The Road To No Where

Manas Ganguly
Manas GangulyFounder & Executive partner at Brightsandz Technologies LLP um Brightsandz Technologies LLP
The road to no where: Subhiksha Retail 13 th  February 2009
Views expressed hereby are  mine . I formed these views initially through interactions with Subhiksha on business levels and later through follow ups of the newspaper reports and conversations with sources from the industry and employees at Subhiksha. This is a follow up on my earlier presentation “The Anatomy of a Bust: Subhiksha Retail” http://www.slideshare.net/Manas.Ganguly/the-anatomy-of-a-bust
Carte Blanche ,[object Object],[object Object]
The Bust! ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Timelines: 30 th  Jan – 13 th  Feb A Degenerating situation ,[object Object],[object Object]
Inconvenient Truth ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Inconvenient Truth ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Inconvenient Truth ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Inconvenient Truth ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Food for thought ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
How did Subhiksha spend Rs.660 crores? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Option 1: Funding Expansion! ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Difficult to imagine such a FURIOUS level of expansion! Subhiksha had announced Consumer Durable stores and Private  Mandis during this period! However non of that saw the light of the day RS was risking Debtors money on very risky expansion plans In Other words “WHAT WERE YOU THINKING?”
Option 2: Financing Existing store Operations ,[object Object],[object Object],Subhiksha’s USP was discounts! It certainly looks like RS discounted his merchandise by 75% or more to eat  up all the Rs.620 in operations! Conversely, this means that a majority of stores were not making Money! Or so it would seem! In Other words, “That’s not BUSINESS! Where are the returns?”
Option 4: Option 1 + Option 2 ,[object Object],[object Object],In Other words “ More investments in a business, which was already  struggling  and  not performing” “ HARDLY GOOD BUSINESS SENSE”
Option3: Was the money siphoned off? ???
Option 5: Debt servicing of earlier loans ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],An aggressive expansion strategy based upon high leverage debt, without  Consolidation and nurturing profits could be a double jeopardy which it Eventually turned out to be
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Subramanian and his baby!
Fact of the matter ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Fact of the Matter ,[object Object],[object Object]
Fact of the matter ,[object Object],[object Object]
Resignation of Board members: Whats cooking? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Resignation of Board members: What's cooking? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
End Lines ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
End Lines ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Thanks
References ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
References ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
1 von 28

Recomendados

Ppt State Bank Group 1226349742695851 9 von
Ppt State Bank Group 1226349742695851 9Ppt State Bank Group 1226349742695851 9
Ppt State Bank Group 1226349742695851 9amit soni
337 views20 Folien
Introducation of SBI von
Introducation of SBI Introducation of SBI
Introducation of SBI Doleshwar Patel
1.4K views16 Folien
State bank of india von
State bank of india State bank of india
State bank of india Tarun Patel
711 views12 Folien
Sbi ppt von
Sbi pptSbi ppt
Sbi pptAhi Bhusan Mukherjee
581 views22 Folien
State Bank of India von
State Bank of IndiaState Bank of India
State Bank of IndiaSubrata Kumar Dey
1.5K views17 Folien
State bank of india von
State bank of indiaState bank of india
State bank of indiaRamakrishna Chinthi
284 views10 Folien

Más contenido relacionado

Was ist angesagt?

4 sbi von
4 sbi4 sbi
4 sbiDrSatishR
155 views27 Folien
SBI Introduction von
SBI IntroductionSBI Introduction
SBI IntroductionHardik Patel
35.4K views22 Folien
sbi History von
sbi Historysbi History
sbi Historyprashanth kumar
1.7K views5 Folien
State bank of india von
State bank of india State bank of india
State bank of india Bonny V Pappachan
3.3K views28 Folien
A Project on Axis Bank von
A Project on Axis BankA Project on Axis Bank
A Project on Axis BankSunil Kumar Behera
11.3K views18 Folien
Interim Reportfinal(Komal Maheshwari) von
Interim Reportfinal(Komal Maheshwari)Interim Reportfinal(Komal Maheshwari)
Interim Reportfinal(Komal Maheshwari)Axis Bank
746 views21 Folien

Was ist angesagt?(20)

