SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 27
What Egyptian employees
want to be motivated?
Presented by: Group A
Presented to: Dr. Hesham Sadek
Agenda
Introduction
Our research process
Conclusion
Recommendation
Agenda
Introduction
Our research process
Conclusion
Recommendation
What is motivation ?
The word motivation stems from the Latin word "movere" which means to
move. Your motivation level is what moves you to participate in an activity and it
affects your desire to continue the activity.
Motivation & Productivity in the
Workplace
 Most employees need motivation to feel good about their jobs and for optimal
performance .
 Some employees are money motivated while others find recognition and
rewards personally is a proper motive for them.
 Motivation levels within the workplace have a direct impact on employee
productivity.
 Workers who are motivated and excited about their jobs carry out their
responsibilities to the best of their ability and production numbers increase as a
result.
The effect of motivation in the workplace?
 Decrease turnover ..... Leads to stability of work force.
 Increase labor productivity...... Leads to achievement of organizational goals.
 Motivation will....... lead to an optimistic and challenging attitude at work place.
That’s Why we will conduct a research about
What Egyptian employees want to be motivated?
Agenda
Introduction
Our research process
Conclusion
Recommendation
Research process
• Research objective .
• Target Segments.
• Sample Size.
• Survey Channels.
• Survey Design.
• Pre-testing.
• Distributing Survey.
• Data Analysis.
Research Objective
To identify new possibilities for increasing human resources motivation for
supporting more sustainable organizational development by determining the
most motivating elements for each group stage.
Target Segment
o All level employees:
 Senior level, Middle level, junior employees, etc…
o Age groups:
From 20 to 30
From 30 to 40
From 40 to 50
Above 50
o Organization type :
Government offices
Local companies
Multinational organization.
Sample Size
Our sample size is 1000
• From 20 to 30 ( 35%)
• From 30 to 40 ( 30 %)
• From 40 to 50 (20%)
• Above 50 (15%)
Survey Channels
“But the pilot survey has been Face to Face only to get the accurate feedback “
Mail
Face To Face
Social Media
Survey design
 Our Survey design separated into three parts:
1. Respondents profile.
2. Factors description.
3. Factors Ranking.
 We use : Cumulative Scale questions.
Pre-testing
 We did a pilot survey of 73 survey.
 All of them were face to face to get the most accurate feedback.
 We did some adjustments according to the feedback from the responds.
Adjustment points
Before After
Q3
What helps you feel included ? We added “ your opinion matters”
Q4 Rate how your job security affects your productivity &
performance ?
We add “ Stability ”
Q8 Dose the company’s clear and fair policies and procedures
ensure your commitments towards the company ?
We add “ code of conduct / business
guidelines”
Q10 How you can be appreciated? (Choose one or more) What is the kind of appreciation which satisfy
your needs
Survey Design
• Our final form of the survey :The Questionaire.docx
Survey distribution
• Target reach : 600 survey
• Face to face : ( for over 50 age group ) 67 survey
• Online survey : From 20 to 30 : 173 survey
From 31 to 40: 107 survey
From 41 to 50: 84 survey
Over 50 : 12 survey
Achieved : 443 survey
Gender: 73% males 27% females
Org type: Governmental 11% Local private 63% multinational 26%
Data analysis
Good Wages
15%
Promotion and growth
9%
Appreciation
8%
Intresting work
26%
sympathetic help
11%
being included
9%
Good working condition
10%
loyalty to employees
6%
tactful desciplne
2%
Job security
4%
From 20 to 30
Good Wages Promotion and growth Appreciation Intresting work sympathetic help
being included Good working condition loyalty to employees tactful desciplne Job security
Data analysis
Good Wages
26%
Promotion and growth
14%
Appreciation
10%
Intresting work
8%
sympathetic help
2%
being included
13%
Good working condition
6%
loyalty to employees
7%
tactful desciplne
2%
Job security
12%
From 31 to 40
Good Wages Promotion and growth Appreciation Intresting work sympathetic help
being included Good working condition loyalty to employees tactful desciplne Job security
Data analysis
Good Wages
26%
Promotion and growth
9%
Appreciation
10%
Intresting work
7%
sympathetic help
2%
being included
11%
Good working condition
4%
loyalty to employees
5%
tactful desciplne
10%
Job security
16%
From 41 to 50
Good Wages Promotion and growth Appreciation Intresting work sympathetic help
being included Good working condition loyalty to employees tactful desciplne Job security
Data analysis
Good Wages
17%
Promotion and growth
7%
Appreciation
10%
Intresting work
5%
sympathetic help
1%
being included
10%
Good working condition
9%
loyalty to employees
7%
tactful desciplne
11%
Job security
23%
Over 50
Good Wages Promotion and growth Appreciation Intresting work sympathetic help
being included Good working condition loyalty to employees tactful desciplne Job security
Data analysis
Good Wages
21%
Promotion and growth
10%
Appreciation
9%
Intresting work
12%
sympathetic help
4%
being included
11%
Good working condition
7%
loyalty to employees
6%
tactful desciplne
6%
Job security
14%
Total
Good Wages Promotion and growth Appreciation Intresting work sympathetic help
being included Good working condition loyalty to employees tactful desciplne Job security
Conclusion
Recommendation
Thank You
Any Questions

