SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 6
Download to read offline
Recurrent IVF failure: other factors
Alan S. Penzias, M.D.
Boston IVF, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Waltham, Massachusetts




IVF failure is a problem for a couple in the singular but can be a tragedy in the plural. Recurrent IVF failure has multiple known causes but many which are
not routinely considered as part of the posttreatment analysis. The reason is there are several causes associated with lifestyle and other causes related to
pre-existing conditions that have only a tenuous or no apparent connection to fertility. This article examines the impact of obesity, cigarette smoke,
uterine anatomy, body mass index, thyroid dysfunction, immune factors, the hereditary and acquired thrombophilias, and embryo transfer technique
on recurrent IVF failure. (Fertil SterilÒ 2012;97:1033–8. Ó2012 by American Society for Reproductive Medicine.)
Key Words: Recurrent IVF failure, ART, obesity, fibroids, cigarette smoke




PROBABILITY,                                         future. Often, they provide the public                significantly to predictive models of
METEOROLOGY, AND IVF                                 with the odds of an event occurring,                  outcome. The list of other factors con-
                                                     much like I do when meeting with a pa-                tained herein is incomplete but grow-
Whenever I quote statistics to an indi-
                                                     tient at the time of embryo transfer.                 ing. When this elusive list is finally
vidual patient regarding her likelihood
                                                          If the meteorologist tells me that               complete, perhaps then we will be able
of having a baby, I have at my disposal
                                                     there is a 65% chance of rain, I                      to forecast the outcome with 100%
direct knowledge of her medical his-
                                                     shouldn't be surprised when the clouds                certainty.
tory, past successes or failures and in-
                                                     roll in and the raindrops fall. However, I
formation about other patients I've
                                                     know that I will be pleased if the 35%
treated and their outcomes. I talk about
                                                     chance of sunshine rules the day. That's              OBESITY
her personal odds in the setting of
                                                     a single day and just about everyone                  The World Health Organization (WHO)
population statistics. There are many
                                                     can accept whichever outcome occurs.                  defines overweight as a body mass in-
quotes about statistics, what they hide
                                                     If my weeklong holiday is punctuated                  dex (BMI) equal to or more than 25,
and what they reveal, and many times
                                                     by 7 consecutive days of rain despite                 and obesity as a BMI equal to or more
gambling analogies are invoked as
                                                     the 35% chance of sun forecast daily,                 than 30. According to the WHO, one
a comparator. How many times a tossed
                                                     I begin to doubt their forecasting abil-              billion adults are overweight and
coin will land heads or tails; the odds of
                                                     ity. The lack of sun in any of 7 days                 more than 300 million are obese. Once
red or black at the Roulette table, etc.
                                                     seems improbable despite the forecast                 associated with high-income countries,
None of these analogies seems to im-
                                                     odds of only 1 chance in 3 each day.                  obesity is now also prevalent in low-
press, amuse, or otherwise satisfy a pa-
                                                          My ability to accept the weather                 and middle-income countries (1). Ap-
tient looking to me for answers when
                                                     outcome on a single day but my rejec-                 proximately one third of U.S. adults
she has completed an IVF cycle that
                                                     tion of a string of 7 such days is proba-             are obese and in 2010, 12 states had
has not resulted in a baby.
                                                     bly attributable to human nature. Why                 an obesity prevalence of 30% or more
    I've now turned to meteorology for
                                                     was the weather forecaster unable to                  (2). The lay press has devoted many pa-
some answers. Much like IVF where
                                                     tell me that there would be 7 consecu-                ges to the negative health conse-
a positive or negative outcome has
                                                     tive days of rain? Clearly, the model                 quences of obesity but with regard to
a cause, so does the weather. Weather
                                                     was lacking data on an important fac-                 fertility, most press coverage regarding
is not random; there are forces, condi-
                                                     tor or factors that shifted the true                  female obesity focuses on disorders of
tions and factors that determine where
                                                     odds beyond the 65:35 split churned                   ovulation and polycystic ovary syn-
rain will fall and when, whether it will
                                                     out by the existing formula.                          drome. One of the earliest studies on
be warm or cool, sunny or cloudy,
                                                          When it comes to predicting IVF                  the subject of BMI and IVF outcome
windy or still. Meteorologists use so-
                                                     outcomes, we know that oocyte                         found no difference when 76 patients
phisticated models of past history and
                                                     biology, embryonic development and                    with a BMI >27.9 were compared to
current circumstances to predict the
                                                     endometrial receptivity contribute                    152 normal controls; or 35 under-
                                                                                                           weight patients (BMI <19) were com-
Received January 16, 2012; revised and accepted March 14, 2012; published online March 28, 2012.           pared to 70 normal controls (3). In
A.S.P. has nothing to disclose.                                                                            2003 a study by Doody et al. (4), the in-
Reprint requests: Alan S. Penzias, M.D., Boston IVF, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, 130 Second
     Avenue, Waltham, MA 02451 (E-mail: alan.penzias@bostonivf.com).                                       vestigators stratified 822 women over
                                                                                                           four WHO BMI categories with mean
Fertility and Sterility® Vol. 97, No. 5, May 2012 0015-0282/$36.00
Copyright ©2012 American Society for Reproductive Medicine, Published by Elsevier Inc.
                                                                                                           age range of 33.1 to 33.7 years and
doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2012.03.017                                                                       demonstrated lower pregnancy and

VOL. 97 NO. 5 / MAY 2012                                                                                                                              1033
VIEWS AND REVIEWS


implantation rates in women with BMI >35. Ryley et al. (5)
                                                                                  FIGURE 1
confirmed these findings the following year in a study of
6,827 cycles in women whose ages averaged 35.2–36.6 years
(Table 1).
     Bellver et al. (6) evaluated 6500 cycles in which only 6.4%
(419) were conducted in women with a BMI >30 (mean 33.6).
An additional comorbidity in the study population was ciga-
rette smoking among roughly one-third of the group. The au-
thors demonstrated a similar number of oocytes retrieved, and
no differences in the fertilization rate, day of embryo transfer
(ET), or mean number of embryos transfered or cryopreserved.
In addition, there was similar embryo quality in all the BMI
groups. However, the implantation rate, pregnancy rate and
live birth rate were clearly and adversely affected by elevated
BMI (Fig. 1).
     In 2007, the first U.S. national data set study was con-
ducted by the Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology
(SART) (7). In that year, height and weight fields were added
to the Clinic Online Reporting System, permitting calculation                      Implantation, pregnancy, and live birth rates in IVF-ICSI cycles
                                                                                   according to the women's BMI. Each point represents percentages
of BMI. The 345 member clinics comprised more than 90% of                          and 95% CI.
all centers performing ART in the U.S. The authors limited                         Penzias. Recurrent IVF failure. Fertil Steril 2012.
analysis to cycles where one or more embryos were trans-
fered, and both height and weight were recorded. A total of
45,163 cycles were analyzed. The investigators found that
higher BMI was associated with lower clinical pregnancy                           comes between groups when thawed cryopreserved embryos
rates, especially in women under age 35 using their own oo-                       were transfered. The authors offer an explanation for the cu-
cytes. The adverse effects of high BMI were mitigated by the                      rious success of obese men and normal weight females and
use of donor oocytes.                                                             cite a study by the Robert Koch Institute (9), which associates
     While all of the aforementioned studies focused exclu-                       the combination with couples of higher social status. The au-
sively on female obesity, the largest study to date by Kupka                      thors postulate ‘‘the increased pregnancy rate in this group
et al. (8) included men. The investigators analyzed 12 years                      might as well be related to other lifestyle factors associated
of data (1997–2008) from the national German IVF Registry.                        with higher social status.’’
A total of 706,360 cycles from as many as 120 centers were                             Overall, while some smaller studies have not found an as-
included, from which 650,452 cycles where information con-                        sociation between elevated BMI and pregnancy outcome, the
cerning weight was given were analyzed. Obesity, defined as                        preponderance of data including two national data sets
BMI >30, was assigned to four groups: none, female, male or                       clearly demonstrates the negative impact of elevated BMI
both. Compared to non-obese couples (28.15%), the highest                         on achievement of pregnancy through ART. An important fi-
clinical pregnancy rate in fresh IVF cycles was found in cou-                     nal distinction to be made about obesity is that while it is
ples with an obese male partner (30.38%, P¼ .0028). In the                        known to be associated with lower per cycle pregnancy and
group of obese women, the pregnancy rate decreased to                             delivery rates, it is not, by itself, a cause of recurrent implan-
27.2%. There was no statistically significant difference in out-                   tation failure.


 TABLE 1

 IVF outcome stratified by BMI.
 Characteristic                                 All cycles   BMI <20   BMI 20–24.9        BMI 25–29.9                 BMI 30–34.9        BMI >35       P value
 n (total)                                       6827          466       3605                  1632                         724            400
 Age (y), mean                                     36.5         36.3       36.6                  36.6                        36.2           35.2      < .0001a
 BMI, mean                                         24.9         18.9       22.1                  26.8                        31.8           37.4         N/A
 Cycles/patient                                     2.7          2.6        2.6                   2.7                         2.7            2.6        .14
 Peak estradiol                                  1290         1424       1333                  1222                        1233           1135        < .0001b
 No. of mature follicles                            6.1          6.0        6.1                   6.0                         6.2            6.2        .34
 No. of oocytes retrieved                           9.4          9.5        9.4                   9.4                         9.4            8.7        .18
 No. of mature oocytes                              7.7          7.7        7.8                   7.7                         7.8            7.2        .35
 No. of embryos transfered                          2.6          2.5        2.6                   2.6                         2.6            2.5        .56
 Implantation rate (%)                             18           20         19                    20                          18             13        < .0001a
 Clinical pregnancy rate (%)                       28.3         32.9       31.4                  27.6                        27.9           21.8      < .0001a
 a
     BMI >35 group vs. all other groups.
 b
     BMI >35 group vs. all groups with BMI 25 and higher.
 Penzias. Recurrent IVF failure. Fertil Steril 2012.



