SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 20
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
The British retail energy
market: politicians and re-
regulation?
Professor Michael Harker
ESRC Centre for Competition Policy and UEA Law School
University of East Anglia
m.harker@uea.ac.uk
Privatisation, regulation and
liberalisation
• National gas market
incumbent
• 14 regional electricity
markets
• RPI-X price-caps for
electricity and gas
incumbents only
• Main entrants other
incumbents
• Gradual deregulation
from 2000 to 2002, all
caps removed April 2002
• Significant industry
consolidation – foreign
entry through acquisition
of incumbent firms,
vertical integration
Deregulation of retail energy: timeline
Market share of new entrants – gas
Market share of new entrants - electricity
Full national domestic
competition
New regulator OFGEM
Competition Act into
force
DD Price
controls
withdrawn
All price
controls
withdrawn
Source: graph from Ofgem (2007)
SSE-Atlantic
merger
Powergen
(E.ON) – TXU
merger
Trends in prices: retail
Index of real domestic energy prices (Q1 1987=100)
Source: quarterly fuel prices, DECC
Pricecontrolslifted
Market structure: the ‘Big 6’
Present Incumbent areas (entrant elsewhere)
E.On Eastern, East Midlands, North West
EDF London, Seeboard
SSE Scottish Hydro, Southern, SWEB
npower Midlands, Northern, Yorkshire
Scottish
Power
Manweb, Midlands, Northern
British
Gas
National Gas incumbent (electricity entrant)
National market shares (2010)
Source: Ofgem (2011)
HHI:
5,897
Incumbent market share – electricity (2010)
Ofcom (2011)
‘Sticky’ consumers
• Sticky consumer – remained with the incumbent,
switched to a dual-fuel deal offered by incumbent,
or switched back to incumbent
Ofcom (2008, 2011)
Savings foregone
• Significant savings could be made if consumers
switched tariffs (both payment and suppliers)
Switch from Dual fuel Electricity
only
Gas only
Direct debit £160-196 £27-86 £5-36
Standard
credit
£236-323 £59-117 £25-82
Prepayment £237-239 £66-109 £42-66
Average savings over 2010 per customer if moved to the
supplier with lowest direct debit tariff
Why are some consumers not
switching?
• Behavioural reasons – status quo bias (Ofcom,
2008)
• Consumers who do switch may choose a more
expensive tariff (Waddams and Wilson)
• Tariff complexity and ‘confusopoly’
• Substantial growth in tariffs: Ofgem c.900 tariffs
(August 2012); DECC estimates 650 ‘dead’ tariffs;
Which claims to have found people on 1,440 tariffs
(March 2013)
Who are the ‘sticky’ consumers
• [Graph from ….
Profile of customers who have never switched, weighted against the British population
Source: Ofcom / MORI (2008); Ofcom (2011)
Re-regulating to tackle
‘unfair’ pricing and tariff
complexity
The non-discrimination clause
(NDC)
• NDC introduced in 2008 to prevent firms from cross-
subsidising their offers as entrants (electricity
incumbents out-of-area, British Gas in electricity) from
their installed/static consumer base as incumbents
• Firms consistently charging an incumbent mark-up of
10% from the time price controls were lifted
• Primary justification was fairness – a concern that
vulnerable consumers were less likely to have switched
• Harm to competition in the form of a barrier to entry –
new entrants did not have an installed consumer base
to subsidise “teaser rates”
The consequences of the non-
discrimination clause
Demand side
• Falling consumer
engagement
• Less incentives to
search and switch
• Switching rates halved
between 2008 and
2013
Supply side
• Softening of
competition – firms
retreat to their
incumbent markets /
less aggressive in out-
of-area markets
(Waddams and Zhu,
2013)
• New entry increased
(higher margins)
The PM’s intervention
• Prime Minister’s Questions (17 October 2012):
• Chris Williamson (Derby North) (Lab): At the Prime Minister’s
energy summit last year, he promised faithfully that he would
take action to help people reduce their energy bills. Will he
tell the House and the country: how is it going?
• The Prime Minister: We have encouraged people to switch,
which is one of the best ways to get energy bills down. I can
announce, which I am sure the hon. Gentleman will welcome,
that we will be legislating so that energy companies have to
give the lowest tariff to their customers—something that
Labour did not do in 13 years, even though the Leader of the
Labour party could have done it because he had the job.
Ofgem’s ‘fairness agenda’
• A result of Ofgem’s review of the market 2008-
2011:
• Limit to four the number of tariffs offered by
supplier (per payment type) (Dec 13)
• Suppliers tell customers when there is a cheaper
live tariff (March 14)
• Consumers on ‘dead’ tariffs will be switched to a
cheaper variable deal (Oct 13 / June 2015)
Legislation: Ministerial back-stop
powers
• Energy Act 2013, s.139: enable the Minister to prescribe
types, and limit numbers, of tariffs; and specify certain types
of consumers to be moved from one tariff to anther
• Sun-set clause (Dec 18);
• Amendments made to the Bill (in Committee stage)
• “The provision will give the Secretary of State the power to
make it compulsory for suppliers to move those who could
save money on to the cheapest, live standard variable-rate
tariffs. This is the meat of what the Prime Minister was
pledging to do. Customers would have the ability to opt out
of the process, if they wish, while the remainder would save
money without having to lift a finger.”
Conclusions
• Lifting of price controls – regulation appeared to be
successful in the context of falling / stable prices
• Sharp price increases result in increased attention
from politicians
• Many of the ‘problems’ with the retail energy
market have resulted from consumer inertia
• Real distributional concerns because those who
have not switched (paying the highest prices) are
the least well-off
Competing policy goals
• For competition to work you need ‘winners and
losers’
• ‘Reward’ those who search and switch
• NDC has resulted in less switching and higher prices
for all consumers
• Enforced switching by suppliers will reduce
incentives to switch
‘Thin end of the wedge’
• Labour party commitments on energy if it wins the
next election
• “Price freeze” – 20 months following from May
2015
• Restructuring the industry: “breaking-up the Big 6”
• “Ofgem has failed” – should be replaced with a
body with “real teeth”