More Related Content

What's hot

Using Data to (Continuously) Develop a Culture First Onboarding Experience
Using Data to (Continuously) Develop a Culture First Onboarding ExperienceUsing Data to (Continuously) Develop a Culture First Onboarding Experience
Using Data to (Continuously) Develop a Culture First Onboarding ExperienceCulture Amp
 
Recruiting the Top Graduate Talent
Recruiting the Top Graduate TalentRecruiting the Top Graduate Talent
Recruiting the Top Graduate TalentTALiNT Partners
 
How employee engagement drives productivity
How employee engagement drives productivityHow employee engagement drives productivity
How employee engagement drives productivityMark Beatson
 
What the *Bleep* Is Employee Experience?
What the *Bleep* Is Employee Experience? What the *Bleep* Is Employee Experience?
What the *Bleep* Is Employee Experience? Limeade
 
Three insights that will define your recruiting strategy in 2017 | Talent Con...
Three insights that will define your recruiting strategy in 2017 | Talent Con...Three insights that will define your recruiting strategy in 2017 | Talent Con...
Three insights that will define your recruiting strategy in 2017 | Talent Con...LinkedIn Talent Solutions
 
Harrison Assessments Talent Soultions Benchmarking brochure
Harrison Assessments Talent Soultions Benchmarking brochure   Harrison Assessments Talent Soultions Benchmarking brochure
Harrison Assessments Talent Soultions Benchmarking brochure CHRISTINE COATES
 
5 Eye-Opening HR Stats: Why Employee Recognition Matters [INFOGRAPHIC]
5 Eye-Opening HR Stats: Why Employee Recognition Matters [INFOGRAPHIC]5 Eye-Opening HR Stats: Why Employee Recognition Matters [INFOGRAPHIC]
5 Eye-Opening HR Stats: Why Employee Recognition Matters [INFOGRAPHIC]Achievers
 
Why Engagement Matters: Change Your Culture, Change Your Bottom Line
Why Engagement Matters: Change Your Culture, Change Your Bottom LineWhy Engagement Matters: Change Your Culture, Change Your Bottom Line
Why Engagement Matters: Change Your Culture, Change Your Bottom Linesparcedge
 
Employee Success Obstacle Course Infographic
Employee Success Obstacle Course InfographicEmployee Success Obstacle Course Infographic
Employee Success Obstacle Course InfographicAchievers
 
#FIRMday Manchester 25th Feb 2016 - Glass door ‘Build an Employee Engagement ...
#FIRMday Manchester 25th Feb 2016 - Glass door ‘Build an Employee Engagement ...#FIRMday Manchester 25th Feb 2016 - Glass door ‘Build an Employee Engagement ...
#FIRMday Manchester 25th Feb 2016 - Glass door ‘Build an Employee Engagement ...Emma Mirrington
 
Performance Accelerated
Performance AcceleratedPerformance Accelerated
Performance AcceleratedO.C. Tanner
 
Foundations of Success - Success through the eyes of advisors (May 2014)
Foundations of Success - Success through the eyes of advisors (May 2014)Foundations of Success - Success through the eyes of advisors (May 2014)
Foundations of Success - Success through the eyes of advisors (May 2014)Advisor Impact
 
Employee engagement in the UK
Employee engagement in the UKEmployee engagement in the UK
Employee engagement in the UKMark Beatson
 
