SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 31
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
Will it Ever Really Count?
Prof Greg Marsden
Institute for Transport Studies
Sustainable Development and
Sustainable Transportation
Sustainable Development and
Sustainable Transportation
National
Economic System
Global Market
Urban System
Telecommunications
System
Energy/Power
System
Water and Sewage
System
Transportation
System
Land Use
Institutional
Structure
Infrastructure
System
System Users/
Stakeholders
Transportation
Modes
Intermodal
Connections
Transit Network Highway Network
Non-motorized
Network
Airway Network
Source: Adapted from Meyer
and Miller (2001, p. 91).
Collectors LocalArterials
Sustainable Development and
Sustainable Transportation
Physical
Systems
Production
Consumption
Waste
Raw
Materials
Solar
Energy Heat
Recycled
Materials
ECOSYSTEM
Other …
Energy
Transportation
Communication
Industrial
Source: Adapted from Daly
(1991)
Sustainable Development and
Sustainable Transportation
“There can be no sustainable development
without sustainable transportation. It is an
essential component not only because transportation is a
prerequisite to development in general but also because
transportation, especially our use of motorized vehicles,
contributes substantially to a wide range of
environmental problems, including energy waste, global
warming, degradation of air and water, noise, ecosystem
loss and fragmentation, and desecration of the
landscape. Our nation’s environmental quality will be
sustainable only if we pursue transportation in a
sustainable way” (Benfield and Replogle 2002, p. 647).
Example Impacts
Economic Environmental Social
• Costs of transport to
customers/consumers
•Time loss in traffic/ Congestion
• Costs relating to accidents
•Transportation facility
construction, maintenance and
disposal costs
•Transportation-related health
costs
•Depletion of non-renewable
resources and energy supplies
• Air pollution
• Noise pollution
• Vibration
• Light pollution
• Visual intrusion
• Water pollution
• Consumption of land/urban
sprawl
• Release of toxic/hazardous
substances
• Solid waste
• Disruption of ecosystems and
habitats
• Hydrologic impacts
• Introduction of exotic species
• Depletion of the ozone layer
• Global climate change
• Mobility
• Accessibility
• Accidents
• Obesity
• Barriers for the disadvantaged
•Inequalities associated with
impacts
• Community livability
• Gender imbalances
• Cohesion/integration
• Opportunity
• Anxiety/’Rootlessness’
• Migration
Source: Gudmundsson and Cornet
Sustainable Development and
Sustainable Transportation
• a critical component of a broader economic system which
supports business and social development;
• an open system, which requires natural and man-made inputs
and produces outputs which impact on the environment;
• part of a social system that shapes and is shaped by that social
system, including other policy areas;
• comprised of a series of physical sub-systems with a range of
physical and operational components and which are organized
through formal and informal conventions; and
• fragmented series of partly connected yet partly competing
sub-systems with complex and varying governance
arrangements.
Sustainable Transportation
Where to make it count?
POLICY
LEVEL
ORGANIZATIONAL
LEVEL
PROJECT
LEVEL
Source: Gudmundsson and Cornet
European Transport White Paper
Policy Level
• Overarching Aim
to build a competitive transport system
that will increase mobility, remove major
barriers in key areas and fuel growth and
employment. At the same time, the
proposals will dramatically reduce Europe's
dependence on imported oil and cut
carbon emissions in transport by 60% by
2050
Remembering Context
Remembering Context
Economic Impacts Assessed
Impact Areas Indicators
Economic Impacts
Transport Activity Passenger kilometers and tonne kilometers by all modes.
Modal Shift Share of passenger or tonne kilometers by mode.
Transport costs to users Unit cost per passenger or tonne transported (including capital costs, fixed operation
costs and variable fuel and non-fuel costs).
Economic growth Qualitative inference of policy impacts on GDP only.
Efficiency of the transport
system
Not defined but incorporates notions of smart pricing, efficient networks, fuel efficiency
and vehicle purchase costs.
Congestion Average speed and use of available road capacity.
Household costs The share of passenger transport costs within the household income of the average EU
household.
Transport related sectors Not defined but qualitative inference of the potential of the strategies to support the
European vehicle manufacturing industry.
Innovation and research Not defined but qualitative inference about the impact of the strategy on research spend
on green innovation.
Reduction of administrative
burden
Not defined but qualitative inference about overall levels of administration.
EU budget Not defined as will be assessed on a case by case basis.
International relations Not defined but qualitative inference about the potential synergies and conflicts with
Social Impacts Assessed
Impact Areas Indicators
Social Impacts
Degree of mobility Refers to the % change in total transport activity for passengers with an
overall reduction being negative.
Choice Not defined but qualitative inferences about rail investments improving
choice.
Accessibility Potential accessibility is a generalized cost based measure. Larger areas are
more attractive and cost, time and distance are negative separation factors.
Distributional Impacts Not clearly defined although the analysis refers in part to the distribution of
household costs by income band.
Employment level and
conditions
Number of jobs in the transport sector. Skills and working conditions are not
defined clearly.
Safety External costs of accidents and total number of accidents.
Environmental Impacts Assessed
Impact Areas Indicators
Environmental Impacts
Climate Change Total CO2 emissions from transport. Both transport and well to wheel analyses are
presented.
Air pollution Emissions of NOx and PM10 and external costs of these pollutants.
Noise pollution External costs of noise pollution.
Energy use/energy
efficiency
Total energy demand from transport Millions of Tonnes of Oil Equivalent (reviewed in
detail below). Energy intensity is an efficiency indicator that uses total energy demand
and transport activity to create a ratio for passenger and freight.
Renewable energy
use
Total energy demand split by fossil fuels, biofuels and electricity.
Biodiversity Not defined but qualitatively refers to fragmentation, land-take, loss of biodiversity and
damage to eco-system services.
European Transport White Paper
-200
-150
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
200
CO2 intensity Energy intensity Activity level Total
Urban Interurban Intercontinental
-44%
-40%
-74%
Passenger transport
33%
31%
120%
-22%
-19%
51%
MtonCO2
0%-11%
-10%
Review of Do-Minimum Case
Factors Influencing CO2 emissions
European Transport White PaperPolicy Option 2 Policy Option 3 Policy Option 4
Economic Impacts
Transport Activity -- = -
Modal Shift ++ = +
Transport costs to users --- = --
Economic growth ++ + +++
Efficiency of the transport system ++ + +++
Congestion ++ = +
Household costs -- - --
Transport related sectors + +++ +++
Innovation and research + +++ ++
Reduction of administrative burden + = +
EU budget = = =
International relations -- - -
Social Impacts
Degree of mobility --- = -
Choice ++ = ++
Accessibility ++ = ++
Distributional Impacts = - +
Employment level and conditions ++ ++ +++
Safety ++ = +
Environmental Impacts
Climate Change +++ +++ +++
Air pollution +++ ++ ++
Noise pollution +++ ++ +
European Transport White Paper
• Largest Scale attempt for Sustainable
Transport Assessment
• Significant improvement in transparency
• Informs policy package choice (coherence with
longer-term goals)
• Positive role as a signal
European Transport White Paper
• Modelling systems not robust
• Indicators are so aggregate as to lose meaning
• Social context is flattened
• Does not really reach out beyond transport
• Implementation is largely national
– Is this joined up?
• Only limited signs that constraints are to play a
part
• “Curbing Mobility is not an option”
– Weak sustainability
High Speed Rail
• Decision taken in same way
as other infrastructure
projects
• Bespoke Sustainability
Appraisal also commissioned
Phase 1 Phase 2 Rolling Stock Total
Target Cost 17.16 n/a
Estimated Cost 15.65 12.5 5.8 33.95
Contingency 5.75 8.7 1.7 16.15
Total 21.4 21.2 7.5 50.1
Source: Environmental Audit Committee
Towards documents about sustainable
transportation (2007, 2008)
Indicators
Greenhouse Gas Emissions
CO2 emissions by end user (industry, transport, domestic, other)
Aviation and shipping emissions
Private Vehicles: CO2 emissions, car-km, and final household expenditure
Road Freight: CO2 emissions, tonne-km, tonnes, and GDP
Road Transport Emissions NOx, PM10, CO2 emissions, and GDP
Emissions of air pollutants
Air Quality and Health
Ecological impacts of air pollution
Mobility
Getting to school
Accessibility
What is HS2 for?
• Never been articulated as part of a sustainable transport
strategy
• 2009 SoS Transport Geoff Hoon announced creation of HS2
Limited in a statement to Parliament about expansion of
Heathrow
• 2 years previously, the Rail White Paper had said:
• “Higher speed is not the only or best way of cutting journey times.
Nor is it without cost. Increasing the maximum speed of a train
from 200 km/h to 350 km/h means a 90 per cent increase in energy
consumption. In exchange, it cuts station-to-station journey time by
less than 25 per cent and door-to-door journey-time by even less. …
The argument that high-speed rail travel is a ‘green option’ does not
stand up to close inspection on the basis of the present electricity
generation mix.” (DfT, 2007b, p. 62).
What is HS2 for?
• The remit of HS2 Limited was subsequently clarified to
focus, in order of priority on:
• Passenger capacity: “this is the driving consideration,
including capacity released on classic lines”;
• Speed;
• Land use and development objectives and the support
of new housing development; and
• Developing the line to be capable of handling freight
for greater network resilience.
• Modal shift from air to rail was “not expected to be a
key objective for HS2” (Rowlands, 2009).
Sustainability Appraisal
Source: Geisler et al. (2011)
Sustainability Appraisal
Key Sustainability Issue Objective
Reducing greenhouse gas emissions and combating climate change
Climatic factors and
adaptability
 Improve resilience of the rail network against extreme
weather events
Greenhouse Gases  Contribute to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions by
facilitating modal shift from road and air to rail
 Reduce relative contribution made by rail to greenhouse
gas emissions by promoting energy efficient technologies
Natural and cultural resource protection and environmental enhancement
Landscape and townscape  Maintain and enhance existing landscape character
 Maintain and enhance existing townscape character
• 18 sustainability issues
• 33 objectives as shown in Table
• 33 objectives => 66 evaluation criteria
Sustainability Appraisal
HS2 Objectives and Option identification process
Option Generation
Scheme Components London
Terminus
Line of
Route
Etc.
Sift 1
90+ long list options
Review of Operations, Cost
Demand and Engineering HS2 Board
Decision Point 1
Sift 2
50+ intermediate list options
Appraisal including simplified
Appraisal of Sustainability HS2 Board
Decision Point 2
Sift 3
Shortlist of stations and whole routes
Appraisal including full
Appraisal of Sustainability HS2 Board
Decision Point 3
Finalising preferred scheme and main alternatives
Likely Impact of Proposed
HS2
Likely change between the
current baseline and
future baseline
Cumulative Impacts
Reducing greenhouse gas emissions and combating climate change
resilience of the rail network + 0 +
greenhouse gas emissions +/- + +
Natural and cultural resource protection and environmental enhancement
landscape character -- - --
townscape character 0 0 0
archeological assets - 0 -
historic buildings - - -
historic landscapes - - -
biodiversity - - -
surface water resources - 0 -
groundwater resources - - -
capacity of flood plains - - --
Creating sustainable communities
local air quality U + +
local noise environment -- - --
local vibration environment - 0 0
community integrity 0 - 0
pedestrian access 0 + +
access to public transport + + ++
public transport interchange + + ++
mental well-being 0 0 0
physical health 0 + +
health inequalities 0 0 0
road traffic accidents 0 0 0
crime and fear of crime 0 0 0
economic competitiveness ++ U ++
wider economic growth and
employment
++ U ++
employment ++ U ++
Support planned
development
- ++ ++
Regeneration + ++ ++
Sustainable consumption and production
land resources - - -
brownfield sites + + +
waste protection - + +
primary material resources - - -
Reflections on HS2 Case
• Comprehensive coverage of indicators
• Influential in changing route and route design
• Transparency in categories that win and lose
• No clear policy framework
• No sense of fit to broader sustainability goals
• Not commissioned to ask if it was worth doing
Conclusions – It is counting
• Significant increase in evidence base
• Greater transparency in decision-making
processes
• Pathways least consistent with direction of
sustainable development avoided
• Possible to deploy to make specific projects
meet more of goals (see also GreenLITES)
Conclusions – But not enough
• As yet no consistent policy position on green growth
• No evidence of limits being a strong influence on
pathways
• Compromises are fudged in +++ -- overarching
summaries
• Worrying lack of joining up across spatial scales (EU-
National, National-Local)
• Modal siloes continue to exist and limit integration
(absent in particular national strategy)
• Cross-sectoral decision-making even further removed
Sustainable transport - will it ever really count?

