More Related Content Similar to China EU in Africa Similar to China EU in Africa (20) China EU in Africa1. DEPARTMENT OF EU INTERNATIONAL
RELATIONS AND DIPLOMACY STUDIES
InBev-Baillet Latour Chair of
European Union-China Relations
Issue 4, 2011
EU-China Observer
2. !"#$%&'(&)'*+%*+,&
&
-. !/0&0123/456&7086!495:/4;&6774<45=&6!&6&>9!!80503?³6&899?&6!&!/0&
95=945=&50=9!46!495&9@&!/0&;36&&
A/65=&BC"'&.......................................................................................................&D&
&
D. @99E&:6@0!F&45&!/0&0179;065&15495&65E&3/456G&&!/0&H086H450&36:0&
;9H:&7'$"*IJ&;04&KC"'("*LJ&:;43/!45=07&E"*C%$&..........................................&M&
&
N. !/0&01&;984&<5(63216(72+,1$·65(6285(',3/20$,1$)5,$
:!6/86**?+OPC*....................................................................................-Q
!+,$-.,/011$2% 3/24#5% 67/05% 48% 9:.670+/% ;$1/204+'% 6411$$% 48% 9#54=$'%
$=/52?$+2%48%9:%!+2$5+/204+/1%;$1/204+%/+@%0=14?/AB%C2#@0$'%0D-$5%**'%
,9.E)))%,5#$'%F/G%HI(.J).KK(J)'%LLLMA41$#54=$M$#%
%
9@02450/1%N4/5@O%
P548$45%Q0+%R$+O% %D0+M?$+SA41$#54=$M$#'%T$1M%HI(.J).KK(JE%
U0+4%,5#+L0DAVO% 0+4MN5#+L0DAVSA41$#54=$M$#'%T$1M%HI(.J).KK(JK%
F5/+A$A/%F$+24+O% 85/+A$A/M8$+24+SA41$#54=$M$#'%T$1M%HI(.J).KK(E%
%
W0$L% $G=5$$@% 0+% 27$% !#$%'()*+,-./-.% /5$% 274$% 48% 27$%/#2745% 4+1B%
/+@%@4%+42%+$A$/501B%5$81$A2%=40204+%48%$027$5%27$%$@0245%45%27$%6411$$%
48%9#54=$M%
!#$%'%()**% *%
3. 7+((8¶632/,RESPONSE 72+,1$¶6
RESOURCE DIPLOMACY IN AFRICA
Z++/%c/27/50+/%C2/71
%
%%
T7$%4.FDOOHG´PLQHUDOVUXOLQJµ*%0#$@%NB%27$%k451@%T5/@$%g5/+0/204+%]kTg^%
4+%Q#1B%J'%()**%//0+2%27$%P$4=1$%;$=#N10A%48%670+/%]670+/^%7/%/225/A2$@%
L0@$% /22$+204+M% !+% 02% 5$=452'% 27$% kTg% =/+$1% A4+A1#@$@% 27/2% 670+$$%
/#2745020$%N54V$%0+2$5+/204+/1%5#1$%NB%5$25/0+0+%27$%$G=452%48%/%+#?N$5%48%
A4-$2$@% 5/L%?/2$50/1M(%Z% 27$% 4#2A4?$% 48% /% @0=#2$% $221$?$+2% A/$% 801$@%
24$27$5%NB%27$%:+02$@%C2/2$%]:C^'%27$%9#54=$/+%:+04+%]9:^%/+@%R$G0A4'%270%
5#10+% 0% A4+0@$5$@% /% /% 1/+@?/5V'% 0+% =/520A#1/5% 5$/5@0+% 27$% 670+$$%
@$A004+%24%5$250A2%02%$G=452%48%5/5$%$/527%$1$?$+2MI%C#A7%/%D#@$?$+2%+$$@%
24% N$% =#2% 0+% 27$% A4+2$G2% 48% 54L0+% 0+2$5+/204+/1% A4+A$5+% 4-$5% /% =40N1$%
7452/$%48%5/5$%$/527%?$2/1'%48%L70A7%670+/%0%27$%1/5$2%#==10$5M%%
9#54=$/+% =410AB?/V$5% L$1A4?$% 27$% 5$A$+2% kTg% -$5@0A2M J %T5/@$%
RPPLVVLRQHU .DUHO 'H *XFKW SRLQWV RXW WKDW WKH :72 MXGJPHQW ´VHQGV D
254+%0+/1%24%5$85/0+%854?%0?=40+%#+8/05%5$250A204+%24%25/@$%/+@%2/V$%#%
4+$%2$=%A14$5%24%/%1$-$1%=1/B0+%ILHOGIRUUDZPDWHULDOVµd%T70%@$?4+25/2$%
27/2% 27$% 9:% $$% 27$% kTg% 5#10+% /% /% #$8#1% 2441% 24% 2/AV1$% A#55$+2% 14N/1%
A7/11$+$% =/5V$@% NB% 27$% #+=5$A$@$+2$@% @$?/+@% 48% 5/L%?/2$50/1% 854?%
$?$50+%A4#+250$%10V$%670+/M%%
C0+A$%27$%2#5+%48%27$%(*2%A$+2#5B'%670+/%7/%5$/A7$@%/%+$L%2/$%48%02%
$A4+4?0A% @$-$14=?$+2M% l$2% 0+% 27$% ?$/+20?$'% 02% 0% 0+A5$/0+1B% 5$10/+2% 4+%