1034                                                                                                                                     VOL. 97 NO. 5 / MAY 2012
Fertility and Sterility®


CIGARETTE SMOKE                                                  FIGURE 2
The incidence of cigarette smoking in the U.S. population
dropped by half between 1965 and 2006; 42% to 20.8% of
adults (10). Unfortunately this decrease is not uniform world-
wide. Though male smokers outnumber female 5:1, the 20.8%
in the U.S. population still represents a very large number of
individuals, many of who are trying to become pregnant.
     In their meta-analysis, Waylen et al. (11) evaluated 17
studies and showed in aggregate significantly lower odds of
live birth per cycle (OR 0.54, 95% CI 0.30–0.99), and signifi-
cantly higher odds of spontaneous miscarriage (OR 2.65,
95% CI 1.33–5.30) in women who smoked. This is very power-
ful data that demonstrate an entirely preventable cause of IVF
failure. Women who smoke cigarettes should be strongly
counseled that smoking cuts their odds of live birth nearly
in half and increases their odds of miscarriage by 265%.          Pregnancy rate and implantation rate following IVF for controls
     The effects of cigarette smoking are felt not just by the    without fibroids and subjects with fibroids stratified by their uterine
                                                                  position. SS ¼ subserosal; IM ¼ intramural; SM ¼ submucosal.
smokers themselves, but to women trying to become pregnant        *P<.05 for IM vs. controls or SS; **P<.005 for IM vs. controls.
who suffer from secondhand tobacco smoke (STS) exposure.          Penzias. Recurrent IVF failure. Fertil Steril 2012.
Benedict et al. (12) measured cotinine, a nicotine metabolite,
in follicular fluid collected during 3270 IVF treatment cycles
from 1909 non-smoking women between 1994 and 2003 to             2355 control cycles. The comparison showed a statistically
examine the relationship between secondhand tobacco smoke        significant 21% relative reduction in live birth rate in women
exposure and implantation failure. They reported a 52% in-       with non-cavity-distorting intramural fibroids compared
crease in the risk of implantation failure among women ex-       with women without fibroids (RR ¼ 0.79, 95% CI: 0.70–
posed to STS compared with those unexposed. They also            0.88; P¼ .0001).
found a 25% decrease in the odds for a live birth among               Somigliana et al. (16) performed a prospective study of
STS-exposed women.                                               119 cases of women with intramural (n ¼ 80) or subserosal fi-
     The summary point is that women trying to get pregnant      broids (n ¼ 39) under 50 mm and 119 controls and found no
should stop smoking, but non-smoking women, too, should          differences in embryo implantation or delivery. The small
remove themselves from chronic exposure to secondhand            sample size and the two locations of fibroids under consider-
smoke.                                                           ation may explain the variance from the findings of Sunkara
                                                                 et al. (15).
UTERINE FIBROIDS                                                      What is most striking is the paucity of literature following
                                                                 surgery to demonstrate improved IVF outcomes following
Leiomyomata have long been a source of gynecological prob-
                                                                 myomectomy. The practitioner whose patient has uterine fi-
lems for women. A number of studies have been performed
                                                                 broids that distort or enter the endometrial cavity may rea-
looking at the impact of uterine fibroids on ART outcomes.
                                                                 sonably conclude that surgical restoration of the uterine
Farhi et al. (13) studied 46 patients with uterine fibroids
                                                                 anatomy is rational given the data of negative outcomes.
who underwent 172 IVF cycles (range 1–9 attempts) between
                                                                 The mixed data on intramural fibroids allow room for clinical
1986 and 1992. The mean Æ SD age of the patients was 34.0 Æ
                                                                 judgment prior to a first attempt at IVF. In cases of recurrent
4.5 years (range 23–40) with a mean duration of infertility of
                                                                 implantation failure with no other attributable factors, surgi-
6.1 Æ 4.5 years (range 1–17). They concluded that fibroids im-
                                                                 cal removal becomes a very reasonable choice. The question
paired implantation and successful pregnancy only when the
                                                                 that remains unresolved is how large an intramural fibroid
uterine cavity was distorted. A subsequent study by Eldar-
                                                                 has to be in order to exert its negative influence.
Geva et al. (14) (Fig. 2) compared the location of uterine fi-
broids—subserosal, intramural and submucosal—to control
patients without fibroids undergoing IVF. In their series of      UTERINE ANOMALIES
88 patients undergoing 106 IVF cycles, they found that preg-     The uterine septum has been implicated as a cause of recurrent
nancy and implantation rates were significantly lower in the      pregnancy loss and its resection touted to improve outcomes
46 patients with intramural fibroids and no cavity distortion     in those affected by them. Whether infertility is caused by the
and the 9 patients with submucosal fibroids.                      presence of a uterine septum is the subject of much specula-
     In an effort to determine whether intramural fibroids are    tion. Most published works on the topic are small, uncon-
associated with lower pregnancy and live birth rates than is     trolled trials; case studies of experiences. Mollo et al.
observed in women without fibroids, Sunkara et al. (15)           recently published a controlled trial on the subject (17). The
(Fig. 3) performed a meta-analysis. The authors' search          authors compared 44 subjects (group A) with a uterine septum
yielded 19 studies that met inclusion criteria, 11 of which      and no other attributable cause of infertility to 132 women
used live birth as an endpoint. There were 1626 cycles with      (group B) with unexplained infertility. The pre-operative
non-cavity distorting intramural fibroids compared with           size of the septum was not described in the study. Following

VOL. 97 NO. 5 / MAY 2012                                                                                                                   1035
VIEWS AND REVIEWS


FIGURE 3




 Forest plot of studies of non-cavity-distorting intramural fibroids versus no fibroids in women undergoing IVF treatment for outcome of live birth
 rates.
 Penzias. Recurrent IVF failure. Fertil Steril 2012.




resection, a post-operative hysteroscopy to confirm a normal                a TSH >2.5 mIU/L compared with cycles with TSH <2.5
uterine cavity and a 12-month follow-up period, the live birth             mIU/L. TSH levels >2.5 mIU/L had a possible weak positive
rate was significantly higher in group A than in group B                    association with spontaneous abortion rate that did not reach
(34.1% and 18.9%, respectively; P< .05). The small study                   statistical significance.’’
size a) does not permit assessment of potential complications                   Reh et al. (22) found no difference in clinical pregnancy,
from surgery and b) limits one's ability to extrapolate to the             delivery or miscarriage rates in 1055 women when those with
general population.                                                        TSH <2.5 mIU/L were compared to those with TSH >2.5 mIU/L.
     The question of whether a septum plays a causative role in            Toulis et al. (23) evaluated the association between risk for
recurrent failure to become pregnant following ART is ad-                  spontaneous miscarriage in subfertile, euthyroid women with
dressed in the literature without a conclusive answer (18,                 thyroid autoimmunity (TAI) (defined as the presence of
19). The reader is left to use clinical judgment in individual             autoantibodies against thyroid peroxidase (TPOab) and/or thy-
patients with recurrent IVF failure without apparent                       roglobulin (TGab) ) undergoing IVF. They found that the risk of
explanation.                                                               miscarriage was nearly double that of women without TAI (RR:
                                                                           1.99, 95% confidence interval: 1.42–2.79, P< .001). The mech-
                                                                           anism for this association is unclear. Revelli et al. (24) compared
THYROID DYSFUNCTION                                                        129 euthyroid anti-thyroid antibody-positive (ATAþ) women
The thyroid gland is most commonly associated with meta-                   undergoing IVF to 200 matched, ATA-negative controls. Dur-
bolic rate, but it's clear that thyroid hormone is necessary               ing IVF cycle, 38 ATAþ patients did not take any adjuvant
for the normal function of numerous other body organs and                  treatment, 55 received levothyroxin (LT), and 38 received LT
tissues. The definition of hypothyroidism remains controver-                þacetylsalicylic acid (ASA) þ prednisolone (P). Patients receiv-
sial. At the present time, most laboratories report the normal             ing LTþASAþP had significantly higher pregnancy and im-
reference range of thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) level as              plantation rates than untreated ATAþ patients (PR/ET 25.6%
0.4–4.5 mIU/L. The National Academy of Clinical Biochemis-                 and IR 17.7% vs. PR/ET 7.5% and IR 4.7%, respectively), and
try, part of the Academy of the American Association for                   overall IVF results comparable to patients without ATA (PR/
Clinical Chemistry (AACC) reported in 2002 that, ‘‘In the fu-              ET 32.8% and IR 19%). The authors concluded that euthyroid
ture, it is likely that the upper limit of the serum TSH euthy-            ATAþ patients undergoing IVF could have better outcome if
roid reference range will be reduced to 2.5 mIU/L because                  given LTþASAþP as adjuvant treatment. They cautioned,
more than 95% of rigorously screened normal euthyroid vol-                 however, that this must be verified in further randomized, pro-
unteers have serum TSH values between 0.4 and 2.5 mIU/L’’                  spective studies.
(20). Thus far, the American Academy of Clinical Endocrinol-
ogists has not yet adopted this position due to insufficient
data of health improvement of cardiac, lipid and neuropsychi-              EMBRYO TRANSFER TECHNIQUE
atric function.                                                            The Cochrane Database study of ultrasound vs. clinical touch
     Baker et al. (21) evaluated the impact of TSH above or be-            for catheter guidance during embryo transfer (25) (Fig. 4) cit-
low 2.5 mIU/L on pregnancy outcome in IVF. They report that                ing 17 studies that compared 3244 ultrasound guided transfers
in ‘‘women who become pregnant through IVF, gestational                    with 3171 clinical touch showed an odds ratio of 1.31 (95% CI
age at delivery and birth weight were lower in cycles with                 1.18–1.46) in favor of ultrasound guidance. While this factor

1036                                                                                                                     VOL. 97 NO. 5 / MAY 2012
Fertility and Sterility®


