Strategy, Decision Making and Leadership for the 21st Century (Not the 20th Century) -- Keynote by Next Jump Co-CEOs, Charlie Kim and Meghan Messenger, for Next Jump Leadership Academy to PACE US Air Force, June 7, 2017.
3. 3
The PROBLEM: what worked before doesn’t work anymore
STRATEGY
GREAT STRATEGY BUT EXECUTED POORLY [DOESN’T EXIST]
STRATEGY CANNOT BE DIVORCED FROM EXECUTION
ALL DATA COMES FROM THE PAST
VUCA WORLD: DATA-DRIVEN DECISION
MAKING DOESN’T WORK
[FUTURE ≠ PAST]
CENTRALIZED DECENTRALIZED LEADERSHIP
BUT: SENIOR LEADERS FEEL EVERYTHING IS
MISSION CRITICAL
[FEAR OF FAILURE]
JUNIOR LEADERS DON’T UNDERSTAND REAL
COSTS TO FAILURE
[NOT ACTING RESPONSIBLE]
4. 4
SOLUTION: SUCCESS = Decision Making Factory
+
CREATIVITY COLLABORATION
NOT AFRAID TO TAKE RISKS
MAKE SOMETHING THAT DID NOT EXIST
INTUITION, A GUESS [INFORMED BY DATA]
TEAM: WORKING W/ OTHERS
MAKE “YOUR THINKING” TRANSPARENT
YOU NEED TRUST
5. 5
EDUCATION 1.0
ISOLATION
FEAR
WORK 1.0
SUBJECTS
[SERVE THE KING]
WORK 2.0
FOLLOWERS
[ASSEMBLY LINE]
WORK 3.0
CITIZENS
[DECISION MAKERS]
EDUCATION 2.0
COMPLIANCE
UNIFORMITY
EDUCATION 3.0
CREATIVITY
COLLABORATION
1750 KING FREDERICK THE GREAT 21ST CENTURY: INNOVATION1920 CUBBERLEY: FACTORY MODEL
ORIGINS of EDUCATION = ORIGINS of WORK
12. 12
Companies have outgrown traditional management..
CEOS WORRIED OF OTHER BIG CO
STRATEGY CHANGED EVERY 1-5 YEARS
WHAT YOU PRODUCE: PRODUCTS & SERVICES
NOWBEFORE
CEOS WORRY OF 2 KIDS IN A GARAGE
STRATEGY CHANGES EVERY DAY
WHAT YOU PRODUCE: DECISION FACTORY
13. 13
GENERAL ODIERNO: former Head of the U.S. Army
“The world is getting so complicated, you have to decentralize
decision making. Do you really know where your enemy is for sure?
The winning model is to build adaptive learning teams.”
14. “You will do what I tell you because I out rank you”
Mandate leadership, while sometimes required, is the
weakest form of leadership
It focuses on the process rather than the people
Is easier to apply and requires less time
Does not require an understanding of those you are leading
Mandated leadership…
Can often result in marginal solutions, disinterested
members, lack of commitment to the end state, and near
zero personal responsibility by those not in charge
“leader/follower” model
CENTRALIZED
15. 15
STRATEGY: OLD [20th Century]
~ WORKS OUT
CENTRALIZED:
STRATEGY, DECISION MAKING & LEADERSHIP
GOALS
KPIS/ METRICS
REWARD SYSTEM/ COMP
HIRING/ PROMOTIONS
TRADITIONAL MANAGEMENT LEVERS STOPPED WORKING
16. Organic Leadership…
“You are part of the solution and we are in this together”
Is more difficult to apply and requires planning
Requires an understanding of those you lead
Requires and environment of trust, teamwork, and a shared
sense of responsibility for the outcome
Often results in superior solutions, greater buy-in,
individual commitment to the end state, and a high degree
of personal responsibility across the entire team
“leader/leader-in-training” model
DECENTRALIZED
17. 17
STRATEGY: NEW [21st Century]
~ WORKS OUT
DECENTRALIZED:
STRATEGY, DECISION MAKING & LEADERSHIP
EVERYONE..
CONTRIBUTING TO STRATEGY
MAKING DECISIONS
TRAINED TO LEAD AND
TRAINING OTHER LEADERS
EVERYONE MUST BE TRAINED TO MAKE REAL-TIME DECISIONS/ADJUSTMENTS
21. 21
STRATEGY is about MAKING DECISIONS/CHOICES..