Monster.com Power Resume Search
Monster.com Power Resume SearchMonster.com Power Resume Search
Monster.com Power Resume SearchMonster
 
Job Fit is The Key to Your Organization's Success
Job Fit is The Key to Your Organization's SuccessJob Fit is The Key to Your Organization's Success
Job Fit is The Key to Your Organization's SuccessInsights For Performance
 
The new world of people management
The new world of people management The new world of people management
The new world of people management Alex Kracov
 
I am management students of amity university
I am management students of amity universityI am management students of amity university
I am management students of amity universityrafu91
 

What's hot (20)

Using Data to (Continuously) Develop a Culture First Onboarding Experience
Using Data to (Continuously) Develop a Culture First Onboarding ExperienceUsing Data to (Continuously) Develop a Culture First Onboarding Experience
Using Data to (Continuously) Develop a Culture First Onboarding Experience
 
Recruiting the Top Graduate Talent
Recruiting the Top Graduate TalentRecruiting the Top Graduate Talent
Recruiting the Top Graduate Talent
 
How employee engagement drives productivity
How employee engagement drives productivityHow employee engagement drives productivity
How employee engagement drives productivity
 
What the *Bleep* Is Employee Experience?
What the *Bleep* Is Employee Experience? What the *Bleep* Is Employee Experience?
What the *Bleep* Is Employee Experience?
 
engage profile-print
engage profile-printengage profile-print
engage profile-print
 
Three insights that will define your recruiting strategy in 2017 | Talent Con...
Three insights that will define your recruiting strategy in 2017 | Talent Con...Three insights that will define your recruiting strategy in 2017 | Talent Con...
Three insights that will define your recruiting strategy in 2017 | Talent Con...
 
Harrison Assessments Talent Soultions Benchmarking brochure
Harrison Assessments Talent Soultions Benchmarking brochure   Harrison Assessments Talent Soultions Benchmarking brochure
Harrison Assessments Talent Soultions Benchmarking brochure
 
5 Eye-Opening HR Stats: Why Employee Recognition Matters [INFOGRAPHIC]
5 Eye-Opening HR Stats: Why Employee Recognition Matters [INFOGRAPHIC]5 Eye-Opening HR Stats: Why Employee Recognition Matters [INFOGRAPHIC]
5 Eye-Opening HR Stats: Why Employee Recognition Matters [INFOGRAPHIC]
 
Why Engagement Matters: Change Your Culture, Change Your Bottom Line
Why Engagement Matters: Change Your Culture, Change Your Bottom LineWhy Engagement Matters: Change Your Culture, Change Your Bottom Line
Why Engagement Matters: Change Your Culture, Change Your Bottom Line
 
Employee Success Obstacle Course Infographic
Employee Success Obstacle Course InfographicEmployee Success Obstacle Course Infographic
Employee Success Obstacle Course Infographic
 
#FIRMday Manchester 25th Feb 2016 - Glass door ‘Build an Employee Engagement ...
#FIRMday Manchester 25th Feb 2016 - Glass door ‘Build an Employee Engagement ...#FIRMday Manchester 25th Feb 2016 - Glass door ‘Build an Employee Engagement ...
#FIRMday Manchester 25th Feb 2016 - Glass door ‘Build an Employee Engagement ...
 
Performance Accelerated
Performance AcceleratedPerformance Accelerated
Performance Accelerated
 
Hidden Talent
Hidden TalentHidden Talent
Hidden Talent
 
Foundations of Success - Success through the eyes of advisors (May 2014)
Foundations of Success - Success through the eyes of advisors (May 2014)Foundations of Success - Success through the eyes of advisors (May 2014)
Foundations of Success - Success through the eyes of advisors (May 2014)
 
Employee engagement in the UK
Employee engagement in the UKEmployee engagement in the UK
Employee engagement in the UK
 
Monster.com Power Resume Search
Monster.com Power Resume SearchMonster.com Power Resume Search
Monster.com Power Resume Search
 
HR Pulse Infographic
HR Pulse InfographicHR Pulse Infographic
HR Pulse Infographic
 
Job Fit is The Key to Your Organization's Success
Job Fit is The Key to Your Organization's SuccessJob Fit is The Key to Your Organization's Success
Job Fit is The Key to Your Organization's Success
 
