SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 3
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
9 Big FAT Garment Liespresented by Barbara ZeinsPresident of Gerson & Gersonat the 2007 Annual Meeting of theAmerican Apparel Producers’ NetworkSanta Monica, CA<br />In August 2007, at our summit in Antigua, Guatemala, Barbara Zeins, President of Gerson & Gerson, gave a talk about Full Value Costing ideology in her own company. Towards the end of her talk, she showed us a slide she invented called “9 Big FAT Garment Lies”. Your personal ability to “get it”, that is, to take this list, learn it, internalize it, lead with it and define it to get and keep business is key to your company and your job. Why? Because its the truth and because the vast majority of your customers don’t know it and/or don’t believe it – and it shows in retail performance figures, for sure. <br /> <br />1. Vendors are substitutable – well, they aren’t. You can’t throw them away. Vendors are as different as brands and retailers. The spectrum of how to best define and categorize a vendor defies data collection. Its personal. We’ve learned this here from nearly 30 continuous years of being a cut/sew contractor-centric organization. You have to work with them on their merits, not those defined by their competitors or yours. (If you source your product strictly on the basis of lowest material and CMT costs, you will wind up producing in some very strange places and paying a very high cost.)<br /> <br />2. There is no cost in setting up a new vendor – baloney. It often costs over $100,000 to set up a new vendor. We know of one instance where a brand sent 4 people offshore for 4 months setting up a new vendor. The first order got screwed up a little and corporate dropped them. And THAT did not show up as an expense? We’ve seen where those who are hired to select vendors will switch a vendor and show on paper how much they saved doing so. They collect their bonus and move on to the next year. But if you look back, those “savings” only looked good on paper, not in fact.<br /> <br />3. Costs are linear, increasing in direct proportion to quantity produced – well, that was true on the early Ford auto assembly lines, but not in apparel. Most do not show their costs in the 85% of the steps in the cycle that precede actual cut and sew.  Its much more expensive to design new products today. (“The direct costs of making the garment compose less that 15% of the total number of operations (activities) and take up less than 15% of the manufacturing period, yet almost all importers exclude the remaining 85% of manufacturing costs from their calculations.”)<br /> <br />4. Last years performance is a good prediction of next year’s performance – maybe last month’s performance is, but not last year’s. (The hard fact. We are going through a transition that will interest historians centuries from now. Its partly a result of globalization, partly the digital revolution and the information based economy it spawns”, Geoffrey Colvin, Fortune Magazine, September 2006)<br /> <br />5. Your people are a variable cost -- when there is a downturn in business just lay them off - “job security” is an oxymoron today. The affects of this economy's all time low sales have not been felt yet, but there isn’t a buyer out there certain of their future. In the “good old days”, when some managers were actually old, when intuition and experience ruled relationships that had taken years to forge, the work got done. Today? Its “what have you done for me today?”.<br /> <br />6. Customization is always expensive – Not at FesslerUSA its not. The later you cut, the more you can adapt to what is selling. Maybe its not so cheap to change colors at the last minute, but as styles change, customizing by changing the cut at the last minute can make much more margin. <br /> <br />7. All costs are either fixed or variable – no, some costs are super-variable. They defy formularization. They come at you out of the blue dictated by forces unseen and unexpected. With margins so thin, these are the costs that gobble them. (“In most situations, SMDA expenses (selling, marketing, distribution,  administration) have become an increasing percentage of sales. They are not fixed costs. They are not even variable costs. They are super-variable costs”, Kaplan & Cooper, Cost & Effect)<br /> <br />8. As long as you are competitively priced you will survive – your stuff can be as cheap as possible and it still won’t sell. Some people won’t buy what you’re selling at any price. When you have garments selling at full margin, their cost is virtually irrelevant. (“Managers searched for cheaper suppliers, wherever they happened to be…purchased in bulk to obtain volume discounts, built large automated warehouses to house and move those purchases, and deployed extensive inventory control systems and scheduling resources to… expedite items… from unreliable suppliers”, Kaplan and Cooper, Cost and Effect)<br /> <br />9. The only way to lower product costs is through cheaper labor or materials – The more you know the real costs, the more you control the customer relationship. (“Direct labor based overhead allocation systems made sense 50-80 years earlier, when they were designed, because direct labor was then a high fraction of the company’s total manufacturing conversion costs”, Kaplan and Cooper, Cost and Effect)<br /> <br />
9 Big Fat Garment Lies
9 Big Fat Garment Lies

