Performance Benchmark with HammerDB Oracle is still performing much better

1. BASEL BERN BRUGG DÜSSELDORF FRANKFURT A.M. FREIBURG I.BR. GENEVA
HAMBURG COPENHAGEN LAUSANNE MUNICH STUTTGART VIENNA ZURICH
PostgreSQL vs Oracle
OLTP performance benchmark against Oracle.
Jacques Kostic Principal Consultant

2. PostgreSQL Best Practices2 04/05/2019
Experience:
• Initially C/C++ developer
• In touch with Oracle since 1990 from version 4 on SCO Unix!
• High Availability and Backup & Recovery Architect
• SQL and Instance Performance & Tuning
• License Audit and Consolidation
Certifications:
• Oracle Certified Master 11g & 12c
• Oracle 11g Performance Tuning Certified Expert
• Oracle RAC 11g and Grid Infrastructure Administration
• Oracle Exadata Administrator Certified Expert
• Oracle Certified SQL Expert 11g
Teaching Courses at Trivadis:
• Oracle 11g & 12c Grid Infrastructure & RAC
• Oracle 11g & 12c Data Guard
• Oracle 11g & 12c Performance & Tuning
• Oracle 11g & 12c Administration
• SQL & PL-SQL
• OEM – 12 & 13
About me…
@JKOFR

3. Agenda
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/2019
1. OLTP performance benchmark PostgreSQL vs Oracle
Configuration
Results
2. Conclusion
Takeaway
3

4. 5/4/2019
OLTP Performance Benchmark
PostgreSQL vs Oracle
Oracle DBaaS4

5. OLTP Test: PostGreSQL vs Oracle
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/20195
Goal
Use the same type of machine
Test the same OLTP workload on both databases
Test different CPU allocation
Compare the results

6. OLTP Test: PostGreSQL vs Oracle: Configuration
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/20196
Server details
Main host:
• 2 * 8 cores CPU E5-2680 0 @ 2.70GHz
• OEL 7.2
• 192 GB
• Flash Storage volumes on PCIe cards (no NVMe)
VMs:
• 8 vCPU
• 8 GB RAM
Concurrent sessions:
• 100

7. OLTP Test: PostGreSQL vs Oracle : Configuration
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/20197
Hammerdbcli PostGreSQL Test Setup
dbset db pg
diset tpcc pg_defaultdbase hammerdb
loadscript
vudestroy
vuset delay 5
vuset repeat 5
vuset showoutput 1
vuset timestamps 1
vuset logtotemp 1
vuset vu 100
vucreate
vurun

8. OLTP Test: PostGreSQL vs Oracle : Configuration
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/20198
Hammerdbcli Oracle Test Setup
dbset db ora
diset connection instance jko
loadscript
vudestroy
vuset delay 5
vuset repeat 5
vuset showoutput 1
vuset timestamps 1
vuset logtotemp 1
vuset vu 100
vucreate
vurun

9. OLTP Test: PostGreSQL vs Oracle : Results
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/20199
PostGreSQL
Time to complete the full test  4.23 mn
Average CPU Usage  88 %
Transaction per minutes max  156’222

10. OLTP Test: PostGreSQL vs Oracle : Results
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/201910
Oracle
Time to complete the full test  Time 4.12 mn
Average CPU Usage  74 %
Transaction per minutes max  172’268

11. OLTP Test: PostGreSQL vs Oracle : Results
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/201911
select sum(value) from v$sysstat where name = 'user commits' or name = 'user rollbacks'
select sum(xact_commit + xact_rollback) from pg_stat_database

12. OLTP Test: PostGreSQL vs Oracle : Configuration
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/201912
Lets Scale!
Main host:
• 2 * 8 cores CPU E5-2680 0 @ 2.70GHz
• OEL 7.2
• 192 GB
• Flash Storage volumes on PCIe cards (no NVMe)
VMs:
• 16 vCPU
• 8 GB RAM
Concurrent sessions:
• 100

13. OLTP Test: PostGreSQL vs Oracle : Results
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/201913
PostGreSQL
Time to complete the full test  Time 3.27 mn
Average CPU Usage  65 %
Transaction per minutes max  194’904

14. OLTP Test: PostGreSQL vs Oracle : Results
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/201914
Oracle
Time to complete the full test  Time 3.16 mn
Average CPU Usage  57 %
Transaction per minutes max  251’292

15. OLTP Test: PostGreSQL vs Oracle : Results
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/201915
select sum(value) from v$sysstat where name = 'user commits' or name = 'user rollbacks'
select sum(xact_commit + xact_rollback) from pg_stat_database

16. OLTP Test: PostGreSQL vs Oracle : Results
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/201916
8 vCPU
2.6% Faster 16% Less CPU 9.3% More TPM

17. OLTP Test: PostGreSQL vs Oracle : Results
PostgreSQL Best Practices5/4/201917
16 vCPU
3.4% Faster 12.3% Less CPU 22.43% More TPM

18. Jacques Kostic, Principal Consultant
Tel. +41-79-909 7263 Jacques.Kostic@trivadis.com
5/4/201918 TechEvent September 2018