FIGURE 4




 Forest plot of studies of clinical touch embyro transfer (CTET) versus ultrasound-guided embryo transfer (UGET) for outcome of clinical pregnancy
 rate.
 Penzias. Recurrent IVF failure. Fertil Steril 2012.




isn't in and of itself an independent contributor to the problem            and hereditary and acquired thrombophilias on IVF outcome.
of recurrent IVF failure, it is a factor that impacts outcomes,             The known or purported causality of phospholipid antibodies
and as such should be considered at least when evaluating                   and coagulation factors on recurrent pregnancy loss long ago
the patient who has not succeeded in multiple IVF cycles.                   spilled over into the arena of conception with IVF or more
     The techniques associated with ultrasound-guided em-                   precisely, the lack of it. Some have argued that without im-
bryo transfer vary from clinic to clinic. We have found it use-             plantation to signal the arrival of an embryo, it would be im-
ful to advise patients to consume enough liquid prior to the                probable for serum or tissue-based response elements to
procedure to create an acoustic window directly above the                   prevent implantation. Others have argued that the effect is
uterus. Bladder filling is especially helpful in obese patients              unrelated to the embryo, but rather the negative impact is
in whom imaging can be a challenge. We favor placement                      at the level of the endometrium. The Practice Committee of
of a trial catheter with an echogenic inner catheter tip to es-             the American Society for Reproductive Medicine released
tablish continuity with the internal cervical os. We leave the              a Committee Opinion in 1999 which it reviewed again in
outer sheath in place while the active transfer catheter is                 2008, ‘‘Anti-phospholipid antibodies (APA) do not affect
loaded. A second set of hands provided by an assistant in                   IVF success’’ (26). The review culled 16 peer reviewed papers,
the operating room is useful to help position the abdominal                 of which 7 included appropriate endpoints and controls. There
ultrasound probe prior to catheter placement. The physician                 was no statistically significant impact of the presence of
performing the transfer thereafter can make minor adjust-                   phospholipid antibodies on IVF outcomes when the studies
ments to the probe position.                                                were examined individually nor when the data were aggre-
     When a difficult transfer is in progress, direct visualiza-             gated in the 2,053 patients studied. The authors concluded
tion is a significant aid. There are times when it's possible                that ‘‘assessment of APA is not indicated among couples un-
to see a trial catheter stuck in a particular position and know-            dergoing IVF. Therapy is not justified on the basis of existing
ing the direction and angle of the cervical canal is a plus. Fur-           data.’’
ther, watching a catheter go in with ease but double back on                     A review was recently published on the topic of thrombo-
itself averts the problem of depositing precious embryos in the             philias and IVF outcome (27). The authors' initial search
cervical canal rather than the endometrium.                                 yielded 694 studies. Case reports, editorials, reviews, meta-
     A side benefit to the use of ultrasound-guided embryo                   analyses, studies with inadequate outcomes, absence of
transfer is patient comfort. Not so much due to an easier tech-             thrombophilia/anti-phospholipid antibodies, and more than
nique, though this can be true, and certainly not due to the full           one of the above were excluded and 33 (6,092 patients) were
bladder, but rather the patient is able to visualize the process            ultimately analyzed. They report that twenty-nine studies
thus removing one of the more mysterious elements of the IVF                (5,270 patients) assessed anti-phospholipid antibodies in
experience.                                                                 women treated with ART. The prevalence of antibodies in in-
                                                                            fertile patients varied from 0%–45%. When examining case-
                                                                            control studies, the authors write ‘‘overall, the presence of
IMMUNE FACTORS AND THROMBOPHILIAS                                           one or more anti-phospholipid antibodies was associated
Few topics in reproductive medicine elicit as many opinions                 with a 3-fold higher risk of ART failure.’’ There was a signifi-
or as much controversy as the impact of immune factors                      cant degree of heterogeneity across these case-control studies

VOL. 97 NO. 5 / MAY 2012                                                                                                                      1037
VIEWS AND REVIEWS


with some using parous controls and others using women who                              9.   Robert Koch-Institut. Gesundheitsberichterstattung des Bundes, Bundes
had achieved a live birth following ART. In addition to case-                                Gesundheitssurvey 1998. Available at: http://www.gbebund.de/gbe10/ab
                                                                                             rechnung.prc_abr_test_logon?p_uid¼gastg&p_aid¼&p_knoten¼FID&p_
control studies, the authors also evaluated cohort studies. In
                                                                                             sprache¼D&p_suchstring¼8397::BMI. Accessed December 30, 2011.
contrast to the findings of the case-control studies, analysis                          10.   Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Cigarette smoking among adults—
of cohort studies showed that anti-phospholipid antibodies                                   United States, 2006. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2007;56(44):1157–61.
were not associated with a lower rate of viable pregnancy,                             11.   Waylen AL, Metwally M, Jones GL, Wilkinson AJ, Ledger WL. Effects of cig-
live birth, or a higher incidence of negative pregnancy tests.                               arette smoking upon clinical outcomes of assisted reproduction: a meta-
     Ten of the studies in the review evaluated the relationship                             analysis. Hum Reprod Update 2009;15:31–44.
between inherited thrombophilia and ART. Seven studies                                 12.   Benedict MD, Missmer SA, Vahratian A, Berry KF, Vitonis AF, Cramer DW,
                                                                                             Meeker JD. Secondhand tobacco smoke exposure is associated with in-
were case-control, 2 were cohorts, and in 1 case-control study
                                                                                             creased risk of failed implantation and reduced IVF success. Hum Reprod
patients undergoing IVF (cases) were followed to assess the                                  2011;26:2525–31.
pregnancy outcomes. Pooled data from patients in 8 case-                               13.   Farhi J, Ashkenazi J, Feldberg D, Dicker D, Orvieto R, Ben Rafael Z. Effect of
control studies showed an overall 3-fold increased risk of                                   uterine leiomyomata on the results of in-vitro fertilization treatment. Hum
ART failure in association with factor V Leiden. In the 3 co-                                Reprod 1995;10:2576.
hort studies, there was no difference in outcome between                               14.   Eldar-Geva T, Meagher S, Healy DL, MacLachlan V, Breheny S, Wood C. Effect
                                                                                             of intramural, subserosal, and submucosal uterine fibroids on the outcome
those with and those without the factor V Leiden mutation.
                                                                                             of assisted reproductive technology treatment. Fertil Steril 1998;70:687–91.
     True to form, the conflicting findings in the literature give                       15.   Sunkara SK, Khairy M, El-Toukhy T, Khalaf Y, Coomarasamy A. The effect of
advocates and detractors of a role for phospholipid antibodies                               intramural fibroids without uterine cavity involvement on the outcome of IVF
and thrombophilias ammunition to bolster their arguments.                                    treatment: a systematic review and metaanalysis. Hum Reprod 2010;25:
The advocates can cite the case-control studies, while the de-                               418–29.
tractors can cite the cohort studies. From a methodology                               16.   Somigliana E, De Benedictis S, Vercellini P, Nicolosi AE, Benaglia L,
standpoint, both study types are Level II-2 (28) with their                                  Scarduelli C, et al. Fibroids not encroaching the endometrial cavity and IVF
                                                                                             success rate: a prospective study. Hum Reprod 2011;26:834–9.
own particular strengths and limitations. Treatment trials
                                                                                       17.   Mollo A, De Franciscis P, Colacurci N, Cobellis L, Perino A, Venezia R, et al.
similarly suffer from methodological flaws and a lack of con-                                 Hysteroscopic resection of the septum improves the pregnancy rate of
clusive answers. Level I evidence is clearly needed.                                         women with unexplained infertility: a prospective controlled trial. Fertil Steril
                                                                                             2009;91:2628–31.