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

EU Energy Law as a barrier to Trade and Investment: A view from the Court
EU Energy Law as a barrier to Trade and Investment: A view from the CourtEU Energy Law as a barrier to Trade and Investment: A view from the Court
EU Energy Law as a barrier to Trade and Investment: A view from the CourtFlorence Shool of Regulation
 
Demand Response: Informed and Empowered Consumers versus Consumer Protection
Demand Response: Informed and Empowered Consumers versus Consumer ProtectionDemand Response: Informed and Empowered Consumers versus Consumer Protection
Demand Response: Informed and Empowered Consumers versus Consumer ProtectionFlorence Shool of Regulation
 
What is wrong with Energy Community law enforcement?
What is wrong with Energy Community law enforcement?What is wrong with Energy Community law enforcement?
What is wrong with Energy Community law enforcement?Florence Shool of Regulation
 
Current arbitration cases under the Energy Charter Treaty
Current arbitration cases under the Energy Charter TreatyCurrent arbitration cases under the Energy Charter Treaty
Current arbitration cases under the Energy Charter TreatyFlorence Shool of Regulation
 
2016 IndustRE Workshop - 1 business models and policy recommendations
2016 IndustRE Workshop - 1 business models and policy recommendations2016 IndustRE Workshop - 1 business models and policy recommendations
2016 IndustRE Workshop - 1 business models and policy recommendationsLeonardo ENERGY
 
Anna Colucci Fingrid Current 5.4.2017
Anna Colucci Fingrid Current 5.4.2017 Anna Colucci Fingrid Current 5.4.2017
Anna Colucci Fingrid Current 5.4.2017 Fingrid Oyj
 
2016 IndustRE Workshop - 2 Model Contracts
2016 IndustRE Workshop - 2 Model Contracts2016 IndustRE Workshop - 2 Model Contracts
2016 IndustRE Workshop - 2 Model ContractsLeonardo ENERGY
 
Mc cannfitzgerald greenexpo
Mc cannfitzgerald greenexpoMc cannfitzgerald greenexpo
Mc cannfitzgerald greenexpoDamian Connon
 
Electrification in the energy transition: towards net-zero emissions by 2050
Electrification in the energy transition: towards net-zero emissions by 2050Electrification in the energy transition: towards net-zero emissions by 2050
Electrification in the energy transition: towards net-zero emissions by 2050Leonardo ENERGY
 
Riku Huttunen Fingrid Current 5.4.2017
Riku Huttunen Fingrid Current 5.4.2017 Riku Huttunen Fingrid Current 5.4.2017
Riku Huttunen Fingrid Current 5.4.2017 Fingrid Oyj
 
Fingrid Current: Lotta Medelius-Bredhe, Director General, Svenska kraftnät
Fingrid Current: Lotta Medelius-Bredhe, Director General, Svenska kraftnät Fingrid Current: Lotta Medelius-Bredhe, Director General, Svenska kraftnät
Fingrid Current: Lotta Medelius-Bredhe, Director General, Svenska kraftnät Fingrid Oyj
 
The european energy policy the role of ENTSO-E and of TSOs
The european energy policy the role of ENTSO-E and of TSOsThe european energy policy the role of ENTSO-E and of TSOs
The european energy policy the role of ENTSO-E and of TSOsENTSO-E
 
Experience from the EU ETS - Peter Vis, European University Institute
Experience from the EU ETS - Peter Vis, European University InstituteExperience from the EU ETS - Peter Vis, European University Institute
Experience from the EU ETS - Peter Vis, European University InstituteOECD Environment
 
Electric vehicles - DecarbEurope
Electric vehicles - DecarbEuropeElectric vehicles - DecarbEurope
Electric vehicles - DecarbEuropeLeonardo ENERGY
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Security of Gas Supply in the Energy Community
Security of Gas Supply in the Energy CommunitySecurity of Gas Supply in the Energy Community
Security of Gas Supply in the Energy Community
 
EU Energy Law as a barrier to Trade and Investment: A view from the Court
EU Energy Law as a barrier to Trade and Investment: A view from the CourtEU Energy Law as a barrier to Trade and Investment: A view from the Court
EU Energy Law as a barrier to Trade and Investment: A view from the Court
 
Demand Response: Informed and Empowered Consumers versus Consumer Protection
Demand Response: Informed and Empowered Consumers versus Consumer ProtectionDemand Response: Informed and Empowered Consumers versus Consumer Protection
Demand Response: Informed and Empowered Consumers versus Consumer Protection
 
RES auctions in Poland: a new opening?
RES auctions in Poland: a new opening?RES auctions in Poland: a new opening?
RES auctions in Poland: a new opening?
 
