SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 27
Download to read offline
Fiscal Year 2011 Budget Development
 Community Engagement Summary
              June 2010
Our Goal

 Educate community about our budget and challenges

 Meaningfully engage the community

 Educate & Engage as broadly as possible
What We Did
What We Did

 Provide context for budget development
   – presentation & video

 Preference survey
   – interactive audience response
   – online & paper format

 6 budget development workshops

 Neighborhood & community organization meetings
KEY:
Blue Markers = Public Meetings
Red Markers = Neighborhood
Meetings
What We Did

 Internal engagement (employees)

 Online engagement
How We Spread the Word
How We Spread the Word

 Passenger notices on vehicles

 Advertising

 Email
   – rider alerts
   – MetroConnections newsletter
   – Partner organization newsletters

 Social media
Who Participated
Who Participated                                          492 total surveys



 27 participants at 6 budget development workshops

 58 responses at 11 neighborhood/community meetings

 27 employee paper surveys                    Budget Workshops,
                                                     6%
 380 online                                           Neighborhood
                                                      Meetings, 12%
                                                         Employee Surveys,
                                                               6%




                       Online Surveys,
                            79%
Who Participated


                                                 26%
                                                                                   age
                                                             25%


                                   20%
                                                                          17%




                                                                                          7%

                     3%
                                                                                                       1%
      0%

  Under 18 yrs.   18 – 24 yrs.   25 – 34 yrs.   35-44 yrs   45-54 yrs   55 – 64 yrs.   65 – 73 yrs   74 + yrs.
Who Participated

  62%
                              Capital Metro services used




                            22%                                              25%

               15%
                                          6%
                                                          2%


 MetroBus   MetroExpress   MetroRail   MetroAccess   Metro RideShare   I Don’t Use Capital
                                                                             Metro
Who Participated
42%
                                               area of residence




                       16%
                                               13%
                                   11%
           6%                                                                             8%
                                                           3%
                                                                     0%       1%


 Central   Southeast   Southwest   Northeast   Northwest   Leander    Manor   Del Valle    Other
 Austin     Austin      Austin      Austin      Austin
Who Participated

    how well do you understand our budget?
                   34%      33%




                                       13%          13%
       7%




     Very Well     Well   Not Very   Not at All   No Answer
                            Well
What We Heard
What We Heard

                           rank options for increasing revenue
1


2
             2.6                     2.7
                                                            3.1                     3.1
3                                                                                                          3.3


4


5
     Increase fares for UT & Increase base fare $.25 Increase Cost of Passes Increase MetroAccess   Eliminate Free Fares
          ACC Students             and passes                 Only                   Fares
                                 porportionately
What We Heard

                              rank options for reducing cost
  1

              1.9
  2                                2.2
                                                      2.5

  3
                                                                           3.4


  4


  5
       Contract out more      Reduce Capital   Reduce MetroAccess   Reduce Bus Service
      service at lower cost     Spending            Service
What We Heard

            rank options for building reserves
1

            2.1
2
                                2.6              2.7
3                                                                   3.2


4                                                                                        4.2


5
     Contract out more      Reduce Capital   Increase Fares   Reduce MetroAccess   Reduce Bus Service
    service at lower cost     Spending                             Service
What We Heard
         rank options for spending additional funds
 1



 2           2.2                    2.3
                                                        2.6                2.7

 3



 4


 5
     Add Local Bus Service Add MetroRail Service   Add Express Bus   Increase Reserves
                                                       Service
What We Heard

     what MetroRail service should be prioritized?
            53%




                                       24%                       24%




   Increase Weekend Service   Increase Midday Service   Do Not Increase Service
What We Heard
           rank optional capital projects for FY2011
1


             2.1                    2.2
2
                                                          2.7                 2.8
3


4



5
     Shelters and benches Bus stop accessibility   Do not add any new   Buying New Buses
         at Bus Stops                                capital projects
What We Heard

          rank optional capital projects for next 5 years
1                                           (select top 3)

        1.6
                       1.8
                                      1.9
                                                  2.0
2                                                              2.1
                                                                            2.2            2.2




3
      MetroRail     MetroAccess     Bus Stop     Safety &   Buying new   New Transit    Freight Rail
       system       Scheduling    Improvements   Security     buses       Centers      Improvements
    improvements      System
                   Improvements
What We Learned

  General Preferences for FY2011 Budget
    – preserve service levels
    – across the board fare increase slightly more tolerable than other
      revenue options
    – add service, if feasible
          -MetroBus
          -MetroRail weekends
    - continue bus stop improvements programs