CONCLUSIONS                                                                            18.   Marcus S, al-Shawaf T, Brinsden P. The obstetric outcome of in vitro fertiliza-
                                                                                             tion and embryo transfer in women with congenital uterine malformation.
It is clear that there are other factors beyond the egg, embryo                              Am J Obstet Gynecol 1996;175:85–9.
and endometrium that contribute to the success or failure of                           19.   Lavergne N, Aristizabal J, Zarka V, Erny R, Hedon B. Uterine anomalies and
an IVF cycle. These factors, if present in serial IVF cycles,                                in vitro fertilization: what are the results? Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol
may serve to diminish the actual odds of conception below                                    1996;68:29–34.
                                                                                       20.   The National Academy of Clinical Biochemistry. Laboratory medicine practice
the population-based odds estimated by patient age and ovar-
                                                                                             guidelines. Laboratory support for the diagnosis of thyroid disease, Volume
ian reserve testing alone. Our mission is twofold: 1) reduce the                             13. Washington, D.C.: The National Academy of Clinical Biochemistry; 2002.
negative impact of factors over which we have control                                  21.   Baker VL, Rone HM, Pasta DJ, Nelson HP, Gvakharia M, Adamson GD. Cor-
through treatment or behavior modification; and 2) continue                                   relation of thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) level with pregnancy outcome
our efforts to identify as yet unknown factors that prevent our                              in women undergoing in vitro fertilization. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2006;194:
patients from achieving a successful outcome.                                                1668–74.
                                                                                       22.   Reh A, Grifo J, Danoff A. What is a normal thyroid-stimulating hormone
                                                                                             (TSH) level? Effects of stricter TSH thresholds on pregnancy outcomes after
REFERENCES                                                                                   in vitro fertilization. Fertil Steril 2010;94:2920–2.
 1.   World Health Organization. Facts on Obesity. Available at: http://www.who.int/   23.   Toulis KA, Goulis DG, Venetis CA, Kolibianakis EM, Negro R, Tarlatzis BC,
      features/factfiles/obesity/facts/en/index1.html. Accessed December 30, 2011.            Papadimas I. Risk of spontaneous miscarriage in euthyroid women with thy-
 2.   Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Overweight and Obesity. Available          roid autoimmunity undergoing IVF: a meta-analysis. Eur J Endocrinol 2010;
      at: http://www.cdc.gov/obesity/data/adult.html. Accessed December 30, 2011.            162:643–52.
 3.   Lashen H, Ledger W, Bernal AL, Barlow D. Extremes of body mass do not ad-        24.   Revelli A, Casano S, Piane LD, Grassi G, Gennarelli G, Guidetti D,
      versely affect the outcome of superovulation and in-vitro fertilization. Hum           Massobrio M. A retrospective study on IVF outcome in euthyroid patients
      Reprod 1999;14:712–5.                                                                  with anti-thyroid antibodies: effects of levothyroxine, acetyl-salicylic acid
 4.   Doody KM, Langley MT, Marek DE, Nackley AC, Doody KJ. Morbid obesity                   and prednisolone adjuvant treatments. Reprod Biol Endocrinol 2009;7:137.
      adversely impacts outcomes with IVF. Fertil Steril 2003;80(Suppl 3):S160.        25.   Brown J, Buckingham K, Abou-Setta AM, Buckett W. Ultrasound versus
 5.   Ryley DA, Bayer SR, Eaton J, Zimon A, Klipstein S, Reindollar R. Influence of           ‘clinical touch’ for catheter guidance during embryo transfer in women. Co-
      body mass index (BMI) on the outcome of 6,827 IVF cycles. Fertil Steril 2004;          chrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2010;1:CD006107. doi:
      82(Suppl 2):S38–9.                                                                     10.1002/14651858.CD006107.pub3.
 6.   Bellver J, Ayllon Y, Ferrando M, Melo M, Goyri E, Pellicer A, Remohi J,          26.   Practice Committee of the ASRM. Anti-phospholipid antibodies do not affect
      Meseguer M. Female obesity impairs in vitro fertilization outcome without              IVF success. Practice Committee of the ASRM. Fertil Steril 2008;90:S172–3.
      affecting embryo quality. Fertil Steril 2010;93:447–54.                          27.   Di Nisio M, Rutjes AWS, Ferrante N, Tiboni GM, Cuccurullo F, Porreca E.
 7.   Luke B, Brown MB, Stern JE, Missmer SA, Fujimoto VY, Leach R, A SART                   Thrombophilia and outcomes of assisted reproduction technologies: a sys-
      Writing Group. Female obesity adversely affects assisted reproductive tech-            tematic review and meta-analysis. Blood 2011;18:2670–8.
      nology (ART) pregnancy and live birth rates. Hum Reprod 2011;26:245–52.          28.   The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Reading the
 8.   Kupka MS, Gnoth C, Buehler K, Dahncke W, Kruessel JS. Impact of female                 Medical Literature. Available at: http://www.acog.org/Resources_And_
      and male obesity on IVF/ICSI: results of 700,000 ART cycles in Germany. Gy-            Publications/Department_Publications/Reading_the_Medical_Literature.
      necol Endocrinol 2011;27:144–9.                                                        Accessed March 11, 2012.



1038                                                                                                                                           VOL. 97 NO. 5 / MAY 2012

More Related Content

More from Asociatia SOS Infertilitatea - www.vremcopii.ro

More from Asociatia SOS Infertilitatea - www.vremcopii.ro (20)

Apel la parteneriat revista „Ce stii despre fertilitatea ta” nr. 4, 1 nov 2021
Apel la parteneriat revista „Ce stii despre fertilitatea ta” nr. 4, 1 nov 2021Apel la parteneriat revista „Ce stii despre fertilitatea ta” nr. 4, 1 nov 2021
Apel la parteneriat revista „Ce stii despre fertilitatea ta” nr. 4, 1 nov 2021
 
Ce stii despre FERTILITATEA TA nr 3, iunie 2021, high resolution
Ce stii despre FERTILITATEA TA nr 3, iunie 2021, high resolutionCe stii despre FERTILITATEA TA nr 3, iunie 2021, high resolution
Ce stii despre FERTILITATEA TA nr 3, iunie 2021, high resolution
 
Ce stii despre FERTILITATEA TA nr 3, iunie 2021, low resolution
Ce stii despre FERTILITATEA TA nr 3, iunie 2021, low resolutionCe stii despre FERTILITATEA TA nr 3, iunie 2021, low resolution
Ce stii despre FERTILITATEA TA nr 3, iunie 2021, low resolution
 
Presentation „What do you know about YOUR FERTILITY?” magazine, Romania
Presentation „What do you know about YOUR FERTILITY?” magazine, Romania Presentation „What do you know about YOUR FERTILITY?” magazine, Romania
Presentation „What do you know about YOUR FERTILITY?” magazine, Romania
 
Apel la parteneriat revista „Ce știi despre FERTILITATEA TA?” nr 3, iunie 2021
Apel la parteneriat revista „Ce știi despre FERTILITATEA TA?” nr 3, iunie 2021Apel la parteneriat revista „Ce știi despre FERTILITATEA TA?” nr 3, iunie 2021
Apel la parteneriat revista „Ce știi despre FERTILITATEA TA?” nr 3, iunie 2021
 
Articol infertilitate revista ELLE
Articol infertilitate revista ELLEArticol infertilitate revista ELLE
Articol infertilitate revista ELLE
 
Revista Ce stii despre FERTILITATEA TA?
Revista Ce stii despre FERTILITATEA TA?Revista Ce stii despre FERTILITATEA TA?
Revista Ce stii despre FERTILITATEA TA?
 
Detalii Subprogram FIV MS 2018
Detalii Subprogram FIV MS 2018Detalii Subprogram FIV MS 2018
Detalii Subprogram FIV MS 2018
 
Statistici subprogram FIV 2019
Statistici subprogram FIV 2019Statistici subprogram FIV 2019
Statistici subprogram FIV 2019
 
Rate de succes Subprogram FIV MS 2011 - 2019
Rate de succes Subprogram FIV MS 2011 -  2019Rate de succes Subprogram FIV MS 2011 -  2019
Rate de succes Subprogram FIV MS 2011 - 2019
 
Cadru fiscal-sponsorizari-decembrie-2019-si-regimul-fiscal-al-veniturilor-ong
Cadru fiscal-sponsorizari-decembrie-2019-si-regimul-fiscal-al-veniturilor-ongCadru fiscal-sponsorizari-decembrie-2019-si-regimul-fiscal-al-veniturilor-ong
Cadru fiscal-sponsorizari-decembrie-2019-si-regimul-fiscal-al-veniturilor-ong
 
Nicoleta Cristea Brunel ESHRE Campus 2019 OHSS patients perspective
Nicoleta Cristea Brunel ESHRE Campus 2019 OHSS patients perspectiveNicoleta Cristea Brunel ESHRE Campus 2019 OHSS patients perspective
Nicoleta Cristea Brunel ESHRE Campus 2019 OHSS patients perspective
 
Globuri barza cuplu
Globuri barza cupluGloburi barza cuplu
Globuri barza cuplu
 
Header Saptamana Nationala de Constientizare a Infertilitatii
Header Saptamana Nationala de Constientizare a InfertilitatiiHeader Saptamana Nationala de Constientizare a Infertilitatii
Header Saptamana Nationala de Constientizare a Infertilitatii
 
Afis SOS Infertilitatea
Afis SOS InfertilitateaAfis SOS Infertilitatea
Afis SOS Infertilitatea
 
ART and IUI regulations, funds and registers in Europe 2018
ART and IUI regulations, funds and registers in Europe 2018ART and IUI regulations, funds and registers in Europe 2018
ART and IUI regulations, funds and registers in Europe 2018
 
Revista Ce stii despre fertilitatea ta nr 1 nov 2019
Revista Ce stii despre fertilitatea ta nr 1 nov 2019Revista Ce stii despre fertilitatea ta nr 1 nov 2019
Revista Ce stii despre fertilitatea ta nr 1 nov 2019
 
Brosura „Acesti copii care, altfel, nu ar fi existat”
Brosura „Acesti copii care, altfel, nu ar fi existat”Brosura „Acesti copii care, altfel, nu ar fi existat”
Brosura „Acesti copii care, altfel, nu ar fi existat”
 
Infertilitatea poate fi invinsa 4
Infertilitatea poate fi invinsa 4Infertilitatea poate fi invinsa 4
Infertilitatea poate fi invinsa 4
 
Infertilitatea poate fi invinsa 3
Infertilitatea poate fi invinsa 3Infertilitatea poate fi invinsa 3
Infertilitatea poate fi invinsa 3
 

Recently uploaded

Premium Villa Projects in Sarjapur Road Bengaluru
Premium Villa Projects in Sarjapur Road BengaluruPremium Villa Projects in Sarjapur Road Bengaluru
Premium Villa Projects in Sarjapur Road BengaluruShivaSeo3
 
Call Girls In Mayur Vihar Delhi ☆↫8447779280 ❤Escorts Service In Delhi
Call Girls In Mayur Vihar Delhi ☆↫8447779280 ❤Escorts Service In DelhiCall Girls In Mayur Vihar Delhi ☆↫8447779280 ❤Escorts Service In Delhi
Call Girls In Mayur Vihar Delhi ☆↫8447779280 ❤Escorts Service In Delhiasmaqueen5
 
Low Rate ↬Call Girls in Trilokpuri Delhi ↫8447779280}Escorts Service In Delhi
Low Rate ↬Call Girls in Trilokpuri Delhi ↫8447779280}Escorts Service In DelhiLow Rate ↬Call Girls in Trilokpuri Delhi ↫8447779280}Escorts Service In Delhi
Low Rate ↬Call Girls in Trilokpuri Delhi ↫8447779280}Escorts Service In Delhiasmaqueen5
 
Call Girls in Karkardooma Delhi +91 84487779280}Woman Seeking Man in Delhi NCR
Call Girls in Karkardooma Delhi +91 84487779280}Woman Seeking Man in Delhi NCRCall Girls in Karkardooma Delhi +91 84487779280}Woman Seeking Man in Delhi NCR
Call Girls in Karkardooma Delhi +91 84487779280}Woman Seeking Man in Delhi NCRasmaqueen5
 
