SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 17
the Pacific Genius - customary land Tim Anderson AAAPS Conference, VUT, April 2010
pacific land ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
modernist land systems ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
resistance ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],CIS Directors are also directors of : Westpac, Macquarie Bank, JP Morgan, News Corp, Deutche Bank, CSR, Newmont Mining, Gates Foundation, Telstra, ASX, USSC
practical implications ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Sources : *Gou and Higaturu 1999; **King 2001 & Higaturu 2003; ***Anderson 2006; #Grieg-Gran 2008; ##ITS Global 2009 Note: conversion rate used is 2.66 Kina = 1US$ 24,671  (US$9,275) Large scale oil palm  8,884  (US$3,340) Large scale oil palm  2,553  (US$960) Smallholder oil palm  3,100  (est. av.) Small holder cash crops (Madang, EHP)  Commercial returns -  13,400  (est. av) Subsistence consumption value (Madang, WHP) 100  (est.) Rural lease rent plus oil palm royalty (Oro Pr.) 20  Rural lease rents (Oro Pr.) Per ha/year (Kina) Rural customary land in PNG is undervalued
Sources : Anderson 2008, except * Sowei et al 2003 138 Women roadside sellers, 2006 (Madang Pr., women) 138 Informal sector survey 2003 (Western Highlands Pr.) 130 Informal sector survey 2003 (Morobe Pr.) 124 Informal sector survey 2003 (ENB Pr.) 158 Informal sector survey 2003 (Central Pr.) Informal sector incomes -  37.20 National minimum wage, 2006 28 Mama Lus Frut income, 2000 (WNB Pr., women) 61 VOP/LSS oil palm growers, 2006 (Oro Pr.) 50 Ramu Nickel construction wage, 2006 (Madang Pr., men) 34 RD Tuna factory wage, 2006 (Madang Pr., women) 42  Ramu Sugar basic wage, 2006 (Madang Pr.) AWE (Kina) Formal sector incomes -  PNG: Formal sector incomes are very low
commerce & subsistence ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
2,000 (min wage) More! 7,300 to 11,400 (POM) 1,000 to 10,000+ 6,000 to 10,000 3,400 to 6,200 (regional) cash incomes housing Food Subsistence equivalent values, by an 'opportunity cost' method (PNG Kina)
problems of CLOs ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
food security ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
sustainable development ,[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],AusAID’s ‘middle way’ involves promotion of leases

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Ähnlich wie Land – the pacific genius

Carmichael Coal Mine Case Study
Carmichael Coal Mine Case StudyCarmichael Coal Mine Case Study
Carmichael Coal Mine Case StudyAasim Mushtaq
 
Latin America: The World’s Future Rice Bowl?
Latin America: The World’s Future Rice Bowl?Latin America: The World’s Future Rice Bowl?
Latin America: The World’s Future Rice Bowl?CIAT
 
Tumusiime Rhoda Peace UNCCD Executive Secretary - Key note speech
Tumusiime Rhoda Peace UNCCD Executive Secretary - Key note speechTumusiime Rhoda Peace UNCCD Executive Secretary - Key note speech
Tumusiime Rhoda Peace UNCCD Executive Secretary - Key note speechWorld Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Permaculture in Somalia: Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...
Permaculture in Somalia:  Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...Permaculture in Somalia:  Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...
Permaculture in Somalia: Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...ipc_conference
 
Perspectives on current and emerging land governance challenges and ILC's re...
Perspectives on  current and emerging land governance challenges and ILC's re...Perspectives on  current and emerging land governance challenges and ILC's re...
Perspectives on current and emerging land governance challenges and ILC's re...Ilc Landcoalition
 
Effects Of Climate On Small Scale Farmers
Effects Of Climate On Small Scale FarmersEffects Of Climate On Small Scale Farmers
Effects Of Climate On Small Scale FarmersMichelle Madero
 
