The Economic and Organised Crime Office (EOCO) has been advised by the Office...
Accelerated Debts Reduction Plans
1. Accelerated Debt Reduction Plans
Advantages, disadvantages; do-it-yourself, and structured plans.
To continue the slide show, mouse click or press
Page Down.
To back up, press the Page Up key on your keyboard.
To end the slide show, click on the Back ← command.
2. Accelerated Debt Reduction Plans
Sound debt reduction or debt elimination plans
involve one or more of the following three
components:
1.Extra principal payments.
• Making larger-than-required payments; and/or
• Bi-weekly payment arrangements
2.Paying the highest rate debt first.
3.Reduction of interest rates.
(Each of these points will be discussed in detail in the following slides).
3. Extra Principal payments:
Nearly all loans made to Utah consumers allow extra principal payments to be applied to the loan
balance, and thus reduce the total amount of interest paid. Before you make extra principal payments,
be sure to follow the method prescribed by your lender. Usually that simply means showing the
amount of extra principal being paid (the amount in excess of the required payment) in the designated
place on the payment coupon or remittance slip. The following is an example of the potential savings.
In this example, if extra principal payments of only $10 are made each month,
10,000 12% 57 mo. 210,000 12% 57 mo. 2332 13,1672 13,167
Loan Rate Term Pmt Total Interest
10,000 12% 60 mo. 222 13,346 3,346
If $50 extra principal is paid each month, the borrower pays
10,000 12% 47 mo. 2772 12,582
If $100 extra principal is paid each month, the borrower pays
10,000 12% 38 mo. 3322 12,069 2,069 $1,277
$1,277 less interest, and pays the
loan off almost 2 years early.
Savings
3,167 $179
the borrower pays $179 less
interest, and pays off the loan
about 3 months early.
2,582 $764
$764 less interest, and pays the
loan off more than a year early
4. Long-Term Loans
The savings resulting from extra principal payments is even more dramatic for long-term loans such as
mortgages. Consider the following example:
136,283 8% 10136,283 8% 101010 29 yr.29 yr.
If $10 extra principal is paid each month
Bal Rate Pmt Term Interest Savings
136,283 8% 1000 30 yr. 223,717
136,283 8% 105050 25 yr.
If $50 extra principal is paid each month
136,283 7.757.75% 1283 1515 yr. 98,077 $125,640
If the borrower can afford $283 extra each month, a 15 year loan can be obtained. Usually 15 year loans can
be obtained at a lower interest rate, thus adding to the savings. In this example, if the loan had been obtained
at 7.75% rather than 8%, $125,640 less interest would have been paid versus the 30 year loan (assuming each
loan was paid according to the schedule shown above).
212,773 $10,944
$10,944 less interest is paid, and the loan
is paid off about one year early
180,817 $42,900
$42,900 less interest is paid, and the loan
is paid off about 5 years early
5. Bi-Weekly (b/w) Payment Programs:
A convenient way to make extra principal
payments, if:
Your paydays are Bi-weeklyYour paydays are Bi-weekly
If you don’t get paid every other week, don’t bother with bi-weekly! (See the following slides).
Your lender accepts extra principalYour lender accepts extra principal (most do without penalty).
Reputable money handlerReputable money handler (some have misused funds).
Low or no feesLow or no fees (some lenders charge no fees, some servicers charge high fees).
Warning: many charge periodic service fees and a set-up fee!
For some people, a small fee may be worth it for the convenience, and discipline, but watch out!
Some servicers claim that the fees come out of the savings. Yes, if you stay with the program,
you will save more than the fee they charge, but if you do it yourself, you can avoid the fees and thus save
even more.
$ 5 b/w service fee $ 150 setup fee
$25 b/w service fee $ 4,0004,000 setup fee
6. If a person makes 26.09 half payments bi-
weekly in an average year:
The Advantage of
Bi-Weekly Payments:
Since there are:
365 1/41/4 days in an average year, and
÷÷ 14 days in a biweekly period, there are
== 26.09 bi-weekly periods in an average
year.
that is the equivalent of 13.045 full payments in an average year!
Most months have 2 bi-weekly paydays, but each year, there will be 2 months with 3 paydays.