Towards a Pan-European Security of Supply Regime
Towards a Pan-European Security of Supply RegimeTowards a Pan-European Security of Supply Regime
Towards a Pan-European Security of Supply Regime
 
What is wrong with Energy Community law enforcement?
What is wrong with Energy Community law enforcement?What is wrong with Energy Community law enforcement?
What is wrong with Energy Community law enforcement?
 
Current arbitration cases under the Energy Charter Treaty
Current arbitration cases under the Energy Charter TreatyCurrent arbitration cases under the Energy Charter Treaty
Current arbitration cases under the Energy Charter Treaty
 
2016 IndustRE Workshop - 1 business models and policy recommendations
2016 IndustRE Workshop - 1 business models and policy recommendations2016 IndustRE Workshop - 1 business models and policy recommendations
2016 IndustRE Workshop - 1 business models and policy recommendations
 
Anna Colucci Fingrid Current 5.4.2017
Anna Colucci Fingrid Current 5.4.2017 Anna Colucci Fingrid Current 5.4.2017
Anna Colucci Fingrid Current 5.4.2017
 
2016 IndustRE Workshop - 2 Model Contracts
2016 IndustRE Workshop - 2 Model Contracts2016 IndustRE Workshop - 2 Model Contracts
2016 IndustRE Workshop - 2 Model Contracts
 
Mc cannfitzgerald greenexpo
Mc cannfitzgerald greenexpoMc cannfitzgerald greenexpo
Mc cannfitzgerald greenexpo
 
Electrification in the energy transition: towards net-zero emissions by 2050
Electrification in the energy transition: towards net-zero emissions by 2050Electrification in the energy transition: towards net-zero emissions by 2050
Electrification in the energy transition: towards net-zero emissions by 2050
 
Riku Huttunen Fingrid Current 5.4.2017
Riku Huttunen Fingrid Current 5.4.2017 Riku Huttunen Fingrid Current 5.4.2017
Riku Huttunen Fingrid Current 5.4.2017
 
Fingrid Current: Lotta Medelius-Bredhe, Director General, Svenska kraftnät
Fingrid Current: Lotta Medelius-Bredhe, Director General, Svenska kraftnät Fingrid Current: Lotta Medelius-Bredhe, Director General, Svenska kraftnät
Fingrid Current: Lotta Medelius-Bredhe, Director General, Svenska kraftnät
 
The european energy policy the role of ENTSO-E and of TSOs
The european energy policy the role of ENTSO-E and of TSOsThe european energy policy the role of ENTSO-E and of TSOs
The european energy policy the role of ENTSO-E and of TSOs
 
Transformers
TransformersTransformers
Transformers
 
TSO Certification: Specific Issues
TSO Certification: Specific Issues TSO Certification: Specific Issues
TSO Certification: Specific Issues
 
Experience from the EU ETS - Peter Vis, European University Institute
Experience from the EU ETS - Peter Vis, European University InstituteExperience from the EU ETS - Peter Vis, European University Institute
Experience from the EU ETS - Peter Vis, European University Institute
 
Electric vehicles - DecarbEurope
Electric vehicles - DecarbEuropeElectric vehicles - DecarbEurope
Electric vehicles - DecarbEurope
 
Vattenfall
VattenfallVattenfall
Vattenfall
 

Andere mochten auch

Application of Article 11 of the Gas Directive: TSOs controlled by companies ...
Application of Article 11 of the Gas Directive: TSOs controlled by companies ...Application of Article 11 of the Gas Directive: TSOs controlled by companies ...
Application of Article 11 of the Gas Directive: TSOs controlled by companies ...Florence Shool of Regulation
 
Enforcing Energy Law Beyond the European Union: the EEA example
Enforcing Energy Law Beyond the European Union: the EEA exampleEnforcing Energy Law Beyond the European Union: the EEA example
Enforcing Energy Law Beyond the European Union: the EEA exampleFlorence Shool of Regulation
 
Legal challenges in the Infrastructure Package: A Perspective from Administra...
Legal challenges in the Infrastructure Package: A Perspective from Administra...Legal challenges in the Infrastructure Package: A Perspective from Administra...
Legal challenges in the Infrastructure Package: A Perspective from Administra...Florence Shool of Regulation
 
Harmonised rules and network codes: The division of competences between Europ...
Harmonised rules and network codes: The division of competences between Europ...Harmonised rules and network codes: The division of competences between Europ...
Harmonised rules and network codes: The division of competences between Europ...Florence Shool of Regulation
 
The transparency of Gas Flows and Security of Supply
The transparency of Gas Flows and Security of SupplyThe transparency of Gas Flows and Security of Supply
The transparency of Gas Flows and Security of SupplyFlorence Shool of Regulation
 
The EU State aid law hot spot in the Energy sector from a German perspective
The EU State aid law hot spot in the Energy sector from a German perspectiveThe EU State aid law hot spot in the Energy sector from a German perspective
The EU State aid law hot spot in the Energy sector from a German perspectiveFlorence Shool of Regulation
 
Security and Contracts: Energy Policy and Resource Policy
Security and Contracts: Energy Policy and Resource PolicySecurity and Contracts: Energy Policy and Resource Policy
Security and Contracts: Energy Policy and Resource PolicyFlorence Shool of Regulation
 
