SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 16
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
ADDING VALUE THROUGH HUMAN
          RESOURCES: REORIENTING HUMAN
          RESOURCE MEASUREMENT TO DRIVE
          BUSINESS PERFORMANCE

                   Arthur K. Yeung and Bob Berman



                   Building upon the balanced scorecard framework, this article addresses three central is-
                   sues of human resource (HR) measurement: (1) Do HR practices impact business re-
                   sults? (2) How can HR practices add value to business performance? (3) What HR mea-
                   sures can drive business performance? Using Eastman Kodak as a case study, this article
                   identifies three paths through which HR practices contribute to business performance:
                   (1) by building organizational capabilities; (2) by improving employee satisfaction; and
                   (3) by shaping customer and shareholder satisfaction. Three clusters of measures are
                   proposed: internal operational HR measures, internal strategic HR measures, and ex-
                   ternal strategic HR measures. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
                                                                                                            s




                  Introduction                         oped, and existing HR measures are not prop-
                                                                                                            What is excep-
                                                       erly formulated to capture the impact of HR          tional about the
In our recent survey of 65 senior human re-            on business performance. As such, efforts to         HR function,
source (HR) executives in California, mea-             refocus HR may not be well positioned to op-         however, is that
surement of HR effectiveness and impact was            timize business performance.                         it is less prepared
ranked as the number one topic that HR ex-                  To stimulate discussion and thinking on         than many other
ecutives are most interested in exploring. As                                                               functions (such
                                                       this timely and vital topic, this article address-
business competition escalates and corporate                                                                as finance or
                                                       es three issues central to the HR–business           management
resources shrink, all staff functions (e.g., man-      performance relationship:                            information
agement information systems, finance, hu-                                                                   systems) to
man resources, and research and develop-                   1. Do HR practices make a difference in          quantify its im-
ment) are being pressured to demonstrate                      business results?                             pact on business
their value added and to refocus their re-                                                                  performance.
                                                           2. In what ways can HR practices add val-
sources for higher business leverage. Possible                ue to business performance?
outcomes of refocusing staff functions are                 3. What are the most appropriate HR
outsourcing, automation, elimination, and/or                  measures that drive business perfor-
downsizing in order to conserve scarce organi-                mance?
zational resources. The HR function is no ex-
ception to this challenge. What is exceptional             Building upon a balanced scorecard
about the HR function, however, is that it is          framework (Kaplan & Norton, 1992, 1993),
less prepared than many other functions (such          this article offers a framework highlighting
as finance or management information sys-              the paths through which HR practices can im-
tems) to quantify its impact on business per-          pact business performance. In general, it can
formance. Conceptual linkages between HR               be said that HR practices play three major
and business performance are not well devel-           roles: (1) building critical organizational capa-

Human Resource Management, Fall 1997, Vol. 36, No. 3, Pp. 321–335
  1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.                                                                    CCC 0090-4848/97/030321-15
322   •   HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997


                 bilities; (2) enhancing employee satisfaction;    whole rather than individual HR practices.
                 and (3) improving customer and shareholder        The synergy and congruence among HR prac-
                 satisfaction. Based on the framework, three       tices have an important impact on business
                 clusters of HR measures—internal opera-           performance. Third, these studies are quite ro-
                 tional measures, internal strategic measures,     bust as they examine sample firms within an
                 and external strategic measures—are suggest-      industry [e.g., the auto industry (MacDuffie &
                 ed to help the HR function demonstrate and        Krafcik, 1992), the steel minimill industry
                 drive its business contribution. Examples from    (Arthur, 1994)] and across multiple industries
                 Eastman Kodak, Sears, and Motorola are used       (Pfeffer, 1994), both within a region (Huselid,
                 to exemplify some innovative measures in          1995) and across the nation (Ostroff, 1995).
                 each cluster. Finally, implications for the HR        Building upon the premise that HR prac-
                 function are discussed.                           tices make a difference in business results, our
                      This article embodies three purposes: (1)    next challenging task is to offer a conceptual
                 to help HR professionals better articulate the    framework that outlines specific ways in
                 value of the HR function; (2) to specify the      which HR practices can exert an impact upon
                 paths through which HR can contribute to          business performance.
                 business performance; and (3) to stimulate
                 HR professionals to develop innovative HR
                 measures that can demonstrate the value                 How Can HR Practices Impact
                 added of HR practices, on the one hand, and                Business Performance?
                 drive business performance on the other.
                 While this article helps frame the HR mea-        To develop meaningful HR measures, a frame-
                 surement issue and helps propose a conceptu-      work is needed to outline how HR can impact
                 al framework, much more effort will clearly be    business performance. Based on the experi-
                 required to develop the exact HR measures         ence of Eastman Kodak, this article proposes
                 that address the unique needs of each com-        an integrative framework that builds upon a
                 pany.                                             balanced scorecard framework (Kaplan &
                                                                   Norton, 1992, 1993) and a strategic HR
                                                                   framework (Ulrich & Lake, 1990). While the
                        Does HR Make a Difference                  balanced scorecard framework defines what a
                           in Business Results?                    business should focus on, the strategic HR
                                                                   framework offers specific tools and paths to
                 To many HR functions, this is the fundamen-       identify how a firm can leverage its HR prac-
                 tal question. Without the conviction that HR      tices in order to succeed. In this section, we
                 does make a difference, HR professionals will     will first briefly review the balanced scorecard
                 not, and cannot, be motivated to develop HR       framework, then the strategic HR framework,
                 measures that drive business performance.         and finally the integrative framework.
                 Fortunately, in the last few years, several re-
                 search studies have reported some important
                 findings regarding the relationships between      Balanced Scorecard
                 HR and business performance (Arthur, 1994;
                 Huselid, 1995; MacDuffie & Krafcik, 1992;          The balanced scorecard framework defines
                 Ostroff, 1995; Pfeffer, 1994; U.S. Depart-        what it takes for a company to succeed. Popu-
                 ment of Labor, 1993). Table I summarizes the      larized by Robert Kaplan, a Harvard professor,
                 key findings of these studies in the area of      and his associate, David Norton (Kaplan &
                 HR–business performance relationships.            Norton, 1992, 1993), it has increasingly been
                      Several consistent themes emerge from        adopted by major companies such as Sears,
                 these exemplary studies of the HR–business        AT&T, Eastman Kodak, American Express,
                 performance relationship. First, HR practices     and Taco Bell. Simply put, two key premises
                 definitely make a difference in business re-      underlie the concept (Ulrich, 1997). First, for
                 sults, especially the use of HR practices that    businesses to succeed in the long run, the ex-
                 build employee commitment. Second, all of         pectations of three stakeholders—sharehold-
                 these studies examine the HR system as a          ers, customers, and employees—need to be
Adding Value through HR   •   323


 TABLE I   Summary of Major Research Studies in HR–Organizational Performance Relationships.

Research Studies           Methodology                                    Key Findings

MacDuffie &         • Studied 70 automotive      • Manufacturing facilities with “lean production systems”
Krafcik (1992)        assembly plants              are much higher in both productivity and quality than
                      representing 24              those with “mass production systems” (Productivity:
                      companies and 17             22 hours vs. 30 hours in producing a car; Quality 0.5
                      countries worldwide.         defects vs. 0.8 defects per 100 vehicles).
                                                 • While the HR strategy of a mass production system is
                                                   used to create a highly specialized and deskilled work-
                                                   force that supports a large-scale production process,
                                                   the HR strategy of a lean production system aims to
                                                   create a skilled, motivated, and flexible workforce that
                                                   can continuously solve problems.
                                                 • The success of a “lean production system” critically
                                                   depends on such “high-commitment” human resource
                                                   policies as the decentralization of production respon-
                                                   sibilities, broad job classification, multiskilling
                                                   practices, profit/gain sharing, a reciprocal psychological
                                                   commitment between firm and employees, employment
                                                   security, and a reduction of status barrier.
U.S. Department     • Summarized all major       Studies that demonstrate business impact by adopting
of Labor (1993)       research studies           the following high-performance work practices are
                      regarding the HR-firm      summarized:
                      performance                • Employee involvement in decision making.
                      relationship.              • Compensation (profit/gain sharing).
                                                 • Training programs.
                                                 • Constellation of high-performance work practices.
Pfeffer (1994)      • Identified the five top-   • Contradictory to traditional strategy literature, these
                      performing firms             five companies are neither in the right industry (based
                      (based on percentage         on Porter’s industry structure analysis) nor are they
                      of stock returns)            market leaders in these industries (based on Boston
                      between 1972 and             Consulting Group’s learning curve).
                      and 1992 and assessed      • Instead, these companies share a set of high commit-
                      their common                 ment work practices such as employment security,
                                                   selectivity in recruiting, high wages, incentive pay,
                                                   employee ownership, information sharing, participation
                                                   and empowerment, teams and job redesign, cross-
                                                   training, etc.
Arthur (1994)       • Conducted a survey         • Empirically identified two distinct HR configurations:
                      research from 30 U.S.        control and commitment systems.
                      steel minimills.           • Control systems aim to reduce direct labor costs, or
                                                   improve efficiency by enforcing employee compliance
                                                   with specified rules and procedures and basing
                                                   employee rewards on some measurable output criteria.
                                                 • Commitment systems aim to shape desired employee
                                                   behaviors and attitudes by forging psychological links
                                                   between organizational and employee goals.
                                                 • The mills with commitment systems had higher
                                                   productivity, lower scrap rates, and lower employee
                                                   turnover than those with control systems.
Huselid (1995)      • Utilized both survey       • Based on his sample, Huselid found that if firms
                      research and financial       increase their high-performance work practices by one
                      data of 968 firms.           standard deviation (SD), their turnover would be
                                                   reduced by 7.05%, productivity increased by 16%.
                                                                                                   continued
324   •   HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997


                   TABLE I   Continued

                             Research Studies Methodology        Key Findings

                                                                       • In terms of financial impact, a one-SD increase in high-
                                                                         performance work practices leads to a $27,044 increase
                                                                         in sales, a $18,641 increase in market value, and a
                                                                         $3,814 increase in profit.
                  Ostroff (1995)         • Conducted a survey         • Developed an overall HR Quality Index based on the
                                           research jointly sponsored   aggregate ratings of all HR activities adopted by a firm.
                                           by Society of Human        • Based on the HR Quality Index, firms are grouped
                                           Resource Management          into four categories based on their percentile (i.e.,
                                           and CCHIncorporated.         bottom 25%, second 25%, third 25%, and top 25%).
                                                                      • Firms that score higher in the HR Quality Index con-
                                                                        sistently outperform firms with a lower index in four
                                                                        financial measures: market/book value ratio, productiv-
                                                                        ity (i.e., sales/employees), market value, and sales.



                 satisfied. While a business may still succeed in          in employee growth and development. If even
                 the short run if it ignores the expectations of           one of the components breaks down, the sys-
                 one of the stakeholders, in the long run, its             tem cannot work.
                 business performance will suffer. Second, as                  The strength of the balanced scorecard
                 depicted in Figure 1, all three stakeholders are          framework is that it provides a simple concep-
                 interrelated. Employee attitudes and behav-               tual and diagnostic tool to ensure that compa-
                 iors impact the level of customer satisfaction            nies utilize the right processes and people to
                 and retention. In turn, customer attitudes and            drive customer and business performance.
                 behaviors influence shareholder satisfaction                  Figure 1 also lists how Sears, Eastman Ko-
                 and retention. Finally, shareholder satisfac-             dak, AT&T, and American Express make use of
                 tion affects employee satisfaction through                the balanced scorecard principle but with dif-
                 bonuses, stock options, or further investment             ferent terms. In spite of different labels and




                 FIGURE 1. Framework of a balanced scorecard.
Adding Value through HR    •   325


 TABLE II      Sears Measures in Operationalizing Balanced Scorecard.


                                            I. Compelling Place to Work

Attitudes about the job
      1.   I like the kind of work I do.
      2.   My work gives me a sense of accomplishment.
      3.   I am proud to say I work at Sears.
      4.   How does the amount of work you are expected to do influence your overall attitude toward the job?
      5.   How do your physical working conditions influence your overall attitude toward your job?
      6.   How does the way you are treated by those who supervise you influence your overall attitude about
           the job?
Attitudes about the company
      7.   I feel good about the future of the company.
      8.   Sears is making the changes necessary to compete effectively.
      9.   I understand our business strategy.
     10.   Do you see a connection between the work you do and the company’s strategic objectives?