7. About
every 11 years:
*Technical detail: Since there are 26.08929 bi-weekly periods in an average
year (365.25 ÷ 14 = 26.08929), about every 11 years, people who get paid bi-
weekly, have 3 months with 3 paydays. Since most years have 26 bi-weekly
pay periods, we may subtract 26 from 26.08929 to get .08929 as the
incomplete portion of a bi-weekly period in an average year. To determine
how many years before an extra full bi-weekly period will take place, we may
divide 1 (bw pmt) by .08929 = 11.1995 years.
a person paying 1/2 of the regular monthly payment bi-
weekly, will make the equivalent of
13 1/2 monthly payments
(by making 27 half payments).
This is because every ~11* years
3 months have 3 paydays.
(3 extra paydays yield 1 ½ extra full payments).
8. Pay 1.09* x 733.77 = 799.81
Loan Rate Pmt Term Total Paid
Extra Principal Bi-Weekly or Monthly
If you don’t get paid bi-weekly, or if you just want to administer your own monthly debt reduction plan and
get the same results, you may pay 1.09 times your required monthly payment. If you do, you will obtain
almost the same result as paying 1/2 of your monthly payment biweekly.
Bi-weekly: 26.09half pmts each yr.
733.77 ÷ 2 = 366.8926.09 times per year
22.65 yrs22.65 yrs
the new term
22.522.5 yrsyrs
new term
48,20948,209
interest saved
(not paid)
216,832216,832
the new total
215,948215,948
new total paid
47,32547,325
less interest
paid
Save
66.04 add .09 of a payment each month.
100,000 8% 733.77 mo. 30 yr. 264,157
Consider the advantage of paying this loan bi-weekly:
(by paying 17,000 early, you avoid paying $47,325 of interest)
Extra Principal
*1.09 = 1/12 of 13.05 pmts
(which is the av. number of full payments
made each year in a bi-weekly plan).
9. Mortgage $ 87,724 734 pmt 8% 20 yrs. remaining
Car loan 13,056 415 pmt 9% 3 yrs.
Other debts 8,000 203 pmt 18% 5 yrs.
Total debt 108,780 1,352
Suppose you were to consolidate these debts into one new mortgage loan; the balance
would immediately go up due to closing costs, but the required monthly payment would
drop. Assuming you could get a better rate, say 7.5% and closing costs of $3,000:
Total
Interest
95,00095,000
If you refinance, but keep paying: 1,352 payoff in 9.75 yrs.
Interest & fees
50,00050,000
If you just keep paying
the old debts as agreed:
New loan 111,780 782 new pmt 7.5% new rate 30 yrs. new term
you “save” (delay paying) 493 each month, but do you really save?
The total of interest and fees paid (assuming you pay according to the new terms):
There are many who claim that you can
Re-finance and “save”.
If your goal is to reduce your monthly payment, it may work just fine. But if your goal is to get out of debt, or
reduce your debt more quickly, if you aren’t careful, refinancing will cause the opposite of what you intend.
Sometimes it works great, especially if you don’t run up other debts again. But often, it just means you are
delaying paying, increasing your debt, and greatly increasing the total amount you pay.
Let’s consider the advantages and disadvantages of refinancing the following debts:
Interest & feesInterest & fees
173,000173,000
50,756 if you keep paying 1352 (no
refi) focusing on highest rate debt first.
10. After 1 year
New New New
Bal. Pmt. Term
77,554 651 21.9
8,072 250 3.1
4,126 150 2.6
6,253 120 8.5
0 0 0
794 90 .8
Getting out of debt quicker, by focusing
first on highest rate debts
Let’s suppose someone had
the following debts. They
could meet the payments, but
with no money to spare:
Existing Balance Payment Rate Remaining
Obligations (p & i*) Term (yrs.)
1st Mort 78,721 651 8.5% 22.9 yrs.
Auto Loan 10,239 250 9.0% 4.1 yrs.
Trailer 5,451 150 9.8% 3.6 yrs.
Credit Card 6,539 120 18.0% 9.5 yrs.
Doctor 400 40 21.0% .9 yrs.