Roundtable on Security of Supply and the Internal Energy Market; EU, EnC and ...
Roundtable on Security of Supply and the Internal Energy Market; EU, EnC and ...Roundtable on Security of Supply and the Internal Energy Market; EU, EnC and ...
Roundtable on Security of Supply and the Internal Energy Market; EU, EnC and ...Florence Shool of Regulation
 
How far can Member States go to derogate from Third Package obligations and m...
How far can Member States go to derogate from Third Package obligations and m...How far can Member States go to derogate from Third Package obligations and m...
How far can Member States go to derogate from Third Package obligations and m...Florence Shool of Regulation
 
The impact of unbundling: Who can invest in what in the future?
The impact of unbundling: Who can invest in what in the future?The impact of unbundling: Who can invest in what in the future?
The impact of unbundling: Who can invest in what in the future?Florence Shool of Regulation
 

Andere mochten auch (14)

Application of Article 11 of the Gas Directive: TSOs controlled by companies ...
Application of Article 11 of the Gas Directive: TSOs controlled by companies ...Application of Article 11 of the Gas Directive: TSOs controlled by companies ...
Application of Article 11 of the Gas Directive: TSOs controlled by companies ...
 
Recent Developments in Energy Arbitration
Recent Developments in Energy ArbitrationRecent Developments in Energy Arbitration
Recent Developments in Energy Arbitration
 
Unbundling: Status and Consequences
Unbundling: Status and ConsequencesUnbundling: Status and Consequences
Unbundling: Status and Consequences
 
Litigating with Sovereigns in the Energy Sector
Litigating with Sovereigns in the Energy Sector Litigating with Sovereigns in the Energy Sector
Litigating with Sovereigns in the Energy Sector
 
Enforcing Energy Law Beyond the European Union: the EEA example
Enforcing Energy Law Beyond the European Union: the EEA exampleEnforcing Energy Law Beyond the European Union: the EEA example
Enforcing Energy Law Beyond the European Union: the EEA example
 
Legal challenges in the Infrastructure Package: A Perspective from Administra...
Legal challenges in the Infrastructure Package: A Perspective from Administra...Legal challenges in the Infrastructure Package: A Perspective from Administra...
Legal challenges in the Infrastructure Package: A Perspective from Administra...
 
The Impact of Unbundling
The Impact of Unbundling The Impact of Unbundling
The Impact of Unbundling
 
Harmonised rules and network codes: The division of competences between Europ...
Harmonised rules and network codes: The division of competences between Europ...Harmonised rules and network codes: The division of competences between Europ...
Harmonised rules and network codes: The division of competences between Europ...
 
The transparency of Gas Flows and Security of Supply
The transparency of Gas Flows and Security of SupplyThe transparency of Gas Flows and Security of Supply
The transparency of Gas Flows and Security of Supply
 
The EU State aid law hot spot in the Energy sector from a German perspective
The EU State aid law hot spot in the Energy sector from a German perspectiveThe EU State aid law hot spot in the Energy sector from a German perspective
The EU State aid law hot spot in the Energy sector from a German perspective
 
Security and Contracts: Energy Policy and Resource Policy
Security and Contracts: Energy Policy and Resource PolicySecurity and Contracts: Energy Policy and Resource Policy
Security and Contracts: Energy Policy and Resource Policy
 
Roundtable on Security of Supply and the Internal Energy Market; EU, EnC and ...
Roundtable on Security of Supply and the Internal Energy Market; EU, EnC and ...Roundtable on Security of Supply and the Internal Energy Market; EU, EnC and ...
Roundtable on Security of Supply and the Internal Energy Market; EU, EnC and ...
 
How far can Member States go to derogate from Third Package obligations and m...
How far can Member States go to derogate from Third Package obligations and m...How far can Member States go to derogate from Third Package obligations and m...
How far can Member States go to derogate from Third Package obligations and m...
 
The impact of unbundling: Who can invest in what in the future?
The impact of unbundling: Who can invest in what in the future?The impact of unbundling: Who can invest in what in the future?
The impact of unbundling: Who can invest in what in the future?
 

Ähnlich wie The British retail energy market: politicians and re-regulation?

Tim Stone. 28th January
Tim Stone. 28th JanuaryTim Stone. 28th January
Tim Stone. 28th JanuaryUKTI2014
 
Switch energy customer presentation
Switch energy customer presentationSwitch energy customer presentation
Switch energy customer presentationSwitch Energy
 
Regulating Electricity Market
Regulating Electricity MarketRegulating Electricity Market
Regulating Electricity MarketJustinas Pagirys
 
The UK’s Energy Transition is Here: How Can Energy Innovation Futureproof you...
The UK’s Energy Transition is Here: How Can Energy Innovation Futureproof you...The UK’s Energy Transition is Here: How Can Energy Innovation Futureproof you...
The UK’s Energy Transition is Here: How Can Energy Innovation Futureproof you...EMEX
 
Rpcon s105 the carbon tax impact on the retail industry - peter ramsay.ppt
Rpcon s105   the carbon tax impact on the retail industry - peter ramsay.pptRpcon s105   the carbon tax impact on the retail industry - peter ramsay.ppt
Rpcon s105 the carbon tax impact on the retail industry - peter ramsay.pptpcmrevents
 
Executive summary Utilities opportunity and betterment
Executive summary Utilities opportunity and bettermentExecutive summary Utilities opportunity and betterment
Executive summary Utilities opportunity and bettermentSagar Zilpe
 
Deregulation of electricity-background
Deregulation of electricity-backgroundDeregulation of electricity-background
Deregulation of electricity-backgroundPulakesh k kalita
 