- General Preference for Longer-term
    - pursue contracting out more service to reduce costs and build reserves,
      if feasible
    - capital investments in MetroRail and MetroBus stops
What We Learned

   how well do you understand our budget?
                      58%




                                                                     Before
                34%          33%                                     After
                                    25%

                                            13%          13%
    7%                                                         9%
          6%
                                                   2%

    Very Well     Well      Not Very Well   Not at All   No Answer
What We Learned

   how useful was this meeting?
                  47%




       19%                                                         19%
                               15%



                                                   0%

    Very Useful   Useful   Not Very Useful   Not Useful at All   No Answer
What We Learned

 Engagement Process
   –   decrease emphasis on Capital Metro hosted public forums
   –   continue use of videos to provide context
   –   continue use of surveys and work to broaden sample
   –   investigate webinars and online meeting formats
Next Steps

 Thank participants                                     June
 Obtain Feedback from Board                             June
 Finance develops proposed FY2011 Budget                July - August
 Draft FY2011 Budget presented to Board                 August
 Report back to community                               August
   – survey results
   – how preferences are reflected in proposed budget
   – obtain feedback
 Public hearing on proposed FY11 Budget                 September
 Board adopts FY11 Budget                               September
 Final report to community                              October

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Metro access policy_recommendations
Metro access policy_recommendationsMetro access policy_recommendations
Metro access policy_recommendationsCapital Metro
 
MetroAccess Policy Options Outreach
MetroAccess Policy Options Outreach MetroAccess Policy Options Outreach
MetroAccess Policy Options Outreach Capital Metro
 
The Phast Times News Nov 2010
The Phast Times News Nov 2010The Phast Times News Nov 2010
The Phast Times News Nov 2010Tom Hulsey
 
Common carrier june 14 2010 rail committee
Common carrier june 14 2010 rail committeeCommon carrier june 14 2010 rail committee
Common carrier june 14 2010 rail committeeCapital Metro
 
Total Cost Ownership Surveillance Systems Th (2) (2)
Total Cost Ownership Surveillance Systems Th (2) (2)Total Cost Ownership Surveillance Systems Th (2) (2)
Total Cost Ownership Surveillance Systems Th (2) (2)Tom Hulsey
 
Tobacco free transit facilities survey
Tobacco free transit facilities surveyTobacco free transit facilities survey
Tobacco free transit facilities surveyCapital Metro
 
MetroAccess Options Outreach
MetroAccess Options Outreach MetroAccess Options Outreach
MetroAccess Options Outreach Capital Metro
 
MetroAccess Community Engagement Summary
MetroAccess Community Engagement Summary MetroAccess Community Engagement Summary
MetroAccess Community Engagement Summary Capital Metro
 
Metro access policy_recommendations
Metro access policy_recommendationsMetro access policy_recommendations
Metro access policy_recommendationsCapital Metro
 
Metro access policy change update 9/14/2011
Metro access policy change update 9/14/2011Metro access policy change update 9/14/2011
Metro access policy change update 9/14/2011Capital Metro
 
The Future of the Capital MetroRail Red Line
The Future of the Capital MetroRail Red LineThe Future of the Capital MetroRail Red Line
The Future of the Capital MetroRail Red LineCapital Metro
 
MetroBus Route Analysis Update (Spring 2011)
MetroBus Route Analysis Update (Spring 2011)MetroBus Route Analysis Update (Spring 2011)
MetroBus Route Analysis Update (Spring 2011)Capital Metro
 
Capital Metro Transit Oriented Development
Capital Metro Transit Oriented DevelopmentCapital Metro Transit Oriented Development
Capital Metro Transit Oriented DevelopmentCapital Metro
 

Viewers also liked (13)

Metro access policy_recommendations
Metro access policy_recommendationsMetro access policy_recommendations
Metro access policy_recommendations
 
MetroAccess Policy Options Outreach
MetroAccess Policy Options Outreach MetroAccess Policy Options Outreach
MetroAccess Policy Options Outreach
 
The Phast Times News Nov 2010
The Phast Times News Nov 2010The Phast Times News Nov 2010
The Phast Times News Nov 2010
 
Common carrier june 14 2010 rail committee
Common carrier june 14 2010 rail committeeCommon carrier june 14 2010 rail committee
Common carrier june 14 2010 rail committee
 
Total Cost Ownership Surveillance Systems Th (2) (2)
Total Cost Ownership Surveillance Systems Th (2) (2)Total Cost Ownership Surveillance Systems Th (2) (2)
Total Cost Ownership Surveillance Systems Th (2) (2)
 