Dentist 1,200 50 19.0% 2.5 yrs.
Totals 102,550 1331 (*p&i stands for principal & interest)
After 1 yr., start
applying the amount
formerly going to the
doctor ($40) to the
next highest rate
debt (the dentist).
After 1.8 years
New New New
Bal. Pmt. Term
76,547 651 21.1
6,194 250 2.3
2,970 150 1.8
5,984 210 3.1
0 0 0
0 0 0
After .8 yr. more,
apply the amount
formerly going to the
doctor ($40) and to
the dentist ($50) to the
next highest rate debt
(the credit card).
11. After 3.7 years
New New New
Bal. Pmt. Term
73,863 651 19.2
1,153 250 .4
0 0 0
2,745 360 .7
0 0 0
0 0 0
Getting out of debt quicker, by focusing
first on highest rate debts
Let’s suppose someone had
the following debts. They
could meet the payments, but
with no money to spare:
Existing Balance Payment Rate Remaining
Obligations (p & i) Term
1st Mort 78,721 651 8.5% 22.9 yrs.
Auto Loan 10,239 250 9.0% 4.1 yrs.
Trailer 5,451 150 9.8% 3.6 yrs.
Credit Card 6,539 120 18.0% 9.5 yrs.
Doctor 400 40 21.0% .9 yrs.
Dentist 1,200 50 19.0% 2.5 yrs.
Totals 102,550 1331
After 1.9 more yrs,
apply the amounts
formerly going to the
doctor & dentist to
the credit card:
After 4.4 years
New New New
Bal. Pmt. Term
72,760 1,261 6.2
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
Out of debt in 10.2Out of debt in 10.2 yrs.
After .7 yr. more,
apply the amounts
formerly going to the
doctor, the dentist, the
credit card, trailer &
auto loan to the
mortgage loan.
12. Formal Debt Reduction Programs:
As shown in the earlier slides, you may do
your own debt reduction plan by simply
adding extra principal to your required
payment. In most cases, the more extra you
pay, the greater your savings, and the
sooner you are out of debt.
If you wish to use a formal plan (maybe
because you lack the willpower to do your
own, or want the convenience), be cautious:
13. Formal Debt Reduction Programs:
Remember: Some bi-weekly servicers
charge very large set-up fees. Although
you will likely save more than the fee - if
you stay with the program, such fees still
represent money out of your pocket.
Watch out for no-refund clauses (if for
some reason you want to get out of the
program early).
14. Formal Debt Reduction Programs:
Also, make sure companies you consider
doing business with are reputable money
handlers. Many of the programs draft
money from your checking account and
then make your payment for you. Some
have been found to misuse the money.
Apparently no regulatory agency oversees
such companies.
15. Dangers Lurking!
Each time you refinance, you
add to your debt (nearly always).
Be careful that you don’t defeat your intent.
There are monsters out there who are more
than willing to take as much money as you
are willing to give them.
A lady called the Department of Financial Institutions recently who wanted to
get a better rate on her mortgage loan. She found out that she’d gotten a very
bad deal the last time she refinanced.
16. She had refinanced her home 2 years prior “because interest rates
had gone down.” She thought she was getting the loan terms
shown in the left column below. When she went to refinance
again, 2 years later “because rates had gone down again,” she
found out she actually had the loan in the middle column below. I
asked why she signed such a loan, she said she was in a hurry and
didn’t read the documents. A very costly mistake! According to
my calculations she lost about $24,000 by not paying attention.
Typical
Re-financed $147,000
“Closing Costs” $3,000
New Loan $150,000
Rate 8%
Diff
$14,000
$3,000
NWFin
Prepay Penalty $0 $7,000 7,000
Total Loss $24,000
10%
$147,000
$17,000
$164,000
17. Variable vs. Fixed RateVariable rate loans can be great if rates go down, but if rates go up, the payments go up, and the total cost
of the loan goes up. In a fixed-rate loan, the rate stays the same and the payment stays the same. If rates
go down, a person can refinance (if s/he thinks the cost of the refinance is worth the difference in rate). If
rates go up in the marketplace, his/her loan is not affected.