Electricity Reforms - An_Overview
Electricity Reforms - An_OverviewElectricity Reforms - An_Overview
Electricity Reforms - An_OverviewNzar Mohammad
 
Japan's Ofgem Action Points from Cambridge
Japan's Ofgem Action Points from CambridgeJapan's Ofgem Action Points from Cambridge
Japan's Ofgem Action Points from CambridgeYohei Kiguchi
 
Brazil and Argentina - Ontario (Ca) S
Brazil and Argentina - Ontario (Ca) SBrazil and Argentina - Ontario (Ca) S
Brazil and Argentina - Ontario (Ca) Slmaurer
 
electricity-markets-basil-sharp.ppt
electricity-markets-basil-sharp.pptelectricity-markets-basil-sharp.ppt
electricity-markets-basil-sharp.pptArslanAbbas36
 
Mcc tariff models dr harish ahuja
Mcc tariff models dr harish ahujaMcc tariff models dr harish ahuja
Mcc tariff models dr harish ahujamcci175
 
New Deal for Smart, Participative Energy
New Deal for Smart, Participative EnergyNew Deal for Smart, Participative Energy
New Deal for Smart, Participative EnergyCrowdsourcing Week
 
BRIDGE POWER CONSULTING
BRIDGE POWER CONSULTINGBRIDGE POWER CONSULTING
BRIDGE POWER CONSULTINGGrafic.guru
 
Amerex energy services intro pp
Amerex energy services intro ppAmerex energy services intro pp
Amerex energy services intro ppSteven Willett
 

Ähnlich wie The British retail energy market: politicians and re-regulation? (20)

Tim Stone. 28th January
Tim Stone. 28th JanuaryTim Stone. 28th January
Tim Stone. 28th January
 
Energy Masterclass: Consumer council
Energy Masterclass: Consumer councilEnergy Masterclass: Consumer council
Energy Masterclass: Consumer council
 
Radical Innovation in the Electricity Sector – Netherlands - June 2017 OECD d...
Radical Innovation in the Electricity Sector – Netherlands - June 2017 OECD d...Radical Innovation in the Electricity Sector – Netherlands - June 2017 OECD d...
Radical Innovation in the Electricity Sector – Netherlands - June 2017 OECD d...
 
Switch energy customer presentation
Switch energy customer presentationSwitch energy customer presentation
Switch energy customer presentation
 
Regulating Electricity Market
Regulating Electricity MarketRegulating Electricity Market
Regulating Electricity Market
 
The UK’s Energy Transition is Here: How Can Energy Innovation Futureproof you...
The UK’s Energy Transition is Here: How Can Energy Innovation Futureproof you...The UK’s Energy Transition is Here: How Can Energy Innovation Futureproof you...
The UK’s Energy Transition is Here: How Can Energy Innovation Futureproof you...
 
Rpcon s105 the carbon tax impact on the retail industry - peter ramsay.ppt
Rpcon s105   the carbon tax impact on the retail industry - peter ramsay.pptRpcon s105   the carbon tax impact on the retail industry - peter ramsay.ppt
Rpcon s105 the carbon tax impact on the retail industry - peter ramsay.ppt
 
Executive summary Utilities opportunity and betterment
Executive summary Utilities opportunity and bettermentExecutive summary Utilities opportunity and betterment
Executive summary Utilities opportunity and betterment
 
Deregulation of electricity-background
Deregulation of electricity-backgroundDeregulation of electricity-background
Deregulation of electricity-background
 
Radical Innovation in the Electricity Sector – New Zealand Electricity Author...
Radical Innovation in the Electricity Sector – New Zealand Electricity Author...Radical Innovation in the Electricity Sector – New Zealand Electricity Author...
Radical Innovation in the Electricity Sector – New Zealand Electricity Author...
 
UK: A Market-led Response to Energy Efficiency
UK: A Market-led Response to Energy Efficiency UK: A Market-led Response to Energy Efficiency
UK: A Market-led Response to Energy Efficiency
 
Electricity Reforms - An_Overview
Electricity Reforms - An_OverviewElectricity Reforms - An_Overview
Electricity Reforms - An_Overview
 
Japan's Ofgem Action Points from Cambridge
Japan's Ofgem Action Points from CambridgeJapan's Ofgem Action Points from Cambridge
Japan's Ofgem Action Points from Cambridge
 
Brazil and Argentina - Ontario (Ca) S
Brazil and Argentina - Ontario (Ca) SBrazil and Argentina - Ontario (Ca) S
Brazil and Argentina - Ontario (Ca) S
 
electricity-markets-basil-sharp.ppt
electricity-markets-basil-sharp.pptelectricity-markets-basil-sharp.ppt
electricity-markets-basil-sharp.ppt
 
Mcc tariff models dr harish ahuja
Mcc tariff models dr harish ahujaMcc tariff models dr harish ahuja
Mcc tariff models dr harish ahuja
 
New Deal for Smart, Participative Energy
New Deal for Smart, Participative EnergyNew Deal for Smart, Participative Energy
New Deal for Smart, Participative Energy
 
Radical Innovation in the Electricity Sector - Darryl Biggar - Australia - Ju...
Radical Innovation in the Electricity Sector - Darryl Biggar - Australia - Ju...Radical Innovation in the Electricity Sector - Darryl Biggar - Australia - Ju...
Radical Innovation in the Electricity Sector - Darryl Biggar - Australia - Ju...
 