+/2#5/1% 5$4#5A$% 24% #2/0+% 02% ?4@$5+0/204+M% Z% /% L/B% 24% 2/AV1$% 27$%
?4#+20+% @$=$+@$+AB% 4+% +/2#5/1% 5$4#5A$'% 27$% 670+$$% 4-$5+?$+2% 7/%
2/52$@% 24% A5$/2$% -/504#% =410AB% 0+25#?$+2'% N427% /2% @4?$20A% /+@%
%Z++/%c/27/50+/%C2/71%0%/%5/@#/2$%0+%9:%!+2$5+/204+/1%;$1/204+%/+@%0=14?/AB%C2#@0$%854?%
27$%6411$$%48%9#54=$'%,5#$M%Z%/%P7%5$$/5A7$5%/2%27$%!+202#2$%845%9#54=$/+%C2#@0$%]!9C^%48%
27$%W50D$%:+0-$502$02%,5#$1%]W:,^'%7$%0%L5020+%/%@0$52/204+%4+%27$%250/+#1/5%9:'%670+/%/+@%
Z850A/%5$1/204+M%C7$%0%/14%/%5$$/5A7%/4A0/2$%/2%27$%,5#$1%!+202#2$%48%64+2$?=45/5B%670+/%
C2#@0$%],!66C^M%
*%F45$0+%/+@%64??4+L$/127%g880A$%]F6g^%/+@%:c%T5/@$%s%!+-$2?$+2%]:cT!^'%$%'(ba:*P)
G'-.(,)7'9'%,$0D0+'%Q#1B%()**M%
(%k451@%T5/@$%g5/+0/204+'%E('-).-=1.2).-9(.;'9%$%'()³)G-(,7.-,)-(2-;)21)2%-)
!M=1.2(21')15)c(.17,)(C)G(2-.(,'%kTeCI_e;'%kTeCI_Je;'%kTeCI_EeI'%U$+$-/O%J%Q#1B%
()**'%722=OeeLLLML24M45e$+107e+$Lf$e+$L**f$eI_fI_JfI_E5f$M72?%%
I%9#54=$/+%64??004+'%(C)G(2-.(,)E1?AU)ZVVR)8''7()-=1.2'%,5#$1'%())_'%
722=Oee25/@$M$AM$#54=/M$#e@4A10Ne@4Ae()*)eD#+$e25/@4Af*d()KM=@8%%
%DQJKXQ-LQJ´KLQD·VUDUHHDUWKLQGXVWUDUHJROGHQWLPHVFRPLQJµLQ6LPRQ(YHQHWW
]$@M^'%-,1/-)@(2-.,)8,)J1+()E.1,=-?2,)a1.,-'P):%-)R2%)J:8)-=1.2'%34+@4+O%6$+25$%845%
9A4+4?0A%P410AB%;$$/5A7'%()*'%==M%J*.d)M%
J%9#54=$/+%64??004+')3UHVVUHOHDVH(8ZHOFRPHV:72UHSRUWRQKLQD·VH[SRUWUHVWULFWLRQV
1').(C)4(2-.(,'%,5#$1'%J%Q#1B%()**'%
722=Oee25/@$M$AM$#54=/M$#e@4A10Ne=5$e0+@$GMA8?h0@rK(I%
d%´KLQDEURNHWUDGHODZRQPHWDOVVDV:72µDD$)6-C,'%J%Q#1B%()**'%
722=OeeLLLMNNAMA4M#Ve+$LeN#0+$.*)I)dd%%
!#$%'%()**% *d%
4. 0+2$5+/204+/1%1$-$1MK%k701$%27$%$G=452%5$250A204+%4+%5/L%?/2$50/1%7/-$%N$$+%
=/52%48%27$%@4?$20A%5$=4+$'%670+/%7/%/14%$+/$@%0+%/%14N/1%25/2$B%
48%@0-$508B0+%02%0?=452%48%+/2#5/1%5$4#5A$M%T70%7/%N$$+%25/+1/2$@%0+24%/%
=410AB% 48% 54L0+% $+/$?$+2% 0+% Z850A/'% /% A4+20+$+2% L027% 254+% 702450A/1%
/+@%A#12#5/1%10+V%L027%9#54=$M%!+%4+1B%/%7452%=$504@%48%20?$'%670+/%7/%2/V$+%
RYHUWKH86DV$IULFD·VVHFRQGODUJHVWWUDGHSDUWQHUDIWHUWKH(8E%%
Z/0+2% 270% N/AV54#+@'% 270% /520A1$% $G/?0+$% 27$% 670+$$% 5$4#5A$%
@0=14?/AB% 0+% Z850A/% /+@% 02% 0?=/A2% 4+% 427$5% ?/D45% A4+#?$5% 48% 5/L%
?/2$50/1M%,427%845%670+/%/+@%27$%9:'%27$%/AA$%24%+4+.$+$5B%5/L%?/2$50/1%
0% /%A5#A0/1%/=$A2% 48%27$05% 5$4#5A$%=410A0$'%/% 27$B%/5$%0+@0=$+0N1$% 0+% 27$%
A4+25#A204+% 48% 0+85/25#A2#5$%/+@%27$% =54@#A204+% 48% 0+@#25B%/+@%A4+#?$5%
=54@#A2M% T7$% 4-$5/11% /5#?$+2% =#2% 845L/5@% 0+% 270% /520A1$% L011% @$?4+25/2$%
27/2% 27$% 670+$$% $/5A7% 845% Z850A/+% +/2#5/1% 5$4#5A$% @4$% +42% +$A$/501B%
0?=1B% /% 02#/204+% 48% 50-/15B% L027% 27$% 9:'% N#2% 4+% 27$% A4+25/5B'% /% ?45$%
A44=$5/20-$% /==54/A7% A4#1@% N$% 0+% 27$% 0+2$5$2% 48% /11% /A245% 0+-41-$@M% T7$%
/520A1$% 0% 25#A2#5$@% /% 84114LO% 8052'% 02% =54-0@$% /+% 4-$5-0$L% 48% 27$% A#55$+2%
670+$$% 5$4#5A$% @0=14?/AB% 0+% Z850A/'% 27$+'% 02% $G/?0+$% 27$% +/A$+2%