                                           II. Compelling Place to Shop

1. Customer service.
2. Customer recommend products.
3. Customer loyalty.

                                          III. Compelling Place to Invest

1.   Revenue growth.
2.   Profit contribution margin.
3.   Sales per square feet.
4.   Inventory turnover.




measurement indices, the logic of the bal-                  more likely to visit Sears again and thus be re-     The Sears exam-
                                                                                                                 ple is distinctive
anced scorecard framework is quite similar in               tained as steady clientele. Through repeated         as it not only
all these companies.                                        shopping by loyal customers, Sears can then          translates “soft”
     It is intriguing to note that the ultimate             become a “Compelling Place to Invest,” as            business issues
power of the balanced scorecard framework                   productivity and financial results both attract      (people) into
does not lie in its conceptual elegance, but in             and retain shareholders. In order to make this       “hard” (financial
                                                                                                                 results), but also
its empirical validity. The following sections              model work, however, Sears understands that
                                                                                                                 identifies people
examine how the balanced scorecard frame-                   all senior managers must be evaluated on the         as the driver of
work is being validated at Sears and Eastman                basis of their performance on all three critical     business growth
Kodak.                                                      success factors, not just on financial results.      and success.
                                                            Their bonuses should also be significantly tied
Sears. As part of its transformation under the              to the measures in these critical factors. Table
new chief executive officer (CEO), Arthur                   II lists the measures used to track the perfor-
Martinez, Sears believes that “Compelling                   mance of managers at Sears.
Place to Work,” “Compelling Place to Shop,”                      To ensure that all senior managers “buy
and “Compelling Place to Invest” are three                  into” this model, Sears has undertaken an ex-
critical success factors that will in the long run          tensive and comprehensive study to assess
sustain the success of the company. The logic               whether the model is in fact working as it pre-
is simple: by creating a “Compelling Place to               dicts. In the first and second quarters of 1995,
Work,” associates’ behaviors will be changed                a Sears task force collected hard data from
in ways which, in turn, create a “Compelling                800 stores. It collected 300,000 data points
Place to Shop.” As a result, customers are                  and utilized vigorous statistical tools to assess
326   •   HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997


                 the strength of relationship among the three          50% based on “Compelling Place to Invest.”
                 critical success factors: “Compelling Place to        By restructuring the bonus system, Sears’ se-
                 Work,” “Compelling Place to Shop,” and                nior managers are encouraged to focus not
                 “Compelling Place to Invest.” The results,            only on the financial outcomes, but also on
                 though preliminary, are impressive. Sears re-         the process and capability that contribute to
                 ported that for every 5% improvement in asso-         such outcomes.
                 ciates’ behaviors, customer retention was in-
                 creased by 1.3%, revenues by 1.04%, and profit        Eastman Kodak. A similar transformation is
                 by 0.4%.                                              under way at Eastman Kodak since George
                      What does this mean to Sears? It means           Fisher became CEO. Eastman Kodak, tradi-
                 that if Sears succeeds in improving associates’       tionally a technologically driven company
                 behaviors by 5% (e.g., from 50% to 55%), its          which capitalized on its brand name, focused
                 revenue will be increased by $300 million             on customer satisfaction through technical in-
                 (Sears’s current revenue is approximately             novation to drive shareholder satisfaction. The
                 $230 billion)! It is also important to note that      implicit assumptions were that employee sat-
                 this enormous increase in revenue does not re-        isfaction could be achieved when the compa-
                 quire additional head count or payroll, but           ny was financially successful and that em-
                 simply an improvement in employee work en-            ployee satisfaction was a byproduct, not a
                 vironment. Moreover, line managers (not HR)           driver, of business success. Results from 1990
                 are critical to the creation of such a positive       to 1993 (please refer to Figure 2), however, re-
                 work environment.                                     vealed that customer satisfaction alone drove
                      The Sears example is distinctive as it not       neither market value nor employee satisfac-
                 only translates “soft” business issues (people)       tion.
                 into “hard” (financial results), but also identi-         While many factors may have contributed
                 fies people as the driver of business growth          to the declining performance of Eastman Ko-
                 and success. Based on the above logic and             dak from 1990 to 1993, George Fisher decid-
                 findings, the bonuses of all senior managers at       ed to restore employee satisfaction as the dri-
                 Sears are now tied to a measure called Total          ver for business success. As he strongly
                 Performance Index, of which 25% of the Index          expressed it: “We will never achieve total cus-
                 is based on “Compelling Place to Work,” 25%           tomer satisfaction without a much higher lev-
                 based on “Compelling Place to Shop,” and              el of employee satisfaction. . . . My funda-




                               FIGURE 2. Traditional paradigm of employee satisfaction at Eastman Kodak.
Adding Value through HR   •   327




             FIGURE 3. The new paradigm of employee satisfaction at Eastman Kodak.




mental responsibility is to make sure this is a          The balanced scorecard provides a useful
strong company and that the employees who            business framework that highlights what is re-
exist in this company have a great place to          quired for a company to succeed by meeting
work.” As a result, he instituted a new para-        the expectations of employees, customers, and
digm, using employee satisfaction to drive cus-      shareholders. The next critical questions are:
tomer satisfaction and then shareholder satis-       Given the balanced scorecard framework, how
faction. Along with other ongoing initiatives,       can the HR function add value to business
the new paradigm appears to be working.              success? What kinds of HR practices should
While employee satisfaction has increased            be designed to enhance business competitive-
about 80% from 1993 to 1995, the market val-         ness? In the next section, Eastman Kodak’s ex-
ue has also increased approximately 90% in           perience will be used to illustrate how HR can
the same period (please refer to Figure 3).          contribute to business competitiveness.
     It is naive, however, to claim that the in-
crease in Kodak’s market value is completely
attributable to the increase in employee satis-      Strategic HR Framework
faction. Causal relationship is also hard to es-
tablish without vigorous statistical analyses        Like many companies that attempt to align
and control (as in the case of Sears). Never-        HR practices with business strategy, Eastman
theless, the story of Eastman Kodak is power-        Kodak’s strategic HR framework involves
ful in two ways: (1) it illustrates how CEO          three components (Ulrich & Lake, 1990).
Fisher reconceptualizes the relationship             They are presented below, along with the most
among employees, customers, and sharehold-           pertinent questions a company could ask in its
ers to drive business success; and (2) it pro-       efforts to formulate plans for each compo-
vides some empirical support of how such a           nent.
paradigm shift can make a difference in busi-
ness performance. Eastman Kodak offers an-               1. Business strategy: What is the business
other story based on the balanced scorecard                 strategy of our company? How do we
principle of how companies use people to dri-               win in the marketplace based on cus-
ve their business performance.                              tomer buying criteria, competition,
328    •    HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997




                      FIGURE 4. Integrative model connecting strategic HR framework to key results areas.




                             government regulations, supplier situ-           Integrative Framework
                             ation, etc.?
                          2. Organizational capabilities: In order to         By integrating the strategic HR framework
                             implement the business strategy, what            with the business framework, the interrela-
                             are the critical organizational capabili-        tionships among the six components can be
                             ties we need to develop? Companies of-           identified in two linkage chains. In the first
                             ten target two or three organizational           chain, HR practice can be conceptualized as
                             capabilities that are critical but with          key drivers in building organizational capabil-
                             which they have not totally succeeded.           ities, enhancing employee satisfaction, and
                             These capabilities might include com-            more innovatively, shaping customer satisfac-
                             petitive shared mindset, speed to mar-           tion (Ulrich, 1989a; Ulrich & Lake, 1990). In
                             ket, innovation, etc.                            turn, both organizational capabilities and em-
                                                                              ployee satisfaction can impact customer satis-
                          3. Human resource practices: How should
                                                                              faction.
                             HR practices be designed and deliv-
                                                                                   In the second chain, organizational capa-
                             ered to build these organizational
                                                                              bilities become key drivers which implement
                             capabilities? Are our leaders and em-
                                                                              business strategy, impact customer satisfac-
                             ployees competent, motivated, and
                                                                              tion, and, eventually, contribute to sharehold-
                             empowered to contribute to the fullest
                                                                              er satisfaction. In addition, both business
                             extent in the development of these ca-
                                                                              strategy and customer satisfaction, if properly
                             pabilities?
                                                                              managed, should increase shareholder satis-
                          In summary, the strategic HR framework              faction.
The Kodak             aims to leverage and/or align HR practices to                The Kodak framework lays out three
framework lays        build critical organizational capabilities that         unique ways in which HR can contribute to
out three unique
                      enable Eastman Kodak to win in the market-              business success: building organizational ca-
ways in which
HR can con-           place.                                                  pabilities, enhancing employee satisfaction,
tribute to business       How can HR practices truly contribute to            and shaping customer satisfaction. While pre-
success: building     the critical business success factors as out-           vious research and case studies have suggest-
organizational        lined in the balanced scorecard framework?              ed the strategic relevance of HR in each of
capabilities,
                      What are the most viable and effective HR               these three areas, very few researchers have
enhancing
employee satisfac-    measures which can demonstrate the value                systematically addressed all three contribu-
tion, and shaping     added of the HR function? To think through              tions:
customer              the impact of HR practices on business, East-
satisfaction.         man Kodak has connected its strategic HR                     a. HR–organizational capability linkage:
                      framework to the business framework (see                        The thesis that HR practices should be
                      Figure 4).                                                      aligned to build organizational capabil-
Adding Value through HR   •   329


   ity was suggested by Schuler & Jackson               more successful; and (2) stronger rela-
   (1987) and Ulrich & Lake (1990). The                 tionships with key customers are estab-
   argument for this linkage is simple: if              lished. Another positive example of us-
   companies intend to compete based on                 ing HR to drive customer satisfaction is
   specific organizational capabilities (e.g.,          Southwest Airline. To ensure that its
   customer service for Nordstrom, inno-                crew members are customer-focused,
   vativeness for 3M, quality for Motoro-               the airline has been involving external
   la), they require a coherent set of HR               customers in selecting the crew force.
   practices to influence the mindset and               As a result, Southwest’s crew members
   behaviors of their leaders and work-                 tend to possess attributes that are de-
   force at all levels.                                 sired by customers.
b. HR–employee satisfaction linkage: The              The integrative model in Figure 4 is
   impact of HR practices on employee            unique in two ways. First, it tightly aligns the
   satisfaction has also been widely publi-      HR planning process with the business plan-
   cized through a well-known example of         ning process. For example, while the business
   New United Motor Manufacturing Inc.           framework (i.e., the balanced scorecard) high-
   (Pfeffer, 1994). In 1982, the GM Fre-         lights what Eastman Kodak needs to focus on
   mont facility was closed due to severe        in order to succeed, the strategic HR frame-
   employee problems. When approached            work provides specific tools and paths to iden-
   by Toyota for a joint venture, GM             tify how Eastman Kodak can leverage its HR
   agreed to reopen the facility in 1984         practices and organizational capabilities to
   under a new entity called New United          succeed. Thus, the integrative model provides
   Motor Manufacturing Inc. (NUMMI).             a simple but comprehensive roadmap for a
   Without moving to a new facility, in-         company to think through its strategic focus.
   vesting heavily in new technology, or         Second, the model helps senior line and HR
   hiring a new group of employees (85%          executives rethink the strategic roles within
   of NUMMI employees were rehired               corporations which can be played by HR prac-
   from the GM Fremont facility with the         tices. As human resources clearly have be-
   same UAW hierarchy), NUMMI was                come an important source of sustainable com-
   able to substantially improve employee        petitive advantage (Pfeffer, 1994; Huselid,
   satisfaction through radical changes in       1995), the model explicitly identifies the high
   human resource philosophy and prac-           value-added contribution of HR practices
   tices. The effects of these HR philoso-       within corporations.
   phy and practice changes were dramat-
   ic. Between 1982 and 1986, employee
   absenteeism was reduced from 20% to
                                                       What Are the New HR Measures
   2%; grievances decreased from 2000
                                                      that Drive Business Performance?
   per year to two per year; and strikes
   went from two–four times per year to          If HR practices can impact business success
   zero times per year. As a result, produc-     through building up organizational capabili-
   tivity was increased by 100%; cost was        ties, improving employee satisfaction, and
   reduced by 30%; and both quality and          shaping customer satisfaction, new HR mea-
   consumer satisfaction were enhanced           sures should be developed to drive business
   substantially.                                performance. As succinctly argued by Kaplan
c. HR–customer satisfaction linkage: Some        & Norton (1992, p. 71): “What you measure
   pioneering companies are leveraging           is what you get.” Unless HR measures are re-
   HR practices to drive customer satis-         aligned to drive the activities and behaviors of
   faction (Ulrich, 1989a). For instance,        HR professionals and line managers, HR prac-
   Baxter Healthcare has offered free con-       tices can hardly be expected to demonstrate
   sulting and training sessions for             any impact on the bottom line.
   its key customers. This has led to two             Dramatic changes in HR measures are ur-
   outcomes: (1) key customers become            gently required to refocus the priorities and re-
330   •   HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997


                 sources of the HR function. Instead of being               3. External strategic measures: How well
                 HR-driven (what makes sense to HR profes-                     do our HR practices increase customer
                 sionals), the next generation of HR measures                  and shareholder satisfaction?
                 needs to be business-driven (how HR can im-                Table III lists the possible combination
                 pact business success). Instead of being activ-        HR measures that can be developed to in-
                 ity-oriented (what and how much we do), new            crease efficiency, quality, and cycle time of HR
                 HR measures should be impact-oriented (how             practices; to build organizational capability;
                 much we improve business results). Instead of          and to enhance employee, customer, and
                 looking backward (what has happened), inno-            shareholder satisfaction. Examples in each
                 vative HR measures should be forward look-             cluster of HR measures are illustrated below.
                 ing, allowing managers to assess and diagnose
                 the processes and people capabilities that can
                 predict the future success of corporations (Ka-        Cluster 1: Internal Operational Measures
                 plan & Norton, 1992). Finally, instead of fo-
                 cusing on individual HR practices (the perfor-         This cluster of HR measures encompasses tra-
                 mance of staffing practices, training and              ditional HR measures for which the HR func-
                 development practices, etc.), future HR mea-           tion and HR professionals are (and have been
                 surement should focus on the entire HR sys-            in the past) held accountable. It focuses on
                 tem, taking into account the synergy existing          the efficiency, quality, and speed of delivering
                 among all HR practices.                                HR practices and managing the HR function
                      Based on the integrative model in Figure          as a whole.
                 4, Eastman Kodak has developed three clus-                  For HR practices, typical measures in-
                 ters of HR measures:                                   clude both process measures (such as cycle
                                                                        time, quality, and cost of HR processes/prac-
                      1. Internal operational measures: How             tices) and result measures (such as offer/ac-
                         well do we design and deliver our HR           cept ratios; different levels of training evalua-
                         practices?                                     tion such as reaction, knowledge, on-the-job
                      2. Internal strategic measures: How effec-        behaviors, and business impact) (Cascio,
                         tively do our HR practices build desired       1987; Fitz-enz, 1984; Ulrich, 1989b). For the
                         organizational capabilities? How effec-        HR function, typical evaluative measures in-
                         tively do our HR practices increase em-        clude the HR ratio (number of HR profes-
                         ployee satisfaction?                           sionals to employee population), the percent-


                   TABLE III   Developing New HR Measures that Drive Business Performance.

