Ashish Dhawan, founder of Central Square Foundation, examines the role technology can plan in improving student learning, teacher training, and accountability systems. Presentation given at a meeting of education leaders in the Bay Area.
2. Indian K-12 Education System
Desperate need for innovative and scalable solutions
Source: DISE, 2011-12 Provisional; ASER 2012; NCERT Study; BCG Study
• Shortage of 1.5 mm teachers
• 90+% qualified candidates did not pass a teacher eligibility
test
• 25% teacher absenteeism
1.3 mm
Schools
8 mm
Teachers
240 mm
Students
• 2-3 grade levels behind by the end of primary education
• ~50% enrolled in high school
• Strong culture of post-school support from tutors
• 97+% gross enrolment ratio in primary schools
• Fragmented system with small average school size
• Government’s focus shifting towards learning outcomes
3. Public and Private Schools
Large migration from public to private schools
Source: DISE, 2011-12 Provisional; ASER 2012; NCERT Study
Government Private
Student Penetration by school type 2012
33%
67%
• 50+% students in urban areas and 25% in rural areas go to private schools
• Migration from public to private schools at the rate of 1-2% points/year
• English medium schools expected to grow at 15% from 64,000 in 2011 to 127,000 in 2016
Government
80%
Private 20%
1.3 mm schools by type (in %) 2012
4. Government
59%
Private 41%
Indian Education Market
ICT/e-Learning expected to grow at CAGR of 70%
Source: Tata Strategic Management Group
Government
64%
Private 36%
Growth in Private Education Market
$175 bn in 2015E$100 bn in 2011
Total Education Spend
5. Quality Student Learning
Personalized with high engagement
1
Excellence in Teacher Education
Scalable and high impact teacher training
2
Efficient School Management Systems
Effective utilization of resources based on real-time data
3
Robust Accountability Systems
Impact with sharper measurement
4
Ed-Tech Promise
Change the way India learns, teaches and measures performance
6. India Education Technology Landscape
Various models emerging in the ecosystem
Student Learning
Learning Resources
Assessments
Learning Management & Social Learning Systems
Teacher Training
and Instruction
ICT Training
ICT Tools
Collaborative Networks
Administration
Student Information Systems
ERP for Schools
Devices
Laptop, Tablet, Mobile, TV, Projector and Radio
Learning
Approaches
Blended Learning
Open
Educational
Resources
System Accountability
Data Portals
8. Mobile Phones
India will be the third largest smart phone market in 2017
Source : TRAI, July 2012; IDC Worldwide, CSF Research
Emerging Adoption Models
• 3 minute audio English lessons and SMS
quizzes in Bangladesh
• On-demand, mobile Math tutoring in
South Africa
• Airtel provides educational content at
daily subscription in India
• Mobilink-UNESCO program in Pakistan
using mobiles to increase literacy skills
906 mm
Total
Subscribers
$80
Entry-level
Smartphone
New education models emerging to leverage the large base of mobile users
8%
92%
46%
54%
Smartphone
Feature phones
Mobile phone sales (by units)
2012
228 mm
2017E
335 mn
9. Tablets
Explosion expected with tablet prices coming down
Source : Research and Markets 2013; Frost and Suvillian; Cybermedia Research
Government Initiatives: Aakash
• Android-based tablet, Aakash IV under
R&D
• Discounted bulk price of $50 for
schools and colleges
• Exclusive marketplace for content &
solutions
Adoption Models
• Budget schools finding tablets less
expensive and more useful for learning
• Tablets bundled with LMS, content,
and personalized learning tools
• Content aligned with school syllabus
• Hindi OS interface introduced
0.31
3
6
33
0
10
20
30
40
2011 2012 2013E 2016E
Sales (in mm)
Tablets will be the preferred education
device in 5-7 years
Samsung
25%
Micromax
14%
Apple
9%
Others
52%
Market Landscape 2012
70
Total
Vendors
10. Connectivity
Critical for adoption of education technology
Source : National Knowledge Network; Office of Public Information Infrastructure and Innovations; IMRB Research
Government Initiatives
• $4.2 bn Optic Fiber project to connect
25,000 villages
• 980 of 1500 Higher Education
Institutions connected under
Knowledge Network. Next phase is K-
12 schools
2012 2017 2020
15 mm
175 mm
600 mm
Broadband Penetration Target
Commercial Initiatives
• Ubiquitous 4G roll-out in 2-3 years
• In absence of connectivity, content
distribution through SD Cards, USB etc.
4.1
17.6
35.7
47.1
92.9
130.6
164.8
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014E 2015E
Mobile Internet Users (in mm)
12. B2B Schools
High market potential with both government and private schools
Source: Industry discussions, World Bank Info Dev, CSF research and analysis
* Only private schools. These estimates are based on our current understanding and the actual numbers may vary
Private Schools
• Highly fragmented ICT landscape
• ~20% penetration in addressable
market of 100,000 schools
• Smart boards used more as a
marketing tool than an educating tool
• Low-cost variants available
Government Schools
• ICT @ Schools Scheme launched to set
up computer labs
• Hardware utilization is low
Hardware platform exists for new content creators
13. • Emerging market space with a large number of small size players
• High perception value of digital content
• Micro-scale content available in form of lesson, subject, grade etc.
