2. Course Objectives County Executive Office
At the end of this course you will be able to:
See how you fit in Ventura County’s Service Excellence
Program
Participate in Continuous Process Improvement events
Apply problem solving tools to improve processes
Use a common Lean Six Sigma language
Recognize how the culture of Ventura County is evolving
Cheat with a clear conscience (“borrow” good ideas > See our website)
3. Employees
Solutions
1. More employees
2. Improved employees
• Training
• Multitasking
• Incentives
• Accountability
3. Customers have to wait
Complaints Proces • “Manage”
expectations
•What took so long? s
• Can’t you go any faster?
• Who dropped the ball?
Customer
s
6. System Perspective County Executive Office
Perspective Adds Meaning
Complexity = Specialization = Narrow Perspective / Barriers
7. Improving Our Systems County Executive Office
Fundamental truth
All organizations are the same
All organizations are collections of systems
All work is part of a system
Continuous Process Improvement
Tap our most valuable resource – You
Culture of action, empowerment, change
Awareness of your surroundings / Be Curious Rt at
Red
9. Training Environment
County Executive Office
Supplies
• Sign in sheet, name tents
• Service Excellence trifold handout
• Exercise equipment (Statapult etc.)
Teams
• Color coded, pick team names
10. County Executive Office
Keys to Your Success In This Course
Have fun
Active participation in class activities
Ask questions
Notice the terminology
Appreciate the concepts; no memorization
Get the Sampler; Check out the specials
11. Team Agreements County Executive Office
HAVE FUN!!!
Be on time returning from breaks & Listen fast
Ask questions anytime – this is a learning experience
Participate fully in all activities
Listen to speakers – one speaker at a time
Parking Lot – 3 knock rule
Handle outside business on breaks
• Set electronic devices to stun (silent mode)
• This is a “Blackberry-Free Zone”
“County bell”
12. Introductions County Executive Office
Pair up – prepare to introduce your partner
Name
Agency
Example of Customer Service Experience
Introduce your partner then let them give their own
short description of a positive or negative customer
service experience they have had (anywhere).
(Take 5 Minutes – Be ready to present at _:__)
13. Ventura County Mission
County Executive Office
To provide public infrastructure, services and
support so that all residents have the opportunity
to achieve a high quality of life and enjoy the
benefits of a healthy economy.
14. County Executive Office
Service Excellence Program Objective
Encourage a county-wide culture of service excellence, continuous improvement
and empirically based decision making as a means of improving quality,
consistency, speed and cost of County Services.
21st Century Business Practice
Fiscal Conservancy
Governmental Transparency
15. Service Excellence Objective
County Executive Office
Encourage Culture Culture First-Inside Out
Service Excellence
Continuous Improvement (Ex. Music Teacher)
Empirically Based Decision-making (Ex. Donkey
Story)
• Observation, Experience
In Order to Improve
Quality
Measurable >>> Consistency
Speed
Cost
17. Service Excellence Structure
County Executive Office
Board of Supervisors
Vision & Direction
Michael Powers, CEO
Catherine Rodriguez, COO Agency Executive Team
Lean Lean Coordinator
Champion
GTE, $,
Service Resources
Excellence
Council All Employees Value Stream
Champion
• Provide data and voice of
Service
customer inputs to Just Do
Team
Excellence Office Its, Kaizen Events and
Leaders
Projects
• Apply concepts to their
own jobs and work areas
Practitioner’s Team
Council Members
Belts
Execution:
Infrastructure: Do it.
Support it.
19. Breathing Life Into Data
County Executive Office
Discretionary Permit Process Resource Management Agency,
Fire, Agriculture, Public Works Agency.
• Reduces number of separate forms from 31 to 1.
• Reduces number of pages from 325 to 59.
• Reduces 872 questions to 110.
• Reduces duplicated questions from 180 to 0.Green.
Blanket Purchase Order General Services Agency. Increased
productivity of BPO’s from 163 to 1,686, 30 steps to 11 steps.
Sustained for 3 years. Staff morale and teamwork “never better”.
Others
PWA/GSA. Heavy Equipment tracking and purchase decisions.
GSA. Changed billing process to electronic. Eliminated 85,000 paper.
Animal Regulation. Eliminated annual dog tags. $35,000 (Why game)
HSA. Eliminated labels on forms, printed contact information.
22. Learning Objectives County Executive Office
The Statapult exercises are designed to give
students experience using the methodologies
and tools taught in this course.
Round 1: Current State
Round 2: Future State - Flow
Improvements
23. Simulation Requirements
County Executive Office
Lean thinkers hear voices.
1. Exercise Requirements
Make the exercise work correctly and cannot be modified
2. Customer Requirements (Voice of the Customer)
How the customer would like the product and/or service to
function
3. Business Requirements (Voice of the Business)
How your “Company” functions, internal policies
4. Statapult Requirements (Voice of the Process)
Constraints or capabilities of the tool used
24. Round 1 County Executive Office
Current State
This round is intended to give the team
experience running the current process.
It includes the following three phases:
1. Baseline
2. Shoot
3. Calculations
4. *Pick your team name*
25. Baseline County Executive Office
In order to run the simulation, you must
determine the accuracy and precision of the
process in order to set up the target area.
Position your Statapult in
designated area
Take 20 test shots (164
degrees)
Mark the landing of each
shot with piece of tape
Use masking tape to
mark off target area
Do not move Statapult
during or after shooting
5 min
26. Exercise Requirements – Round 1
County Executive Office
Each team member will be assigned a role
The balls will be marked as a preparation for
shooting and for rework
• Blue dots symbolize inputs needed to complete a
job function and are considered to be value added
to the process
• Red dots symbolize the time and effort required to
fix a problem
No permanent markings or modifications can
be made to the Statapult or balls
27. Customer Requirements – Round County Executive Office
1
All shots must be fired at an angle of 164 degrees
All shots must land on the floor in a stationary
target area +/-3 inches long and +/- 6 inches wide
with respect to the nominal target
Pass/Fail data must be collected for each shot
The balls must be sorted based on either Pass or
Fail
The balls must be delivered to customer with no
markings (colored dots)
The customer requires 20 passed balls to be
delivered in 5 minutes
All data must be collected “real time”
28. Business Requirements – Round 1
County Executive Office
Balls must be transported in batches of 5
The Statapult must be recalibrated (remove &
reattach rubber band) between every shot
Workers should only be concerned with their
assigned jobs
All shots must originate from the floor
Must use forms 5O-5LO, RUK-1D-1NG, and
1-T5-L8
Balls are aligned with blue dot facing up
29. Statapult Requirements – Round 1
County Executive Office
The Statapult settings and structure cannot
be modified
The Statapult can not be aligned/modified
with any tools, devices or aids
The Statapult can only be handled/touched by
the Shooter
The Statapult must be placed so that the base
is horizontal to the floor and in a stationary
position
30. Roles
County Executive Office
Marker
Shooter
Inspector
Sorter
Customer Liaison
Observer(s)
Take 5 minutes to review what your role is
Take 5 minutes to review what your role is
before the Round 1 shoot
before the Round 1 shoot
31. Round 1 – Layout
County Executive Office
Pass Fail
Cups
Sorter
Customer
Target
Customer Observer
Liaison
x
Inspector
Box of
Balls
Marker
Shooter
32. Round 1 Shoot
County Executive Office
Are you ready to start?