Tobacco free transit facilities survey
Tobacco free transit facilities surveyTobacco free transit facilities survey
Tobacco free transit facilities survey
 
MetroAccess Options Outreach
MetroAccess Options Outreach MetroAccess Options Outreach
MetroAccess Options Outreach
 
MetroAccess Community Engagement Summary
MetroAccess Community Engagement Summary MetroAccess Community Engagement Summary
MetroAccess Community Engagement Summary
 
Metro access policy_recommendations
Metro access policy_recommendationsMetro access policy_recommendations
Metro access policy_recommendations
 
Metro access policy change update 9/14/2011
Metro access policy change update 9/14/2011Metro access policy change update 9/14/2011
Metro access policy change update 9/14/2011
 
The Future of the Capital MetroRail Red Line
The Future of the Capital MetroRail Red LineThe Future of the Capital MetroRail Red Line
The Future of the Capital MetroRail Red Line
 
MetroBus Route Analysis Update (Spring 2011)
MetroBus Route Analysis Update (Spring 2011)MetroBus Route Analysis Update (Spring 2011)
MetroBus Route Analysis Update (Spring 2011)
 
Capital Metro Transit Oriented Development
Capital Metro Transit Oriented DevelopmentCapital Metro Transit Oriented Development
Capital Metro Transit Oriented Development
 

Similar to Engage Budget Process

Day1 opening plenary 1
Day1 opening plenary 1Day1 opening plenary 1
Day1 opening plenary 1elliottofhook
 
MACE Compensation & Benefits Results - Iowa
MACE Compensation & Benefits Results - IowaMACE Compensation & Benefits Results - Iowa
MACE Compensation & Benefits Results - Iowaiowachamberexecs
 
Delvinia Digital Diseases Presentation Smei
Delvinia Digital Diseases Presentation SmeiDelvinia Digital Diseases Presentation Smei
Delvinia Digital Diseases Presentation SmeiDelvinia
 
The rules of mobile advertising
The rules of mobile advertisingThe rules of mobile advertising
The rules of mobile advertisingSeungyul Kim
 
Larry Dowell - Insights from the 2012 MACE Compensation & Benefits Survey
Larry Dowell - Insights from the 2012 MACE Compensation & Benefits SurveyLarry Dowell - Insights from the 2012 MACE Compensation & Benefits Survey
Larry Dowell - Insights from the 2012 MACE Compensation & Benefits SurveyDowell Management
 
State of the Indian Blogosphere 2011
State of the Indian Blogosphere 2011State of the Indian Blogosphere 2011
State of the Indian Blogosphere 2011Drizzlin Media
 
Build your business through social media
Build your business through social mediaBuild your business through social media
Build your business through social mediaMilena Regos
 
Media, emerging comm tech & payments v4 march 2012
Media, emerging comm tech & payments v4 march 2012Media, emerging comm tech & payments v4 march 2012
Media, emerging comm tech & payments v4 march 2012Michael Netzley, Ph.D.
 
Iavi Rotberg - Get to know your BA
Iavi Rotberg - Get to know your BAIavi Rotberg - Get to know your BA
Iavi Rotberg - Get to know your BACodecamp Romania
 
VIVO - Apresentation of 4th Quarter 2007 Results
VIVO - Apresentation of 4th Quarter 2007 ResultsVIVO - Apresentation of 4th Quarter 2007 Results
VIVO - Apresentation of 4th Quarter 2007 ResultsVIVO - Investor Relations
 
Automotive Digital Marketing Search Marketing Combined Strategy
Automotive Digital Marketing Search Marketing Combined StrategyAutomotive Digital Marketing Search Marketing Combined Strategy
Automotive Digital Marketing Search Marketing Combined StrategyRalph Paglia
 
Get To Know Your Ba
Get To Know Your BaGet To Know Your Ba
Get To Know Your BaJohny Bravo
 
Adobe Digital Analytics Competition - Los Tres Amigos
Adobe Digital Analytics Competition - Los Tres AmigosAdobe Digital Analytics Competition - Los Tres Amigos
Adobe Digital Analytics Competition - Los Tres AmigosAgata Dec
 
iStrategy 2012, Melbourne: Customer relevance - the next frontier for competi...
iStrategy 2012, Melbourne: Customer relevance - the next frontier for competi...iStrategy 2012, Melbourne: Customer relevance - the next frontier for competi...
iStrategy 2012, Melbourne: Customer relevance - the next frontier for competi...Jason Juma-Ross
 
Indian Telecom Market Overview
Indian Telecom Market OverviewIndian Telecom Market Overview
Indian Telecom Market OverviewZinnov
 