BRIDGE POWER CONSULTING
BRIDGE POWER CONSULTINGBRIDGE POWER CONSULTING
BRIDGE POWER CONSULTING
 
Amerex energy services intro pp
Amerex energy services intro ppAmerex energy services intro pp
Amerex energy services intro pp
 

Mehr von Florence Shool of Regulation

Drawing lessons from the unwieldy reforms of EU-ETS: Combining price and quan...
Drawing lessons from the unwieldy reforms of EU-ETS: Combining price and quan...Drawing lessons from the unwieldy reforms of EU-ETS: Combining price and quan...
Drawing lessons from the unwieldy reforms of EU-ETS: Combining price and quan...Florence Shool of Regulation
 
The Emerging Governance for the Energy Union: A new role for the Agency
The Emerging Governance for the Energy Union: A new role for the AgencyThe Emerging Governance for the Energy Union: A new role for the Agency
The Emerging Governance for the Energy Union: A new role for the AgencyFlorence Shool of Regulation
 
Renewable Energy Policy: What comes after Feed-in Tariffs?
Renewable Energy Policy: What comes after Feed-in Tariffs?Renewable Energy Policy: What comes after Feed-in Tariffs?
Renewable Energy Policy: What comes after Feed-in Tariffs?Florence Shool of Regulation
 
State aid enforcement in the energy sector in South Eastern Europe
State aid enforcement in the energy sector in South Eastern EuropeState aid enforcement in the energy sector in South Eastern Europe
State aid enforcement in the energy sector in South Eastern EuropeFlorence Shool of Regulation
 
The experience with market liberalisation in the CEE region
The experience with market liberalisation in the CEE regionThe experience with market liberalisation in the CEE region
The experience with market liberalisation in the CEE regionFlorence Shool of Regulation
 
Energy Dispute Resolution: Is Arbitration Outdated?
Energy Dispute Resolution: Is Arbitration Outdated?Energy Dispute Resolution: Is Arbitration Outdated?
Energy Dispute Resolution: Is Arbitration Outdated?Florence Shool of Regulation
 
Legal challenges in establishing organised electricity markets and market cou...
Legal challenges in establishing organised electricity markets and market cou...Legal challenges in establishing organised electricity markets and market cou...
Legal challenges in establishing organised electricity markets and market cou...Florence Shool of Regulation
 

Mehr von Florence Shool of Regulation (16)

Drawing lessons from the unwieldy reforms of EU-ETS: Combining price and quan...
Drawing lessons from the unwieldy reforms of EU-ETS: Combining price and quan...Drawing lessons from the unwieldy reforms of EU-ETS: Combining price and quan...
Drawing lessons from the unwieldy reforms of EU-ETS: Combining price and quan...
 
Training at the florence school of regulation
Training at the florence school of regulationTraining at the florence school of regulation
Training at the florence school of regulation
 
Distribution Unbundling
Distribution UnbundlingDistribution Unbundling
Distribution Unbundling
 
How to design LNG contracts
How to design LNG contracts How to design LNG contracts
How to design LNG contracts
 
The Emerging Governance for the Energy Union: A new role for the Agency
The Emerging Governance for the Energy Union: A new role for the AgencyThe Emerging Governance for the Energy Union: A new role for the Agency
The Emerging Governance for the Energy Union: A new role for the Agency
 
Russia Ukraine Energy Disputes
Russia Ukraine Energy Disputes Russia Ukraine Energy Disputes
Russia Ukraine Energy Disputes
 
A new role for the Agency
A new role for the AgencyA new role for the Agency
A new role for the Agency
 
Renewable Energy Policy: What comes after Feed-in Tariffs?
Renewable Energy Policy: What comes after Feed-in Tariffs?Renewable Energy Policy: What comes after Feed-in Tariffs?
Renewable Energy Policy: What comes after Feed-in Tariffs?
 
An electricity market design at last?
An electricity market design at last?An electricity market design at last?
An electricity market design at last?
 
State aid enforcement in the energy sector in South Eastern Europe
State aid enforcement in the energy sector in South Eastern EuropeState aid enforcement in the energy sector in South Eastern Europe
State aid enforcement in the energy sector in South Eastern Europe
 
The experience with market liberalisation in the CEE region
The experience with market liberalisation in the CEE regionThe experience with market liberalisation in the CEE region
The experience with market liberalisation in the CEE region
 
Pipelines: Between economics, law and diplomacy
Pipelines: Between economics, law and diplomacyPipelines: Between economics, law and diplomacy
Pipelines: Between economics, law and diplomacy
 
Transmission Unbundling
Transmission Unbundling Transmission Unbundling
Transmission Unbundling
 
Energy Dispute Resolution: Is Arbitration Outdated?
Energy Dispute Resolution: Is Arbitration Outdated?Energy Dispute Resolution: Is Arbitration Outdated?
Energy Dispute Resolution: Is Arbitration Outdated?
 
Designing Network Codes
Designing Network CodesDesigning Network Codes
Designing Network Codes
 
Legal challenges in establishing organised electricity markets and market cou...
Legal challenges in establishing organised electricity markets and market cou...Legal challenges in establishing organised electricity markets and market cou...
Legal challenges in establishing organised electricity markets and market cou...
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

The Ultimate Guide to Drafting Your Separation Agreement with a Template
The Ultimate Guide to Drafting Your Separation Agreement with a TemplateThe Ultimate Guide to Drafting Your Separation Agreement with a Template
The Ultimate Guide to Drafting Your Separation Agreement with a TemplateBTL Law P.C.
 
