SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 16
Download to read offline
Project 8: Summary of Work
By: Callum Lamb
Summary of Work
 Major Projects:
 Cell Design
 Getter Design & Support Structure
 Insert Support Structure & Heat Analysis
 Window Gasket Seal Test and Simulations
 Side Projects:
 Learning Thermal Stress Analysis
 KATRIN Project
 Cryocooler Repair
Cell Design:
 Design Features:
 Gold gasket sealed OR soldered gas
line
 Screws directly into bus bar for
stability (6 screws)
 Symmetric window seals for
consistency.
 10 cm of space for adaptability in
coil winding
Getter System Design:
 Design Features:
 Cube at center minimizes space
requirement and removes need for custom
attachment piece.
 Includes filler valve & Ion gauge in assembly
 Getter contained within standard CF nipple
 Feedthrough to power getter
 Each component is easily accessible.
 Fits within large iso cross, close to insert.
Getter Support Structure
& Gas Line:
 Design Features:
 Supported by ‘blank flange’ piece
 Combines blank, gas line input &
support structure
 Very Stable – Stainless Steel
 Leaves majority of iso cross open.
 Does not block bore.
 Gas line remains close to insert
Insert Support Structure
 Design Features:
 Adequate Thermal barrier between
bus bar and iso cross (confirmed in
MATLAB)
 Lower Ring, attachment piece & pipes
made of G-10
 High structural stability: Pipes allow
essentially no flex or vibration
 Screws directly into bus bar
 Applies both upwards & downwards
force to insert from iso cross.
Drawings…
 Lots and lots…
Test Seal Preparation:
 Prepared the test apparatus to begin
mechanical testing of the gold gasket seal.
 Modified previous pieces in the shop to allow
us to attach the cold plate and test cell
together inside the iso cross.
 For this purpose, created the bracket plate
with Martin.
 Apparatus:
• Helium supply
(bottom left),
• Temperature
sensor (bottom right),
• Cold plate (upper
right),
• Test cell (right
middle)
First Test- Corner Seal
 We initially tested the corner seal
design, as shown (sapphire window).
 First tested this at room temperature,
then decided to go straight to a face
seal.
 Unsuccessful initially- the gold gasket
was too large.
 Once the correct gasket was used, the
seal was successful.
Mechanical Simulation:
Sapphire Window
 Digging more into AutoCAD Inventor, I
used in-CAD NASTRAN to perform
mechanical simulations of the window
under the stress required to compress the
gold gasket.
 Performed Face Seal (Upper) & Corner
seal (Lower) stress analysis
 Most realistic constraints:
 Gasket contact surface is axial constrained
 Opposing surface is where force is applied
 Cylindrical side is constrained in the radial
directions.
 Conclusion: Force Required for Gasket
compression will not break sapphire
window.
Face Seal Test:
Setup
 Cell is sealed with alternating aluminum &
titanium screws to alternatively provide
compression during cold & hot cycling.
 Cell is fastened to cold plate inside of iso cross,
with temperature sensors attached with Kapton
tape.
 For initial heat cycle, heating rope is wrapped
around the outer iso cross.
 Full setup with leak checker attached & helium
input (bottom left).
Face Seal Test:
Conclusion
 Peter and I ran the hot and then cold cycle
multiple times.
 Conclusion: The face seal for the sapphire
window reasonably seals for the required
temperature range.
 Curve in Leak rate at the end: Peter removed
and replaced helium source  Leak rate
approx. 1.0E-08. Leak checker is quite old…
Heat damage to
bracket plate:
Cooling with
liquid nitrogen:
Mechanical Simulation & Test:
Calcium Fluoride Window
 Using the same constraints, I did an analysis for the CaF2
windows.
 Maximum force (0.5” OD, 0.396” Bore, 0.45 O-Ring) is 265
Ibs.
 Is this sufficient for gold ring compression?
 Previously estimated about 500 Ibs of force is required, currently
trying to confirm that with simulations, but proving difficult.
 Put CaF2 in previous setup – very quickly broke windows.
 Take away: Surface was rough from failed soldering attempt-
surface roughness is a stress amplifier.
 Result: Back the window with a Kapton ring
Future Work For CaF2 Test Seal:
 Once modified test cell & window holder (accurately simulates final
design) are received from the shop, Peter and I will perform that test.
 Room temperature- If successful continue to heat loading
 If Unsuccessful we’ll need to visit other options, such as sealing between
the window holder and cell faces, which relieves the compressive force
from the window.
 Work on simulations using a different software- Simulation Mechanical
from AutoCAD to model gold gasket compression force requirement.
Side Projects:
Thank You!
 Thank everyone in this project, you’ve all made my time
here a wonderful experience, full of learning and growth.
 A special thank you to Martin, who’s taught me an
incredible amount, Hamish who has been constantly
supportive, and Jared for getting me in here in the first
place.