Announce Company name
Statapult layout is ready
Target area is taped off
Roles are assigned
Role instructions have been distributed
**(Leave Statapult in place when finished)
The simulation will start
simultaneously for all teams!
30 min
33. Calculations – Round 1 County Executive Office
1. Customer Order (How do you know what they want?) ______ (1)
The amount of balls successfully delivered to the customer
2. Total Balls Fired (Effort-Quality) ______ (2)
The total amount of balls fired for the exercise
3. Total Failures (Do customers care?) ______ (3)
The total amount of failures called by the inspector
4. Time to First Delivery (Do customers care?) VOP ______ (4)
The time to make the first delivery to the customer
5. Total Lead Time (seconds) (Expected response) ______ (5)
Total time to complete the customer order
6. WIP (Work In Progress) ______ (6)
The total amount of balls left at each work area
7. Yield ______ (7)
Customer Order(1)/Total Balls Fired(2)
What do these metrics tell us?
34. Exercise: What Went Wrong?
County Executive Office
What went wrong with the process?
No solutions allowed yet; only problems
*At the end: ID which was the biggest problem of all
10 min
35. Module 2
County Executive Office
INTRODUCTION TO
CONTINUOUS PROCESS
IMPROVEMENT METHODODLOGY
36. Module 2 Objectives
County Executive Office
At the end of this module you will be able to:
List and define 3 CPI methodologies
• Lean
• Six Sigma
• Theory of Constraints (TOC)
List and explain the “Five (5) Principles of Lean”
Identify the five (5) Phases of Six Sigma
37. What is “Lean Six Sigma”? County Executive Office
A. A college sorority
B. A diet aid
C. A war on WASTE and
VARIATION in business
processes
39. Lean Six Sigma is . . .
County Executive Office
Making common sense common
practice
A Combination of two schools of thought:
“Lean” - eliminating waste to reduce cycle times;
“Six Sigma” - reducing variation to ensure a
standard, quality output;
A set of methodologies characterized by:
customer satisfaction
a culture of continuous improvement
the search for root causes
and comprehensive employee involvement
40. Origin of Lean County Executive Office
Japan – post WWII – struggling economy
Edwards Deming – Quality guru
Brought radical ideas not yet implemented in America
Acceptable quality level. cost/quality not a trade off
Daily incremental improvement (everyone involved).
Don’t seek perfection…yet (80/20).
Focus – Don’t improve work, eliminate waste
Find colors exercise
41. Lean Basics County Executive Office
Lean Is . . .
A War on
WASTE!
Example: Firemen and Pit Crews
42. Examples of Wastes
County Executive Office
Time spent dealing with complaints
Redundant capture of information
Information not accurate
Time spent looking for information, equipment, people
Excess supplies stored in multiple locations
Limited storage space – not properly used
Variations –
Low process yields, low quality, shift changes,
Information/equip unavailability
43. County Executive Office
Traditional Process Improvement vs. Lean
Inspect
Inspect Re-work Wait Transport
Transport Wait Work Reinstall
Work Work
Disconnect
Start Finish
FLOW TIME
= Value = Non-Value-Added
Added Time Time (WASTE)
Value-Added time is only a very small percentage of the total Time
44. County Executive Office
Traditional Process Improvement vs. Lean
NON Value-added time Traditional
NON Value-added time
Focus
Improve Value-Added
Time work steps
Small Amount of i.e. Better tools, machines,
Time Eliminated
instructions
Result: Small time
LARGE savings
amount
of time saved
Lean Focus Time savings have a direct impact on
Reduce or eliminate NVA/waste • Cost • Capacity
Result: LARGE time savings • Schedule • Flexibility
• Resources • Etc.
45. Lean Process Improvement
County Executive Office
Inspect
Inspect Re-work Wait Transport
Transport Wait Work Reinstall
Work Work
Disconnect
Start Finish
FLOW TIME
= Value = Non-Value-Added
Added Time Time (WASTE)
Value-Added time is only a very small percentage of the total Time
46. Cycle of Lean Principles County Executive Office
Seek Specify
Perfection Customer
Value
Establish Identify
“Pull” Value Stream
Achieve
Flow
47. Power of Lean County Executive Office
Voice of the Customer Examples: BMW, Grapefruit, Coke
• Driving force of the Enterprise: FOCUS
Lean Behavior
• Empowered workforce
Unlocks the potential of the organization
• You can’t help it!
Removes Waste
• Steps reduced/streamlined; systems simplified
• Cycle time reduction
48. What is “Six Sigma”?
County Executive Office
Reduces variation in a process to achieve near perfect quality.
1st Time Quality
99.99966% or 3.4 PPM
Focuses on Operational Excellence
Six Sigma is a data-driven approach aimed at the near-elimination of defects
from every process and transaction.
49. Why “Six Sigma”? County Executive Office
Hey, 99% is good enough right?
99%
99.99966% (6 Sigma)
• 20,000 lost postal mail items • 7 lost postal mail items per
per hour hour
• 15 minutes of unsafe • 1 unsafe minute
drinking water per day every seven months
• 2 long/short landings per day • 1 long/short landing
at a major airport every five years
• 1.7 incorrect operations
• 5,000 incorrect surgical per week
operations per week
• 1 hour without electricity
• 84 hours of lost electricity per every 34 years
year
• 68 wrong prescriptions
• 240,000 wrong prescriptions per year
per year
50. Sources of Variability
County Executive Office
Information unavailability Ex. Fed Ex – Schedule, Status
Equipment & tools unavailability Ex. Badge, Password
Poor planning that results in rushed work Ex. Hot Jobs
Low process yields (Defects) Ex. Hot Dogs
Material condition not as expected
Unique/custom products
Change notices, holds, customer changes
Vacations, illness = absent staff
Many, many more... (obstacles to consistent outcomes)
51. Cycle of Six Sigma Discipline
County Executive Office
Control Define
(Assess & (Problem
Adjust) & Scope)
Improve Measure
(Implement
(Current State
Solutions)
“Map”)
Analyze
Variability
(Causes & Measures)
53. Process Improvement Filter County Executive Office
1. Y = f (x1, x2…)
2. Define Y (Charter)
3. Identify the X’s (tribal knowledge)
4. Identify the red X’s (tribal knowledge) (Vital Few)
5. Validate the red X’s (Gemba/data)
6. Analysis
7. Solution
Don’t accelerate the
excavation until you are
sure your digging in the
right place.
54. Theory of Constraints County Executive Office
Constraints and Barriers
A constraint is anything in an
organization that limits it from moving
forward or achieving its goal
“The slowest vehicle in a convoy sets the pace”
55. Checking In County Executive Office
1. Lean is a war on ______.
2. Six Sigma reduces ____________.
3. Lean Six Sigma engages and
empowers ___________ to make
process changes.
4. The Theory of Constraints strives
to eliminate ________.
57. Module 3
County Executive Office
Team Members
Roles and Responsibilities
58. Module 3 Objectives County Executive Office
At the end of this module you will be able to:
Describe a Lean Thinker
Describe & articulate your role as a Team
Member
Have an appreciation for the impact of
culture on change
59. Lean Thinkers
County Executive Office
It’s not about tools – don’t throw tools at a
problem (Tools do not have solutions, people do)
Turn the “mental corner” together (Use L6S lens)
Filter the problem and problem solving
through Cycle of 5 Lean Principles and
Cycle of Six Sigma Discipline
Your experience + Lean Six Sigma tools =
solutions
If all the same thinking still exists, little by little
you will return to your prior state!