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Environment & life
Environment & lifeEnvironment & life
Environment & lifeAnkit Jain
 
Global Trends in Online Learning
Global Trends in Online LearningGlobal Trends in Online Learning
Global Trends in Online Learningicdeslides
 
Traffic congestion and Bottlenecks - Issues and Dimensions
Traffic congestion and Bottlenecks - Issues and DimensionsTraffic congestion and Bottlenecks - Issues and Dimensions
Traffic congestion and Bottlenecks - Issues and DimensionsEmaan Sharma
 
Solution of Traffic Jam
Solution of Traffic Jam Solution of Traffic Jam
Solution of Traffic Jam Taminul Islam
 
Transportation and our environment
Transportation and our environmentTransportation and our environment
Transportation and our environmentJesusMartinez96
 
Environmental Pollution
Environmental PollutionEnvironmental Pollution
Environmental PollutionSanketKapale1
 
Traffic congestion
Traffic congestionTraffic congestion
Traffic congestionmona_kh
 
Traffic Congestion PowerPoint Presentation
Traffic Congestion PowerPoint PresentationTraffic Congestion PowerPoint Presentation
Traffic Congestion PowerPoint PresentationRoad Safety
 
seminar on environmental issues, air pollution and controls
seminar on environmental issues, air pollution and controlsseminar on environmental issues, air pollution and controls
seminar on environmental issues, air pollution and controlsRahul Dubey
 
Environmental sustainability
Environmental sustainabilityEnvironmental sustainability
Environmental sustainabilityAnna Nepomuceno
 
How Can We Stop Global Warming?
How Can We Stop Global Warming?How Can We Stop Global Warming?
How Can We Stop Global Warming?REVA University
 
Mobility and City Streets: Importance of Public Transport by OP Agarwal
Mobility and City Streets: Importance of Public Transport by OP AgarwalMobility and City Streets: Importance of Public Transport by OP Agarwal
Mobility and City Streets: Importance of Public Transport by OP AgarwalWRI Ross Center for Sustainable Cities
 
