Using the Guggenheim Helsinki proposal as a case study, I created a proposal for an imaginary museum called The American Museum of Wonder and Curiosity Cabinets. The PowerPoint presentation includes the following sections:
• Introduction to The American Museum of Wonder and Curiosity Cabinets
• Location Rationale
• Mission Statement
• Members of the Board of Directors
• Building Program
• Exhibition Plans
• Permanent Collection
• Special Exhibitions
Ideal Museum Project: The American Museum of Wonder and Curiosity Cabinets Proposal PowerPoint Presentation
1. Mission Statement:
“To display, collect, and preserve artifacts
relevant to the study of the visual arts and
sciences and their histories, as well as pay
homage to the history of museums and
museology in the Western European
tradition while incorporating American
history and resources in the presentation of
artifacts and design of exhibitions.”
2. Curiosity cabinets serve
as a pre-cursor to the
modern-day museum,
and their contents and
displays can be seen as a
history of museums
Royalty and members of the
aristocracy were the foremost
collectors
Tsar Peter I
Ferdinand II, Archduke of Austria
Rudolf II, Holy Roman Emperor
Francesco I de’Medici, Grand Duke
of Tuscany
Charles I of England
Frontispiece for the Museum Wormianum, 1655, which depicts Ole Worm’s
cabinet of curiosities
3. The vast majority of these collections remain in
Europe
The Kunstkamera in Saint Petersburg was founded by
Peter the Great, making it Russia’s first museum
Many of these collections can be found in England
▪ Ashmolean Museum (the first university museum) and the Pitt
Rivers, both in Oxford
▪ The British Museum in London
Other collections can be found in Germany, the Czech
Republic, Austria, the Netherlands, and Scandinavia
Can be held in science and anthropological museums,
studiolos, or former palaces
4. Similar types of museums are rare in the United States, and they can
be confusing and sound misleading
The Museum of Jurassic Technology in Los Angeles
▪ Introduces itself as “an educational institution dedicated to the advancement of
knowledge and the public appreciation of the Lower Jurassic…”
▪ While the MJT’s intro and purpose becomes clearer upon further reading… “The public
museum as understood today, is a collection of specimens and other objects of interest
to the scholar, the man of science as well as the more casual visitor, arranged and
displayed in accordance with the scientific method…”
▪ … and one realizes it’s a “museum of museums….”
▪ Visitors have already made up their minds—the MJT must be a dinosaur museum!
The Mütter Museum in Philadelphia
▪ Part of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia, so not completely autonomous…
▪ …which makes its website surprisingly difficult to navigate
▪ The museum is an eponym—doesn’t provide any hints as to what’s inside the museum
or the nature of its collections
▪ And that umlaut throws many people off!
5. Make these collections available to the public,
not just for private viewing by the extremely
wealthy
Understand and appreciate art using objects
traditionally not considered as such
Understand how ideas and thought processes
change over time
Presentation can be flexible, as different
arrangements of objects create different
meanings and contexts
6. The ideal architect is Bertram Grosvenor Goodhue (1869-
1924), who designed several buildings across the U.S.
Goodhue designed spaces that served several functions
necessary for a stable community: religious, civic, and
educational
St. Thomas Church, St. Bartholomew's Episcopal Church, and Church
of St. Vincent Ferrer, all of which are located on the UES
Grolier Club also on the UES
Los Angeles Central Library in Downtown L.A.
▪ Holdings include the Science, Technology & Patents Department
▪ The John Feathers map collection, which is a recent acquisition. Once cataloguing is finished the
LACL will have the fifth-largest map collection in the U.S.
National Academy of Sciences building in Washington, D.C.