                                         Internal Operational         Internal Strategic              External Strategic
                      Clusters
                       of HR            Process      Outcome    Organizational     Employee       Customer      Shareholder
                      Measures          Measures     Measures    Capability       Satisfaction   Satisfaction   Satisfaction

                  Staffing
                  Training/
                  Development
                  Performance
                  appraisal
                  Rewards
                  system
                  Organization
                  design
                  Communications
                  Others
Adding Value through HR    •   331


age of HR expenses to operating expenses, and       tracking of aligned performance commit-
the results of the client satisfaction surveys,     ments, and employees’ surveys which include
etc.                                                questions that focus on management account-
     In short, these internal operational mea-      ability for performance, clarity of performance
sures track the activity, cost, and quality level   expectations, adequacy of performance feed-
of HR services. When corporations conceptu-         back, and reward of goal achievement.
alize the HR function as a cost center, these            To ensure that HR practices are meeting
measures make perfect sense (Wintermantel           employee needs and expectations, Motorola          As the HR func-
                                                                                                       tion is trans-
& Mattimore, 1997). As the HR function is           has developed an index called Individual Dig-
                                                                                                       formed to be
transformed to be more business oriented            nity Entitlement (Ulrich, 1997). Based on the      more business
(Yeung, Brockbank & Ulrich, 1994; Winter-           following six questions, the index directly af-    oriented (Yeung,
mantel & Mattimore, 1997), these traditional        fects the annual performance review and            Brockbank &
HR measures will no longer be adequate and          bonuses of Motorola managers:                      Ulrich, 1994;
                                                                                                       Wintermantel &
accurate means to assess the performance of             1. Meaningful job that contributes to mo-      Mattimore,
new HR roles and activities.                               tivation: Do you have a substantive,        1997), these
                                                           meaningful job that contributes to the      traditional HR
                                                                                                       measures will no
                                                           success of Motorola?
                                                                                                       longer be
Cluster 2: Internal Strategic Measures                  2. Behavior and knowledge to be success-       adequate and
                                                           ful: Do you have the on-the-job behav-      accurate means
The internal strategic HR measures assess the              iors and the knowledge base to be suc-      to assess the
effectiveness of HR practices in building or-                                                          performance of
                                                           cessful?                                    new HR roles
ganizational capabilities and enhancing em-
                                                        3. Training available to upgrade skills: Has   and activities.
ployee satisfaction. For instance, at Eastman
                                                           training been identified and been made
Kodak three critical organizational capabili-
                                                           available to continuously upgrade your
ties are identified, and specific HR measures
                                                           skills?
are developed to track the progress in these ca-
pabilities. The targeted organizational capa-           4. Career plan: Do you have a career plan
bilities include:                                          and is it exciting, achievable, and being
                                                           acted on?
    • Leadership effectiveness (both compe-
                                                        5. Feedback: Have you received candid,
      tency and diversity).
                                                           positive, or negative feedback within
    • Workforce competencies (in terms of                  the last 30 days which has been help-
      customer commitment and market fo-                   ful in improving your performance or
      cus, working across boundaries, finan-               achieving your career plan?
      cial excellence, and operational excel-
                                                        6. Personal Sensitivity: Is there appropri-
      lence).
                                                           ate sensitivity to your personal circum-
    • Performance-based culture.                           stances, gender, and cultural heritage
                                                           so that such issues do not distract from
     While Eastman Kodak uses 360-degree
                                                           your success?
assessment to measure leadership competen-
cy, it also tracks leadership diversity through         By tracking these six questions, Motorola
the race, gender, and nationality composition       can ensure that its HR practices are adding
of its senior and middle managers. Workforce        value through a more committed and compe-
competencies are measured by three aspects          tent workforce.
of the development process: (1) the percent-            Unlike internal operational measures, line
age of employees with documented develop-           managers should be held accountable for the
ment plans to develop required competencies;        internal strategic measures. As emphasized at
(2) the number of hours devoted to develop-         Hewlett-Packard, managers are responsible
ment; and (3) the results of developmental          for people management. While HR profes-
programs as measured by four levels: reaction       sionals may design and develop all kinds of HR
and planned action, learning, on-the-job be-        practices (such as performance appraisal, re-
havior, and business results. Performance-          ward systems, succession planning, promotion
based culture is regularly assessed through the     process), the effectiveness of these practices
332   •   HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997


                  ultimately relies on implementation by line        between HR practices and shareholder satis-
                  managers; therefore, line managers, more           faction. For example, Kodak traditionally had
                  than HR professionals, should be held ac-          a program called “wage dividend,” which was
                  countable for building critical organizational     essentially an annual bonus payment that,
                  capabilities and enhancing employee satisfac-      over time, became a pure entitlement for em-
                  tion.                                              ployees. Every year they could expect 7–8% of
                                                                     their base pay as a bonus at the end of the year;
                                                                     however, in the last few years, Kodak has
                  Cluster 3: External Strategic Measures             changed the plan so that the wage dividend
                                                                     payoff is strictly a function of shareholder sat-
                  The external strategic measures assess the ef-     isfaction as measured by return on net assets
                  fectiveness of HR practices in satisfying cus-     (RONA) within the corporation. This was sup-
                  tomers and shareholders. The purpose is to         ported by a communication process driven by
                  use HR practices to drive customer and share-      the HR community to help employees under-
                  holder satisfaction. Eastman Kodak has ex-         stand what RONA is and how it translates to
                  perimented with several HR programs to             their particular operation within the company.
                  achieve this goal.                                 In this way, they could understand what they
                       The first, a program called Champions for     could do to influence their wage dividend by
                  Customer Success, is a customer-oriented           the end of the year. The HR measure for this
                  program that serves two goals: (1) to create a     program is to determine the change in em-
                  learning situation that directly connects man-     ployee mindset from entitlement to contribu-
                  ufacturing employees with customers (e.g.,         tion. The purpose is to use the bonus system
                  print shops); and (2) to share best practices      to drive shareholder value.
                  and expertise with customers in areas in which         Kodak has also used a strategic investment
                  they need help, such as reducing paper waste,      approach to plan and evaluate incentive com-
                  deploying total quality management (TQM),          pensation plans (Boudreau & Berman, 1991).
                  establishing self-managed teams, etc. By en-       Using return on investment as a key metric,
                  gaging manufacturing people with customers         they have applied tools such as sensitivity
                  and by helping customers build their capabil-      analysis and break-even analysis to foster an
                  ity in those areas, the HR function intends to     alignment between HR systems and strategic
                  drive greater customer satisfaction and com-       imperatives from a shareholder perspective.
                  mitment to Kodak products. In addition, the        Kodak has taken a similar approach to evalu-
                  program serves to build employees’ under-          ating the effectiveness of various wellness pro-
                  standing of customers’ needs. The simple mea-      gram initiatives. By collecting a variety of
                  sures necessary for this program include: (1)      health care experience data from both partic-
                  incremental sales and earnings as a result of      ipants and nonparticipants in these programs,
                  establishing these customer relationships; and     Kodak has been able to assess the financial re-
                  (2) change in customer satisfaction and com-       turn it is realizing from these wellness pro-
                  mitment.                                           grams.
                       Another HR effort that drives customer            While these examples highlight how East-
                  satisfaction is that of leveraging the executive   man Kodak is beginning to refocus its HR
                  education process. By inviting senior execu-       practices to drive business performance, cor-
                  tives from major customers to attend and           porations still need to invest time and re-
                  share an executive education experience with       sources in developing a set of external strate-
                  Kodak executives, Eastman Kodak succeeds in        gic HR measures that can systematically align
First, HR mat-    achieving two goals: (1) creating a greater        their HR practices with critical business re-
ters. Second, a
framework is a
                  shared mindset with key customers; and (2)         sults.
prerequisite to   enabling Eastman Kodak to meet customer
the development   needs more effectively. The performance mea-
of specific HR    sure is the degree of change in customer sat-                  Implications for HR
measures.         isfaction and commitment as a result of the
                  shared executive education experience.             By reviewing some recent research studies re-
                       Eastman Kodak also has changed a num-         garding the HR–business performance rela-
                  ber of processes to create a greater connection    tionship, and by building upon the use of the
Adding Value through HR    •    333


balanced scorecard framework in some com-            and shareholders are the three interre-
panies such as Sears and Eastman Kodak, this         lated stakeholders who deserve special
article has answered the three questions posed       attention.
at the outset: (1) HR does make a difference
                                                  2. Understand how HR can add value to
in business results; (2) HR practices can con-
                                                     the critical success factors. In what ways
tribute to business performance through a
                                                     can HR create sustainable competitive
multidimensional approach—building organi-
                                                     advantage for the corporation? Will it
zational capabilities, improving employee sat-
                                                     be certain organizational capabilities
isfaction, and increasing customer and share-
                                                     such as speed, customer service, and
holder satisfaction and commitment; and (3)
                                                     innovation? Will it be the accumula-
new clusters of HR measures, in addition to
                                                     tion of intellectual capital? Will it be a
the traditional HR measures, should be devel-
                                                     pool of committed and competent em-
oped to capture and drive the impact of HR on
                                                     ployees? Will it be a group of loyal and
business performance. After gaining a broad
                                                     committed customers? This article
understanding of these issues, several impli-
                                                     suggests organizational capability, em-
cations for HR function and professionals can
                                                     ployee satisfaction, and customer sat-
be developed.
                                                     isfaction as three possible avenues
     First, HR matters. With this conviction as
                                                     through which HR can make an im-
the springboard, the challenges which lie
                                                     pact. Different corporations may at dif-
ahead for HR professionals are to ensure that:
                                                     ferent times have different priorities.
(1) their HR practices are aligned through dif-
                                                     The soul-searching question remains,
ferent paths to add value to business perfor-
                                                     however: What is the highest value-
mance; and (2) their HR measures are prop-
                                                     added contribution of HR in this cor-
erly formulated to drive desirable activities
                                                     poration? This question should be an-
and behaviors of both HR professionals and
                                                     swered in the strategic HR plan.
line managers. Because “what you measure is
what you get,” a new set of HR measures are       3. Design the appropriate HR measures to
required to refocus the resources and energies       be aligned with the framework. Once
of the HR function.                                  the HR function identifies its unique
     Second, a framework is a prerequisite to        contribution to the corporation, appro-
the development of specific HR measures. HR          priate measures need to be developed.
professionals need to understand how HR can          This article suggests three clusters of
contribute to business success before they can       HR measures: internal operational
decide on HR measures that add business val-         measures, internal strategic measures,       Third, the impact
ue. The design and development of HR mea-            and external strategic measures. As de-      of HR measures
sures typically involves deep thinking, reflec-      scribed in Table III, the HR measures        on business suc-
tion, and discussion in the following three          should be developed in a way to rein-        cess is most
steps:                                               force and accomplish the intended            powerful if a
                                                                                                  complete process
                                                     contribution of HR. HR professionals,        cycle is followed.
    1. Determine what it takes for the corpo-        moreover, need to resist the temptation
       ration to succeed. What are some im-          of adopting HR measures in good part
       portant business trends that impact the       because they are easy to collect or
       corporation? What will make or break          track. By all means, internal opera-
       the corporation in the current and fu-        tional HR measures are the easiest
       ture business environment? Who are            measures to assess; however, it does
       the critical stakeholders? How can you,       not mean they are the most important.
       as an HR professional, meet their ex-         On the other hand, it is much harder to
       pectations and needs? What are the            assess the contribution of HR in inter-
       scarce resource constraints for the cor-      nal and external strategic measures, as
       poration to succeed? These questions          a host of other factors are also influ-
       should be answered as part of the cor-        encing such measures. As “what you
       porate strategic plan. Based on the bal-      measure is what you get,” a weak mea-
       anced scorecard principle, this article       sure on the right issue is better than a
       suggests that employees, customers,           strong measure on the wrong issue.
334   •   HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997


                          Third, the impact of HR measures on              4. Both HR and line managers are ac-
                     business success is most powerful if a                   countable for HR measures. Depending
                     complete process cycle is followed. While                on their areas of responsibility, both
                     the development of appropriate HR mea-                   HR managers and line managers
                     sures is a vital first step, the implementa-             should be assessed based on the HR
                     tion of the measurement process is equal-                measures. While HR professionals
                     ly important. The full potential of HR                   should be accountable for the internal
                     measurement cannot be fully utilized un-                 operational HR measures (e.g., cost
                     til the following steps are taken:                       and efficiency of delivering HR ser-
                                                                              vices), line managers (like those in
                     1. Accurate data on desirable HR measures                Sears and Motorola) should also be ac-
                        are collected on an ongoing and timely                countable for their approaches to man-
                        basis. It is important to ensure that crit-           aging employees, to building organiza-
                        ical data are captured at the right mo-               tional capability, and to enhancing
                        ment when HR programs or activities                   customer satisfaction. The results of
                        are designed and delivered.                           HR measures should constitute part of
                     2. HR measures are analyzed and feedback                 their performance review and bonus
                        is presented in a timely manner. One                  scheme.
                        common fallacy for many companies is
                                                                      Without moving through such a complete cy-
                        to collect quantities of data, analyze
                                                                      cle, HR measures cannot drive the desirable
                        them, and file them on a shelf. To
                                                                      behaviors of line managers in utilizing em-
                        drive behaviors and performance, all
                                                                      ployee contribution. As a result, the linkages
                        HR measures need to be widely dis-
                                                                      between HR measures and business perfor-
                        seminated to the right audience (both
                                                                      mance will be weakened.
                        HR professional and line managers) for
                                                                           When faced with the challenges of
                        feedback purposes.
                                                                      demonstrating its value added, the HR func-
                     3. The purpose of HR measures is to stim-        tion has to carefully think through its value
                        ulate change and improvement. HR              proposition and its impact on business perfor-
                        professionals and line managers need          mance. By developing the right measures, HR
                        to use the findings to create an open fo-     can clearly demonstrate its strategic relevance
                        rum to diagnose/solve problems and to         within corporations, firmly establish its in-
                        improve organizational capabilities.          valuable status as a strategic business partner,
                        The discussion and action planning            and substantially contribute to business suc-
                        which result from the HR measures are         cess.
                        much more valuable than the results of
                        the measures themselves.