Maha Mauka Squarefeet Brochure |Maha Mauka Squarefeet PDF Brochure|
Maha Mauka Squarefeet Brochure |Maha Mauka Squarefeet PDF Brochure|Maha Mauka Squarefeet Brochure |Maha Mauka Squarefeet PDF Brochure|
Maha Mauka Squarefeet Brochure |Maha Mauka Squarefeet PDF Brochure|AkshayJoshi575980
 
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 137 Noida (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 137 Noida (Call Girls) Delhi9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 137 Noida (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 137 Noida (Call Girls) Delhidelhimodel235
 
Kohinoor Flats In Hinjewadi Phase 2 | Homes Built To Suit Your Needs
Kohinoor Flats In Hinjewadi Phase 2 | Homes Built To Suit Your NeedsKohinoor Flats In Hinjewadi Phase 2 | Homes Built To Suit Your Needs
Kohinoor Flats In Hinjewadi Phase 2 | Homes Built To Suit Your Needsaidasheikh47
 
2k Shot Call girls Aiims Delhi 9205541914
2k Shot Call girls Aiims Delhi 92055419142k Shot Call girls Aiims Delhi 9205541914
2k Shot Call girls Aiims Delhi 9205541914Delhi Call girls
 
Majestique Viman Nagar Pune Brochure.pdf
Majestique Viman Nagar Pune Brochure.pdfMajestique Viman Nagar Pune Brochure.pdf
Majestique Viman Nagar Pune Brochure.pdfBabyrudram
 
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 2 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 2 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 2 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 2 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhidelhimodel235
 
TENANT SCREENING REPORT SERVICES​ How Tenant Screening Reports Work
TENANT SCREENING REPORT SERVICES​ How Tenant Screening Reports WorkTENANT SCREENING REPORT SERVICES​ How Tenant Screening Reports Work
TENANT SCREENING REPORT SERVICES​ How Tenant Screening Reports WorkTurbo Tenant
 
SVN Live 5.6.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 5.6.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN Live 5.6.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 5.6.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN International Corp.
 
Girls in Kalyanpuri }Delhi↫8447779280↬Escort Service. In Delhi NCR
Girls in Kalyanpuri }Delhi↫8447779280↬Escort Service. In Delhi NCRGirls in Kalyanpuri }Delhi↫8447779280↬Escort Service. In Delhi NCR
Girls in Kalyanpuri }Delhi↫8447779280↬Escort Service. In Delhi NCRasmaqueen5
 
Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi +91-8447779280! !Best Woman Seeking Man Escor...
Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi +91-8447779280! !Best Woman Seeking Man Escor...Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi +91-8447779280! !Best Woman Seeking Man Escor...
Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi +91-8447779280! !Best Woman Seeking Man Escor...asmaqueen5
 
Call girls in new Ashok NagarDelhi꧁ 8447779280꧂ Escort Service Women Seeking ...
Call girls in new Ashok NagarDelhi꧁ 8447779280꧂ Escort Service Women Seeking ...Call girls in new Ashok NagarDelhi꧁ 8447779280꧂ Escort Service Women Seeking ...
Call girls in new Ashok NagarDelhi꧁ 8447779280꧂ Escort Service Women Seeking ...asmaqueen5
 
M3M The Line Brochure - Premium Investment Opportunity for Commercial Ventures
M3M The Line Brochure - Premium Investment Opportunity for Commercial VenturesM3M The Line Brochure - Premium Investment Opportunity for Commercial Ventures
M3M The Line Brochure - Premium Investment Opportunity for Commercial Venturessheltercareglobal
 
M3M 129 E Brochure Noida Expressway, Sector 129, Noida
M3M 129 E Brochure Noida Expressway, Sector 129, NoidaM3M 129 E Brochure Noida Expressway, Sector 129, Noida
M3M 129 E Brochure Noida Expressway, Sector 129, Noidasarak0han45400
 
Purva Soukhyam in Guduvancheri Chennai.pdf
Purva Soukhyam in Guduvancheri Chennai.pdfPurva Soukhyam in Guduvancheri Chennai.pdf
Purva Soukhyam in Guduvancheri Chennai.pdfpritika141199
 
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 1 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 1 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 1 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 1 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhidelhimodel235
 
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 3 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 3 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 3 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 3 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhidelhimodel235
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Premium Villa Projects in Sarjapur Road Bengaluru
Premium Villa Projects in Sarjapur Road BengaluruPremium Villa Projects in Sarjapur Road Bengaluru
Premium Villa Projects in Sarjapur Road Bengaluru
 
Call Girls In Mayur Vihar Delhi ☆↫8447779280 ❤Escorts Service In Delhi
Call Girls In Mayur Vihar Delhi ☆↫8447779280 ❤Escorts Service In DelhiCall Girls In Mayur Vihar Delhi ☆↫8447779280 ❤Escorts Service In Delhi
Call Girls In Mayur Vihar Delhi ☆↫8447779280 ❤Escorts Service In Delhi
 
Low Rate ↬Call Girls in Trilokpuri Delhi ↫8447779280}Escorts Service In Delhi
Low Rate ↬Call Girls in Trilokpuri Delhi ↫8447779280}Escorts Service In DelhiLow Rate ↬Call Girls in Trilokpuri Delhi ↫8447779280}Escorts Service In Delhi
Low Rate ↬Call Girls in Trilokpuri Delhi ↫8447779280}Escorts Service In Delhi
 
Call Girls in Karkardooma Delhi +91 84487779280}Woman Seeking Man in Delhi NCR
Call Girls in Karkardooma Delhi +91 84487779280}Woman Seeking Man in Delhi NCRCall Girls in Karkardooma Delhi +91 84487779280}Woman Seeking Man in Delhi NCR
Call Girls in Karkardooma Delhi +91 84487779280}Woman Seeking Man in Delhi NCR
 
Maha Mauka Squarefeet Brochure |Maha Mauka Squarefeet PDF Brochure|
Maha Mauka Squarefeet Brochure |Maha Mauka Squarefeet PDF Brochure|Maha Mauka Squarefeet Brochure |Maha Mauka Squarefeet PDF Brochure|
Maha Mauka Squarefeet Brochure |Maha Mauka Squarefeet PDF Brochure|
 
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 137 Noida (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 137 Noida (Call Girls) Delhi9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 137 Noida (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 137 Noida (Call Girls) Delhi
 
Kohinoor Flats In Hinjewadi Phase 2 | Homes Built To Suit Your Needs
Kohinoor Flats In Hinjewadi Phase 2 | Homes Built To Suit Your NeedsKohinoor Flats In Hinjewadi Phase 2 | Homes Built To Suit Your Needs
Kohinoor Flats In Hinjewadi Phase 2 | Homes Built To Suit Your Needs
 
2k Shot Call girls Aiims Delhi 9205541914
2k Shot Call girls Aiims Delhi 92055419142k Shot Call girls Aiims Delhi 9205541914
2k Shot Call girls Aiims Delhi 9205541914
 
Majestique Viman Nagar Pune Brochure.pdf
Majestique Viman Nagar Pune Brochure.pdfMajestique Viman Nagar Pune Brochure.pdf
Majestique Viman Nagar Pune Brochure.pdf
 
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 2 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 2 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 2 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 2 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
 
TENANT SCREENING REPORT SERVICES​ How Tenant Screening Reports Work
TENANT SCREENING REPORT SERVICES​ How Tenant Screening Reports WorkTENANT SCREENING REPORT SERVICES​ How Tenant Screening Reports Work
TENANT SCREENING REPORT SERVICES​ How Tenant Screening Reports Work
 
SVN Live 5.6.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 5.6.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN Live 5.6.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 5.6.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
 
Girls in Kalyanpuri }Delhi↫8447779280↬Escort Service. In Delhi NCR
Girls in Kalyanpuri }Delhi↫8447779280↬Escort Service. In Delhi NCRGirls in Kalyanpuri }Delhi↫8447779280↬Escort Service. In Delhi NCR
Girls in Kalyanpuri }Delhi↫8447779280↬Escort Service. In Delhi NCR
 
Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi +91-8447779280! !Best Woman Seeking Man Escor...
Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi +91-8447779280! !Best Woman Seeking Man Escor...Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi +91-8447779280! !Best Woman Seeking Man Escor...
Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi +91-8447779280! !Best Woman Seeking Man Escor...
 
Call girls in new Ashok NagarDelhi꧁ 8447779280꧂ Escort Service Women Seeking ...
Call girls in new Ashok NagarDelhi꧁ 8447779280꧂ Escort Service Women Seeking ...Call girls in new Ashok NagarDelhi꧁ 8447779280꧂ Escort Service Women Seeking ...
Call girls in new Ashok NagarDelhi꧁ 8447779280꧂ Escort Service Women Seeking ...
 