Intelligent Transportation System
Intelligent Transportation SystemIntelligent Transportation System
Intelligent Transportation SystemGAURAV. H .TANDON
 
Powerpoint on environmental issues
Powerpoint on environmental issuesPowerpoint on environmental issues
Powerpoint on environmental issuesMonika Uppal
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Environment & life
Environment & lifeEnvironment & life
Environment & life
 
How To Save The Earth
How To Save The EarthHow To Save The Earth
How To Save The Earth
 
Global Trends in Online Learning
Global Trends in Online LearningGlobal Trends in Online Learning
Global Trends in Online Learning
 
Traffic congestion and Bottlenecks - Issues and Dimensions
Traffic congestion and Bottlenecks - Issues and DimensionsTraffic congestion and Bottlenecks - Issues and Dimensions
Traffic congestion and Bottlenecks - Issues and Dimensions
 
Solution of Traffic Jam
Solution of Traffic Jam Solution of Traffic Jam
Solution of Traffic Jam
 
Green living[1]
Green living[1]Green living[1]
Green living[1]
 
Transportation and our environment
Transportation and our environmentTransportation and our environment
Transportation and our environment
 
Environmental Pollution
Environmental PollutionEnvironmental Pollution
Environmental Pollution
 
Carbon footprint
Carbon footprintCarbon footprint
Carbon footprint
 
Traffic congestion
Traffic congestionTraffic congestion
Traffic congestion
 
Traffic Congestion PowerPoint Presentation
Traffic Congestion PowerPoint PresentationTraffic Congestion PowerPoint Presentation
Traffic Congestion PowerPoint Presentation
 
Defining Sustainable Mobility, Indicators and Targets
Defining Sustainable Mobility, Indicators and TargetsDefining Sustainable Mobility, Indicators and Targets
Defining Sustainable Mobility, Indicators and Targets
 
seminar on environmental issues, air pollution and controls
seminar on environmental issues, air pollution and controlsseminar on environmental issues, air pollution and controls
seminar on environmental issues, air pollution and controls
 
Environmental sustainability
Environmental sustainabilityEnvironmental sustainability
Environmental sustainability
 
Types of pollution
Types of pollutionTypes of pollution
Types of pollution
 
Types of Pollutions
Types of PollutionsTypes of Pollutions
Types of Pollutions
 
How Can We Stop Global Warming?
How Can We Stop Global Warming?How Can We Stop Global Warming?
How Can We Stop Global Warming?
 
Mobility and City Streets: Importance of Public Transport by OP Agarwal
Mobility and City Streets: Importance of Public Transport by OP AgarwalMobility and City Streets: Importance of Public Transport by OP Agarwal
Mobility and City Streets: Importance of Public Transport by OP Agarwal
 
Intelligent Transportation System
Intelligent Transportation SystemIntelligent Transportation System
Intelligent Transportation System
 
Powerpoint on environmental issues
Powerpoint on environmental issuesPowerpoint on environmental issues
Powerpoint on environmental issues
 

Andere mochten auch

Fuel Saving Tips
Fuel Saving TipsFuel Saving Tips
Fuel Saving TipsEason Chan
 
Sustainable Innovation Day
Sustainable Innovation DaySustainable Innovation Day
Sustainable Innovation DayPeter Bertels
 
Natural Vegetation and wildlife of india
Natural Vegetation and wildlife of indiaNatural Vegetation and wildlife of india
Natural Vegetation and wildlife of indiafatima_zaheen
 
What is the Environmental Defense Fund
What is the Environmental Defense FundWhat is the Environmental Defense Fund
What is the Environmental Defense FundPeter Getty
 
How Millennials feel About Climate Change
How Millennials feel About Climate ChangeHow Millennials feel About Climate Change
How Millennials feel About Climate ChangeMSL
 
Energy Report - Strange Brew: Adapting to Changing Fundamentals
Energy Report - Strange Brew: Adapting to Changing FundamentalsEnergy Report - Strange Brew: Adapting to Changing Fundamentals
Energy Report - Strange Brew: Adapting to Changing FundamentalsMarcellus Drilling News
 
25 Cars Worth Waiting For 2016–2019
25 Cars Worth Waiting For 2016–201925 Cars Worth Waiting For 2016–2019
25 Cars Worth Waiting For 2016–2019Eason Chan
 
Hype vs. Reality: The AI Explainer
Hype vs. Reality: The AI ExplainerHype vs. Reality: The AI Explainer
Hype vs. Reality: The AI ExplainerLuminary Labs
 
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving Cars
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving CarsStudy: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving Cars
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving CarsLinkedIn
 
Visual Design with Data
Visual Design with DataVisual Design with Data
Visual Design with DataSeth Familian
 
UX, ethnography and possibilities: for Libraries, Museums and Archives
UX, ethnography and possibilities: for Libraries, Museums and ArchivesUX, ethnography and possibilities: for Libraries, Museums and Archives
UX, ethnography and possibilities: for Libraries, Museums and ArchivesNed Potter
 
15 Common Myths you were taught to believe about Cars
15 Common Myths you were taught to believe about Cars15 Common Myths you were taught to believe about Cars
15 Common Myths you were taught to believe about CarsEason Chan
 
21 Twitter Accounts to Follow Ahead of COP21
21 Twitter Accounts to Follow Ahead of COP2121 Twitter Accounts to Follow Ahead of COP21
21 Twitter Accounts to Follow Ahead of COP21Enablon
 
UX for connected cars
UX for connected carsUX for connected cars
UX for connected carsPlan
 
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your Niche
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your NicheHow to Become a Thought Leader in Your Niche
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your NicheLeslie Samuel
 
World Energy Outlook 2015: Presentation to Press
World Energy Outlook 2015: Presentation to PressWorld Energy Outlook 2015: Presentation to Press
World Energy Outlook 2015: Presentation to PressInternational Energy Agency
 
17 Ways to Design a Presentation People Want to View
17 Ways to Design a Presentation People Want to View17 Ways to Design a Presentation People Want to View
17 Ways to Design a Presentation People Want to ViewJim MacLeod
 

Andere mochten auch (19)

Fuel Saving Tips
Fuel Saving TipsFuel Saving Tips
Fuel Saving Tips
 
Sustainable Innovation Day
Sustainable Innovation DaySustainable Innovation Day
Sustainable Innovation Day
 
Natural Vegetation and wildlife of india
Natural Vegetation and wildlife of indiaNatural Vegetation and wildlife of india
Natural Vegetation and wildlife of india
 
What is the Environmental Defense Fund
What is the Environmental Defense FundWhat is the Environmental Defense Fund
What is the Environmental Defense Fund
 
How Millennials feel About Climate Change
How Millennials feel About Climate ChangeHow Millennials feel About Climate Change
How Millennials feel About Climate Change
 
Low oil prices and the new climate economy: constraint or opportunity
Low oil prices and the new climate economy: constraint or opportunityLow oil prices and the new climate economy: constraint or opportunity
Low oil prices and the new climate economy: constraint or opportunity
 
Energy Report - Strange Brew: Adapting to Changing Fundamentals
Energy Report - Strange Brew: Adapting to Changing FundamentalsEnergy Report - Strange Brew: Adapting to Changing Fundamentals
Energy Report - Strange Brew: Adapting to Changing Fundamentals
 