Classification of Contracts in Business Regulations
Classification of Contracts in Business RegulationsClassification of Contracts in Business Regulations
Classification of Contracts in Business RegulationsSyedaAyeshaTabassum1
 
Law-on-Partnership-and-Corporation business org
Law-on-Partnership-and-Corporation business orgLaw-on-Partnership-and-Corporation business org
Law-on-Partnership-and-Corporation business orgAnonymousUKTzN2ggtG
 
Women and the World of Climate Change- A Conceptual Foundation by Shraddha Pa...
Women and the World of Climate Change- A Conceptual Foundation by Shraddha Pa...Women and the World of Climate Change- A Conceptual Foundation by Shraddha Pa...
Women and the World of Climate Change- A Conceptual Foundation by Shraddha Pa...SHRADDHA PANDIT
 
An introduction to Indian Contract Act, 1872 by Shraddha Pandit
An introduction to Indian Contract Act, 1872 by Shraddha PanditAn introduction to Indian Contract Act, 1872 by Shraddha Pandit
An introduction to Indian Contract Act, 1872 by Shraddha PanditSHRADDHA PANDIT
 
Embed-7.pdfp;kpokipppedoioediouedooedijed
Embed-7.pdfp;kpokipppedoioediouedooedijedEmbed-7.pdfp;kpokipppedoioediouedooedijed
Embed-7.pdfp;kpokipppedoioediouedooedijedbhavenpr
 
ArtificiaI Intelligence based Cyber Forensic Tools: Relevancy and Admissibili...
ArtificiaI Intelligence based Cyber Forensic Tools: Relevancy and Admissibili...ArtificiaI Intelligence based Cyber Forensic Tools: Relevancy and Admissibili...
ArtificiaI Intelligence based Cyber Forensic Tools: Relevancy and Admissibili...Anadi Tewari
 
Islamabad High Court Judges wrote a letter to Supreme Judicial Council.pdf
Islamabad High Court Judges wrote a letter to Supreme Judicial Council.pdfIslamabad High Court Judges wrote a letter to Supreme Judicial Council.pdf
Islamabad High Court Judges wrote a letter to Supreme Judicial Council.pdfNo One
 
Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chai...
Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chai...Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chai...
Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chai...Dr. Oliver Massmann
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (9)

The Ultimate Guide to Drafting Your Separation Agreement with a Template
The Ultimate Guide to Drafting Your Separation Agreement with a TemplateThe Ultimate Guide to Drafting Your Separation Agreement with a Template
The Ultimate Guide to Drafting Your Separation Agreement with a Template
 
Classification of Contracts in Business Regulations
Classification of Contracts in Business RegulationsClassification of Contracts in Business Regulations
Classification of Contracts in Business Regulations
 
Law-on-Partnership-and-Corporation business org
Law-on-Partnership-and-Corporation business orgLaw-on-Partnership-and-Corporation business org
Law-on-Partnership-and-Corporation business org
 
Women and the World of Climate Change- A Conceptual Foundation by Shraddha Pa...
Women and the World of Climate Change- A Conceptual Foundation by Shraddha Pa...Women and the World of Climate Change- A Conceptual Foundation by Shraddha Pa...
Women and the World of Climate Change- A Conceptual Foundation by Shraddha Pa...
 
An introduction to Indian Contract Act, 1872 by Shraddha Pandit
An introduction to Indian Contract Act, 1872 by Shraddha PanditAn introduction to Indian Contract Act, 1872 by Shraddha Pandit
An introduction to Indian Contract Act, 1872 by Shraddha Pandit
 
Embed-7.pdfp;kpokipppedoioediouedooedijed
Embed-7.pdfp;kpokipppedoioediouedooedijedEmbed-7.pdfp;kpokipppedoioediouedooedijed
Embed-7.pdfp;kpokipppedoioediouedooedijed
 
ArtificiaI Intelligence based Cyber Forensic Tools: Relevancy and Admissibili...
ArtificiaI Intelligence based Cyber Forensic Tools: Relevancy and Admissibili...ArtificiaI Intelligence based Cyber Forensic Tools: Relevancy and Admissibili...
ArtificiaI Intelligence based Cyber Forensic Tools: Relevancy and Admissibili...
 
Islamabad High Court Judges wrote a letter to Supreme Judicial Council.pdf
Islamabad High Court Judges wrote a letter to Supreme Judicial Council.pdfIslamabad High Court Judges wrote a letter to Supreme Judicial Council.pdf
Islamabad High Court Judges wrote a letter to Supreme Judicial Council.pdf
 
Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chai...
Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chai...Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chai...
Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chai...
 

The British retail energy market: politicians and re-regulation?