M3M The Line Brochure - Premium Investment Opportunity for Commercial Ventures
M3M The Line Brochure - Premium Investment Opportunity for Commercial VenturesM3M The Line Brochure - Premium Investment Opportunity for Commercial Ventures
M3M The Line Brochure - Premium Investment Opportunity for Commercial Ventures
 
M3M 129 E Brochure Noida Expressway, Sector 129, Noida
M3M 129 E Brochure Noida Expressway, Sector 129, NoidaM3M 129 E Brochure Noida Expressway, Sector 129, Noida
M3M 129 E Brochure Noida Expressway, Sector 129, Noida
 
Purva Soukhyam in Guduvancheri Chennai.pdf
Purva Soukhyam in Guduvancheri Chennai.pdfPurva Soukhyam in Guduvancheri Chennai.pdf
Purva Soukhyam in Guduvancheri Chennai.pdf
 
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 1 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 1 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 1 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 1 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
 
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 3 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 3 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 3 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
9990771857 Call Girls in Dwarka Sector 3 Delhi (Call Girls) Delhi
 

Other factors IVF failure

  • 1. Recurrent IVF failure: other factors Alan S. Penzias, M.D. Boston IVF, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Waltham, Massachusetts IVF failure is a problem for a couple in the singular but can be a tragedy in the plural. Recurrent IVF failure has multiple known causes but many which are not routinely considered as part of the posttreatment analysis. The reason is there are several causes associated with lifestyle and other causes related to pre-existing conditions that have only a tenuous or no apparent connection to fertility. This article examines the impact of obesity, cigarette smoke, uterine anatomy, body mass index, thyroid dysfunction, immune factors, the hereditary and acquired thrombophilias, and embryo transfer technique on recurrent IVF failure. (Fertil SterilÒ 2012;97:1033–8. Ó2012 by American Society for Reproductive Medicine.) Key Words: Recurrent IVF failure, ART, obesity, fibroids, cigarette smoke PROBABILITY, future. Often, they provide the public significantly to predictive models of METEOROLOGY, AND IVF with the odds of an event occurring, outcome. The list of other factors con- much like I do when meeting with a pa- tained herein is incomplete but grow- Whenever I quote statistics to an indi- tient at the time of embryo transfer. ing. When this elusive list is finally vidual patient regarding her likelihood If the meteorologist tells me that complete, perhaps then we will be able of having a baby, I have at my disposal there is a 65% chance of rain, I to forecast the outcome with 100% direct knowledge of her medical his- shouldn't be surprised when the clouds certainty. tory, past successes or failures and in- roll in and the raindrops fall. However, I formation about other patients I've know that I will be pleased if the 35% treated and their outcomes. I talk about chance of sunshine rules the day. That's OBESITY her personal odds in the setting of a single day and just about everyone The World Health Organization (WHO) population statistics. There are many can accept whichever outcome occurs. defines overweight as a body mass in- quotes about statistics, what they hide If my weeklong holiday is punctuated dex (BMI) equal to or more than 25, and what they reveal, and many times by 7 consecutive days of rain despite and obesity as a BMI equal to or more gambling analogies are invoked as the 35% chance of sun forecast daily, than 30. According to the WHO, one a comparator. How many times a tossed I begin to doubt their forecasting abil- billion adults are overweight and coin will land heads or tails; the odds of ity. The lack of sun in any of 7 days more than 300 million are obese. Once red or black at the Roulette table, etc. seems improbable despite the forecast associated with high-income countries, None of these analogies seems to im- odds of only 1 chance in 3 each day. obesity is now also prevalent in low- press, amuse, or otherwise satisfy a pa- My ability to accept the weather and middle-income countries (1). Ap- tient looking to me for answers when outcome on a single day but my rejec- proximately one third of U.S. adults she has completed an IVF cycle that tion of a string of 7 such days is proba- are obese and in 2010, 12 states had has not resulted in a baby. bly attributable to human nature. Why an obesity prevalence of 30% or more I've now turned to meteorology for was the weather forecaster unable to (2). The lay press has devoted many pa- some answers. Much like IVF where tell me that there would be 7 consecu- ges to the negative health conse- a positive or negative outcome has tive days of rain? Clearly, the model quences of obesity but with regard to a cause, so does the weather. Weather was lacking data on an important fac- fertility, most press coverage regarding is not random; there are forces, condi- tor or factors that shifted the true female obesity focuses on disorders of tions and factors that determine where odds beyond the 65:35 split churned ovulation and polycystic ovary syn- rain will fall and when, whether it will out by the existing formula. drome. One of the earliest studies on be warm or cool, sunny or cloudy, When it comes to predicting IVF the subject of BMI and IVF outcome windy or still. Meteorologists use so- outcomes, we know that oocyte found no difference when 76 patients phisticated models of past history and biology, embryonic development and with a BMI >27.9 were compared to current circumstances to predict the endometrial receptivity contribute 152 normal controls; or 35 under- weight patients (BMI <19) were com- Received January 16, 2012; revised and accepted March 14, 2012; published online March 28, 2012. pared to 70 normal controls (3). In A.S.P. has nothing to disclose. 2003 a study by Doody et al. (4), the in- Reprint requests: Alan S. Penzias, M.D., Boston IVF, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, 130 Second Avenue, Waltham, MA 02451 (E-mail: alan.penzias@bostonivf.com). vestigators stratified 822 women over four WHO BMI categories with mean Fertility and Sterility® Vol. 97, No. 5, May 2012 0015-0282/$36.00 Copyright ©2012 American Society for Reproductive Medicine, Published by Elsevier Inc. age range of 33.1 to 33.7 years and doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2012.03.017 demonstrated lower pregnancy and VOL. 97 NO. 5 / MAY 2012 1033
  • 2. VIEWS AND REVIEWS implantation rates in women with BMI >35. Ryley et al. (5) FIGURE 1 confirmed these findings the following year in a study of 6,827 cycles in women whose ages averaged 35.2–36.6 years (Table 1). Bellver et al. (6) evaluated 6500 cycles in which only 6.4% (419) were conducted in women with a BMI >30 (mean 33.6). An additional comorbidity in the study population was ciga- rette smoking among roughly one-third of the group. The au- thors demonstrated a similar number of oocytes retrieved, and no differences in the fertilization rate, day of embryo transfer (ET), or mean number of embryos transfered or cryopreserved. In addition, there was similar embryo quality in all the BMI groups. However, the implantation rate, pregnancy rate and live birth rate were clearly and adversely affected by elevated BMI (Fig. 1). In 2007, the first U.S. national data set study was con- ducted by the Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology (SART) (7). In that year, height and weight fields were added to the Clinic Online Reporting System, permitting calculation Implantation, pregnancy, and live birth rates in IVF-ICSI cycles according to the women's BMI. Each point represents percentages of BMI. The 345 member clinics comprised more than 90% of and 95% CI. all centers performing ART in the U.S. The authors limited Penzias. Recurrent IVF failure. Fertil Steril 2012. analysis to cycles where one or more embryos were trans- fered, and both height and weight were recorded. A total of 45,163 cycles were analyzed. The investigators found that higher BMI was associated with lower clinical pregnancy comes between groups when thawed cryopreserved embryos rates, especially in women under age 35 using their own oo- were transfered. The authors offer an explanation for the cu- cytes. The adverse effects of high BMI were mitigated by the rious success of obese men and normal weight females and use of donor oocytes. cite a study by the Robert Koch Institute (9), which associates While all of the aforementioned studies focused exclu- the combination with couples of higher social status. The au- sively on female obesity, the largest study to date by Kupka thors postulate ‘‘the increased pregnancy rate in this group et al. (8) included men. The investigators analyzed 12 years might as well be related to other lifestyle factors associated of data (1997–2008) from the national German IVF Registry. with higher social status.’’ A total of 706,360 cycles from as many as 120 centers were Overall, while some smaller studies have not found an as- included, from which 650,452 cycles where information con- sociation between elevated BMI and pregnancy outcome, the cerning weight was given were analyzed. Obesity, defined as preponderance of data including two national data sets BMI >30, was assigned to four groups: none, female, male or clearly demonstrates the negative impact of elevated BMI both. Compared to non-obese couples (28.15%), the highest on achievement of pregnancy through ART. An important fi- clinical pregnancy rate in fresh IVF cycles was found in cou- nal distinction to be made about obesity is that while it is ples with an obese male partner (30.38%, P¼ .0028). In the known to be associated with lower per cycle pregnancy and group of obese women, the pregnancy rate decreased to delivery rates, it is not, by itself, a cause of recurrent implan- 27.2%. There was no statistically significant difference in out- tation failure. TABLE 1 IVF outcome stratified by BMI. Characteristic All cycles BMI <20 BMI 20–24.9 BMI 25–29.9 BMI 30–34.9 BMI >35 P value n (total) 6827 466 3605 1632 724 400 Age (y), mean 36.5 36.3 36.6 36.6 36.2 35.2 < .0001a BMI, mean 24.9 18.9 22.1 26.8 31.8 37.4 N/A Cycles/patient 2.7 2.6 2.6 2.7 2.7 2.6 .14 Peak estradiol 1290 1424 1333 1222 1233 1135 < .0001b No. of mature follicles 6.1 6.0 6.1 6.0 6.2 6.2 .34 No. of oocytes retrieved 9.4 9.5 9.4 9.4 9.4 8.7 .18 No. of mature oocytes 7.7 7.7 7.8 7.7 7.8 7.2 .35 No. of embryos transfered 2.6 2.5 2.6 2.6 2.6 2.5 .56 Implantation rate (%) 18 20 19 20 18 13 < .0001a Clinical pregnancy rate (%) 28.3 32.9 31.4 27.6 27.9 21.8 < .0001a a BMI >35 group vs. all other groups. b BMI >35 group vs. all groups with BMI 25 and higher. Penzias. Recurrent IVF failure. Fertil Steril 2012. 1034 VOL. 97 NO. 5 / MAY 2012