25 Cars Worth Waiting For 2016–2019
25 Cars Worth Waiting For 2016–201925 Cars Worth Waiting For 2016–2019
25 Cars Worth Waiting For 2016–2019
 
Hype vs. Reality: The AI Explainer
Hype vs. Reality: The AI ExplainerHype vs. Reality: The AI Explainer
Hype vs. Reality: The AI Explainer
 
Build Features, Not Apps
Build Features, Not AppsBuild Features, Not Apps
Build Features, Not Apps
 
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving Cars
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving CarsStudy: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving Cars
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving Cars
 
Visual Design with Data
Visual Design with DataVisual Design with Data
Visual Design with Data
 
UX, ethnography and possibilities: for Libraries, Museums and Archives
UX, ethnography and possibilities: for Libraries, Museums and ArchivesUX, ethnography and possibilities: for Libraries, Museums and Archives
UX, ethnography and possibilities: for Libraries, Museums and Archives
 
15 Common Myths you were taught to believe about Cars
15 Common Myths you were taught to believe about Cars15 Common Myths you were taught to believe about Cars
15 Common Myths you were taught to believe about Cars
 
21 Twitter Accounts to Follow Ahead of COP21
21 Twitter Accounts to Follow Ahead of COP2121 Twitter Accounts to Follow Ahead of COP21
21 Twitter Accounts to Follow Ahead of COP21
 
UX for connected cars
UX for connected carsUX for connected cars
UX for connected cars
 
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your Niche
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your NicheHow to Become a Thought Leader in Your Niche
How to Become a Thought Leader in Your Niche
 
World Energy Outlook 2015: Presentation to Press
World Energy Outlook 2015: Presentation to PressWorld Energy Outlook 2015: Presentation to Press
World Energy Outlook 2015: Presentation to Press
 
17 Ways to Design a Presentation People Want to View
17 Ways to Design a Presentation People Want to View17 Ways to Design a Presentation People Want to View
17 Ways to Design a Presentation People Want to View
 

Ähnlich wie Sustainable transport - will it ever really count?

Supply chain management and the environment
Supply chain management and the environmentSupply chain management and the environment
Supply chain management and the environmentMishael Divinagracia
 
Environmental fiscal reform and the proposed carbon tax
Environmental fiscal reform and the proposed carbon tax  Environmental fiscal reform and the proposed carbon tax
Environmental fiscal reform and the proposed carbon tax Tristan Wiggill
 
22.02, Group 4 — Concept of sustainable development in built environment
22.02, Group 4 — Concept of sustainable development in built environment22.02, Group 4 — Concept of sustainable development in built environment
22.02, Group 4 — Concept of sustainable development in built environmentWDC_Ukraine
 
Cycling and urban air quality a study of european experiences
Cycling and urban air quality a study of european experiencesCycling and urban air quality a study of european experiences
Cycling and urban air quality a study of european experiencesEuropean Cyclists Federation
 
2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session
2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session
2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening SessionOECD Environment
 
Air Pollution and Climate Change Investment Bonds
Air Pollution and Climate Change Investment BondsAir Pollution and Climate Change Investment Bonds
Air Pollution and Climate Change Investment Bondseric keogh
 
Future beholds in unconventional electric vehicles
Future beholds in unconventional electric vehiclesFuture beholds in unconventional electric vehicles
Future beholds in unconventional electric vehiclesViresh Malhotra
 
REVIEW ON THE UNITED KINGDON’S TRANSPORT WHITE PAPER
REVIEW ON THE UNITED KINGDON’S TRANSPORT WHITE PAPERREVIEW ON THE UNITED KINGDON’S TRANSPORT WHITE PAPER
REVIEW ON THE UNITED KINGDON’S TRANSPORT WHITE PAPERHappiness Davies Mac Eteli
 
7.2 sustainable mobility
7.2 sustainable mobility7.2 sustainable mobility
7.2 sustainable mobilityLeNS_slide
 
2 co benefits-small-ol_mb_fin
2 co benefits-small-ol_mb_fin2 co benefits-small-ol_mb_fin
2 co benefits-small-ol_mb_finICLEI
 
1.8 Joaquin decision support tool (C.Stroobants)
1.8 Joaquin decision support tool (C.Stroobants)1.8 Joaquin decision support tool (C.Stroobants)
1.8 Joaquin decision support tool (C.Stroobants)Stevie Swenne
 
Impact of transportation system on environent
Impact of transportation system on environentImpact of transportation system on environent
Impact of transportation system on environentshrikrishna kesharwani
 
IRJET- Analytical Evaluation of Vehicular Air Pollutants at Urban Arterial Ro...
IRJET- Analytical Evaluation of Vehicular Air Pollutants at Urban Arterial Ro...IRJET- Analytical Evaluation of Vehicular Air Pollutants at Urban Arterial Ro...
IRJET- Analytical Evaluation of Vehicular Air Pollutants at Urban Arterial Ro...IRJET Journal
 

Ähnlich wie Sustainable transport - will it ever really count? (20)

Supply chain management and the environment
Supply chain management and the environmentSupply chain management and the environment
Supply chain management and the environment
 
Environmental fiscal reform and the proposed carbon tax
Environmental fiscal reform and the proposed carbon tax  Environmental fiscal reform and the proposed carbon tax
Environmental fiscal reform and the proposed carbon tax
 
9 12
9 129 12
9 12
 
22.02, Group 4 — Concept of sustainable development in built environment
22.02, Group 4 — Concept of sustainable development in built environment22.02, Group 4 — Concept of sustainable development in built environment
22.02, Group 4 — Concept of sustainable development in built environment
 
Changing Course: Building a Low Carbon Transport Sector in Asia
Changing Course:Building a Low Carbon Transport Sector in AsiaChanging Course:Building a Low Carbon Transport Sector in Asia
Changing Course: Building a Low Carbon Transport Sector in Asia
 
Measuring intelligent transport policy
Measuring intelligent transport policyMeasuring intelligent transport policy
Measuring intelligent transport policy
 
Cycling and urban air quality a study of european experiences
Cycling and urban air quality a study of european experiencesCycling and urban air quality a study of european experiences
Cycling and urban air quality a study of european experiences
 
2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session
2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session
2021 GGSD Forum : High-Level Opening Session
 
Air Pollution and Climate Change Investment Bonds
Air Pollution and Climate Change Investment BondsAir Pollution and Climate Change Investment Bonds
Air Pollution and Climate Change Investment Bonds
 
Future beholds in unconventional electric vehicles
Future beholds in unconventional electric vehiclesFuture beholds in unconventional electric vehicles
Future beholds in unconventional electric vehicles
 
REVIEW ON THE UNITED KINGDON’S TRANSPORT WHITE PAPER
REVIEW ON THE UNITED KINGDON’S TRANSPORT WHITE PAPERREVIEW ON THE UNITED KINGDON’S TRANSPORT WHITE PAPER
REVIEW ON THE UNITED KINGDON’S TRANSPORT WHITE PAPER
 
2.2. mathew ledbury
2.2. mathew ledbury2.2. mathew ledbury
2.2. mathew ledbury
 
Transport industry
Transport  industryTransport  industry
Transport industry
 
7.2 sustainable mobility
7.2 sustainable mobility7.2 sustainable mobility
7.2 sustainable mobility
 