7. Renovation of an existing building or constructing a new
one are both appropriate architectural programs for the
AMWCC
Planners and builders have easy access to the Bertram
Grosvenor Goodhue Architectural Drawings and Papers,
1882-1980 Collection at Columbia University’s Avery
Architectural and Fine Arts Library in their Department of
Drawings & Archives
Some of Goodhue’s buildings were completed posthumously
by other architectural firms and designers, such as the
Oriental Institute at the University of Chicago
8. The ideal location would be on the Upper East Side in
close proximity to Museum Mile
Visitors would have the option of seeing a more specialized
collection that’s close to Museum Mile
Museum Mile incorporates several specialized museums,
including the Neue Galerie, El Museo del Barrio, and most
recently, the Museum of African Art
▪ The Museum of African Art is supposed to reopen in 2014 under the
new name the New Africa Center
Demonstrates that Museum Mile isn’t a static area and the
museum-going public desires new institutions that allow
visitors to explore alternate U.S. histories and experiences
9. Florence Fearrington
Joanna Ebenstein
Robert D. Hicks, PhD
John Coppola
Judith B. Prowda, Esq.
10. Education:
AB from the University of North Carolina—Chapel
Hill, 1958
Certificate in Business Administration from the
Harvard-Radcliffe Program, 1961
Activities:
Trustee at Grinnell College in Grinnell, Iowa
Member of the Council of the Bibliographical
Society of America and the Grolier Club, both in
New York
Member of the American Antiquarian Society in
Worcester, Massachusetts
Library Fellow at the American Museum of Natural
History
Professional Experience:
Founder and former President of Florence
Fearrington Inc., an investment management firm
(now part of the U.S. Trust Company of New York)
Curator of the exhibition “Rooms of Wonder: From
Wunderkammer to Museum,” which has been
shown at Harvard University’s Houghton Library
and the Grolier Club in New York
Since October 4th, 2013, the exhibition has been at
Grinnell College’s Faulconer Gallery and will be on
view until December 15th, 2013
At UNC-Chapel Hill’s Wilson Library from February
20th, 2014 to April 20th, 2014
Florence Fearrington (left) with William P. Stoneman,
the first Florence Fearrington Librarian of
Houghton Library at Harvard University.
11. Why her?
Longtime and avid collector of rare books and
antiques
Has easy access to sources and materials that
could be used for exhibitions at the AMWCC
Supporter and donator for other organizations
outside of the cultural realm in addition to her
professional and academic affiliations
▪ A nice way of saying that she has tons of money,
which never hurts
12. Founder of the Morbid Anatomy Library
in Brooklyn and its blog, which “survey[s]
the interstices of art and medicine, death
and culture”
Education:
BA, University of California—Santa
Cruz
Organizations:
Founding Member of Observatory in
Brooklyn
Wellcome Trust in London
The Coney Island Museum
Activities:
Artist
Photographer
Lecturer
Collector
Traveler
13. Why her?
The Morbid Anatomy Library statement of purpose
complements the mission and goals of the AMWCC
▪ “The Morbid Anatomy Library is a research library and private
museum in Brooklyn, New York. It is committed to celebrating and
providing materials dedicated to the places where death and beauty
intersect. The library makes available a collection of curiosities,
books, photographs, artworks, ephemera, and artifacts relating to
medical museums, anatomical art, collectors and collecting,
cabinets of curiosity, the history of medicine, death and society,
natural history, arcane media, and curiosity and curiosities broadly
considered.”
The MAL is free to the public
Observatory offers lectures and studio workshops, some of
which involve taxidermy and Victorian hair art
Only working artist on the Board of Directors
14. Director of the Mütter Museum and
Historical Medical Library of the College
of Physicians of Philadelphia
Director of the Francis Clark Wood
Institute for the History of Medicine at the
College of Physicians of Philadelphia
William Maul Measey Chair for the History
of Medicine
Education:
PhD, University of Exeter
Anthropology and Archeology from the
University of Arizona
Professional Experience
Director of the Roy Eddleman Institute for
Education and Interpretation at the
Chemical Heritage Foundation in
Philadelphia
U.S. Naval officer and worked in criminal
justice for over two decades
Author of Voyage to Jamestown: Practical
Navigation in the Age of Discovery (U.S.
Naval Institute Press, 2011)
15. Why him?
The Mütter Museum as one of the first
American Curiosity Cabinets
Experience with collections management,
exhibitions, and educational outreach for over
30 years
Expert in several fields of science and history
▪ PhD is in Maritime History
16. Member of the National Museum and
Library Services Board
Graduate Instructor in Curatorial Studies
and Museum Management at Corcoran
College of Art and Design in Washington,
D.C.