  • 3. Fertility and Sterility® CIGARETTE SMOKE FIGURE 2 The incidence of cigarette smoking in the U.S. population dropped by half between 1965 and 2006; 42% to 20.8% of adults (10). Unfortunately this decrease is not uniform world- wide. Though male smokers outnumber female 5:1, the 20.8% in the U.S. population still represents a very large number of individuals, many of who are trying to become pregnant. In their meta-analysis, Waylen et al. (11) evaluated 17 studies and showed in aggregate significantly lower odds of live birth per cycle (OR 0.54, 95% CI 0.30–0.99), and signifi- cantly higher odds of spontaneous miscarriage (OR 2.65, 95% CI 1.33–5.30) in women who smoked. This is very power- ful data that demonstrate an entirely preventable cause of IVF failure. Women who smoke cigarettes should be strongly counseled that smoking cuts their odds of live birth nearly in half and increases their odds of miscarriage by 265%. Pregnancy rate and implantation rate following IVF for controls The effects of cigarette smoking are felt not just by the without fibroids and subjects with fibroids stratified by their uterine position. SS ¼ subserosal; IM ¼ intramural; SM ¼ submucosal. smokers themselves, but to women trying to become pregnant *P<.05 for IM vs. controls or SS; **P<.005 for IM vs. controls. who suffer from secondhand tobacco smoke (STS) exposure. Penzias. Recurrent IVF failure. Fertil Steril 2012. Benedict et al. (12) measured cotinine, a nicotine metabolite, in follicular fluid collected during 3270 IVF treatment cycles from 1909 non-smoking women between 1994 and 2003 to 2355 control cycles. The comparison showed a statistically examine the relationship between secondhand tobacco smoke significant 21% relative reduction in live birth rate in women exposure and implantation failure. They reported a 52% in- with non-cavity-distorting intramural fibroids compared crease in the risk of implantation failure among women ex- with women without fibroids (RR ¼ 0.79, 95% CI: 0.70– posed to STS compared with those unexposed. They also 0.88; P¼ .0001). found a 25% decrease in the odds for a live birth among Somigliana et al. (16) performed a prospective study of STS-exposed women. 119 cases of women with intramural (n ¼ 80) or subserosal fi- The summary point is that women trying to get pregnant broids (n ¼ 39) under 50 mm and 119 controls and found no should stop smoking, but non-smoking women, too, should differences in embryo implantation or delivery. The small remove themselves from chronic exposure to secondhand sample size and the two locations of fibroids under consider- smoke. ation may explain the variance from the findings of Sunkara et al. (15). UTERINE FIBROIDS What is most striking is the paucity of literature following surgery to demonstrate improved IVF outcomes following Leiomyomata have long been a source of gynecological prob- myomectomy. The practitioner whose patient has uterine fi- lems for women. A number of studies have been performed broids that distort or enter the endometrial cavity may rea- looking at the impact of uterine fibroids on ART outcomes. sonably conclude that surgical restoration of the uterine Farhi et al. (13) studied 46 patients with uterine fibroids anatomy is rational given the data of negative outcomes. who underwent 172 IVF cycles (range 1–9 attempts) between The mixed data on intramural fibroids allow room for clinical 1986 and 1992. The mean Æ SD age of the patients was 34.0 Æ judgment prior to a first attempt at IVF. In cases of recurrent 4.5 years (range 23–40) with a mean duration of infertility of implantation failure with no other attributable factors, surgi- 6.1 Æ 4.5 years (range 1–17). They concluded that fibroids im- cal removal becomes a very reasonable choice. The question paired implantation and successful pregnancy only when the that remains unresolved is how large an intramural fibroid uterine cavity was distorted. A subsequent study by Eldar- has to be in order to exert its negative influence. Geva et al. (14) (Fig. 2) compared the location of uterine fi- broids—subserosal, intramural and submucosal—to control patients without fibroids undergoing IVF. In their series of UTERINE ANOMALIES 88 patients undergoing 106 IVF cycles, they found that preg- The uterine septum has been implicated as a cause of recurrent nancy and implantation rates were significantly lower in the pregnancy loss and its resection touted to improve outcomes 46 patients with intramural fibroids and no cavity distortion in those affected by them. Whether infertility is caused by the and the 9 patients with submucosal fibroids. presence of a uterine septum is the subject of much specula- In an effort to determine whether intramural fibroids are tion. Most published works on the topic are small, uncon- associated with lower pregnancy and live birth rates than is trolled trials; case studies of experiences. Mollo et al. observed in women without fibroids, Sunkara et al. (15) recently published a controlled trial on the subject (17). The (Fig. 3) performed a meta-analysis. The authors' search authors compared 44 subjects (group A) with a uterine septum yielded 19 studies that met inclusion criteria, 11 of which and no other attributable cause of infertility to 132 women used live birth as an endpoint. There were 1626 cycles with (group B) with unexplained infertility. The pre-operative non-cavity distorting intramural fibroids compared with size of the septum was not described in the study. Following VOL. 97 NO. 5 / MAY 2012 1035
  • 4. VIEWS AND REVIEWS FIGURE 3 Forest plot of studies of non-cavity-distorting intramural fibroids versus no fibroids in women undergoing IVF treatment for outcome of live birth rates. Penzias. Recurrent IVF failure. Fertil Steril 2012. resection, a post-operative hysteroscopy to confirm a normal a TSH >2.5 mIU/L compared with cycles with TSH <2.5 uterine cavity and a 12-month follow-up period, the live birth mIU/L. TSH levels >2.5 mIU/L had a possible weak positive rate was significantly higher in group A than in group B association with spontaneous abortion rate that did not reach (34.1% and 18.9%, respectively; P< .05). The small study statistical significance.’’ size a) does not permit assessment of potential complications Reh et al. (22) found no difference in clinical pregnancy, from surgery and b) limits one's ability to extrapolate to the delivery or miscarriage rates in 1055 women when those with general population. TSH <2.5 mIU/L were compared to those with TSH >2.5 mIU/L. The question of whether a septum plays a causative role in Toulis et al. (23) evaluated the association between risk for recurrent failure to become pregnant following ART is ad- spontaneous miscarriage in subfertile, euthyroid women with dressed in the literature without a conclusive answer (18, thyroid autoimmunity (TAI) (defined as the presence of 19). The reader is left to use clinical judgment in individual autoantibodies against thyroid peroxidase (TPOab) and/or thy- patients with recurrent IVF failure without apparent roglobulin (TGab) ) undergoing IVF. They found that the risk of explanation. miscarriage was nearly double that of women without TAI (RR: 1.99, 95% confidence interval: 1.42–2.79, P< .001). The mech- anism for this association is unclear. Revelli et al. (24) compared THYROID DYSFUNCTION 129 euthyroid anti-thyroid antibody-positive (ATAþ) women The thyroid gland is most commonly associated with meta- undergoing IVF to 200 matched, ATA-negative controls. Dur- bolic rate, but it's clear that thyroid hormone is necessary ing IVF cycle, 38 ATAþ patients did not take any adjuvant for the normal function of numerous other body organs and treatment, 55 received levothyroxin (LT), and 38 received LT tissues. The definition of hypothyroidism remains controver- þacetylsalicylic acid (ASA) þ prednisolone (P). Patients receiv- sial. At the present time, most laboratories report the normal ing LTþASAþP had significantly higher pregnancy and im- reference range of thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) level as plantation rates than untreated ATAþ patients (PR/ET 25.6% 0.4–4.5 mIU/L. The National Academy of Clinical Biochemis- and IR 17.7% vs. PR/ET 7.5% and IR 4.7%, respectively), and try, part of the Academy of the American Association for overall IVF results comparable to patients without ATA (PR/ Clinical Chemistry (AACC) reported in 2002 that, ‘‘In the fu- ET 32.8% and IR 19%). The authors concluded that euthyroid ture, it is likely that the upper limit of the serum TSH euthy- ATAþ patients undergoing IVF could have better outcome if roid reference range will be reduced to 2.5 mIU/L because given LTþASAþP as adjuvant treatment. They cautioned, more than 95% of rigorously screened normal euthyroid vol- however, that this must be verified in further randomized, pro- unteers have serum TSH values between 0.4 and 2.5 mIU/L’’ spective studies. (20). Thus far, the American Academy of Clinical Endocrinol- ogists has not yet adopted this position due to insufficient data of health improvement of cardiac, lipid and neuropsychi- EMBRYO TRANSFER TECHNIQUE atric function. The Cochrane Database study of ultrasound vs. clinical touch Baker et al. (21) evaluated the impact of TSH above or be- for catheter guidance during embryo transfer (25) (Fig. 4) cit- low 2.5 mIU/L on pregnancy outcome in IVF. They report that ing 17 studies that compared 3244 ultrasound guided transfers in ‘‘women who become pregnant through IVF, gestational with 3171 clinical touch showed an odds ratio of 1.31 (95% CI age at delivery and birth weight were lower in cycles with 1.18–1.46) in favor of ultrasound guidance. While this factor 1036 VOL. 97 NO. 5 / MAY 2012