SBI Introduction von Hardik Patel
SBI IntroductionSBI Introduction
SBI Introduction
Hardik Patel35.4K views
Interim Reportfinal(Komal Maheshwari) von Axis Bank
Interim Reportfinal(Komal Maheshwari)Interim Reportfinal(Komal Maheshwari)
Interim Reportfinal(Komal Maheshwari)
Axis Bank746 views
Comparitive analysis of sbi bank and icici bank von shweta248001
Comparitive analysis of sbi bank and icici bankComparitive analysis of sbi bank and icici bank
Comparitive analysis of sbi bank and icici bank
shweta24800141.4K views
Deposit scheme project report von surekhaparasur
Deposit scheme project reportDeposit scheme project report
Deposit scheme project report
surekhaparasur3.1K views
POWER POINT PRESENTATION ON STATE BANK OF INDIA AND ITS SUBSIDIARIES von Gandham Rajesh
POWER POINT PRESENTATION ON STATE BANK OF INDIA AND ITS SUBSIDIARIESPOWER POINT PRESENTATION ON STATE BANK OF INDIA AND ITS SUBSIDIARIES
POWER POINT PRESENTATION ON STATE BANK OF INDIA AND ITS SUBSIDIARIES
Gandham Rajesh7.4K views
co oparative bank training project report bharati nama von Cool Bharati
co oparative bank training project report bharati namaco oparative bank training project report bharati nama
co oparative bank training project report bharati nama
Cool Bharati67.4K views
Naresh Axis Bank Project von raki001
Naresh Axis Bank ProjectNaresh Axis Bank Project
Naresh Axis Bank Project
raki0015.2K views
Vijay orignal sbi.ppt von vijay soni
Vijay orignal sbi.pptVijay orignal sbi.ppt
Vijay orignal sbi.ppt
vijay soni5.6K views
Summer internship tranning report on jccb final von vachhani sumit
Summer internship tranning report on jccb finalSummer internship tranning report on jccb final
Summer internship tranning report on jccb final
vachhani sumit2.5K views

Destacado

Failure of subhiksha von
Failure of subhikshaFailure of subhiksha
Failure of subhikshaUdayan Sikdar
24.6K views33 Folien
Subhiksha von
SubhikshaSubhiksha
Subhikshashivpal
7K views22 Folien
Envp case von
Envp caseEnvp case
Envp casevinod097
406 views11 Folien
Subhiksha manendra von
Subhiksha manendraSubhiksha manendra
Subhiksha manendraManendra Shukla
1.6K views37 Folien
Subhiksha von
SubhikshaSubhiksha
SubhikshaSwagat Rath
524 views12 Folien
“LEVEL OF CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AT SUBHIKSHA” von
“LEVEL OF CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AT SUBHIKSHA”“LEVEL OF CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AT SUBHIKSHA”
“LEVEL OF CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AT SUBHIKSHA”BHOMA RAM
3.5K views45 Folien

Destacado(11)

Similar a The Road To No Where

Sordid Saga of Recovery Suits filed by India's Public Sector Banks von
Sordid Saga of Recovery Suits filed by India's Public Sector BanksSordid Saga of Recovery Suits filed by India's Public Sector Banks
Sordid Saga of Recovery Suits filed by India's Public Sector BanksShantanu Basu
377 views5 Folien
summer training in SBI about hosiery cluster in ludhiana city von
summer training in SBI about hosiery cluster in ludhiana citysummer training in SBI about hosiery cluster in ludhiana city
summer training in SBI about hosiery cluster in ludhiana cityAnmol Vashishat
1.8K views43 Folien
Sbiprojecthardikpatel2 140723072115-phpapp02 von
Sbiprojecthardikpatel2 140723072115-phpapp02Sbiprojecthardikpatel2 140723072115-phpapp02
Sbiprojecthardikpatel2 140723072115-phpapp02Harsha Grandhi
226 views22 Folien
AMAN SRIVASTAVA BRP REPORT.pdf von
AMAN SRIVASTAVA BRP REPORT.pdfAMAN SRIVASTAVA BRP REPORT.pdf
AMAN SRIVASTAVA BRP REPORT.pdfPrinceVerma938105
20 views102 Folien
60087744-CUSTOMER-S-PERCEPTION-TOWARDS-THE-LOAN-PRODUCT-OF-STATE-BANK-OF-INDI... von
60087744-CUSTOMER-S-PERCEPTION-TOWARDS-THE-LOAN-PRODUCT-OF-STATE-BANK-OF-INDI...60087744-CUSTOMER-S-PERCEPTION-TOWARDS-THE-LOAN-PRODUCT-OF-STATE-BANK-OF-INDI...
60087744-CUSTOMER-S-PERCEPTION-TOWARDS-THE-LOAN-PRODUCT-OF-STATE-BANK-OF-INDI...SHAIKMOHAMMADKHADIR
24 views60 Folien
4.1 sbi von
4.1 sbi4.1 sbi
4.1 sbiDrSatishR
507 views22 Folien