(XURSHDQ UDZ PDWHULDO VWUDWHJ DV D UHVSRQVH WR KLQD·V ULVH )LQDOO LW
A4+A1#@$% NB% =40+20+% 4#2% 5$A$+2% @$-$14=?$+2'% L70A7% A4#1@% $-$+2#/11B%
1$/@%24%C0+4.9#54=$/+%A44=$5/204+%4-$5%Z850A/+%A4??4@020$M%
KLQD·VTXHVWIRUQDWXUDOUHVRXUFHVLQ$IULFD
50-$+% NB% =5/?/20A% 5$845?% 0+020/2$@% #+@$5% $+% m0/4=0+% 0+% 27$% *_K)'%
670+/%7/%$2%02%A4#5$%24%0+@#250/10/204+M%F/A$@%L027%/%8/@0+%0@$414B'%27$%
1$020?/AB% 48% 27$% 5#10+% 670+$$% 64??#+02% P/52B% ]66P^% 0% 24@/B% 1/5$1B%
N/$@%4+%27$%/N0102B%24%$+#5$%/%A4+20+#/204+%48%27$%$G25/45@0+/5B%$A4+4?0A%
54L27M% T7$%66P% 0% 27$5$NB% A4+854+2$@%L027% 27$% A7/11$+$% 48% $A#50+% 27$%
#==1B% 48% +/2#5/1% 5$4#5A$'% L70A7% /5$% 0+@0=$+/N1$% 845% 27$% 8#527$5%
?4@$5+0/204+% 48% 27$%A4#+25BM%R/0-$% #5N/+0/204+'% 0+%=/520A#1/5'%7/%?$/+2%
27/2%27$%@$?/+@%845%?$2/1%845%27$%A4+25#A204+%0+@#25B%7/%#5$@%4-$5%27$%
=/2% 8$L% B$/5'%?/V0+% 670+/% 4+$% 48% 27$% 1$/@0+% A4+#?$5% 48% 2$$1% /+@%
A4==$5%0+%27$%L451@M%ZAA45@0+%24%845$A/2'%27$%A#55$+2%670+$$%@$?/+@%845%
A4??4@020$% 0% 10V$1B% 24% 54L% $G=4+$+20/11B% 0+% 27$% 84527A4?0+% @$A/@$M_%!+%
270%A4+2$G2'%27$%670+$$%4-$5+?$+2%0#$@%0+%())I%/%k702$%P/=$5%4+%R0+$5/1%
;$4#5A$M%67/=2$5%84#5%48%27$%=410AB%@4A#?$+2%845$$$%27$%$G=145/204+%/+@%
H[SORLWDWLRQ RI PLQHUDO UHVRXUFHV RXWVLGH RI KLQD XQGHUOLQLQJ WKDW ´27$%
670+$$% 4-$5+?$+2% $+A4#5/$% @4?$20A% $+2$5=50$% 24% 2/V$% =/52% 0+%
0+2$5+/204+/1% A44=$5/204+% 0+% 27$% =7$5$% 48% ?0+$5/1% 5$4#5A$'% /+@% 0+%
H[SORUDWLRQH[SORLWDWLRQDQGXWLOL]DWLRQRIIRUHLJQPLQHUDOUHVRXUFHVµ*)%%
K%!/N$11$%;/?@44'%´6KRSSLQJIRUUDZPDWHULDOV.%C74#1@%Z850A/%N$%L4550$@%/N4#2%9:%;/L%
0DWHULDOV,QLWLDWLYHµ-?;=4)L,?7,,1')E(=-.'%+4M%*)J'%R//250A72'%F$N5#/5B%()**'%=M%*8M%
E%:+02$@%[/204+%64+8$5$+A$%4+%T5/@$%/+@%$-$14=?$+2%]:[6TZ^'%!?1'14?)L-/-1=4-'2)
')85.?()-=1.2)ZVQV)²)3172%#3172%)$11=-.(21'P)85.?()(';)2%-)6-C)@1.4,)15)L-/-1=4-'2)
E(.2'-.,%='%[$L%l45V'%U$+$-/O%:+02$@%[/204+'%()*)'%=M%I)M%
_%T/?/5/%T50+7%HWDO´KLQD
VFRPPRGLWKXQJHU,PSOLFDWLRQVIRU$IULFDDQG/DWLQ$PHULFDµ
L-72,?%-)D('F)$7..-'2)N,,7-,'%670+/%C=$A0/1'%F5/+V8#52%/?%R/0+'%*I%Q#+$%())dM%
*)%!+845?/204+%g880A$%48%27$%C2/2$%64#+A01'%$%'(d,)E1?A)1')G'-.()-,17.?-,'%,$0D0+'%
$A$?N$5%())IM%
!#$%'%()**% *K%
5. !+% 27$% 85/?$L45V% 48% 27$%$-41-0+%670+$$% 5$4#5A$% @0=14?/AB'%Z850A/%
7/%N$$+%0@$+2080$@%/%/%V$B%5$04+M%,/$@%4+%27$%())d%Z850A/+%k702$%P/=$5%
/+@% 27$% F45#?% 845% 670+/.Z850A/% 644=$5/204+% ]Fg6Z6^'% 27$% 670+$$%
4-$5+?$+2%7/%$2%#=%-/504#%?$A7/+0?%24%#==452%670+$$%C2/2$.gL+$@%
9+2$5=50$% ]Cg9^% 0+% 27$% $G=145/204+'% $G=1402/204+% /+@% #2010/204+% 48% Z850A/+%
+/2#5/1%5$4#5A$M%64+A$04+/1%14/+%=54-0@$@%2754#7%KLQD·VRIILFLDOH[SRUW
A5$@02%/$+AB'%27$%670+$$%9G=452%/+@%!?=452%,/+V%]9G0?%,/+V^'%7/-$%=54-$+%
24%N$%4+$%48%27$%?42%$880A0$+2%2441%24%$+A4#5/$%27$%$G=/+04+%48%670+$$%
Cg9% 24% Z850A/M**%T70% 2/2$% =/254+/$% 4-$5% 805?% /114L% ,$0D0+% 24% 488$5% 4.