2 co benefits-small-ol_mb_fin
2 co benefits-small-ol_mb_fin2 co benefits-small-ol_mb_fin
2 co benefits-small-ol_mb_fin
 
Charging for use of infrastructure by road freight
Charging for use of infrastructure by road freightCharging for use of infrastructure by road freight
Charging for use of infrastructure by road freight
 
1.8 Joaquin decision support tool (C.Stroobants)
1.8 Joaquin decision support tool (C.Stroobants)1.8 Joaquin decision support tool (C.Stroobants)
1.8 Joaquin decision support tool (C.Stroobants)
 
Impact of transportation system on environent
Impact of transportation system on environentImpact of transportation system on environent
Impact of transportation system on environent
 
The Future of Road Transport
The Future of Road TransportThe Future of Road Transport
The Future of Road Transport
 
IRJET- Analytical Evaluation of Vehicular Air Pollutants at Urban Arterial Ro...
IRJET- Analytical Evaluation of Vehicular Air Pollutants at Urban Arterial Ro...IRJET- Analytical Evaluation of Vehicular Air Pollutants at Urban Arterial Ro...
IRJET- Analytical Evaluation of Vehicular Air Pollutants at Urban Arterial Ro...
 

Mehr von Institute for Transport Studies (ITS)

Transport Projects Aimed at Fostering Economic Growth – experience in the UK ...
Transport Projects Aimed at Fostering Economic Growth – experience in the UK ...Transport Projects Aimed at Fostering Economic Growth – experience in the UK ...
Transport Projects Aimed at Fostering Economic Growth – experience in the UK ...Institute for Transport Studies (ITS)
 
London's Crossrail Scheme - its evolution, governance, financing and challenges
London's Crossrail Scheme  - its evolution, governance, financing and challengesLondon's Crossrail Scheme  - its evolution, governance, financing and challenges
London's Crossrail Scheme - its evolution, governance, financing and challengesInstitute for Transport Studies (ITS)
 
A clustering method based on repeated trip behaviour to identify road user cl...
A clustering method based on repeated trip behaviour to identify road user cl...A clustering method based on repeated trip behaviour to identify road user cl...
A clustering method based on repeated trip behaviour to identify road user cl...Institute for Transport Studies (ITS)
 
Social networks, activities, and travel - building links to understand behaviour
Social networks, activities, and travel - building links to understand behaviourSocial networks, activities, and travel - building links to understand behaviour
Social networks, activities, and travel - building links to understand behaviourInstitute for Transport Studies (ITS)
 
Agent based car following model for heterogeneities of platoon driving with v...
Agent based car following model for heterogeneities of platoon driving with v...Agent based car following model for heterogeneities of platoon driving with v...
Agent based car following model for heterogeneities of platoon driving with v...Institute for Transport Studies (ITS)
 

Mehr von Institute for Transport Studies (ITS) (20)

Transport Projects Aimed at Fostering Economic Growth – experience in the UK ...
Transport Projects Aimed at Fostering Economic Growth – experience in the UK ...Transport Projects Aimed at Fostering Economic Growth – experience in the UK ...
Transport Projects Aimed at Fostering Economic Growth – experience in the UK ...
 
BA Geography with Transport Studies at the University of Leeds
BA Geography with Transport Studies at the University of LeedsBA Geography with Transport Studies at the University of Leeds
BA Geography with Transport Studies at the University of Leeds
 
Highways Benchmarking - Accelerating Impact
Highways Benchmarking - Accelerating ImpactHighways Benchmarking - Accelerating Impact
Highways Benchmarking - Accelerating Impact
 
Using telematics data to research traffic related air pollution
Using telematics data to research traffic related air pollutionUsing telematics data to research traffic related air pollution
Using telematics data to research traffic related air pollution
 
Masters Dissertation Posters 2017
Masters Dissertation Posters 2017Masters Dissertation Posters 2017
Masters Dissertation Posters 2017
 
Institute for Transport Studies - Masters Open Day 2017
Institute for Transport Studies - Masters Open Day 2017Institute for Transport Studies - Masters Open Day 2017
Institute for Transport Studies - Masters Open Day 2017
 
London's Crossrail Scheme - its evolution, governance, financing and challenges
London's Crossrail Scheme  - its evolution, governance, financing and challengesLondon's Crossrail Scheme  - its evolution, governance, financing and challenges
London's Crossrail Scheme - its evolution, governance, financing and challenges
 
Secretary of State Visit
Secretary of State VisitSecretary of State Visit
Secretary of State Visit
 
Business model innovation for electrical vehicle futures
Business model innovation for electrical vehicle futuresBusiness model innovation for electrical vehicle futures
Business model innovation for electrical vehicle futures
 
A clustering method based on repeated trip behaviour to identify road user cl...
A clustering method based on repeated trip behaviour to identify road user cl...A clustering method based on repeated trip behaviour to identify road user cl...
A clustering method based on repeated trip behaviour to identify road user cl...
 
Cars cars everywhere
Cars cars everywhereCars cars everywhere
Cars cars everywhere
 
Annual Review 2015-16 - University of leeds
Annual Review 2015-16 - University of leedsAnnual Review 2015-16 - University of leeds
Annual Review 2015-16 - University of leeds
 
Social networks, activities, and travel - building links to understand behaviour
Social networks, activities, and travel - building links to understand behaviourSocial networks, activities, and travel - building links to understand behaviour
Social networks, activities, and travel - building links to understand behaviour
 
Rail freight in Japan - track access
Rail freight in Japan - track accessRail freight in Japan - track access
Rail freight in Japan - track access
 
Real time traffic management - challenges and solutions
Real time traffic management - challenges and solutionsReal time traffic management - challenges and solutions
Real time traffic management - challenges and solutions
 
Proportionally fair scheduling for traffic light networks
Proportionally fair scheduling for traffic light networksProportionally fair scheduling for traffic light networks
Proportionally fair scheduling for traffic light networks
 
Capacity maximising traffic signal control policies
Capacity maximising traffic signal control policiesCapacity maximising traffic signal control policies
Capacity maximising traffic signal control policies
 
Bayesian risk assessment of autonomous vehicles
Bayesian risk assessment of autonomous vehiclesBayesian risk assessment of autonomous vehicles
Bayesian risk assessment of autonomous vehicles
 
Agent based car following model for heterogeneities of platoon driving with v...
Agent based car following model for heterogeneities of platoon driving with v...Agent based car following model for heterogeneities of platoon driving with v...
Agent based car following model for heterogeneities of platoon driving with v...
 
