More Related Content
Similar to Cross Border Estate Planning Issues For Dual Citizens - Cheyenne Reese (20)
Cross Border Estate Planning Issues For Dual Citizens - Cheyenne Reese
- 1. Cross Border Estate Planning
Issues for Dual Citizens
Cheyenne J.H. Reese
Legacy Tax + Trust Lawyers
September 20, 2017
- 2. The Rules Today
“Permanence” since December 2012
9/22/2017 © Copyright all rights reserved 2
- 3. U.S. Estate Tax
Imposed on transfers of property on
death
For U.S. citizens and residents,
imposed on worldwide taxable estate
For U.S. citizens and residents exemption
now at $5,490,000 (adjusted for inflation)
Top rate of estate tax is 40%
9/22/2017 3
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 4. Example – U.S. Citizen Deceased
Deceased dual U.S. and Canadian citizen and
Canadian resident owned the following assets:
U.S. $
Insurance Proceeds 1,000,000
RRSP 1,000,000
House 1,000,000
Canadian Investments 1,500,000
U.S. Investments 1,000,000
U.S. Condominium 1,000,000
Total $6,500,000
9/22/2017 4
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 5. Example – U.S. Citizen Deceased
U.S. Estate Tax Calculation:
Gross Estate Tax $2,545,800
Less Applicable Credit ($2,141,800)
Net Estate Tax $404,000
Credit for Canadian capital gains tax paid
Surviving Spouse a U.S. Citizen?
Unlimited Marital Deduction
Olden Days - Traditional Planning – Shelter Trusts
Portability
Surviving Spouse Canadian Only?
Treaty Marital Credit – Extra $2,141,800 – no tax!
9/22/2017 5
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 6. U.S. Estate Tax
For non-citizen non-residents, imposed
on “U.S. taxable estate”, includes:
Real property located in the United States;
Shares in a U.S. corporation;
Trusts with retained interests; and
Tangible personal property located in the United States
9/22/2017 6
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 7. U.S. Estate Tax (cont’d)
Residency based on “domicile”, all others
non-resident aliens (NRA)
For NRA, $60,000 is exempt
9/22/2017 7
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 8. NRA’s Treaty Credit
$13,000 credit, shelters $60,000
Treaty Credit = proportionate credit
U.S. Assets x $2,141,800 (2017)
Worldwide Assets
Available to every Canadian resident (other than a
U.S. citizen)
Also, U.S. estate tax available as a credit against
Canadian capital gains tax payable on U.S. asset
9/22/2017 8
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 9. Calculation of NRA’s Estate Tax
Extra Marital Credit
• Calculated same as Treaty Credit
• Outright to Canadian Spouse or in qualifying trust
for Canadian Spouse
• Better than QDOT because savings (up to
$2,141,800) vs. deferral
Unlimited Marital Deduction for property passing to a
U.S. citizen spouse or qualified trust for U.S. citizen
spouse
9/22/2017 9
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 10. Example – Canadian Deceased
Deceased Canadian citizen and Canadian resident
owned the following assets:
U.S. $
Insurance Proceeds 1,000,000
RRSP 1,000,000
House 1,000,000
Canadian Investments 1,500,000
U.S. Investments 1,000,000
U.S. Condominium 1,000,000
Total $6,500,000
Estate would be entitled to an Applicable Credit of $654,092,
as follows:
$2,000,000 x $ 2,141,800 = $659,015
$6,500,000
9/22/2017 10
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 11. Calculation of NRA’s Estate Tax
U.S. Estate Tax Calculation:
U.S. Taxable Estate $2,000,000
Tentative U.S. Estate Tax $745,800
Less: Applicable Credit ($659,015)
Equals: Net Tax $86,785
Credit for Canadian capital gains tax paid (accelerate if
necessary)
Surviving Spouse a U.S. Citizen?
Unlimited Marital Deduction
Surviving Spouse Canadian Only?
Treaty Marital Credit – Extra $659,015 – no tax!