360i Report: The Future of Viewability
360i Report: The Future of Viewability360i Report: The Future of Viewability
360i Report: The Future of Viewability360i
 
Three Reasons Investors Want You Off Spreadsheets; Risk Management Alternatives
Three Reasons Investors Want You Off Spreadsheets; Risk Management AlternativesThree Reasons Investors Want You Off Spreadsheets; Risk Management Alternatives
Three Reasons Investors Want You Off Spreadsheets; Risk Management Alternativesimaginesoftware
 

Similar to Engage Budget Process (20)

Day1 opening plenary 1
Day1 opening plenary 1Day1 opening plenary 1
Day1 opening plenary 1
 
3Q08
3Q083Q08
3Q08
 
MACE Compensation & Benefits Results - Iowa
MACE Compensation & Benefits Results - IowaMACE Compensation & Benefits Results - Iowa
MACE Compensation & Benefits Results - Iowa
 
Delvinia Digital Diseases Presentation Smei
Delvinia Digital Diseases Presentation SmeiDelvinia Digital Diseases Presentation Smei
Delvinia Digital Diseases Presentation Smei
 
The rules of mobile advertising
The rules of mobile advertisingThe rules of mobile advertising
The rules of mobile advertising
 
Larry Dowell - Insights from the 2012 MACE Compensation & Benefits Survey
Larry Dowell - Insights from the 2012 MACE Compensation & Benefits SurveyLarry Dowell - Insights from the 2012 MACE Compensation & Benefits Survey
Larry Dowell - Insights from the 2012 MACE Compensation & Benefits Survey
 
State of the Indian Blogosphere 2011
State of the Indian Blogosphere 2011State of the Indian Blogosphere 2011
State of the Indian Blogosphere 2011
 
Build your business through social media
Build your business through social mediaBuild your business through social media
Build your business through social media
 
Media, emerging comm tech & payments v4 march 2012
Media, emerging comm tech & payments v4 march 2012Media, emerging comm tech & payments v4 march 2012
Media, emerging comm tech & payments v4 march 2012
 
Iavi Rotberg - Get to know your BA
Iavi Rotberg - Get to know your BAIavi Rotberg - Get to know your BA
Iavi Rotberg - Get to know your BA
 
VIVO - Apresentation of 4th Quarter 2007 Results
VIVO - Apresentation of 4th Quarter 2007 ResultsVIVO - Apresentation of 4th Quarter 2007 Results
VIVO - Apresentation of 4th Quarter 2007 Results
 
Automotive Digital Marketing Search Marketing Combined Strategy
Automotive Digital Marketing Search Marketing Combined StrategyAutomotive Digital Marketing Search Marketing Combined Strategy
Automotive Digital Marketing Search Marketing Combined Strategy
 
Get To Know Your Ba
Get To Know Your BaGet To Know Your Ba
Get To Know Your Ba
 
Adobe Digital Analytics Competition - Los Tres Amigos
Adobe Digital Analytics Competition - Los Tres AmigosAdobe Digital Analytics Competition - Los Tres Amigos
Adobe Digital Analytics Competition - Los Tres Amigos
 
iStrategy 2012, Melbourne: Customer relevance - the next frontier for competi...
iStrategy 2012, Melbourne: Customer relevance - the next frontier for competi...iStrategy 2012, Melbourne: Customer relevance - the next frontier for competi...
iStrategy 2012, Melbourne: Customer relevance - the next frontier for competi...
 
Indian Telecom Market Overview
Indian Telecom Market OverviewIndian Telecom Market Overview
Indian Telecom Market Overview
 
360i Report: The Future of Viewability
360i Report: The Future of Viewability360i Report: The Future of Viewability
360i Report: The Future of Viewability
 
Three Reasons Investors Want You Off Spreadsheets; Risk Management Alternatives
Three Reasons Investors Want You Off Spreadsheets; Risk Management AlternativesThree Reasons Investors Want You Off Spreadsheets; Risk Management Alternatives
Three Reasons Investors Want You Off Spreadsheets; Risk Management Alternatives
 
IS Analysis for GENI.org
IS Analysis for GENI.orgIS Analysis for GENI.org
IS Analysis for GENI.org
 
Credit Suisse Group Financial Services Forum
	Credit Suisse Group Financial Services Forum 	Credit Suisse Group Financial Services Forum
Credit Suisse Group Financial Services Forum
 