A new theory of lane selection on highways
A new theory of lane selection on highwaysA new theory of lane selection on highways
A new theory of lane selection on highways
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

A closer look at wasteland and their reclamation
A closer look at wasteland and their reclamationA closer look at wasteland and their reclamation
A closer look at wasteland and their reclamationSagar Chaudhary
 
Discussing Specific Encounters for Eastern European Scientists: Involvement a...
Discussing Specific Encounters for Eastern European Scientists: Involvement a...Discussing Specific Encounters for Eastern European Scientists: Involvement a...
Discussing Specific Encounters for Eastern European Scientists: Involvement a...pensoftservices
 
Oro -dental Preparation.pdfsksjssjsjsssss
Oro -dental Preparation.pdfsksjssjsjsssssOro -dental Preparation.pdfsksjssjsjsssss
Oro -dental Preparation.pdfsksjssjsjsssssMustafaHussain83
 
Issues regarding the provision of the Convention. Introduction to the Text an...
Issues regarding the provision of the Convention. Introduction to the Text an...Issues regarding the provision of the Convention. Introduction to the Text an...
Issues regarding the provision of the Convention. Introduction to the Text an...pensoftservices
 
Biodiversity and Health. Prof. Richard Kock.
Biodiversity and Health. Prof. Richard Kock.Biodiversity and Health. Prof. Richard Kock.
Biodiversity and Health. Prof. Richard Kock.pensoftservices
 
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES AND AWARENESS - Presentation
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES AND AWARENESS - PresentationENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES AND AWARENESS - Presentation
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES AND AWARENESS - PresentationTaruna Deshwal
 
DETAILED LESSON FINAL DEMO TEACHING.docx
DETAILED LESSON FINAL DEMO TEACHING.docxDETAILED LESSON FINAL DEMO TEACHING.docx
DETAILED LESSON FINAL DEMO TEACHING.docxImilyAcma
 
Objectives and main international biodiversity events during the upcoming Hun...
Objectives and main international biodiversity events during the upcoming Hun...Objectives and main international biodiversity events during the upcoming Hun...
Objectives and main international biodiversity events during the upcoming Hun...pensoftservices
 
Green minimalist professional Business Proposal Presentation.pptx
Green minimalist professional Business Proposal Presentation.pptxGreen minimalist professional Business Proposal Presentation.pptx
Green minimalist professional Business Proposal Presentation.pptxrudkiaman0001
 
The KM-GBF monitoring framework –status & key messages. Joachim Töpper and Ha...
The KM-GBF monitoring framework –status & key messages. Joachim Töpper and Ha...The KM-GBF monitoring framework –status & key messages. Joachim Töpper and Ha...
The KM-GBF monitoring framework –status & key messages. Joachim Töpper and Ha...pensoftservices
 
Your Compost Is Not Compostable -- Tips on What Best Rots
Your Compost Is Not Compostable -- Tips on What Best RotsYour Compost Is Not Compostable -- Tips on What Best Rots
Your Compost Is Not Compostable -- Tips on What Best RotsDeidre Pike
 
CO-OP4CBD and its role in increasing Science – Policy Interface. Jorge Luis V...
CO-OP4CBD and its role in increasing Science – Policy Interface. Jorge Luis V...CO-OP4CBD and its role in increasing Science – Policy Interface. Jorge Luis V...
CO-OP4CBD and its role in increasing Science – Policy Interface. Jorge Luis V...pensoftservices
 
Tech-Session-5c-Applying-Equator-Principles.pptx
Tech-Session-5c-Applying-Equator-Principles.pptxTech-Session-5c-Applying-Equator-Principles.pptx
Tech-Session-5c-Applying-Equator-Principles.pptxJulieDash5
 
Planning and Designing Green buildings-.issues, options and strategies
Planning and Designing Green buildings-.issues, options and strategiesPlanning and Designing Green buildings-.issues, options and strategies
Planning and Designing Green buildings-.issues, options and strategiesJIT KUMAR GUPTA
 
Little Green Ranger ESG Sustainability Report
Little Green Ranger ESG Sustainability ReportLittle Green Ranger ESG Sustainability Report
Little Green Ranger ESG Sustainability ReportKennethOng48
 
Winter Springs Sediment Removal: A Major Step Forward
Winter Springs Sediment Removal: A Major Step ForwardWinter Springs Sediment Removal: A Major Step Forward
Winter Springs Sediment Removal: A Major Step ForwardVictoriaColangelo
 
Biodiversity in CEE countries CBD challenges and opportunities for implement...
Biodiversity in CEE countries CBD challenges and opportunities for implement...Biodiversity in CEE countries CBD challenges and opportunities for implement...
Biodiversity in CEE countries CBD challenges and opportunities for implement...pensoftservices
 
Synthetic biology. Fanny Coppens, Sciensano.
Synthetic biology. Fanny Coppens, Sciensano.Synthetic biology. Fanny Coppens, Sciensano.
Synthetic biology. Fanny Coppens, Sciensano.pensoftservices
 
Forest Loss in 2023: Regional Contexts and Global Trends - April 4, 2024 Webinar
Forest Loss in 2023: Regional Contexts and Global Trends - April 4, 2024 WebinarForest Loss in 2023: Regional Contexts and Global Trends - April 4, 2024 Webinar
Forest Loss in 2023: Regional Contexts and Global Trends - April 4, 2024 WebinarGlobal Forest Watch
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

A closer look at wasteland and their reclamation
A closer look at wasteland and their reclamationA closer look at wasteland and their reclamation
A closer look at wasteland and their reclamation
 
Discussing Specific Encounters for Eastern European Scientists: Involvement a...
Discussing Specific Encounters for Eastern European Scientists: Involvement a...Discussing Specific Encounters for Eastern European Scientists: Involvement a...
Discussing Specific Encounters for Eastern European Scientists: Involvement a...
 
Oro -dental Preparation.pdfsksjssjsjsssss
Oro -dental Preparation.pdfsksjssjsjsssssOro -dental Preparation.pdfsksjssjsjsssss
Oro -dental Preparation.pdfsksjssjsjsssss
 
Issues regarding the provision of the Convention. Introduction to the Text an...
Issues regarding the provision of the Convention. Introduction to the Text an...Issues regarding the provision of the Convention. Introduction to the Text an...
Issues regarding the provision of the Convention. Introduction to the Text an...
 
Biodiversity and Health. Prof. Richard Kock.
Biodiversity and Health. Prof. Richard Kock.Biodiversity and Health. Prof. Richard Kock.
Biodiversity and Health. Prof. Richard Kock.
 
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES AND AWARENESS - Presentation
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES AND AWARENESS - PresentationENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES AND AWARENESS - Presentation
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES AND AWARENESS - Presentation
 
DETAILED LESSON FINAL DEMO TEACHING.docx
DETAILED LESSON FINAL DEMO TEACHING.docxDETAILED LESSON FINAL DEMO TEACHING.docx
DETAILED LESSON FINAL DEMO TEACHING.docx
 
Objectives and main international biodiversity events during the upcoming Hun...
Objectives and main international biodiversity events during the upcoming Hun...Objectives and main international biodiversity events during the upcoming Hun...
Objectives and main international biodiversity events during the upcoming Hun...
 
Green minimalist professional Business Proposal Presentation.pptx
Green minimalist professional Business Proposal Presentation.pptxGreen minimalist professional Business Proposal Presentation.pptx
Green minimalist professional Business Proposal Presentation.pptx
 
The KM-GBF monitoring framework –status & key messages. Joachim Töpper and Ha...
The KM-GBF monitoring framework –status & key messages. Joachim Töpper and Ha...The KM-GBF monitoring framework –status & key messages. Joachim Töpper and Ha...
The KM-GBF monitoring framework –status & key messages. Joachim Töpper and Ha...
 