                       Arthur K. Yeung is the Executive Director (Asia-Pacific) of the University of Michigan
                       Business School and a faculty member at the Michigan Executive Education Center. His
                       areas of specialization include HR process reengineering, strategic HR management, Asia-
                       Pacific management practices, and organizational learning. He is an Associate Editor of
                       Human Resource Management and has published more than 15 articles in leading HR jour-
                       nals. Dr. Yeung is involved in leadership development programs for numerous corporations,
                       including ABB, Philips, Carrier, Hewlett-Packard, ICI, and Allied Signal Inc.

                       Robert Berman is Director, Human Resources, and Vice President of the Consumer
                       Imaging business of Eastman Kodak Company. He joined Kodak in 1982, and has served
                       in a wide variety of assignments within Kodak’s HR community. His current responsibili-
                       ties include leadership in the delivery of integrated strategic and operational HR services
                       to Kodak’s global, $7 billion consumer products business. He is leading the organizational
                       and individual capability strategies underpinning the growth strategies of the Consumer
                       Imaging business. Mr. Berman has a B.S. in Business from the University of Minnesota
                       and a Master of Industrial and Labor Relations from the New York State School of Indus-
                       trial and Labor Relations at Cornell University.
Adding Value through HR   •   335



                                              REFERENCES

Arthur, J. (1994). Effects of human resource systems        Ideas and trends in personnel, June 21, Issue num-
   on manufacturing performance and turnover.               ber 356, CCH Incorporated.
   Academy of Management Journal, 37, 670–687.           Pfeffer, J. (1994). Competitive advantage through peo-
Boudreau, J.W. & Berman, R.L. (1991). Using per-            ple: Unleashing the power of the work force. Boston,
   formance measurement to evaluate strategic hu-           MA: Harvard Business School Press.
   man resource decisions: Kodak’s experience with       Schuler, R. & Jackson, S. (1987). Linking competitive
   profit sharing. Human Resource Management, Fall,         strategies with human resource management prac-
   393–410.                                                 tices. The Academy of Management Executive, 1,
Cascio, W. (1987). Costing human resources: The fi-         207–219.
   nancial impact of behavior in organizations. New      Ulrich, D. (1989a). Tie the corporate knot: Gaining
   York: Van Nostrand Reinhold.                             complete customer commitment. Sloan Manage-
Fitz-enz, J. (1984). How to measure human resources         ment Review, Summer, 19–28.
   management. New York: McGraw-Hill.                    Ulrich, D. (1989b). Assessing human resource effec-
Huselid, M. (1995). The impact of human resource            tiveness: Stakeholder, index, and relationship ap-
   management practices on turnover, productivity,          proaches. Human Resource Planning, 12,
   and corporate financial performance. Academy of          301–315.
   Management Journal, 38, 635–672.                      Ulrich, D. (1997). Measuring human resources: An
Kaplan, R.S. & Norton, D.P. (1992). The balanced            overview of practice and a prescription for results.
   scorecard—Measures that drive performance.               Human Resource Management, this issue.
   Harvard Business Review, January–February,            Ulrich, D. & Lake, D. (1990). Organizational capabil-
   71–79.                                                   ity: Competing from the inside/out. New York: Wi-
Kaplan, R.S. & Norton, D.P. (1993). Putting the bal-        ley.
   anced scorecard to work. Harvard Business Review,     U.S. Department of Labor (1993). High performance
   September–October, 134–147.                              work practices and firm performance, August.
MacDuffie, J.P. & Krafcik, J.F. (1992). Integrating      Wintermantel, R. & Mattimore, K. (1997). In the
   technology and human resources for high-perfor-          changing world of human resources: Matching
   mance manufacturing: Evidence from the interna-          measures to mission. Human Resource Manage-
   tional auto industry. In Kochan, T. & Useem, M.          ment, this issue.
   (eds.), Transforming organizations. New York: Ox-     Yeung, A., Brockbank, W., & Ulrich, D. (1994). Low-
   ford University Press.                                   er cost, higher value: HR function in transforma-
Ostroff, C. (1995). Human resource management:              tion. Human Resource Planning, 17, 1–16.


                                              ENDNOTE

We acknowledge the financial support of the California    ers and leading practitioners in this topic. Special
Strategic Human Resource Partnership in sponsoring        thanks to Dave Ulrich at the University of Michigan,
the conference, “Measuring HR Effectiveness and Im-       Rick Quinn at Sears, and Tapas Sen at AT&T who
pact,” which brought together a group of thought lead-    helped frame the ideas in this article.
ADDING VALUE THROUGH HR .......

Más contenido relacionado

Was ist angesagt?

Defining Value And Measuring Hr
Defining Value And Measuring HrDefining Value And Measuring Hr
Defining Value And Measuring Hrsonyacurley
 
Strategic Human Resource Management
Strategic Human Resource ManagementStrategic Human Resource Management
Strategic Human Resource ManagementElijah Ezendu
 
deloitte-high-impact-hr-operating-model
deloitte-high-impact-hr-operating-modeldeloitte-high-impact-hr-operating-model
deloitte-high-impact-hr-operating-modelKyle Ku
 
Measuring Hr Strategic Alignment Through The Hr Scorecard
Measuring Hr Strategic Alignment Through The Hr ScorecardMeasuring Hr Strategic Alignment Through The Hr Scorecard
Measuring Hr Strategic Alignment Through The Hr ScorecardR M
 
HR Business Partnering Sascha Michel
HR Business Partnering Sascha MichelHR Business Partnering Sascha Michel
HR Business Partnering Sascha MichelSascha Michel
 
Importance Of Aligning Human Resources With Strategy
Importance Of Aligning Human Resources With StrategyImportance Of Aligning Human Resources With Strategy
Importance Of Aligning Human Resources With StrategyNISHA SHAH
 
Role of hr in business strategy
Role of hr in business strategyRole of hr in business strategy
Role of hr in business strategySambit Biswal
 
Strategic Talent Management_Employee Retention_Engagement
Strategic Talent Management_Employee Retention_EngagementStrategic Talent Management_Employee Retention_Engagement
Strategic Talent Management_Employee Retention_EngagementCharles Cotter, PhD
 
10 things HR transformation
10 things HR transformation   10 things HR transformation
10 things HR transformation Rob Scott
 
Operational Workforce Planning: Optimizing Talent and Maximizing Profitability
Operational Workforce Planning: Optimizing Talent and Maximizing ProfitabilityOperational Workforce Planning: Optimizing Talent and Maximizing Profitability
Operational Workforce Planning: Optimizing Talent and Maximizing ProfitabilityVisier
 
Strategic Hrm And Hr Scorecard
Strategic Hrm And Hr ScorecardStrategic Hrm And Hr Scorecard
Strategic Hrm And Hr ScorecardIllahibux Brohi
 
Strategic Workforce Planning
Strategic Workforce PlanningStrategic Workforce Planning
Strategic Workforce PlanningShane Allen
 
20678074 Hrd Scorecardgroup I
20678074 Hrd Scorecardgroup I20678074 Hrd Scorecardgroup I
20678074 Hrd Scorecardgroup Ihide_seek
 
SHRM HR Competency Model and New Certifications
SHRM HR Competency Model and New CertificationsSHRM HR Competency Model and New Certifications
SHRM HR Competency Model and New CertificationsHR Metrics
 
STRATEGIC HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT (jameson)
STRATEGIC HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT (jameson)STRATEGIC HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT (jameson)
STRATEGIC HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT (jameson)gcd, dublin, ireland
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Defining Value And Measuring Hr
Defining Value And Measuring HrDefining Value And Measuring Hr
Defining Value And Measuring Hr
 
Driving Hr Transformation With Metrics V7
Driving Hr Transformation With Metrics V7Driving Hr Transformation With Metrics V7
Driving Hr Transformation With Metrics V7
 
Strategic Human Resource Management
Strategic Human Resource ManagementStrategic Human Resource Management
Strategic Human Resource Management
 
HR Transformation 2015
HR Transformation 2015HR Transformation 2015
HR Transformation 2015
 
deloitte-high-impact-hr-operating-model
deloitte-high-impact-hr-operating-modeldeloitte-high-impact-hr-operating-model
deloitte-high-impact-hr-operating-model
 
Measuring Hr Strategic Alignment Through The Hr Scorecard
Measuring Hr Strategic Alignment Through The Hr ScorecardMeasuring Hr Strategic Alignment Through The Hr Scorecard
Measuring Hr Strategic Alignment Through The Hr Scorecard
 
HR Business Partnering Sascha Michel
HR Business Partnering Sascha MichelHR Business Partnering Sascha Michel
HR Business Partnering Sascha Michel
 
Importance Of Aligning Human Resources With Strategy
Importance Of Aligning Human Resources With StrategyImportance Of Aligning Human Resources With Strategy
Importance Of Aligning Human Resources With Strategy
 
Strategic hrm
Strategic hrmStrategic hrm
Strategic hrm
 
Role of hr in business strategy
Role of hr in business strategyRole of hr in business strategy
Role of hr in business strategy
 
Strategic Talent Management_Employee Retention_Engagement
Strategic Talent Management_Employee Retention_EngagementStrategic Talent Management_Employee Retention_Engagement
Strategic Talent Management_Employee Retention_Engagement
 
10 things HR transformation
10 things HR transformation   10 things HR transformation
10 things HR transformation
 
Operational Workforce Planning: Optimizing Talent and Maximizing Profitability
Operational Workforce Planning: Optimizing Talent and Maximizing ProfitabilityOperational Workforce Planning: Optimizing Talent and Maximizing Profitability
Operational Workforce Planning: Optimizing Talent and Maximizing Profitability
 
Strategic Hrm And Hr Scorecard
Strategic Hrm And Hr ScorecardStrategic Hrm And Hr Scorecard
Strategic Hrm And Hr Scorecard
 
Strategic Human Resource Management
Strategic Human Resource ManagementStrategic Human Resource Management
Strategic Human Resource Management
 
Strategic Workforce Planning
Strategic Workforce PlanningStrategic Workforce Planning
Strategic Workforce Planning
 
20678074 Hrd Scorecardgroup I
20678074 Hrd Scorecardgroup I20678074 Hrd Scorecardgroup I
20678074 Hrd Scorecardgroup I
 
SHRM HR Competency Model and New Certifications
SHRM HR Competency Model and New CertificationsSHRM HR Competency Model and New Certifications
SHRM HR Competency Model and New Certifications
 
STRATEGIC HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT (jameson)
STRATEGIC HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT (jameson)STRATEGIC HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT (jameson)
STRATEGIC HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT (jameson)
 
SHR ppt 1
SHR ppt 1SHR ppt 1
SHR ppt 1
 

Ähnlich wie ADDING VALUE THROUGH HR .......

Shri human capital aug 2008-strategic hrm_prof_sattar bawany
Shri human capital   aug 2008-strategic hrm_prof_sattar bawanyShri human capital   aug 2008-strategic hrm_prof_sattar bawany
Shri human capital aug 2008-strategic hrm_prof_sattar bawanyCentre for Executive Education
 
How The Strategic Application Of Hr Practices Improves...
How The Strategic Application Of Hr Practices Improves...How The Strategic Application Of Hr Practices Improves...
How The Strategic Application Of Hr Practices Improves...Mary Price
 
דיוויד אולריך מאמר
דיוויד אולריך מאמרדיוויד אולריך מאמר
דיוויד אולריך מאמרSivan Cohen
 
Human resources scorecard
Human resources scorecardHuman resources scorecard
Human resources scorecardAngita Singh
 
Latest trends in hr
Latest trends in hrLatest trends in hr
Latest trends in hr1manomay
 
workforce analytics_whitepaper[2]
workforce analytics_whitepaper[2]workforce analytics_whitepaper[2]
workforce analytics_whitepaper[2]Tanuj Poddar
 
Linking Individual Performance To Business Strategy
Linking Individual Performance To Business StrategyLinking Individual Performance To Business Strategy
Linking Individual Performance To Business Strategyguest5e0c7e
 
Seat at the table
Seat at the tableSeat at the table
Seat at the tablealdampier
 
Human Resource Management (Hrm)
Human Resource Management (Hrm)Human Resource Management (Hrm)
Human Resource Management (Hrm)Papers Help UK
 
A Review Of Smes Recruitment And Selection Dilemma Finding A Fit
A Review Of Smes Recruitment And Selection Dilemma  Finding A  FitA Review Of Smes Recruitment And Selection Dilemma  Finding A  Fit
A Review Of Smes Recruitment And Selection Dilemma Finding A FitDon Dooley
 
Employee competencies and relationship to performance applied hrm research
Employee competencies and relationship to performance  applied hrm researchEmployee competencies and relationship to performance  applied hrm research
Employee competencies and relationship to performance applied hrm researchSunil Ramlall, Ph.D.
 