FDOOHG ´SDFNDJH GHDOVµ RI DLG LQIUDVWUXFWXUH SURMHFWV WHFKQLFDO DQG
4?$20?$% ?0102/5B% $a#0=?$+2% 24% Z850A/+% A4#+250$'% 0+% 5$2#5+% 845% +/2#5/1%
5$4#5A$M% Y$+A$'% 27$% N4#+@/50$% N$2L$$+% 670+$$% /0@% /+@% $A4+4?0A%
0+2$5$2%/5$%482$+%N1#55$@M%%
F#527$5?45$'% 7/-0+% 0@$+2080$@% 0+85/25#A2#5$% /% /+% $$+20/1%
=5$5$a#002$%845%27$%$G25/A204+%/+@%25/+=452/204+%48%Z850A/+%?0+$5/1%5$4#5A$'%
27$% 670+$$% 9G0?% ,/+V% 0% +4L% /14% 7$/-01B% 0+-41-$@% 0+% 80+/+A0+% 670+$$%
=54D$A2% 0+% 270% $A245M% g+% 27$% 4+$% 7/+@'% 670+/% A4+250N#2$% 24% 80110+% 27$%
0+85/25#A2#5$%/=% 0+%Z850A/'%L70A7% 0% 0+%?/+B%A/$% /%?/D45% 0?=$@0?$+2% 845%
@$-$14=?$+2M%g+%27$%427$5%7/+@'%,$0D0+%8/A$%54L0+%A5020A0?%48%0+-$20+%
0+% 0+85/25#A2#5$%L027% 27$% 41$%/0?% 48% $G25/A20+% +/2#5/1% 5$4#5A$M%R45$4-$5'%
27$% 4.FDOOHG ´LQIUDVWUXFWXUHV.845.PLQHUDOVµ GHDOV KDYH RIWHQ WXUQHG RXW WR
N$+$802% 27$% 670+$$% 0+2$5$2% ?#A7% ?45$% 27/+% 274$% 48% 27$05% Z850A/+%
´SDUWQHUVµ 7KH DJUHHPHQW VLJQHG LQ $SULO EHWZHHQ WKH RQJROHVH
4-$5+?$+2%/+@%/%A4+4520#?%48%670+$$%A4?=/+0$'%L4527%:Cp_%N01104+'%0%/%
44@%011#25/204+%845%27$%482$+%5/27$5%#+$a#/1%+/2#5$%48%C0+4.Z850A/+%5$1/204+M%
k701$% 27$% C0+4.64+41$$% D40+2% -$+2#5$% ²% C0A4?0+$% ²% =54-0@$% 0+85/25#A2#5$%
0+-$2?$+2'%27$%64+41$$%4-$5+?$+2%7/%0-$+%27$%670+$$%/#2745020$%/%
85$$%7/+@%4-$5%27$%?0+$5/1%A4+A$04+%0+%27$%c/2/+/%=54-0+A$M*(%
,Q WKH OLWHUDWXUH KLQD·V JURZLQJ DFWLYLWLHV LQ $IULFD DUH KHQFH RIWHQ
@$=0A2$@% /% A445@0+/2$@'% ?$5A/+20102% #+@$52/V0+M*I %T70% =40+2% 48% -0$L% 0%
=/521B%5$81$A2$@%0+%27$%9#54=$/+%=410AB%/==54/A7M%T7$%9:%7/%N$$+%/1/5?$@%
E KLQD·V ´QR VWULQJV DWWDFKHGµ DLG ZKLFK FRQWUDGLFWV WKH (XURSHDQ
+45?/20-$%@0A4#5$%A$+25$@% 4+% =41020A/1% A4+@0204+/102BM% !2% 0% 8$/5$@% 27/2% 27$%
=5/?/20A% N#0+$.450$+2$@% 670+$$% /==54/A7% 0% #+@$5?0+0+% 44@%
4-$5+/+A$% 0+% Z850A/'% NB% 0+@05$A21B% 20?#1/20+% 4+40+% A4+810A2% 4-$5%
5$4#5A$% 0+% A4#+250$% 10V$% C#@/+% 45% [0$50/M*%!+% /@@0204+'% 9#54=$/+% $G=$52%
**%P$2$5%,47/5@'%´KLQD·VUROHLQILQDQFLQJ$IULFDQLQIUDVWUXFWXUHVµN'2-.'(21'()/-.,)
6-2C1.F'%,$5V$1B'%R/B%())K'%722=OeeLLLM0+2$5+/204+/150-$5M45e801$e670+/9G0?,/+VZ850A/M=@8%%
*(%%Q47/++/%Q/+4+%HWDO´KLQHVHRPSDQLHVLQWKH([WUDFWLYH,QGXVWULHVRI*DERQDQG'5
3HUFHSWLRQVRI7UDQVSDUHQFµ$-'2.-)51.)$%'-,-)327;-,)-=1.2'%:+0-$502B%48%C2$11$+N4A7'%
C2$11$+N4A7'%Z##2%())_'%=M%IIM%
*I%Q4+/27/+%Y411/'%´KLQD·V1HZ0HUFDQWLOLVPLQHQWUDO$IULFDµ85.?(')(';)8,(')327;-,'%
-41M%J'%+4M%I'%3$0@$+'%())d'%==M%*II.*d_M%
*%/+0$1%,/A7'%´$IULFD·VFRPPRGLWERRPWKHSLWIDOOVRIFKDQJHZLWKRXWUHIRUPµLQ;#A702/%
,$50%/+@%:22/?%c#?/5%C0+7/%]$@M^'%85.?()(';)!'-.9A)3-?7.2A'%[$L%$170'%ZA/@$?0A%
F4#+@/204+'%())_'%==M%E*._)M%
!#$%'%()**% *E%
6. 7/-$% @$=145$@% 27/2% ?/+B% 670+$$% =54D$A2% 0+% Z850A/% /5$% +42% 0+% 10+$% L027%
0+2$5+/204+/1%$+-054+?$+2/1%2/+@/5@M*J%
!+% 7452'% 27$% =5$-04#% =/5/5/=7% 7/-$% 7071072$@% 27/2% 27$% 670+$$%
5$4#5A$%@0=14?/AB%0+%Z850A/%0%?#A7%?45$%?#1208/A$2$@%27/+%482$+%/#?$@M%