Professional Experience
Director of the Office of Exhibits Central at
the Smithsonian Institution
Chief of the Bureau of International
Expositions
Exhibitions Program Manager for Arts
America at the U.S. Information Agency
(now part of the U.S. State Department)
Exhibition Manager for the Museum of
Latin American Art, the Smithsonian
Latino Center, the National Museum of
Women in the Arts in Washington, D.C., St.
Thomas University in Miami, and the
Stonewall Library & Archives in Fort
Lauderdale
17. Why him?
Appointed by President Obama to the NMLBS
Governing and political experience
Works with international and culturally diverse
communities
▪ Museum consultant in the Middle East and Latin
America
▪ Has overseen exhibitions pertaining to historically
underrepresented groups
18.
19.
20. Dealing with multiple and often overlapping fields of
practice, including
Entertainment, Arts, and Sports Law (EASL)
Environmental Law
Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Law
Intellectual Property (IP) Law
International Law
Need specialists within these fields
Copyrights, Trademarks, and Patents (IP)
International Business and Transactions (International Law)
Cultural Property and Ownership (EASL)
21. EASL Committees include:
Alternative Dispute Resolution
Copyright and Trademark
Digital Media
Fashion Law
Fine Arts
Literary Works and Related Rights
Motion Pictures
Music and Recording Industry
Publications
Television and Radio
Theatre and Performing Arts
International Committee
22. IP committees include:
Copyright Law
International IP
Patent Law
Pro Bono and Public Interest
Trademark Law
Transactional Law
23. International Law committees include:
Committee on Europe
Committee on International Art Law, Art Funds,
and Art Finance
24. Senior Lecturer at Sotheby’s Institute of Art in New York
Education:
LLM from New York University School of Law
JD from Fordham University School of Law
MA in International Relations from Johns Hopkins
University
MA in French from Middlebury College
Certificate from l’Institut d’Etudes Politiques in Paris
Professional Experience:
Chair of the NYSBA Committee on Fine Arts
Co-Founder and Co-Chair of the NYSBA Committee on
Alternative Dispute Resolution
Immediate Past Chair of the NYSBA EASL Section
Editorial Board Member of the Copyright Society of the
USA
Author of Visual Arts and the Law: A Handbook for
Professionals (Lund Humphries 2013)
25. Why her?
Expert in EASL, IP Law, and International Law
▪ Specializes in legal issues pertaining to fine arts
Holds prominent positions in professional
organizations while working in academia
Writes several articles for law journals and
professional texts
Former journalist and interpreter for the U.S. State
Department
Based in NY, but has worked in Paris and Geneva as
an attorney and mediator
26. One permanent collection, and three or
four special exhibitions a year, with the
possibility of traveling nationwide and/or
internationally in the future
References American cultural history and phenomena,
such as circuses and sideshows, as well as the rapid
physical expansion of the U.S.
27. Relics and Reliquaries around the U.S.
▪ The Holy Finger of Kansas City at the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art in
Kansas City, Missouri
▪ St. Valentine’s relics at Old St. Ferdinand Church in Florissant, Missouri
▪ The Maria Stein Convent in Maria Stein, Ohio
▪ St. Herman’s Reliquary in Kodiak, Alaska
▪ St. Edmund’s arm in the Chapel of Our Lady of Assumption at Saint
Edmund's Retreat in Mystic, Connecticut
Medical and pharmaceutical ephemera in the growth of the
American drugstore—explores scientific breakthroughs, “cure-alls,”
quack medicine, and the like
▪ Materials from the Museum of Questionable Medical Devices in Minnesota
(now part of the Science Museum of Minnesota in St. Paul)
▪ The American Institute of the History of Pharmacy in Madison, Wisconsin
Memento moris and Victorian funerary practices
▪ Death masks
▪ Postmortem photographs
28. William Michael Harnett, Music and Literature, 1878, oil on
canvas, Albright-Knox Art Gallery, Buffalo, NY