More Related Content

Similar to Project 8 Summary

MEC441 - Solar Panel Cooling System
MEC441 - Solar Panel Cooling SystemMEC441 - Solar Panel Cooling System
MEC441 - Solar Panel Cooling SystemLuis Lituma
 
Farzad Mirshams, Mechanical / Thermal Engineer
Farzad Mirshams, Mechanical / Thermal EngineerFarzad Mirshams, Mechanical / Thermal Engineer
Farzad Mirshams, Mechanical / Thermal EngineerFarzad Mirshams
 
Chapter 7: Fluxtrol Induction Heating Case Studies and Success Stories
Chapter 7:  Fluxtrol Induction Heating  Case Studies and Success StoriesChapter 7:  Fluxtrol Induction Heating  Case Studies and Success Stories
Chapter 7: Fluxtrol Induction Heating Case Studies and Success StoriesFluxtrol Inc.
 
0.8um-0.9Tip-13Low
0.8um-0.9Tip-13Low0.8um-0.9Tip-13Low
0.8um-0.9Tip-13LowJustin Smith
 
Est group harbin urea conference 2014 pap paper v1 english
Est group harbin urea conference 2014 pap paper v1 englishEst group harbin urea conference 2014 pap paper v1 english
Est group harbin urea conference 2014 pap paper v1 englishJim Novak (吉因龙)
 
Hot Hydroforging for Lightweighting Presentation IDE 2015
Hot Hydroforging for Lightweighting Presentation IDE 2015 Hot Hydroforging for Lightweighting Presentation IDE 2015
Hot Hydroforging for Lightweighting Presentation IDE 2015 Fluxtrol Inc.
 
Dashboard Thermal Analysis with HyperWorks
Dashboard Thermal Analysis with HyperWorksDashboard Thermal Analysis with HyperWorks
Dashboard Thermal Analysis with HyperWorksSimone Vizzini
 
Conformal cooling
Conformal coolingConformal cooling
Conformal coolingwebinliu
 
investigation of Cracking of the outer shroud component of a turbine blade
investigation of Cracking of the outer shroud component of a turbine bladeinvestigation of Cracking of the outer shroud component of a turbine blade
investigation of Cracking of the outer shroud component of a turbine bladeMohammad Rizwan Khan
 
En Pres Cryogenic 0710 V2
En Pres Cryogenic 0710 V2En Pres Cryogenic 0710 V2
En Pres Cryogenic 0710 V2eurolinx
 
Hot Hydroforging of Lightweight Bilateral Gears and Hollow Products
Hot Hydroforging of Lightweight Bilateral Gears and Hollow ProductsHot Hydroforging of Lightweight Bilateral Gears and Hollow Products
Hot Hydroforging of Lightweight Bilateral Gears and Hollow ProductsFluxtrol Inc.
 