Engage Budget Process

  • 1. Fiscal Year 2011 Budget Development Community Engagement Summary June 2010
  • 2. Our Goal Educate community about our budget and challenges Meaningfully engage the community Educate & Engage as broadly as possible
  • 4. What We Did Provide context for budget development – presentation & video Preference survey – interactive audience response – online & paper format 6 budget development workshops Neighborhood & community organization meetings
  • 5. KEY: Blue Markers = Public Meetings Red Markers = Neighborhood Meetings
  • 6. What We Did Internal engagement (employees) Online engagement
  • 7. How We Spread the Word
  • 8. How We Spread the Word Passenger notices on vehicles Advertising Email – rider alerts – MetroConnections newsletter – Partner organization newsletters Social media
  • 10. Who Participated 492 total surveys 27 participants at 6 budget development workshops 58 responses at 11 neighborhood/community meetings 27 employee paper surveys Budget Workshops, 6% 380 online Neighborhood Meetings, 12% Employee Surveys, 6% Online Surveys, 79%
  • 11. Who Participated 26% age 25% 20% 17% 7% 3% 1% 0% Under 18 yrs. 18 – 24 yrs. 25 – 34 yrs. 35-44 yrs 45-54 yrs 55 – 64 yrs. 65 – 73 yrs 74 + yrs.
  • 12. Who Participated 62% Capital Metro services used 22% 25% 15% 6% 2% MetroBus MetroExpress MetroRail MetroAccess Metro RideShare I Don’t Use Capital Metro
  • 13. Who Participated 42% area of residence 16% 13% 11% 6% 8% 3% 0% 1% Central Southeast Southwest Northeast Northwest Leander Manor Del Valle Other Austin Austin Austin Austin Austin
  • 14. Who Participated how well do you understand our budget? 34% 33% 13% 13% 7% Very Well Well Not Very Not at All No Answer Well
  • 16. What We Heard rank options for increasing revenue 1 2 2.6 2.7 3.1 3.1 3 3.3 4 5 Increase fares for UT & Increase base fare $.25 Increase Cost of Passes Increase MetroAccess Eliminate Free Fares ACC Students and passes Only Fares porportionately
  • 17. What We Heard rank options for reducing cost 1 1.9 2 2.2 2.5 3 3.4 4 5 Contract out more Reduce Capital Reduce MetroAccess Reduce Bus Service service at lower cost Spending Service
  • 18. What We Heard rank options for building reserves 1 2.1 2 2.6 2.7 3 3.2 4 4.2 5 Contract out more Reduce Capital Increase Fares Reduce MetroAccess Reduce Bus Service service at lower cost Spending Service
  • 19. What We Heard rank options for spending additional funds 1 2 2.2 2.3 2.6 2.7 3 4 5 Add Local Bus Service Add MetroRail Service Add Express Bus Increase Reserves Service
  • 20. What We Heard what MetroRail service should be prioritized? 53% 24% 24% Increase Weekend Service Increase Midday Service Do Not Increase Service
  • 21. What We Heard rank optional capital projects for FY2011 1 2.1 2.2 2 2.7 2.8 3 4 5 Shelters and benches Bus stop accessibility Do not add any new Buying New Buses at Bus Stops capital projects
  • 22. What We Heard rank optional capital projects for next 5 years 1 (select top 3) 1.6 1.8 1.9 2.0 2 2.1 2.2 2.2 3 MetroRail MetroAccess Bus Stop Safety & Buying new New Transit Freight Rail system Scheduling Improvements Security buses Centers Improvements improvements System Improvements
  • 23. What We Learned General Preferences for FY2011 Budget – preserve service levels – across the board fare increase slightly more tolerable than other revenue options – add service, if feasible -MetroBus -MetroRail weekends - continue bus stop improvements programs - General Preference for Longer-term - pursue contracting out more service to reduce costs and build reserves, if feasible - capital investments in MetroRail and MetroBus stops
  • 24. What We Learned how well do you understand our budget? 58% Before 34% 33% After 25% 13% 13% 7% 9% 6% 2% Very Well Well Not Very Well Not at All No Answer
  • 25. What We Learned how useful was this meeting? 47% 19% 19% 15% 0% Very Useful Useful Not Very Useful Not Useful at All No Answer
  • 26. What We Learned Engagement Process – decrease emphasis on Capital Metro hosted public forums – continue use of videos to provide context – continue use of surveys and work to broaden sample – investigate webinars and online meeting formats
  • 27. Next Steps Thank participants June Obtain Feedback from Board June Finance develops proposed FY2011 Budget July - August Draft FY2011 Budget presented to Board August Report back to community August – survey results – how preferences are reflected in proposed budget – obtain feedback Public hearing on proposed FY11 Budget September Board adopts FY11 Budget September Final report to community October