Más contenido relacionado

Ähnlich wie 9 Big Fat Garment Lies

Givaudan Flavors
Givaudan FlavorsGivaudan Flavors
Givaudan FlavorsBecki Roy
 
Burt’S Bees Case Analysis
Burt’S Bees Case AnalysisBurt’S Bees Case Analysis
Burt’S Bees Case AnalysisJennifer Reither
 
The everyday fallacies of marketing technology: doing it right versus doing i...
The everyday fallacies of marketing technology: doing it right versus doing i...The everyday fallacies of marketing technology: doing it right versus doing i...
The everyday fallacies of marketing technology: doing it right versus doing i...Drthomasbrand Limited
 
Essay On Comm 287 Study Guide
Essay On Comm 287 Study GuideEssay On Comm 287 Study Guide
Essay On Comm 287 Study GuideVeronica Sulaiman
 
Inside BGA Marketing Groups - AimcoR
Inside BGA Marketing Groups - AimcoRInside BGA Marketing Groups - AimcoR
Inside BGA Marketing Groups - AimcoRJohn Ziambras
 
Innovation Strategy &amp; Mangement Final Project V1.5
Innovation Strategy &amp; Mangement Final Project V1.5Innovation Strategy &amp; Mangement Final Project V1.5
Innovation Strategy &amp; Mangement Final Project V1.5coleyperry
 
Book 2nd Ed Excerpt # 2
Book 2nd Ed Excerpt # 2Book 2nd Ed Excerpt # 2
Book 2nd Ed Excerpt # 2Joe Piergrossi
 
2013 Powertrain Expo
2013 Powertrain Expo2013 Powertrain Expo
2013 Powertrain ExpoJordan Olivas
 
Price Discrimination At A Grocery Store
Price Discrimination At A Grocery StorePrice Discrimination At A Grocery Store
Price Discrimination At A Grocery StoreLeslie Thomas
 
MBO15_ReviewGuide
MBO15_ReviewGuideMBO15_ReviewGuide
MBO15_ReviewGuideTim Hickle
 
Executive Overview - Building the case for Customer Centricity
Executive Overview - Building the case for Customer CentricityExecutive Overview - Building the case for Customer Centricity
Executive Overview - Building the case for Customer CentricitySteve Towers, CEO and CPP Champion
 
What Happens When Marketing And Advertising Collides With Pop Culture
What Happens When Marketing And Advertising Collides With Pop CultureWhat Happens When Marketing And Advertising Collides With Pop Culture
What Happens When Marketing And Advertising Collides With Pop CultureSteve Olenski
 
How To Turn Your Million Dollar Idea Into A Reality Part 3
How To Turn Your Million Dollar Idea Into A Reality Part 3How To Turn Your Million Dollar Idea Into A Reality Part 3
How To Turn Your Million Dollar Idea Into A Reality Part 3king911
 
15 Ways to Increase Value
15 Ways to Increase Value15 Ways to Increase Value
15 Ways to Increase Valueguestadf0590
 
30 Ideas in 40 Minutes for Marketing in the Recession
30 Ideas in 40 Minutes for Marketing in the Recession30 Ideas in 40 Minutes for Marketing in the Recession
30 Ideas in 40 Minutes for Marketing in the RecessionDana Vanden Heuvel
 
How To Write A Descriptive Essay 14 Steps (With Pictu
How To Write A Descriptive Essay 14 Steps (With PictuHow To Write A Descriptive Essay 14 Steps (With Pictu
How To Write A Descriptive Essay 14 Steps (With PictuBrittany Jones
 