!+@$$@'% 27$% 670+$$% =410AB% 0+%Z850A/% 0%=/52% 48% 27$%4-$5/11%670+$$%a#$2% 845%
5/L%?/2$50/1'%B$2%2L4%=40+2%+$$@%24%N$%?$+204+$@%7$5$M%F052'%02%L4#1@%N$%/+%
4-$50?=1080A/204+% 24% /#?$% 27/2% 670+$$% 845$0+% @05$A2% 0+-$2?$+2% ]F!^%
4+1B%4%24% 27$% $G25/A20-$% 0+@#250$% $A245% 0+%Z850A/M%Z% /%?/22$5%48%8/A2'% 27$%
670+$$% A4+250N#204+% 24% 27$% 2$1$A4??#+0A/204+% /+@% 27$% 80+/+A0/1% $A245% 0+%
A$52/0+% Z850A/% A4#+250$% 0% 482$+% #+@$5$20?/2$@M% F#527$5?45$'% N/$@% 4+% 02%
?4@$1% 48% $G=452.1$@% ?/+#8/A2#50+'% 670+/% 7/% 0@$+2080$@% 27$% Z850A/+%
A4+20+$+2%/% /% =54?00+%?/5V$2% 845% 02% A7$/=% 44@M% C$A4+@'% 27$% 670+$$%
/A20-020$%5$1/2$@%24%27$%0?=452%48%Z850A/+%5$4#5A$%/5$%+42%+$A$/501B%=/52%48%
/% A4+A$52$@% +/2#5/1% 5$4#5A$% 25/2$B'% /% /#?$@% NB% 27$% A4+A$=2% 10V$%
´KLQD,QFµRU´%HLMLQJRQVHQVXVµ5HFHQWVWXGLHVKDYHVKRZQWKDWGHVSLWH
27$% #0@0+% 7/+@% 48% 27$% 670+$$% 4-$5+?$+2'% @0-$50+% 0+2$5$2% 7/-$%
$?$5$@% /% /% 5$#12% 48% /% 54L0+% +#?N$5% 48% 670+$$% /A245% $+/0+% 0+%
Z850A/M%
8.*+*%1-.13?%$'*.%B+/*%-);-')$+9=
T7$% 670+$$% $4=41020A/1% 25/2$B% 24% $A#5$% +/2#5/1% 5$4#5A$% 0+% Z850A/% 7/%
250$5$@%?/0-$%5$/A204+%0+%9#54=$M%T7$%9#54=$/+%@$N/2$%7/%N$$+%?421B%
A7/5/A2$50$@% NB% 27$% 8$/5% 27/2% A#55$+2% A7/+$% 0+% 27$% 14N/1% #==1B% /+@%
GHPDQGSDWWHUQV RIFRPPRGLWLHVFDXVHGEKLQDFRXOGWKUHDWHQWKH (8·V
$A#502B%/+@%$A4+4?0A%A4?=$2020-$+$M% T7$% /#?=204+% 27/2% 27$%/AA$% 24%
+/2#5/1% 5$4#5A$%0%A5#A0/1%24%#/5/+2$$% 27$% N54/@$5%9#54=$/+%$A#502B%7/%
N$$+%5$81$A2$@%0+%?/D45%9#54=$/+%=410AB%=/=$5%#A7%/%27$%())I%9#54=$/+%
C$A#502B% C25/2$B% ]9CC^% /+@% 02% ())E% !?=1$?$+2/204+% ;$=452M% ,427% =410AB%
@4A#?$+2% 5$A4??$+@%27$%$2/N107?$+2%48%/%A4??4+%9#54=$/+%25/2$B%
24%$A#5$%+/2#5/1%5$4#5A$M*d%)URPDQHFRQRPLFSHUVSHFWLYHKLQD·V$IULFD
SROLF FRXOG FDOO LQWR TXHVWLRQ WKH FRQWLQXHG VHFXULW RI WKH (8·V PLQHUDO
0?=452% 854?% Z850A/% /+@% /% /% 5$#12% #+@$5?0+$% 27$% ()))% 30N4+% C25/2$B'*K%
L70A7% 0% /0?$@% /2% ?/V0+% WKH (8 ´WKH PRVW FRPSHWLWLYH DQG GQDPLF
V+4L1$@$.N/$@%$A4+4?B% 0+% 27$%L451@%A/=/N1$% 48% #2/0+/N1$%$A4+4?0A%
JURZWKZLWKPRUHDQGEHWWHUMREVDQGJUHDWHUVRFLDOFRKHVLRQµ*E%%
Z% /% A4+$a#$+A$% 48% 9#54=$/+% 0+2$5/204+'% R$?N$5% C2/2$% 7/-$%
@$1$/2$@%/%54L0+%+#?N$5%48%25/@$%5$1/2$@%A4?=$2$+A$%24%27$%9#54=$/+%
1$-$1%/+@%02%7/%27#%N$A4?$%0+A5$/0+1B%@0880A#12%24%0@$+208B%27$%+/204+/102B%48%
/%=/520A#1/5% A4?=/+BM% F45% 270% 5$/4+'% 27$% 9#54=$/+%64??004+% 7/%N$$+%
*J%6750%Z1@$+%/+@%Z+/%65020+/%$OYHV´KLQDDQG$IULFD·V1DWXUDO5HVRXUFHV7KHKDOOH+$%
DQG,PSOLFDWLRQVIRU'HYHORSPHQWDQG*RYHUQDQFHµ38NN8)*??(,1'()E(=-.'%+4M%*'%C4#27%
Z850A/+%!+202#2$%48%!+2$5+/204+/1%Z88/05'%Q47/++$N#5'%C$=2$?N$5%())_'%=M*M%
*d%9#54=$/+%64#+A01'%8)3-?7.-)!7.1=-)')()D-22-.)a1.;#)!7.1=-(')3-?7.2A)32.(2-9A'%,5#$1'%*(%
$A$?N$5%())I'%=M%I`%%9#54=$/+%64#+A01'%-=1.2)1')2%-)N4=-4-'2(21')15)2%-)!7.1=-(')
3-?7.2A)32.(2-9A)#)E.1/;'9)3-?7.2A)')()$%('9'9)a1.;'%,5#$1'%**%$A$?N$5%())E'%=M%JM%
*K%9#54=$/+%64??004+'%$144,,1')32(55)a1.F'9)L1?74-'2)#)8'(A,,)15)2%-)?14=-22/-'-,,)