60. Where to find team members?
County Executive Office
Process Step External Customer(s):
Suppliers Process Step
1 Those who receive or use
2
your product or service,
outside your organization
Here
Here
Here
Stakeholders:
Regulatory Agencies, Partner
Here
Agencies or Departments, Auditor-Controller, etc.
Two types of team members:
Core Team Members: Are there for the duration of the project.
Extended Team Member: Are requested as needed for the duration of the project.
61. Team Members
County Executive Office
Represent your area
Communicate back to your group
Participate fully
Think, think, think
Participate in implementation planning
Be a conduit for change
Be personally accountable – own it!
62. Culture Trumps Tools County Executive Office
Process, Results and Focus
Improvement Tools
Operations
Metrics
Must address BOTH Processes
Culture and Tools
to avoid unintended
consequences & Invisible:
Hard to Measure & Change
less than desirable
Blind Spots
long-term success with
Resistance
Process Management History
Mindsets
Norms
Assumptions
Habits
Perceptions
63. Change is Uncomfortable County Executive Office
Fold Arms Exercise
ABC Exercise (2 volunteers)
Change is difficult
Need to develop a culture of change
Look out for CAVE dwellers
65. Module 4 County Executive Office
Integrating the Toolsets
Using DMAIC Approach
66. Module 4 Objectives
County Executive Office
At the end of this module you will be able to:
Recognize tools used in the Lean process
Describe the Define Phase and its purpose
List parts of a Charter
Participate a SIPOC (Suppliers-Inputs-Process-
Outputs-Customer) Diagram
67. Lean Toolkit
County Executive Office
Value Stream Mapping
5S, and Visual Workplace
Work Standardization
Cellular Work Processing
Push and Pull System
Setup Reduction
Error Proofing (poke yoke)
Project teams decide which tools to apply to their problem.
68. Just Do It
County Executive Office
Not every idea needs a team (Kaizen)
• Do you already know what needs to be done?
Manager/supervisor or approves
Do It!
Report it!
69. Process for Process Improvement - DMAIC
County Executive Office
Objectives
Identify and/or validate the improvement
Opportunity.
Develop the business processes, define the
critical customer requirements.
Identify what adds value to the process from both
the business, process and customer perspective
(Voice Of the Business/Customer/ Process; VOC,
VOB, VOP).
70. Process for Process Improvement - DMAIC
County Executive Office
If I had one hour to save the world, I would
spend 59 minutes defining the problem and 1
minute finding solutions.
- Albert Einstein
72. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - DMAIC
Good Charter opportunity / problem
statements should provide the following
information:
What is the problem or opportunity for
improvement (what )?
Where is the problem? Is it in your workplace
or someone else's (where )?
How long has it been happening (when )?
What is the extent of the problem (extent )?
How large is the impact of the problem
(impact )?
73. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - DMAIC
Example of a bad opportunity
or problem statement:
“ It takes too long to process a Example of a better
material order form and wrong opportunity or problem
parts are ordered.” statement:
What “The material ordering process
for ACME Company - West
takes in excess of 30 days.
The problem has existed for
Where the past year. 85% of the
orders require rework due to
When wrong parts. This has
resulted in the postponement
of 60 projects in the last 6
months.”
Extent
Impact
74. Date Initiated:
PH Clinic Registration and Billing Process Revision Date:
Event Start Date:
Event End Date:
DEFINE
Project Information
ROLE Phone No. LAST NAME FIRST NAME AGENCY
Department Champion
Value Stream Analysis Champion
Team Lead
Subject Matter Expert
Subject Matter Expert Review the Charter
Green Belt
Green Belt Carefully.
Total Man Hours
- - - - - - - - - - -
Event Type I Kaizen
Be sure to
Event Type II Part of GTEP
understand the
Business Case
Opportunity or Problem Statement/Business Impact
scope.
Focus effort toward
the goals and
Goal Statement
Project Deliverables
deliverables.
In Scope Out of Scope
Value Stream Champion Date
75. SIPOC
County Executive Office
Y = f (x)
SUPPLIERS
INPUTS
PROCESS
OUTPUTS
CUSTOMER
Team will be hunting for Red “X’s” – Sources of Variance
76. SIPOC
County Executive Office
Y?
Suppliers Inputs Process Outputs Customers
X X Y
Y
X X Y
X X
Houseplants/Firehose (S, C); Looking for the 20% that have 80% of impact
77. SIPOC - Exercise
County Executive Office
Exercise – SIPOC for the
Simulation
10 minutes
79. Module 5 County Executive Office
Integrating the Toolsets Using DMAIC
Approach
80. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - D MAIC
Objectives
Identify critical measurements that are necessary
to meet customer requirements and develop a
method of collecting data to measure process
performance.
What measurements matter?
How will you collect the data?
Understand the data calculations and establish a
baseline for the process being measured.
Current state
81. Process for Process Improvement - D MAIC
County Executive Office
Tools
Value Stream Mapping / Process Mapping
82. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - D MAIC
Value Stream Mapping
Products & Customers
Process steps / Measurements
Current State = ID Focus Areas, Kaizens…
Future State = Lean, Synchronize to Demand
83. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - D MAIC
Spaghetti Map
- Follow Products or People
- Transportation, Over processing
Number of Handoffs: 9
Number of Handoffs: 18
Total Time: 8 days
Total Time: 45 days
Touch Time: 5 days
Touch Time: 5 days
Waiting 2 Days
Waiting 40 Days
Distance traveled: 5000 feet Distance traveled: 1000 feet
84. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - D MAIC
Information Flow “Circle” Diagram
Ring
o
George Linda
Number of Handoffs: 11
Total Time: 8 days
Touch Time: 5 days
Paul
Waiting 3 Days
Yoko
John
Pete
85. Process for Process Improvement - D MAIC
County Executive Office
Flow Diagram
86. Process for Process Improvement - D MAIC
County Executive Office
Swim Lane Process Map
89. Module 6
County Executive Office
Integrating the Toolsets
Using DMAIC Approach
90. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - DM AIC
Objectives
Identify and validate the root cause(s) that assure
the elimination of waste, variation, and constraints.
Identify, validate and prioritize all root causes.
Determine the true sources of variation and
potential failure modes that can lead to customer
dissatisfaction.
91. Process for Process Improvement - DM AIC
County Executive Office
Analysis: Determining Root Cause
Root cause analysis is where the real cause of the
problem is uncovered.
A root cause, if corrected would prevent a recurrence of
the problem.
Problem-solving without root cause analysis, results in
managing a symptom of the problem. (ex
Aspirin for a headache)
One technique is asking “Why” 5 times. By asking why,
you can peel away the layers of symptoms that lead to
the root cause of a problem.
92. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - DM AIC
Problem: Lincoln memorial Analysis: Determining
deteriorating at a high rate. Root Cause
1. Why: We wash this memorial
more than the others.
2. Why: Bird droppings make it
unsanitary for tourists.
3. Why: Birds eat the Spiders
that gather in masse.