Ähnlich wie 9 Big Fat Garment Lies (20)

Givaudan Flavors
Givaudan FlavorsGivaudan Flavors
Givaudan Flavors
 
Burt’S Bees Case Analysis
Burt’S Bees Case AnalysisBurt’S Bees Case Analysis
Burt’S Bees Case Analysis
 
The everyday fallacies of marketing technology: doing it right versus doing i...
The everyday fallacies of marketing technology: doing it right versus doing i...The everyday fallacies of marketing technology: doing it right versus doing i...
The everyday fallacies of marketing technology: doing it right versus doing i...
 
Essay On Comm 287 Study Guide
Essay On Comm 287 Study GuideEssay On Comm 287 Study Guide
Essay On Comm 287 Study Guide
 
The innovation challenge
The innovation challengeThe innovation challenge
The innovation challenge
 
Inside BGA Marketing Groups - AimcoR
Inside BGA Marketing Groups - AimcoRInside BGA Marketing Groups - AimcoR
Inside BGA Marketing Groups - AimcoR
 
Innovation Strategy &amp; Mangement Final Project V1.5
Innovation Strategy &amp; Mangement Final Project V1.5Innovation Strategy &amp; Mangement Final Project V1.5
Innovation Strategy &amp; Mangement Final Project V1.5
 
Book 2nd Ed Excerpt # 2
Book 2nd Ed Excerpt # 2Book 2nd Ed Excerpt # 2
Book 2nd Ed Excerpt # 2
 
2013 Powertrain Expo
2013 Powertrain Expo2013 Powertrain Expo
2013 Powertrain Expo
 
Price Discrimination At A Grocery Store
Price Discrimination At A Grocery StorePrice Discrimination At A Grocery Store
Price Discrimination At A Grocery Store
 
Pricing rules
Pricing rulesPricing rules
Pricing rules
 
93.06.pricing rules
93.06.pricing rules93.06.pricing rules
93.06.pricing rules
 
When to say no 100302
When to say no 100302When to say no 100302
When to say no 100302
 
MBO15_ReviewGuide
MBO15_ReviewGuideMBO15_ReviewGuide
MBO15_ReviewGuide
 
Executive Overview - Building the case for Customer Centricity
Executive Overview - Building the case for Customer CentricityExecutive Overview - Building the case for Customer Centricity
Executive Overview - Building the case for Customer Centricity
 
What Happens When Marketing And Advertising Collides With Pop Culture
What Happens When Marketing And Advertising Collides With Pop CultureWhat Happens When Marketing And Advertising Collides With Pop Culture
What Happens When Marketing And Advertising Collides With Pop Culture
 
How To Turn Your Million Dollar Idea Into A Reality Part 3
How To Turn Your Million Dollar Idea Into A Reality Part 3How To Turn Your Million Dollar Idea Into A Reality Part 3
How To Turn Your Million Dollar Idea Into A Reality Part 3
 
15 Ways to Increase Value
15 Ways to Increase Value15 Ways to Increase Value
15 Ways to Increase Value
 
30 Ideas in 40 Minutes for Marketing in the Recession
30 Ideas in 40 Minutes for Marketing in the Recession30 Ideas in 40 Minutes for Marketing in the Recession
30 Ideas in 40 Minutes for Marketing in the Recession
 
How To Write A Descriptive Essay 14 Steps (With Pictu
How To Write A Descriptive Essay 14 Steps (With PictuHow To Write A Descriptive Essay 14 Steps (With Pictu
How To Write A Descriptive Essay 14 Steps (With Pictu
 