The Impact of Human Resource Practices on Organizational Performance: A Study...
The Impact of Human Resource Practices on Organizational Performance: A Study...The Impact of Human Resource Practices on Organizational Performance: A Study...
The Impact of Human Resource Practices on Organizational Performance: A Study...AI Publications
 
10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis
10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis
10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman AguinisBenitoSumpter862
 
10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis
10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis
10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman AguinisSantosConleyha
 

Ähnlich wie ADDING VALUE THROUGH HR ....... (20)

Techni~1
Techni~1Techni~1
Techni~1
 
Shri human capital aug 2008-strategic hrm_prof_sattar bawany
Shri human capital   aug 2008-strategic hrm_prof_sattar bawanyShri human capital   aug 2008-strategic hrm_prof_sattar bawany
Shri human capital aug 2008-strategic hrm_prof_sattar bawany
 
Strategic HR management
Strategic HR management Strategic HR management
Strategic HR management
 
Chapter 2(1)
Chapter 2(1)Chapter 2(1)
Chapter 2(1)
 
How The Strategic Application Of Hr Practices Improves...
How The Strategic Application Of Hr Practices Improves...How The Strategic Application Of Hr Practices Improves...
How The Strategic Application Of Hr Practices Improves...
 
דיוויד אולריך מאמר
דיוויד אולריך מאמרדיוויד אולריך מאמר
דיוויד אולריך מאמר
 
Human resources scorecard
Human resources scorecardHuman resources scorecard
Human resources scorecard
 
Latest trends in hr
Latest trends in hrLatest trends in hr
Latest trends in hr
 
workforce analytics_whitepaper[2]
workforce analytics_whitepaper[2]workforce analytics_whitepaper[2]
workforce analytics_whitepaper[2]
 
Linking Individual Performance To Business Strategy
Linking Individual Performance To Business StrategyLinking Individual Performance To Business Strategy
Linking Individual Performance To Business Strategy
 
Seat at the table
Seat at the tableSeat at the table
Seat at the table
 
Hrm 15
Hrm 15Hrm 15
Hrm 15
 
Human Resource Management (Hrm)
Human Resource Management (Hrm)Human Resource Management (Hrm)
Human Resource Management (Hrm)
 
A Review Of Smes Recruitment And Selection Dilemma Finding A Fit
A Review Of Smes Recruitment And Selection Dilemma  Finding A  FitA Review Of Smes Recruitment And Selection Dilemma  Finding A  Fit
A Review Of Smes Recruitment And Selection Dilemma Finding A Fit
 
Employee competencies and relationship to performance applied hrm research
Employee competencies and relationship to performance  applied hrm researchEmployee competencies and relationship to performance  applied hrm research
Employee competencies and relationship to performance applied hrm research
 
Mhr 16
Mhr 16Mhr 16
Mhr 16
 
Hrd Strategic Perspective
Hrd Strategic PerspectiveHrd Strategic Perspective
Hrd Strategic Perspective
 
The Impact of Human Resource Practices on Organizational Performance: A Study...
The Impact of Human Resource Practices on Organizational Performance: A Study...The Impact of Human Resource Practices on Organizational Performance: A Study...
The Impact of Human Resource Practices on Organizational Performance: A Study...
 
10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis
10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis
10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis
 
10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis
10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis
10 STRATEGIC WORKFORCE PLANNINGWayne F. Cascio, Herman Aguinis
 

Último

10 Tips for Great Teams CSUN Conference 2024
10 Tips for Great Teams CSUN Conference 202410 Tips for Great Teams CSUN Conference 2024
10 Tips for Great Teams CSUN Conference 2024Nate Evans
 
pitchdeck ORPC 2019 data info turine.pdf
pitchdeck ORPC 2019 data info turine.pdfpitchdeck ORPC 2019 data info turine.pdf
pitchdeck ORPC 2019 data info turine.pdflebob12
 
Benihana of Tokyo case study11111111.pdf
Benihana of Tokyo case study11111111.pdfBenihana of Tokyo case study11111111.pdf
Benihana of Tokyo case study11111111.pdfjavenxxx01
 
Streamlining Your Accounting A Guide to QuickBooks Migration Tools.pptx
Streamlining Your Accounting A Guide to QuickBooks Migration Tools.pptxStreamlining Your Accounting A Guide to QuickBooks Migration Tools.pptx
Streamlining Your Accounting A Guide to QuickBooks Migration Tools.pptxPaulBryant58
 
Unleashing the Power of Fandom: A Short Guide to Fan Business
Unleashing the Power of Fandom: A Short Guide to Fan BusinessUnleashing the Power of Fandom: A Short Guide to Fan Business
Unleashing the Power of Fandom: A Short Guide to Fan Businesstompeter3736
 
PHX Corporate Presentation March 2024 Final
PHX Corporate Presentation March 2024 FinalPHX Corporate Presentation March 2024 Final
PHX Corporate Presentation March 2024 FinalPanhandleOilandGas
 
Bus Eth ch3 ppt.ppt business ethics and corporate social responsibilities ppt
Bus Eth ch3 ppt.ppt business ethics and corporate social responsibilities pptBus Eth ch3 ppt.ppt business ethics and corporate social responsibilities ppt
Bus Eth ch3 ppt.ppt business ethics and corporate social responsibilities pptendeworku
 
Optimize Your CRM Customization and Beyond
Optimize Your CRM Customization and BeyondOptimize Your CRM Customization and Beyond
Optimize Your CRM Customization and BeyondBoundify
 
Olympus 38DL Plus Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge
Olympus 38DL Plus Ultrasonic Thickness GaugeOlympus 38DL Plus Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge
Olympus 38DL Plus Ultrasonic Thickness GaugeStephenKim86
 
ICv2 Hobby Games White Paper 2024 - State of the Industry
ICv2 Hobby Games White Paper 2024 - State of the IndustryICv2 Hobby Games White Paper 2024 - State of the Industry
ICv2 Hobby Games White Paper 2024 - State of the IndustryDennisViau
 
Business Models and Business Model Innovation
Business Models and Business Model InnovationBusiness Models and Business Model Innovation
Business Models and Business Model InnovationMichal Hron
 
CXO 2.0 Conference (Event Information Deck | Dec'24-Mar'25)
CXO 2.0 Conference (Event Information Deck | Dec'24-Mar'25)CXO 2.0 Conference (Event Information Deck | Dec'24-Mar'25)
CXO 2.0 Conference (Event Information Deck | Dec'24-Mar'25)CXO 2.0 Conference
 
The Smart Bridge Interview now Veranda Learning
The Smart Bridge Interview now Veranda LearningThe Smart Bridge Interview now Veranda Learning
The Smart Bridge Interview now Veranda LearningNaval Singh
 
Green Innovations: Wristbands Ireland's Eco-Friendly Products
Green Innovations: Wristbands Ireland's Eco-Friendly ProductsGreen Innovations: Wristbands Ireland's Eco-Friendly Products
Green Innovations: Wristbands Ireland's Eco-Friendly ProductsWristbands Ireland
 
NewBase 14 March 2024 Energy News issue - 1707 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...
NewBase  14 March  2024  Energy News issue - 1707 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...NewBase  14 March  2024  Energy News issue - 1707 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...
NewBase 14 March 2024 Energy News issue - 1707 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...Khaled Al Awadi
 
HOW TO START EARNING WITH AFFILIATE MARKETING
HOW TO START EARNING WITH AFFILIATE MARKETINGHOW TO START EARNING WITH AFFILIATE MARKETING
HOW TO START EARNING WITH AFFILIATE MARKETINGNATHAN SPEAKS
 
Shravan Kumaran and sanjay kumaran.pdf..
Shravan Kumaran and sanjay kumaran.pdf..Shravan Kumaran and sanjay kumaran.pdf..
Shravan Kumaran and sanjay kumaran.pdf..ranjithapriya2
 
0311 National Accounts Online Giving Trends.pdf
0311 National Accounts Online Giving Trends.pdf0311 National Accounts Online Giving Trends.pdf
0311 National Accounts Online Giving Trends.pdfBloomerang
 
A Case Study On SQUARE GROUP Bangladesh.pdf
A Case Study On SQUARE GROUP Bangladesh.pdfA Case Study On SQUARE GROUP Bangladesh.pdf
A Case Study On SQUARE GROUP Bangladesh.pdfmeftaul987
 
EPC Contractors aspects Presentation.pdf
EPC Contractors  aspects Presentation.pdfEPC Contractors  aspects Presentation.pdf
EPC Contractors aspects Presentation.pdfGiuseppe Tommasone
 

Último (20)

10 Tips for Great Teams CSUN Conference 2024
10 Tips for Great Teams CSUN Conference 202410 Tips for Great Teams CSUN Conference 2024
10 Tips for Great Teams CSUN Conference 2024
 
pitchdeck ORPC 2019 data info turine.pdf
pitchdeck ORPC 2019 data info turine.pdfpitchdeck ORPC 2019 data info turine.pdf
pitchdeck ORPC 2019 data info turine.pdf
 
Benihana of Tokyo case study11111111.pdf
Benihana of Tokyo case study11111111.pdfBenihana of Tokyo case study11111111.pdf
Benihana of Tokyo case study11111111.pdf
 
Streamlining Your Accounting A Guide to QuickBooks Migration Tools.pptx
Streamlining Your Accounting A Guide to QuickBooks Migration Tools.pptxStreamlining Your Accounting A Guide to QuickBooks Migration Tools.pptx
Streamlining Your Accounting A Guide to QuickBooks Migration Tools.pptx
 
Unleashing the Power of Fandom: A Short Guide to Fan Business
Unleashing the Power of Fandom: A Short Guide to Fan BusinessUnleashing the Power of Fandom: A Short Guide to Fan Business
Unleashing the Power of Fandom: A Short Guide to Fan Business
 
PHX Corporate Presentation March 2024 Final
PHX Corporate Presentation March 2024 FinalPHX Corporate Presentation March 2024 Final
PHX Corporate Presentation March 2024 Final
 
Bus Eth ch3 ppt.ppt business ethics and corporate social responsibilities ppt
Bus Eth ch3 ppt.ppt business ethics and corporate social responsibilities pptBus Eth ch3 ppt.ppt business ethics and corporate social responsibilities ppt
Bus Eth ch3 ppt.ppt business ethics and corporate social responsibilities ppt
 
Optimize Your CRM Customization and Beyond
Optimize Your CRM Customization and BeyondOptimize Your CRM Customization and Beyond
Optimize Your CRM Customization and Beyond
 
Olympus 38DL Plus Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge
Olympus 38DL Plus Ultrasonic Thickness GaugeOlympus 38DL Plus Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge
Olympus 38DL Plus Ultrasonic Thickness Gauge
 
ICv2 Hobby Games White Paper 2024 - State of the Industry
ICv2 Hobby Games White Paper 2024 - State of the IndustryICv2 Hobby Games White Paper 2024 - State of the Industry
ICv2 Hobby Games White Paper 2024 - State of the Industry
 
Business Models and Business Model Innovation
Business Models and Business Model InnovationBusiness Models and Business Model Innovation
Business Models and Business Model Innovation
 
CXO 2.0 Conference (Event Information Deck | Dec'24-Mar'25)
CXO 2.0 Conference (Event Information Deck | Dec'24-Mar'25)CXO 2.0 Conference (Event Information Deck | Dec'24-Mar'25)
CXO 2.0 Conference (Event Information Deck | Dec'24-Mar'25)
 
The Smart Bridge Interview now Veranda Learning
The Smart Bridge Interview now Veranda LearningThe Smart Bridge Interview now Veranda Learning
The Smart Bridge Interview now Veranda Learning
 
Green Innovations: Wristbands Ireland's Eco-Friendly Products
Green Innovations: Wristbands Ireland's Eco-Friendly ProductsGreen Innovations: Wristbands Ireland's Eco-Friendly Products
Green Innovations: Wristbands Ireland's Eco-Friendly Products
 
NewBase 14 March 2024 Energy News issue - 1707 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...
NewBase  14 March  2024  Energy News issue - 1707 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...NewBase  14 March  2024  Energy News issue - 1707 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...
NewBase 14 March 2024 Energy News issue - 1707 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...
 
HOW TO START EARNING WITH AFFILIATE MARKETING
HOW TO START EARNING WITH AFFILIATE MARKETINGHOW TO START EARNING WITH AFFILIATE MARKETING
HOW TO START EARNING WITH AFFILIATE MARKETING
 
Shravan Kumaran and sanjay kumaran.pdf..
Shravan Kumaran and sanjay kumaran.pdf..Shravan Kumaran and sanjay kumaran.pdf..
Shravan Kumaran and sanjay kumaran.pdf..
 