4. Why: Spiders gather to eat
the flying midges that swarm.
5. Why: Midges swarm around
the bright, warm lights that
are turned on at dusk.
Answer: Delay turning on
the lights for one hour.
93. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - DM AIC
Cause and Effect Analysis Office Setting:
aka Fishbone Diagram -People
-Process
X -Policy
-Product
Machiner People
y
Y
Methods Materials Example Next
Slide
95. Knowledge Work
8- Wastes Product Work
Too many reports, reviews, County Executive Office
Running equipment to keep
approvals. Batching paperwork. equipment and people busy.
Overproduction
Waiting for meetings to start. Waiting for equipment, people or
Information, paperwork and process to cycle, waiting for
approvals. Waiting materials and tools.
Work not meeting requirements. Scrap, rework, lost capacity due
Missing information. Rework. to mistakes, inaccurate SOP’s.
Defects
Paper- based data vs. electronic Long travel distances, unplanned
transfers. Routing of premium postal.
unnecessary Transportation
approvals/processing.
Unnecessary steps. Too many
Over Processing Incapable equipment and
handoffs, lack of SOP’s. processes. Equipment with
unbalanced flow.
Excessive backlog of work to be
Unnecessary Making what we can instead of
processed. Too much paper to what customers need. High
be handled, processed or filed. Inventory obsolescence and write offs.
Walking to deliver paperwork,
Unnecessary Repetitive/unnecessary
poor ergonomics, chasing movement caused by poor
information. Motion ergonomic design.
Over or under staffing, talents
Under utilization Using expensive labor to do work
not utilized, work load not that can be done by less
balanced. of people expensive labor.
What examples can you think of?
96. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - D MAIC
Exercise – Identify 8 Wastes
Review List of Statapult Process Problems
1. Waste or Variation?
2. Which Type of Waste? 1. Overproduction
2. Waiting
3. Defects
4. Transportation
5. Overprocessing
6. Inventory
10minutes
7. Motion
8. Underutilize People
97. Process for Process Improvement - DM AIC
County Executive Office
Value-Added and Non-Value-Added work
– Value-added is defined as adding value to the product or service in
the eyes of the customer
– Non-value-added is work in the process that the customer is not
willing to pay for if they had a choice (waste)
Value-Added Activities Non Value-Added Activities
An activity that transforms or shapes Activities that consume resources but create
material or information no value in the eyes of the customer
Customer wants it Pure waste
Done right the first time (no rework) If you can’t get rid of the activity, it - ”E”
Non Value-Added – Essential Activities
E Activities causing no value to be created but which cannot be eliminated
based on current state of technology or thinking
Required (regulatory, customer mandate, legal)
Necessary (due to non-robustness of process, currently required; current
risk tolerance)
Waste is…Any action, process or product that adds cost (uses
resources), without adding value as perceived by our customer.
98. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - DM AIC
Exercise – Current Process
Analysis
Value Added (to customer)
Non-Value Added (to customer)
- - - - - - - - - - - - -
E
Non-Value Added (Essential)
(determine during Future State Mapping)
See next slide for reminder of
customer requirements.
20 minutes
99. County Executive Office
Customer Requirements – Review
All shots must be fired at an angle of 164 degrees
All shots must land on the floor in a stationary target area
+/-3 inches long and +/- 6 inches wide with respect to the
nominal target
Pass/Fail data must be collected for each shot
The balls must be sorted based on either Pass or Fail
The balls must be delivered to customer with no markings
(colored dots)
The customer requires 20 passed balls to be delivered in 5
minutes
All data must be collected “real time”
101. Module 7
County Executive Office
Integrating the Toolsets
Using DMAIC Approach
Define, Measure, and Analyze before Improve stage.
What is the problem, what are the red X’s, validate
the red X’s.
Don’t accelerate the excavation until you are sure
you’re looking in the right place.
102. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - DMA IC
Objectives
Identify potential solutions
Question/Validate
requirements
Question non-value added
steps
Map out “TO BE” process
Develop an implementation
Plan
Pilot solution Build a process that can
produce consistent results.
Consider 5 S
Don’t rely on Dan!
Add error proofing
103. 5-S (Workplace Org)
County Executive Office
5S is a technique that results in a well-
organized workplace complete with
visual controls and order. It’s an
environment that has “a place for
everything and everything in its place,
when you need it”.
104. Elements of a 5S Program
County Executive Office
Sort Remove from the workplace all items that are
not needed for current operation.
Set in Order/Straighten Arranging needed
items so that they are readily accessible and labeled so
that anyone can find them or put them away .
Shine The key purpose is to keep everything in top
condition so that when someone needs to use
something, it is ready to be used
Standardize The standard should be easily
understood and easy to communicate (i.e. visual
controls).
Sustain Implementing solutions to address the root
causes of work area organization issues. All employees
must be properly trained and use visual management
techniques What is most difficult?
What is most difficult?
105. Types of Error Proofing
County Executive Office
Create quality at the source through error proofing
(This is called = Poka Yoke)
Types of error proofing
Make it impossible to create error
Make it harder to create error
Make it obvious the error has occurred
Examples:
Minivan – Gas tank/sliding door
– Beeping when leave keys in car
– Trunk latch/remote lock
Others: USB, Color coding, Edits, Checklists (Pilot,gas cap,Dr?)
Poor Quality = Waste (Defects, rework, scrap)
107. Learning Objectives
County Executive Office
The Statapult exercises are designed to give
students experience using the methodologies
and tools taught in this course.
Round 2: Future State - Flow
Improvements/Variation
Reduction
108. Round 2
County Executive Office
Flow Improvements/Variation
Reduction
This round is intended to give the team
experience with specific flow changes &
reducing variation to improve quality and
yield.
109. Exercise Requirements – Round 2
County Executive Office
Team members do not have to perform the
same roles as in Round 1
No permanent markings or modifications can
be made to the Statapult or balls
110. Customer Requirements – Round
2
County Executive Office
All shots must be fired at an angle of 164
degrees
All shots must land on the floor in the target
Pass/Fail data must be collected for each
shot
The balls must be sorted based on either
Pass or Fail
The customer requires 20 passed balls to be
delivered in 5 minutes
All data must be collected “real time”
111. Requirements – Round 2
County Executive Office
Business Requirements
None
Statapult Requirements
The Statapult must be placed so that the base
is on the floor and in a stationary position
112. Future State Map Exercise
County Executive Office
Based on the new requirements and your
team’s value analysis of the Current State Map,
design the new process layout for the next
Statapult round. Consider the following:
1. Strategies to reduce variation
Address list of items causing variation
2. Strategies to reduce waste
Create Future State Map
Eliminate steps / improve flow
New roles/responsibilities
Listen to voice of the customer 45 minutes
**Only keep value added and essential steps**
113. Round 2 Shoot
County Executive Office
Are you ready to start?
The Future State Map is ready
Statapult layout is ready
The simulation will
start simultaneously for
all teams! 15 minutes
115. Module 8
County Executive Office
Integrating the Toolsets
Using DMAIC Approach
116. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - DMAIC
Objectives
Solution implementation
Establish control plan (Metrics: Avg/Std Dev; oven/bucket)
Verify improvements (Monitor targets)
Verify long term capability
Transition project to process owner
“What gets measured
gets managed”
117. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - DMAI C
Tools
Control Charts
Standard Operating Procedures
Process Control Plan
Communication Plan
Mistake Proofing
Team Feedback Session
No Control Plan?