IS NOT IS
“NO = DOUBLE YES”
YOU MUST TEST YOUR CHOICES
B/C WE HEDGE: WE CANNOT SAY NO
CANNOT BE STUPID ON ITS FACE
IS: CUSTOMER ORIENTED
IS NOT: IGNORING YOUR CUSTOMERS*
* NOT A CHOICE
REQUIRES COURAGE
+
22. 22
CHOICES require COURAGE
IS NOT
IS
C
A
NEXT VERSION
THIS VERSION
LAGGING METRICS
ADULT METRICS
LEADING METRICS
BABY METRICS
23. 23
STRATEGY requires RIGOR + CREATIVITY
RIGOR
BRILLIANT IN THE BASICS
CREATIVITY
MAKE SOMETHING THAT DID NOT EXIST
+
24. 24
HOW to be CREATIVE
Simply put, creativity happens when your
mind is unfocused, daydreaming or idle.
(This is why we have so many “aha” moments in the shower.)
Three solutions:
1/ long walks
2/ pick up a hobby/ learn something new
3/ fun and games
29. 29
GAS “give a shit”
No matter how good your strategy is, if your people
don’t have gas “don’t give a shit”, it won’t work.
WARNING: Level 1 Alone Leads to…
ENTITLEMENT – perks inflation
FIZZLES OUT – less exciting over time
32. Common
obstacles to
accuracy
Anchoring bias: Over-reliance on first piece of
information
Expertise bias: Weighting expert “authority”
over information and logic
Outcome bias: Judging something based on level of
desire for the outcome
Ostrich effect: Ignoring dangerous or negative
information
Observational selection bias: Noticing what was
not noted before & wrongly assessing increased
frequency
Halo effect: Impression of a person or
entity influences the assessment
of the credibility of the
information he/it provides
Availability bias: Overestimating importance of
available information
Stereotyping: Expecting a person or group to
have certain qualities without having
information
Blind spot bias: Failing to recognize your own
cognitive bias
Sunk cost bias: Being attached to an investment
already made (time, effort) despite utility of it
34. LHF “lying/hiding/faking” = Walking on EGG SHELLS
What does LHF feel like?
Like you can’t say what you really feel.
Like people are not telling you things.
Like it’s not safe to disagree.
Like it’s not safe to be honest.
It feels like walking on egg shells.
Poor performing teams are surrounded by
eggs shells.
And poor performing teams destroy value.
34
38. 38
CREATIVITY:
Do I have an opinion? POV I’m sharing?
Am I revealing my assumptions/ rationale?
FEAR:
What am I afraid of?
COLLABORATION:
Do I make it easy for others
to tell me the truth?
AM I MAKING THE RIGHT CALLS?
Right decisions – consistently
Wrong decisions – lessons learned
Indecision – the most common
OUTCOME:
Score/Results
MONEYBALL of LEADERSHIP
5 Levels to Decision Making
Our inability to deal with our fears/ our negative emotions
39. WHAT is No LHF
TRUTH, AUTHENTICITY, LEAVING NOTHING UNSAID
FACTS, MY THINKING, MY ASSUMPTIONS, GUT/INTUITION, WHAT YOU’RE FEELING
[HIGHEST FORM OF TRANSPARENCY]
47. The 2nd Job
In an ordinary organization, most people are doing a
second job no one is paying them for.
In businesses large and small; in government
agencies, schools, and hospitals; in for-profits and
non-profits and in any country in the world,
most people are spending time and energy covering
up their weaknesses, managing other people’s
impressions of them, showing themselves to their
best advantage, playing politics, hiding their
inadequacies, hiding their uncertainties, hiding their
limitations. Hiding.
We regard this as the single biggest loss of resources
that organizations suffer everyday.
47
49. 49
why we LHF
TOP 3 REASONS [FEAR]
1. We Feel Inferior – it’s contagious
2. We Make a Mistake – leads to downward spirals
3. Loyalty – how we justify it
54. 54
DRIVERS of our SUCCESS are also our LIMITING FACTORS
You have more responsibility & stress
Now you worry about how you look
You make a mistake, “you’re in your head”
You start LHF (hiding emotionally)
Emotional Hiding quickly turns into
Physically Hiding
You show up to the “bare minimum”
When junior, effort gets you noticed
Gives you the opportunity to get promoted
Back to basics: SHOW UP/ EFFORT
Reapply GAS
EDU 1.0 – how do you control the masses of people w/out using a gun. Kindergarten: garden the children so they will serve the king.
Isolation – rows, can’t talk to each other, teachers isolation in classrooms
Fear – everyone afraid of the next level, kids, teachers, principals, superintendents
Do what you’re told. Every semester new teacher, can’t collaborate b/c new teacher
King Frederick's system was designed to teach obedience to solidify his control of the country
EDU 2.0 – industrial schools, no collaboration, children move along like widgets on assembly line: math, science, etc.
key characteristics of factory model education are top-down management, emphasis on management, centralized planning, standardization, efficiency in producing results
typified by efficiency and uniformity, often resembling a factory building.
system has been described as being "designed to create docile subjects and factory workers
Cubberley described "schools as, in a sense, factories in which the raw products (children) are to be shaped and fashioned into products to meet the various demands of life.”