Similar a The Road To No Where(20)

Sordid Saga of Recovery Suits filed by India's Public Sector Banks von Shantanu Basu
Sordid Saga of Recovery Suits filed by India's Public Sector BanksSordid Saga of Recovery Suits filed by India's Public Sector Banks
Sordid Saga of Recovery Suits filed by India's Public Sector Banks
Shantanu Basu377 views
summer training in SBI about hosiery cluster in ludhiana city von Anmol Vashishat
summer training in SBI about hosiery cluster in ludhiana citysummer training in SBI about hosiery cluster in ludhiana city
summer training in SBI about hosiery cluster in ludhiana city
Anmol Vashishat1.8K views
Sbiprojecthardikpatel2 140723072115-phpapp02 von Harsha Grandhi
Sbiprojecthardikpatel2 140723072115-phpapp02Sbiprojecthardikpatel2 140723072115-phpapp02
Sbiprojecthardikpatel2 140723072115-phpapp02
Harsha Grandhi226 views
60087744-CUSTOMER-S-PERCEPTION-TOWARDS-THE-LOAN-PRODUCT-OF-STATE-BANK-OF-INDI... von SHAIKMOHAMMADKHADIR
60087744-CUSTOMER-S-PERCEPTION-TOWARDS-THE-LOAN-PRODUCT-OF-STATE-BANK-OF-INDI...60087744-CUSTOMER-S-PERCEPTION-TOWARDS-THE-LOAN-PRODUCT-OF-STATE-BANK-OF-INDI...
60087744-CUSTOMER-S-PERCEPTION-TOWARDS-THE-LOAN-PRODUCT-OF-STATE-BANK-OF-INDI...
Need for better customer services in Valsad district co-operative Bank von AnjaliSingh748
Need for better customer services in Valsad district co-operative BankNeed for better customer services in Valsad district co-operative Bank
Need for better customer services in Valsad district co-operative Bank
AnjaliSingh74858 views
Presentation on how to open a bank von Riskyrider
Presentation on how to open a bankPresentation on how to open a bank
Presentation on how to open a bank
Riskyrider23 views
Sbi and its associates merger von Biplab Mandal
Sbi and its associates mergerSbi and its associates merger
Sbi and its associates merger
Biplab Mandal7.1K views
Reserve Bank of India von aman963
Reserve Bank of IndiaReserve Bank of India
Reserve Bank of India
aman9631.6K views
Project report on ratio analysis of axis bank von Sukhchain Aggarwal
Project report on ratio analysis of axis bankProject report on ratio analysis of axis bank
Project report on ratio analysis of axis bank
Sukhchain Aggarwal46.1K views
Mergeroficicibankandbankofrajasthan 140126212042-phpapp01 von Tarun Devrani
Mergeroficicibankandbankofrajasthan 140126212042-phpapp01Mergeroficicibankandbankofrajasthan 140126212042-phpapp01
Mergeroficicibankandbankofrajasthan 140126212042-phpapp01
Tarun Devrani142 views
Lokesh_BBA_Project_on_Axis_Bank_Pvt_ltd20200403-114304-w6vuuq.pdf von tangadeH
Lokesh_BBA_Project_on_Axis_Bank_Pvt_ltd20200403-114304-w6vuuq.pdfLokesh_BBA_Project_on_Axis_Bank_Pvt_ltd20200403-114304-w6vuuq.pdf
Lokesh_BBA_Project_on_Axis_Bank_Pvt_ltd20200403-114304-w6vuuq.pdf
tangadeH30 views