Like Shooting an arrow in the sky and
expecting it to stick. Gravity!
118. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement - DMAI C
Maintaining Process Improvements
A Control Plan’s primary intent is to create a
structured approach to control the process.
Control plans assure well thought-out
reactions are in place if an out of control
condition occurs.
They provide a method for documentation
and communication of control methods.
Entropy- It just isn’t what it used to be
119. Celebrate!
County Executive Office
Go to brief-outs
Team Certificates
Publicize results
Brag!
120. County Executive Office
Process for Process Improvement – DMAIC- V
V-Validate
Improvements/Savings will be validated six months
to one year after completion of your CPI project to
insure improvements are realized and sustained.
Tools Champions
/Leads
Metrics Collection System
Audits
122. Push to Change County Executive Office
“ ..you’ll have trouble creating a
new culture if you insist on doing
it in the ways that are consistent
with the old one.”
123. What Can I Do? County Executive Office
See for
yourself!
Go to the Website
Be an advocate – find a story and tell it!
Get involved!
•Get training
•Ask why
Be Positive
•Submit ideas
•Get on a team
www.countyofventura.org/serviceexcellence
124. Seven Deadly Words County Executive Office
“ WE HAVE
ALWAYS
DONE IT
THIS
WAY.”
Hinweis der Redaktion
The presenter should introduce themselves to the class and thank them for coming. “ I’ll be your server today”
Cheat with a clear conscience: This program encourages you to look at what other people and organizations are doing and borrow their good ideas. Don’t reinvent the wheel if someone else has already done it. When you notice or hear about things that are working well for others, think about how your area could benefit from something similar. Paul Ex. How many different waiting rooms do we have across the County in hospitals, clinics, etc. Next time you are in a waiting room what do you notice that is good or bad about it? In the Service Excellence program we track and document every improvement event and strive to make that information available for other County agencies that could benefit from the improvements or lessons learned.
In a complex world we are forced to specialize in our jobs in order to be effective and efficient. However, along with specialization comes a more narrow perspective of our surroundings. This creates barriers because when we don’t see the big picture it is more difficult to put our work into context so that we can efficiently and effectively work with other parts of the organization to increase the overall value and quality of services we deliver. Paul: Every time I see this video clip I am also reminded of how perspective can be distorted when I view the location of South America in relation to North America. Most of South America is actually East of Florida. Think big act small. Perspective and understanding of the whole, can make it easier to see and improve the whole process.
A monk is meditating under a tree when he is alerted into the world by a thundering noise of a horse galloping across the river and thundering past him. After a few minutes, he returns to his quiet meditation. 10 minutes pass and once again, he hears the sound of racing past him – this time into the river and crossing to the other side. He notices that it is the very same monk who just went by. He then returns again to his meditation. After another 10 minutes, he hear approaching the sound of a horse crossing the river. He get up and calls to the monk on the horse as he approaches – “Brother, where are you going?” The monk on the horse calls back as he speeds by – “I don’t know, ask the horse!”. Do you every feel like your just along for the ride? No control over the direction? Part of today is learning about how to get off the ride and ask questions. What are we doing? Why are we doing these activities? Is it working? What’s not working? Is there a better way? Lean Six Sigma is a set of tools to help us ask and answer these questions. Somewhat like learning meditation. Often it is not complicated but it can be difficult. The truth or heart of the issue is the value we are adding. How do you get to the truth/value. ……… Also a cautionary tale. Don’t get too excited and blindly use the tools without a plan, direction.
This course is like going to a restaurant. Get the sampler, check out the specials. See what Lean Six Sigma has to offer.
When you are part of a team – facilitator may ask you to come to some agreements about how you will be together – Aka – Ground rules
Paul: Name, Agency ***Paul Example*** Wedding cake experience Set a specific time by which they should be ready to present. When businesses or government agencies provide services to customers/citizens, the customers overall experiences in terms of the services provided and the experience of the transactions is what equates to the value that was delivered. Our goal is to add value to services through the work we do. All of the work that we do relates to the process of product or service delivery. Improving the process increases the value of the product or service.
What drives us to do something different? -Something is wrong -Something looks good -It’s the right thing to do Steven Covey – suggests that only by serving others is our purpose “right”. CEO – Our community is better because of the work that we do. When we work, it should beyond the business, beyond the teams, beyond the self…we should stay attached to the bigger good – service.
SEP is a cornerstone of CEO’s commitment to implement 21st century business practices here at Ventura County. 4 things that the Board and Executives BELIEVE: We are already good - there is nothing wrong with our people – in fact we are responsible a tremendous amount of process improvement going on in all County agencies and departments previously. We would not be the exceptional County we are today without such efforts going on here on a daily basis. We can only get better if we work together - The objectives of the Service Excellence Program are to take these efforts to the next level, specifically, to equip County management and staff with a common set of tools, skill sets and vernacular that will allow them to make process improvements more effectively and more importantly , empower more of our employees and key process owners to recognize and make process improvement an integral part of their mindset and daily jobs. People first, processes second - tapping in to the knowledge workers and process owners and leveraging there ideas , …..engaging them to take ownership of improving the processes they are the experts on and responsible for. We need to all, continually ask two questions, are we getting better and how do we know . One of the unique aspects of the Lean Six Sigma tool that is the foundation of our program is that its focus on metrics will allow all participants in a process to know whether they are improving.
Note: It doesn’t say were going to improve quality, speed, cost in order to encourage culture. We must first develop the culture from which improvements will follow. Service Excellence: is about you doing the work. Not outside consultants coming in to “fix” us. Continuous Improvement: ***Paul Example***: Music teacher that didn’t tell students what they did wrong. She asked them. It forced them to evaluate themselves. They became their own teacher in could therefore continuously improve through constant adjustments. Empirical Decision-Making: ***Paul Example*** : Donkey story- man asks to borrow neighbors donkey. He says the donkey is not there. While walking away disappointed he hears the donkey bray. He goes back angry and says I just heard your donkey, what do you mean he’s not here. The owner says, well who are you going to believe? Me or the donkey? Lesson, trust your own observation and experience. Trust the metrics and numbers that provide empirical data, rather than a person’s guess or subjective assessment. Measurement is critical to knowing. None of it works without the culture first. Conversely, with the culture in place, it becomes easy. (Need an example!)