Your Compost Is Not Compostable -- Tips on What Best Rots
Your Compost Is Not Compostable -- Tips on What Best RotsYour Compost Is Not Compostable -- Tips on What Best Rots
Your Compost Is Not Compostable -- Tips on What Best Rots
 
CO-OP4CBD and its role in increasing Science – Policy Interface. Jorge Luis V...
CO-OP4CBD and its role in increasing Science – Policy Interface. Jorge Luis V...CO-OP4CBD and its role in increasing Science – Policy Interface. Jorge Luis V...
CO-OP4CBD and its role in increasing Science – Policy Interface. Jorge Luis V...
 
Tech-Session-5c-Applying-Equator-Principles.pptx
Tech-Session-5c-Applying-Equator-Principles.pptxTech-Session-5c-Applying-Equator-Principles.pptx
Tech-Session-5c-Applying-Equator-Principles.pptx
 
Planning and Designing Green buildings-.issues, options and strategies
Planning and Designing Green buildings-.issues, options and strategiesPlanning and Designing Green buildings-.issues, options and strategies
Planning and Designing Green buildings-.issues, options and strategies
 
Little Green Ranger ESG Sustainability Report
Little Green Ranger ESG Sustainability ReportLittle Green Ranger ESG Sustainability Report
Little Green Ranger ESG Sustainability Report
 
Winter Springs Sediment Removal: A Major Step Forward
Winter Springs Sediment Removal: A Major Step ForwardWinter Springs Sediment Removal: A Major Step Forward
Winter Springs Sediment Removal: A Major Step Forward
 
Biodiversity in CEE countries CBD challenges and opportunities for implement...
Biodiversity in CEE countries CBD challenges and opportunities for implement...Biodiversity in CEE countries CBD challenges and opportunities for implement...
Biodiversity in CEE countries CBD challenges and opportunities for implement...
 
The IFLA ENSULIB Webinar Series #11: The Walking Librarians in Kerala
The IFLA ENSULIB Webinar Series #11: The Walking Librarians in KeralaThe IFLA ENSULIB Webinar Series #11: The Walking Librarians in Kerala
The IFLA ENSULIB Webinar Series #11: The Walking Librarians in Kerala
 
Synthetic biology. Fanny Coppens, Sciensano.
Synthetic biology. Fanny Coppens, Sciensano.Synthetic biology. Fanny Coppens, Sciensano.
Synthetic biology. Fanny Coppens, Sciensano.
 
Forest Loss in 2023: Regional Contexts and Global Trends - April 4, 2024 Webinar
Forest Loss in 2023: Regional Contexts and Global Trends - April 4, 2024 WebinarForest Loss in 2023: Regional Contexts and Global Trends - April 4, 2024 Webinar
Forest Loss in 2023: Regional Contexts and Global Trends - April 4, 2024 Webinar
 

Sustainable transport - will it ever really count?