The new world of people management
The new world of people management The new world of people management
The new world of people management
 
I am management students of amity university
I am management students of amity universityI am management students of amity university
I am management students of amity university
 

Similar to What Motivate the Egyptian Employee

Engaging for succes - a story about employee engagement
Engaging for succes - a story about employee engagementEngaging for succes - a story about employee engagement
Engaging for succes - a story about employee engagementSD Worx Belgium
 
Culture U certification and lists 2020
Culture U certification and lists 2020 Culture U certification and lists 2020
Culture U certification and lists 2020 Kam Kazemi
 
Best Practices of Retention
Best Practices of RetentionBest Practices of Retention
Best Practices of RetentionLAWRENCE A
 
Purpose-in-Organisations-P- (2)
Purpose-in-Organisations-P- (2)Purpose-in-Organisations-P- (2)
Purpose-in-Organisations-P- (2)Jo Martens
 
The Science of Building Happier Higher Performing Teams - David Inglis
The Science of Building Happier Higher Performing Teams - David InglisThe Science of Building Happier Higher Performing Teams - David Inglis
The Science of Building Happier Higher Performing Teams - David InglisIAB Canada
 
Talent Management Best Practices
Talent Management Best PracticesTalent Management Best Practices
Talent Management Best PracticesHR VLZ
 
ASHAVI Employee Engagement Program
ASHAVI Employee Engagement ProgramASHAVI Employee Engagement Program
ASHAVI Employee Engagement ProgramDinh Thi Diem Thuy
 
The Future of Employee Engagement: HR’s Critical Role in Driving Business Out...
The Future of Employee Engagement: HR’s Critical Role in Driving Business Out...The Future of Employee Engagement: HR’s Critical Role in Driving Business Out...
The Future of Employee Engagement: HR’s Critical Role in Driving Business Out...Human Capital Media
 
Job hopping in IT Industry
Job hopping in IT IndustryJob hopping in IT Industry
Job hopping in IT IndustryJean Brenda
 
presentation on employee motivation
presentation on employee motivationpresentation on employee motivation
presentation on employee motivationFarazAli126
 
Interesting data on 2014 award winners
Interesting data on 2014 award winnersInteresting data on 2014 award winners
Interesting data on 2014 award winnersZweig Group
 
From “Yes, Let’s Do it” to “Yes, We Did It”: Ensuring Your Engagement Initiat...
From “Yes, Let’s Do it” to “Yes, We Did It”: Ensuring Your Engagement Initiat...From “Yes, Let’s Do it” to “Yes, We Did It”: Ensuring Your Engagement Initiat...
From “Yes, Let’s Do it” to “Yes, We Did It”: Ensuring Your Engagement Initiat...The HR Observer
 
Accenture Getting To Equal 2020 Research Presentation
Accenture Getting To Equal 2020 Research Presentation Accenture Getting To Equal 2020 Research Presentation
Accenture Getting To Equal 2020 Research Presentation accenture
 
HRIA 2014 Conference Presentation - Employee Engagement
HRIA 2014 Conference Presentation - Employee EngagementHRIA 2014 Conference Presentation - Employee Engagement
HRIA 2014 Conference Presentation - Employee EngagementTalentMap
 
CEB & LinkedIn: 2015 Global Recruiting Trends | Webcast
CEB & LinkedIn: 2015 Global Recruiting Trends | WebcastCEB & LinkedIn: 2015 Global Recruiting Trends | Webcast
CEB & LinkedIn: 2015 Global Recruiting Trends | WebcastLinkedIn Talent Solutions
 
Impact of motivation on employee performance
Impact of motivation on employee performanceImpact of motivation on employee performance
Impact of motivation on employee performanceMd. Mehadi Hassan Bappy
 
Employee Engagement - Ryan Gunhold
Employee Engagement - Ryan GunholdEmployee Engagement - Ryan Gunhold
Employee Engagement - Ryan GunholdRyan Gunhold
 

Similar to What Motivate the Egyptian Employee (20)

Engaging for succes - a story about employee engagement
Engaging for succes - a story about employee engagementEngaging for succes - a story about employee engagement
Engaging for succes - a story about employee engagement
 
Culture U certification and lists 2020
Culture U certification and lists 2020 Culture U certification and lists 2020
Culture U certification and lists 2020
 