  • 1. The British retail energy market: politicians and re- regulation? Professor Michael Harker ESRC Centre for Competition Policy and UEA Law School University of East Anglia m.harker@uea.ac.uk
  • 2. Privatisation, regulation and liberalisation • National gas market incumbent • 14 regional electricity markets • RPI-X price-caps for electricity and gas incumbents only • Main entrants other incumbents • Gradual deregulation from 2000 to 2002, all caps removed April 2002 • Significant industry consolidation – foreign entry through acquisition of incumbent firms, vertical integration
  • 3. Deregulation of retail energy: timeline Market share of new entrants – gas Market share of new entrants - electricity Full national domestic competition New regulator OFGEM Competition Act into force DD Price controls withdrawn All price controls withdrawn Source: graph from Ofgem (2007) SSE-Atlantic merger Powergen (E.ON) – TXU merger
  • 4. Trends in prices: retail Index of real domestic energy prices (Q1 1987=100) Source: quarterly fuel prices, DECC Pricecontrolslifted
  • 5. Market structure: the ‘Big 6’ Present Incumbent areas (entrant elsewhere) E.On Eastern, East Midlands, North West EDF London, Seeboard SSE Scottish Hydro, Southern, SWEB npower Midlands, Northern, Yorkshire Scottish Power Manweb, Midlands, Northern British Gas National Gas incumbent (electricity entrant)
  • 6. National market shares (2010) Source: Ofgem (2011) HHI: 5,897
  • 7. Incumbent market share – electricity (2010) Ofcom (2011)
  • 8. ‘Sticky’ consumers • Sticky consumer – remained with the incumbent, switched to a dual-fuel deal offered by incumbent, or switched back to incumbent Ofcom (2008, 2011)
  • 9. Savings foregone • Significant savings could be made if consumers switched tariffs (both payment and suppliers) Switch from Dual fuel Electricity only Gas only Direct debit £160-196 £27-86 £5-36 Standard credit £236-323 £59-117 £25-82 Prepayment £237-239 £66-109 £42-66 Average savings over 2010 per customer if moved to the supplier with lowest direct debit tariff
  • 10. Why are some consumers not switching? • Behavioural reasons – status quo bias (Ofcom, 2008) • Consumers who do switch may choose a more expensive tariff (Waddams and Wilson) • Tariff complexity and ‘confusopoly’ • Substantial growth in tariffs: Ofgem c.900 tariffs (August 2012); DECC estimates 650 ‘dead’ tariffs; Which claims to have found people on 1,440 tariffs (March 2013)
  • 11. Who are the ‘sticky’ consumers • [Graph from …. Profile of customers who have never switched, weighted against the British population Source: Ofcom / MORI (2008); Ofcom (2011)
  • 12. Re-regulating to tackle ‘unfair’ pricing and tariff complexity
  • 13. The non-discrimination clause (NDC) • NDC introduced in 2008 to prevent firms from cross- subsidising their offers as entrants (electricity incumbents out-of-area, British Gas in electricity) from their installed/static consumer base as incumbents • Firms consistently charging an incumbent mark-up of 10% from the time price controls were lifted • Primary justification was fairness – a concern that vulnerable consumers were less likely to have switched • Harm to competition in the form of a barrier to entry – new entrants did not have an installed consumer base to subsidise “teaser rates”
  • 14. The consequences of the non- discrimination clause Demand side • Falling consumer engagement • Less incentives to search and switch • Switching rates halved between 2008 and 2013 Supply side • Softening of competition – firms retreat to their incumbent markets / less aggressive in out- of-area markets (Waddams and Zhu, 2013) • New entry increased (higher margins)
  • 15. The PM’s intervention • Prime Minister’s Questions (17 October 2012): • Chris Williamson (Derby North) (Lab): At the Prime Minister’s energy summit last year, he promised faithfully that he would take action to help people reduce their energy bills. Will he tell the House and the country: how is it going? • The Prime Minister: We have encouraged people to switch, which is one of the best ways to get energy bills down. I can announce, which I am sure the hon. Gentleman will welcome, that we will be legislating so that energy companies have to give the lowest tariff to their customers—something that Labour did not do in 13 years, even though the Leader of the Labour party could have done it because he had the job.
  • 16. Ofgem’s ‘fairness agenda’ • A result of Ofgem’s review of the market 2008- 2011: • Limit to four the number of tariffs offered by supplier (per payment type) (Dec 13) • Suppliers tell customers when there is a cheaper live tariff (March 14) • Consumers on ‘dead’ tariffs will be switched to a cheaper variable deal (Oct 13 / June 2015)
  • 17. Legislation: Ministerial back-stop powers • Energy Act 2013, s.139: enable the Minister to prescribe types, and limit numbers, of tariffs; and specify certain types of consumers to be moved from one tariff to anther • Sun-set clause (Dec 18); • Amendments made to the Bill (in Committee stage) • “The provision will give the Secretary of State the power to make it compulsory for suppliers to move those who could save money on to the cheapest, live standard variable-rate tariffs. This is the meat of what the Prime Minister was pledging to do. Customers would have the ability to opt out of the process, if they wish, while the remainder would save money without having to lift a finger.”
  • 18. Conclusions • Lifting of price controls – regulation appeared to be successful in the context of falling / stable prices • Sharp price increases result in increased attention from politicians • Many of the ‘problems’ with the retail energy market have resulted from consumer inertia • Real distributional concerns because those who have not switched (paying the highest prices) are the least well-off
  • 19. Competing policy goals • For competition to work you need ‘winners and losers’ • ‘Reward’ those who search and switch • NDC has resulted in less switching and higher prices for all consumers • Enforced switching by suppliers will reduce incentives to switch
  • 20. ‘Thin end of the wedge’ • Labour party commitments on energy if it wins the next election • “Price freeze” – 20 months following from May 2015 • Restructuring the industry: “breaking-up the Big 6” • “Ofgem has failed” – should be replaced with a body with “real teeth”