How to mobilize donor agencies for farmer-managed re-greening
How to mobilize donor agencies for farmer-managed re-greeningHow to mobilize donor agencies for farmer-managed re-greening
How to mobilize donor agencies for farmer-managed re-greeningWorld Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14
Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14
Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14developslides
 
Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14
Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14
Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14developslides
 
Social Issues in the Sustainable Environment
Social Issues in the Sustainable EnvironmentSocial Issues in the Sustainable Environment
Social Issues in the Sustainable Environmentkomal4322
 
Detailed Haiti Presentation by GLDI
Detailed Haiti Presentation by GLDIDetailed Haiti Presentation by GLDI
Detailed Haiti Presentation by GLDIgraciuslee
 
Resource Grabbing in Asia
Resource Grabbing in AsiaResource Grabbing in Asia
Resource Grabbing in AsiaAPWG_Denis
 
Brussels Briefings n.60; Len Ishmael: What agrifood challenges and opportunit...
Brussels Briefings n.60; Len Ishmael: What agrifood challenges and opportunit...Brussels Briefings n.60; Len Ishmael: What agrifood challenges and opportunit...
Brussels Briefings n.60; Len Ishmael: What agrifood challenges and opportunit...Brussels Briefings (brusselsbriefings.net)
 
policy options.pdf
policy options.pdfpolicy options.pdf
policy options.pdfrashi39442
 
Essay On Wetland Restoration
Essay On Wetland RestorationEssay On Wetland Restoration
Essay On Wetland RestorationMegan Espinoza
 
Impact Of Natural Resources On Economic Development
Impact Of Natural Resources On Economic DevelopmentImpact Of Natural Resources On Economic Development
Impact Of Natural Resources On Economic DevelopmentMelissa Dudas
 
Seaconomics - The Economic Perspective of Marine Biodiversity
Seaconomics - The Economic Perspective of Marine BiodiversitySeaconomics - The Economic Perspective of Marine Biodiversity
Seaconomics - The Economic Perspective of Marine BiodiversityNuno Gaspar de Oliveira
 

Ähnlich wie Land – the pacific genius (20)

Carmichael Coal Mine Case Study
Carmichael Coal Mine Case StudyCarmichael Coal Mine Case Study
Carmichael Coal Mine Case Study
 
Latin America: The World’s Future Rice Bowl?
Latin America: The World’s Future Rice Bowl?Latin America: The World’s Future Rice Bowl?
Latin America: The World’s Future Rice Bowl?
 
Vulnerability of West Africa Agriculture and Food Systems to Climate Change b...
Vulnerability of West Africa Agriculture and Food Systems to Climate Change b...Vulnerability of West Africa Agriculture and Food Systems to Climate Change b...
Vulnerability of West Africa Agriculture and Food Systems to Climate Change b...
 
Tumusiime Rhoda Peace UNCCD Executive Secretary - Key note speech
Tumusiime Rhoda Peace UNCCD Executive Secretary - Key note speechTumusiime Rhoda Peace UNCCD Executive Secretary - Key note speech
Tumusiime Rhoda Peace UNCCD Executive Secretary - Key note speech
 
Permaculture in Somalia: Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...
Permaculture in Somalia:  Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...Permaculture in Somalia:  Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...
Permaculture in Somalia: Overview of Agroecological Natural Technology Syste...
 
Perspectives on current and emerging land governance challenges and ILC's re...
Perspectives on  current and emerging land governance challenges and ILC's re...Perspectives on  current and emerging land governance challenges and ILC's re...
Perspectives on current and emerging land governance challenges and ILC's re...
 