9 Big Fat Garment Lies

  • 1. 9 Big FAT Garment Liespresented by Barbara ZeinsPresident of Gerson & Gersonat the 2007 Annual Meeting of theAmerican Apparel Producers’ NetworkSanta Monica, CA<br />In August 2007, at our summit in Antigua, Guatemala, Barbara Zeins, President of Gerson & Gerson, gave a talk about Full Value Costing ideology in her own company. Towards the end of her talk, she showed us a slide she invented called “9 Big FAT Garment Lies”. Your personal ability to “get it”, that is, to take this list, learn it, internalize it, lead with it and define it to get and keep business is key to your company and your job. Why? Because its the truth and because the vast majority of your customers don’t know it and/or don’t believe it – and it shows in retail performance figures, for sure. <br /> <br />1. Vendors are substitutable – well, they aren’t. You can’t throw them away. Vendors are as different as brands and retailers. The spectrum of how to best define and categorize a vendor defies data collection. Its personal. We’ve learned this here from nearly 30 continuous years of being a cut/sew contractor-centric organization. You have to work with them on their merits, not those defined by their competitors or yours. (If you source your product strictly on the basis of lowest material and CMT costs, you will wind up producing in some very strange places and paying a very high cost.)<br /> <br />2. There is no cost in setting up a new vendor – baloney. It often costs over $100,000 to set up a new vendor. We know of one instance where a brand sent 4 people offshore for 4 months setting up a new vendor. The first order got screwed up a little and corporate dropped them. And THAT did not show up as an expense? We’ve seen where those who are hired to select vendors will switch a vendor and show on paper how much they saved doing so. They collect their bonus and move on to the next year. But if you look back, those “savings” only looked good on paper, not in fact.<br /> <br />3. Costs are linear, increasing in direct proportion to quantity produced – well, that was true on the early Ford auto assembly lines, but not in apparel. Most do not show their costs in the 85% of the steps in the cycle that precede actual cut and sew.  Its much more expensive to design new products today. (“The direct costs of making the garment compose less that 15% of the total number of operations (activities) and take up less than 15% of the manufacturing period, yet almost all importers exclude the remaining 85% of manufacturing costs from their calculations.”)<br /> <br />4. Last years performance is a good prediction of next year’s performance – maybe last month’s performance is, but not last year’s. (The hard fact. We are going through a transition that will interest historians centuries from now. Its partly a result of globalization, partly the digital revolution and the information based economy it spawns”, Geoffrey Colvin, Fortune Magazine, September 2006)<br /> <br />5. Your people are a variable cost -- when there is a downturn in business just lay them off - “job security” is an oxymoron today. The affects of this economy's all time low sales have not been felt yet, but there isn’t a buyer out there certain of their future. In the “good old days”, when some managers were actually old, when intuition and experience ruled relationships that had taken years to forge, the work got done. Today? Its “what have you done for me today?”.<br /> <br />6. Customization is always expensive – Not at FesslerUSA its not. The later you cut, the more you can adapt to what is selling. Maybe its not so cheap to change colors at the last minute, but as styles change, customizing by changing the cut at the last minute can make much more margin. <br /> <br />7. All costs are either fixed or variable – no, some costs are super-variable. They defy formularization. They come at you out of the blue dictated by forces unseen and unexpected. With margins so thin, these are the costs that gobble them. (“In most situations, SMDA expenses (selling, marketing, distribution,  administration) have become an increasing percentage of sales. They are not fixed costs. They are not even variable costs. They are super-variable costs”, Kaplan & Cooper, Cost & Effect)<br /> <br />8. As long as you are competitively priced you will survive – your stuff can be as cheap as possible and it still won’t sell. Some people won’t buy what you’re selling at any price. When you have garments selling at full margin, their cost is virtually irrelevant. (“Managers searched for cheaper suppliers, wherever they happened to be…purchased in bulk to obtain volume discounts, built large automated warehouses to house and move those purchases, and deployed extensive inventory control systems and scheduling resources to… expedite items… from unreliable suppliers”, Kaplan and Cooper, Cost and Effect)<br /> <br />9. The only way to lower product costs is through cheaper labor or materials – The more you know the real costs, the more you control the customer relationship. (“Direct labor based overhead allocation systems made sense 50-80 years earlier, when they were designed, because direct labor was then a high fraction of the company’s total manufacturing conversion costs”, Kaplan and Cooper, Cost and Effect)<br /> <br />