  • 5. Fertility and Sterility® FIGURE 4 Forest plot of studies of clinical touch embyro transfer (CTET) versus ultrasound-guided embryo transfer (UGET) for outcome of clinical pregnancy rate. Penzias. Recurrent IVF failure. Fertil Steril 2012. isn't in and of itself an independent contributor to the problem and hereditary and acquired thrombophilias on IVF outcome. of recurrent IVF failure, it is a factor that impacts outcomes, The known or purported causality of phospholipid antibodies and as such should be considered at least when evaluating and coagulation factors on recurrent pregnancy loss long ago the patient who has not succeeded in multiple IVF cycles. spilled over into the arena of conception with IVF or more The techniques associated with ultrasound-guided em- precisely, the lack of it. Some have argued that without im- bryo transfer vary from clinic to clinic. We have found it use- plantation to signal the arrival of an embryo, it would be im- ful to advise patients to consume enough liquid prior to the probable for serum or tissue-based response elements to procedure to create an acoustic window directly above the prevent implantation. Others have argued that the effect is uterus. Bladder filling is especially helpful in obese patients unrelated to the embryo, but rather the negative impact is in whom imaging can be a challenge. We favor placement at the level of the endometrium. The Practice Committee of of a trial catheter with an echogenic inner catheter tip to es- the American Society for Reproductive Medicine released tablish continuity with the internal cervical os. We leave the a Committee Opinion in 1999 which it reviewed again in outer sheath in place while the active transfer catheter is 2008, ‘‘Anti-phospholipid antibodies (APA) do not affect loaded. A second set of hands provided by an assistant in IVF success’’ (26). The review culled 16 peer reviewed papers, the operating room is useful to help position the abdominal of which 7 included appropriate endpoints and controls. There ultrasound probe prior to catheter placement. The physician was no statistically significant impact of the presence of performing the transfer thereafter can make minor adjust- phospholipid antibodies on IVF outcomes when the studies ments to the probe position. were examined individually nor when the data were aggre- When a difficult transfer is in progress, direct visualiza- gated in the 2,053 patients studied. The authors concluded tion is a significant aid. There are times when it's possible that ‘‘assessment of APA is not indicated among couples un- to see a trial catheter stuck in a particular position and know- dergoing IVF. Therapy is not justified on the basis of existing ing the direction and angle of the cervical canal is a plus. Fur- data.’’ ther, watching a catheter go in with ease but double back on A review was recently published on the topic of thrombo- itself averts the problem of depositing precious embryos in the philias and IVF outcome (27). The authors' initial search cervical canal rather than the endometrium. yielded 694 studies. Case reports, editorials, reviews, meta- A side benefit to the use of ultrasound-guided embryo analyses, studies with inadequate outcomes, absence of transfer is patient comfort. Not so much due to an easier tech- thrombophilia/anti-phospholipid antibodies, and more than nique, though this can be true, and certainly not due to the full one of the above were excluded and 33 (6,092 patients) were bladder, but rather the patient is able to visualize the process ultimately analyzed. They report that twenty-nine studies thus removing one of the more mysterious elements of the IVF (5,270 patients) assessed anti-phospholipid antibodies in experience. women treated with ART. The prevalence of antibodies in in- fertile patients varied from 0%–45%. When examining case- control studies, the authors write ‘‘overall, the presence of IMMUNE FACTORS AND THROMBOPHILIAS one or more anti-phospholipid antibodies was associated Few topics in reproductive medicine elicit as many opinions with a 3-fold higher risk of ART failure.’’ There was a signifi- or as much controversy as the impact of immune factors cant degree of heterogeneity across these case-control studies VOL. 97 NO. 5 / MAY 2012 1037
  • 6. VIEWS AND REVIEWS with some using parous controls and others using women who 9. Robert Koch-Institut. Gesundheitsberichterstattung des Bundes, Bundes had achieved a live birth following ART. In addition to case- Gesundheitssurvey 1998. Available at: http://www.gbebund.de/gbe10/ab rechnung.prc_abr_test_logon?p_uid¼gastg&p_aid¼&p_knoten¼FID&p_ control studies, the authors also evaluated cohort studies. In sprache¼D&p_suchstring¼8397::BMI. Accessed December 30, 2011. contrast to the findings of the case-control studies, analysis 10. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Cigarette smoking among adults— of cohort studies showed that anti-phospholipid antibodies United States, 2006. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2007;56(44):1157–61. were not associated with a lower rate of viable pregnancy, 11. Waylen AL, Metwally M, Jones GL, Wilkinson AJ, Ledger WL. Effects of cig- live birth, or a higher incidence of negative pregnancy tests. arette smoking upon clinical outcomes of assisted reproduction: a meta- Ten of the studies in the review evaluated the relationship analysis. Hum Reprod Update 2009;15:31–44. between inherited thrombophilia and ART. Seven studies 12. Benedict MD, Missmer SA, Vahratian A, Berry KF, Vitonis AF, Cramer DW, Meeker JD. Secondhand tobacco smoke exposure is associated with in- were case-control, 2 were cohorts, and in 1 case-control study creased risk of failed implantation and reduced IVF success. Hum Reprod patients undergoing IVF (cases) were followed to assess the 2011;26:2525–31. pregnancy outcomes. Pooled data from patients in 8 case- 13. Farhi J, Ashkenazi J, Feldberg D, Dicker D, Orvieto R, Ben Rafael Z. Effect of control studies showed an overall 3-fold increased risk of uterine leiomyomata on the results of in-vitro fertilization treatment. Hum ART failure in association with factor V Leiden. In the 3 co- Reprod 1995;10:2576. hort studies, there was no difference in outcome between 14. Eldar-Geva T, Meagher S, Healy DL, MacLachlan V, Breheny S, Wood C. Effect of intramural, subserosal, and submucosal uterine fibroids on the outcome those with and those without the factor V Leiden mutation. of assisted reproductive technology treatment. Fertil Steril 1998;70:687–91. True to form, the conflicting findings in the literature give 15. Sunkara SK, Khairy M, El-Toukhy T, Khalaf Y, Coomarasamy A. The effect of advocates and detractors of a role for phospholipid antibodies intramural fibroids without uterine cavity involvement on the outcome of IVF and thrombophilias ammunition to bolster their arguments. treatment: a systematic review and metaanalysis. Hum Reprod 2010;25: The advocates can cite the case-control studies, while the de- 418–29. tractors can cite the cohort studies. From a methodology 16. Somigliana E, De Benedictis S, Vercellini P, Nicolosi AE, Benaglia L, standpoint, both study types are Level II-2 (28) with their Scarduelli C, et al. Fibroids not encroaching the endometrial cavity and IVF success rate: a prospective study. Hum Reprod 2011;26:834–9. own particular strengths and limitations. Treatment trials 17. Mollo A, De Franciscis P, Colacurci N, Cobellis L, Perino A, Venezia R, et al. similarly suffer from methodological flaws and a lack of con- Hysteroscopic resection of the septum improves the pregnancy rate of clusive answers. Level I evidence is clearly needed. women with unexplained infertility: a prospective controlled trial. Fertil Steril 2009;91:2628–31. CONCLUSIONS 18. Marcus S, al-Shawaf T, Brinsden P. The obstetric outcome of in vitro fertiliza- tion and embryo transfer in women with congenital uterine malformation. It is clear that there are other factors beyond the egg, embryo Am J Obstet Gynecol 1996;175:85–9. and endometrium that contribute to the success or failure of 19. Lavergne N, Aristizabal J, Zarka V, Erny R, Hedon B. Uterine anomalies and an IVF cycle. These factors, if present in serial IVF cycles, in vitro fertilization: what are the results? Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol may serve to diminish the actual odds of conception below 1996;68:29–34. 20. The National Academy of Clinical Biochemistry. Laboratory medicine practice the population-based odds estimated by patient age and ovar- guidelines. Laboratory support for the diagnosis of thyroid disease, Volume ian reserve testing alone. Our mission is twofold: 1) reduce the 13. Washington, D.C.: The National Academy of Clinical Biochemistry; 2002. negative impact of factors over which we have control 21. Baker VL, Rone HM, Pasta DJ, Nelson HP, Gvakharia M, Adamson GD. Cor- through treatment or behavior modification; and 2) continue relation of thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) level with pregnancy outcome our efforts to identify as yet unknown factors that prevent our in women undergoing in vitro fertilization. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2006;194: patients from achieving a successful outcome. 1668–74. 22. Reh A, Grifo J, Danoff A. What is a normal thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) level? Effects of stricter TSH thresholds on pregnancy outcomes after REFERENCES in vitro fertilization. Fertil Steril 2010;94:2920–2. 1. World Health Organization. Facts on Obesity. Available at: http://www.who.int/ 23. Toulis KA, Goulis DG, Venetis CA, Kolibianakis EM, Negro R, Tarlatzis BC, features/factfiles/obesity/facts/en/index1.html. Accessed December 30, 2011. Papadimas I. Risk of spontaneous miscarriage in euthyroid women with thy- 2. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Overweight and Obesity. Available roid autoimmunity undergoing IVF: a meta-analysis. Eur J Endocrinol 2010; at: http://www.cdc.gov/obesity/data/adult.html. Accessed December 30, 2011. 162:643–52. 3. Lashen H, Ledger W, Bernal AL, Barlow D. Extremes of body mass do not ad- 24. Revelli A, Casano S, Piane LD, Grassi G, Gennarelli G, Guidetti D, versely affect the outcome of superovulation and in-vitro fertilization. Hum Massobrio M. A retrospective study on IVF outcome in euthyroid patients Reprod 1999;14:712–5. with anti-thyroid antibodies: effects of levothyroxine, acetyl-salicylic acid 4. Doody KM, Langley MT, Marek DE, Nackley AC, Doody KJ. Morbid obesity and prednisolone adjuvant treatments. Reprod Biol Endocrinol 2009;7:137. adversely impacts outcomes with IVF. Fertil Steril 2003;80(Suppl 3):S160. 25. Brown J, Buckingham K, Abou-Setta AM, Buckett W. Ultrasound versus 5. Ryley DA, Bayer SR, Eaton J, Zimon A, Klipstein S, Reindollar R. Influence of ‘clinical touch’ for catheter guidance during embryo transfer in women. Co- body mass index (BMI) on the outcome of 6,827 IVF cycles. Fertil Steril 2004; chrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2010;1:CD006107. doi: 82(Suppl 2):S38–9. 10.1002/14651858.CD006107.pub3. 6. Bellver J, Ayllon Y, Ferrando M, Melo M, Goyri E, Pellicer A, Remohi J, 26. Practice Committee of the ASRM. Anti-phospholipid antibodies do not affect Meseguer M. Female obesity impairs in vitro fertilization outcome without IVF success. Practice Committee of the ASRM. Fertil Steril 2008;90:S172–3. affecting embryo quality. Fertil Steril 2010;93:447–54. 27. Di Nisio M, Rutjes AWS, Ferrante N, Tiboni GM, Cuccurullo F, Porreca E. 7. Luke B, Brown MB, Stern JE, Missmer SA, Fujimoto VY, Leach R, A SART Thrombophilia and outcomes of assisted reproduction technologies: a sys- Writing Group. Female obesity adversely affects assisted reproductive tech- tematic review and meta-analysis. Blood 2011;18:2670–8. nology (ART) pregnancy and live birth rates. Hum Reprod 2011;26:245–52. 28. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Reading the 8. Kupka MS, Gnoth C, Buehler K, Dahncke W, Kruessel JS. Impact of female Medical Literature. Available at: http://www.acog.org/Resources_And_ and male obesity on IVF/ICSI: results of 700,000 ART cycles in Germany. Gy- Publications/Department_Publications/Reading_the_Medical_Literature. necol Endocrinol 2011;27:144–9. Accessed March 11, 2012. 1038 VOL. 97 NO. 5 / MAY 2012