3. Questions for Discussion
1. What features distinguish
“Modern Humans (MHs)” from
other animals?
– Anatomical: brain mass, bipedal
locomotion, etc.
– Artifacts: inventions, e.g. tools,
weapons, etc.
– Abstract: intelligence, knowledge,
advanced civilization …Spirit?
2. When/how did “MHs” appear?
– Was it sudden or gradual?
– Was it a single event or a
multistep process?
– Was it random, natural process or
special creation?
The fossil record is a
major stumbling block
for some Christians
4. The Term Human has Different Meanings
• Humans (confusing term)
– Individual of the genus Homo,
especially Homo sapiens.
– The only existing species of the
Hominid family.
• Homo Sapiens
– Characterized by brain capacity
of ~ 1400 cc dependent upon
language and the creation and
utilization of complex tools
• Homo Sapien Sapiens
– Only existing species of homo
genus, subspecies of homo
sapiens, i.e. modern humans
– Appeared ~ 50,000 YA
Taxonomy: science of describing,
classifying, and naming organisms
5. • Darwinian Evolution Hypothesis: “Humans (Homo sapiens) are
primates of the Hominin family, and the only extant species of the genus
Homo.”
Hominid (Hominin) Family*
*Remember, this is
the secular, random,
undirected, approach
based on anatomy
Hominin cranial
capacity vs. time.
Encyclopedia
Britannica, Inc.
Modern humans are
Homo sapien spiens
10. What is Modern Human (MH) Intelligence?
• Intelligence* is a property of the
mind that includes:
1. Abstract thought
2. Complex ideas & inventions
3. Symbolic logic & mathematics
4. Self-awareness
5. Planning
6. Reasoning
7. Problem solving
It is dramatically
different than
animal
intelligence
*Caveat: Logical/mathematical and
verbal/linguistic intelligence
Language is critical
11. What is Animal Intelligence?
• Chimps make tools and hunt in organized groups.
Lab experiments show chimps are capable of
empathy, altruism and self-awareness.
• This dolphin in Australia uses a sponge (tool) to
protect her snout when foraging on the seafloor, a
behavior that is passed on from mother to daughter.
• This Asian elephant appears to recognize herself
in the mirror. This behavior is shared only with
humans, great apes and dolphins.
• Crows fashion tools from twigs and other bits of
debris to snare food from hard-to-reach places.
• This dog discriminated between photos of dogs
landscapes - an indication he was able to form the
concept of "dog“ (self-awareness)
Are these tools really complex inventions?
Was self-awareness motivated by reward?
12. Other Ways We Are Unique
• Creativity/innovation
– What is the source?
– Answer from several disciplines has
converged on a key answer: language
• Language gives us access to information in
the brains of other humans.
• Collective learning - we are like
networked computers. Language
allows us to exploit this unique
characteristic
– We bring in multiple disciplines to
solve problems
Prof David Christian
15. Special Creation Stages
• Genesis 1:26: Then God said, “Let Us make [ asah] man
in Our image, according to Our likeness; and let them
rule over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the sky
and over the cattle and over all the earth, and over every
creeping thing that creeps on the earth.
• Genesis 1:27: God created [bara] man in His own
image, in the image of God He created [bara] him; male
and female He created [bara] them.
• Genesis 2:7: Then the LORD God formed [yatsar] man
of dust from the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the
breath of life; and man became a living being.
The Hebrew word bara is often translated "create".
The Hebrew word asah is often translated "make".
The Hebrew word yatsar is often translated "form".
18. Anatomically
Modern
Humans
In paleoanthropology, anatomically
modern humans[4] (AMH) are members
of the species Homo sapiens with an
appearance consistent with modern
humans.
Anatomically modern humans evolved
about 200,000 years ago.[5]
4. Nitecki, Matthew H. and Nitecki, Doris V. (1994).
Origins of Anatomically Modern Humans. Springer.
5. Bradshaw, John L. (1997). Human Evolution: A
Neuropsychological Perspective. Psychology Press.
pp. 185–. ISBN 978-0-86377-505-5.
19. “Modern” Human Behavior vs. Anatomy
• “Within the grand scope of human* evolution,
symbolic behavior was a very recent
innovation.”
• “Before 50,000 years ago, human anatomy
and human behavior appear to have evolved
relatively slowly, more or less in concert.”
• “After 50,000 years ago, anatomical evolution
all but ceased, while behavioral evolution
accelerated dramatically.”
*In this context
human = hominid
23. • An invention is a
novel device, method,
composition or
process
• It a creative process
that requires
intelligence*.
• A discovery is a
previously unknown
product of the workings
of nature.
What is an Invention?
• We will use inventions to
measure intelligence
25. First Evidence of Complexity
“The flutes, made from bird
bone and mammoth ivory,
come from a cave in southern
Germany …”
“Scientists used carbon dating
to show that the flutes were
between 42,000 and 43,000
years old.” BBC 25 May 2012
Divje Babe flute is a
cave bear femur pierced
found in 1995 and dated
at 43,000 years ago.
First Bow and Arrow: The
earliest evidence from
Western Europe ~ 40,000
years ago. In 30,000 B.C.,
artists left cave paintings of
the bow and arrow.
Complexity generates emergent properties
Examples: crude musical instruments,
earth-fired pottery and bow and arrow.
China 18,000 years old
26. Onset Advanced Civilization
YEARS AGO Milestones more accurate
12,000 Domestication of animals
10,000 Agriculture invented
8000 Weaving
7000 Irrigation systems developed in the Middle East.
6000 First use of metals - copper smelted for making tools.
5500
Bronze, copper tin alloy, for making weapons and tools
Wheel appears in Mesopotamia by Sumerians
Writing (Cuneiform) invented by Sumerians
5000 Abacus invented by the Chinese.
Jomon pottery
dated 10,500 BC
Extensive evidence of Complexity
OnsetAdvanced
Rapid change in Mesopotamia
27. Mesopotamia: First Agrarian Civilization
1. 10,000 BC: Domestication of animals
2. 8,000 BC: Agriculture begins -
farmers settle in fertile river valleys,
produce surplus food leading to small
settlements
3. 6000 BC: Sumerians and Egyptians
use irrigation to farm large areas of
land in the fertile crescent.
4. Next Threshold: Rapid (Explosion)
of Advanced Civilizations 3,500 BC
Genesis 2:15 The Lord God took the man and put him in the Garden of Eden to work it
and take care of it.
Genesis 1:26 Then God said, "Let us make mankind in our image, in our likeness, so that
they may rule over the fish in the sea and the birds in the sky, over the livestock and all
the wild animals
28. Complex Invention in Mesopotamia
• 3300 BC – Cuneiform uses pictures for words and
inscribes them on clay tablets.
• 3300 BC – Metallurgy first bronze - an alloy of tin
and copper
• 3200 BC - Sumerians use the wheel on vehicles
• 3000 BC - Sumerians invent mathematics using a
base 60 number system
• 3000 BC - Looms for weaving fabric began
1 Kings 7:32 The four wheels were under the panels, and
the axles of the wheels were attached to the stand. The
diameter of each wheel was a cubit and a half.
Genesis 4:22 Zillah also had a son, Tubal-Cain, who forged
all kinds of tools out of bronze and iron.
2 Kings 23:7 … the quarters where women did weaving for
Asherah