This image depicts how we are organized to implement Service Excellence in the County. As you can see the organization is split across the center of this image to designate, on the left of the dashed line - Program leadership, support and facilitation. On the right, think Program implementation and execution. And appropriately at the core of the Program, think process owners and experts, i.e. our employees . Principal: The people closest to the process are the closest to the solution GSA did a one year pilot. Improved the Blanket PO process by 500%, reduced steps. County leaders made a scope decision = “All In”. This would allow for intra-agency improvements where some big gains could be made. On the Program leadership and support side we have (Infrastructure): Lean / Deployment Champions : That’s the County Executive Team. Your Board, CEO and Agency and Department Heads and Executives. Your role is to primarily provide the direction and support to the organization to demonstrate that formal process improvement is a priority Service Excellence Council – Volunteer agency and department heads, headed by Paul Grossgold, define specific program goals and implementation strategies. 1. How is it going out there? 2. What systems should we look to improve? 3. Develop a County-wide strategic plan with emphasis on the whole. - Program Office , known as the Transformation office is the primary support and working team supporting the Program, its run by Deputy Executive Officer Elaine Crandall who will follow me this morning. Primary function: - Practitioner’s Council – Made up of belts who have completed training, develops specific implementation recommendations for the SEC and providers a forum for trained belts to exchanged ideas and lessons learned. - Belts – Lead, facilitate and conduct Lean process improvement events. Have had training and know tools. On The Program Execution Side we have roles which may be Countywide or specific to an agency or department, depending on the areas being worked. Deployment Champion – Responsible for the vision and direction Value Stream Champion – Owns the GTE plan and the financial results, removes barriers. Process owners Team Leaders – Leaders and SME’s w/in their area of expertise. Work closely with Belts. (Team Leads and Team Members actually develop the new process) Team Members – SME’s in events, support team leader. We will talk more about this is a later slide but note that this is where YOU are – as Team Members Let participants know that there is Champion Training available for managers and supervisors who may also participate as a Champion or Team Leader. Event Types: For now just refer to them as small, medium, and big – will define later
**** Need to update this slide: current quad chart & Catherine is now deployment champion Tracking for: Training – Training that has been completed Events – Training is done in order to support the completion of events. Value Metrics – Events are done in order to save time, or money, or improve quality. Lessons are learned as we gain experience. *** We are investing in you! Confidence in you to add value and make the County more efficient.
Here are just a few highlighted improvements that have taken place at the county. The single Application and Comprehensive Site Plan for Discretionary Processing. The community played an active role in this process Despite how good these metrics look, this is just phase one This improvement required the cooperation of 4 agencies. Blanket Purchase Order – Not just important for GSA efficiency, makes a profound impact on customer agencies. Others: Because of the culture of asking why, someone asked why they reissue dog tags every year. –Changed to permanent dog tags saving $35,000 per year. Many outcomes are intangibles – increased communication, safety, morale, clarity. These were just a few examples, to get a fuller picture, I recommend that you visit the County website under the banner of “Service Excellence”. …………… Here are just a few highlighted Kaizens that have taken place at the county. The single Application and Comprehensive Site Plan for Discretionary Processing just completed last week. Your board has heard several presentations on permitting and I draw this to your attention for three reasons. The first is the active role of the community in this process, second because, despite how good these metrics look, this is just phase one, and finally, this improvement required the cooperation of 4 agencies. The Harbor’s Vacation Request Process not only yielded a cycle time improvement of 75%, but also an improvement in teamwork and morale.
You will experience three gears in this course – I’ll point them out to you. So far, you’ve had a little lecture – I’ll be a talking head. We will have two types of simulations – what it is like to be part of a problem solving team and simulation of a problem and solution. Finally you will practice using some tools together. Explain Event Types: For now just refer to them as small, medium, and big – will define later Just Do It – Implement now (30 days or less). There is agreement on what needs to be done, do not need a team to identify root cause or figure out what to do about it. Kaizen – Rapid improvement event (4-6 weeks). Assign team members based on focus of the event. The process is transformed during the event. Combine team members knowledge with Lean Six tools to accomplish. Project – More complex problem (3-6 months). Use DMAIC process. May address quality and/or variation.
Typical time ranges for exercise (with 30 balls)(should be less with 20 balls: Fastest = 11 minutes Average = 25 minutes Longest = 40 minutes
This slide not in book. We will have 2 exercises with the statapult today. First exercise is to participate in a process as it exists now “current state”. It happens to be very bad process. Don’t try to improve it yet, just observe, and ask yourself what is working? What is not working. How do you feel participating in this process? This afternoon you will get a chance to change the process.
Statapult cup – 1st hole on top of Statapult arm Rubber band eye screw – 4th hole from top of Statapult arm Front post pin (rubber band will rest on this) – 2nd hole from top of front post Angle pin – 3rd hole from back of Statapult base
Instructor Notes Designate where each team should set up for simulation. Provide each team with a Statapult (preset) and 20 balls in their team color. The designated Shooter on each team should perform the test shots. Emphasize that team member roles will come into play for the actual shoot. Each team should have masking tape and/or adhesive dots to mark shots on the floor. After 20 balls have been fired (and the shots marked) teams should use masking tape to “draw off” the target area where most of the shots landed. Allow approximately 5 minutes for the teams to complete their baseline shots and mark their target.
Instructor Notes Have teams select a facilitator and do the following: Name their “Company” Assign roles (if you have more than 6 on a team you can have multiple Observers) Make teams aware that you will be passing out additional information regarding role responsibilities 5 minutes before the shoot.
Instructor Notes Distribute the Role Instructions and required forms. Example: Have all shooters (one from each team) meet with you. Pass out the Shooter instructions. Limit the number of questions you’ll answer. Then call up the Inspectors,… 5 Minutes before Shoot The team members should be reading over their instructions, and finalizing their positions and preparing to start the round 1 shoot. The customer wants 20 balls in 5 minutes. Takt time=300 seconds/20 units=15 START THE EXERCISE SIMULTANEOUSLY FOR ALL TEAMS! During the Simulation Keep a stopwatch running on the projection screen for yourself and time the exercise because the Customer Liaisons will be coming to you to deliver balls in batches of 5 and may be asking you for the time of first delivery, time to complete exercise, etc. Remember to keep a penalty/fine sheet with you so you can make sure proper procedures are being followed. If not give the team a $50-200 fine. Look at the delivered balls to make sure that they are being delivered with no dots on them. Don’t accept a delivery if a ball has a blue or red sticker. Send all 5 balls back and fine the team $100. When a team makes its 4 th delivery (20 passed balls), make sure they mark their final delivery time. Keep your clock running until all of the teams are finished.
Instructor Notes For Round 1 it’s recommended to do the calculations as a class. Each team will use their data (collected real time during the shoot) for this exercise. It is suggested that the clock runs until all teams deliver 20 balls to the customer. Instructors can create additional chaos by designating specific balls as damaged or obsolete. (Or for example change the requirements in the middle of the exercise and say that all blue balls cannot be used)
Whole group exercise – document problems on Easel or White board and keep for later. Should be written as process problems that can be sorted by WASTE or VARIATION. Variation – Be Sure to include Statapult unstable Measurement system inaccurate (observing where ball lands) Difficult for shooter to measure 167 each time Waste No need to calibrate every time No talking No helping Stickers waste Work stoppage waste Biggest problem? – Didn’t meet customer requirement of 20 balls in 5 minutes
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date ICONS
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date The WHO AM I? GAME: Write down an interesting but lesser known fact about yourself on a post-it note. Make sure that you do not mind sharing what you write with the class! Write your name on the note. Fold the Post-It note twice into a small square. An instructor will collect the “Who am I’s” We will draw one or two at the breaks and each team will try to guess who the person is. If you guess correctly – 50 points. If the person is in your group and no team guesses correctly – 100 points.