0311 National Accounts Online Giving Trends.pdf
0311 National Accounts Online Giving Trends.pdf0311 National Accounts Online Giving Trends.pdf
0311 National Accounts Online Giving Trends.pdf
 
A Case Study On SQUARE GROUP Bangladesh.pdf
A Case Study On SQUARE GROUP Bangladesh.pdfA Case Study On SQUARE GROUP Bangladesh.pdf
A Case Study On SQUARE GROUP Bangladesh.pdf
 
EPC Contractors aspects Presentation.pdf
EPC Contractors  aspects Presentation.pdfEPC Contractors  aspects Presentation.pdf
EPC Contractors aspects Presentation.pdf
 

ADDING VALUE THROUGH HR .......

  • 1. ADDING VALUE THROUGH HUMAN RESOURCES: REORIENTING HUMAN RESOURCE MEASUREMENT TO DRIVE BUSINESS PERFORMANCE Arthur K. Yeung and Bob Berman Building upon the balanced scorecard framework, this article addresses three central is- sues of human resource (HR) measurement: (1) Do HR practices impact business re- sults? (2) How can HR practices add value to business performance? (3) What HR mea- sures can drive business performance? Using Eastman Kodak as a case study, this article identifies three paths through which HR practices contribute to business performance: (1) by building organizational capabilities; (2) by improving employee satisfaction; and (3) by shaping customer and shareholder satisfaction. Three clusters of measures are proposed: internal operational HR measures, internal strategic HR measures, and ex- ternal strategic HR measures. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. s Introduction oped, and existing HR measures are not prop- What is excep- erly formulated to capture the impact of HR tional about the In our recent survey of 65 senior human re- on business performance. As such, efforts to HR function, source (HR) executives in California, mea- refocus HR may not be well positioned to op- however, is that surement of HR effectiveness and impact was timize business performance. it is less prepared ranked as the number one topic that HR ex- To stimulate discussion and thinking on than many other ecutives are most interested in exploring. As functions (such this timely and vital topic, this article address- business competition escalates and corporate as finance or es three issues central to the HR–business management resources shrink, all staff functions (e.g., man- performance relationship: information agement information systems, finance, hu- systems) to man resources, and research and develop- 1. Do HR practices make a difference in quantify its im- ment) are being pressured to demonstrate business results? pact on business their value added and to refocus their re- performance. 2. In what ways can HR practices add val- sources for higher business leverage. Possible ue to business performance? outcomes of refocusing staff functions are 3. What are the most appropriate HR outsourcing, automation, elimination, and/or measures that drive business perfor- downsizing in order to conserve scarce organi- mance? zational resources. The HR function is no ex- ception to this challenge. What is exceptional Building upon a balanced scorecard about the HR function, however, is that it is framework (Kaplan & Norton, 1992, 1993), less prepared than many other functions (such this article offers a framework highlighting as finance or management information sys- the paths through which HR practices can im- tems) to quantify its impact on business per- pact business performance. In general, it can formance. Conceptual linkages between HR be said that HR practices play three major and business performance are not well devel- roles: (1) building critical organizational capa- Human Resource Management, Fall 1997, Vol. 36, No. 3, Pp. 321–335 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. CCC 0090-4848/97/030321-15
  • 2. 322 • HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997 bilities; (2) enhancing employee satisfaction; whole rather than individual HR practices. and (3) improving customer and shareholder The synergy and congruence among HR prac- satisfaction. Based on the framework, three tices have an important impact on business clusters of HR measures—internal opera- performance. Third, these studies are quite ro- tional measures, internal strategic measures, bust as they examine sample firms within an and external strategic measures—are suggest- industry [e.g., the auto industry (MacDuffie & ed to help the HR function demonstrate and Krafcik, 1992), the steel minimill industry drive its business contribution. Examples from (Arthur, 1994)] and across multiple industries Eastman Kodak, Sears, and Motorola are used (Pfeffer, 1994), both within a region (Huselid, to exemplify some innovative measures in 1995) and across the nation (Ostroff, 1995). each cluster. Finally, implications for the HR Building upon the premise that HR prac- function are discussed. tices make a difference in business results, our This article embodies three purposes: (1) next challenging task is to offer a conceptual to help HR professionals better articulate the framework that outlines specific ways in value of the HR function; (2) to specify the which HR practices can exert an impact upon paths through which HR can contribute to business performance. business performance; and (3) to stimulate HR professionals to develop innovative HR measures that can demonstrate the value How Can HR Practices Impact added of HR practices, on the one hand, and Business Performance? drive business performance on the other. While this article helps frame the HR mea- To develop meaningful HR measures, a frame- surement issue and helps propose a conceptu- work is needed to outline how HR can impact al framework, much more effort will clearly be business performance. Based on the experi- required to develop the exact HR measures ence of Eastman Kodak, this article proposes that address the unique needs of each com- an integrative framework that builds upon a pany. balanced scorecard framework (Kaplan & Norton, 1992, 1993) and a strategic HR framework (Ulrich & Lake, 1990). While the Does HR Make a Difference balanced scorecard framework defines what a in Business Results? business should focus on, the strategic HR framework offers specific tools and paths to To many HR functions, this is the fundamen- identify how a firm can leverage its HR prac- tal question. Without the conviction that HR tices in order to succeed. In this section, we does make a difference, HR professionals will will first briefly review the balanced scorecard not, and cannot, be motivated to develop HR framework, then the strategic HR framework, measures that drive business performance. and finally the integrative framework. Fortunately, in the last few years, several re- search studies have reported some important findings regarding the relationships between Balanced Scorecard HR and business performance (Arthur, 1994; Huselid, 1995; MacDuffie & Krafcik, 1992; The balanced scorecard framework defines Ostroff, 1995; Pfeffer, 1994; U.S. Depart- what it takes for a company to succeed. Popu- ment of Labor, 1993). Table I summarizes the larized by Robert Kaplan, a Harvard professor, key findings of these studies in the area of and his associate, David Norton (Kaplan & HR–business performance relationships. Norton, 1992, 1993), it has increasingly been Several consistent themes emerge from adopted by major companies such as Sears, these exemplary studies of the HR–business AT&T, Eastman Kodak, American Express, performance relationship. First, HR practices and Taco Bell. Simply put, two key premises definitely make a difference in business re- underlie the concept (Ulrich, 1997). First, for sults, especially the use of HR practices that businesses to succeed in the long run, the ex- build employee commitment. Second, all of pectations of three stakeholders—sharehold- these studies examine the HR system as a ers, customers, and employees—need to be
  • 3. Adding Value through HR • 323 TABLE I Summary of Major Research Studies in HR–Organizational Performance Relationships. Research Studies Methodology Key Findings MacDuffie & • Studied 70 automotive • Manufacturing facilities with “lean production systems” Krafcik (1992) assembly plants are much higher in both productivity and quality than representing 24 those with “mass production systems” (Productivity: companies and 17 22 hours vs. 30 hours in producing a car; Quality 0.5 countries worldwide. defects vs. 0.8 defects per 100 vehicles). • While the HR strategy of a mass production system is used to create a highly specialized and deskilled work- force that supports a large-scale production process, the HR strategy of a lean production system aims to create a skilled, motivated, and flexible workforce that can continuously solve problems. • The success of a “lean production system” critically depends on such “high-commitment” human resource policies as the decentralization of production respon- sibilities, broad job classification, multiskilling practices, profit/gain sharing, a reciprocal psychological commitment between firm and employees, employment security, and a reduction of status barrier. U.S. Department • Summarized all major Studies that demonstrate business impact by adopting of Labor (1993) research studies the following high-performance work practices are regarding the HR-firm summarized: performance • Employee involvement in decision making. relationship. • Compensation (profit/gain sharing). • Training programs. • Constellation of high-performance work practices. Pfeffer (1994) • Identified the five top- • Contradictory to traditional strategy literature, these performing firms five companies are neither in the right industry (based (based on percentage on Porter’s industry structure analysis) nor are they of stock returns) market leaders in these industries (based on Boston between 1972 and Consulting Group’s learning curve). and 1992 and assessed • Instead, these companies share a set of high commit- their common ment work practices such as employment security, selectivity in recruiting, high wages, incentive pay, employee ownership, information sharing, participation and empowerment, teams and job redesign, cross- training, etc. Arthur (1994) • Conducted a survey • Empirically identified two distinct HR configurations: research from 30 U.S. control and commitment systems. steel minimills. • Control systems aim to reduce direct labor costs, or improve efficiency by enforcing employee compliance with specified rules and procedures and basing employee rewards on some measurable output criteria. • Commitment systems aim to shape desired employee behaviors and attitudes by forging psychological links between organizational and employee goals. • The mills with commitment systems had higher productivity, lower scrap rates, and lower employee turnover than those with control systems. Huselid (1995) • Utilized both survey • Based on his sample, Huselid found that if firms research and financial increase their high-performance work practices by one data of 968 firms. standard deviation (SD), their turnover would be reduced by 7.05%, productivity increased by 16%. continued
  • 4. 324 • HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997 TABLE I Continued Research Studies Methodology Key Findings • In terms of financial impact, a one-SD increase in high- performance work practices leads to a $27,044 increase in sales, a $18,641 increase in market value, and a $3,814 increase in profit. Ostroff (1995) • Conducted a survey • Developed an overall HR Quality Index based on the research jointly sponsored aggregate ratings of all HR activities adopted by a firm. by Society of Human • Based on the HR Quality Index, firms are grouped Resource Management into four categories based on their percentile (i.e., and CCHIncorporated. bottom 25%, second 25%, third 25%, and top 25%). • Firms that score higher in the HR Quality Index con- sistently outperform firms with a lower index in four financial measures: market/book value ratio, productiv- ity (i.e., sales/employees), market value, and sales. satisfied. While a business may still succeed in in employee growth and development. If even the short run if it ignores the expectations of one of the components breaks down, the sys- one of the stakeholders, in the long run, its tem cannot work. business performance will suffer. Second, as The strength of the balanced scorecard depicted in Figure 1, all three stakeholders are framework is that it provides a simple concep- interrelated. Employee attitudes and behav- tual and diagnostic tool to ensure that compa- iors impact the level of customer satisfaction nies utilize the right processes and people to and retention. In turn, customer attitudes and drive customer and business performance. behaviors influence shareholder satisfaction Figure 1 also lists how Sears, Eastman Ko- and retention. Finally, shareholder satisfac- dak, AT&T, and American Express make use of tion affects employee satisfaction through the balanced scorecard principle but with dif- bonuses, stock options, or further investment ferent terms. In spite of different labels and FIGURE 1. Framework of a balanced scorecard.
  • 5. Adding Value through HR • 325 TABLE II Sears Measures in Operationalizing Balanced Scorecard. I. Compelling Place to Work Attitudes about the job 1. I like the kind of work I do. 2. My work gives me a sense of accomplishment. 3. I am proud to say I work at Sears. 4. How does the amount of work you are expected to do influence your overall attitude toward the job? 5. How do your physical working conditions influence your overall attitude toward your job? 6. How does the way you are treated by those who supervise you influence your overall attitude about the job? Attitudes about the company 7. I feel good about the future of the company. 8. Sears is making the changes necessary to compete effectively. 9. I understand our business strategy. 10. Do you see a connection between the work you do and the company’s strategic objectives? II. Compelling Place to Shop 1. Customer service. 2. Customer recommend products. 3. Customer loyalty. III. Compelling Place to Invest 1. Revenue growth. 2. Profit contribution margin. 3. Sales per square feet. 4. Inventory turnover. measurement indices, the logic of the bal- more likely to visit Sears again and thus be re- The Sears exam- ple is distinctive anced scorecard framework is quite similar in tained as steady clientele. Through repeated as it not only all these companies. shopping by loyal customers, Sears can then translates “soft” It is intriguing to note that the ultimate become a “Compelling Place to Invest,” as business issues power of the balanced scorecard framework productivity and financial results both attract (people) into does not lie in its conceptual elegance, but in and retain shareholders. In order to make this “hard” (financial results), but also its empirical validity. The following sections model work, however, Sears understands that identifies people examine how the balanced scorecard frame- all senior managers must be evaluated on the as the driver of work is being validated at Sears and Eastman basis of their performance on all three critical business growth Kodak. success factors, not just on financial results. and success. Their bonuses should also be significantly tied Sears. As part of its transformation under the to the measures in these critical factors. Table new chief executive officer (CEO), Arthur II lists the measures used to track the perfor- Martinez, Sears believes that “Compelling mance of managers at Sears. Place to Work,” “Compelling Place to Shop,” To ensure that all senior managers “buy and “Compelling Place to Invest” are three into” this model, Sears has undertaken an ex- critical success factors that will in the long run tensive and comprehensive study to assess sustain the success of the company. The logic whether the model is in fact working as it pre- is simple: by creating a “Compelling Place to dicts. In the first and second quarters of 1995, Work,” associates’ behaviors will be changed a Sears task force collected hard data from in ways which, in turn, create a “Compelling 800 stores. It collected 300,000 data points Place to Shop.” As a result, customers are and utilized vigorous statistical tools to assess