Factory model schools employ direct instruction methods: a teacher drilled information into the class in "assembly line fashion",[6] the students learn by rote copying and memorization, and they are then tested on the information presented to them
factory model method also features depersonalization, strict hierarchy of authority, uniformity over innovation, process and procedure, and standardization of curriculum, testing, class sizes, time periods, and learning rates
EDU 3.0 – preschools, charter schools, school for autism, training former prisoners
15 years to build amazon book business. He built Kindle ebook in 2 years.
) 1991 – David Rose 1st internet company, $20MM VC raised to get to 1st product shipped
) 1996 – next company, rather than server farm, used cloud, $2MM raised to get to 1st product shipped
) 2001 – first angel investment, wireless internet co, took $200K to 1st internet product shipped
) 2007 – led investment round, online marketplace, bootstrapped sweat equity, $20K only, now worth $150MM
) NOW – few thousand dollars to get someone to create a mobile app for you, Brooklyn, Botswana, bangalore
Requires leadership to take an organization from Low High
Requires leadership to take an organization from Low High
Highest form of radical transparency is NO LHF. You can be transparent to the question I ask but if I don’t ask it…
Best diligence question ever – “What am I not asking you that I should be asking…”
This is a complex topic – dealing with the reasons why we LHF
Yet it is also the MONEY METRIC – the limiting factor to almost every career
Titantic Bin Laden
This is a complex topic – dealing with the reasons why we LHF
Yet it is also the MONEY METRIC – the limiting factor to almost every career
Inappropriate Transparency happens far less
Majority of what happens is lying/hiding/faking
As a culture, as a society, we’re more likely to not say the truth
It is not THIS
When you’re doing it right, NO LHF, this is what it looks like
What you see, what you hear…but most importantly, what you feel “something doesn’t feel right” – you share [this is not optional]
This is what creates group think. Transparency so someone can benefit from your signal, but can also correct your assumption
Years later, I learned from an amazing mentor, friend and coach: Jim Loehr, this problem is so common, it has a name. It’s called “The Imposter Syndrome”
AND by the way…The more successful you get, the worse this problem gets. The majority of senior leaders in the world feel this way.
Most of you have probably seen this movie Catch Me If You Can. It looks glamorous, he’s an imposter…
) when you're LHF you are an imposter
) you're pretending to be somebody you're not
And when you do that (I'm going to into few examples of why we do that) but first I'm going to tell you what the cost of doing this is
) this is what it looks like, looks glamorous at first but if you saw the movie Xyz this is the cost, this is what it looks at like
It's exhausting and can ruin your life. Your career
Scientific data from neurologists, best brain doctors in the country that…it Takes twice as much energy to lie than tell the truth
If an average person worked 45 hours in a week, 15 hours on their first job telling the truth. 30 hours is spend lying hiding faking doing their 2nd Job.
We can’t reduce this to zero. For instance
I don’t recommend walking into a board meeting and say: I have no idea what I’m doing.
There are times when the truth is just unnecessary. You have a cute baby – doesn’t have to be true.
The book NxJ was recently case studied in: An Everyone Culture, talks about the 2nd Job.
The very first lines go like this…
Feeling inferior – you feel less than your colleague
Most senior person asks you – is this clear?
Guy sitting next to you says: crystal clear
Next person – got it
Comes to you – are you going to say, “sorry, I actually have no clue, I’m lost”
It’s not the fumble (accidents happen)…
It’s the series of mistakes that follow (downward spiral)…
…that cost you the game.
This is a cycle, you can get stuck in this cycle…for years, your entire career
In most companies, they take away your power. They passive aggressively remove decision making power from your hands. They don’t trust you anymore.
Once you master Level 2, your chances of success increase exponentially
Getting to Level 3: independent thinking, Level 4: inviting critical feedback, Level 5: making better decisions
It’s the foundation of success: SHOW UP, BE HONEST
Volunteering that might make you look bad. But on the off chance it can benefit the enterprise
We care about how we look over the enterprise
When we prioritize fear in ourselves, the fear of looking bad – we are prioritizing SELF over the ENTERPRISE
-----
We don’t need to know everything…but when could jeopardize the enterprise..
Loyalty – the choice to protect your ego/ your brand/ your pride…vs do what’s right for the enterprise
Going to feel like you’ve been punched in the face – the first time you get it. You may not be able to function after it, can’t believe someone would talk to you like that.
Something Brene Brown said: “It’s you're job receiving feedback – find the pearls of wisdom b/c not everyone gives feedback well.”
Build a culture
People are scared to get feedback and give feedback. People are scared of the truth. But you can’t operate on bed of LHF. If decision making occurs on LHF, you’re gonna lose.
With practice like anything you become less scared…