Best Practices of Retention
Best Practices of RetentionBest Practices of Retention
Best Practices of Retention
 
Purpose-in-Organisations-P- (2)
Purpose-in-Organisations-P- (2)Purpose-in-Organisations-P- (2)
Purpose-in-Organisations-P- (2)
 
The Science of Building Happier Higher Performing Teams - David Inglis
The Science of Building Happier Higher Performing Teams - David InglisThe Science of Building Happier Higher Performing Teams - David Inglis
The Science of Building Happier Higher Performing Teams - David Inglis
 
Talent Management Best Practices
Talent Management Best PracticesTalent Management Best Practices
Talent Management Best Practices
 
ASHAVI Employee Engagement Program
ASHAVI Employee Engagement ProgramASHAVI Employee Engagement Program
ASHAVI Employee Engagement Program
 
The Future of Employee Engagement: HR’s Critical Role in Driving Business Out...
The Future of Employee Engagement: HR’s Critical Role in Driving Business Out...The Future of Employee Engagement: HR’s Critical Role in Driving Business Out...
The Future of Employee Engagement: HR’s Critical Role in Driving Business Out...
 
Job hopping in IT Industry
Job hopping in IT IndustryJob hopping in IT Industry
Job hopping in IT Industry
 
presentation on employee motivation
presentation on employee motivationpresentation on employee motivation
presentation on employee motivation
 
Interesting data on 2014 award winners
Interesting data on 2014 award winnersInteresting data on 2014 award winners
Interesting data on 2014 award winners
 
From “Yes, Let’s Do it” to “Yes, We Did It”: Ensuring Your Engagement Initiat...
From “Yes, Let’s Do it” to “Yes, We Did It”: Ensuring Your Engagement Initiat...From “Yes, Let’s Do it” to “Yes, We Did It”: Ensuring Your Engagement Initiat...
From “Yes, Let’s Do it” to “Yes, We Did It”: Ensuring Your Engagement Initiat...
 
Accenture Getting To Equal 2020 Research Presentation
Accenture Getting To Equal 2020 Research Presentation Accenture Getting To Equal 2020 Research Presentation
Accenture Getting To Equal 2020 Research Presentation
 
HRIA 2014 Conference Presentation - Employee Engagement
HRIA 2014 Conference Presentation - Employee EngagementHRIA 2014 Conference Presentation - Employee Engagement
HRIA 2014 Conference Presentation - Employee Engagement
 
SIP BVM.pptx
SIP BVM.pptxSIP BVM.pptx
SIP BVM.pptx
 
CEB & LinkedIn: 2015 Global Recruiting Trends | Webcast
CEB & LinkedIn: 2015 Global Recruiting Trends | WebcastCEB & LinkedIn: 2015 Global Recruiting Trends | Webcast
CEB & LinkedIn: 2015 Global Recruiting Trends | Webcast
 
Impact of motivation on employee performance
Impact of motivation on employee performanceImpact of motivation on employee performance
Impact of motivation on employee performance
 
Employee Engagement - Ryan Gunhold
Employee Engagement - Ryan GunholdEmployee Engagement - Ryan Gunhold
Employee Engagement - Ryan Gunhold
 
Engagement 2.0
Engagement 2.0Engagement 2.0
Engagement 2.0
 
Employee engagement, involvmemnt and empowerment (keterlibatan dan pemberdaya...
Employee engagement, involvmemnt and empowerment (keterlibatan dan pemberdaya...Employee engagement, involvmemnt and empowerment (keterlibatan dan pemberdaya...
Employee engagement, involvmemnt and empowerment (keterlibatan dan pemberdaya...
 