  • 6. 326 • HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997 the strength of relationship among the three 50% based on “Compelling Place to Invest.” critical success factors: “Compelling Place to By restructuring the bonus system, Sears’ se- Work,” “Compelling Place to Shop,” and nior managers are encouraged to focus not “Compelling Place to Invest.” The results, only on the financial outcomes, but also on though preliminary, are impressive. Sears re- the process and capability that contribute to ported that for every 5% improvement in asso- such outcomes. ciates’ behaviors, customer retention was in- creased by 1.3%, revenues by 1.04%, and profit Eastman Kodak. A similar transformation is by 0.4%. under way at Eastman Kodak since George What does this mean to Sears? It means Fisher became CEO. Eastman Kodak, tradi- that if Sears succeeds in improving associates’ tionally a technologically driven company behaviors by 5% (e.g., from 50% to 55%), its which capitalized on its brand name, focused revenue will be increased by $300 million on customer satisfaction through technical in- (Sears’s current revenue is approximately novation to drive shareholder satisfaction. The $230 billion)! It is also important to note that implicit assumptions were that employee sat- this enormous increase in revenue does not re- isfaction could be achieved when the compa- quire additional head count or payroll, but ny was financially successful and that em- simply an improvement in employee work en- ployee satisfaction was a byproduct, not a vironment. Moreover, line managers (not HR) driver, of business success. Results from 1990 are critical to the creation of such a positive to 1993 (please refer to Figure 2), however, re- work environment. vealed that customer satisfaction alone drove The Sears example is distinctive as it not neither market value nor employee satisfac- only translates “soft” business issues (people) tion. into “hard” (financial results), but also identi- While many factors may have contributed fies people as the driver of business growth to the declining performance of Eastman Ko- and success. Based on the above logic and dak from 1990 to 1993, George Fisher decid- findings, the bonuses of all senior managers at ed to restore employee satisfaction as the dri- Sears are now tied to a measure called Total ver for business success. As he strongly Performance Index, of which 25% of the Index expressed it: “We will never achieve total cus- is based on “Compelling Place to Work,” 25% tomer satisfaction without a much higher lev- based on “Compelling Place to Shop,” and el of employee satisfaction. . . . My funda- FIGURE 2. Traditional paradigm of employee satisfaction at Eastman Kodak.
  • 7. Adding Value through HR • 327 FIGURE 3. The new paradigm of employee satisfaction at Eastman Kodak. mental responsibility is to make sure this is a The balanced scorecard provides a useful strong company and that the employees who business framework that highlights what is re- exist in this company have a great place to quired for a company to succeed by meeting work.” As a result, he instituted a new para- the expectations of employees, customers, and digm, using employee satisfaction to drive cus- shareholders. The next critical questions are: tomer satisfaction and then shareholder satis- Given the balanced scorecard framework, how faction. Along with other ongoing initiatives, can the HR function add value to business the new paradigm appears to be working. success? What kinds of HR practices should While employee satisfaction has increased be designed to enhance business competitive- about 80% from 1993 to 1995, the market val- ness? In the next section, Eastman Kodak’s ex- ue has also increased approximately 90% in perience will be used to illustrate how HR can the same period (please refer to Figure 3). contribute to business competitiveness. It is naive, however, to claim that the in- crease in Kodak’s market value is completely attributable to the increase in employee satis- Strategic HR Framework faction. Causal relationship is also hard to es- tablish without vigorous statistical analyses Like many companies that attempt to align and control (as in the case of Sears). Never- HR practices with business strategy, Eastman theless, the story of Eastman Kodak is power- Kodak’s strategic HR framework involves ful in two ways: (1) it illustrates how CEO three components (Ulrich & Lake, 1990). Fisher reconceptualizes the relationship They are presented below, along with the most among employees, customers, and sharehold- pertinent questions a company could ask in its ers to drive business success; and (2) it pro- efforts to formulate plans for each compo- vides some empirical support of how such a nent. paradigm shift can make a difference in busi- ness performance. Eastman Kodak offers an- 1. Business strategy: What is the business other story based on the balanced scorecard strategy of our company? How do we principle of how companies use people to dri- win in the marketplace based on cus- ve their business performance. tomer buying criteria, competition,
  • 8. 328 • HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997 FIGURE 4. Integrative model connecting strategic HR framework to key results areas. government regulations, supplier situ- Integrative Framework ation, etc.? 2. Organizational capabilities: In order to By integrating the strategic HR framework implement the business strategy, what with the business framework, the interrela- are the critical organizational capabili- tionships among the six components can be ties we need to develop? Companies of- identified in two linkage chains. In the first ten target two or three organizational chain, HR practice can be conceptualized as capabilities that are critical but with key drivers in building organizational capabil- which they have not totally succeeded. ities, enhancing employee satisfaction, and These capabilities might include com- more innovatively, shaping customer satisfac- petitive shared mindset, speed to mar- tion (Ulrich, 1989a; Ulrich & Lake, 1990). In ket, innovation, etc. turn, both organizational capabilities and em- ployee satisfaction can impact customer satis- 3. Human resource practices: How should faction. HR practices be designed and deliv- In the second chain, organizational capa- ered to build these organizational bilities become key drivers which implement capabilities? Are our leaders and em- business strategy, impact customer satisfac- ployees competent, motivated, and tion, and, eventually, contribute to sharehold- empowered to contribute to the fullest er satisfaction. In addition, both business extent in the development of these ca- strategy and customer satisfaction, if properly pabilities? managed, should increase shareholder satis- In summary, the strategic HR framework faction. The Kodak aims to leverage and/or align HR practices to The Kodak framework lays out three framework lays build critical organizational capabilities that unique ways in which HR can contribute to out three unique enable Eastman Kodak to win in the market- business success: building organizational ca- ways in which HR can con- place. pabilities, enhancing employee satisfaction, tribute to business How can HR practices truly contribute to and shaping customer satisfaction. While pre- success: building the critical business success factors as out- vious research and case studies have suggest- organizational lined in the balanced scorecard framework? ed the strategic relevance of HR in each of capabilities, What are the most viable and effective HR these three areas, very few researchers have enhancing employee satisfac- measures which can demonstrate the value systematically addressed all three contribu- tion, and shaping added of the HR function? To think through tions: customer the impact of HR practices on business, East- satisfaction. man Kodak has connected its strategic HR a. HR–organizational capability linkage: framework to the business framework (see The thesis that HR practices should be Figure 4). aligned to build organizational capabil-
  • 9. Adding Value through HR • 329 ity was suggested by Schuler & Jackson more successful; and (2) stronger rela- (1987) and Ulrich & Lake (1990). The tionships with key customers are estab- argument for this linkage is simple: if lished. Another positive example of us- companies intend to compete based on ing HR to drive customer satisfaction is specific organizational capabilities (e.g., Southwest Airline. To ensure that its customer service for Nordstrom, inno- crew members are customer-focused, vativeness for 3M, quality for Motoro- the airline has been involving external la), they require a coherent set of HR customers in selecting the crew force. practices to influence the mindset and As a result, Southwest’s crew members behaviors of their leaders and work- tend to possess attributes that are de- force at all levels. sired by customers. b. HR–employee satisfaction linkage: The The integrative model in Figure 4 is impact of HR practices on employee unique in two ways. First, it tightly aligns the satisfaction has also been widely publi- HR planning process with the business plan- cized through a well-known example of ning process. For example, while the business New United Motor Manufacturing Inc. framework (i.e., the balanced scorecard) high- (Pfeffer, 1994). In 1982, the GM Fre- lights what Eastman Kodak needs to focus on mont facility was closed due to severe in order to succeed, the strategic HR frame- employee problems. When approached work provides specific tools and paths to iden- by Toyota for a joint venture, GM tify how Eastman Kodak can leverage its HR agreed to reopen the facility in 1984 practices and organizational capabilities to under a new entity called New United succeed. Thus, the integrative model provides Motor Manufacturing Inc. (NUMMI). a simple but comprehensive roadmap for a Without moving to a new facility, in- company to think through its strategic focus. vesting heavily in new technology, or Second, the model helps senior line and HR hiring a new group of employees (85% executives rethink the strategic roles within of NUMMI employees were rehired corporations which can be played by HR prac- from the GM Fremont facility with the tices. As human resources clearly have be- same UAW hierarchy), NUMMI was come an important source of sustainable com- able to substantially improve employee petitive advantage (Pfeffer, 1994; Huselid, satisfaction through radical changes in 1995), the model explicitly identifies the high human resource philosophy and prac- value-added contribution of HR practices tices. The effects of these HR philoso- within corporations. phy and practice changes were dramat- ic. Between 1982 and 1986, employee absenteeism was reduced from 20% to What Are the New HR Measures 2%; grievances decreased from 2000 that Drive Business Performance? per year to two per year; and strikes went from two–four times per year to If HR practices can impact business success zero times per year. As a result, produc- through building up organizational capabili- tivity was increased by 100%; cost was ties, improving employee satisfaction, and reduced by 30%; and both quality and shaping customer satisfaction, new HR mea- consumer satisfaction were enhanced sures should be developed to drive business substantially. performance. As succinctly argued by Kaplan c. HR–customer satisfaction linkage: Some & Norton (1992, p. 71): “What you measure pioneering companies are leveraging is what you get.” Unless HR measures are re- HR practices to drive customer satis- aligned to drive the activities and behaviors of faction (Ulrich, 1989a). For instance, HR professionals and line managers, HR prac- Baxter Healthcare has offered free con- tices can hardly be expected to demonstrate sulting and training sessions for any impact on the bottom line. its key customers. This has led to two Dramatic changes in HR measures are ur- outcomes: (1) key customers become gently required to refocus the priorities and re-
  • 10. 330 • HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997 sources of the HR function. Instead of being 3. External strategic measures: How well HR-driven (what makes sense to HR profes- do our HR practices increase customer sionals), the next generation of HR measures and shareholder satisfaction? needs to be business-driven (how HR can im- Table III lists the possible combination pact business success). Instead of being activ- HR measures that can be developed to in- ity-oriented (what and how much we do), new crease efficiency, quality, and cycle time of HR HR measures should be impact-oriented (how practices; to build organizational capability; much we improve business results). Instead of and to enhance employee, customer, and looking backward (what has happened), inno- shareholder satisfaction. Examples in each vative HR measures should be forward look- cluster of HR measures are illustrated below. ing, allowing managers to assess and diagnose the processes and people capabilities that can predict the future success of corporations (Ka- Cluster 1: Internal Operational Measures plan & Norton, 1992). Finally, instead of fo- cusing on individual HR practices (the perfor- This cluster of HR measures encompasses tra- mance of staffing practices, training and ditional HR measures for which the HR func- development practices, etc.), future HR mea- tion and HR professionals are (and have been surement should focus on the entire HR sys- in the past) held accountable. It focuses on tem, taking into account the synergy existing the efficiency, quality, and speed of delivering among all HR practices. HR practices and managing the HR function Based on the integrative model in Figure as a whole. 4, Eastman Kodak has developed three clus- For HR practices, typical measures in- ters of HR measures: clude both process measures (such as cycle time, quality, and cost of HR processes/prac- 1. Internal operational measures: How tices) and result measures (such as offer/ac- well do we design and deliver our HR cept ratios; different levels of training evalua- practices? tion such as reaction, knowledge, on-the-job 2. Internal strategic measures: How effec- behaviors, and business impact) (Cascio, tively do our HR practices build desired 1987; Fitz-enz, 1984; Ulrich, 1989b). For the organizational capabilities? How effec- HR function, typical evaluative measures in- tively do our HR practices increase em- clude the HR ratio (number of HR profes- ployee satisfaction? sionals to employee population), the percent- TABLE III Developing New HR Measures that Drive Business Performance. Internal Operational Internal Strategic External Strategic Clusters of HR Process Outcome Organizational Employee Customer Shareholder Measures Measures Measures Capability Satisfaction Satisfaction Satisfaction Staffing Training/ Development Performance appraisal Rewards system Organization design Communications Others
  • 11. Adding Value through HR • 331 age of HR expenses to operating expenses, and tracking of aligned performance commit- the results of the client satisfaction surveys, ments, and employees’ surveys which include etc. questions that focus on management account- In short, these internal operational mea- ability for performance, clarity of performance sures track the activity, cost, and quality level expectations, adequacy of performance feed- of HR services. When corporations conceptu- back, and reward of goal achievement. alize the HR function as a cost center, these To ensure that HR practices are meeting measures make perfect sense (Wintermantel employee needs and expectations, Motorola As the HR func- tion is trans- & Mattimore, 1997). As the HR function is has developed an index called Individual Dig- formed to be transformed to be more business oriented nity Entitlement (Ulrich, 1997). Based on the more business (Yeung, Brockbank & Ulrich, 1994; Winter- following six questions, the index directly af- oriented (Yeung, mantel & Mattimore, 1997), these traditional fects the annual performance review and Brockbank & HR measures will no longer be adequate and bonuses of Motorola managers: Ulrich, 1994; Wintermantel & accurate means to assess the performance of 1. Meaningful job that contributes to mo- Mattimore, new HR roles and activities. tivation: Do you have a substantive, 1997), these meaningful job that contributes to the traditional HR measures will no success of Motorola? longer be Cluster 2: Internal Strategic Measures 2. Behavior and knowledge to be success- adequate and ful: Do you have the on-the-job behav- accurate means The internal strategic HR measures assess the iors and the knowledge base to be suc- to assess the effectiveness of HR practices in building or- performance of cessful? new HR roles ganizational capabilities and enhancing em- 3. Training available to upgrade skills: Has and activities. ployee satisfaction. For instance, at Eastman training been identified and been made Kodak three critical organizational capabili- available to continuously upgrade your ties are identified, and specific HR measures skills? are developed to track the progress in these ca- pabilities. The targeted organizational capa- 4. Career plan: Do you have a career plan bilities include: and is it exciting, achievable, and being acted on? • Leadership effectiveness (both compe- 5. Feedback: Have you received candid, tency and diversity). positive, or negative feedback within • Workforce competencies (in terms of the last 30 days which has been help- customer commitment and market fo- ful in improving your performance or cus, working across boundaries, finan- achieving your career plan? cial excellence, and operational excel- 6. Personal Sensitivity: Is there appropri- lence). ate sensitivity to your personal circum- • Performance-based culture. stances, gender, and cultural heritage so that such issues do not distract from While Eastman Kodak uses 360-degree your success? assessment to measure leadership competen- cy, it also tracks leadership diversity through By tracking these six questions, Motorola the race, gender, and nationality composition can ensure that its HR practices are adding of its senior and middle managers. Workforce value through a more committed and compe- competencies are measured by three aspects tent workforce. of the development process: (1) the percent- Unlike internal operational measures, line age of employees with documented develop- managers should be held accountable for the ment plans to develop required competencies; internal strategic measures. As emphasized at (2) the number of hours devoted to develop- Hewlett-Packard, managers are responsible ment; and (3) the results of developmental for people management. While HR profes- programs as measured by four levels: reaction sionals may design and develop all kinds of HR and planned action, learning, on-the-job be- practices (such as performance appraisal, re- havior, and business results. Performance- ward systems, succession planning, promotion based culture is regularly assessed through the process), the effectiveness of these practices