Más de Manas Ganguly

Brightsandz_Profile (1) von
Brightsandz_Profile (1)Brightsandz_Profile (1)
Brightsandz_Profile (1)Manas Ganguly
226 views16 Folien
OTT versus Operator von
OTT versus OperatorOTT versus Operator
OTT versus OperatorManas Ganguly
1.6K views1 Folie
GSMA Mobile Economy India Report 2013 von
GSMA Mobile Economy India Report 2013GSMA Mobile Economy India Report 2013
GSMA Mobile Economy India Report 2013Manas Ganguly
1.8K views84 Folien
Data business - The Indian Context von
Data business - The Indian ContextData business - The Indian Context
Data business - The Indian ContextManas Ganguly
571 views17 Folien
India Data Traffic – The Broadband Story von
India Data Traffic – The Broadband StoryIndia Data Traffic – The Broadband Story
India Data Traffic – The Broadband StoryManas Ganguly
1.1K views15 Folien
LTE-Operational Challenges & Deployment conundrum von
LTE-Operational Challenges & Deployment conundrumLTE-Operational Challenges & Deployment conundrum
LTE-Operational Challenges & Deployment conundrumManas Ganguly
2.2K views19 Folien

Más de Manas Ganguly(20)

GSMA Mobile Economy India Report 2013 von Manas Ganguly
GSMA Mobile Economy India Report 2013GSMA Mobile Economy India Report 2013
GSMA Mobile Economy India Report 2013
Manas Ganguly1.8K views
Data business - The Indian Context von Manas Ganguly
Data business - The Indian ContextData business - The Indian Context
Data business - The Indian Context
Manas Ganguly571 views
India Data Traffic – The Broadband Story von Manas Ganguly
India Data Traffic – The Broadband StoryIndia Data Traffic – The Broadband Story
India Data Traffic – The Broadband Story
Manas Ganguly1.1K views
LTE-Operational Challenges & Deployment conundrum von Manas Ganguly
LTE-Operational Challenges & Deployment conundrumLTE-Operational Challenges & Deployment conundrum
LTE-Operational Challenges & Deployment conundrum
Manas Ganguly2.2K views
Data in indian context – networks & traffic von Manas Ganguly
Data in indian context – networks & trafficData in indian context – networks & traffic
Data in indian context – networks & traffic
Manas Ganguly579 views
Smart TV in Indian Context: Great product, limited functionality von Manas Ganguly
Smart TV in Indian Context: Great product, limited functionalitySmart TV in Indian Context: Great product, limited functionality
Smart TV in Indian Context: Great product, limited functionality
Manas Ganguly1.2K views
Mobile Media: Future of Mobile media powered by Applications von Manas Ganguly
Mobile Media: Future of Mobile media powered by ApplicationsMobile Media: Future of Mobile media powered by Applications
Mobile Media: Future of Mobile media powered by Applications
Manas Ganguly1.4K views
State Of Internet In India von Manas Ganguly
State Of Internet In IndiaState Of Internet In India
State Of Internet In India
Manas Ganguly1.2K views
The Indian Mobile Consumer von Manas Ganguly
The Indian Mobile ConsumerThe Indian Mobile Consumer
The Indian Mobile Consumer
Manas Ganguly1.3K views
Google’s Mobile Strategy von Manas Ganguly
Google’s Mobile StrategyGoogle’s Mobile Strategy
Google’s Mobile Strategy
Manas Ganguly765 views

Último

Super Solar Mounting Solutions 20230509(1).pdf von
Super Solar Mounting Solutions 20230509(1).pdfSuper Solar Mounting Solutions 20230509(1).pdf
Super Solar Mounting Solutions 20230509(1).pdfcarrie55bradshaw
12 views25 Folien
Navigating the Complexity of Derivatives Valuation 📈 von
Navigating the Complexity of Derivatives Valuation 📈Navigating the Complexity of Derivatives Valuation 📈
Navigating the Complexity of Derivatives Valuation 📈ValAdvisor
15 views6 Folien
The Talent Management Navigator Performance Management von
The Talent Management Navigator Performance ManagementThe Talent Management Navigator Performance Management
The Talent Management Navigator Performance ManagementSeta Wicaksana
35 views36 Folien
HSI CareFree Service Plan 2023 (2).pdf von
HSI CareFree Service Plan 2023 (2).pdfHSI CareFree Service Plan 2023 (2).pdf
HSI CareFree Service Plan 2023 (2).pdfHomeSmart Installations
43 views1 Folie
sample.potx von
sample.potxsample.potx
sample.potxMaryna Yurchenko
20 views3 Folien
Assignment 4: Reporting to Management.pptx von
Assignment 4: Reporting to Management.pptxAssignment 4: Reporting to Management.pptx
Assignment 4: Reporting to Management.pptxBethanyAline
21 views20 Folien