Similar to Project 8 Summary (20)

Engineering and Design Webinar - September
Engineering and Design Webinar - SeptemberEngineering and Design Webinar - September
Engineering and Design Webinar - September
 
MEC441 - Solar Panel Cooling System
MEC441 - Solar Panel Cooling SystemMEC441 - Solar Panel Cooling System
MEC441 - Solar Panel Cooling System
 
Farzad Mirshams, Mechanical / Thermal Engineer
Farzad Mirshams, Mechanical / Thermal EngineerFarzad Mirshams, Mechanical / Thermal Engineer
Farzad Mirshams, Mechanical / Thermal Engineer
 
Engineering & Design - January
Engineering & Design - JanuaryEngineering & Design - January
Engineering & Design - January
 
Engineering & Design - April
Engineering & Design - April Engineering & Design - April
Engineering & Design - April
 
Chapter 7: Fluxtrol Induction Heating Case Studies and Success Stories
Chapter 7:  Fluxtrol Induction Heating  Case Studies and Success StoriesChapter 7:  Fluxtrol Induction Heating  Case Studies and Success Stories
Chapter 7: Fluxtrol Induction Heating Case Studies and Success Stories
 
Pipe Support Engineering & Design - June
Pipe Support Engineering & Design - JunePipe Support Engineering & Design - June
Pipe Support Engineering & Design - June
 
0.8um-0.9Tip-13Low
0.8um-0.9Tip-13Low0.8um-0.9Tip-13Low
0.8um-0.9Tip-13Low
 
Chinese Curtainwall Manufacturers Review_Liang Gong
Chinese Curtainwall Manufacturers Review_Liang GongChinese Curtainwall Manufacturers Review_Liang Gong
Chinese Curtainwall Manufacturers Review_Liang Gong
 
Final Portfolio
Final PortfolioFinal Portfolio
Final Portfolio
 
Est group harbin urea conference 2014 pap paper v1 english
Est group harbin urea conference 2014 pap paper v1 englishEst group harbin urea conference 2014 pap paper v1 english
Est group harbin urea conference 2014 pap paper v1 english
 
Engineering & Design of Pipe Supports
Engineering & Design of Pipe SupportsEngineering & Design of Pipe Supports
Engineering & Design of Pipe Supports
 
Hot Hydroforging for Lightweighting Presentation IDE 2015
Hot Hydroforging for Lightweighting Presentation IDE 2015 Hot Hydroforging for Lightweighting Presentation IDE 2015
Hot Hydroforging for Lightweighting Presentation IDE 2015
 
Devilllkevin
DevilllkevinDevilllkevin
Devilllkevin
 
Pipe Support Field Examples & Case Studies
Pipe Support Field Examples & Case StudiesPipe Support Field Examples & Case Studies
Pipe Support Field Examples & Case Studies
 
Dashboard Thermal Analysis with HyperWorks
Dashboard Thermal Analysis with HyperWorksDashboard Thermal Analysis with HyperWorks
Dashboard Thermal Analysis with HyperWorks
 
Conformal cooling
Conformal coolingConformal cooling
Conformal cooling
 
investigation of Cracking of the outer shroud component of a turbine blade
investigation of Cracking of the outer shroud component of a turbine bladeinvestigation of Cracking of the outer shroud component of a turbine blade
investigation of Cracking of the outer shroud component of a turbine blade
 
En Pres Cryogenic 0710 V2
En Pres Cryogenic 0710 V2En Pres Cryogenic 0710 V2
En Pres Cryogenic 0710 V2
 
Hot Hydroforging of Lightweight Bilateral Gears and Hollow Products
Hot Hydroforging of Lightweight Bilateral Gears and Hollow ProductsHot Hydroforging of Lightweight Bilateral Gears and Hollow Products
Hot Hydroforging of Lightweight Bilateral Gears and Hollow Products
 