  • 1. Will it Ever Really Count? Prof Greg Marsden Institute for Transport Studies
  • 3. Sustainable Development and Sustainable Transportation National Economic System Global Market Urban System Telecommunications System Energy/Power System Water and Sewage System Transportation System Land Use Institutional Structure Infrastructure System System Users/ Stakeholders Transportation Modes Intermodal Connections Transit Network Highway Network Non-motorized Network Airway Network Source: Adapted from Meyer and Miller (2001, p. 91). Collectors LocalArterials
  • 4. Sustainable Development and Sustainable Transportation Physical Systems Production Consumption Waste Raw Materials Solar Energy Heat Recycled Materials ECOSYSTEM Other … Energy Transportation Communication Industrial Source: Adapted from Daly (1991)
  • 5. Sustainable Development and Sustainable Transportation “There can be no sustainable development without sustainable transportation. It is an essential component not only because transportation is a prerequisite to development in general but also because transportation, especially our use of motorized vehicles, contributes substantially to a wide range of environmental problems, including energy waste, global warming, degradation of air and water, noise, ecosystem loss and fragmentation, and desecration of the landscape. Our nation’s environmental quality will be sustainable only if we pursue transportation in a sustainable way” (Benfield and Replogle 2002, p. 647).
  • 6.
  • 7. Example Impacts Economic Environmental Social • Costs of transport to customers/consumers •Time loss in traffic/ Congestion • Costs relating to accidents •Transportation facility construction, maintenance and disposal costs •Transportation-related health costs •Depletion of non-renewable resources and energy supplies • Air pollution • Noise pollution • Vibration • Light pollution • Visual intrusion • Water pollution • Consumption of land/urban sprawl • Release of toxic/hazardous substances • Solid waste • Disruption of ecosystems and habitats • Hydrologic impacts • Introduction of exotic species • Depletion of the ozone layer • Global climate change • Mobility • Accessibility • Accidents • Obesity • Barriers for the disadvantaged •Inequalities associated with impacts • Community livability • Gender imbalances • Cohesion/integration • Opportunity • Anxiety/’Rootlessness’ • Migration Source: Gudmundsson and Cornet
  • 8. Sustainable Development and Sustainable Transportation • a critical component of a broader economic system which supports business and social development; • an open system, which requires natural and man-made inputs and produces outputs which impact on the environment; • part of a social system that shapes and is shaped by that social system, including other policy areas; • comprised of a series of physical sub-systems with a range of physical and operational components and which are organized through formal and informal conventions; and • fragmented series of partly connected yet partly competing sub-systems with complex and varying governance arrangements.
  • 9. Sustainable Transportation Where to make it count? POLICY LEVEL ORGANIZATIONAL LEVEL PROJECT LEVEL Source: Gudmundsson and Cornet
  • 10. European Transport White Paper Policy Level • Overarching Aim to build a competitive transport system that will increase mobility, remove major barriers in key areas and fuel growth and employment. At the same time, the proposals will dramatically reduce Europe's dependence on imported oil and cut carbon emissions in transport by 60% by 2050
  • 13. Economic Impacts Assessed Impact Areas Indicators Economic Impacts Transport Activity Passenger kilometers and tonne kilometers by all modes. Modal Shift Share of passenger or tonne kilometers by mode. Transport costs to users Unit cost per passenger or tonne transported (including capital costs, fixed operation costs and variable fuel and non-fuel costs). Economic growth Qualitative inference of policy impacts on GDP only. Efficiency of the transport system Not defined but incorporates notions of smart pricing, efficient networks, fuel efficiency and vehicle purchase costs. Congestion Average speed and use of available road capacity. Household costs The share of passenger transport costs within the household income of the average EU household. Transport related sectors Not defined but qualitative inference of the potential of the strategies to support the European vehicle manufacturing industry. Innovation and research Not defined but qualitative inference about the impact of the strategy on research spend on green innovation. Reduction of administrative burden Not defined but qualitative inference about overall levels of administration. EU budget Not defined as will be assessed on a case by case basis. International relations Not defined but qualitative inference about the potential synergies and conflicts with
  • 14. Social Impacts Assessed Impact Areas Indicators Social Impacts Degree of mobility Refers to the % change in total transport activity for passengers with an overall reduction being negative. Choice Not defined but qualitative inferences about rail investments improving choice. Accessibility Potential accessibility is a generalized cost based measure. Larger areas are more attractive and cost, time and distance are negative separation factors. Distributional Impacts Not clearly defined although the analysis refers in part to the distribution of household costs by income band. Employment level and conditions Number of jobs in the transport sector. Skills and working conditions are not defined clearly. Safety External costs of accidents and total number of accidents.
  • 15. Environmental Impacts Assessed Impact Areas Indicators Environmental Impacts Climate Change Total CO2 emissions from transport. Both transport and well to wheel analyses are presented. Air pollution Emissions of NOx and PM10 and external costs of these pollutants. Noise pollution External costs of noise pollution. Energy use/energy efficiency Total energy demand from transport Millions of Tonnes of Oil Equivalent (reviewed in detail below). Energy intensity is an efficiency indicator that uses total energy demand and transport activity to create a ratio for passenger and freight. Renewable energy use Total energy demand split by fossil fuels, biofuels and electricity. Biodiversity Not defined but qualitatively refers to fragmentation, land-take, loss of biodiversity and damage to eco-system services.
  • 16. European Transport White Paper -200 -150 -100 -50 0 50 100 150 200 CO2 intensity Energy intensity Activity level Total Urban Interurban Intercontinental -44% -40% -74% Passenger transport 33% 31% 120% -22% -19% 51% MtonCO2 0%-11% -10% Review of Do-Minimum Case Factors Influencing CO2 emissions
  • 17. European Transport White PaperPolicy Option 2 Policy Option 3 Policy Option 4 Economic Impacts Transport Activity -- = - Modal Shift ++ = + Transport costs to users --- = -- Economic growth ++ + +++ Efficiency of the transport system ++ + +++ Congestion ++ = + Household costs -- - -- Transport related sectors + +++ +++ Innovation and research + +++ ++ Reduction of administrative burden + = + EU budget = = = International relations -- - - Social Impacts Degree of mobility --- = - Choice ++ = ++ Accessibility ++ = ++ Distributional Impacts = - + Employment level and conditions ++ ++ +++ Safety ++ = + Environmental Impacts Climate Change +++ +++ +++ Air pollution +++ ++ ++ Noise pollution +++ ++ +
  • 18. European Transport White Paper • Largest Scale attempt for Sustainable Transport Assessment • Significant improvement in transparency • Informs policy package choice (coherence with longer-term goals) • Positive role as a signal
  • 19. European Transport White Paper • Modelling systems not robust • Indicators are so aggregate as to lose meaning • Social context is flattened • Does not really reach out beyond transport • Implementation is largely national – Is this joined up? • Only limited signs that constraints are to play a part • “Curbing Mobility is not an option” – Weak sustainability
  • 20. High Speed Rail • Decision taken in same way as other infrastructure projects • Bespoke Sustainability Appraisal also commissioned Phase 1 Phase 2 Rolling Stock Total Target Cost 17.16 n/a Estimated Cost 15.65 12.5 5.8 33.95 Contingency 5.75 8.7 1.7 16.15 Total 21.4 21.2 7.5 50.1 Source: Environmental Audit Committee
  • 21. Towards documents about sustainable transportation (2007, 2008) Indicators Greenhouse Gas Emissions CO2 emissions by end user (industry, transport, domestic, other) Aviation and shipping emissions Private Vehicles: CO2 emissions, car-km, and final household expenditure Road Freight: CO2 emissions, tonne-km, tonnes, and GDP Road Transport Emissions NOx, PM10, CO2 emissions, and GDP Emissions of air pollutants Air Quality and Health Ecological impacts of air pollution Mobility Getting to school Accessibility
  • 22. What is HS2 for? • Never been articulated as part of a sustainable transport strategy • 2009 SoS Transport Geoff Hoon announced creation of HS2 Limited in a statement to Parliament about expansion of Heathrow • 2 years previously, the Rail White Paper had said: • “Higher speed is not the only or best way of cutting journey times. Nor is it without cost. Increasing the maximum speed of a train from 200 km/h to 350 km/h means a 90 per cent increase in energy consumption. In exchange, it cuts station-to-station journey time by less than 25 per cent and door-to-door journey-time by even less. … The argument that high-speed rail travel is a ‘green option’ does not stand up to close inspection on the basis of the present electricity generation mix.” (DfT, 2007b, p. 62).
  • 23. What is HS2 for? • The remit of HS2 Limited was subsequently clarified to focus, in order of priority on: • Passenger capacity: “this is the driving consideration, including capacity released on classic lines”; • Speed; • Land use and development objectives and the support of new housing development; and • Developing the line to be capable of handling freight for greater network resilience. • Modal shift from air to rail was “not expected to be a key objective for HS2” (Rowlands, 2009).
  • 25. Sustainability Appraisal Key Sustainability Issue Objective Reducing greenhouse gas emissions and combating climate change Climatic factors and adaptability  Improve resilience of the rail network against extreme weather events Greenhouse Gases  Contribute to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions by facilitating modal shift from road and air to rail  Reduce relative contribution made by rail to greenhouse gas emissions by promoting energy efficient technologies Natural and cultural resource protection and environmental enhancement Landscape and townscape  Maintain and enhance existing landscape character  Maintain and enhance existing townscape character • 18 sustainability issues • 33 objectives as shown in Table • 33 objectives => 66 evaluation criteria
  • 26. Sustainability Appraisal HS2 Objectives and Option identification process Option Generation Scheme Components London Terminus Line of Route Etc. Sift 1 90+ long list options Review of Operations, Cost Demand and Engineering HS2 Board Decision Point 1 Sift 2 50+ intermediate list options Appraisal including simplified Appraisal of Sustainability HS2 Board Decision Point 2 Sift 3 Shortlist of stations and whole routes Appraisal including full Appraisal of Sustainability HS2 Board Decision Point 3 Finalising preferred scheme and main alternatives
  • 27. Likely Impact of Proposed HS2 Likely change between the current baseline and future baseline Cumulative Impacts Reducing greenhouse gas emissions and combating climate change resilience of the rail network + 0 + greenhouse gas emissions +/- + + Natural and cultural resource protection and environmental enhancement landscape character -- - -- townscape character 0 0 0 archeological assets - 0 - historic buildings - - - historic landscapes - - - biodiversity - - - surface water resources - 0 - groundwater resources - - - capacity of flood plains - - -- Creating sustainable communities local air quality U + + local noise environment -- - -- local vibration environment - 0 0 community integrity 0 - 0 pedestrian access 0 + + access to public transport + + ++ public transport interchange + + ++ mental well-being 0 0 0 physical health 0 + + health inequalities 0 0 0 road traffic accidents 0 0 0 crime and fear of crime 0 0 0 economic competitiveness ++ U ++ wider economic growth and employment ++ U ++ employment ++ U ++ Support planned development - ++ ++ Regeneration + ++ ++ Sustainable consumption and production land resources - - - brownfield sites + + + waste protection - + + primary material resources - - -
  • 28. Reflections on HS2 Case • Comprehensive coverage of indicators • Influential in changing route and route design • Transparency in categories that win and lose • No clear policy framework • No sense of fit to broader sustainability goals • Not commissioned to ask if it was worth doing
  • 29. Conclusions – It is counting • Significant increase in evidence base • Greater transparency in decision-making processes • Pathways least consistent with direction of sustainable development avoided • Possible to deploy to make specific projects meet more of goals (see also GreenLITES)
  • 30. Conclusions – But not enough • As yet no consistent policy position on green growth • No evidence of limits being a strong influence on pathways • Compromises are fudged in +++ -- overarching summaries • Worrying lack of joining up across spatial scales (EU- National, National-Local) • Modal siloes continue to exist and limit integration (absent in particular national strategy) • Cross-sectoral decision-making even further removed