  • 12. 332 • HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997 ultimately relies on implementation by line between HR practices and shareholder satis- managers; therefore, line managers, more faction. For example, Kodak traditionally had than HR professionals, should be held ac- a program called “wage dividend,” which was countable for building critical organizational essentially an annual bonus payment that, capabilities and enhancing employee satisfac- over time, became a pure entitlement for em- tion. ployees. Every year they could expect 7–8% of their base pay as a bonus at the end of the year; however, in the last few years, Kodak has Cluster 3: External Strategic Measures changed the plan so that the wage dividend payoff is strictly a function of shareholder sat- The external strategic measures assess the ef- isfaction as measured by return on net assets fectiveness of HR practices in satisfying cus- (RONA) within the corporation. This was sup- tomers and shareholders. The purpose is to ported by a communication process driven by use HR practices to drive customer and share- the HR community to help employees under- holder satisfaction. Eastman Kodak has ex- stand what RONA is and how it translates to perimented with several HR programs to their particular operation within the company. achieve this goal. In this way, they could understand what they The first, a program called Champions for could do to influence their wage dividend by Customer Success, is a customer-oriented the end of the year. The HR measure for this program that serves two goals: (1) to create a program is to determine the change in em- learning situation that directly connects man- ployee mindset from entitlement to contribu- ufacturing employees with customers (e.g., tion. The purpose is to use the bonus system print shops); and (2) to share best practices to drive shareholder value. and expertise with customers in areas in which Kodak has also used a strategic investment they need help, such as reducing paper waste, approach to plan and evaluate incentive com- deploying total quality management (TQM), pensation plans (Boudreau & Berman, 1991). establishing self-managed teams, etc. By en- Using return on investment as a key metric, gaging manufacturing people with customers they have applied tools such as sensitivity and by helping customers build their capabil- analysis and break-even analysis to foster an ity in those areas, the HR function intends to alignment between HR systems and strategic drive greater customer satisfaction and com- imperatives from a shareholder perspective. mitment to Kodak products. In addition, the Kodak has taken a similar approach to evalu- program serves to build employees’ under- ating the effectiveness of various wellness pro- standing of customers’ needs. The simple mea- gram initiatives. By collecting a variety of sures necessary for this program include: (1) health care experience data from both partic- incremental sales and earnings as a result of ipants and nonparticipants in these programs, establishing these customer relationships; and Kodak has been able to assess the financial re- (2) change in customer satisfaction and com- turn it is realizing from these wellness pro- mitment. grams. Another HR effort that drives customer While these examples highlight how East- satisfaction is that of leveraging the executive man Kodak is beginning to refocus its HR education process. By inviting senior execu- practices to drive business performance, cor- tives from major customers to attend and porations still need to invest time and re- share an executive education experience with sources in developing a set of external strate- Kodak executives, Eastman Kodak succeeds in gic HR measures that can systematically align First, HR mat- achieving two goals: (1) creating a greater their HR practices with critical business re- ters. Second, a framework is a shared mindset with key customers; and (2) sults. prerequisite to enabling Eastman Kodak to meet customer the development needs more effectively. The performance mea- of specific HR sure is the degree of change in customer sat- Implications for HR measures. isfaction and commitment as a result of the shared executive education experience. By reviewing some recent research studies re- Eastman Kodak also has changed a num- garding the HR–business performance rela- ber of processes to create a greater connection tionship, and by building upon the use of the
  • 13. Adding Value through HR • 333 balanced scorecard framework in some com- and shareholders are the three interre- panies such as Sears and Eastman Kodak, this lated stakeholders who deserve special article has answered the three questions posed attention. at the outset: (1) HR does make a difference 2. Understand how HR can add value to in business results; (2) HR practices can con- the critical success factors. In what ways tribute to business performance through a can HR create sustainable competitive multidimensional approach—building organi- advantage for the corporation? Will it zational capabilities, improving employee sat- be certain organizational capabilities isfaction, and increasing customer and share- such as speed, customer service, and holder satisfaction and commitment; and (3) innovation? Will it be the accumula- new clusters of HR measures, in addition to tion of intellectual capital? Will it be a the traditional HR measures, should be devel- pool of committed and competent em- oped to capture and drive the impact of HR on ployees? Will it be a group of loyal and business performance. After gaining a broad committed customers? This article understanding of these issues, several impli- suggests organizational capability, em- cations for HR function and professionals can ployee satisfaction, and customer sat- be developed. isfaction as three possible avenues First, HR matters. With this conviction as through which HR can make an im- the springboard, the challenges which lie pact. Different corporations may at dif- ahead for HR professionals are to ensure that: ferent times have different priorities. (1) their HR practices are aligned through dif- The soul-searching question remains, ferent paths to add value to business perfor- however: What is the highest value- mance; and (2) their HR measures are prop- added contribution of HR in this cor- erly formulated to drive desirable activities poration? This question should be an- and behaviors of both HR professionals and swered in the strategic HR plan. line managers. Because “what you measure is what you get,” a new set of HR measures are 3. Design the appropriate HR measures to required to refocus the resources and energies be aligned with the framework. Once of the HR function. the HR function identifies its unique Second, a framework is a prerequisite to contribution to the corporation, appro- the development of specific HR measures. HR priate measures need to be developed. professionals need to understand how HR can This article suggests three clusters of contribute to business success before they can HR measures: internal operational decide on HR measures that add business val- measures, internal strategic measures, Third, the impact ue. The design and development of HR mea- and external strategic measures. As de- of HR measures sures typically involves deep thinking, reflec- scribed in Table III, the HR measures on business suc- tion, and discussion in the following three should be developed in a way to rein- cess is most steps: force and accomplish the intended powerful if a complete process contribution of HR. HR professionals, cycle is followed. 1. Determine what it takes for the corpo- moreover, need to resist the temptation ration to succeed. What are some im- of adopting HR measures in good part portant business trends that impact the because they are easy to collect or corporation? What will make or break track. By all means, internal opera- the corporation in the current and fu- tional HR measures are the easiest ture business environment? Who are measures to assess; however, it does the critical stakeholders? How can you, not mean they are the most important. as an HR professional, meet their ex- On the other hand, it is much harder to pectations and needs? What are the assess the contribution of HR in inter- scarce resource constraints for the cor- nal and external strategic measures, as poration to succeed? These questions a host of other factors are also influ- should be answered as part of the cor- encing such measures. As “what you porate strategic plan. Based on the bal- measure is what you get,” a weak mea- anced scorecard principle, this article sure on the right issue is better than a suggests that employees, customers, strong measure on the wrong issue.
  • 14. 334 • HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, Fall 1997 Third, the impact of HR measures on 4. Both HR and line managers are ac- business success is most powerful if a countable for HR measures. Depending complete process cycle is followed. While on their areas of responsibility, both the development of appropriate HR mea- HR managers and line managers sures is a vital first step, the implementa- should be assessed based on the HR tion of the measurement process is equal- measures. While HR professionals ly important. The full potential of HR should be accountable for the internal measurement cannot be fully utilized un- operational HR measures (e.g., cost til the following steps are taken: and efficiency of delivering HR ser- vices), line managers (like those in 1. Accurate data on desirable HR measures Sears and Motorola) should also be ac- are collected on an ongoing and timely countable for their approaches to man- basis. It is important to ensure that crit- aging employees, to building organiza- ical data are captured at the right mo- tional capability, and to enhancing ment when HR programs or activities customer satisfaction. The results of are designed and delivered. HR measures should constitute part of 2. HR measures are analyzed and feedback their performance review and bonus is presented in a timely manner. One scheme. common fallacy for many companies is Without moving through such a complete cy- to collect quantities of data, analyze cle, HR measures cannot drive the desirable them, and file them on a shelf. To behaviors of line managers in utilizing em- drive behaviors and performance, all ployee contribution. As a result, the linkages HR measures need to be widely dis- between HR measures and business perfor- seminated to the right audience (both mance will be weakened. HR professional and line managers) for When faced with the challenges of feedback purposes. demonstrating its value added, the HR func- 3. The purpose of HR measures is to stim- tion has to carefully think through its value ulate change and improvement. HR proposition and its impact on business perfor- professionals and line managers need mance. By developing the right measures, HR to use the findings to create an open fo- can clearly demonstrate its strategic relevance rum to diagnose/solve problems and to within corporations, firmly establish its in- improve organizational capabilities. valuable status as a strategic business partner, The discussion and action planning and substantially contribute to business suc- which result from the HR measures are cess. much more valuable than the results of the measures themselves. Arthur K. Yeung is the Executive Director (Asia-Pacific) of the University of Michigan Business School and a faculty member at the Michigan Executive Education Center. His areas of specialization include HR process reengineering, strategic HR management, Asia- Pacific management practices, and organizational learning. He is an Associate Editor of Human Resource Management and has published more than 15 articles in leading HR jour- nals. Dr. Yeung is involved in leadership development programs for numerous corporations, including ABB, Philips, Carrier, Hewlett-Packard, ICI, and Allied Signal Inc. Robert Berman is Director, Human Resources, and Vice President of the Consumer Imaging business of Eastman Kodak Company. He joined Kodak in 1982, and has served in a wide variety of assignments within Kodak’s HR community. His current responsibili- ties include leadership in the delivery of integrated strategic and operational HR services to Kodak’s global, $7 billion consumer products business. He is leading the organizational and individual capability strategies underpinning the growth strategies of the Consumer Imaging business. Mr. Berman has a B.S. in Business from the University of Minnesota and a Master of Industrial and Labor Relations from the New York State School of Indus- trial and Labor Relations at Cornell University.
  • 15. Adding Value through HR • 335 REFERENCES Arthur, J. (1994). Effects of human resource systems Ideas and trends in personnel, June 21, Issue num- on manufacturing performance and turnover. ber 356, CCH Incorporated. Academy of Management Journal, 37, 670–687. Pfeffer, J. (1994). Competitive advantage through peo- Boudreau, J.W. & Berman, R.L. (1991). Using per- ple: Unleashing the power of the work force. Boston, formance measurement to evaluate strategic hu- MA: Harvard Business School Press. man resource decisions: Kodak’s experience with Schuler, R. & Jackson, S. (1987). Linking competitive profit sharing. Human Resource Management, Fall, strategies with human resource management prac- 393–410. tices. The Academy of Management Executive, 1, Cascio, W. (1987). Costing human resources: The fi- 207–219. nancial impact of behavior in organizations. New Ulrich, D. (1989a). Tie the corporate knot: Gaining York: Van Nostrand Reinhold. complete customer commitment. Sloan Manage- Fitz-enz, J. (1984). How to measure human resources ment Review, Summer, 19–28. management. New York: McGraw-Hill. Ulrich, D. (1989b). Assessing human resource effec- Huselid, M. (1995). The impact of human resource tiveness: Stakeholder, index, and relationship ap- management practices on turnover, productivity, proaches. Human Resource Planning, 12, and corporate financial performance. Academy of 301–315. Management Journal, 38, 635–672. Ulrich, D. (1997). Measuring human resources: An Kaplan, R.S. & Norton, D.P. (1992). The balanced overview of practice and a prescription for results. scorecard—Measures that drive performance. Human Resource Management, this issue. Harvard Business Review, January–February, Ulrich, D. & Lake, D. (1990). Organizational capabil- 71–79. ity: Competing from the inside/out. New York: Wi- Kaplan, R.S. & Norton, D.P. (1993). Putting the bal- ley. anced scorecard to work. Harvard Business Review, U.S. Department of Labor (1993). High performance September–October, 134–147. work practices and firm performance, August. MacDuffie, J.P. & Krafcik, J.F. (1992). Integrating Wintermantel, R. & Mattimore, K. (1997). In the technology and human resources for high-perfor- changing world of human resources: Matching mance manufacturing: Evidence from the interna- measures to mission. Human Resource Manage- tional auto industry. In Kochan, T. & Useem, M. ment, this issue. (eds.), Transforming organizations. New York: Ox- Yeung, A., Brockbank, W., & Ulrich, D. (1994). Low- ford University Press. er cost, higher value: HR function in transforma- Ostroff, C. (1995). Human resource management: tion. Human Resource Planning, 17, 1–16. ENDNOTE We acknowledge the financial support of the California ers and leading practitioners in this topic. Special Strategic Human Resource Partnership in sponsoring thanks to Dave Ulrich at the University of Michigan, the conference, “Measuring HR Effectiveness and Im- Rick Quinn at Sears, and Tapas Sen at AT&T who pact,” which brought together a group of thought lead- helped frame the ideas in this article.