18. Home Loans: Beware
1. Prepayment penalties?
Most loans do not have them. Make sure yours doesn’t!
Or if it does, make sure you get some benefit in exchange.
2. Compare Rates
3. Compare Fees
4. Fixed vs. Variable?
19. Avoid Closing Trapsespecially if delayed
Understand
what you are
signing and
why.
Take your time
Don’t just (sign, sign, sign)
Expect delays, and keep all your other
obligations current.
Could be the most important 3 hours of
your financial life.
20. Some say: Put your equity to work
Companies keep trying to encourage people
to mortgage their homes and invest the
money.
These speculative arrangements have cost
many people their homes. Beware!
Even though they promise
all sorts of guarantees, too often the
investments fail andthe borrowers
lose their homes.
Don’t risk your home for speculative
investments!
21. Equity Investments: Suppose a person with plenty of equity
takes out a new mortgage and lets the company “invest it”
0
20000
40000
60000
80000
100000
120000
140000
160000 $150,000 value of home$150,000 value of home
Existing mortgageExisting mortgage
New mortgageNew mortgage InvestInvest
EquityEquity
(proceeds(proceeds
of loan)of loan)
Interest to make paymentsInterest to make payments
Remember:Remember:
EquityEquity HigherHigher
raterate
2. If you can’t afford to lose it, don’t invest it!2. If you can’t afford to lose it, don’t invest it!
1. The greater the rate, the higher the risk!1. The greater the rate, the higher the risk!
LowLow
raterate
22. Equity Investments
0
20000
40000
60000
80000
100000
120000
140000
160000 $150,000 value of home$150,000 value of home
Old mortgageOld mortgage
New mortgageNew mortgage
Remember:Remember:
1. The greater the rate, the higher the risk!1. The greater the rate, the higher the risk!
2. If you can’t afford to lose it, don’t invest it!2. If you can’t afford to lose it, don’t invest it!
3. Don’t borrow it if you don’t want to pay it back!3. Don’t borrow it if you don’t want to pay it back!
Far too manyFar too many
programs, have lostprograms, have lost
the investment, leavingthe investment, leaving
the victim to pay backthe victim to pay back
both the old and theboth the old and the
new mortgage.new mortgage.
23. If you are divorced or getting
divorced...
Have you closed out
all of your old joint
accounts?
If not, you may be
liable even if the
divorce court directed
your x-spouse to pay!
24. Don’t sign it -
unless you agree to it!
How can you agree to it if you
don’t understand it?
How can you understand it, if
you don’t read it?
If you still don’t understand it,
get some help before signing!!!
25. For more information,
You may contact the Utah Department of
Financial Institutions.
801 538-8830
www.dfi.utah.gov
Hinweis der Redaktion
Most home buyers are astute enough to compare interest rates, but some don’t compare closing costs. This slide shows real numbers charged by a mortgage company. Early in 2002, the borrower called the Department of Financial institutions. She said that 2 years prior, she had consolidated her debt because rates were down. She thought she was getting the loan in the left column. Two years later, she heard that rates were down even more and called her lender asking if they’d re-write her loan at a better rate. They told her they would, at 9%. She asked why 9% when she already had an 8% loan. They told her she didn’t have an 8% loan, but a 10% loan. She pulled out her documents and realized that she did have a 10% loan, and that they had charged her an outrageous $17,000 in closing costs (typical would have been somewhere close to $3,000).
I asked her why she signed the unfavorable contract. She said she and her husband were in a big hurry, and the loan officer brought the papers to each of them while they were at work, and neither of them bothered to check to see if what they were signing was consistent with what the understood.
They went to another mortgage company to refinance at a better rate. When her loan to NWFin was paid off, she learned that she had also signed a note with prepayment penalty. That cost them almost $7,000. I figure their inattention to detail cost them $24,000 (14,000 too much for closing costs, $3,000 in extra interest paid on a $164,000 loan balance at 10% rather than 150,000 balance at 8%, and the prepayment penalty of $7,000).
In my estimation, they got ripped off legally. If there was anything illegal about the deal, it was that the loan officer told them one thing and had them sigh something different. How would they prove it to a judge?