15)2%-)'1'#-'-.9A)-M2.(?2/-)';7,2.A)')2%-)!'%C96%]())K^%KK*'%,5#$1'%())KM%
*E%9#54=$/+%64#+A01'%E.-,;-'?A)$1'?7,1','%30N4+'%(I.(%R/5A7%()))M%
!#$%'%()**% *_%
8. µ()%
F4114L0+% /%=#N10A%A4+#12/204+% 48%-/504#% 2/V$741@$5'% 27$% 9#54=$/+%
64??004+%/@4=2$@%0+%())E%27$%9#54=$/+%;/L%R/2$50/1%!+020/20-$%];R!^'%/%/%
8052%0+2$5/2$@%9#54=$/+%25/2$B%5$/5@0+%5/L%?/2$50/1M(*%T7$%;R!%0%N/$@%
4+%275$$%=011/5'%27$%8052%4+$%84A#0+%4+%74L%24%$A#5$%27$%/AA$%48%25/2$0A%
5$4#5A$% 0+% 2705@% A4#+250$M% Y$+A$'% 02% =5$$+2% 27$% A45+$524+$% 48% /% ?45$%
SURDFWLYH(8´UDZPDWHULDOVGLSORPDFµ,Q)HEUXDUWKH50,ZDVIXUWKHU
XSGDWHGEDRPPLVVLRQFRPPXQLFDWLRQHQWLWOHG´7DFNOLQJWKHFKDOOHQJHV
0+%A4??4@02B%?/5V$2%/+@%4+%UDZPDWHULDOVµ((%ZAA45@0+%24%4?$%4N$5-$5'%
WKLV VHFRQG SROLF GRFXPHQW LV PXFK PRUH DVVHUWLYH UHJDUGLQJ WKH (8·V
DPELWLRQV ´WR FRXQWHU %HLMLQJ·V DOOHJHG XQIDLU SUDFWLFHV LQ DFFHVVLQJ NH
PLQHUDOVµ (I %:KHQ FRQWULEXWLQJ WR WKH (8·V UDZ PDWHULDOV LQLWLDWLYH'% 27$%
9#54=$/+% P/510/?$+2% /14% $G=5$$@% $G=10A02% A4+A$5+% 5$/5@0+% 670+/M%
Z?4+%27$%5$/4+%102$@%845%27$%$2.#=%48%/%=$A0/1%9#54=$/+%;/L%R/2$50/1%
U54#=% 48% 27$% 9#54=$/+% P/510/?$+2'% 27$% +$L1B% /==40+2$@% A7/05'% c/51.Y$0+b%
F145$+b'%?$+204+$@% L4550$% 4-$5% 9#54=$/+% A4?=/+0$% #88$50+% 854?% #+8/05%
670+$$%A4?=$20204+%0+%Z850A/M(%%
F$/5%/N4#2% =42$+20/1% @05#=204+% 854?%670+/% 5$/5@0+% 27$% /AA$% 24%
+/2#5/1%5$4#5A$%7/-$%/14%A4+0@$5/N1B%/12$5$@%9:.Z850A/%5$1/204+M%k7$5$/%
LQWKHSDVWWKH(8·VUHODWLRQVKLSZLW7%Z850A/%L/%@4?0+/2$@%NB%2/1V%/N4#2%/0@%
/+@%=4-$52B%5$@#A204+'%670+/%7/%N54#72%27$%0#$%48%5/L%?/2$50/1%707%4+%
27$% 9:.Z850A/% /$+@/M% T7$5$% 7/% N$$+% /+% 0+A5$/0+% /L/5$+$% /?4+%
9#54=$/+% =410AB?/V$5% /+@% N#0+$% 5$=5$$+2/20-$% 48% 27$% =42$+20/1% 48%
$IULFD·V PRVWO XQH[SORLWHG UDZ PDWHULDOV 7KH -RLQ $IULFD.9:% C25/2$B%
]QZ9C^'%2754#7%27$%ZA204+%P1/+%4+%5/L%?/2$50/1'%7/%=#2%27$%84#+@/204+%845%
/%A14$5%9:.Z850A/%A44=$5/204+%0+%270%80$1@M(J%T7$%0?=452/+A$%48%5/L%?/2$50/1%
*_%´(XURSH·V5HVRXUFH*UDE.%W$2$@%0+2$5$2%/2%L45V%0+%27$%9#54=$/+%P/510/?$+2´$1.=1.(2-)
!7.1=-)*+,-./(21.A'%(K%Q#+$%()**'%722=OeeLLLMA45=45/2$$#54=$M45e14N/1.
$#54=$eA4+2$+2e()**e)de$#54=$.5$4#5A$.5/N%%
()%64?=$2020-$+$%64#+A01%48%R0+02$5'%$17'?)$1'?7,1''%,5#$1'%(*%R/B%())KM%
(*%9#54=$/+%64??004+'%:%-)(C)G(2-.(,)N'2(2/-)#)G--2'9)17.)?.2?()'--;,)5.)9.1C2%)(';)
01+,)')!7.1=-U)64??#+0A/204+%6gR%]())E^%d__'%,5#$1'%())E'%=MJM%
((%9#54=$/+%64??004+'%:(?F'9)?%(-'9-,)')?1441;2A)4(.F-2,)(';)1').(C)4(2-.(,U)
6gR%]()**^%(J%80+/1'%,5#$1'%()**M%
(I%´(8GUDZVXSSODQVWROXUH$IULFD·VPLQHUDOVµ!7.8?2/'%*%$A$?N$5%()*)'%
722=OeeLLLM$#5/A20-MA4?e$+e#2/0+/N0102Be$#.@5/L.=1/+.1#5$./850A/.?0+$5/1.+$L.J))*JK%%
(%´3DUOLDPHQWWRGLJXSUDZPDWHULDOVLVVXHVµ!7.8?2/'%*%R/5A7%()**'%
722=OeeLLLM$#5/A20-MA4?e$+e=$A0/15$=452.5/L?/2$50/1e=/510/?$+2.54#=.@0.5/L.?/2$50/1.
0#$.+$L.J)(JdE%%
(J%9#54=$/+%64#+A01'%:%-)85.?(#!)32.(2-9?)E(.2'-.,%=P)8)01'2)85.?(#!)32.(2-9A'%30N4+'%_%
$A$?N$5%())KM%
!#$%'%()**% ()%
9. 7/%/14%N$$+%5$02$5/2$@%0+%/%?45$%5$A$+2%9#54=$/+%=410AB%@4A#?$+2%4+%9:.