Último(20)

Super Solar Mounting Solutions 20230509(1).pdf von carrie55bradshaw
Super Solar Mounting Solutions 20230509(1).pdfSuper Solar Mounting Solutions 20230509(1).pdf
Super Solar Mounting Solutions 20230509(1).pdf
carrie55bradshaw12 views
Navigating the Complexity of Derivatives Valuation 📈 von ValAdvisor
Navigating the Complexity of Derivatives Valuation 📈Navigating the Complexity of Derivatives Valuation 📈
Navigating the Complexity of Derivatives Valuation 📈
ValAdvisor15 views
The Talent Management Navigator Performance Management von Seta Wicaksana
The Talent Management Navigator Performance ManagementThe Talent Management Navigator Performance Management
The Talent Management Navigator Performance Management
Seta Wicaksana35 views
Assignment 4: Reporting to Management.pptx von BethanyAline
Assignment 4: Reporting to Management.pptxAssignment 4: Reporting to Management.pptx
Assignment 4: Reporting to Management.pptx
BethanyAline21 views
Better Appeals and Solicitations - Bloomerang.pdf von Bloomerang
Better Appeals and Solicitations - Bloomerang.pdfBetter Appeals and Solicitations - Bloomerang.pdf
Better Appeals and Solicitations - Bloomerang.pdf
Bloomerang81 views
Bloomerang_Forecasting Your Fundraising Revenue 2024.pptx.pdf von Bloomerang
Bloomerang_Forecasting Your Fundraising Revenue 2024.pptx.pdfBloomerang_Forecasting Your Fundraising Revenue 2024.pptx.pdf
Bloomerang_Forecasting Your Fundraising Revenue 2024.pptx.pdf
Bloomerang167 views
The Truth About Customer Journey Mapping von Aggregage
The Truth About Customer Journey MappingThe Truth About Customer Journey Mapping
The Truth About Customer Journey Mapping
Aggregage117 views
Nevigating Sucess.pdf von TEWMAGAZINE
Nevigating Sucess.pdfNevigating Sucess.pdf
Nevigating Sucess.pdf
TEWMAGAZINE26 views
Why are KPIs(key performance indicators) important? von Epixel MLM Software
Why are KPIs(key performance indicators) important? Why are KPIs(key performance indicators) important?
Why are KPIs(key performance indicators) important?
Accounts Class 12 project cash flow statement and ratio analysis von JinendraPamecha
Accounts Class 12 project cash flow statement and ratio analysisAccounts Class 12 project cash flow statement and ratio analysis
Accounts Class 12 project cash flow statement and ratio analysis
JinendraPamecha50 views
Navigating EUDR Compliance within the Coffee Industry von Peter Horsten
Navigating EUDR Compliance within the Coffee IndustryNavigating EUDR Compliance within the Coffee Industry
Navigating EUDR Compliance within the Coffee Industry
Peter Horsten46 views
Top 10 IT Tasks Small Businesses Can Entrust to Offshore Professionals von altafhsayyednimetler
Top 10 IT Tasks Small Businesses Can Entrust to Offshore ProfessionalsTop 10 IT Tasks Small Businesses Can Entrust to Offshore Professionals
Top 10 IT Tasks Small Businesses Can Entrust to Offshore Professionals
PMU Launch - Guaranteed Slides von pmulaunch
PMU Launch - Guaranteed SlidesPMU Launch - Guaranteed Slides
PMU Launch - Guaranteed Slides
pmulaunch18 views

The Road To No Where

  • 1. The road to no where: Subhiksha Retail 13 th February 2009
  • 2. Views expressed hereby are mine . I formed these views initially through interactions with Subhiksha on business levels and later through follow ups of the newspaper reports and conversations with sources from the industry and employees at Subhiksha. This is a follow up on my earlier presentation “The Anatomy of a Bust: Subhiksha Retail” http://www.slideshare.net/Manas.Ganguly/the-anatomy-of-a-bust
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15. Option3: Was the money siphoned off? ???
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 27.
  • 28.