Challenges and issuesof distance education Pakistan
1. CHALLENGES AND ISSUES OF
DISTANCE EDUCATION IN PAKISTAN
By Hina Jalal , Roll # 303,
, PhD, Education
Department of Education, GCUF. 2015
2. “Distance education is a field of
education that focuses on teaching
methods and technology with the
aim of delivering teaching, often on
an individual basis, to students who
are not physically present in a
traditional setting such as a
classroom” (Awe, 2003).
3. One of the biggest issue in education is that there is low
rate of participation of Pakistani adults in tertiary
education than the other countries. The obvious reasons
are:
Financial Constraints
Insufficient number of academic institutions
Inadequate Institutes for employees
Differences between personal schedule and education
4. The University’s distance education program offers
following merits:
Reaches wider students community.
Provides opportunity for obtaining higher education at
cost affordable by common man.
Helps student’s complete studies without suffering
emotionally or financially due to relocation.
Possibility of seeking help of appearing in examinations
while out of town.
Enables students to earn while they learn.
5. Need for support staff for training and technical
assistance
Adequate assessment of distance education classes
Adequate student services for DE students
Operating and equipment budgets
Faculty acceptance and
Organizational acceptance
6. Pakistan, being a third world country faces additional
challenges for matching Distance Education standards
with the traditional universities. these challenges can be
categorized as:
1. Administrative related challenges
2. Faculty related challenges
3. Student related challenges
7. 1. ADMINISTRATIVE RELATED CHALLENGES
High quality course content
Availability of technology
Delivering quality with most difficult classes
Online admission and examination system
Specification of educational objective
Suitable fee
Online class and course registration
Online library and text book sales
Adequate assessment of distance education classes
8. 2. FACULTY RELATED CHALLENGES
Training on subject and technologies
Workload problems
Compensation issues
Help desk and technical support for faculty
synchronous and asynchronous learning
9. 3. STUDENTS RELATED CHALLENGES
Online counselling and advising services
Campus testing centre for students
Assessment of student learning and performance
Orientation and preparation
Online application system
Online tutoring services
Student completion rate
Reducing cheating/ unfair means
10. Sufficient resources and
infrastructure
Sufficient infrastructures
like physical and digital
library
Competent and
experienced senior faculty
Particular system of quality
assurance
Complete detail about all
programs
Students’ Financial
Support
The assessment strategies
and validity
Provide self study material
Motivate the learners
Improve the interaction
Higher Education Commission provided a thematic guideline
to the Directors of Distance Education , like
11. Lack of technology adoption
Societal recognition
Funding
Quality assurance of academic programs
Management issues
Instructional delivery method
Relevance of education
While the advance countries are tackling issues,
we in Pakistan still face some issues to implement the
provided lines in Distance Education system. Such as
12. Cheap computer facilities and network infrastructures
must be integrated with appropriate software systems in
Pakistan.
An advanced methodology is needed to help the
instructors or administers to minimize hesitation to
adopt technology during distance education.
In our country adaptation of advancement technology is
very costly for common man.
13. It must be realized that Distance education is
an innovation that is going to be accepted
with caution by a society
Fear that mechanization of education could
bring down the standard
14. The issue of funding continues to dominate discussions
on challenges facing in Pakistan.
Sufficient fund must be provided by the institution
running the program to make it result oriented.
Distance education institutions can be categorized
under specialized institutions that are given special
attention in view of their capital intensive nature
15. The propensity of the distance education system to
malpractices in homework assignments, tests and
examinations.
There should not be any room for complacency as the
level of examination malpractice involving staff and
students was still intolerably high
16. It becomes imperative for the management of distance
education institutions in PAKISTAN to adopt
management strategies that will ensure sustainable
development of distance education.
Most of pioneer staff of distance education institutions
in Pakistan are drawn from the formal system of
education.
17. There is a great difference between distance learning
and traditional type in which students listen to
lecturers, read their textbooks and are busy with
memorizing and recalling selected topics.
Distance learning, since students do not have unlimited
access to lecturers as in formal tertiary institutions,
instructional materials must be packaged to facilitate
self-study and easy comprehension by the learners
without much assistance from their facilitators.
18. The content of education more meaningful and the
methods of delivery more cost-effective within the
context of nation building and economic development.
The lack of social demand for education is related to
the fact that families and communities do not value or
are ambivalent about formal education. It is pointed to
the Parental disillusionment with the present education
systems and expressed support for More relevant
curricula
Awe Bolupe, (2003), The Challenges Of Distance Education In Nigeria, PhD, Distance Learning Department, National Open University of Nigeria, 14/16 Ahmadu Bello Way, Victoria Island, Lagos
So, the Distance education is much more flexible and student centred in approach. By allowing students to learn in more convenient locations, and often at more convenient times, distance education opens educational opportunity to previously un-reached learners. It also enables students to extend the period of their education from a limited number of schooling years to a lifelong learning process.
A recent survey conducted by ITC (Instructional Technology Conference) for distance education survey report, revealed these most basic challenges in distance ducation around the world.
Distance Education surveys results, 2010
Whereas, in an international perspective, rapid growth of distance education industry has identified further challenges;
Qureshi, Shah, & Zaka, (2014), divided these challenges faced by distance education institutes in Pakistan into three categories.
Source: Qureshi, M. F, Shah S. M. A & Zaka, B. (2014). Towards providing better Distance Education: A roadmap for universities, Journal
of Strategy and Performance Management, 2(2), 67-78.
Development of high quality course content.
Availability of technology for course management including Audio/Video streaming, website, web portal, blogs and LMS, to delivering live class sessions
Delivering quality with most difficult classes, which include Lab-based sciences, Fine arts, Math, Industrial technology and Computer hardware etc.
Online admission system
Specification of educational objective and future prospects of each degree program
Suitable fee structure to attract more students
Online class and course registration
Online library and text book sales
Adequate assessment of Distance Education classes
FACULTY RELATED CHALLENGES
Training on subject and technologies used for Distance education
Workload problems
Compensation issues
Help desk and technical support for faculty
Hiring of suitable faculty for both synchronous and asynchronous learning. Synchronous learning, method needs more dedicated staff.
STUDENTS RELATED CHALLENGES
Online counselling and advising services
Assessment of student learning and performance
Campus testing centre for students
Orientation and preparation for taking Distance education classes
Online application system for scholarships/financial aid
Online tutoring services
Student completion rate
Reducing Cheating/ unfair means for completing course works and assessments
HEC, 2015 , GUIDELINE ON QUALITY OF DISTANCE EDUCATION FOR EXTERNAL STUDENTS AT THE HEI’S OF PAKISTAN,
All is well is our education system is very repetitive phrase, but t he prevailing situation in the our educational system seems to indicate that all is not well.
, it is not without problems.
It’s not all about to have degree, diploma and tagging yourself with qualification but to face challenges globalised, however, It must be realized that distance education is an innovation that is going to be accepted with caution by a society that has some reservations about the formal university system. But still the quality assurance reports showed the fear that mechanism of distance education with large numbers of students could bring down the standards of education.
Policy makers in Pakistan have been preoccupied in seeking ways of making the content of education more meaningful and the methods of delivery more cost-effective within the
context of nation building and economic development rather than the need and suitable production of high quality graduation in every field of life. It is pointed to the parental disillusionment with the present education systems and expressed support for
more relevant curricula and other activities.