Z850A/%5$1/204+M(d%F#527$5?45$'%27$%()**%-$504+%48%27$%;R!%7/%0+254@#A$@%27$%
=40N0102B%48%#0+%48%27$%9:.Z850A/%!+85/25#A2#5$%F#+@%845%27$%8#+@0+%48%5/L%
?/2$50/1%=54D$A2%0+%Z850A/M(K%
Z1274#7%270%/UWLFOHDGRSWVD(XURSHDQSHUVSHFWLYHUHJDUGLQJKLQD·V
5/L%?/2$50/1% =410AB% 0+% Z850A/'% 4+$% 7/% /14% 24% 2/V$% 0+24% /AA4#+2% +/204+/1%
0+020/20-$%L70A7%A4+250N#2$@%24%27$%9#54=$/+%=410AB%A7$?$%4+%5/L%?/2$50/1M%
U$5?/+B'%845%0+2/+A$'%/@4=2$@%02%4L+%5/L%?/2$50/1%25/2$B%0+%()*)M(E%T70%
=410AB% @4A#?$+2% 7/% N$$+% 27$% 4#2A4?$% 48% 0+2$+$% A4+#12/204+% N$2L$$+%
27$%U$5?/+%4-$5+?$+2%/+@%27$%U$5?/+%?$2/1%0+@#25B'%5$=5$$+2$@%NB%27$%
U$5?/+% 0+@#25B% 8$@$5/204+% ],!^M% C0?01/5% 24% 27$% 9#54=$/+% 25/2$B'% 27$%
U$5?/+%@$N/2$%/54#+@%?0+$5/1%5$4#5A$%7/%N$$+%@4?0+/2$@%NB%8$/5%4-$5%
KLQD DV GHPRQVWUDWHG E WKH %', UHSRUW RQ ´TXHVWLRQV UHODWHG WR
LQWHUQDWLRQDOUDZPDWHULDOVµRI0DUFK(_%%
6$.9)?,-$.A7%$,'*9/,.;'$,,-()*(*.*2-/,$2-.$53?%$'*.9$$'*%/-$.-.
82%-9
T4% FRQFOXGH LW LV HVVHQWLDO WR UHODWH WKH (8·V SROLF UHVSRQVH RQ KLQD·V
5$4#5A$% @0=14?/AB% 0+% Z850A/% 24% 27$% 4-$5/11% +/2#5$% 48% 9:.670+/% 5$1/204+% 0+%
Z850A/M% P#bb1$@% NB% 27$% $?$50+% 670+$$% 0+2$5$2% 0+%Z850A/'%?/+B% 9#54=$/+%
$G=$52% /+@% =410AB?/V$5% 7/-$% 1/5$1B% $G/$5/2$@% 27$% A4=$% 48% 670+$$%
/A20-020$% 4+% 27$% Z850A/+% A4+20+$+2O% #+201% +4L'% 27$5$% /5$% +4% 0+% 48% 670+/%
14AV0+.#=%?0+$5/1% 854?% 27$% 9:M%g+% 27$% A4+25/5B'% 02% 7/% N$$+% /5#$@% 27/2%
670+$$% 0+-$2?$+2% 0+% $G=145/204+% /+@% $G=1402/204+% 48% ?0+$5/1% 5$$5-$% 0+%
Z850A/%A4#1@%/@@%24%14N/1%#==10$M%k701$%27$5$%0%A$52/0+1B%/+%4+40+%14N/1%
´VFUDPEOH IRU QDWXUDO UHVRXUFHVµ FXUUHQWO RQO OLPLWHG ORFDO FRPSHWLWLRQ
4AA#5% N$2L$$+% 9#54=$/+% /+@% 670+$$% A4?=/+0$% 0+% Z850A/M I) %!+% 8/A2'%
670+$$% Cg9% ?421B% A4+A$+25/2$% 27$05% /A20-020$% 0+% Z850A/+% A4#+250$% /+@%
$A4+4?0A% $A245%L7$5$% 27$B% 8/A$% 1$% 14A/1% A4?=$20204+MI*%Z%+$L.A4?$5%
4+%0+2$5+/204+/1%?/5V$2'%670+$$%?$2/1%/+@%?0+0+%A4?=/+0$%7/-$%2/52$@%
(d%9#54=$/+%64??004+')*')2%-)?1',1;(21')15)!)85.?().-(21',)²)QUT)+1')=-1=-U)SV)
?17'2.-,U)2C1)?1'2'-'2,U)1'-)5727.-'%6gR]()*)^%dI'%,5#$1'%()*)'%=M%KM%
(K%9#54=$/+%64??004+'%:(?F'9)?%(-'9-,)')?1441;2A)4(.F-2,)(';)1').(C)4(2-.(,U)
6gR%]()**^%(J%80+/1'%,5#$1'%()**'%=M%*IM%
(E%U$5?/+%F$@$5/1%R0+025B%48%9A4+4?0A%/+@%T$A7+414B'%7KH*HUPDQ*RYHUQPHQW·VUDZ
4(2-.(,),2.(2-9A)#))3(5-97(.;'9)(),7,2('(+-),7==A)15)'1'#-'-.9A)4'-.().-,17.?-,)51.)
J-.4('A'%,$510+'%gA24N$5%()**M%
(_%,#+@$-$5N/+@%@$5%$#2A7$+%!+@#250$%],!^'%1%,2155,?%-.%-2)²)8'51.;-.7'9-')(')
N';7,2.-)7';)E12F)!.9-+',+-.?%2);-.)DLN#E.e,;(9.7==-)N'2-.'(21'(-)1%,21555.(9-''%
,$510+'%*d%R/5A7%())K'%%722=OeeLLLMN@0.
