class 29 (milk goods and other dairy products) of the Trademarks Act, 1999. • After the advertisement of this application, Kaira District Co-Operative Milk Producers’ Union Limited (appellant) opposed registration of the trademark. • The opposition was based on the ground that the appellant was carrying on a well established business of manufacturing, marketing and exporting milk products under the name AMUL since 1955. THE DISPUTE APPELLANT – AMUL RESPONDENT- IMUL
  • 9.  By virtue of its long, continuous and extensive use of the trademark, it was contended that the public now associated ‘AMUL’ with the appellant’s products. Therefore, the respondent’s adoption of the mark IMUL would cause confusion among the public and in the trade as it was deceptively similar to the appellant’s trademark.  The registrar, however, found that the respondent’s adoption of the mark IMUL was honest and was not deceptively similar.  The decision was based on the fact that the respondent had been using this mark since 2001 and its turnover had increased continuously since then.  According to the registrar, refusal of registration would cause unnecessary inconvenience and damage to the respondents.
  • 10. THE DECISION  After perusing several cases, the Intellectual Property Appellate Board , IPAB held that a statement showing increase in sales turnover (by way of affidavit) was no ground to grant registration of a trademark that was deceptively similar to AMUL’s trademark.  It was held that the mark (IMUL) was phonetically similar to AMUL, except for the first letter ‘A’ and ‘I’.  Against this order, the appellant appealed to IPAB (Circuit Bench, Kolkata).  Despite notice, the respondents did not appear before the IPAB nor did they file counter statements.  The IPAB decided the matter in favour of AMUL ex parte. The order of the IPAB (No. 34 of 2013) is available.
  • 11.  The IPAB used the test of “an unwary purchaser with average intelligence and imperfect recollection” to show that phonetically similar marks are likely to cause confusion among such purchasers.  Moreover, case law showed that AMUL had become a household name and the appellant had been successful, in the past, in restraining others from using its registered trademark.  The board comprising Vice-Chairman S. Usha and member V. Ravi said: “The marks are no doubt phonetically similar, except for first letters a and i . When we consider the marks to be deceptively similar, the possibility of confusion is certain. The trademark, therefore, shall not proceed to registration.”  Also, since the respondents did not appear before the IPAB to prove the use of the mark IMUL since 2001 and give reasons for adopting the same, the IPAB held that AMUL was a well known mark and the registration of a deceptively similar mark ought not to have been allowed. Therefore, the order was set aside.