9/22/2017 11
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 12. Basis Issues
U.S. Estate tax is 40% on each $1
above $5,490,000
U.S. Capital Gains tax is up to 20%
plus 3.8% (plus State tax if
applicable) with foreign tax credit
only against U.S. federal capital
gains tax
© Copyright all rights reserved 129/22/2017
- 13. Basis Issues (Cont’d)
Canadian capital gains tax payable in any
case on death (or on surviving spouse’s
death)
The capital gains tax issue will now often
drive planning instead of U.S. estate tax
13© Copyright all rights reserved9/22/2017
- 14. Basis Issues (Cont’d)
If property is includible in decedent’s
estate (regardless of whether estate tax is
payable) is entitled to an increase in cost
basis for U.S. purposes to fair market
value at date of death
If property is held in a U.S. estate tax
protected manner (e.g. bypass trust) no
automatic increase to cost basis to fair
market value
14© Copyright all rights reserved9/22/2017
- 15. Basis Issues – Case Study
Canadian spouse (Spouse A) holds shares
in a Canadian corporation with significant
potential for continued appreciation, now
worth $10M
U.S. surviving spouse (Spouse B)
Two children, both dual U.S. and Canadian
citizens
Traditional Planning in Spouse A’s Will –
all in U.S. estate tax protected trust for
Spouse B
15© Copyright all rights reserved9/22/2017
- 16. Case Study (Cont’d)
Problem? If Spouse A dies first, kids
inherit shares with cost base equal to
fair market value on Spouse B’s date
of death for Canadian purposes but
because trust is U.S. estate tax
protected, U.S. cost base is Spouse
A’s date of death value
© Copyright all rights reserved 169/22/2017
- 17. U.S. Gift Tax for U.S. Citizens
Imposed on transfers of property during
lifetime
Same graduated rates as the estate tax
Imposed on transfers on a cumulative
basis
For U.S. citizens and residents, Applicable
Credit (maximum $5,490,000) applies to
gift tax and reduces exemption at death
9/22/2017 17
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 18. U.S. Gift Tax for U.S. Citizens (cont’d)
Annual Exclusion – each year an individual
is entitled to gift up to $14,000 to each of any
number of donees
Increased to $149,000 for gifts to non-U.S.
citizen spouse
Direct payments of medical and tuition
expenses are generally excluded from taxable
gifts, regardless of amount
Marital Exclusion – unlimited deduction for
gifts to a U.S. citizen spouse only
9/22/2017 18
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 19. U.S. Gift Taxation of NRAs
U.S. Gift Tax Liability for NRA
Gifts of U.S. real estate or tangible
personal property located in U.S.
• Gift of vacation property itself; or
• Gift of cash if gift completes in the
U.S.
40% top gift tax rate
Does not apply to shares in U.S.
corporations
9/22/2017 19
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 20. U.S. Gift Taxation of NRAs
Treaty credit is not available to offset tax
on gifts by an NRA
No foreign tax credit for Canadian capital
gains tax and vice versa
• Canada treats gifts as disposition at fair
market value
$14,000 annual exclusion is available
Deduction for gift to NRA spouse is limited
to $149,000 (2017) per year
Gifts to U.S. citizen spouse qualify
9/22/2017 20
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 21. What’s Next for the Estate Tax?
Estate Tax
• Complete Repeal?
• Repeal and Replace?
• Sunset Repeal?
9/22/2017 21
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 22. What’s Next for the Estate Tax?
Repeal for Whom?
• Difference between U.S. and Non-U.S.?
Replace with What?
Repeal for How Long?
Need 60/100 Senate Seats –
Republicans hold 52
9/22/2017 22
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 23. What’s Next for the Estate Tax?
Donald Trump’s Deemed Disposition
Proposal
• Exemption for $10M of assets
• $10M per person or per couple?
• $10M of fair market value or gain?
• Step-up in basis on first $10M?
• Exemption for family farms and small
businesses only? Or just different?
9/22/2017 23
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 24. What’s Next for the Gift Tax?
Repeal?
No Change?
Even Less Incentive for NRA to Gift
U.S. Real Estate
9/22/2017 24
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 25. What’s Next for the Gift Tax?
Republican Platform and Trump’s
Campaign Plan are silent
Gift Tax protects State income tax
system
Carryover Cost Base of a Gift
9/22/2017 25
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 26. What’s Next for the Generation-
Skipping Transfer Tax?
Repeal if Estate Tax is Repealed?
No Change? Tied to Estate Tax…
Retain to add to Gift Tax?
9/22/2017 26
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 27. What’s Next for Minority Interest
Discounts?
Valuable tool to reduce Estate Tax
and Gift Tax liability
Significantly reduces revenue from
the transfer taxes
Attempts to eliminate discounts for
years
Now? Stalled.
If Estate Tax and/or Gift Tax
remain?
9/22/2017 27
© Copyright all rights reserved
- 28. Principal Residence Exemption
U.S. capital gains exemption on the
sale of a principal residence is
USD$250,000 for an individual or
USD$500,000 for spouses filing
jointly
Helpful in many markets. Not,
however, in the Vancouver or
Toronto regions, for example.
9/22/2017 © Copyright all rights reserved 28
- 30. PRE – Planning to Avoid U.S.
Capital Gains Tax
Planning with a Non-U.S. Spouse
No deemed disposition on death, so
if below U.S. estate tax threshold
and not anticipating sale, no problem
9/22/2017 © Copyright all rights reserved 30
- 31. Conclusion
Careful Estate Planning creates significant U.S. tax and
other savings.
Thank You.
Legacy Tax + Trust Lawyers
Cheyenne J.H. Reese
604.631.1251
creese@legacylawyers.com
9/22/2017 © Copyright all rights reserved 31