4+10+$M@$e,!g[3![9f![9ZZCPe0F!39M@11em9d*d9*_ZF9K6dEJ,ZI96d*()K,IZe(F(J(*)(**dK*
*JZ_6)))_)(Kd(6E)ePFe;472488N$50A72MPF%%
30 Z8,'%g96'%:[P'%:[96Z'%85.?(')!?1'14?)*7211F)ZVQQ'%=M*)dM%
30 ´KLQDDQG5LR7LQWRFRPSOHWH*XLQHDPLQLQJGHDOµDD$'%(_%Q#1B%()*)'
I*%Q4+/27/+%+ROVODJHWDO´KLQD·VUHVRXUFHVDQGHQHUJSROLFLQ6#N.6DKDUDQ$IULFDµ-=1.2)
51.)2%-)L-/-1=4-'2)$14422--)15)2%-)!7.1=-(')E(.(4-'2'%W50D$%:+0-$502$02%,5#$1%]W:,^'%
,5#$1'%*_%R/5A7%())K'%=M%_M%
!#$%'%()**% (*%
10. 24%=/52+$5%L027%?45$%$G=$50$+A$@%k$2$5+%A4?=/+0$%0+%Z850A/MI(%Z+%$G/?=1$%
845% 270% 7/% N$$+% 27$% D40+2% -$+2#5$% N$2L$$+% 27$% Z1#?0+0#?% 645=45/204+% 48%
670+/%]670+/1A4^%/+@%27$%?0+0+%0/+2%;04%T0+24%0+%/%=54D$A2%0+%U#0+$/MII%%
T7$%9:%0+020/2$@%0+%())J%/%@0/14#$%L027%670+/%4+%Z850A/'%#0@$@%NB%/%
=$5=$A20-$% 48% A44=$5/204+% #QGHU WKH OHDGHUVKLS RI WKH RPPLVVLRQ·V '*
$-$14=?$+2M%9-$+2#/11B'%270%L/%25/+1/2$@%0+24%/%9#54=$/+%=54=4/1%4-$5%/%
´WULODWHUDO(8$IULFDDQGKLQDFRRSHUDWLRQµI%/%/+%0++4-/20-$%85/?$L45V%48%
$GA7/+$% /?4+% 9#54=$/+'% 670+$$% /+@% Z850A/+% 5$=5$$+2/20-$M% T7$%
RPPLVVLRQ·V FRPPXQLFDWLRQ IRUHVHHV WKH HVWDEOLVKPHQW RI WULODWHUDO
=/52+$570=%0+%84#5% $A245'%4+$%48%L70A7% 0%27$% #2/0+/N1$%?/+/$?$+2%48%
+/2#5/1%5$4#5A$M%%
$OWKRXJKWKHRIILFLDOKLQHVHSROLFUHVSRQVHWRWKH(8·VFRRSHUDWLRQ
0+020/20-H KDV EHHQ UDWKHU FDXWLRXV WKHUH DUH LQFUHDVLQJ VLJQV WKDW ´KLQD·V
5$4#5A$% 25/2$B% 24L/5@%Z850A/% 0% #+@$540+% 4?$%?4@$2% A7/+$% 27/2%
DUHLQQRVPDOOSDUWDUHVXOWRIWKH@H[SRVXUHWRLQWHUQDWLRQDOVFUXWLQµIJ%R42%
=54?0+$+21B'% 27$% 670+$$% 25/@0204QDO SRVLWLRQ RI ´QRQ.LQWHUIHUHQFHµ LQ WKH
0+2$5+/1%/88/05%48%2705@%A4#+250$%7/%$-41-$@'%/%670+$$%4880A0/1%7/-$%2/52$@%
24%N/1/+A$%27$05%$A4+4?0A%4ND$A20-$%0+%Z850A/%L027%50V%48%=41020A/1%0+2/N0102BM%
C#@/+%/+@%?45$%5$A$+21B%30NB/%/5$%$G/?=1$%845%27$%A/#204#%5$A/10N5/204+%48%
670+$$%0+2$5$2%0+%Z850A/MId%T/V0+%0+24%/AA4#+2%270%$+$5/1%25$+@'%Z1@$+%/+@%
$OYHVHPSKDVLVHWKDWKLQHVHOHDGHUVDUHVKRZLQJPRUH´RSHQQHVVWRZDUGV
/% +#?N$5% 48% 0+2$5+/204+/1% 5$#1/204+% 0+020/20-$% 24% 0?=54-$% 4-$5+/+A$'%
25DQVSDUHQFDQGVXVWDLQDELOLWRIQDWXUDOUHVRXUFHVGHYHORSPHQWLQ$IULFDµIK%%
%T4% #?%#='%N427%9#54=$/+%/+@%670+$$%=410AB?/V$5% $$?%24% 7/5$%
27$% -0$L% 27/2% /% ?/D45% A4+#?$5% 48% 5/L% ?/2$50/1'% 02% 0% 0+% 27$05% A4??4+%
0+2$5$2%24%$+#5$%/%2/N1$%/+@%2$/@B%814L%48%5/L%?/2$50/1%854?%Z850A/O%27$5$%
0%/%+$$@%845%A4+A$52$@%C0+4.9#54=$/+%$88452%845%#/5/+2$$0+%/%#2/0+/N1$%
/+@% 25/+=/5$+2% #==1B% 48% +/2#5/1% 5$4#5A$M% Y$+A$'% $G020+% 0+2$5+/204+/1%
0+020/20-$% #A7% /% 27$% 9G25/A20-$% !+@#250$% T5/+=/5$+AB% !+020/20-$% ]9!T!^%A4#1@%
=5$$+2% /% 44@% 2/520+% =40+2% 845% C0+4.9#54=$/+% A44=$5/204+% 5$/5@0+%
Z850A/+%+/2#5/1%5$4#5A$M%%
%%
I(%$N45/7%,5t#20/?'%´KLQDDQG5LR7LQWRLQ*XLQHD$:LOGRXUWVKLSµ$%'()')85.?(P):%-)
.-(),21.AU)()%R/5A7%()*)'%722=OeeLLLMA70+//850A/5$/1245BMA4?e()*)e)IeA70+/./+@.504.20+24.0+.
#0+$/.L01@M72?1%
II%,,6'%14AM%A02M
I%9#54=$/+%64??004+'%:%-)!U)85.?()(';)$%'(P):1C(.;,)2.(2-.();(197-)(';)
?11=-.(21''%6gR]())E^%dJ'%,5#$1'%())EM%
IJ%Z1@$+%/+@%Z1-$'%4=M%A02M'%=M%()M%
Id%Q4+/%P/5$114.P1$+$5'%´KLQD·%30NB/%7$@$%7071072%7082%4+%+4+.LQWHUIHUHQFHµa1.;)
E12?,)-/-C'%*%Q#+$%()**'%722=OeeLLLML451@=41020A5$-0$LMA4?e/520A1$e_*JeA70+/.10NB/.
7$@$.7071072.7082.4+.+4+0+2$58$5$+A$%%
IK%!N0@M'%=M%()M%
!#$%'%()**% ((%