Lean Six Sigma, and Theory of constraints are a set of principles, disciplines, and tools that are used together to do one thing – improve the speed and quality of a process. Overall the purpose of Lean tools is to eliminate waste to go faster.*** The purpose of Six Sigma tools is to ensure that we don’t leave quality in the dust.**** Finally, the Theory of Constraints focuses our attention to bottlenecks and how to deal with them. Using them together, you can drive performance and quality improvements ***Paul Example*** - Like writing a Novel – iterative process. Each review has a narrow scope of what you are looking for: Plot, Character Development, Language choices,.. Applying different tools to same process is similar.
It is a practice that makes common sense common practice – and more importantly, when deployed across the entire organization, like it is here in VC, creates a culture of wanting to improve our services and having the measures to know that we did . Lean, which focuses on eliminating waste to reduce cycle times; its about improving flow to increase speed Six Sigma , which focuses on reducing variation to ensure a standard, quality output ; applies scientific principles to find, measure, analyze, improve and control improvements. Both employ: An emphasis on customer satisfaction, a culture of continuous improvement, the search for root causes, and comprehensive employee involvement.
John Wooden: (Only Person in Hall of Fame as Player & Coach) 10 Championships in 12 years, 88 consecutive games, As player: All-American 3 times, National Champ
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date Key Points: Instead of having to tell everyone, all they have to do is look All people participate ***Paul Example*** : Fireman and Pit crews cannot afford any wasted steps.
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date This image demonstrates how Lean Six Sigma differs in its approach to a traditional process. Describe slide. Lean pre-defines value added for purposes of analysis. This way decisions are based on definitions and not opinions. (VA = The customer is willing to pay for it. It changes the form, fit or function of the material or information. It is done right the first time - not rework) There are 8 kinds of waste: Overproduction Waiting Defects Transportation Over Processing Unnecessary Inventory Unnecessary Motion Human capacity
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date Traditional approach is to adjust activities – in other words – how can we improve what we are doing? Lean asks that we recognize waste – wherein lies hidden costs – This is not always easy to do…
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date This image demonstrates how Lean Six Sigma differs in its approach to a traditional process. Describe slide. Lean pre-defines value added for purposes of analysis. This way decisions are based on definitions and not opinions. (VA = The customer is willing to pay for it. It changes the form, fit or function of the material or information. It is done right the first time - not rework) There are 8 kinds of waste: Overproduction Waiting Defects Transportation Over Processing Unnecessary Inventory Unnecessary Motion Human capacity
These are the 5 Lean Principles A Principle (American Heritage Dictionary): A basic or essential quality determining ..characteristic behavior. As you recall, we talked about Lean Thinkers and how thought drives beliefs that define your principles that drive your behavior. When we are ready, we will use Lean Principles to drive our behavior – that is how we approach a process problem: We will, with the help of a facilitator: Always be clear about who our customer is, care about their reality is, and understand their needs (can be many customers and many values) Then you really see how the work is done – you observe activities, connections, and flows You then analyze it with the idea of removing waste and redesigning it to improve it’s flow Then we will give provide that product or service based on customer requirements, rather than based sender’s process Finally, we will not sit on our laurels, but rather continuously work to get better How we manage changes will be critical to our team. If we adopt the Lean Principles, we can give people the language that explains their thinking, give them new experiences that outweigh the old ones, and help people to reflect and internalize the new thinking. Inherent in every step is PDCA. The tools in the specifying customer value and identifying the value stream are planning and checking activities. Achieving Flow and establishing pull are “doing and acting” activities, and Seeking perfection is a concept that embraces all four elements. One of the great benefits of Lean Principles is what we call “Learning to See” – I’ll give you an example.
Voice of the Customer – ***Paul Example***: BMW transfers programmed radio preferences from your old car to your new one. ***Paul Example***: Grapefruit story – shopper wants half a grapefruit…worker complains to boss and says this “crazy” lady want to buy only half. Lady overhears worker and worker quickly says, but that’s OK because this nice lady here wants to buy the other half. (Lesson: listen to what the customer wants)
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date Six Sigma attends to Quality. It asks – Where does Variation exist? Definition of “variation” (Business Dictionary): “Inevitable change in the output or result of a process because all systems vary over time. Two major types of variations are (1) Common, which is inherent in a system, and (2) Special, which is caused by changes in the circumstances or environment.” IN LAYMAN TERMS – If a process has too many shifts or changes in its behavior, you will have poor quality. Six Sigma uses tools that will look for where variation exists, and why it exists. It will seek the “root cause” of a problem before attempting to resolve it. While we may not all seek six-sigma perfection, we can all focus on Operational Excellence and use the Six Sigma principles.
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date If you think 99% is good enough, then you agree that all of these things listed are ok. If you deal with large volumes then 99% is a lot. At the shipyard we deal with small volumes of ships but large volumes of paperwork, etc. A six sigma process produces only 3 defective products out of a million Motorola is a six sigma company. Since they have a six sigma process they have chosen to not even inspect their cell phones before they leave the facility. They figure that if you get one of the 3 out of a million defect ones then they will just replace it, which is cheaper for them Audience Question : What are the key points of Six Sigma? Reduce variability Centered (on target) Customer Value POINT OUT SIX SIGMA BOOK
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date What are some sources of variability from the Statapult exercise? ***Paul Examples*** Information unavailability (Employee ID, Acct #) Fed Ex-Schedule, Status, Trash; PR/PO, Verizon FIOS) Equipment & tools unavailability (twist key, coworker login) Poor priority management (hot jobs) Low process yields (low quality – rework, hot dogs) Material condition not as expected (have to send back) Unique/custom products Change notices, holds, customer changes (Hospital) Vacations, illness, Laker games (personnel) Many, many more...
In Six Sigma, we subject our problems through what we in the business call “DMAIC”. Under each of these discipline steps, are lean, six sigma, and TOC tools. Define – helps us to be clear about what we are seeking to improve and why. Measuring gives us further clarity – this is where the tools give us the ability to begin to see with new eyes. We analyze what we see – again using L6S tools – we deal with our constraints and finally, We design a new improved state. After we have implemented, we then use control tools to ensure that the new process works, and how to make any necessary adjustments. Can we see PDCA here?
The Yield is a function of each variable that goes into the process. Look for variables (x’s) where there is variation (or waste).
Monuments
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date Let participants know that in the Yellow Belt training the focus is on the team member roles. There is Champion training available for those who will be Champions or Team Leaders. ICONS
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date
Along with the fist belief that we have a system of work, it is important to recognize that tools do not have solutions – people do . Lean Six Sigma tools themselves cannot fix a problem or feel committed to a solution enough to act on it – only people can do that . It also must be said that tools do not have solutions – people do . Lean Six Sigma is not a panacea for all problems – it will not solve discipline issues, it will not save a program, it will not restructure your organization. It can influence all those things, but it Lean Six Sigma is designed to solve process issues. Lean Six Sigma tools themselves cannot fix a problem or feel committed to a solution enough to act on it – only people can do that . We have to turn that mental corner and believe together. In other words, we have to be willing to put on the lens of Lean Six Sigma and Learn to see with a new perspective. Before we attempt to use Lean Six Sigma to solve a problem, we need to address the fact that it’s important that we all first believe that see a problem or opportunity before us and that we are all willing to do something about it. Buy-in is not enough! No one want you to be behind this because - behind is just behind! What do leaders do – they lead! That position is in front ! Leaders have to think first and behave differently before they can ask their staff to behave differently. One way to check in with yourself, is after you have deployed, ask yourself , what % of your work has changed in content or method each month. Over time, you should find yourself not being able to help yourself – you can’t help but build robust systems, you can’t help but want to re-think processes, you can’t help but want to eliminate waste everyday. So Lean is not from what we know, or what we see – it is what we think and what we believe. And that needs to start with you the leaders. When you decide to use Lean Six Sigma, you will ask a team subject the problem to Lean Principles and Six Sigma Discipline. Then, any team will use their experience plus Lean Sigma tools to find a solution. Remember – if we cannot turn the corner, then “little by little, the process can return to the prior state!” Belief check: #9
Est. Cycle time – 30 seconds Points to Cover Where to find Team Members In the Process Internal Customers Stakeholder Suppliers External Customers- Example: lawyer reviewing documents; IT reviewing specs Instructor notes for study Team members come from the pool of critical and essential stakeholders. Ideal size for a team is 3-5 people. Extended team members who are Subject Matter Experts are drawn from remaining stakeholder communities .