Effects Of Climate On Small Scale Farmers
Effects Of Climate On Small Scale FarmersEffects Of Climate On Small Scale Farmers
Effects Of Climate On Small Scale Farmers
 
How to mobilize donor agencies for farmer-managed re-greening
How to mobilize donor agencies for farmer-managed re-greeningHow to mobilize donor agencies for farmer-managed re-greening
How to mobilize donor agencies for farmer-managed re-greening
 
tragedy of the commons.ppt
tragedy of the commons.ppttragedy of the commons.ppt
tragedy of the commons.ppt
 
Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14
Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14
Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14
 
Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14
Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14
Ag policy for Qld 18Nov14
 
Social Issues in the Sustainable Environment
Social Issues in the Sustainable EnvironmentSocial Issues in the Sustainable Environment
Social Issues in the Sustainable Environment
 
Detailed Haiti Presentation by GLDI
Detailed Haiti Presentation by GLDIDetailed Haiti Presentation by GLDI
Detailed Haiti Presentation by GLDI
 
Resource Grabbing in Asia
Resource Grabbing in AsiaResource Grabbing in Asia
Resource Grabbing in Asia
 
Brussels Briefings n.60; Len Ishmael: What agrifood challenges and opportunit...
Brussels Briefings n.60; Len Ishmael: What agrifood challenges and opportunit...Brussels Briefings n.60; Len Ishmael: What agrifood challenges and opportunit...
Brussels Briefings n.60; Len Ishmael: What agrifood challenges and opportunit...
 
policy options.pdf
policy options.pdfpolicy options.pdf
policy options.pdf
 
Essay On Wetland Restoration
Essay On Wetland RestorationEssay On Wetland Restoration
Essay On Wetland Restoration
 
Impact Of Natural Resources On Economic Development
Impact Of Natural Resources On Economic DevelopmentImpact Of Natural Resources On Economic Development
Impact Of Natural Resources On Economic Development
 
Seaconomics - The Economic Perspective of Marine Biodiversity
Seaconomics - The Economic Perspective of Marine BiodiversitySeaconomics - The Economic Perspective of Marine Biodiversity
Seaconomics - The Economic Perspective of Marine Biodiversity
 
Lberta Case Study
Lberta Case StudyLberta Case Study
Lberta Case Study
 

Land – the pacific genius

  • 1. the Pacific Genius - customary land Tim Anderson AAAPS Conference, VUT, April 2010
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8. Sources : *Gou and Higaturu 1999; **King 2001 & Higaturu 2003; ***Anderson 2006; #Grieg-Gran 2008; ##ITS Global 2009 Note: conversion rate used is 2.66 Kina = 1US$ 24,671 (US$9,275) Large scale oil palm 8,884 (US$3,340) Large scale oil palm 2,553 (US$960) Smallholder oil palm 3,100 (est. av.) Small holder cash crops (Madang, EHP) Commercial returns - 13,400 (est. av) Subsistence consumption value (Madang, WHP) 100 (est.) Rural lease rent plus oil palm royalty (Oro Pr.) 20 Rural lease rents (Oro Pr.) Per ha/year (Kina) Rural customary land in PNG is undervalued
  • 9. Sources : Anderson 2008, except * Sowei et al 2003 138 Women roadside sellers, 2006 (Madang Pr., women) 138 Informal sector survey 2003 (Western Highlands Pr.) 130 Informal sector survey 2003 (Morobe Pr.) 124 Informal sector survey 2003 (ENB Pr.) 158 Informal sector survey 2003 (Central Pr.) Informal sector incomes - 37.20 National minimum wage, 2006 28 Mama Lus Frut income, 2000 (WNB Pr., women) 61 VOP/LSS oil palm growers, 2006 (Oro Pr.) 50 Ramu Nickel construction wage, 2006 (Madang Pr., men) 34 RD Tuna factory wage, 2006 (Madang Pr., women) 42 Ramu Sugar basic wage, 2006 (Madang Pr.) AWE (Kina) Formal sector incomes - PNG: Formal sector incomes are very low
  • 10.
  • 11. 2,000 (min wage) More! 7,300 to 11,400 (POM) 1,000 to 10,000+ 6,000 to 10,000 3,400 to 6,200 (regional) cash incomes housing Food Subsistence equivalent values, by an 'opportunity cost' method (PNG Kina)
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.