What Motivate the Egyptian Employee

  • 1. What Egyptian employees want to be motivated? Presented by: Group A Presented to: Dr. Hesham Sadek
  • 4. What is motivation ? The word motivation stems from the Latin word "movere" which means to move. Your motivation level is what moves you to participate in an activity and it affects your desire to continue the activity.
  • 5. Motivation & Productivity in the Workplace  Most employees need motivation to feel good about their jobs and for optimal performance .  Some employees are money motivated while others find recognition and rewards personally is a proper motive for them.  Motivation levels within the workplace have a direct impact on employee productivity.  Workers who are motivated and excited about their jobs carry out their responsibilities to the best of their ability and production numbers increase as a result.
  • 6. The effect of motivation in the workplace?  Decrease turnover ..... Leads to stability of work force.  Increase labor productivity...... Leads to achievement of organizational goals.  Motivation will....... lead to an optimistic and challenging attitude at work place.
  • 7. That’s Why we will conduct a research about What Egyptian employees want to be motivated?
  • 8.
  • 10. Research process • Research objective . • Target Segments. • Sample Size. • Survey Channels. • Survey Design. • Pre-testing. • Distributing Survey. • Data Analysis.
  • 11. Research Objective To identify new possibilities for increasing human resources motivation for supporting more sustainable organizational development by determining the most motivating elements for each group stage.
  • 12. Target Segment o All level employees:  Senior level, Middle level, junior employees, etc… o Age groups: From 20 to 30 From 30 to 40 From 40 to 50 Above 50 o Organization type : Government offices Local companies Multinational organization.
  • 13. Sample Size Our sample size is 1000 • From 20 to 30 ( 35%) • From 30 to 40 ( 30 %) • From 40 to 50 (20%) • Above 50 (15%)
  • 14. Survey Channels “But the pilot survey has been Face to Face only to get the accurate feedback “ Mail Face To Face Social Media
  • 15. Survey design  Our Survey design separated into three parts: 1. Respondents profile. 2. Factors description. 3. Factors Ranking.  We use : Cumulative Scale questions.
  • 16. Pre-testing  We did a pilot survey of 73 survey.  All of them were face to face to get the most accurate feedback.  We did some adjustments according to the feedback from the responds.
  • 17. Adjustment points Before After Q3 What helps you feel included ? We added “ your opinion matters” Q4 Rate how your job security affects your productivity & performance ? We add “ Stability ” Q8 Dose the company’s clear and fair policies and procedures ensure your commitments towards the company ? We add “ code of conduct / business guidelines” Q10 How you can be appreciated? (Choose one or more) What is the kind of appreciation which satisfy your needs
  • 18. Survey Design • Our final form of the survey :The Questionaire.docx
  • 19. Survey distribution • Target reach : 600 survey • Face to face : ( for over 50 age group ) 67 survey • Online survey : From 20 to 30 : 173 survey From 31 to 40: 107 survey From 41 to 50: 84 survey Over 50 : 12 survey Achieved : 443 survey Gender: 73% males 27% females Org type: Governmental 11% Local private 63% multinational 26%
  • 20. Data analysis Good Wages 15% Promotion and growth 9% Appreciation 8% Intresting work 26% sympathetic help 11% being included 9% Good working condition 10% loyalty to employees 6% tactful desciplne 2% Job security 4% From 20 to 30 Good Wages Promotion and growth Appreciation Intresting work sympathetic help being included Good working condition loyalty to employees tactful desciplne Job security
  • 21. Data analysis Good Wages 26% Promotion and growth 14% Appreciation 10% Intresting work 8% sympathetic help 2% being included 13% Good working condition 6% loyalty to employees 7% tactful desciplne 2% Job security 12% From 31 to 40 Good Wages Promotion and growth Appreciation Intresting work sympathetic help being included Good working condition loyalty to employees tactful desciplne Job security
  • 22. Data analysis Good Wages 26% Promotion and growth 9% Appreciation 10% Intresting work 7% sympathetic help 2% being included 11% Good working condition 4% loyalty to employees 5% tactful desciplne 10% Job security 16% From 41 to 50 Good Wages Promotion and growth Appreciation Intresting work sympathetic help being included Good working condition loyalty to employees tactful desciplne Job security
  • 23. Data analysis Good Wages 17% Promotion and growth 7% Appreciation 10% Intresting work 5% sympathetic help 1% being included 10% Good working condition 9% loyalty to employees 7% tactful desciplne 11% Job security 23% Over 50 Good Wages Promotion and growth Appreciation Intresting work sympathetic help being included Good working condition loyalty to employees tactful desciplne Job security
  • 24. Data analysis Good Wages 21% Promotion and growth 10% Appreciation 9% Intresting work 12% sympathetic help 4% being included 11% Good working condition 7% loyalty to employees 6% tactful desciplne 6% Job security 14% Total Good Wages Promotion and growth Appreciation Intresting work sympathetic help being included Good working condition loyalty to employees tactful desciplne Job security