Before we go any further, it is imperative that we recognize the People aspect of Change. No tool will generate change in any system without its people. The value of people-system-and technology must each be solidified before we move forward. We as managers must ask ourselves if WE are ready to embark on change And the first place we have to look at culture is by looking at ourselves!
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date Should be starting this Module right after lunch ICONS
Est. Cycle time – 30 seconds Points to Cover – Discuss bullets but don’t add detail, next slide has example. Instructor notes for study
Est. Cycle time – 30 seconds Points to Cover – Read example of bad problem statement and then read example of better statement A good problem statements should clearly address the WHAT WHERE WHEN EXTENT IMPACT of the problem or improvement opportunity. Instructor notes for study
Evaluating the SIPOC components allows the team to filter down the scope of their focus to the areas that contribute most to the variance in the output
Red X’s = sources of variance But more than that: Red X’s are the source’s of variance that have the biggest impact on the Y Could verbally describe an example without doing an entire exercise:
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date ICONS
Discuss the good handoffs where there is one inbound and one outbound. Point out the possible waste (constraints) at the points where there is a cluster of handoffs to and from the same point.
to Sim notes
Refer to Sim notes
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date ICONS
Est. Cycle time – 30 seconds Points to Cover – Read objectives and a couple of the activities. Stress “leadership approval” review Instructor notes for study
Note: You may need to ask “Why” more or less than 5 times depending on the problem.
5 Why’s – Why is the measurement system inaccurate for the Statapult exercise
First identify a problem and the effect that it is having (right side) Traditional Manufacturing Common Causes: (6 M’s – Materials, Methods, Machines, Measurements, Mother nature, Manpower (people). Common Causes in Office Setting: (6 P’s – People, Process, Policy, Plant, Program, Product) *goal is to provide some structure to the search for root causes of the problem, categories can vary. Grouping the causes helps generate more ideas and lets you more easily recognize trends and opportunities. Causes can be identified by brainstorming or observation. Describe a short example: Late to work – Possible causes, power outage at home, alarm clock didn’t sound, snow storm, too tired to get up, …
First identify a problem and the effect that it is having (right side) Traditional Manufacturing Common Causes: (6 M’s – Materials, Methods, Machines, Measurements, Mother nature, Manpower (people). Common Causes in Office Setting: (6 P’s – People, Process, Policy, Plant, Program, Product) *goal is to provide some structure to the search for root causes of the problem, categories can vary. Grouping the causes helps generate more ideas and lets you more easily recognize trends and opportunities. Causes can be identified by brainstorming or observation. Describe a short example: Late to work – Possible causes, power outage at home, alarm clock didn’t sound, snow storm, too tired to get up, …
Exercise – have teams list examples of waste in their processes.
Go back to the list of problems with the Statapult exercise Mark each problem as either Waste (Lean) or Variation (Six Sigma) For the Lean problems which of the 8 common waste types is each item listed?
The 8 Wastes that have been defined are all waste in the eyes of the customer. They do not meet the criteria above for “Value Added” activity. Now lets look at the current state process with this in mind. **Approximately 2:30 pm
Do not improve yet.
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date ICONS
Sort Straighten Shine Standardize Safety
***Paul Example*** Like our family Honda Minivan Impossible – Door will not open all the way when gas tank is open Harder – Car beeps when you open the door while keys are still in ignician Obvious – If trunk not closed all the way – Cannot remotely lock doors (Should have made it impossible – Toyota trunk, auto retract)
Note: this round you are measuring the distance of shoots to be used later.
Instructor Notes Entire group exercise Review the new requirements and (using their Value Analysis of the Current State Map) begin laying out the new process using butcher paper and sticky notes (or in some cases by rearranging and removing sticky notes from the Current State Map) Ideal State Map Assign new roles/responsibilities Implement a new measurement system (to the nearest ½ inch) Come up with innovative ideas for improvement (participants should be considering changes to the supply and delivery steps as well)
Instructor Notes The customer wants 20 balls in 5 minutes. Takt time=300 seconds/20 units=15 START THE EXERCISE SIMULTANEOUSLY FOR ALL TEAMS! During the Simulation Keep a stopwatch running on the projection screen. There’s no requirement to deliver balls in batches. Most teams should be going to one piece flow. Remember to keep a penalty/fine sheet with you so you can make sure proper procedures are being followed. If not give the team a $50-200 fine. INSTRUCTOR NOTES DURING EXERCISE Teams must deliver 20 Teams may keep deliveries onsite if this arrangement was made with the customer. Arrangements may also be made with supply for on-site delivery. This round introduces customer requirement changes. Stop the process 1.5 minutes into the round and inform the teams that the target area has changed from 6” x 12” to 4” x 8”. Give teams time to change the target area but DO NOT STOP THE CLOCK. Any balls already delivered to the customer are OK. Any balls not yet delivered have to meet new requirements (hits within 4” x 8” target). If team can document that a specific ball already shot and not delivered passes new requirement they will be acceptable.
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date ICONS
Est. Cycle time – 50 seconds Points to Cover – Read objectives and a couple of the activities. Very important to prepare a “project transition plan” . If you don’t transition the completed project over to the process owners, you may be called to address issues concerning the “new process” Stress “leadership approval” review Instructor notes for study
GREEN BELT Instructor Guide Published Date
First, we should be very proud of what we do. As public servants, we make roads, we keep our community safe, we protect our resources, we help the poor, we attend to the sick and elderly. Don’t let anyone ever make you feel less of an employee because you work for the government. Second, we should be very proud of where we are on this journey. We should believe that lean government is achievable. If President Kennedy can ask us to put a man on the moon even when the technology to do that didn’t even exist, we can surely fix a few processes, right!? Go to the website and get educated. Get your proof! Find an outcome in an agency you are working with or in a process that would affect your agency and build a story around it. Tell that story over and over. Attend a training – talk to your leadership and see where you will best fit in. Look around at what you are doing – or what your agencies are doing – what can be improved? How would it tie to their performance measures and benchmarks? (if applicable) Finally – Be a living example! “You will find no better way to coach employees on what the new culture must look like than by how you carry yourself.” Pritchett/Pound. Any employee should be able to get a refresher course simply by watching you work! BELIEVE that this is a program that is beneficial to us all – stay positive – positive in attitude and positive in the knowledge that we are on the path excellence. as a way of doing business.