Compare and Contrast the ADDIE Model to Dick and Carey Model. What is fundamentally the same with each model and likewise, what is different? Identify at least one advantage and one challenge that each ID model presents when compared to each other

1. COMPARE AND CONTRAST
ADDIE TO DICK AND CAREY
By: Courtlyn Heard
HRD: 647 INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN
JUNE 12, 2019

2. WHAT IS INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN?
• Instructional design is the creation of learning experiences and materials in a
manner that results in the achievement and application of knowledge and skills. The
discipline follows a system of assessing needs, designing a process, developing
materials and evaluating it’s effectiveness.

3. ADDIE MODEL
• The Addie Model is the God Father of Instructional Design . Addie has been around
since the 70’s and many people has used this model as a framework in designing
and creating training programs. Addie is one of the most used model and it stands
for
•

4. DICK AND CAREY MODEL
• The Dick and Carey is also know as the Systems Approach model. Created by Walter
Dick Lou Carey and James Carey and its mostly used in the educational
environments. Dick and Carey Model has ten steps that most instructors identify
with.
•

5. COMPARE OF ADDIE AND DICK AND
CAREY
• BOTH USES SYSTEMATRIC
APPROACH
• BOTH FOCUS ON THE
INPUT,OUTPUT, & PROCCESING
OF DESIGINING THE CURRICULME
ADDIE
&
DICK &CARY
MODEL

6. CONTRAST ADDIE AND DICK AND
CAREY MODEL
*The Addie model has 5 phases
*Addie is very popular in the
business industry
* The Addie model also, don’t
allows you to move forward
with the next phase without
completing the following one.
Addie
Model *The Dick and Carey Model has 10
phases.
* D & C model is mostly used in
educational environments.
* The D & C has a different
approach with evaluation they
evaluate during every phase. And
reevaluate at the end to make sure
the objectives are being met are to
see what they need to change.
Dick
&Carey
model

7. ADVANTAGE OF ADDIE AND DICK
AND CAREY MODEL
ADVANTAGE OF ADDIE
• Flexible
• Addie its mostly used in the business world but also can be used in the educational arena.
ADVANTAGE OF DICKE &CAREY
• Its measurable and straightforward
• Changes can be implemented easily throughout the model layout

8. DISADVANTAGE OF ADDIE AND
DICK AND CAREY MODEL
DISADVANTAGE ADDIE
Time consuming
Very expensive
You have to finish one phase before moving on to the
next one
DISADVANTAGE OF D&C
Time consuming because it has a lot of steps
Every step is beneficial so each step needs to be
fulfilled in order for the D&C model to be successful
Learning is not liner

9. CONCLUSION
• Addie and the Dick and Carey are two important models in the ID world. These
models has helped shaped and mode the way instructors view learning. It has
provided learning with a more clear concise way to meet learning objectives, and
although they may have many differences they both share a common goal to help
provide the best experience for an instructor and a learner.

10. REFERENCE
• Kurt, S. (2018, December 16). ADDIE Model: Instructional Design. Retrieved from
https://educationaltechnology.net/the-addie-model-instructional-design/
• Kurt, S. (2016, December 12). Dick and Carey Instructional Model. Retrieved from
https://educationaltechnology.net/dick-and-carey-instructional-model/
• Dumont, J. (2018, October 29). The AI Rush. Retrieved from
https://www.slideshare.net/jeanbaptiste.dumont/the-ai-rush-
121047435?next_slideshow=2
• Burrows, L. (2018, March 18). Compare & Contrast ADDIE and Dick and Carey Models.
Retrieved from https://www.slideshare.net/LatoyaBurrows1/compare-contrast-addie- and-
dick-and-carey-models
• What is Instructional Design? (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.td.org/what-is- instructional-
design
• Instructional Design Models. (n.d.). Retrieved from
https://www.instructionaldesigncentral.com/instructionaldesignmodels