Project 8 Summary

  • 1. Project 8: Summary of Work By: Callum Lamb
  • 2. Summary of Work  Major Projects:  Cell Design  Getter Design & Support Structure  Insert Support Structure & Heat Analysis  Window Gasket Seal Test and Simulations  Side Projects:  Learning Thermal Stress Analysis  KATRIN Project  Cryocooler Repair
  • 3. Cell Design:  Design Features:  Gold gasket sealed OR soldered gas line  Screws directly into bus bar for stability (6 screws)  Symmetric window seals for consistency.  10 cm of space for adaptability in coil winding
  • 4. Getter System Design:  Design Features:  Cube at center minimizes space requirement and removes need for custom attachment piece.  Includes filler valve & Ion gauge in assembly  Getter contained within standard CF nipple  Feedthrough to power getter  Each component is easily accessible.  Fits within large iso cross, close to insert.
  • 5. Getter Support Structure & Gas Line:  Design Features:  Supported by ‘blank flange’ piece  Combines blank, gas line input & support structure  Very Stable – Stainless Steel  Leaves majority of iso cross open.  Does not block bore.  Gas line remains close to insert
  • 6. Insert Support Structure  Design Features:  Adequate Thermal barrier between bus bar and iso cross (confirmed in MATLAB)  Lower Ring, attachment piece & pipes made of G-10  High structural stability: Pipes allow essentially no flex or vibration  Screws directly into bus bar  Applies both upwards & downwards force to insert from iso cross.
  • 8. Test Seal Preparation:  Prepared the test apparatus to begin mechanical testing of the gold gasket seal.  Modified previous pieces in the shop to allow us to attach the cold plate and test cell together inside the iso cross.  For this purpose, created the bracket plate with Martin.  Apparatus: • Helium supply (bottom left), • Temperature sensor (bottom right), • Cold plate (upper right), • Test cell (right middle)
  • 9. First Test- Corner Seal  We initially tested the corner seal design, as shown (sapphire window).  First tested this at room temperature, then decided to go straight to a face seal.  Unsuccessful initially- the gold gasket was too large.  Once the correct gasket was used, the seal was successful.
  • 10. Mechanical Simulation: Sapphire Window  Digging more into AutoCAD Inventor, I used in-CAD NASTRAN to perform mechanical simulations of the window under the stress required to compress the gold gasket.  Performed Face Seal (Upper) & Corner seal (Lower) stress analysis  Most realistic constraints:  Gasket contact surface is axial constrained  Opposing surface is where force is applied  Cylindrical side is constrained in the radial directions.  Conclusion: Force Required for Gasket compression will not break sapphire window.
  • 11. Face Seal Test: Setup  Cell is sealed with alternating aluminum & titanium screws to alternatively provide compression during cold & hot cycling.  Cell is fastened to cold plate inside of iso cross, with temperature sensors attached with Kapton tape.  For initial heat cycle, heating rope is wrapped around the outer iso cross.  Full setup with leak checker attached & helium input (bottom left).
  • 12. Face Seal Test: Conclusion  Peter and I ran the hot and then cold cycle multiple times.  Conclusion: The face seal for the sapphire window reasonably seals for the required temperature range.  Curve in Leak rate at the end: Peter removed and replaced helium source  Leak rate approx. 1.0E-08. Leak checker is quite old… Heat damage to bracket plate: Cooling with liquid nitrogen:
  • 13. Mechanical Simulation & Test: Calcium Fluoride Window  Using the same constraints, I did an analysis for the CaF2 windows.  Maximum force (0.5” OD, 0.396” Bore, 0.45 O-Ring) is 265 Ibs.  Is this sufficient for gold ring compression?  Previously estimated about 500 Ibs of force is required, currently trying to confirm that with simulations, but proving difficult.  Put CaF2 in previous setup – very quickly broke windows.  Take away: Surface was rough from failed soldering attempt- surface roughness is a stress amplifier.  Result: Back the window with a Kapton ring
  • 14. Future Work For CaF2 Test Seal:  Once modified test cell & window holder (accurately simulates final design) are received from the shop, Peter and I will perform that test.  Room temperature- If successful continue to heat loading  If Unsuccessful we’ll need to visit other options, such as sealing between the window holder and cell faces, which relieves the compressive force from the window.  Work on simulations using a different software- Simulation Mechanical from AutoCAD to model gold gasket compression force requirement.
  • 16. Thank You!  Thank everyone in this project, you’ve all made my time here a wonderful experience, full of learning and growth.  A special thank you to Martin, who’s taught me an incredible amount, Hamish who has been constantly supportive, and Jared for getting me in here in the first place.