• Use of many distribution channels, including USB drive, SD card, tablet etc.
• Use of telemarketing to drive sale conversion
B2C Content
Strong demand for direct-to-student models
B2C Content Landscape
Cloud/Offline Providers Publishers bundling content• Largest online portal for K-12 in India
• 4 million registrations
• 100,000 paid customers
• 7500 videos, 3000 tests, 500 games
and 100 experts
Source : Interaction with industry players, CSF analysis
Supplemental content and test prep space are ripe for disruption in B2C content space
14. Open Educational Resources (OER)
Need high quality local OER to avoid the Peru OLPC experience
India OER landscape
Source : CSF analysis, meetings with stakeholders
• OER mostly available in English; limited content in Indian languages
• Need OER mapped to curriculum
• Textbooks from NCERT, India’s largest K-12 publisher, available online for free
• Use of many distribution channels, including tablet, SD card, USB, CD ROM etc.
• Adoption in schools still a challenge because of poor ICT training for teachers
Opportunity to activate and streamline the OER environment in India
15. National Institute of Open Schooling (NIOS)
Potential to make NIOS a leading Virtual School
Source: National Institute of Open Schooling, Innosight Institute, Florida Virtual School
Florida Virtual School
• Largest online school in the US
• 130,000 enrolments across K-12
• Focused at children who are home
schooled, attend low performing
schools etc.
• More than 110 courses
• Little or no face-to-face interaction
between teachers and students
• Offers Franchise Program
National Institute of Open Schooling
• World’s largest open school
• 600,000 enrollments in Grade 9-12
• Focused at children who drop out
of traditional school for economic
or health reasons
• 38 courses
• Offline content delivery and contact
time through 2144 study centers
• 16 State level Open Schools
Could NIOS be leveraged to create the largest high school in the world?
17. • 13,867 Teacher Education Institutions
(TEIs) with capacity to train 1.1
million teachers annually
• 85% TEIs are private
• 35% teachers received in-service
training in 2009
• 55% teachers find in-service trainings
irrelevant
Teacher Education
Need for blended Teacher Education Institutions
IGNOU
• 3.5 mm students
• Ed School offers 3 programs
• Repository of digital learning content
• Webcast of lectures through TV
channels
• YouTube Channel with only 85 videos
• Network of study centers
Blended models can transform teacher education in India
18. Teacher Excellence
Online community of teachers picking up momentum
Subject Teacher Forum
• State-wide initiative for high
school teachers
• In-service subject-wise teacher training
• Trained 4000+ teachers in 1700 schools
• Covers computer skills, basic web 2.0
skills, open source software tools
• Online mailing groups
Karnataka Open Education Resources
• Participatory form of resource creation
• Sporadic efforts to build online
communities of teachers
• Secret behind Shanghai’s PISA results –
teacher study groups
• TES India’s online community for
teachers in India - 500,000 resources
• Over 400,000 teachers benefited from
TESSA resources in Africa
• Teachers of India offers resources and
online community forum in 5 languages
Technology based models emerging for building communities of teachers in India
20. School Management Software
Significant scope of improvement in school administrative functions
Some school management products
• Fragmented market with 200+ ERP products and low price points
• Products by large IT as well as niche companies
• Limited awareness about benefits of digital platforms among teachers
• Purchasing decision made by schools; large scale implementations by states
• Lack of teacher training makes adoption a challenge
• Need flexible, easy to implement solutions
Kerala – State wide SIS project
Source : Interaction with industry players, CSF analysis
School ERP space is crowded and difficult to monetize
22. Accountability Systems
Technology platforms can significantly improve accountability systems
National Institute of Smart Governance
(NISG) is helping government build
accountability in School Education
Source: Core Scope Document, NISG for MHRD
School Management
Learning Support
School Education Governance
• Student Lifecycle Services including
admissions, attendance, performance
• Digital teacher learning material for
LM and teacher training for ICT
• Teacher Life Cycle Management
Services
Some of the services piloted by
government:
Government is piloting new technology based initiatives to drive accountability
24. Blended Learning
Early stage pilots testing blended learning in India
Mindspark Centers, a blended learning pilot with low-income kids Other blended
learning pilots
Grade 6 Math in a
Chennai
government aided
School
Physics, Chemistry
and Math for Grade
12 in Chennai
After-school blended
learning centers for
Grade 9-12 in Mumbai
Source : Organization websites; Note: Mindspark Centers’ project is supported by CSF
Now Zaya
Many more blended learning pilots required to assess the potential in India
25. Critical Questions
How can we build an OER movement in India?
1
How can mobiles be leveraged to improve student learning?
3
What blended models could improve quality of teacher training?
2
What lessons in blended learning could be used in India?
4
How effective have the virtual schools been in the US?
5